Primary Assumption of Risk in California

What is Primary Assumption of Risk?

“Primary assumption of risk arises where a plaintiff voluntarily participates in an activity or sport involving certain inherent risks; primary assumption of risk... bar[s] recovery because no duty of care is owed as to such risks.” Connelly v. Mammoth Mountain Ski Area (1995) 39 Cal.App.4th 8, 11.

“Primary assumption of the risk is an objective test. It does not depend on a particular plaintiff’s subjective knowledge or appreciation of the potential for risk.... Whether a duty exists ‘does not turn on the reasonableness or unreasonableness of the plaintiff’s conduct, but rather on:

  1. the nature of the activity or sport in which the defendant is engaged and
  2. the relationship of the defendant and the plaintiff to that activity or sport.’

If a duty is found not to exist, primary assumption of risk applies, and a defendant is liable only if he intentionally injures the plaintiff or engages in conduct so reckless as to be totally outside the range of the ordinary activity involved in the sport or activity.” Saville v. Sierra College (2005) 133 Cal.App.4th 857, 866, citing Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 313).

The doctrine of primary assumption of risk applies “where ‘conditions or conduct that otherwise might be viewed as dangerous often are an integral part of the sport [or activity] itself.’” Saville, supra, at 867. “Although the doctrine is often applied as between sports co-participants, it defines the duty owed as between persons engaged in any activity involving inherent risks. The doctrine applies to activity ‘done for enjoyment or thrill, requires physical exertion as well as elements of skill, and involves a challenge containing a potential risk of injury’....” Jimenez v. Roseville City School Dist. (2016) 247 Cal.App.4th 594, 601 (citations omitted); see also Bertsch v. Mammoth Community Water Dist. (2016) 247 Cal.App.4th 1201, 1208 (“These factors certainly apply to skateboarding”).

There is also a duty not to unreasonably increase the risks of injury to participants beyond those inherent in the activity. Nalwa v. Cedar Fair, L.P. (2012) 55 Cal.4th 1148, 1162.

Rulings for Primary Assumption of Risk in California

The issue of whether the primary assumption of the risk doctrine applies will be tried first, with the remaining issues being tried by the same jury if the court rules that primary assumption of the risk does not apply.

  • Name

    HUALUN WANG, ET AL. VS UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    22STCV30501

  • Hearing

    Jan 27, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Primary assumption of risk applies to a recreational activity that “is done for enjoyment or thrill, requires physical exertion as well as elements of skill, and involves a challenge containing a potential risk of injury.” Record v. Reason (1999) 73 Cal.App.4th 472, 482. The scope of a public entity’s duty to protect those who use public roads is subject to the primary assumption of risk doctrine. Bertsch v. Mammoth Community Water Dist. (2016) 247 Cal.App.4th 1201.

  • Name

    LUCIDO, JAMES, ET AL VS. STATE OF CALIFORNIA, ET AL

  • Case No.

    S-CV-0039073

  • Hearing

    Jul 03, 2018

Where the plaintiff encounters a known risk that exists by nature of the activity and the relationship of the parties to the activity, the defendant owes no duty of care to protect the plaintiff from that risk and primary assumption of risk applies. Id. In cases of primary assumption of risk, the doctrine is a complete bar to the plaintiffs negligence claim, because the defendant does not owe the plaintiff a duty of care as an issue of law. Id.

  • Name

    LAURA MONACO VS PORTOFIO-LOS ANGELES CORPORATION, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    23SMCV00744

  • Hearing

    Jun 06, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Primary Assumption of Risk Primary assumption of risk is a complete defense where, by virtue of the nature of the activity and the parties’ relationship to the activity, a defendant owes no legal duty to protect a plaintiff from the particular risk of harm that caused the injury. (Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 308-09.)

  • Name

    JOY AHMED VS EXCHANGE LOS ANGELES ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC577154

  • Hearing

    Feb 09, 2017

Citrus Community College Dist. (2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 161 (“Primary assumption of the risk arises when, as a matter of law and policy, a defendant owes no duty to protect a plaintiff from particular harms”).) “The doctrine of ‘primary’ assumption of risk developed as an exception to the general rule that all persons have a duty to use due care to avoid injury to others. . . . Primary assumption of risk is a complete bar to recovery.” (Childs v.

  • Name

    DAMON KING VS GERALD STANLEY BRONSTRUP

  • Case No.

    BC713044

  • Hearing

    Oct 01, 2019

The trial court granted summary judgment, ruling that primary assumption of risk applied, but the court of appeal reversed.

  • Name

    RODRIGUES VS WOODSON

  • Case No.

    MSC18-01805

  • Hearing

    Dec 02, 2020

Primary Assumption of the Risk In the recreation and sports context, primary assumption of risk is a defense that relieves a defendant of any duty to the plaintiff when the injury is due to a risk that is inherent in an activity in which the plaintiff chose to participate. (Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 308 (Knight); Nalwa v. Cedar Fair, L.P. (2012) 55 Cal.4th 1148, 1154 (Nalwa).)

  • Name

    ROSE V. COUNTY OF FRESNO

  • Case No.

    17CECG02164

  • Hearing

    Nov 19, 2018

[T]he primary assumption of risk doctrine is not limited to activities classified as sports, but applies as well to other recreational activities involving an inherent risk of injury to voluntary participants . . . where the risk cannot be eliminated without altering the fundamental nature of the activity. ( Nalwa , supra , 55 Cal.4th at 1156 [quoting Beninati v. Black Rock City, LLC (2009) 175 Cal.App.4th 650, 658].)

  • Name

    KYONG SOON KANG VS DK SOL, INC.

  • Case No.

    20STCV20258

  • Hearing

    Jan 03, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Unlike primary assumption of the risk cases, secondary assumption of the risk cases are subsumed into the comparative fault scheme, and a plaintiffs assumption of the risk does not act as a bar to the action. ( Id. at p. 315.) In Moser v. Ratinoff , the appellate court found that the primary assumption of the risk doctrine applied where a plaintiff was injured while participating in an organized, noncompetitive bicycle ride with others. ( Moser v. Ratinoff (2003) 105 Cal.App.4th 1211.)

  • Name

    JONAS V. MAS VS RENE RIZO

  • Case No.

    21STCV26601

  • Hearing

    Jan 06, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Accordingly, as a matter of public policy, the following rules apply regarding the doctrine of primary assumption of risk.

  • Name

    RILEY VS. BIALY

  • Case No.

