We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

MONTGOMERY SANSOME ET AL VS ARCH CONSTR. ET AL

A (13) Unlimited Defamation case was filed by (Subcribe to view) represented by (Subcribe to view) against (Subscribe to view) represented by (Subscribe to view) in the jurisdiction of San Mateo County. Judge Gerald J. Buchwald presiding.

Case Details

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)   

Filing Date

October 04, 2011

Last Refreshed

August 30, 2023

Filing Location

San Mateo County, CA

Judge

Hon. Gerald J. Buchwald   

Category

(13) Unlimited Defamation

Practice Area

Torts

Matter Type

Slander,Libel,Defamation

Case Outcome Type

Judgment

Status

Relief Denied

Verdict Information
See the final verdict for this case along with the verdict amount

Description

Defendant denied making allegedly slanderous comment

Jury Vote

Semper mauris faucibus vestibulum.

Case Type(s)

  • Intentional Torts; Slander

Demand

$X,XXX,XXX

Jury Composition

9 Female, 3 Male

Verdict Type

Verdict-Defendant

Offer

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Sit aliquam vel nunc quam.

Result

Request access to view Verdict Results

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Risus integer vitae nullam at. Quis metus, enim et vitae risus nisl nec, sed scelerisque. Posuere facilisi magna ullamcorper id. Aenean cras aliquam morbi egestas eget massa tortor euismod euismod. Ac aliquam ante gravida aenean neque pharetra eget. Lectus molestie vivamus morbi tortor id cursus in faucibus. Sit ut vulputate ornare vivamus hac sit turpis. Viverra feugiat viverra venenatis.

Parties

Plaintiffs

Montgomery Sansomelp
Nordeman, Leonard A

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Tumlin, Tracy N

Defendants

Arch Construction Lp
Mahallati, Nasser
Mahallati, Sayl

Attorneys for Defendants

Biernat, James D.

Case Documents

Declaration

Date: Jul 01, 2013

Conversion Action

Date: Jun 21, 2013

Motion

Date: Jun 13, 2013

Document

Date: Jun 13, 2013

Conversion Action

Date: Apr 16, 2013

Conversion Action

Date: Mar 25, 2013

Notice

Date: Mar 15, 2013

Conversion Action

Date: Mar 15, 2013

Notice

Date: Feb 22, 2013

Order

Date: Feb 15, 2013

Order

Date: Feb 15, 2013

Document

Date: Feb 04, 2013

Document

Date: Feb 04, 2013

Declaration

Date: Jan 18, 2013

Conversion Action

Date: Jan 08, 2013

Notice

Date: Jan 08, 2013

Conversion Action

Date: Dec 24, 2012

Conversion Action

Date: Dec 24, 2012

Document

Date: Dec 17, 2012

Document

Date: Dec 14, 2012

Document

Date: Dec 10, 2012

Document

Date: Dec 10, 2012

Document

Date: Dec 10, 2012

Document

Date: Dec 10, 2012

Document

Date: Dec 10, 2012

Document

Date: Dec 10, 2012

Answer (Unlimited)

Date: Oct 29, 2012

Document

Date: Oct 03, 2012

Document

Date: Oct 03, 2012

Declaration

Date: Sep 20, 2012

Opposition

Date: Sep 20, 2012

Ex Parte

Date: Sep 17, 2012

Motion

Date: Sep 17, 2012

Order

Date: Sep 17, 2012

Declaration

Date: Sep 17, 2012

Notice

Date: Sep 14, 2012

Answer (Unlimited)

