Exhausting Administrative Remedies in California

What Are the Laws on Exhausting Administrative Remedies?

Purpose and Scope of Administrative Remedy

“‘[W]here an administrative remedy is provided by statute, relief must be sought from the administrative body and this remedy exhausted before the courts will act.’” (Terris v. County of Santa Barbara (2018) 20 Cal.App.5th 551, 555 citing Campbell v. Regents of University of California (2005) 35 Cal.4th 311, 320.)

Administrative remedies include ‘internal grievance procedures’ provided by a public entity. (Id.) “County employees must exhaust internal administrative remedies that are provided in county civil service rules.” (Id.)

“The Government Tort Claims Act (Gov. Code, § 810 et seq.) requires that ‘[b]efore suing a public entity, the plaintiff must present a timely written claim for damages to the entity.’” (A.M. v. Ventura Unified School District (2016) 3 Cal.App.5th 1252, 1257.) “A claim relating to a cause of action for ... injury to person[s] ... shall be presented ... not later than six months after the accrual of the cause of action.” (Id.) ‘Timely claim presentation is not merely a procedural requirement, but is ... “ ‘ “a condition precedent to plaintiff’s maintaining an action against defendant” ’ ” [citations], and thus an element of the plaintiff’s cause of action. [Citation.]’ [Citation.]” (A.M. v. Ventura Unified School District (2016) 3 Cal.App.5th 1252, 1257.) It is therefore clear that the presentation of a claim is not the same as filing a judicial action for damages because the presentation of the claim is condition precedent to the filing of a judicial action.

Labor Commissioner and Labor Code Distinction

“Campbell v. Regents of University of California (2005) 35 Cal.4th 311, 25 Cal.Rptr.3d 320, 106 P.3d 976 holds that public employees must pursue appropriate internal administrative remedies before filing a civil action against their employer.” (Terris v. Cnty. of Santa Barbara (2018) 20 Cal.App.5th 551, 553.) “Labor Code § 244 does not require a litigant to exhaust administrative remedies before bringing a civil action.” (Id.) “Here we hold § 244 applies only to claims before the Labor Commissioner. It has no effect on the Campbell rule.” (Id.)

In Terris, the plaintiff filed a complaint with County’s Civil Service Commission, alleging that the termination procedure violated her seniority rights and that the County had discriminated against her for exercising her rights as a County employee. (Id. at 554.) The Commission ruled that it could decide whether the County had followed the proper procedures for terminating the plaintiff, but could not decide the discrimination claim because the plaintiff had not exhausted her administrative remedy of filing a discrimination complaint with the EEOC. (Id.)

The appeals court concluded: “The Commission also advised [the plaintiff] and her counsel that if [the plaintiff] wanted to raise her Labor Code discrimination/retaliation issues, she first had to file an EEOC complaint. Because she had not filed it, the Commission could only decide whether proper job termination procedures were followed. It offered her a continuance so that issue and the discrimination/retaliation issues could be decided together. But she and her counsel rejected that alternative and elected to have a Commission hearing only on the procedural issues. [The plaintiff] decided not to file the EEO complaint. Consequently, her §§ 1101, 1102, and 1102.5 claims are barred.” (Id. at 559.)

“Exhaustion” Defined

“[A]n administrative remedy is exhausted only upon ‘termination of all available, nonduplicative administrative review procedures.’” (Coachella Valley Mosquito and Vector Control Dist. v. California Public Employment Relations Bd. (2005) 35 Cal.4th 1072, 1080.)

Ordinarily, filing a claim with a public entity pursuant to the Claims Act is a jurisdictional element of any cause of action for damages against the public entity (City of San Jose v. Superior Court (1974) 12 Cal.3d 447, 454; Snipes v. City of Bakersfield (1983) 145 Cal.App.3d 861, 865) that must be satisfied in addition to the exhaustion of any administrative remedies (Richards v. Department of Alcoholic Beverages Control (2006) 139 Cal.App.4th 304, 315 [mere filing of claim does not satisfy need to exhaust remedy by applying for license before bringing suit]; see Ortiz v. Lopez (E.D.Cal.2010) 688 F.Supp.2d 1072, 1079– 1080; Creighton v. City of Livingston (E.D.Cal.2009) 628 F.Supp.2d 1199, 1221– 1222 [both holding that allegation of compliance with Claims Act insufficient without allegation of exhaustion of administrative remedy as well].)

“There are certain types of claims in Government Code § 905 expressly exempted from the presentation requirement; otherwise, a court will infer a legislative intent to excuse compliance only where a claim is based on a statutory scheme with a ‘functionally equivalent claim process’ and a comparable scheme for administrative enforcement.” (Gatto v. County of Sonoma (2002) 98 Cal.App.4th 744, 763–764 [state civil rights actions lack such equivalency and are therefore not exempt from Claims Act; as a result, limitations period extended and action is timely]; accord, Bates v. Franchise Tax Bd. (2004) 124 Cal.App.4th 367, 373, 383–385, [agency's violations of restrictions on disseminating personal information; Information Practices Act of 1977 (Civ.Code, § 1798 et seq.) does not have an administrative mechanism for enforcement of its provisions, and nothing gives agency notice that damages might be sought for noncompliance; thus failure to file claim bars action].) Such exceptions to the presentation procedure are rarely found. (Gatto, supra, 98 Cal.App.4th at p. 764.) (Cornejo v. Lightbourne (2013) 220 Cal.App.4th 932, 938–39.)

Rulings for Exhausting Administrative Remedies in California

Defendant argues that plaintiff must first exhaust her administrative remedies prior to filing an action for violation of Section 230.1 and she has not alleged exhaustion of those administrative remedies.

  • Name

    CLARK V. TAHOE TURNING POINT

  • Case No.