    30-2019-01064202

  • Hearing

    Sep 14, 2020

Citrus Community College Dist. (2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 161 (“Primary assumption of the risk arises when, as a matter of law and policy, a defendant owes no duty to protect a plaintiff from particular harms”).) “The doctrine of ‘primary’ assumption of risk developed as an exception to the general rule that all persons have a duty to use due care to avoid injury to others. . . . Primary assumption of risk is a complete bar to recovery.” (Childs v.

  • Name

    ISABELLA RODRIGUEZ VS PARAMOUNT UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT

  • Case No.

    BC703644

  • Hearing

    Sep 19, 2019

Primary Assumption of Risk “‘Primary assumption of risk arises where a plaintiff voluntarily participates in an activity or sport involving certain inherent risks; primary assumption of risk...bar[s] recovery because no duty of care is owed as to such risks.’(Citation.)” (West v. Sundown Little League of Stockton (2002) 96 Cal.App.4th 351, 357.)

  • Name

    TAYLOR WOODS VS FREMANTLE MEDIA NORTH AMERICA ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC591704

  • Hearing

    Nov 30, 2016

The elements of negligent hiring are: (1) an employer hiring an employee; (2) the employee is incompetent or unfit; (3) the employer had reason to believe the employment caused an undue risk of harm; (4) the harm occurs. ( Federico v. Superior Court (1997) 59 Cal.App.4th 1207, 1213-1214.) Defendants argue that the Fourth and Fifth Causes of Action for Negligence and Negligent Hiring are barred by the primary assumption of risk doctrine. Primary assumption of risk is a complete bar to recovery.

  • Name

    JANELLE ARAMBULA, AN INDIVIDUAL VS JOSEPHINE M DECORA, AN INDIVIDUAL, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    22NWCV01050

  • Hearing

    Feb 07, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

[T]he primary assumption of risk doctrine is not limited to activities classified as sports, but applies as well to other recreational activities involving an inherent risk of injury to voluntary participants ... where the risk cannot be eliminated without altering the fundamental nature of the activity.

  • Name

    JONAS V. MAS VS RENE RIZO

  • Case No.

    21STCV26601

  • Hearing

    May 11, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The court applied the doctrine of primary assumption of risk derived from the firefighter’s rule. The injury arouse from an inherent risk of his job. “Primary assumption of risk cases often involve recreational activity, but the doctrine also governs claims arising from inherent occupational hazards.” Gregory v. Cott (2014) 59 Cal. 4th 996, 1001. Courts have applied the firefighter’s rule to numerous employment settings such as veterinarians, tow truck driver and profession in-home healthcare giver.

  • Name

    SMITH VS PHOENIX HOUSE FOUNDATION

  • Case No.

    30-2015-00807785-CU-PO-CJC

  • Hearing

    Sep 26, 2016

Determining whether primary assumption of the risk applies depends upon "the nature of the activity or sport in which the defendant is engaged and the relationship of the defendant and the plaintiff to that activity or sport." (Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 309.) "Primary assumption of the risk is an objective test. It does not depend on a particular plaintiff's subjective knowledge or appreciation of the potential for risk." (Saville v. Sierra College (2005) 133 Cal.App.4th 857, 866.)

  • Name

    TUBINO VS. THE OFFICE BAR

  • Case No.

    37-2016-00011536-CU-PO-CTL

  • Hearing

    Oct 26, 2017

Defendants fail to demonstrate the absence of a triable issue of fact as to whether the doctrine of primary assumption of risk applies to Plaintiff's negligence claim Defendants contend that there is no triable issue of fact as to whether Plaintiff's negligence claim is barred by the doctrine of "primary assumption of risk."

  • Case No.

    2021-00552470

  • Hearing

    May 19, 2022

There is a critical distinction in the law between primary assumption of the risk and secondary assumption of the risk: In cases involving primary assumption of risk where, by virtue of the nature of the activity and the parties' relationship to the activity, the defendant owes no legal duty to protect the plaintiff from the particular risk of harm that caused the injurythe doctrine continues to operate as a complete bar to the plaintiff's recovery.

  • Name

    JOHN UMALE VS MARK MAZHNYY, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    22STCV13379

  • Hearing

    Jan 22, 2025

Pursuant to Avila , the Court finds that Plaintiffs claims for negligence and negligent supervision are barred by the primary assumption of risk doctrine. As to the battery and intentional infliction of emotional distress claims, the Court finds such claims are precluded by Plaintiffs primary assumption of risk.

  • Name

    FRANCESCA SNYDER VS WHITTIER COLLEGE, A CALIFORNIA NON-PROFIT CORPORATION, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    24NWCV00059

  • Hearing

    Jan 29, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Citrus Community College Dist. (2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 161 [[p]rimary assumption of the risk arises when, as a matter of law and policy, a defendant owes no duty to protect a plaintiff from particular harms].) The doctrine of primary assumption of risk developed as an exception to the general rule that all persons have a duty to use due care to avoid injury to others. . . . Primary assumption of risk is a complete bar to recovery. (Childs v.

  • Name

    GERALDINE MYERS VS SKATELAND ENTERPRISES, INC., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    21STCV09851

  • Hearing

    Jan 18, 2023

Mammoth Mountain Ski Area (1995) 39 Cal.App.4th 8, 11 (“Primary assumption of risk arises where a plaintiff voluntarily participates in an activity or sport involving certain inherent risks; primary assumption of risk. . . bar[s] recovery because no duty of care is owed as to such risks” (emphasis added)); Knight v.

  • Name

    HORNSBY VS. SAINT MARY'S COLLEGE

  • Case No.

    MSC17-01737

  • Hearing

    May 15, 2019

PB Hospitality also argues primary assumption of risk of the bounce house. Opposing Argument Plaintiff argues that the bounce house on PB Hospitality s property created an unreasonable risk of harm because it was used during a party , and that the primary assumption of risk defense does not eliminate PB Hospitality s duty because PB Hospitality increased the risks encountered by Plaintiff. c.

  • Name

    IVAN ARRELLANO VS PB HOSPITALITY GROUP, LLC, A LIMITED LIABILITY CORPORATION, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    21STCV24364

  • Hearing

    Oct 10, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Primary Assumption of Risk Doctrine – The primary assumption of risk doctrine was developed in recognition that some activities are inherently dangerous such that the defendant has no duty to protect the plaintiff from those inherent dangers. ( Nalwa v. Cedar Fair, L.P. (2012) 55 Cal.4th 1148, 1154; Knight, supra, 3 Cal.4th at p. 308.)