Date: Aug 07, 2012

Conversion Action

Date: Jul 30, 2012

Conversion Action

Date: Jul 13, 2012

Order

Date: Jun 08, 2012

Complaint

Date: Oct 04, 2011

Case Events

Type Description
Docket Event
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 140528-0905-XJ DEP/ 22.82 PAYMENT
Docket Event Conversion Action
EJT: EXONERATE JURY TRUST
Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: - 2 -.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY PDEANG ON 07/09/13.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: SUFFICIENT NOTICE TO THE PARTIES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: PURSUANT TO RULE 3.1312 OR ANY OTHER NOTICE IS REQUIRED, AS THE TENTATIVE RULING AFFORDS
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE GERALD J\. BUCHWALD, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: PATRICE DEANG, COURT REPORTER: ROSA DE NOLA Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Buchwald, Gerald J.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: 3.1308(A)(1), ADOPTED BY LOCAL RULE 3.10, EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY, AND NO FORMAL ORDER
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: IF THE TENTATIVE RULING IS UNCONTESTED, IT SHALL BECOME THE ORDER OF THE COURT, PURSUANT TO RULE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THE ARBITRATION AWARD HAS NOT YET EXPIRED. SEE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, SECTION 1288.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THE COURT NOTES THAT THE 100 DAY DEADLINE FOR FILING A DIRECT PETITION TO VACATE OR CORRECT
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: NOTICE OF HEARING AND PETITION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: SOUGHT FROM THE ARBITRATOR. AND IT APPEARS THAT THIS DECLARATION WAS NOT SERVED ALONG WITH THE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THE ARBITRATOR (JUDGE-RETIRED V. GENE MCDONALD). APPARENTLY, NO SUCH MODIFICATION OF AWARD WAS
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: ADDED RECOVERY OF COSTS IN THE AMOUNT OF APPROXIMATELY $25,000 THAT WERE NOT AWARDED BY
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: MADE, THE SUPPORTING DECLARATION OF PETITIONER SEEKS A CORRECTION OF THE AWARD TO SET FORTH
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: WHILE THE PETITION HERE RECITES THAT NO APPLICATION FOR CORRECTION OF THE AWARD HAS BEEN
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: AWARD HAS NOT BEEN SUBMITTED TO THE ARBITRATOR THEREBY RENDERING THE PETITION PREMATURE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THE COURT CANNOT ACT ON THE PETITION AT THIS TIME FOR LACK OF COMPLETE SERVICE OF ALL OF THE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: SUBMITTED MOTION PAPERS ON THE OPPOSING SIDE, AND THE REQUESTED MODIFICATION OF ARBITRATION
Docket Event Conversion Minute
NAP: NO APPEARANCE IS MADE BY ANY PARTIES HEREIN OR THEIR COUNSEL OF RECORD.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: COMPLETE NOTICE TO COUNSEL FOR ARCH CONSTRUCTION, INC.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRA: TENTATIVE RULING ADOPTED AND BECOMES THE ORDER:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: LP'S UNOPPOSED PETITION TO CONFIRM ARBITRATION AWARD IS DENIED AS PREMATURE AND/OR FOR LACK OF
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO BEING RE-SUBMITTED. PETITIONER LEONARD NORDEMAN & MONTGOMERY SANSOME
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
HEARING: MOTION RE: TO CONFIRM ARBITRATION AWARD BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Motion hearings
Dept: LM HEARING: MOTION RE: TO CONFIRM ARBITRATION AWARD BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM1: * *
Docket Event DECLARATION OF LEONARD NORDEMAN IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO CONFIRM ARBITRATION AWARD
Declaration
DEC: DECLARATION OF LEONARD NORDEMAN IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO CONFIRM ARBITRATION AWARD
Docket Event REMITTITUR FILED FOR APPEAL A138125. APPEAL IS DISMISSED.
Conversion Action
COMMI: REMITTITUR FILED FOR APPEAL A138125. APPEAL IS DISMISSED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION TO CONFIRM ARBITRATION FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMA
Motion
NM: NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION TO CONFIRM ARBITRATION FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN
Docket Event PETITION TO CONFIRM ARBITRATION AWARD, FILED.
Document
FILED: PETITION TO CONFIRM ARBITRATION AWARD, FILED.
Docket Event (PROPOSED) JUDGMENT CONFIRMING ARBITRATION AWARD RECEIVED.
Conversion Action
COMMI: (PROPOSED) JUDGMENT CONFIRMING ARBITRATION AWARD RECEIVED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 130613-0417-CK 036/ 60.00 PAYMT
Docket Event First Paper Fee Paid
FFP4: MOTION FEE PAID BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP.
Docket Event ABANDONMENT OF APPEAL A138125 FILED .
Conversion Action
COMMI: ABANDONMENT OF APPEAL A138125 FILED .
Docket Event CLERK'S CERTIFICATE RE: ABANDONMENT OF APPEAL A138 125 FILED.
Conversion Action
COMMI: CLERK'S CERTIFICATE RE: ABANDONMENT OF APPEAL A138 125 FILED.
Docket Event RECEIVED ORDER FROM COA, FILED 04/11/13, APPEAL A1 38125 IS DISMISSED.
Conversion Action
COMMI: RECEIVED ORDER FROM COA, FILED 04/11/13, APPEAL A1 38125 IS DISMISSED.
Docket Event CLERK'S CERTIFICATE RE: APPELLANT'S DEFAULT ON APP EAL A138125 FILED.
Conversion Action
COMMI: CLERK'S CERTIFICATE RE: APPELLANT'S DEFAULT ON APP EAL A138125 FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Action
ETT: EXONERATE TRANSCRIPT TRUST
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 130328-0199-XT DEP/ 100.00 PAYMENT
Docket Event APPELLANT'S NOTICE DESIGNATING RECORD ON APPEAL A138125 FILED.
Conversion Action
COMMI: APPELLANT'S NOTICE DESIGNATING RECORD ON APPEAL A138125 FILED.
Docket Event NOTICE RE: APPELLANT'S DEFAULT ON APPEAL A138125 FILED.
Conversion Action
COMMI: NOTICE RE: APPELLANT'S DEFAULT ON APPEAL A138125 FILED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF APPEAL FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP.
Notice
N: NOTICE OF APPEAL FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP.
Docket Event NOTICE OF FILING OF APPEAL FILED .
Conversion Action
COMMI: NOTICE OF FILING OF APPEAL FILED .
Docket Event Conversion Action
COMM: RECEIVED JP CLOZEL, MARTINE CLOZEL & SIMON BUCKING HAM'S COMBINED REPLY & C/R BRIEF ON A133927.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 130315-0392-CK TRN/ 100.00 PAYMENT
Docket Event Conversion Action
DTT: TRANSCRIPT TRUST POSTED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOME, LP ON BEHALF OF MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN.
Docket Event NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI.
Notice
N: NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI.
Docket Event ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR A NEW TRIAL, SIGNED BY JUDGE GERALD J\. BUCHWALD ON 02/15/13, FILED.
Order
O: ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR A NEW TRIAL, SIGNED BY JUDGE GERALD J\. BUCHWALD ON 02/15/13, FILED. Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for
Docket Event ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR JUDGMENT NOV, SIGNED BY JUDGE GERALD J BUCHWALD ON 02/15/13, FILED.
Order
O: ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR JUDGMENT NOV, SIGNED BY JUDGE GERALD J BUCHWALD ON 02/15/13, FILED. Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: AS TO NON-SUIT ON LIBEL CLAIM, COURT FINDS NO ERROR OF LAW. THERE WAS CLEAR AND CONVINCING
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 03:35, COURT CONVENES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL TO RETURN AT 3:30 P.M..
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAD: ATTORNEY JAMES D. BIERNAT APPEARING WITH/FOR DEFENDANT(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAP: ATTORNEY TRACY TUMLIN APPEARING WITH/FOR PLAINTIFF(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 02:51, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 02:46, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE GERALD J\. BUCHWALD, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: PATRICE DEANG, COURT REPORTER: WENDY WACHHORST Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Buchwald, Gerald J.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Hearing
HEARING RE: SETTING HEARING ON MOTIONS FOR NEW TRIAL & FOR JUD.NOTWITH.VERDICT.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Other hearing
Dept: 10 HEARING RE: SETTING HEARING ON MOTIONS FOR NEW TRIAL & FOR JUD.NOTWITH.VERDICT.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FOS: FORMAL ORDER SUBMITTED AND SIGNED BY THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY PDEANG ON 02/15/13.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
DENIED: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT NOTWITHSTANDING THE VERDICT IS DENIED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT FINDS SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THE VERDICT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
DENIED: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR A NEW TRIAL IS DENIED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: EVIDENCE AND BEYOND DISPUTE, COMMENTS WERE STATEMENTS OF OPINION AND THEREFORE CANNOT
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MAS: MATTER ARGUED BY COUNSEL AND SUBMITTED TO THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: CONSTITUTE LIBEL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
HCSM: HAVING CONSIDERED THE SUBMITTED MATTER, THE COURT RULES AS FOLLOWS:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CFO: THE COURT FINDS/ORDERS: * *.
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
HEARING RE: SETTING HEARING ON MOTIONS FOR NEW TRIAL & FOR JUD.NOTWITH.VERDICT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
HC: HEARING CONTINUED TO 02/15/13 AT 02:30 IN DEPARTMENT 10.
Docket Event Other hearing
Dept: 10 HEARING RE: SETTING HEARING ON MOTIONS FOR NEW TRIAL & FOR JUD.NOTWITH.VERDICT.
Docket Event DEFENDANT'S POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR JUDGMENT, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFENDANT'S POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR JUDGMENT, FILED.
Docket Event DEFENDANT'S POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFENDANT'S POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL, FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 130204-0582-XJ DEP/ 222.12 PAYMENT
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 130204-0580-XJ DEP/ 512.70 PAYMENT
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 130204-0579-XJ DEP/ 1143.50 PAYMENT
Docket Event PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED.
Order received
POR: PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED.
Docket Event Conversion Action
EJT: EXONERATE JURY TRUST
Docket Event DECLARATION OF TRACY N TUMLIN IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONS BY PLAINTIFFS FOR JUDGMENT, ETC FILED BY MONTGO
Declaration
DECL: DECLARATION OF TRACY N TUMLIN IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONS BY PLAINTIFFS FOR JUDGMENT, ETC FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN
Docket Event MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP IN SUPPORT O
Memorandum of Points & Authorities
MPA: MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL AND JUDGMENT NOTWITHSTANDING THE VERDICT
Docket Event ORDER SETTING HEARING ON MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL AND JUD.NOTWITH.VERDICT, SIGNED BY JUDGE GERALD BUCHW
Order
O2: ORDER SETTING HEARING ON MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL AND JUD.NOTWITH.VERDICT, SIGNED BY JUDGE GERALD BUCHWALD ON 01/18/13 FILED. Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for
Docket Event MEMO FOR COSTS IN THE AMOUNT OF $14,423.12 FILED BY ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, SAYL MAHALLATI, NASSER MA
Conversion Action
MC: MEMO FOR COSTS IN THE AMOUNT OF $14,423.12 FILED BY ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, SAYL MAHALLATI, NASSER MAHALLATI
Docket Event NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR JUDGMENT NOTWITHSTANDING THE VERDICT FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, M
Notice
N2: NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR JUDGMENT NOTWITHSTANDING THE VERDICT FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP.
Docket Event Conversion Action
COMM: NOTICES OF PLAINTIFFS RE NEW TRIAL/JUDGMENT LOCATED TO DEPT. 10.
Docket Event NOTICE OF INTENTION TO MOVE FOR NEW TRIAL FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP.
Notice
N: NOTICE OF INTENTION TO MOVE FOR NEW TRIAL FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP.
Docket Event Conversion Action
CRFEE: COURT REPORTER FEES OF $244.00 PAID BY ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 130104-0153-CK 022/ 244.00 PAYMT
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 130104-0150-CK JRY/ 244.94 PAYMENT
Docket Event Conversion Action
DJT: JURY TRUST POSTED BY JAMES D BIERNAT ON BEHALF OF ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP.
Docket Event JUDGMENT ON VERDICT FILED
Conversion Action
JOV: JUDGMENT ON VERDICT FILED
Docket Event NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT FILED AND MAILED TO ALL PARTIES
Conversion Action
NEJM: NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT FILED AND MAILED TO ALL PARTIES
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DECEMBER 19, 2012.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: ENTRY OF JUDGMENT IS STAYED TO AND INCLUDING WED., DECEMBER 26, 2012. NUNC PRO TUNC TO
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DEFENDANT ARCH CONTRUCTION LP; SAYL MAHALLATI AND AGAINST PLAINTIFF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP;
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: LEONARD A. NORDEMAN. DEFENDANTS TO HAVE AND RECOVER THEIR COSTS OF SUIT HEREIN. TIME FOR
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: HEREIN PURSUANT TO THE ATTACHED VERDICT, ON 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP, FOR
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TOT1: TOTAL JUDGMENT $0.00
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT PLAINTIFFS SHALL TAKE NOTHING BY THEIR COMPLAINT
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JFD: JUDGMENT ENTERED ON 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP FOR ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, SAYL MAHALLATI
Docket Event Conversion Minute
PRI: PRINCIPAL IS $0.00.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JAGP: JUDGMENT ENTERED ON 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP AGAINST MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN
Docket Event Conversion Action
JEAS: JUDGMENT ENTERED ON 12/24/12 AS FOLLOWS:
Docket Event NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING JURY FEES & CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/18/12 (DEFT), FILED.
Document
FILED: NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING JURY FEES & CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/18/12 (DEFT), FILED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/18/12 (PLAINTIFF), FILED.
Document
FILED: NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/18/12 (PLAINTIFF), FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Action
COMM: HARDSHIP REQUEST FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Action
COMM: JURY VERDICT FORMS (GIVEN) FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Action
COMM: CONFIDENTIAL JURY INFORMATION FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Action
COMM: JURY INSTRUCTIONS READ TO THE JURY FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Action
COMM: JURY INSTRUCTIONS NOT GIVEN TO THE JURY FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Action
COMM: JUROR NOTES FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 121218-0333-CK JRY/ 1656.20 PAYMENT
Docket Event Conversion Action
DJT: JURY TRUST POSTED BY JAMES BIERNAT ON BEHALF OF ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 121218-0330-CK 022/ 1220.00 PAYMT
Docket Event Conversion Action
CRFEE: COURT REPORTER FEES OF $1,220.00 PAID BY ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $244.94 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, SAYL MAHALLATI ON 12/18/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $0.00 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN ON 12/18/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY PDEANG ON 12/18/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JPV: THE JURORS ARE POLLED ON THE VERDICT(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JUDGMENT TO BE ENTERED WITHIN 24 HOURS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JTE: AT 03:47, THE JURORS ARE THANKED AND EXCUSED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRVEE: AT THE DIRECTION OF THE COURT, THE CLERK ENTERED THE VERDICT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
VF: VERDICT FILED AND ATTACHED TO MINUTES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
VFD: VERDICT ON THE 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP FOR DEFENDANT ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, SAYL MAHALLATI AND AGAINST PLAINTIFF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
DSJF: DATED: 12/18/12; SIGNED BY JUROR 3176176, JURY FOREPERSON.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
VR: VERDICT READ, THE JURY FINDING AS FOLLOWS:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT RECITES ON THE RECORD INSTRUCTIONS NOT READ TO THE JURY.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
ATJV: AT 03:37, THE JURY RETURNS TO THE COURTROOM AND INDICATES THEY HAVE REACHED A VERDICT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PLAINTIFF'S CAUSE OF ACTION IS VOLUNTARY DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JURY NOT PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 03:26, COURT RECONVENES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 02:45, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CFO: THE COURT FINDS/ORDERS: ALTERNATE JUROR TO REMAIN ON STANDBY UNTIL THE CONCLUSION OF THE CASE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AJR: AT 02:35 THE JURORS RETIRE TO JURY DELIBERATIONS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: ALTERNATE JUROR NO. 3204541 THANKED AND EXCUSED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
BSJ: AT 02:34, BAILIFF KEITH JULIEN IS SWORN TO TAKE CHARGE OF THE JURY.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CIJ: AT 01:35, THE COURT INSTRUCTS THE JURY.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 01:33, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT'S COMMENTS AND STATES HIS REASONS ON THE RECORD.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 11:50, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
DENIED: DEFT'S MOTION FOR A DIRECTED VERDICT IS * DENIED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MAS: MATTER ARGUED BY COUNSEL AND SUBMITTED TO THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
OPOJ: OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, DEFENSE REQUEST FOR A MOTION FOR A DIRECTED VERDICT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JA: JURORS ADMONISHED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 11:38, JURY EXCUSED AND ORDERED TO RETURN AT 1:30 P.M..
Docket Event Conversion Minute
RAB: AT 11:22, THE REBUTTAL ARGUMENT OF PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL, MR. TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 11:20, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 11:35, REBUTTAL ARGUMENT CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 10:55, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CAB: AT 09:40, CLOSING ARGUMENT BY PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL, TRACY TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CAB: AT 10:10, CLOSING ARGUMENT BY DEFENSE COUNSEL, MR. BIERNAT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: SLANDER (ORAL DEFAMATION) AS TO PHONECALL IS WHAT THE JURY WILL DECIDE ON.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: PLAINTIFF HAS NOT MET HIS BURDEN OF PROOF. NO SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE TO FIND A FALSE STATEMENT
Docket Event Conversion Minute
GRANT: AS TO CLAIM OF LIBEL, DEFT'S MOTION FOR NONSUIT IS GRANTED GRANTED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: OF FACT. COURT FINDS A STATEMENT OF OPINION AND GIVES HIS REASONS AS STATED ON THE RECORD.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
HCSM: HAVING CONSIDERED THE SUBMITTED MATTER, THE COURT RULES AS FOLLOWS:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: FURTHER ARGUMENTS MADE BY COUNSEL AS TO DEFT'S MOTION FOR NONSUIT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JRES: COUNSEL FOR THE PARTIES STIPULATE THAT THE JURY MAY RETIRE FOR THE EVENING IF A VERDICT HAS NOT BEENREACHED AND FURTHER STIPULATE THAT THE JURY MAY ASSEMBLE IN THE HALLWAY WHEN INSTRUCTED TO DO SO IN
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JSTIP: COUNSEL FOR THE PARTIES STIPULATE THE JURY MAY GO TO LUNCH AND RETURN TO RESUME DELIBERATIONS WITHOUT COUNSEL AND THE PARTIES BEING PRESENT
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JRR: COUNSEL STIPULATE THAT IF THE JURY REQUESTS RE-READING OF TESTIMONY, THE COURT REPORTER MAY DO SO INTHE JURY ROOM AFTER THE JURY HAS BEEN INSTRUCTED NOT TO DELIBERATE DURING THE RE-READING, UPON
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 09:13, COURT RECONVENES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAP: ATTORNEY TRACY TUMLIN APPEARING WITH/FOR PLAINTIFF(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAD: ATTORNEY JAMES BIERNAT APPEARING WITH/FOR DEFENDANT(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRDAY: TRIAL DAY 7
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE GERALD J\. BUCHWALD, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: PATRICE DEANG, COURT REPORTER: ROSA DE NOLA Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Buchwald, Gerald J.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Hearing
JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Jury Trial
Dept: 10 JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event DEFT'S MOTION FOR NON SUIT FOR LIBEL, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S MOTION FOR NON SUIT FOR LIBEL, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS DATED 12/17/12, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS DATED 12/17/12, FILED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING JURY FEES & CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/17/12 (DEFENDANT), FILED.
Document
FILED: NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING JURY FEES & CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/17/12 (DEFENDANT), FILED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/17/12 (PLAINTIFF), FILED.
Document
FILED: NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/17/12 (PLAINTIFF), FILED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING JURY FEES AND CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/14/12, FILED.
Document
FILED: NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING JURY FEES AND CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/14/12, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S PROPOSED VERDICT FORM ON LIBEL, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S PROPOSED VERDICT FORM ON LIBEL, FILED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/14/12 (PLAINTIFF), FILED.
Document
FILED: NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/14/12 (PLAINTIFF), FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S BRIEF ON JURY INSTRUCTIONS, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S BRIEF ON JURY INSTRUCTIONS, FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY PDEANG ON 12/18/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
HC: HEARING CONTINUED TO 12/18/12 AT 09:00 IN DEPARTMENT 10.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: FURTHER HEARING TO CONTINUE 12/18/12 AT 9:00 A.M..