    PC-20170185

  • Hearing

    Sep 08, 2017

Petitioners were required to exhaust their administrative remedies Petitioners do not argue that they have exhausted their administrative remedies. Rather, they argue that they should be excused from exhausting their administrative remedies for several reasons. First, they argue that “a party is not required to exhaust the available administrative remedies when those administrative procedures are the very source of the asserted injury.

  • Name

    HOUSING REFORM COALITION OF LA VS CITY OF LOS ANGELES

  • Case No.

    BS144425

  • Hearing

    Mar 27, 2018

Failure to Exhaust Administrative Remedies Defendants argue that each of Plaintiffs causes of action should be dismissed because Plaintiff has failed to adequately plead that he has exhausted his administrative remedies.

  • Case No.

    23STC11319

  • Hearing

    May 01, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Issue No. 1: Failure to Exhaust Administrative Remedies under FEHA Defendant’s demurrer is based upon the fact that all of Plaintiff’s causes of action are brought under FEHA, as evidenced by the FAC’s caption and substance. Defendant contends that Plaintiff does not, however, identify any FEHA laws violated by Defendant. More generally, Defendant asserts that because Plaintiff failed to timely exhaust administrative remedies under FEHA, the FAC must be dismissed its entirety.

  • Name

    BERNARD ALLER VS SARAH CANNON

  • Case No.

    BC706163

  • Hearing

    Mar 05, 2019

Truong (which it is not), Plaintiff failed to exhaust her grievance through the Second and Third Levels of Review, and her administrative remedies cannot therefore be deemed exhausted. (15 CCR § 3084.1(b); Wright v. State of California (2004) 122 Cal.App.4th 659; Parthemore v. Col (2013) 221 Cal.App.4th 1372, 1380.) Plaintiff’s failure to exhaust administrative remedies is not excused.

  • Name

    JACKSON VS. STATE OF CALIFORNIA

  • Case No.

    RIC1715688

  • Hearing

    Jul 30, 2019

However, Defendant did not previously move for summary adjudication on the grounds Plaintiff failed to exhaust her administrative remedies, and it appears Code of Civil Procedure section 437c(f) does not prevent Defendant from moving for judgment on the pleadings on such grounds. Plaintiff also contends Plaintiff was not required to exhaust administrative remedies pursuant to Labor Code sections 98.7 and 244. However, such contention was addressed and rejected in Terris v.

  • Name

    KARIMI VS. REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CA TRANS

  • Case No.

    30-2017-00916063-CU-WT-CJC

  • Hearing

    Jul 11, 2019

Issues 1-8: Failure to Exhaust Administrative Remedies Due to Lack of Specificity of June 5, 2019 Administrative Complaint Issues 1-8 address whether Katono's June 5, 2019 administrative complaint to the Department of Fair Employment and Housing ("DEFH") was sufficiently specific to exhaust administrative remedies as required by FEHA . As an initial point, the Court notes that Defendants already raised this issue in an earlier motion for summary adjudication .

  • Name

    ANNA KATONO, ET AL. VS LOS ANGELES COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT, A CORPORATION, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    20STCV03322

  • Hearing

    Nov 07, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: HEARING ON DEMURRER — TO PLAINTIFF’S AMENDED COMPLAINT [DEFT] LIEUTENANT ERNST RULI'NG The Court previously sustained Defendant’s demurrer because Plaintiff failed to exhaust his administrative remedies and allege facts sufficient to state a cause of action for negligence. The Court, however) granted leave to amend. Plaintiff has now submitted an amended complaint which fails to cure these defects.

  • Name

    ALFRED KING AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICER HAN, ET AL

  • Case No.

    CV1900724

  • Hearing

    May 11, 2021

NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: HEARING ON DEMURRER — TO PLAINTIFF’S AMENDED COMPLAINT [DEFT] LIEUTENANT ERNST RULING The Court previously sustained Defendant’s demurrer because Plaintiff failed to exhaust his administrative remedies and allege facts sufficient to state a. cause of action for negligence. The Court, however, granted leave to amend. Plaintiff has now submitted an amended complaint which fails to cure these defects.

  • Name

    ALFRED KING AND CORRECTIONAL OFFICER HAN, ET AL

  • Case No.

    CV1900724

  • Hearing

    May 04, 2021

  There, the Court of Appeal addressed whether it would have been futile for the plaintiff to exhaust administrative remedies before bringing an inverse condemnation action against the defendant.  Barata makes no such futility argument here in support of her motion for leave to amend.

  • Name

    SABRINA BARATA VS THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    25STCV24978

  • Hearing

    Oct 29, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

On August 8, 2022, Defendant filed a reply arguing that the requirement to exhaust administrative remedies is applicable to everything seeking a refund from EDD, regardless of whether based in California or another State. Further Defendant argues that Plaintiff is attempting to litigate the merits of the case using extrinsic evidence and the arguments still do not excuse the requirement to exhaust administrative remedies. ANALYSIS I.

  • Name

    TOPOLEWSKI AMERICA, INC., A NEVADA CORPORATION VS STATE OF CALIFORNIA EMPLOYMENT DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT

  • Case No.

    22STCV18199

  • Hearing

    Sep 02, 2022

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

SUSTAIN THE DEMURRER TO THE 6TH (CLAIM PRECLUSION), 7TH (IMPLIED CONTRACT), 9TH (FILED RATE DOCTRINE) AND 10TH (FAILURE TO EXHAUST ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES-MEDI-CAL CLAIMS) AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES WITHOUT LEAVE TO AMEND. OVERRULE THE DEMURRER TO THE 11TH (FAILURE TO EXHAUST ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES-MEDICARE CLAIMS) AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE.