  • Name

    N B, ET AL. VS BURBANK UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    18STCV06782

  • Hearing

    Apr 09, 2021

  • Judge

    12/14/2022

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

While primary assumption of the risk applies to the question of duty, secondary assumption of the risk concerns the calculation of damages. (Shin, supra, 42 Cal.4th at p. 499.) “In secondary assumption of the risk, the defendant owes a duty to the plaintiff, but the plaintiff ‘knowingly encounters a risk of injury caused by the defendant’s breach of that duty.’ [Citation.] Where secondary assumption of the risk applies, liability is apportioned under principles of comparative fault.” (Rodrigo v.

  • Name

    SILVIA HOOKS V. PATRICIA CROAD

  • Case No.

    18CVP-0029

  • Hearing

    Jul 23, 2019

The elements of negligent hiring are: (1) an employer hiring an employee; (2) the employee is incompetent or unfit; (3) the employer had reason to believe the employment caused an undue risk of harm; (4) the harm occurs. ( Federico v. Superior Court (1997) 59 Cal.App.4th 1207, 1213-1214.) Defendant Decora argues that the Fourth and Fifth Causes of Action for Negligence and Negligent Hiring are barred by the primary assumption of risk doctrine. Primary assumption of risk is a complete bar to recovery.

  • Name

    JANELLE ARAMBULA, AN INDIVIDUAL VS JOSEPHINE M DECORA, AN INDIVIDUAL, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    22NWCV01050

  • Hearing

    Jan 03, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Determining whether the primary assumption of risk doctrine applies is a legal question to be decided by the court. ( Ibid. at 1217.) [T]he primary assumption of risk doctrine is not limited to activities classified as sports, but applies as well to other recreational activities involving an inherent risk of injury to voluntary participants . . . where the risk cannot be eliminated without altering the fundamental nature of the activity.

  • Name

    CHRISTIAN MANUEL ESPARZA, III VS GCMHP, INC., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    21STCV45158

  • Hearing

    Oct 04, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Demurrer – Primary Assumption of Risk A demurrer may be sustained by operation of the primary assumption of risk doctrine. (See, e.g., Avila v. Citrus Community College Dist. (2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 160-168.) The primary assumption of the risk doctrine bars a plaintiff’s recovery for negligence when “it can be established that, because of the nature of the activity involved and the parties’ relationship to the activity, the defendant owed the plaintiff no duty of care.” (Neighbarger v.

  • Name

    ALEXANDRA GRANDE VS WILLIAM S. HART UNION HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT, A PUBLIC ENTITY, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    19STCV14114

  • Hearing

    Jul 31, 2020

(Id at 1254) Here, Defendants set forth 25 undisputed material facts to establish the existence of primary assumption of the risk in this case.

  • Case No.

    Mikayla Hoffman, et al. v Christina M. Young, et al 16CVP0060 (consolidated with Gunner Young, et al. v. Amy Jacobson, et al. 16CVP0230)

  • Hearing

    Jun 13, 2017

  • County

    San Luis Obispo County, CA

Merits Defendants argue that they are entitled to summary judgment as to Plaintiff’s claims based upon the primary assumption of the risk doctrine. Primary assumption of the risk arises when a plaintiff voluntarily participates in a sport or “other activities involving an inherent risk of injury [ ] where the risk cannot be eliminated without altering the fundamental nature of the activity.” (Beninati v. Black Rock City, LLC (2009) 175 Cal.App.4th 650, 658, internal citation omitted; see Knight v.

  • Name

    LAIRMORE V. BLEEKER, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    30-2017-00953751-

  • Hearing

    Jan 17, 2020

The doctrine of primary assumption of the risk, however, “does not grant unbridled legal immunity to all defendants.” (Campbell v. Derylo (1999) 75 Cal.App.4th 823, 827 [89 Cal. Rptr. 2d 519].)

  • Name

    VEGA -V- FISHER ET AL PRINT

  • Case No.

    CIVSB2108551

  • Hearing

    Aug 04, 2023

  • County

    San Bernardino County, CA

Before determining whether or not primary assumption of the risk applies, the court has to determine whether the activity engaged in by Plaintiffs constitute a “qualified activity” for purposes of the doctrine. In the employment context, primary assumption of the risk applies if the risk of injury from engaging in the work-related activity is inherent in that activity. Thus in Moore v.

  • Name

    OK CHOUN KIM ET AL VS BEST LIFE REALTY LLC

  • Case No.

    BC621150

  • Hearing

    Oct 26, 2017

Rickshaw Stop has not satisfied its initial summary judgment burden showing that the doctrine of primary assumption of risk bars plaintiff Kevin Paterson's recovery for the injuries he allegedly suffered. The facts relied on by Rickshaw Stop do not establish that Mr. Paterson was voluntarily participating in any activity other than attending a concert at the time he was injured. Attending a concert is not an activity that implicates the doctrine of primary assumption of risk.

  • Name

    KEVIN D. PATERSON VS. RICKSHAW STOP ET AL

  • Case No.

    CGC15546421

  • Hearing

    Jun 22, 2016

The Haunted Hotel, Inc. (2015) 242 Cal.App.4th 490, 498 [the “primary assumption of risk is not limited to sports, but also applies to other recreational activities involving an inherent risk or injury to voluntary participants where the risk cannot be eliminated without altering the fundamental nature of the activity”]; Saville v.

  • Name

    BRINDLE V. TRUSTEES OF THE CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    FCS052075

  • Hearing

    Aug 19, 2020

Therefore, Defendant argues that the primary assumption of risk doctrine bars Plaintiff’s claim. “Primary assumption of risk arises where a plaintiff voluntarily participates in an activity or sport involving certain inherent risks; primary assumption of risk . . . bar[s] recovery because no duty of care is owed as to such risks.” (West v. Sundown Little League of Stockton (2002) 96 Cal.App.4th 351, 357, internal quotations and citations omitted.)

  • Name

    ESTEBAN MIGUEL SILVA JR VS WATTS LEARNING CENTER INC ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC662428

  • Hearing

    May 22, 2019

Citrus Community College Dist. (2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 161 [“[p]rimary assumption of the risk arises when, as a matter of law and policy, a defendant owes no duty to protect a plaintiff from particular harms”].) “The doctrine of ‘primary’ assumption of risk developed as an exception to the general rule that all persons have a duty to use due care to avoid injury to others. . . . Primary assumption of risk is a complete bar to recovery.” (Childs v.