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: FURTHER HEARING HELD ON DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR NONSUIT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MAS: MATTER ARGUED BY COUNSEL AND SUBMITTED TO THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: STIPULATED EXHIBITS BY COUNSEL HAVE BEEN ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 04:16, COURT RECONVENES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT ORDERS COUNSEL TO CONFER AS TO EXHIBITS TO BE ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JAD: AT 03:19, THE JURORS ARE ADMONISHED AND DIRECTED TO RETURN ON 12/18/12 AT 09:00.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 03:27, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 03:16, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER RECROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: EXCLUDING EXHIBITS, EVIDENCE STANDS CLOSED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
REST: AT 03:18, PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT REST(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
EXC: AT 03:17, THE WITNESS IS EXCUSED FROM THE STAND.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 03:11, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER REDIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 03:06, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 03:07, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER CROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 02:33, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 02:36, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER DIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: VOLUME 2 (NOT LODGED) DEPOSITION OF LEONARD NORDEMAN REFERRED BY COUNSEL AND READ TO THE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 02:39, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 02:36, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 31 - DIAGRAM CHART PREPARED BY WITNESS, LEONARD NORDEMAN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WS: AT 02:02, WITNESS LEONARD ALBERT NORDEMAN IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 02:01, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 12:00, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
OPOJ: OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, DEFENSE COUNSEL RAISED ISSUES RE: WITNESS, ELOA SHARIF'S TESTIMONY DURING THE TRIAL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: DEFENSE MOTION TO STRIKE WITNESS' TESTIMONY IS RESERVED BY THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JURORS EXCUSED UNTIL 1:45 P.M..
Docket Event Conversion Minute
EXC: AT 11:55, THE WITNESS IS EXCUSED FROM THE STAND.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JA: JURORS ADMONISHED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:54, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER REDIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:51, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER RECROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:45, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER REDIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO DEFT'S EXHIBIT 210.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: DEFT'S EXHIBIT 208 - LETTER FROM MONTGOMERY SANSOME TO LYNN MURPHY DATED 10/07/11.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO DEFT'S EXHIBIT 212.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: DEFT'S EXHIBIT 210 - MONTGOMERY SANSOME, REVISED MOLD BILL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 14.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: DEFT'S EXHIBIT 212 - LETTER FROM MONTGOMERY SANSOME TO BRET BRADANINI.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:30, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER CROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: DEFENSE COUNSEL'S MOTION TO STRIKE WITNESS' TESTIMONY RESERVED RULING OUTSIDE PRESENCE OF JURY.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 4 *.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 3.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: DEFT'S EXHIBIT 206 - MONTGOMERY SANSOME INVOICE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:02, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER CROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 11:00, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WR: AT 11:01, WITNESS ELOA SHARIF, PREVIOUSLY SWORN, RESUMES THE STAND AND TESTIFIES FURTHER UNDER DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 10:15, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 10:14, WITNESS ADMONISHED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JURORS EXCUSED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 10:13, JURORS ADMONISHED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 29 - GMAIL DATED 09/30/11 AT 12:21 P.M. TO AMBER NASSER.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT ORDERS EXHIBIT 1 WITHDRAWN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 10:02, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER DIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 10:01, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 10:02, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: OBJECTION MADE BY DEFENSE COUNSEL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 1 - DECLARATION OF ELOA SHARIF.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 09:52, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 09:53, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER DIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 09:46, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WR: AT 09:14, WITNESS ELOA SHARIF, PREVIOUSLY SWORN, RESUMES THE STAND AND TESTIFIES FURTHER UNDER DIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 09:13, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAD: ATTORNEY JAMES BIERNAT APPEARING WITH/FOR DEFENDANT(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAP: ATTORNEY TRACY TUMLIN APPEARING WITH/FOR PLAINTIFF(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRDAY: TRIAL DAY 6
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE GERALD J\. BUCHWALD, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: PATRICE DEANG, COURT REPORTER: ROSA DE NOLA Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Buchwald, Gerald J.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $244.94 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP ON 12/17/12.
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $0.00 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN ON 12/17/12.
Docket Event DEFT'S PROPOSED VERDICT FORM ON SLADER, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S PROPOSED VERDICT FORM ON SLADER, FILED.
Docket Event Jury Trial
Dept: 10 JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 03:00, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: JURY: PP. 35-36, LINE 14; P.108, LINE 16-25; P. 143, LINE 4-20.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 02:48, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER CROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 02:38, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREID: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE INTRODUCED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO DEFT'S EXHIBIT 206.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 21.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREID: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE INTRODUCED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF:
Docket Event DEFT'S BRIEF ON SPECIAL DAMAGES FOR ALLEGED LIBEL, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S BRIEF ON SPECIAL DAMAGES FOR ALLEGED LIBEL, FILED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING JURY FEES & CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/13/12 (DEFENDANT), FILED.
Document
FILED: NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING JURY FEES & CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/13/12 (DEFENDANT), FILED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING JURY FEES AND CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/12/12 (DEFENDANT), FILED.
Document
FILED: NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING JURY FEES AND CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/12/12 (DEFENDANT), FILED.
Docket Event NTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/13/12 (PLAINTIFF), FILED.
Document
FILED: NTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/13/12 (PLAINTIFF), FILED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/12/12, FILED.
Document
FILED: NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES FOR 12/12/12, FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $244.94 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP ON 12/14/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $0.00 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN ON 12/14/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY PDEANG ON 12/17/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
ACAT: AT 1645, THE COURT ADJOURNS FURTHER TRIAL UNTIL 12/17/12 AT 09:00, IN DEPARTMENT 10.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 4:41, WITNESS ORDERED TO RETURN ON 12/14/12 AT 9:00 A.M..
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 04:30, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JAD: AT 04:49, THE JURORS ARE ADMONISHED AND DIRECTED TO RETURN ON 12/17/12 AT 09:00.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 04:29, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 04:25, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER DIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 04:18, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 04:25, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 04:02, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WR: AT 04:02, WITNESS ELOA SHARIF, PREVIOUSLY SWORN, RESUMES THE STAND AND TESTIFIES FURTHER UNDER DIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 03:41, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 3 - EMSL LAB RESULTS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 4 - EM LAB RESULTS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 03:30, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER DIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 7.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT ACCEPTS FACTS AS ESTABLISHED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL STIPULATE ON THE RECORD THAT MONTGOMERY SANSOME IS A LIMITED PARTNERSHIP.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 3:16, JURORS NOW PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT ADMONISHED THE WITNESS, ELOA SHARIF.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WS: AT 03:18, WITNESS ELOA SHARIF IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
OPOJ: OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, ARGUMENTS/BRIEFS MADE ON THE RECORD AS TO ISSUES RE: LENGTH OF TIME OF POSTING.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
EXC: AT 02:51, THE WITNESS IS EXCUSED FROM THE STAND.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 21 *.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREAD: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE PREVIOUSLY MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF AND ARE NOW ADMITTED:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 02:42, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER REDIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 14.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WR: AT 02:20, WITNESS SOHYL MAHALLATI, PREVIOUSLY SWORN, RESUMES THE STAND AND TESTIFIES FURTHER UNDER CROSS EXAMINATION BY MR. BIERNAT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: COURT'S EXHIBIT 3 - NOTE RECEIVED FROM JUROR NO. 4.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
EXC: AT 02:18, THE WITNESS IS EXCUSED FROM THE STAND.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 02:13, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER CROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 02:12, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: FURTHER DIRECT EXAMINATION RESUMES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 02:10, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 02:03, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WS: AT 02:05, WITNESS MAURICE FRETTY IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT INSTRUCTS THE JURY TO RETURN AT 2:00 P.M..
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:47, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER EXAMINATION BY THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
EXC: AT 11:52, THE WITNESS IS EXCUSED FROM THE STAND.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 7.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:44, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER REDIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 7 - LEONARD NORDEMAN MOLD INVOICE TO LYNN MURPHY.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:28, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER CROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: DEFT'S EXHIBIT 208 - LETTER FROM M.SANSOME TO LYNN MURPHY DATED 10/07/11.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREID: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE INTRODUCED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO DEPOSITION OF LYNN MURPHY.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: LODGED DEPOSITION OF LYNN MURPHY UNSEALED BY THE CLERK.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WS: AT 11:08, WITNESS LYNN MURPHY IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. BIERNAT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: CROSS EXAMINATION TO COMMENCE AFTER DEFT'S WITNESS (OUT OF ORDER) IS EXAMINED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
EXC: AT 11:06, THE WITNESS IS EXCUSED FROM THE STAND.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERS TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 22 *.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERS TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 21.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WR: AT 11:03, WITNESS SOHYL MAHALLATI, PREVIOUSLY SWORN, RESUMES THE STAND AND TESTIFIES FURTHER UNDER DIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 11:00, COURT RECONVENES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
OPOJ: OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, ARGUMENTS MADE AS TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 19 AND OTHERS ISSUES RAISED RE: THE TRIAL PROCESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 10:35, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JUROR NO. 12 EXCUSED FROM THE COURTROOM.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT SPEAKS TO JUROR NO. 12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JURORS EXCUSED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 19.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 24 - COPY OF FB POSTING WITH DATE 10/02/11.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 22 - COPY OF PHOTOS DATED 12/21/11.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: DEFT'S EXHIBIT 207 WAS REFERRED TO BY PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 10:12, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER DIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 10:10, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER EXAMINATION BY THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 21 - COLORED EMAIL FROM L. NORDEMAN TO NINA NEVAREZ DATED 09/28/11.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT RESERVE'S RULING ON PLTF'S 16 & 17.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERS TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 19.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 17 - SAYL'S YELP PROFILE *.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 16 - YELP'S EMAIL TO SAYL DATED 11/14/11.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 15 - SAYLE'S EMAIL TO LEN DATED 09/10/11.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 14.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 18.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREIA: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION AND ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: COURT'S EXHIBIT 2 - NOTE RECEIVED FROM JUROR NO. 2.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
776: AT 09:16, SOHYL MAHALLATI IS CALLED ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF PURSUANT TO SECTION 776 OF THE EVIDENCE CODE AND TESTIFIES DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 09:13, COURT RECONVENES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 09:12, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 09:02, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAP: ATTORNEY TRACY TUMLIN APPEARING WITH/FOR PLAINTIFF(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAD: ATTORNEY JAMES BIERNAT APPEARING WITH/FOR DEFENDANT(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRDAY: TRIAL DAY 5
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE GERALD J\. BUCHWALD, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: PATRICE DEANG, COURT REPORTER: ROSA DE NOLA Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Buchwald, Gerald J.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Jury Trial
Dept: 10 JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
JA: JURORS ADMONISHED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREID: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE INTRODUCED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 21.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREID: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE INTRODUCED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION ON BEHALF OF COURT:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: COURT EXHIBIT 1 - NOTE RECEIVED FROM JUROR NO. 13.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 11:14, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 11:19, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 11:12, LODGED DEPOSITION OF TAM CHANDLER UNSEALED BY THE CLERK.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 11:01, JURY NOW PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WS: AT 11:03, WITNESS ELIZABETH "TAM" CHANDLER IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
OPOJ: OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, COUNSEL STIPULATE ON THE RECORD AS TO SEVERAL DEPOSITIONS TO BE USED AT THE TRIAL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 10:58, COURT RECONVENES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 10:38, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: (AT 9:49).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CPIJ: COURT PRE-INSTRUCTS THE JURY.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 9:47, JURORS PRESENT *.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CFO: THE COURT FINDS/ORDERS: WITNESSES TO BE EXCLUDED FROM THE COURTROOM.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: THE COURT ADMONISHED THE WITNESSES DIRECTLY AS TO ISSUES TO BE EXCLUDED FROM THEIR TESTIMONY.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CFO: THE COURT FINDS/ORDERS: COURT WILL NOT PRE-INSTRUCT & INSTRUCT JURY ON NEGLIGENCE CAUSE OF ACTION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PLAINTIFF'S CAUSE OF ACTION, EMOTION HARM CLAIM IS WITHDRAWN AND VOLUNTARY DISMISSED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
HCSM: HAVING CONSIDERED THE SUBMITTED MATTER, THE COURT RULES AS FOLLOWS:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CFO: THE COURT FINDS/ORDERS: THE RULING PREVIOUSLY MADE WILL REMAIN IN EFFECT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: ARGUMENTS BY COUNSEL AS TO RULING MADE BY THE COURT AS DEFT'S MIL NO. 2 & 3.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 09:13, COURT RECONVENES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAD: ATTORNEY JAMES D. BIERNAT APPEARING WITH/FOR DEFENDANT(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAP: ATTORNEY TRACY N. TUMLIN APPEARING WITH/FOR PLAINTIFF(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRDAY: TRIAL DAY 4
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE GERALD J\. BUCHWALD, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: PATRICE DEANG, COURT REPORTER: CINDY DEL ROSARIO Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Buchwald, Gerald J.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Jury Trial
Dept: 10 JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $0.00 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP ON 12/13/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $244.94 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP ON 12/13/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY PDEANG ON 12/13/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
ACAT: AT 1635, THE COURT ADJOURNS FURTHER TRIAL UNTIL 12/14/12 AT 09:00, IN DEPARTMENT 10.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
PJA: PROSPECTIVE JURORS ARE ADMONISHED AND DIRECTED TO RETURN ON 12/14/12 AT 09:00.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 14.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
EXC: AT 04:33, THE WITNESS IS EXCUSED FROM THE STAND.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 04:31, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER RECROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 13 *.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 04:27, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER REDIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 04:25, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER EXAMINATION BY THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 04:24, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 04:18, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 13 - BRET BRADANINI RECOMMENDATION LETTER.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 04:16, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER REDIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: DEFT'S EXHIBIT 215 - TIME AND EXPENSE RECORD.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: DEFENSE COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 14.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 04:02, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER CROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL REFERRED TO DESPOSITION OF BRET BRADANINI.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL REFERRED TO PLTF'S EXHIBIT 14.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL REFERRED TO DEPOSITION OF BRET BRADANINI.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 3:47, LODGED DEPOSITION OF BRED BRADANINI UNSEALED BY THE CLERK.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREID: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE INTRODUCED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 18 - SAYL'S EMAIL TO BRET BRADANINI DATED 09/23/11.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: (ADMITTED AT THE REQUEST OF THE PLAINTIFF).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL REFERRED TO DEFT'S EXHIBIT 209.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 03:33, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WS: AT 03:35, WITNESS BRET BRADANINI IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 03:06, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
EXC: AT 03:05, THE WITNESS IS EXCUSED FROM THE STAND.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 03:04, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER REDIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: DEFENSE COUNSEL REFERRED TO DEPOSITION OF DAN MCCARTHY.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 02:53, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER CROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: LODGED DEPOSITION OF DAN MCCARTHY UNSEALED BY THE CLERK.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREPM: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE PRE-MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: DEFT'S EXHIBIT 209 - BRET BRADANINI PHOTOGRAPHS 1-14 TAKEN SEPT. 28, 2011.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