  • Name

    RIVERSIDE EMERGENCY V VANTAGE MEDICAL

  • Case No.

    RIC1405100

  • Hearing

    Dec 20, 2016

DECEDENT AND PLAINTIFF FAILED TO EXHAUST ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES. SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION FOR RETALIATION: DECEDENT AND PLAINTIFF FAILED TO EXHAUST ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES. PLAINTIFF HAS FAILED TO PRESENT EVIDENCE OF RETALIATION. THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION FOR TERMINATION IN VIOLATION OF PUBLIC POLICY MAY NOT BE BROUGHT AGAINST A PUBLIC ENTITY. FOURTH CAUSE OF ACTION BREACH OF STATUTORY DUTY. U. C. WAS NOT DECEDENT'S EMPLOYER.

  • Name

    ALVIN SYKES VS. DONNA BORLAND ET AL

  • Case No.

    CGC06448665

  • Hearing

    Sep 05, 2007

(Notice at p. 2. ) The original Answer previously alleged only that Plaintiffs “failed to exhaust administrative remedies.” The Amended Answer’s Second Affirmative Defense now alleges that Plaintiffs “failed to exhaust the administrative remedies” created by Health & Safety Code §§ 1367, 1371.38, and Code of Regulations § 130071.38. (FAA ¶ 3.) The Amended Answer further alleges that Plaintiffs were given notice of the administrative remedies, noting that they were required to exhaust these remedies.

  • Name

    GOLDEN STATE EMERGENCY PHYSICIANS, INC., ET AL. VS ANGELES-IPA, A MEDICAL CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    19STCV19808

  • Hearing

    Jun 29, 2020

DISCUSSION Second Cause of Action for Whistleblower Retaliation Labor Code § 1102.5 Defendants demurrer to Plaintiffs second cause of action on the grounds that Plaintiff has failed to exhaust administrative remedies prior to bringing his claim. In opposition, Plaintiff argues that he is not required to exhaust administrative remedies and any failure to exhaust is based on Defendants improper conduct.

  • Name

    ANTHONY RUSSO VS CITY OF PASADENA, A MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    23AHCV01866

  • Hearing

    Apr 22, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

As explained below, however, Plaintiff has failed to exhaust administrative remedies as to Le. Issue No.3: Failure to Exhaust Administrative Remedies Defendants allege that Plaintiff failed to exhaust her administrative remedies as to Le and SMH. Plaintiff presents no argument that she was not required to exhaust administrative remedies with respect to claims against Le. Plaintiff, however, argues that she was not required to exhaust administrative remedies in connection with the sixth cause of action.

  • Name

    CHRISTOPHER GOORIS VS ROBERT WYAR

  • Case No.

    19STCV09644

  • Hearing

    Aug 12, 2020

As Plaintiffs point out in their opposition, there appear to be no published cases on the issue of whether a plaintiff asserting a housing discrimination claim is required to exhaust his or her administrative remedies before filing suit.

  • Name

    MARTHA RUMBO ET AL VS 3044 LEE WARD AVENUE LLC ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC702472

  • Hearing

    Apr 30, 2021

PLAINTIFF FAILED TO EXHAUST HIS ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES. =(302/LMG)

  • Name

    PETER HEIN VS. CITY COLLEGE OF SAN FRANCISCO ET AL

  • Case No.

    CGC09494744

  • Hearing

    Mar 10, 2011

In opposition, ALADS contends that certain facts excuse ALADS from having to first exhaust administrative remedies.

  • Name

    ASSOCIATION FOR LOS ANGELES DEPUTY SHERIFFS VS COUNTY OF LA

  • Case No.

    BC684856

  • Hearing

    Feb 23, 2018

It states: The district court granted summary judgment on Ramirez's retaliation claim under California Labor Code § 6310 because Ramirez had not exhausted his administrative remedies prior to filing his complaint. At the time, the California Labor Code was silent as to whether a plaintiff must exhaust administrative remedies prior to filing a complaint.

  • Case No.

    April J Grundfor v California Department of State Hospitals, et al. 17CVP0107

  • Hearing

    Jul 11, 2017

  • County

    San Luis Obispo County, CA

DEMURRER Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies (as to all five causes of action of Complaint) Basurto v. Imperial Irrigation District (2012) 211 C.A.4th 866, 879 explains: “Employees who believe they have suffered discrimination at the hands of their employers and wish to file civil claims for damages under the FEHA must first exhaust their administrative remedies by filing a complaint with the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) and obtaining a right-to-sue notice. [Citations.]

  • Name

    JOEY MORALES, A.K.A. JOEY HERNANDEZ VS COUNTY OF SAN JOAQUIN ET AL.

  • Case No.

    STK-CV-UWT-2019-0000614

  • Hearing

    Jul 02, 2019

Indeed, it is clear from the face of the petition that Veerapan did not exhaust her administrative remedies, and that she filed this action before the last steps in the administrative process were completed. 3 Veerapan also fails to allege facts that demonstrate she was not required to exhaust her administrative remedies. Simply alleging the administrative remedies are “worthless,” without more, is insufficient.

  • Name

    ARAYAN VEERAPAN VS. CALIFORNIA MASSAGE THERAPY COUNCIL

  • Case No.

    34-2019-80003069-CU-WM-GDS

  • Hearing

    Sep 20, 2019

Second, plaintiff argues estoppel bars from asserting he failed to exhaust administrative remedies. [A] government entity will be estopped from asserting as a defense a failure to exhaust administrative remedies when a government agent has negligently or intentionally caused a party to fail to comply with a procedural precondition to recovery. ( Shuer v. County of San Diego (2004) 117 Cal.App.4th 476, 486.)