  • Name

    ARMINEH TAVOOSIAN VS RAGING WATERS OF CALIFORNIA LTD ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC673092

  • Hearing

    Nov 24, 2020

Only “primary assumption of the risk” acts as complete defense; cases of secondary assumption of the risk are merged into comparative fault, and the trier of fact, in apportioning loss resulting from the injury, may consider the parties’ relative responsibility. “Thus, primary assumption of the risk applies to the question of duty and secondary assumption of risk applies to the calculation of damages. (Shin v. Ahn (2007) 42 Cal.4th 482, 499.)

  • Name

    RUBY F VS NORCO EQUESTRIAN ACADEMY

  • Case No.

    RIC1617067

  • Hearing

    Dec 03, 2020

The burden shifts to Plaintiffs to establish a triable issue of material fact to circumvent the primary assumption of the risk doctrine. Plaintiffs contend primary assumption of the risk is inapplicable where a co-participant “engage[s] in conduct that is so reckless as to be totally outside the range of the ordinary activity involved in the sport.” (Knight, supra, at p. 320.)

  • Name

    GUNNER YOUNG, ET AL. V. AMY JACOBSON, ET AL. (CONSOLIDATED WITH MIKAYLA HOFFMAN V. CHRISTINA YOUNG, ET AL 16CVP0060.)

  • Case No.

    16CVP0230

  • Hearing

    Apr 24, 2018

Thus, the analysis is not separate from each other (issue of duty v. primary assumption) as they are actually related. Primary assumption of the risk may also be resolved via demurrer. (See Avila v. Citrus Community College Dist. (2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 162-168.) Here Defendants contend that Plaintiff’s relationship to the activities occurring at the venue means assumption of the risk applies.

  • Name

    COATS VS BALBOA MANAGEMENT GROUP, LLC,

  • Case No.

    CVRI2302803

  • Hearing

    Dec 11, 2023

  • County

    Riverside County, CA

Thus, the analysis is not separate from each other (issue of duty v. primary assumption) as they are actually related. Primary assumption of the risk may also be resolved via demurrer. (See Avila v. Citrus Community College Dist. (2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 162-168.) Here Defendants contend that Plaintiff’s relationship to the activities occurring at the venue means assumption of the risk applies.

  • Name

    COATS VS BALBOA MANAGEMENT GROUP, LLC,

  • Case No.

    CVRI2302803

  • Hearing

    Dec 10, 2023

  • County

    Riverside County, CA

Thus, the analysis is not separate from each other (issue of duty v. primary assumption) as they are actually related. Primary assumption of the risk may also be resolved via demurrer. (See Avila v. Citrus Community College Dist. (2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 162-168.) Here Defendants contend that Plaintiff’s relationship to the activities occurring at the venue means assumption of the risk applies.

  • Name

    COATS VS BALBOA MANAGEMENT GROUP, LLC,

  • Case No.

    CVRI2302803

  • Hearing

    Dec 09, 2023

  • County

    Riverside County, CA

It cannot be determined from the Complaint that the affirmative defense of primary assumption of the risk necessarily bars the causes of action. (Kahn v. East Side Union High School Dist. (2003) 31 Cal.4th 990; Rostai v. Neste Enterprises (2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 326; Complaint ¶13.) Defendants are to file an Answer within 14 days notice of service of this order.

  • Name

    MACK V. PETRUCHIK

  • Case No.

    30-2016-00880429-CU-PO-CJC

  • Hearing

    Mar 07, 2017

Additionally, the primary assumption of risk defense may be defeated on summary judgment if there is a triable issue of fact as to whether the defendant failed to warn Plaintiff of a hazardous condition or the cause of the injury was not related to the inherent risk involved with the activity. Gregory v. Cott (2014) 59 Cal.4th 996, 1010. First, Defendant has failed to carry their burden with respect to the primary assumption of risk defense.

  • Name

    RUBIO VS CAREFUSION 303 INC

  • Case No.

    37-2021-00037174-CU-PO-CTL

  • Hearing

    Jan 19, 2024

  • County

    San Diego County, CA

Citrus Community College Dist. (2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 161 [“[p]rimary assumption of the risk arises when, as a matter of law and policy, a defendant owes no duty to protect a plaintiff from particular harms”].) “The doctrine of ‘primary’ assumption of risk developed as an exception to the general rule that all persons have a duty to use due care to avoid injury to others. . . . Primary assumption of risk is a complete bar to recovery.” (Childs v.

  • Name

    NORMA J. PALOMO VS CENTAUR HOLDINGS UNITED STATES, INC.

  • Case No.

    19STCV04207

  • Hearing

    Oct 26, 2020

The parties do not dispute that Pilates is a recreational activity that is subject to the primary assumption of the risk defense. The parties, however, do not cite legal authority that directly applies the primary assumption of the risk doctrine to the practice of Pilates.

  • Name

    CARRIE TIVADOR VS EQUINOX HOLDINGS INC

  • Case No.

    BC641396

  • Hearing

    Aug 07, 2019

Whether the primary assumption of risk doctrine applies depends on whether the recreational activity involves an inherent risk of injury. The Court finds that sliding down a slide, even from a two-story fun house, does not carry an inherent risk of injury. The primary assumption of risk doctrine thus does not apply in this case. Therefore, Defendant City is not entitled to summary judgment on this ground. 2.

  • Name

    ALEJANDRA REYES VS KASTL AMUSEMENTS ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC701726

  • Hearing

    Sep 24, 2020

  • Judge

    Lori Ann Fournier or Olivia Rosales

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Motion for Summary Judgment/Adjudication Defendants’ first contention is that Plaintiff’s entire complaint against them is barred by the primary assumption of the risk doctrine. a. Law Governing assumption of the risk Assumption of risk falls into two categories: primary and secondary. Primary assumption of risk occurs when a plaintiff voluntarily engages in a sport or activity with inherent risks.

  • Name

    JORDAN ALAN VS LA FITNESS ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC588038

  • Hearing

    Apr 21, 2017

Motion for Summary Judgment/Adjudication Defendants’ first contention is that Plaintiff’s entire complaint against them is barred by the primary assumption of the risk doctrine. a. Law Governing assumption of the risk Assumption of risk falls into two categories: primary and secondary. Primary assumption of risk occurs when a plaintiff voluntarily engages in a sport or activity with inherent risks.

  • Name

    JORDAN ALAN VS LA FITNESS ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC588038

  • Hearing

    Jun 01, 2017

DISCUSSION Defendant Billy Beez USA, LLC moves for summary judgment on grounds that (1) Plaintiff’s claims are barred by the primary assumption of risk and (2) the alleged dangerous condition was open and obvious. Primary Assumption of Risk The primary assumption of risk doctrine was developed in recognition that some activities are inherently dangerous such that the defendant has no duty to protect the plaintiff from those inherent dangers. ( Nalwa v. Cedar Fair, L.P.