EXC: AT 02:39, THE WITNESS IS EXCUSED FROM THE STAND.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WS: AT 02:40, WITNESS DAN MCCARTHY IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 02:38, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER EXAMINATION BY THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 14.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 02:19, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER CROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 02:35, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER REDIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 14 - E-MAIL TO NEIL HARTMAN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 1:56, FURTHER DIRECT EXAMINATION RESUMES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: READ BACK BY THE REPORTER.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 01:54, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 01:55, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER DIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 01:51, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 1:45, LODGED DEPOSITION OF NEIL HARTMAN UNSEALED BY THE CLERK.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL REFERRED TO DEPOSITION OF NEIL HARTMAN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WS: AT 01:37, WITNESS NEIL HARTMAN IS SWORN AND TESTIFIES DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 01:35, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 11:54, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
EXC: AT 11:52, THE WITNESS IS EXCUSED FROM THE STAND.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:49, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER REDIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:52, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER RECROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:25, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER CROSS EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL REFERS TO DEPOSITION OF TAM CHANDLER.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
WIT: AT 11:21, THE WITNESS TESTIFIES UNDER FURTHER DIRECT EXAMINATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREID: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE INTRODUCED AND MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION ON BEHALF OF COURT:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREAD: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE PREVIOUSLY MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF AND ARE NOW ADMITTED:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREPM: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE PRE-MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREIA: THE EXHIBITS LISTED BELOW WERE MARKED FOR IDENTIFICATION AND ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JA: JURORS ADMONISHED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TREXH: PLTF'S EXHIBIT 19 - SAYL'S EMAIL TO MOMENTUM FOR MENTAL HEALTH DATED 09/22/11.
Docket Event NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES (DEFENDANT), FILED.
Document
FILED: NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES (DEFENDANT), FILED.
Docket Event PLAINTIFF'S DOCUMENT LIST, FILED.
Document
FILED: PLAINTIFF'S DOCUMENT LIST, FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $921.38 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP ON 12/12/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $0.00 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP ON 12/12/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY PDEANG ON 12/12/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JAD: AT 03:56, THE JURORS ARE ADMONISHED AND DIRECTED TO RETURN ON 12/13/12 AT 09:00.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
ACAT: AT 1547, THE COURT ADJOURNS FURTHER TRIAL UNTIL 12/13/12 AT 09:00, IN DEPARTMENT 10.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
OSB: AT 03:23, OPENING STATEMENT BY DEFENSE COUNSEL, MR. BIERNAT S.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 03:15, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 03:22, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
OPOJ: OUT OF THE PRESENCE OF THE JURY, ARGUMENTS MADE BY MR. BIERNAT AS TO ISSUES STATED ON THE RECORD.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: THE COURT WILL ALLOW EVIDENCE TO COME IN AS TO THE ISSUE OF CAUSATION ONLY.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 02:25, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
OSB: AT 02:25, OPENING STATEMENT BY MR. TUMLIN S.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 02:05, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 01:35, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 12:03, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AJ: 3204541 SELECTED TO SERVE AS AN ALTERNATE JUROR.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
PJTE: THE REMAINING PROSPECTIVE JURORS ARE THANKED AND EXCUSED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3206506.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3101948.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3276313.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3142233.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3204541.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3195775.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3201212.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3045543.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3176176.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3084205.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3207756.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3151333.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3229425.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JSEA: THE FOLLOWING JURORS ARE SWORN, EXAMINED AND ACCEPTED:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL SATISFIED WITH THE JURY PANEL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JUROR NO. 3195775 CALLED TO THE BOX.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: DEFENDANT PASS FOR PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE NO. 3.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE NO. 4 BY THE PLAINTIFF EXCUSES JUROR NO. 3114288.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JUROR NO. 3114288 CALLED TO THE BOX.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT EXCUSES JUROR NO. 3144648 FOR HARDSHIP.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JUROR NO. 3144648 CALLED TO THE JURY BOX.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE NO. 3 BY THE PLAINTIFF EXCUSES JUROR NO. 3226750.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: DEFENDANT PASS FOR PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE NO. 2.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JUROR NO. 3226750 CALLED TO THE JURY BOX.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 10:44, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 11:12, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
PJA1: PROSPECTIVE JURORS ADMONISHED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE NO. 2 BY THE PLAINTIFF EXCUSES JUROR NO. 3194248.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JUROR NO. 3206506 CALLED TO THE JURY BOX.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE NO. 1 BY THE DEFT EXCUSES JUROR NO. 3065107.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JUROR NO. 3084205 CALLED TO THE JURY BOX.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE NO. 1 BY THE PLAINTIFF EXCUSES JUROR NO. 3297002.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3265001.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JUROR 3249877 CALLED TO THE JURY BOX BUT NO RESPONSE/APPEARANCE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT DIRECTED CLERK TO CALL FOR PROSPECTIVE JURORS TO THE BOX.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 10:02, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT EXCUSES JUROR NO. 3265001 FOR HARDSHIP.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCCW: COURT CONDUCTS CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS WITH COUNSEL & JUROR NO. 3265001.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC1: AT 09:27, THE COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 09:30, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 9:10, FURTHER VOIR DIRE COMMENCED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 09:09, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAD: ATTORNEY JAMES D. BIERNAT APPEARING WITH/FOR DEFENDANT(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAP: ATTORNEY TRACY N TUMLIN APPEARING WITH/FOR PLAINTIFF(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE GERALD J\. BUCHWALD, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: PATRICE DEANG, COURT REPORTER: ROSA MARTINEZ Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Buchwald, Gerald J.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Hearing
JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES (PLAINTIFF), FILED.
Document
FILED: NOTICE OF REQUIREMENT FOR DEPOSITING CRT RPTR FEES (PLAINTIFF), FILED.
Docket Event Jury Trial
Dept: 10 JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
JA: JURORS ADMONISHED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: FURTHER VOIR DIRE RESUMES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $0.00 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP ON 12/11/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CRJFEE: NOTICE TO PAY $0.00 JURY FEES AND $244.00 COURT REPORTER FEES PROVIDED TO MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN ON 12/11/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY PDEANG ON 12/12/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
PJA: PROSPECTIVE JURORS ARE ADMONISHED AND DIRECTED TO RETURN ON 12/12/12 AT 09:00.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
ACAT: AT 4:47, THE COURT ADJOURNS FURTHER TRIAL UNTIL 12/12/12 AT 09:00, IN DEPARTMENT 10.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3204541.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: FURTHER VOIR DIRE COMMENCED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: CLERK CALLED PROSPECTIVE JURORS TO THE BOX: *.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT EXCUSES JUROR NO. 3061743 FOR HARDSHIP *.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3194248.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT EXCUSES JUROR NO. 2864513 FOR HARDSHIP.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT EXCUSES JUROR NO. 3090977 FOR HARDSHIP.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
APJTA: AT 04:14, COURT RECONVENES. ABOVE-NOTED COUNSEL, PARTIES AND JURY PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 03:52, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT AND COUNSEL DISCUSS HARDSHIP REQUESTS IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: FURTHER VOIR DIRE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
PJA1: PROSPECTIVE JURORS ADMONISHED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: CLERK CALLS JUROR 3229425.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: JUROR 3231659 EXCUSED FOR HARDSHIP.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 2:40, VOIR DIRE COMMENCED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3065107.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3101948.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3276313.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3142233.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3090977.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 2864513.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3201212.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3265001.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3045543.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3176176.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3151333.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3207756.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 2:37, CLERK DIRECTED TO CALL FOR PROSPECTIVE JURORS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
J: JUROR 3231659.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COURT: THE COURT READS THE WITNESS LIST, INTRODUCES THE PARTIES AND EXPLAINS THE NATURE OF THE CASE TO THE PROSPECTIVE JURORS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: ABOVE NOTED COUNSEL AND PARTIES PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 02:08, COURT RECONVENES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
PJPS: PROSPECTIVE JURORS HAVING BEEN SUMMONED, ARE SWORN REGARDING THEIR QUALIFICATIONS TO ACT AS TRIAL JURORS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 2:02, PROSPECTIVE JURORS ARE PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: CLERK TAKES ROLL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL PRESENT, READY FOR TRIAL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL STIPULATE TO THE REPORTING OF VOIR DIRE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: STIPULATIONS WERE MADE ON THE RECORD AS TO THE TRIAL PROCESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 01:43, COURT RECONVENES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 12:13, COURT RECESS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: EXCLUDED WERE STATED ON THE RECORD BY THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: TELEPHONE CONVERSATION IS GRANTED ON THE BASIS OF NO YELP POSTING INSULTS. THE LANGUAGE TO BE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: MONTGOMERY SANSOME, AND TO EXCLUDE TESTIMONY AND DECLARATION OF ELOA SHARIF CONCERNING SAID
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DEFENDANT'S MIL NO. 3 - TO EXCLUDE REFERENCE TO AN ALLEGED A TELEPHONE CALL FROM DEFT TO
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DEFENDANT'S MIL NO. 2 - TO EXCLUDE REFERENCE TO CERTAIN PORTIONS OF YELP.COM POST IS GRANTED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: * *.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DEFT'S MIL NO 1 - TO EXCLUDE REFERENCE TO LEONARD NORDEMAN'S MEDICAL CONDITION IS GRANTED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: VIEW OF WRITTEN STIPULATION TO BE PREPARED BY COUNSEL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DEFENDANT'S MIL NO. 7 - TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME'S QUALITY OF WORK IS MOOT IN
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: MIL NO. 6 - TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE DEFENDANT LIBELED PLAINTIFFS TO BRET BRADANINI IS GRANTED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: MIL NO. 5 - TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE MONTGOMERY SANSOME DID NOT CHARGE FOR OVERTIME WORK IS
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DEFENDANT'S MIL NO. 4 - TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE NEIL HARTMAN REFUSES TO REFER BUSINESS TO MONTGOMERY
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: SANSOME BECAUSE OF DEFENDANT'S ALLEGEDLY DEFAMATORY STATEMENTS IS DENIED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: HEARING HEARD ON DEFENDANTS' MOTIONS IN LIMINE:.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: BE BIFURCATED FROM THE FIRST PHASE OF THE TRIAL IS GRANTED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: PRESENTED IN THE FIRST PHASE OF THIS TRIAL AS PLAINTIFFS HEREBY REQUEST THAT PUNITIVE DAMAGES
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: MIL NO. 6 - THAT NO EVIDENCE OF THE DEFENDANTS, ARCH CONSTRUCTION AND SAYL MAHALLATI WEALTH BE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: MIL NO. 5 - RESERVE RULING
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: RELATIVE TO THE DETAILS OF PRIOR OR PENDING LAWSUITS INVOLVING THE PLAINTIFFS IS GRANTED
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: WITHOUT PREJUDICE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: MIL NO. 4 - THAT DEFENDANTS BE PRECLUDED FROM OFFERING EVIDENCE OR CROSS EXAMINING WITNESS
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DENIED FOR REASONS STATED ON THE RECORD.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: COMPLAINT VS. DEFENDANTS ARCH CONSTRUCTION AND SAYL MAHALLATI AND THAT HE DOES NOT TESTIFY IS
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: MIL NO. 3 - THE SAME MOTION AS NO. 1 BUT ASSUME LEONARD A. NORDEMAN DISMISSES HIS PERSONAL
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: MIL NO. 2 - THE SAME MOTION AS NO. 1 BUT ASSUME LEONARD A. NORDEMAN DOES NOT TESTIFY IS DENIED
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: FOR REASONS STATED ON THE RECORD.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THE BALANCING TEST OF EVID CODE SECTION 352 ASSUMING LEONARD A. NORDEMAN, TESTIFIES IS
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: STATEMENT ON A LOAN APPLICATION, VIOLATING 18 U.S.C. SECTION 1014, A FELONY, BE EXCLUDED UNDER
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: PLAINTIFFS' MIL NO. 1 - THAT EVIDENCE OF LEONARD A. NORDEMAN'S CONVICTION OF MAKING A FALSE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
HCSM: HAVING CONSIDERED THE SUBMITTED MATTER, THE COURT RULES AS FOLLOWS:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: HEARING HEARD ON PLAINTIFFS' MOTIONS IN LIMINE:.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MAS: MATTER ARGUED BY COUNSEL AND SUBMITTED TO THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CFO: THE COURT FINDS/ORDERS: COUNSEL TO PREPARE AUTHORITIES TO QUESTIONS BY THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRBRK: AT 09:43, COURT CONVENES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAD: ATTORNEY JAMES D. BIERNAT APPEARING WITH/FOR DEFENDANT(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAP: ATTORNEY TRACY N TUMLIN APPEARING WITH/FOR PLAINTIFF(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE GERALD J\. BUCHWALD, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: PATRICE DEANG, COURT REPORTER: ROSA DE NOLA Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Buchwald, Gerald J.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRDAY: TRIAL DAY 2
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Jury Trial
Dept: 10 JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM1: * *
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DENIED.
Docket Event PLAINTIFFS' MOTION IN LIMINE, FILED.
Document
FILED: PLAINTIFFS' MOTION IN LIMINE, FILED.
Docket Event DECLARATION OF LENARD A. NORDEMAN IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONS IN LIMINE, FILED.
Document
FILED: DECLARATION OF LENARD A. NORDEMAN IN SUPPORT OF MOTIONS IN LIMINE, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT SOHYL MAHALLATI'S TRIAL BRIEF, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT SOHYL MAHALLATI'S TRIAL BRIEF, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S PROPOSED STATEMENT OF THE CASE, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S PROPOSED STATEMENT OF THE CASE, FILED.
Docket Event DEFTS' WITNESS LIST (IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER), FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFTS' WITNESS LIST (IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER), FILED.
Docket Event PLTFS' MEMO OF PTS & AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF MOTION IN LIMINE, FILED.
Document
FILED: PLTFS' MEMO OF PTS & AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF MOTION IN LIMINE, FILED.
Docket Event DEFENDANT'S EXHIBIT LIST, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFENDANT'S EXHIBIT LIST, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S MIL NO. 7 - TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF M.SANSOME'S QUALITY OF WORK, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S MIL NO. 7 - TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF M.SANSOME'S QUALITY OF WORK, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S MIL NO. 6 -TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE DEFT LIBELED PLAINTIFFS TO BRET BRADANINI, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S MIL NO. 6 -TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE DEFT LIBELED PLAINTIFFS TO BRET BRADANINI, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S MIL NO. 5 - TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE M. SANSOME DID NOT CHARGE FOR OVERTIME WORK, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S MIL NO. 5 - TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE M. SANSOME DID NOT CHARGE FOR OVERTIME WORK, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S MIL NO. 4 - TO EXCLUDE EVID NEIL HARTMAN REFUSES TO REFER BUSINESS TO M.SANSOME..., FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S MIL NO. 4 - TO EXCLUDE EVID NEIL HARTMAN REFUSES TO REFER BUSINESS TO M.SANSOME..., FILED.
Docket Event DEFTS' MIL NO. 3 - TO EXCLUDE REF TO AN ALLEGED A TELEPHONE CALL FROM DEFT TO M.SANSOME..., FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFTS' MIL NO. 3 - TO EXCLUDE REF TO AN ALLEGED A TELEPHONE CALL FROM DEFT TO M.SANSOME..., FILED.
Docket Event DEFTS' MIL NO. 2 - TO EXCLUDE REFERENCE TO CERTAIN PORTIONS OF YELP.COM POST, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFTS' MIL NO. 2 - TO EXCLUDE REFERENCE TO CERTAIN PORTIONS OF YELP.COM POST, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S MIL NO. 1 - EXCLUDE REF TO L. NORDEMAN'S MEDICAL CONDITION, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S MIL NO. 1 - EXCLUDE REF TO L. NORDEMAN'S MEDICAL CONDITION, FILED.
Docket Event PLAINTIFFS' WITNESS LIST, FILED.
Document
FILED: PLAINTIFFS' WITNESS LIST, FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY PDEANG ON 12/10/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCC2: AT 04:15, THE UNREPORTED CONFERENCE CONCLUDED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
HC: HEARING CONTINUED TO 12/11/12 AT 09:30 IN DEPARTMENT 10.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 2:50, COURT AND COUNSEL HELD AN UNREPORTED PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCR1: HONORABLE GERALD J\. BUCHWALD, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: PATRICE DEANG. COURT REPORTER: NONE. Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Buchwald, Gerald J.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event PLTF'S PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS, FILED.
Document
FILED: PLTF'S PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS, FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: MATTER IS ASSIGNED TO DEPT. 10/JUDGE BUCHWALD IN COURTROOM 8D FORTHWITH FOR JURY TRIAL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
HT: HEARING TRANSFERRED TO 12/10/12 AT 02:00 IN DEPARTMENT 10.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL ESTIMATE FOUR DAYS FOR TRIAL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL FOR PARTIES INDICATE CASE REMAINS READY FOR TRIAL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: AT 2:17, MATTER RE-CALLED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY LORRAINE ON 12/10/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: PARTIES WILL RETURN TO THE PRESIDING JUDGE AT 2PM THIS AFTERNOON FOR ASSIGNMENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: THIS MATTER DID NOT SETTLE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AT: ATTORNEY(S): JAMES BIERNAT FOR DEFENDANT
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: UNREPORTED CONFERENCE HELD WITH THE COURT AND ABOVE COUNSEL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AP: ALSO PRESENT: LEONARD NORDEMAN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCR: HONORABLE STEVEN L\. DYLINA, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: LORRAINE GUERRERO. COURT REPORTER: MEGAN ZALMAI. Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Dylina, Steven L.