  • Name

    ARTHUR LITTLE VS REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    22STCV36102

  • Hearing

    Jun 01, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Instead, the Courts minute order (also dated November 15) stated that [b]ecause the Court finds that Plaintiff has not sufficiently pled that FEHA applies to David, it does not reach Defendants argument that Plaintiff failed to exhaust her administrative remedies. There is no inconsistency between this final November 15 order and the subsequent November 21 order which concluded that Veloso failed to exhaust her administrative remedies.

  • Name

    AURICE VELOSO VS LEO DAVID, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    22STCV35085

  • Hearing

    Jan 08, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

On Cross-Defendants Dahl, Thompson, Dippel and Dippel's demurrer to all causes of action for failure to exhaust administrative remedies, the demurrer to the first, second and third causes of action is sustained without leave to amend. The demurrer to the fourth cause of action for failure to exhaust administrative remedies is overruled on the grounds that a wrongful discharge claim is not subject to an exhaustion requirement. Rojo v. Kliger (1990) 52 Cal. 3d 65.

  • Name

    ORSBORN, TIFFANY A VS SUPERCUTS ET AL

  • Case No.

    17CV01144

  • Hearing

    Aug 14, 2019

Plaintiff has thus failed to show she can successfully amend her complaint to overcome her failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Therefore, leave to amend is denied unless Plaintiff can allege facts supporting compliance with the requirements to exhaust administrative remedies. Dated this 15th day of August, 2017. HON. MICHELLE WILLIAMS COURT Judge of the Superior Court

  • Name

    GRACIELA E ORTIZ VS COMPASSIONATE CARE HOSPICE ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC646004

  • Hearing

    Aug 15, 2017

DISCUSSION Second Cause of Action for Whistleblower Retaliation Labor Code § 1102.5 Defendants demurrer to Plaintiffs second cause of action on the grounds that Plaintiff has failed to exhaust administrative remedies prior to bringing his claim. In opposition, Plaintiff argues that he is not required to exhaust administrative remedies and any failure to exhaust is based on Defendants improper conduct.

  • Name

    CAVANAUGH THOMPSON VS CITY OF PASADENA, A MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    23AHCV01862

  • Hearing

    Apr 22, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Exhaustion of administrative remedies “Under both state and federal law, a prisoner must exhaust available administrative remedies before seeking judicial relief. By 1941, as a rule of general application, state courts required litigants to exhaust their administrative remedies. [Citations.] The exhaustion requirement is jurisdictional: a court cannot hear a case before a litigant exhausts administrative remedies.” (Wright v. State of California (2004) 122 Cal.App.4th 659, 664–665.)

  • Name

    JONES VS STATE OF CALIFORNIA,BY AND THROUGH THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AND REHABILITATION

  • Case No.

    RIC2000035

  • Hearing

    Jun 03, 2022

  • County

    Riverside County, CA

Exhaustion of administrative remedies “Under both state and federal law, a prisoner must exhaust available administrative remedies before seeking judicial relief. By 1941, as a rule of general application, state courts required litigants to exhaust their administrative remedies. [Citations.] The exhaustion requirement is jurisdictional: a court cannot hear a case before a litigant exhausts administrative remedies.” (Wright v. State of California (2004) 122 Cal.App.4th 659, 664–665.)

  • Name

    JONES VS STATE OF CALIFORNIA,BY AND THROUGH THE CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS AND REHABILITATION

  • Case No.

    RIC2000035

  • Hearing

    Jun 02, 2022

  • County

    Riverside County, CA

A party must exhaust administrative remedies before resorting to the courts. (Plantier v. Ramona Municipal Water Dist. (2019) 7 Cal.5th 372, 382-383.) Plaintiff’s petition does not demonstrate that plaintiff exhausted all administrative remedies. (See California Vehicle Code section 22852.) Law & Motion ADD-ON

  • Case No.

    N24-1027

  • Hearing

    Dec 20, 2024

  • County

    Contra Costa County, CA

[Citation.] [¶] The Schifando court made plain that, having chosen a forum for discrimination claims, a public employee must exhaust “the chosen administrative forum's procedural requirements.” [Citation.]” ( Page v. Los Angeles County Probation Dept. (2004) 123 Cal.App.4th 1135, 1141–1142.) A party fails to exhaust administrative remedies if they do no await an administrative body’s final decision before filing suit. ( Page , supra , 123 Cal.App.4th at 1143.)

  • Name

    RANDI WINTER VS EL CAMINO COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    20STCV15305

  • Hearing

    Feb 10, 2021

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

  • Type

    Employment

  • Sub Type

    Discrimination/Harass

ORTIZ ("Plaintiffs") are required to exhaust administrative remedies, pursuant to Labor Code section 2699.3, before bringing the instant claims and have not yet exhausted their administrative remedies, is GRANTED. Defendants' Request (ROA # 15) for judicial notice is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART. The Court takes judicial notice only of the date on which Plaintiffs filed their Complaint with the Court; otherwise, the Request is DENIED.

  • Name

    HAUGEN VS ATTIC CONSTRUCTION INC

  • Case No.

    37-2018-00033020-CU-OE-CTL

  • Hearing

    Oct 02, 2018

Here, the Second Amended Complaint (the “SAC”) does not allege exhaustion of administrative remedies. Instead, Plaintiff contends that she is excused or that there are exceptions to the requirement of exhaustion of administrative remedies.

  • Name

    ELLISON V. RENOVATE AMERICA, INC.

  • Case No.

    30-2019-01103023

  • Hearing

    Apr 28, 2021

Analysis Though Section 53069.4 of the Government Code allows an individual to contest the administrative decision of a local agency in superior court, the individual must first exhaust other administrative remedies. (Section 53069.4(b)(1) of the Government Code.)

  • Case No.