  • Name

    PUJA ZAFAR VS BILLY BEEZ USA, LLC

  • Case No.

    19STCV29341

  • Hearing

    Dec 09, 2020

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Defendant does not owe a duty to protect the Plaintiff from injury from a particular risk of harm inherent in an activity engaged in by Plaintiff. “Primary assumption of the risk” acts as a complete bar to Plaintiff’s complaint. Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 315-316. Whether primary assumption of the risk applies can be determined as a matter of law if the facts are not in dispute. Childs v. County of Santa Barbara (2004) 115 Cal. App. 4th 64, 69.

  • Name

    ETHAN HERNANDEZ VS TARGET CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    BC670491

  • Hearing

    Jul 19, 2019

Primary Assumption of the Risk USC next argues that Plaintiffs claim is barred under the doctrine of primary assumption of the risk. The primary assumption of the risk doctrine bars a plaintiffs recovery for negligence when it can be established that, because of the nature of the activity involved and the parties relationship to the activity, the defendant owed the plaintiff no duty of care. (Neighbarger v. Irwin Industries, Inc. (1994) 8 Cal.4th 532, 538; see also Avila v.

  • Name

    HARRISON ROTH VS UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    19STCV33972

  • Hearing

    Mar 06, 2023

Assumption of the Risk Defendants move for summary judgment on the basis that the primary assumption of the risk doctrine is a complete defense to Daganass cause of action for negligence. Under the doctrine of primary assumption of the risk, defendants do not owe a duty of care to a plaintiff in certain situations involving a dangerous activity. ( McGarry v. Sax (2008) 158 Cal.App.4th 983, 999.) Many different sports and recreational activities qualify for the application of this doctrine. ( Kindrich v.

  • Name

    FRANCISCO DAGANAS, JR., ET AL. VS SAN FERNANDO VALLEY R.C. FLYERS, INC., ET AL.

  • Case No.

    22STCV17662

  • Hearing

    Sep 25, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Only “primary assumption of the risk” acts as complete defense; cases of secondary assumption of the risk are merged into comparative fault, and the trier of fact, in apportioning loss resulting from the injury, may consider the parties’ relative responsibility. “Thus, primary assumption of the risk applies to the question of duty and secondary assumption of risk applies to the calculation of damages. (Shin v. Ahn (2007) 42 Cal.4th 482, 499).

  • Name

    ROCCO VS YOUNG LIFE

  • Case No.

    MCC1500376

  • Hearing

    Jan 11, 2017

(2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 161 [ “ [p] rimary assumption of the risk arises when, as a matter of law and policy, a defendant owes no duty to protect a plaintiff from particular harms” ] . ) “The doctrine of ‘primary’ assumption of risk developed as an exception to the general rule that all persons have a duty to use due care to avoid injury to others. . . . Primary assumption of risk is a complete bar to recovery.” ( Childs v.

  • Name

    PRISCILLA MALKA VS BBC HOLDINGS, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    19STCV32877

  • Hearing

    Feb 18, 2021

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Citrus Community College Dist. (2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 161 [“[p]rimary assumption of the risk arises when, as a matter of law and policy, a defendant owes no duty to protect a plaintiff from particular harms”].) “The doctrine of ‘primary’ assumption of risk developed as an exception to the general rule that all persons have a duty to use due care to avoid injury to others. . . . Primary assumption of risk is a complete bar to recovery.” (Childs v.

  • Name

    PRISCILLA MALKA VS BBC HOLDINGS, LLC A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    19STCV32877

  • Hearing

    Feb 17, 2021

Primary Assumption of Risk With respect to this issue, it is apparent that neither party has discussed the correct legal doctrine that is applicable to the current matter. Instead, both parties have erroneously relied on legal authority concerning the primary assumption of risk when the facts of this case do not fall within that doctrine.

  • Name

    OLIVER MELLADO VS REDWOOD ARMS LLC ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC584832

  • Hearing

    Nov 08, 2016

Moving Defendants further argue that Plaintiff’s claim fails because: 1) there was no dangerous condition on or in the parking lot where Plaintiff fell; and 2) it is barred by the primary assumption of risk doctrine. Moving Defendants assert that falling is an inherent risk of running and they did nothing to increase the risk of harm to Plaintiff. Plaintiff contends that his primary theory of liability is negligent supervision, which is not barred by the primary assumption of risk doctrine.

  • Name

    HO JUNG JEONG VS GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE TRUE JESUS CHURCH I

  • Case No.

    BC591747

  • Hearing

    Feb 02, 2017

Primary assumption of risk occurs when, by virtue of the nature of the activity and the parties’ relationship to the activity, the defendant owes no legal duty to protect the plaintiff from the particular inherent risk of harm in the activity that caused the injury. Primary assumption of risk operates as a complete bar to the plaintiff's recovery.

  • Name

    JON EDMONSON, ET AL. VS TFI GROUP, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    19STCV10121

  • Hearing

    Jun 08, 2021

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

DISCUSSION Primary Assumption of Risk The primary assumption of risk doctrine was developed in recognition that some activities are inherently dangerous such that the defendant has no duty to protect the plaintiff from those inherent dangers. ( Nalwa v. Cedar Fair, L.P. (2012) 55 Cal.4th 1148, 1154; Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 308.)

  • Name

    ROBERT SHADANLOO VS 441 NORTH OAKHURST DRIVE COA, INC

  • Case No.

    20STCV33796

  • Hearing

    Sep 23, 2021

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Whether the primary assumption of risk doctrine applies is a question of law and “depends on the nature of the sport or activity in question and on the parties' general relationship to the activity.” (Knight v. Jewett, supra, 3 Cal.4th at p. 313.) “The overriding consideration in the application of primary assumption of risk is to avoid imposing a duty which might chill vigorous participation in the implicated activity and thereby alter its fundamental nature.” (Ferrari v.

  • Name

    GAUDREAU, ET AL. V. CITY OF LA HABRA

  • Case No.

    30-2019-01064083

  • Hearing

    Aug 20, 2021

Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 312, bars the defense of primary assumption of risk from being asserted in medical malpractice actions. In Opposition, Defendants agree with Plaintiff’s legal authority but argue that Defendants’ fourth affirmative defense concerns consent and does not concern the primary assumption of risk doctrine. The Court finds that a plain reading of Defendants’ fourth affirmative defense does not support Defendants’ contention. In no place does Defendants’ defense discuss consent.