Judge: Dylina, Steven L.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
AT: ATTORNEY(S): TRACY TUMLIN FOR PLAINTIFF
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: MATTER IS ASSIGNED TO DEPT. 7/JUDGE DYLINA IN COURTROOM 8B FORTHWITH FOR A DAY-OF-TRIAL
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COUNSEL FOR PARTIES ANNOUNCE READY FOR TRIAL.
Docket Event DEFENDANT'S PROPOSED VERDICT FORM, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFENDANT'S PROPOSED VERDICT FORM, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS, FILED.
Docket Event STIPULATION TO BE READ TO THE JURY REGARDING YELP.COM, FILED.
Document
FILED: STIPULATION TO BE READ TO THE JURY REGARDING YELP.COM, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S OPP TO PLTFS' MIL #4 - TO EXCLUDE EVID OF PRIOR OR PENDING LAWSUITS INVOLVING PLTFS, FILED.
Document
FILED: DEFT'S OPP TO PLTFS' MIL #4 - TO EXCLUDE EVID OF PRIOR OR PENDING LAWSUITS INVOLVING PLTFS, FILED.
Docket Event DEFT'S OPP TO PLTF'S MIL #1,2 & 3 TO EXCLUDE EVID OF PLTF NORDEMAN'S FED FELONY CONVICT FOR FRAUD,
Document
FILED: DEFT'S OPP TO PLTF'S MIL #1,2 & 3 TO EXCLUDE EVID OF PLTF NORDEMAN'S FED FELONY CONVICT FOR FRAUD, FILED.
Docket Event Jury Trial
Dept: 10 JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Jury Trial
Dept: PJ JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: FREEMAN, BETH

Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAD: ATTORNEY JAMES D. BIERNAT APPEARING WITH/FOR DEFENDANT(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAP: ATTORNEY TRACY N. TUMLIN APPEARING WITH/FOR PLAINTIFF(S).
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.

Judge: Buchwald, Gerald J.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY S KANE ON 12/10/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE BETH LABSON FREEMAN, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: SEAN KANE, COURT REPORTER: CHRIS PEREZ

Judge: FREEMAN, BETH

Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY ASIEVERT ON 11/15/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MSCNS: MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE HELD, NOT SETTLED.CASE REMAINS SET FOR TRIAL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
CCCW: COURT CONDUCTS CONFERENCE IN CHAMBERS WITH COUNSEL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AT: ATTORNEY(S): JAMES BIERNAT APPEARED ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANTS
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AP: ALSO PRESENT: RON KOJIMA OF NAVIGATORS INSURANCE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: MONTGOMERY SANSOME PRESENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE GEORGE A\. MIRAM, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: ANN SIEVERT, COURT REPORTER: LORNA TRAUBE Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Miram, George A.

Judge: Miram, George A.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
AT: ATTORNEY(S): TRACY N. TUMLIN APPEARED ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFFS
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE

Judge: Miram, George A.

Docket Event Settlement Conference
Dept: 28 MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE

Judge: Miram, George A.

Docket Event Conversion Action
*620*: HMSC CALENDARED ON 11/15/12 IN DEPT. 7. HAS BEEN UPDATED TO 11/15/12 IN DEPT. 28.
Docket Event Mandatory Settlement Conference Statement received
MSS: MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT RECEIVED FROM MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN
Docket Event Mandatory Settlement Conference Statement received
MSS: MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT RECEIVED FROM ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, NASSER MAHALLATI, SAYL MAHALLATI
Docket Event (S) ANSWER TO 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP FILED BY ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, REPRESE
Answer (Unlimited)
ANS: (S) ANSWER TO 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP FILED BY ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, REPRESENTED BY JAMES D. BIERNAT
Docket Event Conversion Minute
HCONT: HEARING CONTINUED TO 12/10/12 AT 09:00 IN DEPARTMENT PJ.
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.
Docket Event Jury Trial
Dept: PJ JURY TRIAL. TIME ESTIMATE: 4 DAYS 00:00 HOURS.
Docket Event SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES FOR LIBEL & SLANDER, NEGLIGENCE, FILED.
Document
FILED: SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES FOR LIBEL & SLANDER, NEGLIGENCE, FILED.
Docket Event ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT, FILED.
Document
FILED: ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT, FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: NOTE - 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT WAS FILED IN THE COURT ROOM BY LINDA.
Docket Event Conversion Action
ACS: (U) 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP FILED (AMENDED COMPLAINT)
Docket Event Conversion Minute
LAG: LEAVE TO AMEND GRANTED. MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN GRANTED 10 DAYS LEAVE TO AMEND
Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY LMAKELA ON 10/01/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: COURT. THE ORDER IS TO BE SUBMITTED DIRECTLY TO JUDGE JOSEPH C\. SCOTT, DEPARTMENT 25 Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THEREOF TO THE OPPOSING PARTY/COUNSEL AS REQUIRED BY LAW AND THE CALIFORNIA RULES OF
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: COURT'S SIGNATURE, PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA RULES OF COURT, RULE 3.1312, AND TO PROVIDE NOTICE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: "MOVING PARTY IS DIRECTED TO PREPARE A WRITTEN ORDER CONSISTENT WITH THE COURT'S RULING FOR THE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: AMENDED COMPLAINT SUBMITTED WITH THE MOVING PAPERS, NO LATER THAN 10/10/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DISCOVERY REMAINS CLOSED AND THE TRIAL SHALL PROCEED AS SCHEDULED ON DECEMBER 10, 2012.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: PLAINTIFFS SHALL FILE AND SERVE A 2ND AMENDED COMPLAINT, CONSISTENT WITH THE PROPOSED 2ND
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: BASED ON THE SAME FACTS PREVIOUSLY ALLEGED IS GRANTED. ABSENT A CONTRARY ORDER BY THIS COURT,
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AN AMENDED COMPLAINT CONTAINING TWO NEW CAUSES OF ACTION
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRA: TENTATIVE RULING ADOPTED AND BECOMES THE ORDER:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
NAP: NO APPEARANCE IS MADE BY ANY PARTIES HEREIN OR THEIR COUNSEL OF RECORD.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCR: HONORABLE JOSEPH C\. SCOTT, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: LINDA MAKELA. COURT REPORTER: FAKHOURI. Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Scott, Joseph C.

Judge: Scott, Joseph C.

Docket Event Motion hearings
Dept: 25 HEARING: MOTION RE: FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: Scott, Joseph C.

Docket Event Conversion Hearing
HEARING: MOTION RE: FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: Scott, Joseph C.

Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
HCONT: HEARING CONTINUED TO 11/15/12 AT 01:30 IN DEPARTMENT 7.
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY K. CALDWELL ON 09/26/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: COURT FOR A CALENDAR DATE AT (650) 363-4334.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THIS MATTER IS ASSIGNED TO DEPARTMENT 25, THE HONORABLE JOSEPH C\. SCOTT. PLEASE CALL HIS Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM1: -- --
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRA: TENTATIVE RULING ADOPTED AND BECOMES THE ORDER:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: JUDGE JOSEPH E\. BERGERON RECUSED HIMSELF PURSUANT TO C.C.P. 170.1(6)(A)(III). Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
HEARING: MOTION RE: FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: Bergeron, Joseph E

Docket Event Conversion Minute
NAP: NO APPEARANCE IS MADE BY ANY PARTIES HEREIN OR THEIR COUNSEL OF RECORD.
Docket Event Motion hearings
Dept: LM HEARING: MOTION RE: FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: Bergeron, Joseph E

Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE JOSEPH E\. BERGERON, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: KAREN CALDWELL, COURT REPORTER: MAUREEN HARTMAN Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Bergeron, Joseph E

Judge: Bergeron, Joseph E

Docket Event Settlement Conference
Dept: 7 MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE
Docket Event DECLARATION OF JAMES D. BIERNAT IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND
Declaration
DEC: DECLARATION OF JAMES D. BIERNAT IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND
Docket Event OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP,
Opposition
OPP: OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, SAYL MAHALLATI, NASSER MAHALLATI
Docket Event EX-PARTE APPLICATION FOR ORDER SHORTENING TIME RE MOTION TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY MONTGOM
Ex Parte
EPA: EX-PARTE APPLICATION FOR ORDER SHORTENING TIME RE MOTION TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN
Docket Event NOTICE OF MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDE
Motion
NM: NOTICE OF MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN
Docket Event ORDER SHORTENING TIME FOR MOTION, SIGNED BY JUDGE BERGERON ON 09/17/12, FILED.
Order
O: ORDER SHORTENING TIME FOR MOTION, SIGNED BY JUDGE BERGERON ON 09/17/12, FILED.
Docket Event MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN IN SUPPORT O
Memorandum of Points & Authorities
MPA: MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT
Docket Event DECLARATION OF TRACY N. TUMLIN IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT
Declaration
DEC: DECLARATION OF TRACY N. TUMLIN IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 120917-0577-CK 036/ 60.00 PAYMT
Docket Event Conversion Action
EXFEE: EX-PARTE FEE PAID BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN.
Docket Event PROPOSED AMENDED COMPLAINT RECEIVED.
Conversion Action
COMMI: PROPOSED AMENDED COMPLAINT RECEIVED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, NASSER MAHALLATI.
Notice
N: NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, NASSER MAHALLATI.
Docket Event PRINT COMBINED MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND JURY TRIAL OR COURT TRIAL NOTICE
Conversion Action
PNTWO: PRINT COMBINED MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND JURY TRIAL OR COURT TRIAL NOTICE
Docket Event ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL, SIGNED BY JUDGE FREEMAN ON 08/31/12, FILED.
Order
O: ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL, SIGNED BY JUDGE FREEMAN ON 08/31/12, FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY K. CALDWELL ON 08/29/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: SUFFICIENT NOTICE TO THE PARTIES.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: PURSUANT TO RULE 3.1312 OR ANY OTHER NOTICE IS REQUIRED, AS THE TENTATIVE RULING AFFORDS
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: 3.1308(A)(L), ADOPTED BY LOCAL RULE 3.10, EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY, AND NO FORMAL ORDER
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: IF THE TENTATIVE RULING IS UNCONTESTED, IT SHALL BECOME THE ORDER OF THE COURT, PURSUANT TO RULE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM1: -- --
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: NOTICE AS IT WAS MAILED WITHOUT PROVIDING THE REQUISITE 16 COURT DAYS, PLUS 5 ADDITIONAL
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: CALENDAR DAYS NOTICE. NOTICE IS INSUFFICIENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: FOR LACK OF SUFFICIENT NOTICE. PURSUANT TO CCP 1005(B) THE MOVING PARTY DID NOT PROVIDE PROPER
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL, SHAWN RIDGELL'S MOTION TO BE RELIEVED AS COUNSEL IS DENIED WITHOUT PREJUDICE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MDEN: MOTION DENIED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRA: TENTATIVE RULING ADOPTED AND BECOMES THE ORDER:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
NAP: NO APPEARANCE IS MADE BY ANY PARTIES HEREIN OR THEIR COUNSEL OF RECORD.
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
HEARING: MOTION RE: TO BE RELIEVED AS COUNSEL FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: Bergeron, Joseph E

Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE JOSEPH E\. BERGERON, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: KAREN CALDWELL, COURT REPORTER: MAUREEN HARTMAN Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Bergeron, Joseph E

Judge: Bergeron, Joseph E

Docket Event Motion hearings
Dept: LM HEARING: MOTION RE: TO BE RELIEVED AS COUNSEL FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: Bergeron, Joseph E

Docket Event SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY FILED. FORMER ATTORNEY SHAWN RIDGELL REMOVED AS TO LEONARD A NORDEMAN AND
Substitution of Attorney as to
SAT: SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY FILED. FORMER ATTORNEY SHAWN RIDGELL REMOVED AS TO LEONARD A NORDEMAN AND REPLACED WITH ATTORNEY TRACY N TUMLIN.
Docket Event PRINT COMBINED MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND JURY TRIAL OR COURT TRIAL NOTICE
Conversion Action
PNTWO: PRINT COMBINED MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND JURY TRIAL OR COURT TRIAL NOTICE
Docket Event SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY FILED. FORMER ATTORNEY SHAWN RIDGELL REMOVED AS TO MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP AN
Substitution of Attorney as to
SAT: SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY FILED. FORMER ATTORNEY SHAWN RIDGELL REMOVED AS TO MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP AND REPLACED WITH ATTORNEY TRACY N TUMLIN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY S KANE ON 08/28/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
LINE: =====================================
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT SIGNS PROPOSED ORDER.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DATE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: DISCOVERY DEADLINES SHALL REMAIN UNCHANGED, AND SHALL CORRESPOND TO THE ORIGINAL OCTOBER TRIAL
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: MSC IS CONTINUED TO NOVEMBER 15TH, 2012 AT 1:30 P.M. IN DEPT. 7.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: TIME ESTIMATE FOR TRIAL = 5 DAYS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: TRIAL IS CONTINUED TO DECEMBER 10TH, 2012 AT 9:00 A.M. IN THE PRESIDING JUDGE'S DEPARTMENT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: FOR TRIAL ON THE DATE CURRENTLY SET.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: INTEREST CAUSING HIM TO WITHDRAW AND NEW COUNSEL'S DETERMINATION THAT HE CANNOT BE READY
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: HAS BEEN DEMONSTRATED BASED UPON PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL'S RECENT DETERMINATION OF A CONFLICT OF
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: COURT GRANTS PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL. THE COURT IS SATISFIED THAT GOOD CAUSE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRA: TENTATIVE RULING ADOPTED AND BECOMES THE ORDER:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MAS: MATTER ARGUED BY COUNSEL AND SUBMITTED TO THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: COURT'S TENTATIVE RULING INSTRUCTED PARTIES TO APPEAR RE: SELECTION OF NEW TRIAL DATE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAP: ATTORNEY TRACY N. TUMLIN APPEARING WITH/FOR PLAINTIFF(S).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AAD: ATTORNEY JAMES D. BIERNAT APPEARING WITH/FOR DEFENDANT(S).
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
HEARING: MOTION RE: TO CONTINUE TRIAL DATE FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: FREEMAN, BETH

Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE BETH LABSON FREEMAN, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: SEAN KANE, COURT REPORTER: CHRIS PEREZ

Judge: FREEMAN, BETH

Docket Event NOTICE OF MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL DATE FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP.
Notice
N: NOTICE OF MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL DATE FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP.
Docket Event Motion hearings
Dept: PJLM HEARING: MOTION RE: TO CONTINUE TRIAL DATE FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: FREEMAN, BETH

Docket Event MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP IN OPPOSITION TO
Memorandum of Points & Authorities
MPA: MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL
Docket Event DECLARATION OF JAMES D. BIERNAT IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI,
Declaration
DECL: DECLARATION OF JAMES D. BIERNAT IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP
Docket Event DECLARATION OF TRACY N. TUMLIN IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL
Declaration
DEC: DECLARATION OF TRACY N. TUMLIN IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL
Docket Event PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED.
Order received
POR: PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED.
Docket Event MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN IN SUPPORT O
Memorandum of Points & Authorities
MPA: MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL DATE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 120823-0160-CK 036/ 60.00 PAYMT
Docket Event First Paper Fee Paid
FFP4: MOTION FEE PAID BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 120823-0514-CK 036/ 60.00 PAYMT
Docket Event Conversion Action
EXFEE: EX-PARTE FEE PAID BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN.
Docket Event ORDER SHORTENING TIME FOR MOTION TO CONTINUE, SIGNED BY JUDGE FOILES ON 08/23/12, FILED.
Order
O: ORDER SHORTENING TIME FOR MOTION TO CONTINUE, SIGNED BY JUDGE FOILES ON 08/23/12, FILED.
Docket Event NOTICE OF MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL DATE FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN
Motion
NM: NOTICE OF MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL DATE FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN
Docket Event EX-PARTE APPLICATION FOR ORDER SHORTENING TIME RE: MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL FILED BY MONTGOMERY SAN
Ex Parte
EPA: EX-PARTE APPLICATION FOR ORDER SHORTENING TIME RE: MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN
Docket Event PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED.
Order received
POR: PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 120808-0292-CK 036/ 60.00 PAYMT
Docket Event NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION TO BE RELIEVED AS COUNSEL FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSO
Motion
NM: NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION TO BE RELIEVED AS COUNSEL FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP
Docket Event PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED.
Order received
POR: PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED.
Docket Event DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF ATTORNEY'S MOTION TO BE RELIEVED AS COUNSEL
Declaration
DEC: DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF ATTORNEY'S MOTION TO BE RELIEVED AS COUNSEL
Docket Event First Paper Fee Paid
FFP4: MOTION FEE PAID BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP.
Docket Event (S) ANSWER TO 1ST AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, ARCH CONSTRUC
Answer (Unlimited)
ANS: (S) ANSWER TO 1ST AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, REPRESENTED BY JAMES D. BIERNAT
Docket Event Advance Jury Fees Non-Refundable
AJFEE: ADVANCE JURY FEE POSTED BY JAMES D BIERNAT ON BEHALF OF SAYL MAHALLATI.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 120807-0601-CK 209/ 150.00 PAYMT
Docket Event REQUEST FOR DISMISSAL ON 1ST AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP AS TO DEFENDANT NASSER MAHA
Conversion Action
REQDD: REQUEST FOR DISMISSAL ON 1ST AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP AS TO DEFENDANT NASSER MAHALLATI WITH PREJUDICE FILED AND ENTERED.
Docket Event (U) 1ST AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP FILED (AMENDED COMPLAINT)
Conversion Action
ACS: (U) 1ST AMENDED COMPLAINT OF MONTGOMERY SANSOME LP FILED (AMENDED COMPLAINT)
Docket Event Conversion Action
COMM: PER COMM'N WITH BOTH COUNSEL: WILL PURSUE PRIVATE NON-BINDING ARBITRATION.
Docket Event ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND, SIGNED BY JUDGE SWOPE ON 06/08/12, FILED.
Order
O: ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND, SIGNED BY JUDGE SWOPE ON 06/08/12, FILED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY S.HARRIS ON 06/08/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FOS: FORMAL ORDER SUBMITTED AND SIGNED BY THE COURT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: INTENDS TO APPEAR AND CONTEST THIS TENTATIVE RULING.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THE COURT WILL SIGN THE PROPOSED ORDER SUBMITTED BY PLAINTIFF ABSENT NOTICE THAT EITHER PARTY
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: AMENDMENT OF PLEADINGS AT ANY STAGE IN THE LITIGATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: SECTION 473(A). UNDER CCP SECTION 473, THE COURT HAS BROAD DISCRETION TO PERMIT THE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: PLAINTIFFS' UNOPPOSED MOTION TO AMEND COMPLAINT IS GRANTED PURSUANT TO CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRA: TENTATIVE RULING ADOPTED AND BECOMES THE ORDER:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE V. RAYMOND SWOPE, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: SANDRA HARRIS, COURT REPORTER: GERALDINE VANDEVELD