    L26-10394

  • Hearing

    Oct 13, 2026

  • County

    Contra Costa County, CA

We have recognized, in the context of the Fair Employment and Housing Act, that "[t]he failure to exhaust an administrative remedy is a jurisdictional, not a procedural, defect," and thus that failure to exhaust administrative remedies is a ground for a defense summary judgment. (Miller v. United Airlines, Inc., supra, 174 Cal.App.3d at p. 890.)" Martin v Lockheed Missiles & Space Co., Inc (1994) 29 CA 4th 1718, 1724.

  • Name

    ANGELICA MARI RIVERA DE NUNEZ VS. DREAM TEAM SERVICES INC

  • Case No.

    56-2014-00457510-CU-OE-VTA

  • Hearing

    Feb 09, 2015

Timeliness of Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies Defendants previously demurred to Plaintiffs complaint for failure to exhaust administrative remedies.

  • Name

    LAZARO HERNANDEZ VS EVOQUA WATER TECHNOLOGIES, LLC, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    25STCV04501

  • Hearing

    Apr 20, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Even if plaintiff had not been precluded from pursuing his FEHA claims by his failure to exhaust his judicial remedies, his FEHA claims would still be precluded by his failure to timely exhaust his administrative remedies under FEHA. FEHA requires that an employee exhaust his or her administrative remedies by filing a complaint with the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (Gov. Code, § 12960, subd. (c)), and obtain a notice of right to sue. (Gov. Code, § 12965, subd. (b).)

  • Name

    JOSE RODRIGUEZ VS CITY OF SANTA BARBARA

  • Case No.

    19CV04331

  • Hearing

    Feb 11, 2020

Defendant Borga, Inc., demurs on the grounds that this Court lacks jurisdiction because Plaintiff has failed to exhaust his administrative remedies as against this defendant, and that Plaintiff has failed to establish that Defendants Borga, Inc., and BSCS are joint employers as alleged.

  • Name

    RENE TREJO V. BORGA STEEL BUILDINGS AND COMPONENTS, INC., ET AL.

  • Case No.

    16CECG00111

  • Hearing

    May 10, 2016

As such, Plaintiff has failed to exhaust her administrative remedies as to her CFRA claim. See Martin, 29 Cal.App.4th at 1724 ("[F]ailure to exhaust administrative remedies is a ground for a defense summary judgment.").

  • Name

    BYRD VS. VISTA UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT

  • Case No.

    37-2017-00020461-CU-OE-NC

  • Hearing

    Aug 01, 2019

As such, Plaintiff has failed to exhaust her administrative remedies as to her CFRA claim. See Martin, 29 Cal.App.4th at 1724 ("[F]ailure to exhaust administrative remedies is a ground for a defense summary judgment.").

  • Name

    BYRD VS. VISTA UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT

  • Case No.

    37-2017-00020461-CU-OE-NC

  • Hearing

    Jul 26, 2019

Plaintiffs attempt to remedy this failure by submitting the April 15, 2025 Right-to-Sue letter does not cure her failure to exhaust administrative remedies. (See Guzman v. NBA Automotive, Inc. (2021) 68 Cal.App.5th 1109, 1118.) Therefore, the Court sustains the demurrer without leave to amend. CONCLUSION The Court sustains Defendants demurrer without leave to amend. Defendant to give notice.

  • Name

    SYLVIA MONIQUE MURRAY VS SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA PERMANENTE MEDICAL GROUP, INC., ET AL.

  • Case No.

    23STCV00865

  • Hearing

    Apr 30, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

· If the May 21, 2024 SB 9 approval of the tentative map constitutes the decision for purposes of Government Code section 66499.37, what administrative remedies was petitioner required to exhaust prior to filing suit within 90 days?

  • Name

    ASHLAND NEIGHBORS VS CITY OF SANTA MONICA, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    25STCP02497

  • Hearing

    Apr 09, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Petitioner must first exhaust his administrative remedy, and then raise any objections to either the procedure utilized by the administrative body or the substance of the administrative decision with the administrative body before seeking court intervention.

  • Name

    JOHN DOE, II VS THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA

  • Case No.

    21CV-01690

  • Hearing

    Nov 15, 2021

  • County

    Merced County, CA

The court lacks subject matter jurisdiction because petitioner has failed to allege that she has exhausted her administrative remedies prior to bringing this petition. Petitioner was required to bring a grievance procedure under the Education Code, and the FAP does not contain sufficient allegations demonstrating that a contractual grievance procedure resulting in arbitration, was pursued. Nor has petitioner shown that the requirement to exhaust her administrative remedies was excused.

  • Name

    TATUM V. MT. SAN JACINTO COMMUNITY COLLEGE

  • Case No.

    RIC2003189

  • Hearing

    Jul 20, 2021

Defendants argue that plaintiff failed to provide any authority that she need not exhaust administrative remedies against the individual defendants. Further, defendants assert, the Labor Code sections cited by plaintiff does not alleviate her obligation to exhaust administrative remedies against them by timely giving notice to the LWDA of their alleged violations of the Labor Code.

  • Name

    CAROLINA SALAZAR VS. THE BAY CLUBS COMPANY, LLC, ET AL

  • Case No.

    YC073022

  • Hearing

    Nov 19, 2021

  • Judge

    Timothy Lee Johnson

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Section 1, 2 and 3, the administrative remedies/procedures therein outlined relate only to decisions regarding a physician’s privileges made by the Medical Executive Committee for a medical disciplinary cause or reason preceded by a Notice and Hearing which did not occur here. In the absence of an adequate remedy, Plaintiff could not have been required to exhaust the stated administrative remedies.  (Payne v. Anaheim Mem'l Med. Ctr., Inc., (2005)130 Cal. App. 4th 729).

  • Name

    - WILLIAMS, R MICHAEL, MD VS DOCTORS MEDICAL CENTER OF MODESTO INC - A)

  • Case No.

    CV-20-004732

  • Hearing

    Feb 02, 2026

  • County

    Stanislaus County, CA

Section 1, 2 and 3, the administrative remedies/procedures therein outlined relate only to decisions regarding a physician’s privileges made by the Medical Executive Committee for a medical disciplinary cause or reason preceded by a Notice and Hearing which did not occur here. In the absence of an adequate remedy, Plaintiff could not have been required to exhaust the stated administrative remedies.  (Payne v. Anaheim Mem'l Med. Ctr., Inc., (2005)130 Cal. App. 4th 729).

  • Name

    - WILLIAMS, R MICHAEL, MD VS DOCTORS MEDICAL CENTER OF MODESTO INC - A)

  • Case No.

    CV-20-004732

  • Hearing

    Feb 01, 2026

  • County

    Stanislaus County, CA

Section 1, 2 and 3, the administrative remedies/procedures therein outlined relate only to decisions regarding a physician’s privileges made by the Medical Executive Committee for a medical disciplinary cause or reason preceded by a Notice and Hearing which did not occur here. In the absence of an adequate remedy, Plaintiff could not have been required to exhaust the stated administrative remedies.  (Payne v. Anaheim Mem'l Med. Ctr., Inc., (2005)130 Cal. App. 4th 729).

  • Name

    - WILLIAMS, R MICHAEL, MD VS DOCTORS MEDICAL CENTER OF MODESTO INC - A)

  • Case No.

    CV-20-004732

  • Hearing

    Jan 31, 2026

  • County

    Stanislaus County, CA

Section 1, 2 and 3, the administrative remedies/procedures therein outlined relate only to decisions regarding a physician’s privileges made by the Medical Executive Committee for a medical disciplinary cause or reason preceded by a Notice and Hearing which did not occur here. In the absence of an adequate remedy, Plaintiff could not have been required to exhaust the stated administrative remedies.  (Payne v. Anaheim Mem'l Med. Ctr., Inc., (2005)130 Cal. App. 4th 729).

  • Name

    - WILLIAMS, R MICHAEL, MD VS DOCTORS MEDICAL CENTER OF MODESTO INC - A)

  • Case No.

    CV-20-004732

  • Hearing

    Jan 30, 2026

  • County

    Stanislaus County, CA

The defendant demurred to the complaint, contending the plaintiff failed to exhaust administrative remedies prior to filing suit. The P.W. Court explained that plaintiffs must exhaust all administrative remedies prior to filing litigation.

  • Name

    CREDITORS ADJUSTMENT BUREAU, INC. VS ALPINE ROOF COMPANY, INC.

  • Case No.

    19LBCV00210

  • Hearing

    Oct 21, 2021

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Accordingly, on the face of the petition, Petitioner has failed to exhaust his administrative remedies. Accordingly, the demurrer of the CDCR is sustained. Because the Court sustains the demurrer on this basis, it need not address the other grounds asserted by CDCR. Petitioner is granted ten (10) days leave to file an amended petition addressing this defect. All parties must comply with Marin County Superior Court Local Rules, Rule 2.10(B) to contest the tentative decision.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jul 17, 2024

  • County

    Marin County, CA

Accordingly, on the face of the petition, Petitioner has failed to exhaust his administrative remedies. Accordingly, the demurrer of the CDCR is sustained. Because the Court sustains the demurrer on this basis, it need not address the other grounds asserted by CDCR. Petitioner is granted ten (10) days leave to file an amended petition addressing this defect. All parties must comply with Marin County Superior Court Local Rules, Rule 2.10(B) to contest the tentative decision.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jul 20, 2024

  • County

    Marin County, CA

Accordingly, on the face of the petition, Petitioner has failed to exhaust his administrative remedies. Accordingly, the demurrer of the CDCR is sustained. Because the Court sustains the demurrer on this basis, it need not address the other grounds asserted by CDCR. Petitioner is granted ten (10) days leave to file an amended petition addressing this defect. All parties must comply with Marin County Superior Court Local Rules, Rule 2.10(B) to contest the tentative decision.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jul 21, 2024

  • County

    Marin County, CA

Accordingly, on the face of the petition, Petitioner has failed to exhaust his administrative remedies. Accordingly, the demurrer of the CDCR is sustained. Because the Court sustains the demurrer on this basis, it need not address the other grounds asserted by CDCR. Petitioner is granted ten (10) days leave to file an amended petition addressing this defect. All parties must comply with Marin County Superior Court Local Rules, Rule 2.10(B) to contest the tentative decision.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jul 22, 2024

  • County

    Marin County, CA

Accordingly, on the face of the petition, Petitioner has failed to exhaust his administrative remedies. Accordingly, the demurrer of the CDCR is sustained. Because the Court sustains the demurrer on this basis, it need not address the other grounds asserted by CDCR. Petitioner is granted ten (10) days leave to file an amended petition addressing this defect. All parties must comply with Marin County Superior Court Local Rules, Rule 2.10(B) to contest the tentative decision.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jul 18, 2024

  • County

    Marin County, CA

Accordingly, on the face of the petition, Petitioner has failed to exhaust his administrative remedies. Accordingly, the demurrer of the CDCR is sustained. Because the Court sustains the demurrer on this basis, it need not address the other grounds asserted by CDCR. Petitioner is granted ten (10) days leave to file an amended petition addressing this defect. All parties must comply with Marin County Superior Court Local Rules, Rule 2.10(B) to contest the tentative decision.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jul 16, 2024

  • County

    Marin County, CA

The racing association argued that the horsemens association was required to exhaust administrative remedies with the CHRB, citing CHRB Rule 2043.

  • Name

    GEORGE SHARP VS SANTA ANITA PARK, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    20STCV04582

  • Hearing

    Aug 15, 2022

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Accordingly, the Court finds that Petitioner failed to exhaust his administrative remedies. IV. Conclusion For the foregoing reasons, the Court SUSTAINS Respondent’s demurrer WITHOUT LEAVE TO AMEND. (See Tejon Real Estate, LLC v. City of Los Angeles (2014) 223 Cal.App.4th 149, 156 [“A demurrer may properly be sustained based on the failure to adequately plead exhaustion of administrative remedies.”].)

  • Name

    MARK PENN VS STATE OF CALIFORNIA ET AL

  • Case No.

    BS162647

  • Hearing

    Mar 08, 2017

Exhaust administrative remedies issue. Because the request for judicial notice is denied, the Court cannot make a determination from the face of the Petition as to whether Ps were required to exhaust. They allege they were not required to exhaust and the Court must take this as true on demurrer. (Gerawan Farming, Inc. v. Lyons (2000) 24 Cal.4th 468, 515-516.)

  • Name

    CITY OF IRWINDALE VS. COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

  • Case No.

    56-2015-00464100-CU-WM-VTA

  • Hearing

    Apr 07, 2015

““In the enforcement of this section, there is no requirement that an individual exhaust administrative remedies or procedures.” Cal. Lab. Code § 98.7(g). The Legislature also enacted Labor Code section 244, which provides that, “An individual is not required to exhaust administrative remedies or procedures in order to bring a civil action under any provision of this code, unless that section under which the action is brought expressly requires exhaustion of an administrative remedy.” Cal. Lab.

  • Name

    ROBERT MATTHEWS VS. STOCKTON UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT

  • Case No.

    STK-CV-UOE-2015-0008208

  • Hearing

    Jul 09, 2019

Judge Cowan entered a detailed order denying leave, finding that defendant had failed to exhaust his administrative remedies by failing to appeal the administrative ruling within the City. Under the law governing such writs, judicial review can be sought only after the party seeking such review has exhausted all administrative remedies, meaning that all avenues of appeal within the City have been properly tried and have failed.

  • Name

    CITY OF CALABASAS, A CALIFORNIA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION VS TOPANGA LAND, LLC, A COLORADO LLC, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    24SMCV01271

  • Hearing

    Apr 11, 2025

  • Judge

    6/18/2022

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Therefore, Reliance failed to exhaust administrative remedies prior to filing this action. In the alternative, Reliance argues that six months have passed since the final payment was made on December 17, 2024, and the CDFTA has not yet responded. The Court is unpersuaded by this argument because [a]s our Supreme Court observed, both the California Constitution and the tax code require a taxpayer to exhaust administrative remedies before bringing an action in court. (See Stettner v.

  • Name

    RELIANCE RESTAURANTS LLC, A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION VS CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF TAX AND FEE ADMINISTRATION; AND, DOES 1-10

  • Case No.

    25STCV00280

  • Hearing

    Aug 20, 2025

  • Judge

    Echo Dawn Ryan

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Therefore, Beri Enterprises failed to exhaust administrative remedies prior to filing this action. In the alternative, Beri Ventures argues that six months have passed since the final payment was made on December 17, 2024, and the CDFTA has not yet responded. The Court is unpersuaded by this argument because, [a]s our Supreme Court observed, both the California Constitution and the tax code require a taxpayer to exhaust administrative remedies before bringing an action in court. (See Stettner v.

  • Name

    BERI VENTURES LLC, A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION VS CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF TAX AND FEE ADMINISTRATION; AND, DOES 1-10

  • Case No.

    25STCV00261

  • Hearing

    Aug 20, 2025

  • Judge

    Echo Dawn Ryan

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Therefore, Beri Development failed to exhaust administrative remedies prior to filing this action. In the alternative, Beri Development argues that six months have passed since the final payment was made on November 21, 2024, and the CDFTA has not yet responded. The Court is unpersuaded by this argument because [a]s our Supreme Court observed, both the California Constitution and the tax code require a taxpayer to exhaust administrative remedies before bringing an action in court. (See Stettner v.

  • Name

    BERI DEVELOPMENT LLC, A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION VS CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF TAX AND FEE ADMINISTRATION; AND, DOES 1-10

  • Case No.

    25STCV00285

  • Hearing

    Aug 20, 2025

  • Judge

    Echo Dawn Ryan

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Defendant County contends plaintiff Church’s submission of a claim for Welfare Exemption subsequent to the institution of this action amounts to a failure to exhaust administrative remedies. In opposition, plaintiff Church contends the timing of its submission of a claim for Welfare Exemption to the County Assessor does not amount to a failure to exhaust administrative remedies.

  • Name

    CHURCH OF SCIENTOLOGY OF SILICON VALLEY VS COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA, A BODY CORPORATE AND POLITIC

  • Case No.

    19CV357287

  • Hearing

    Jun 04, 2020

As explained below, the gravamen of the 4th through 6th causes of action against defendant Alvord Unified School District (“defendant AUSD”) is the denial of Free and Appropriate Public Education (“FAPE”) and Plaintiff did not exhaust her administrative remedies.

  • Name

    MINOR DARBY VS RIVERSIDE COUNTY OFFICE OF EDUCATION

  • Case No.

    RIC1500915

  • Hearing

    Aug 20, 2018

Accordingly, even if the action were not moot, dismissal would have been appropriate in light of petitioners’ failure to exhaust available administrative remedies. The court will therefore respectfully DENY the motion for attorneys’ fees and costs.

  • Name

    PECHANGA BAND OF LUISENO INDIANS VS CITY OF MENIFEE

  • Case No.

    CVRI2000531

  • Hearing

    Aug 06, 2022

  • County

    Riverside County, CA

Accordingly, even if the action were not moot, dismissal would have been appropriate in light of petitioners’ failure to exhaust available administrative remedies. The court will therefore respectfully DENY the motion for attorneys’ fees and costs.

  • Name

    PECHANGA BAND OF LUISENO INDIANS VS CITY OF MENIFEE

  • Case No.

    CVRI2000531

  • Hearing

    Aug 07, 2022

  • County

    Riverside County, CA

Accordingly, even if the action were not moot, dismissal would have been appropriate in light of petitioners’ failure to exhaust available administrative remedies. The court will therefore respectfully DENY the motion for attorneys’ fees and costs.

  • Name

    PECHANGA BAND OF LUISENO INDIANS VS CITY OF MENIFEE

  • Case No.

    CVRI2000531

  • Hearing

    Aug 08, 2022

  • County

    Riverside County, CA

As such, the Court finds that Plaintiff’s first, second, fourth, fifth, and sixth causes of action arising under FEHA in the FAC are SUSTAINED without leave to amend as Plaintiff did not exhaust his administrative remedies.

  • Name

    GREGORY DAVENPORT VS COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC718192

  • Hearing

    Jun 18, 2019

Defendants move for judgment on the pleadings on the grounds that Plaintiff failed to exhaust his administrative remedies.

  • Name

    KEVIN BLACKMAN VS TRANSDEV SERVICES, INC., ET AL.

  • Case No.

    21STCV28191

  • Hearing

    Sep 05, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Respondents make various arguments in demurring, with the principal arguments being that Petitioner failed to exhaust its administrative remedies and that Plaintiff lacks standing. The Court rejects the first argument. Although administrative remedies may have been required to be exhausted if Petitioner were seeking to, for example, delist any plant or animal under the California Endangered Species Act ("CESA"), that is not the relief Petitioner seeks.

  • Name

    PETITION OF CALIFORNIA CATTLEMENS ASSOCIATION

  • Case No.

    37-2016-00006135-CU-WM-CTL

  • Hearing

    Dec 08, 2016

Superior Court (2002) 97 Cal.App.4th 109, 115 – 119 [naming of the person who allegedly committed the unlawful practice is mandatory; failure to do so is a failure to exhaust administrative remedies as against said person]; (Davenport v.

  • Case No.

    CV-2021-0297

  • Hearing

    Feb 28, 2023

  • County

    Yolo County, CA

The Supreme Court concluded that “the exhaustion rule requires university employees to exhaust university administrative remedies before proceeding to suit.” (Ibid.) The Campbell court did not expressly consider an exhaustion requirement under Labor Code section 98.7, but reached a more general conclusion addressing university administrative remedies not applicable here.

  • Name

    RICHARD QUIROGA VS SANTA BARBARA COMMUNITY COLLEGE ETC ET AL

  • Case No.

    1418131

  • Hearing

    Jan 07, 2014

ANALYSIS A party seeking relief pursuant to FEHA must first exhaust his or her administrative remedies. ( Wills v. Superior Court (2011) 195 Cal.App.4th 143, 153 (Before filing a civil action alleging FEHA violations, an employee must exhaust his or her administrative remedies with DFEH).)

  • Name

    MAHTAB TABAN VS GURSEY, SCHNEIDER & CO. LLC, A CALIFORNIA LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    19STCV25387

  • Hearing

    Jan 27, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies The Johnson Defendants argue that Plaintiff was required to exhaust his administrative remedies before filing this lawsuit. (Wright v. State of California (2004) 122 Cal.App.4th 659, 663, 666-667 [plaintiff prisoner asserting medical malpractice claims was required to exhaust his administrative remedies via administrative appeal process prior to filing his lawsuit].)

  • Name

    VINCENT CALLENDER V. JESUS PEREZ, M.D. ET AL.

  • Case No.

    18CVP0055

  • Hearing

    Feb 26, 2019

Taylor did not exhaust her administrative remedies with regards to these moving defendants. Further, Plaintiff Taylor does not oppose the motion as to these defendants. 2. Judgment on the pleadings is DENIED as to defendant FilmOn.TV, Inc. because Taylor’s original DFEH complaint did list this defendant as a respondent. 3.

  • Name

    ELIZABETH TAYLOR ET AL VS ALKIVIADES DAVID ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC649025

  • Hearing

    Sep 28, 2017

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 05, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    May 30, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    May 31, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 17, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 06, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 02, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 01, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 03, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 04, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 10, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 21, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 23, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

Although Plaintiff admits that the tax sale was authorized by law in arguing that hi failure to exhaust administrative remedies would have been futile, he raises new challenges t the conduct of the sale based on several procedural constitutional grounds. Plaintiff contend that the sale was procedurally improper due to a lack of notice of the sale.

  • Name

    MCINNIS V COUNTY OF SANTA CRUZ

  • Case No.

    20CV02234

  • Hearing

    Mar 03, 2020

  • Judge

    : Timothy Volkmann</p>

  • County

    Santa Cruz County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 15, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    May 24, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    May 25, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    May 26, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    May 27, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    May 28, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 09, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 22, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025. Respondent has now demurred to the amended petition.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 25, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA

ASCENCIO, ET AL NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: 1) DEMURRER 2) CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE RULING The Court previously sustained Respondent California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitations (CDCR) demurrer to Petitioner Charles Carters (Petitioner) petition for a writ of mandate for failure to exhaust administrative remedies. Petitioner was granted leave to amend and filed an amended petition on January 23, 2025. Respondent has now demurred to the amended petition.

  • Case No.

    CV0002451

  • Hearing

    Jun 26, 2025

  • County

    Marin County, CA