  • Name

    LIGIA LEZAMA VS TORAL LS PANDYA DDS ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC642906

  • Hearing

    Mar 01, 2017

App. 4th 975, 994 n. 22 (“The courts have applied primary assumption of risk principles to activities other than sporting or recreational endeavors, including injuries in the workplace.”). Defendants argue that skateboarding fits within the primary assumption of risk doctrine, citing to Calhoon v. Lewis (2000) 81 Cal. App. 4 th 108, 115 (“Skateboarding is a type of activity covered by the primary assumption of the risk doctrine.

  • Name

    KAILEY SNIDER VS ERIC BIRKEMEIER, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    19STCV35710

  • Hearing

    May 18, 2021

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Primary Assumption of the Risk “The common law doctrine of primary assumption of risk has been used a complete defense in personal injury lawsuits arising from any particular sports activity that is done for enjoyment or thrill, requires physical exertion as well as elements of skill, and involves a challenge containing a potential risk of injury.

  • Name

    SO LAN MUI V. BTM FITNESS, LLC DBA ANASTASIA’S CLUB FIT

  • Case No.

    1-12-CV-226097

  • Hearing

    Feb 06, 2014

The primary assumption of risk doctrine applies to rock climbing. “Falling, whether because of one’s own slip, a coclimber's stumble, or an anchor system giving way, is the very risk inherent in the sport of mountain climbing and cannot be completely eliminated without destroying the sport itself.” (Regents of University of California v. Superior Court (1996) 41 Cal.App.4th 1040, 1047.)

  • Name

    THOMAS WAYNE HARVEY VS GLOWZONE LA ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC685816

  • Hearing

    Jan 08, 2019

Primary Assumption of the Risk Under the doctrine of primary assumption of the risk, defendants do not owe a duty of care to a plaintiff in certain situations, depending on the nature of the activity. (McGarry v. Sax (2008) 158 Cal.App.4th 983, 999.)

  • Name

    NICHOLAS ESPINOSA VS CITY OF LONG BEACH ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC593929

  • Hearing

    Mar 05, 2018

Primary Assumption of Risk In the alternative, City seeks summary judgment based on the doctrine of primary assumption of risk. As our Supreme Court has explained, the primary assumption of risk doctrine was developed in recognition that some activities are inherently dangerous such that the defendant has no duty to protect the plaintiff from those inherent dangers.¿ ( Nalwa v. Cedar Fair, L.P. (2012) 55 Cal.4th 1148, 1154; Knight v.

  • Name

    PAUL TVEDT VS CITY OF LOS ANGELES, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    21STCV00893

  • Hearing

    May 13, 2025

Application of Primary Assumption of Risk Doctrine to Hart Show Choir 1. The Primary Assumption of Risk Doctrine The primary assumption of risk is based upon the absence of a defendants duty of care. ( Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 308 ( Knight ) .) Although persons generally owe a duty of due care not to cause an unreasonable risk of harm to others (Code Civ. Proc., § 1714, subd. (a)), some activities are inherently dangerous.

  • Name

    R. S., JR., ET AL. VS WILLIAM S. HART UNION HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT, A PUBLIC ENTITY

  • Case No.

    20STCV24311

  • Hearing

    Feb 23, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Primary Assumption of Risk Defendants argue that Plaintiff’s action is barred by the primary assumption of risk doctrine because falling or being fallen on is an inherent risk of performing cheerleading stunts . The primary assumption of risk doctrine was developed in recognition that some activities are inherently dangerous such that the defendant has no duty to protect the plaintiff from those inherent dangers.¿ ( Nalwa v. Cedar Fair, L.P. (2012) 55 Cal.4th 1148, 1154; Knight v.

  • Name

    RAYLENE LOPEZ VS DON BOSCO TECHNICAL SCHOOL, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    18STCV07505

  • Hearing

    Apr 20, 2021

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

  • Type

    Personal Injury/ Tort

  • Sub Type

    other

As Defendant has met its burden and Plaintiff has failed to meet his burden of demonstrating triable issues of material fact exist as to gross negligence, Defendant is entitled to summary judgment based on the express assumption of risk and release and waiver. Primary Assumption of Risk Defendant also argues that Plaintiff’s claims are barred under the primary assumption of risk doctrine.

  • Case No.

    20STCV0591

  • Hearing

    Oct 21, 2021

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Long Beach Unified School District (2006) 143 Cal.App.4th 566, as holding that being hit by a golf club was not an inherent risk in the sport of golf, and thus, a typical duty analysis with comparative fault applied in Hemady. (Id. at 493.) Consequently, in determining whether primary or secondary assumption of the risk applies, a court determines whether the risk is inherent in the sport or not; if the risk is inherent, then primary assumption of the risk applies. (Shin, 42 Cal. 4th at 489.)

  • Name

    YARON VS. PARK

  • Case No.

    MSC18-01490

  • Hearing

    Jan 10, 2020

Law Governing Primary Assumption of the Risk Assumption of risk falls into two categories: primary and secondary. Primary assumption of risk occurs when a plaintiff voluntarily engages in a sport or activity with inherent risks. It embodies those instances where there is a legal conclusion that there is no duty on the part of the defendant to protect the plaintiff from that particular risk.

  • Name

    TANYA CRUZ VS SKATELAND ENTERPRISES INC

  • Case No.

    BC715838

  • Hearing

    Jan 02, 2020

Law Governing Primary Assumption of the Risk Assumption of risk falls into two categories: primary and secondary. Primary assumption of risk occurs when a plaintiff voluntarily engages in a sport or activity with inherent risks. It embodies those instances where there is a legal conclusion that there is no duty on the part of the defendant to protect the plaintiff from that particular risk.

  • Name

    TANYA CRUZ VS SKATELAND ENTERPRISES INC

  • Case No.

    BC715838

  • Hearing

    Jan 21, 2020

In the context of a security guard, if the attack is considered an inherent risk of the job, the primary assumption of risk doctrine may bar Plaintiffs claim against her employer or other parties. (See, e.g., Tilley v. CZ Master Assn. (2005) 131 Cal.App.4th 464) (concluding the primary assumption of risk doctrine applied to a security guard who was assaulted while on duty as confronting such risks was part of the job.)

  • Name

    JANE Y.G. DOE VS RESIDENCES ON MAIN L.P., ET AL.

  • Case No.

    21STCV44285

  • Hearing

    Feb 20, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

“[A]ssumption of risk doctrine embodies a legal conclusion that there is “no duty” on the part of the defendant to protect the plaintiff from a particular risk-the category of assumption of risk that the legal commentators generally refer to as ‘primary assumption of risk’.” (Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 308.)