Judge: Swope, V. Raymond

Docket Event Conversion Minute
NAP: NO APPEARANCE IS MADE BY ANY PARTIES HEREIN OR THEIR COUNSEL OF RECORD.
Docket Event Conversion Hearing
HEARING: MOTION RE: MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: Swope, V. Raymond

Docket Event Motion hearings
Dept: LM HEARING: MOTION RE: MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN

Judge: Swope, V. Raymond

Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: * *.
Docket Event Order received
POR: PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED.
Docket Event Memorandum of Points & Authorities
MPA: MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES FILED BY LEONARD A NORDEMAN, MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT
Docket Event Declaration
DECL: DECLARATION OF SHAWN RIDGELL IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 120426-0087-CK 036/ 40.00 PAYMT
Docket Event Motion
NM: NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN
Docket Event Notice of Change of Address of Attorney
NCA: NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS OF ATTORNEY JAMES D. BIERNAT FILED
Docket Event Order
O2: ORDER DENYING DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO STRIKE, SIGNED BY JUDGE SWOPE ON 03/16/12 FILED.
Docket Event Stipulation and Order to ADR
SOADR: STIP AND ORDER TO ADR SIGNED BY STEVEN L. DYLINA ON 03/08/12
Docket Event Conversion Action
COMM: ORDER DENYING MOT TO STRIKE FORWARDE TO DEPT 23 FOR APPROVAL.
Docket Event 10 Day Reminder Notice to file Stipulation and Order to ADR
ADRSTP: PRINT ADR STIPULATION DUE NOTICE.
Docket Event Conversion Action
COMM: STIP AND ORDER TO ADR FORWARDED TO DEPT. #7.
Docket Event Conversion - Clerks Calendars
ADSTDU: STIPULATION TO ADR DUE.
Docket Event ADR Referral
ADRREF: PRINT ADR REFERRAL LETTER. ADR CASE CATEGORY: DEFAMATION.
Docket Event Conversion Action
PNTWO: PRINT COMBINED MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND JURY TRIAL OR COURT TRIAL NOTICE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM1: - 1 -
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY C LYSSAND ON 02/10/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
PSWM: THE PARTIES SPOKE WITH ADR STAFF REGARDING MEDIATION.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MCSDSN: MASTER CALENDAR TO SET A MSC DATE ACCORDINGLY & SEND PROPER NOTICE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TIMEJT: 4 DAY JURY TRIAL.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MCSJT2: MASTER CALENDAR TO SET PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT JURY TRIAL FOR OCTOBER 15, 2012.
Docket Event Parties ordered to file stipulation to ADR within 21 days
POSOM: PARTIES ARE ORDERED TO FILE A WRITTEN STIPULATION & ORDER FOR MEDIATION WITH THE COURT WITHIN 21 DAYS.
Docket Event Parties stipulate to Mediation at hearing
PSM: PARTIES STIPULATE TO GO TO MEDIATION. COURT ORDERS PARTIES TO COMPLETE MEDIATION BY THE MANDATORY SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE DATE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MAI: THE COURT DEEMS THIS MATTER AT ISSUE.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AT: ATTORNEY(S): JAMES D. BIERNAT APPEARED BY COURTCALL ON BEHALF OF THE DEFENDANTS.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
AT: ATTORNEY(S): SHAWN RIDGELL APPEARED ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE STEVEN L\. DYLINA, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: CHERYL LYSSAND, COURT REPORTER: MEGAN ZALMAI Trellis Spinner 👉 Discover key insights by exploring more analytics for Dylina, Steven L.

Judge: Dylina, Steven L.

Docket Event CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
Conversion Hearing

Judge: Dylina, Steven L.

Docket Event Case Management Conference
Dept: 7 CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE

Judge: Dylina, Steven L.

Docket Event Case Management Statement
CMS: CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
MICMS: ENTERED BY S.HARRIS ON 01/30/12.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THEREOF TO THE OPPOSING PARTY/COUNSEL AS REQUIRED BY LAW AND THE CALIFORNIA RULES OF
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: COURT. THE ORDER IS TO BE SUBMITTED DIRECTLY TO JUDGE V. RAYMOND SWOPE, DEPARTMENT 23.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: COURT'S SIGNATURE, PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA RULES OF COURT, RULE 3.1312, AND TO PROVIDE NOTICE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: PREVAILING PARTY IS DIRECTED TO PREPARE A WRITTEN ORDER CONSISTENT WITH THE COURT'S RULING FOR THE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: FEES ARE GRANTED.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THE COURT DOES NOT FIND THAT THE MOTION IS FRIVOLOUS OR SOLELY INTENDED TO CAUSE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: UNNECESSARY DELAY. (CODE OF CIV. PROC. SECTION 425.16, SUBD. (C)). ACCORDINGLY, NO ATTORNEY'S
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THE ALLEGED PUBLICATION IN THIS MATTER ADDRESSES ONLY PLAINTIFF, BUT NO MATTER OF PUBLIC INTEREST.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: INFORMATION ABOUT BROKER FRAUD, OF WHICH PLAINTIFF'S BUSINESS WAS JUST ONE EXAMPLE)).
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: WILBANKS V. WOLK (2004) 121 CAL.APP.4TH 883 (WEB POSTING CONTAINED GENERAL CONSUMER PROTECTION
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: AMALGAM AND USE OF NITROUS OXIDE);
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: SOMETHING BEYOND JUST A PARTICULAR INCIDENT OCCURRING BETWEEN THE PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: (E. G., WING V. JING, SUPRA (REVIEW PERTAINED ALSO TO GENERAL CONTROVERSIES ABOUT SILVER
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: SECTION 425.16, SUBD. (E). TO BE A MATTER OF PUBLIC INTEREST, THE PUBLICATION MUST CONCERN
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: NOT IN CONNECTION WITH AN ISSUE OF PUBLIC INTEREST FOR PURPOSES OF CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: JING (2010) 189 CAL.APP.4TH 1354 (YELP.COM AS PUBLIC FORUM)). HOWEVER, THE PUBLICATION WAS
Docket Event Conversion Minute
FFT: THE MOTION TO STRIKE IS DENIED. THE PUBLICATION OCCURRED IN A PUBLIC FORUM. (WING V. WONG V.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
TRA: TENTATIVE RULING ADOPTED AND BECOMES THE ORDER:
Docket Event Conversion Minute
NAP: NO APPEARANCE IS MADE BY ANY PARTIES HEREIN OR THEIR COUNSEL OF RECORD.
Docket Event Conversion Minute
JCRB: HONORABLE V. RAYMOND SWOPE, JUDGE PRESIDING. CLERK: SANDRA HARRIS, COURT REPORTER: GERALDINE VANDEVELD

Judge: Swope, V. Raymond

Docket Event Conversion Hearing
HEARING: MOTION RE: TO STRIKE PER CCP425.16 FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, NASSER MAHALLATI

Judge: Swope, V. Raymond

Docket Event Motion hearings
Dept: LM HEARING: MOTION RE: TO STRIKE PER CCP425.16 FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, NASSER MAHALLATI

Judge: Swope, V. Raymond

Docket Event Conversion Minute
COM: * *.
Docket Event Conversion Action
REP: REPLY TO PLAINTIFFS' OPPOSITION TO SPECIAL MOTION FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, NASSER MAHALLATI, ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP
Docket Event Document
FILED: DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' EVIDENCE IN OPPOSITION TO SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE, FILED.
Docket Event Case Management Statement
CMS: CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP.
Docket Event Declaration
DEC: DECLARATION OF ELOA SHARIF IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS' OPPOSITION TO SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE
Docket Event Declaration
DEC: DECLARATION OF LEONARD A. NORDEMAN IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION TO SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE
Docket Event Declaration
DEC: DECLARATION OF EZRA CHATMAN IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS' OPPOSITION TO SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE
Docket Event Memorandum of Points & Authorities
MPA: MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES FILED BY MONTGOMERY SANSOMELP, LEONARD A NORDEMAN IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE
Docket Event Order received
POR: PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED.
Docket Event Request
REQ: REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE.
Docket Event Declaration
DEC: DECLARATION OF JAMES D. BIERNAT IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE
Docket Event Declaration
DEC: DECLARATION OF NASSER MAHALLATI IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE
Docket Event Motion
NM: NOTICE OF MOTION AND SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, NASSER MAHALLATI
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 111206-0694-CK 167/ 790.00 PAYMT
Docket Event Conversion Action
AAD: ATTORNEY ADDED FOR THE DEFENDANT(S)/RESPONDENT(S) ARCH CONSTRUCTION LP, SAYL MAHALLATI, NASSER MAHALLATI. ATTORNEY: JAMES D. BIERNAT.
Docket Event Memorandum of Points & Authorities
MPA: MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES FILED BY SAYL MAHALLATI, NASSER MAHALLATI IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE
Docket Event Declaration
DEC: DECLARATION OF SOHYL MAHALLATI IN SUPPORT OF SPECIAL MOTION TO STRIKE
Docket Event First Paper Fee Paid
FFP: FIRST PAPER FEE PAID BY SAYL MAHALLATI, NASSER MAHALLATI.
Docket Event (S) COMPLAINT FILED
Complaint
COM: (S) COMPLAINT FILED
Docket Event Cause Of Action
Docket Event Conversion Minute
*FEE: 111004-0746-CK 166/ 395.00 PAYMT
Docket Event CIVIL CASE COVERSHEET RECEIVED
Civil Case Cover Sheet
CCS: CIVIL CASE COVERSHEET RECEIVED
Docket Event New Filed Case
Docket Event 30 DAY SUMMONS, ISSUED AND FILED.
Summons Issued / Filed
S30IF: 30 DAY SUMMONS, ISSUED AND FILED.

Please wait a moment while we load this page.

New Envelope

Your free document request was received.

Your request has been received. We will email you this document within 4 business hours.

You have used out of 0 document requests this month.

Continue

Document Requested

You have exceeded your document request limit for this month.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue
Docket Refresh Requested

Your docket refresh request has been received. You will receive a notification when the docket is refreshed.

Docket Refresh Requested

A refresh is already in progress.

If you need immediate assistance, please contact support@trellis.law

Continue