  • Name

    NATALIE NASSER V. MARGARITA ADVENTURES, LLC

  • Case No.

    19CVP-0148

  • Hearing

    Jan 14, 2021

Plaintiffs also argue that Washausen’s conduct increased the risk inherent in the game of touch football, which bars the assumption of risk defense. BUSD Defendants satisfy their prima facie burden to show that the primary assumption of risk doctrine is applicable to the instant action.

  • Name

    N B, ET AL. VS BURBANK UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    18STCV06782

  • Hearing

    Jun 04, 2021

  • Judge

    12/14/2022

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Primary Assumption of Risk Primary assumption of risk is a complete defense where, by virtue of the nature of the activity and the parties’ relationship to the activity, a defendant owes no legal duty to protect a plaintiff from the particular risk of harm that caused the injury. (Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 308-09.)

  • Name

    JUDITH MORA-JOSE VS RAY CAMMACK SHOWS INC ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC570674

  • Hearing

    Mar 20, 2017

Defendant requests an order bifurcating the issue of “liability via the primary assumption of the risk doctrine” from causation and damages. (Ntc. of Mtn., p. 1; see Mtn. P&As at pp. 3, 9.) Contrary to defendant’s contentions, the primary assumption of the risk doctrine does not provide a complete bar to liability in this case. The “primary assumption of the risk” doctrine is matter of duty.

  • Name

    A. V. VS. BREA OLINDA UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT

  • Case No.

    2024-01383647

  • Hearing

    Jul 16, 2026

Express assumption of the risk doctrine and implied primary assumption of the risk doctrine operate similarly. Under primary assumption of the risk, defendant owes no legal duty to protect plaintiff from the particular risk of harm. This type of assumption of the risk, in which defendant's conduct did not breach a legal duty of care to plaintiff, is a complete defense. (Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 308-309; see Shin v. Ahn (2007) 42 Cal.4th 482, 498.)

  • Name

    WESTERFELD V. ALISAL PROPERTIES

  • Case No.

    21CV02866

  • Hearing

    Feb 21, 2023

Defendant moves for summary judgment in its favor on two grounds-the lawsuit is barred by the primary assumption of the risk doctrine, and Defendant owes no legal duty to Plaintiff under a traditional duty analysis. Primary Assumption of the Risk: Primary assumption of the risk, the basis for defendants' summary judgment motions, is a complete defense to a negligence claim.

  • Name

    ROTHENBERG VS HOSSEINI

  • Case No.

    30-2015-00799074-CU-PO-NC

  • Hearing

    Oct 12, 2017

Issue No. 1: Defendant and Intervenor contend that the primary assumption of the risk doctrine bars Plaintiffs’ claims for negligence. (Notice of Motion (Notice), filed on 5-31-18, 2:20-23.) Rostai v. Neste Enterprises (Rostai) (2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 326, 335 found that the doctrine of primary assumption of the risk applies to physical fitness training.

  • Name

    MACK V. PETRUCHIK

  • Case No.

    30-2016-00880429-CU-PO-CJC

  • Hearing

    Sep 04, 2018

Rather, they discuss the applicability of primary assumption of risk. (See CACI Nos. 471 and 472 regarding primary assumption of risk as to instructors and facilities owners, respectively.) “What the primary assumption of risk doctrine does not do, however, is absolve operators of any obligation to protect the safety of their customers.

  • Name

    GHIZZONI VS. PURPLE PEDAL

  • Case No.

    30-2018-01015594

  • Hearing

    Nov 01, 2020

Cedar Fair, L.P., supra 55 Cal.4th at 1157-1158—primary assumption of risk not limited to traditional “sports” but includes “nonsport” recreational activities.)

  • Name

    MELIAN VS. FLUCHT

  • Case No.

    30-2019-01095944

  • Hearing

    Sep 22, 2020

Primary Assumption of the Risk Defendant argues that primary assumption of risk applies. Primary assumption of risk arises where a plaintiff voluntarily participates in an activity or sport involving certain inherent risks; primary assumption of risk does bar recovery because no duty of care is owed as to such risks. (Connelly v. Mammoth Mountain Ski Area (1995) 39 Cal.App.4th 8, 11.)

  • Name

    MARIANNA TERGHAZARYAN, ET AL. VS LOS ANGELES UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT

  • Case No.

    24VECV03918

  • Hearing

    Apr 10, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Under the primary assumption of the risk doctrine, an absolute defense to liability exists when defendant is a member of a class to which defendant should owe no duty of care in relation to the activity in which plaintiff is involved. This is a question of duty, and when primary assumption of the risk is applied, no duty of care exists to plaintiff. See, Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 310-15.

  • Name

    JAMES M LODDENGAARD M D VS HARDY & HARPER INC ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC698033

  • Hearing

    Dec 04, 2020

Primary assumption of the risk embodies a legal conclusion that there is no duty on the part of the defendant to protect the plaintiff from a particular risk. In primary assumption of the risk cases, if there is no duty of care owed, the plaintiff's assumption of the risk acts as a complete bar to the plaintiff's cause of action.

  • Case No.

    MSC21-00302

  • Hearing

    Dec 08, 2023

  • County

    Contra Costa County, CA

Analysis Primary Assumption of Risk Defendant moves for summary judgment on the ground that the primary assumption of risk doctrine bars Plaintiff’s claim. “Primary assumption of risk occurs when a plaintiff voluntarily engages in a sport or activity with inherent risks. It embodies those instances where there is a ‘legal conclusion that there is “no duty” on the part of the defendant to protect the plaintiff from that particular risk....’” (Balthazor v.

  • Name

    JONG HO LEE VS YUN SUNG JOO ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC649848

  • Hearing

    Feb 01, 2018

Primary Assumption of Risk: The defense of primary assumption of risk commonly applies to sporting activities. “Inherent in the sport of rockclimbing is the fact a fall can occur at any time, regardless of the negligence of one's coparticipants.” Regents of University of California v. Superior Court (1996) 41 Cal.App.4th 1040, 1047.

  • Name

    DRANCEA VS. UMI & BUDU, LLC

  • Case No.

    30-2017-00959920-CU-NP-CJC

  • Hearing

    Nov 19, 2018

Law Governing Primary Assumption of the Risk Assumption of risk falls into two categories: primary and secondary. Primary assumption of risk occurs when a plaintiff voluntarily engages in a sport or activity with inherent risks. It embodies those instances where there is a legal conclusion that there is no duty on the part of the defendant to protect the plaintiff from that particular risk.

  • Name

    J P ET AL VS INGLEWOOD UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC658197

  • Hearing

    Sep 11, 2018

ISSUE TWO: PRIMARY ASSUMPTION OF RISK: Absent reckless conduct, golfers assume the risk of being hit by a wayward shot made either by a “teammate” or a golfer playing another hole. (Shin v. Ahn (2007) 42 Cal.4th 482, 494, 497, 499-500 & fn. 11; compare Hemady v. Long Beach Unified School Dist. (2006) 143 Cal.App.4th 566, 577—being hit in head by club swung by another golfer not inherent risk.)

  • Name

    PACE VS. ALLAN

  • Case No.

    30-2016-00859259-CU-PO-CJC

  • Hearing

    Mar 06, 2018

To the extent the written release (constituting express assumption of the risk doctrine) and implied primary assumption of the risk doctrine operate similarly, the omission of the written release from the record does not preclude the court’s inquiry under an implied primary assumption of risk rationale.

  • Name

    NATASHA WESTERFELD VS ALISAL PROPERTIES

  • Case No.

    21CV02866

  • Hearing

    Nov 02, 2021

Primary or Secondary Assumption of Risk Defendants also contend they are entitled to summary judgment on the independent ground that they have shown a complete defense of primary assumption of risk. In Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296 (Knight), the California Supreme Court clarified the primary assumption of risk doctrine.

  • Name

    ANDREW RAMOS VS. ELIZABETH BAUN

  • Case No.

    23CECG02865

  • Hearing

    Oct 30, 2024

  • County

    Fresno County, CA

(2006) 38 Cal.4th 148, 161 (Primary assumption of the risk arises when, as a matter of law and policy, a defendant owes no duty to protect a plaintiff from particular harms).) The doctrine of primary assumption of risk developed as an exception to the general rule that all persons have a duty to use due care to avoid injury to others. . . . Primary assumption of risk is a complete bar to recovery. ( Childs v. County of Santa Barbara (2004) 115 Cal.

  • Name

    TIMOTHY VANGEL VS SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON COMPANY, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    21STCV21901

  • Hearing

    May 31, 2022

Thus, the Court finds that the primary assumption of risk doctrine applies here. The remaining issues are whether collisions between players is an inherent risk of volleyball and whether LAUSD increased that risk. LAUSD, as the party moving for summary adjudication, bears the burden of establishing both that the collision was an inherent risk of volleyball and that it did not increase the risk of harm to Plaintiff. Luna v. Vela (2008) 169 Cal.App.4th 102, 112. LAUSD has made no such showing.

  • Name

    MADISON PERRY VS LOS ANGELES UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC579027

  • Hearing

    Dec 20, 2016

Primary Assumption of Risk Lastly, “[w]hen a defendant moves for summary judgment on the basis of implied¿assumption¿of the¿risk, he or she has the burden of establishing the plaintiff's¿primary¿assumption¿of the¿risk¿by demonstrating that the defendant owed no legal duty to the plaintiff to prevent the harm of which the plaintiff complains.”¿ (Moser v. Ratinoff¿(2003) 105 Cal.App.4th 1211, 1217 [citation omitted].)

  • Name

    ROBERT LOPEZ VS JEFF CONOR TANGUCHI

  • Case No.

    19STCV06382

  • Hearing

    Aug 14, 2020

Under the primary assumption of the risk doctrine, an absolute defense to liability exists when defendant is a member of a class to which defendant should owe no duty of care in relation to the activity in which plaintiff is involved. This is a question of duty, and when primary assumption of the risk is applied, no duty of care exists to plaintiff. See Knight v. Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4 th 296, 310-15.

  • Name

    TE'NIYA HILBERT, AN INDIVIDUAL VS K1 SPEED, INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    24TRCV01513

  • Hearing

    Mar 16, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

After reviewing cases in which courts have found a primary assumption of risk and finding none involving organized, noncompetitive, recreational bicycle riding, the court nonetheless found that “this sport” fell within the category of cases to which the primary assumption of risk doctrine applies. (Id. at 1221.)

  • Name

    MINICK V. CITY OF PETALUMA

  • Case No.

    SCV-251915

  • Hearing

    Sep 07, 2018

Therefore, unless plaintiff alleges facts from which “conduct so reckless as to be totally outside the range of the ordinary activity in golf” could be inferred, primary assumption of risk precludes liability.

  • Name

    RICHARD ECKERT VS SHEN CHEN

  • Case No.

    1401621

  • Hearing

    Sep 20, 2012

Jewett (1992) 3 Cal.4th 296, 308, described primary assumption of the risk as encompassing situations when a defendant owes no duty of care to protect the plaintiff from a particular risk, regardless of whether the plaintiff acted reasonably or unreasonably in encountering the risk.

  • Name

    MICHELLE KIKUYE LAU IWAMOTO VS. STEVEN GEE

  • Case No.

    STK-CV-UPI-2014-0008603

  • Hearing

    Sep 13, 2018

Primary Assumption of the Risk “‘Primary assumption of risk arises where a plaintiff voluntarily participates in an activity or sport involving certain inherent risks; primary assumption of risk...bar[s] recovery because no duty of care is owed as to such risks.’(Citation.)” (West v. Sundown Little League of Stockton (2002) 96 Cal.App.4th 351, 357.)

  • Name

    ROBIN KING VS FITNESS INTERNATIONAL LLC ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC585765

  • Hearing

    Jan 13, 2017

The moving papers fail to carry Defendants' evidentiary burden of demonstrating that hitting one's head against the bottom of a swimming pool is an inherent risk of diving. (Capri v. L.A. Fitness Intern., LLC (2006) 136 Cal.App.4th 1078, 1087 [defendant seeking summary judgment based on primary assumption of the risk must establish that he owed no legal duty to the plaintiff to prevent the harm of which the plaintiff complains].)

  • Name

    NATHAN BERNEMAN VS. GARY ZELMAN

  • Case No.

    56-2010-00371268-CU-PO-SIM

  • Hearing

    Dec 02, 2011

Primary Assumption of the Risk Under the doctrine of primary assumption of the risk, defendants do not owe a duty of care to a plaintiff in certain situations, depending on the nature of the activity. (McGarry v. Sax (2008) 158 Cal.App.4th 983, 999.)

  • Name

    ANTHONY WILLIAM PAREDES BARRERA, ET AL. VS CITY OF LONG BEACH, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    21STCV02506

  • Hearing

    Jan 26, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA