Someone from our team will get in touch with you shortly
“An easement is a nonpossessory interest in the land of another that gives its owner the right to use that property. As such, an easement cannot be an estate in real property. An easement may not be imposed upon another easement because only an estate in land may serve as the servient tenement. ” (Carstens v. California Coastal Commission, supra, 182 Cal.App.3d at p. 287.)
“A transfer of real property passes all easements attached thereto, and creates in favor thereof an easement to use other real property of the person whose estate is transferred in the same manner and to the same extent as such property was obviously and permanently used by the person whose estate is transferred, for the benefit thereof, at the time when the transfer was agreed upon or completed.” (Civil Code § 1104; see Larsson v. Grabach (2004) 121 Cal.App.4th 1147, 1151-1152.)
“An easement by way of necessity arises when it is established that:
(Kellogg v. Garcia (2002) 102 Cal.App.4th 796, 799.)
In Zissler v. Saville (2018) 29 Cal.App.5th 630, the easement at issue was described as “‘[p]roviding Grantee access, ingress and egress to vehicles and pedestrians over Grantors’ real property from Green Meadows Road to Grantees’ real property.’” (Id. at 635.) “‘An easement agreement is subject to the rules of interpretation that apply to contracts ... As with all contracts, the paramount goal of interpreting a writing creating an easement is to determine the intent of the parties.’” (Id.) But “[i]t is fundamental that the language of a grant of an easement determines the scope of the easement.”(Id.) “The extent of a servitude is determined by the terms of the grant.” (Id. at 639.)
In California, “a covenant against encumbrances, implied in a grant of real estate under [Civil Code] § 1113, imposes a personal obligation on the grantor; and that where there are two or more grantors, such obligation is joint and several, and is binding on one of them, although he may have no interest in the land at the time of the execution of the grant.” (Evans v. Faught (1965) 231 Cal.App.2d 698, 712.)
For well over 75 years, the California courts have had the discretionary authority to deny a landowner's request to eject a trespasser and instead force the landowner to accept damages as compensation for the judicial creation of an easement over the trespassed-upon property in the trespasser's favor, provided that the trespasser shows that
(Shoen v. Zacarias (2015) 237 Cal.App.4th 16, 19, stating: "[T]here are good reasons to require the trespasser seeking an equitable easement to prove that she will suffer greatly disproportionate hardship from denial of the easement than the presumptively heavy hardship the owner will suffer from its grant.") (Id. at 20.)
“[E]quitable easements give the trespasser ‘what is, in effect, the right of eminent domain by permitting him to occupy property owned by another.’” (Shoen v. Zacarias (2015) 237 Cal.App.4th, 20 citing Christensen v. Tucker (1952) 114 Cal.App.2d 554, 560; Donnell v. Bisso Bros. (1970) 10 Cal.App.3d 38, 46) “Such a right is in tension with the general constitutional prohibition against the taking of private property.” (Shoen v. Zacarias (2015) 237 Cal.App.4th, 20 citing U.S. Const., 5th Amend. ['[private property' 'shall' not 'be taken for public use, without just compensation']; Cal. Const., art. I, § 19(a).) “This is why courts approach the issuance of equitable easements with ‘an abundance of caution’, and resolve all doubts against their issuance.” (Shoen, supra, 237 Cal.App.4th at 20.) “It explains why additional weight is given to the owner's loss of the exclusive use of the property arising from her ownership, independent of any hardship caused by the owner's loss of specific uses in a given case.” (Id. at 21.) “And it elucidates why there must be a showing that the hardship on the trespasser be greatly disproportionate to these hardships on the owner.” (Id.) “To allow a court to reassign property rights on a lesser showing is to dilute the sanctity of property rights enshrined in our Constitutions.” (Id.)
As a result of the October, 2017 quitclaim Plaintiff became the owner of all rights and interest in the easement. The easement was extinguished by operation of law because a landowner cannot have an easement over its own property. Defendants are no longer entitled to use of the easement, and conversely Plaintiff is no longer entitled to annual payments from Defendants.
TACWEST HOLDINGS LLC VS 2515 OFFICE PARK ASSOCIATION
37-2017-00039353-CU-BC-CTL
May 14, 2019
San Diego County, CA
Contract
Breach
There, the court did not consider whether an easement gave the dominant propertys owner a right to exclusive possessioni.e., whether the easement was exclusive. Instead, the question was [w]hether a so-called exclusive easement constitutes ownership in fee, rather than an easement. ( Blackmore, supra, 150 Cal.App.4th at p. 1600.)
SIMA ASHRAFI, ET AL. VS SANDRA MARIANA VIDAL
22STCV30058
Jul 03, 2023
Los Angeles County, CA
If the court grants judgment for some or all of the Well Site Owners upon the stipulated facts, then the Easement Holders, their successors, and their assigns, will forever release and relinquish any and all claims against all of the Well Site Owners related to any easement or right of passage, however characterized, over the Well Site, whether by express easement, implied easement, easement by prescription, easement by necessity, or any other right or entitlement on, in, under, or through the Well Site.
OLAF NEGARD VS EMMETT RICE ET AL
1301746
Aug 17, 2010
Santa Barbara County, CA
Ackerly ) (Exhibit T) included the easement whereas the deed conveying title to Plaintiff (Exhibit C) does not reference the easement, suggesting the property was conveyed to Plaintiff without the easement.
BRUCE D. MANSDORF VS FRANCES ONTKEAN
22SMCV00989
Jul 06, 2023
Los Angeles County, CA
¿ Regardless, Defendant has asserted that Plaintiff has no right to use any part of the easement. ¿ The cases that Defendant relies upon do not support dismissing Plaintiffs Complaint. · There is no requirement that a Plaintiff needs to have future plans to use the easement. Further, the easement deeds identify the permissible uses of Plaintiffs easement.
MOUNT SAINT MARYS UNIVERSITY, A CALIFORNIA NONPROFIT CORPORATION VS THE J. PAUL GETTY TRUST, A CALIFORNIA CHARITABLE TRUST,
23STCV04707
Aug 23, 2023
Los Angeles County, CA
Zissler’s predecessor in interest granted the easement to Saville’s predecessor in interest in a document recorded on January 21, 1994, which easement was clarified in a document recorded on March 18, 1994 (hereinafter “the Easement”). The original express Easement and subsequent clarification are both entitled “EASEMENT GENERAL.”
JAMES F. ZISSLER V. PATRICK J. SAVILLE
16CV02421
Jun 17, 2019
Santa Barbara County, CA
Based on the recorded First Easement Deed, Plaintiffs evidence establishes their easement rights over the area of land covered by the First Easement Deed. However, because the Second Easement Deed expired on May 15, 2004, Plaintiffs must establish some other basis for their claimed easement over the area covered by the Second Easement Deed. Plaintiffs argue prescriptive easement as an alternative basis for the claimed easement.
NENA GOASDOUE ET. AL. VS. KIRK MORROW ET. AL.
SC129613
May 17, 2022
Los Angeles County, CA
In contrast to a non-exclusive easement, an exclusive easement only permits the dominant owner to use the easement area. ( Romero v. Shih , (2022) 78 Cal. App. 5th 326, 349.)
JASON HAIM, ET AL. VS NOUSHIN ABRISHAMI LAALY, ET AL.
21SMCV01032
Jan 24, 2024
Los Angeles County, CA
This easement consists of the six (6) separately described parcels in Exhibit "C" hereto and depicted on the plot in Exhibit "D" hereto, together with an additional easement to maintain, repair and replace the existing telephone line at its existing location along the westerly line of [Parcel 2] (collectively, "Easement"). The Easement shall be appurtenant to [Parcel 3].
MANFRED KRANKL ET AL VS ROWLES HOLDINGS, LLC
17CV01892
Jul 31, 2018
Santa Barbara County, CA
In order to prevail on a cause of action for prescriptive easement, the plaintiffor the party claiming an interest in the easement propertymust solely seek a nonpossessory right in the easement property, by way of a mere right to use the property of another, as opposed to exclusive title, or possession, of the easement property.
MATTHEW DE SANTIS VS A & B PROPERTY INVESTMENTS, A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION, ET AL.
19STCV45276
May 19, 2022
Los Angeles County, CA
The Court further rejects Elliott's argument that it removed the USAF Easement from the title of Lot 1; or amended the USAF Easement to allow construction of buildings in the area affected by that easement, by obtaining an endorsement to the First American Title insurance policy removing the insurer's previous exception as to the USAF Easement.
MAC MILLAN PARTNERS. ET AL. VS. ELLIOTT HOMES
07AS02136
Nov 18, 2010
Sacramento County, CA
Contract
Breach
MODIFICATION OF EASEMENT “The current 10 foot easement benefiting the Antonucci Property and burdening the Faoro property reads: ‘An easement for existing and future structures and access over and upon that portion of Block 194 in said City of Santa Barbara, County of Santa Barbara, State of California described as follows: [legal description of easement area]’ “The parties shall sign and record a Modification of Easement that changes the wording and the purpose of the easement to: ‘A 10 foot easement for ingress
JOSEPH ANTONUCCI VS ELIZABETH FAORO ET AL
19CV06659
Aug 24, 2021
Santa Barbara County, CA
Here, Patel does not testify that the easement is in a state of disrepair, that any other lot owner has been paying for maintenance, or that any easement owner refused to pay for the cost of maintenance. Therefore, the evidence is insufficient to show that Plaintiff or any other easement owner abandoned the easement.
1525 COLORADO, LLC VS MANIBEN CORP., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION, ET AL.
23STCV22497
Mar 19, 2024
Los Angeles County, CA
When the easement “is an appropriate and useful adjunct” to another parcel of land owned by the easement holder, an appurtenant easement is presumed. (Id. at pp.196-198.) Especially, when a roadway easement provides access to a particular parcel of real property, the court is justified in concluding that the easement is appurtenant to the property served by the easement. (Continental Baking Co. v. Katz (1968) 68 Cal.2d 512, 523.)
PALM DESERT GOLF VENTURES LLC VS LUS
CVPS2000139
Sep 25, 2022
Riverside County, CA
When the easement “is an appropriate and useful adjunct” to another parcel of land owned by the easement holder, an appurtenant easement is presumed. (Id. at pp.196-198.) Especially, when a roadway easement provides access to a particular parcel of real property, the court is justified in concluding that the easement is appurtenant to the property served by the easement. (Continental Baking Co. v. Katz (1968) 68 Cal.2d 512, 523.)
PALM DESERT GOLF VENTURES LLC VS LUS
CVPS2000139
Sep 26, 2022
Riverside County, CA
When the easement “is an appropriate and useful adjunct” to another parcel of land owned by the easement holder, an appurtenant easement is presumed. (Id. at pp.196-198.) Especially, when a roadway easement provides access to a particular parcel of real property, the court is justified in concluding that the easement is appurtenant to the property served by the easement. (Continental Baking Co. v. Katz (1968) 68 Cal.2d 512, 523.)
PALM DESERT GOLF VENTURES LLC VS LUS
CVPS2000139
Sep 23, 2022
Riverside County, CA
When the easement “is an appropriate and useful adjunct” to another parcel of land owned by the easement holder, an appurtenant easement is presumed. (Id. at pp.196-198.) Especially, when a roadway easement provides access to a particular parcel of real property, the court is justified in concluding that the easement is appurtenant to the property served by the easement. (Continental Baking Co. v. Katz (1968) 68 Cal.2d 512, 523.)
PALM DESERT GOLF VENTURES LLC VS LUS
CVPS2000139
Sep 24, 2022
Riverside County, CA
"In an action to establish the abandonment of an easement pursuant to this chapter, the court shall permit the owner of the easement to record a late notice of intent to preserve the easement as a condition of dismissal of the action, upon payment into court for the benefit of the owner of the real property the litigation expenses attributable to the easement or portion thereof as to which the notice is recorded.
SOUZA VS ARGLEBEN
37-2020-00045974-CU-BC-CTL
Jun 07, 2024
San Diego County, CA
Defendants chief argument is that the easement is too old to be enforced. He argues plaintiff has no Current Easement Agreement and instead relies on an outdated Easement Agreement. (Demurrer, p. 6.) He argues the easement was granted in 1965 to Jack Emreck and Sue Ann Emreck from Harold Rosen and does not mention the current property owner, plaintiff. (Demurrer, p. 4.) The easement is not outdated.
21STLC07798
Nov 07, 2022
Los Angeles County, CA
Dodge’s (“Dodges” together) Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings to the second cause of action for Declaratory Relief for Easement By Necessity, and the third cause of action for Declaratory Relief for Easement by Implication, are granted without leave to amend.
HAJJ VS DODGE
30-2018-00991306-CU-OR-CJC
Nov 02, 2018
Orange County, CA
Paragraph 4.2 provides that plaintiff’s counsel will prepare and record an easement in favor of plaintiff “for ingress and egress over the existing driveway with the width of the easement not to exceed 17’ and said easement shall provide that there will be no parking on the driveway.” The agreement defendant signed is clear and unambiguous. The court does not accept defendant’s claim that she was surprised or mistaken about the placement of the easement.
CHACON VS. ZHOU
MSC19-01249
Feb 03, 2021
Contra Costa County, CA
Ransford’s (“Ransfords” together) Demurrer to the second cause of action for Declaratory Relief for Easement By Necessity, and the third cause of action for Declaratory Relief for Easement by Implication, are Sustained without leave to amend.
HAJJ VS DODGE
30-2018-00991306-CU-OR-CJC
Aug 24, 2018
Orange County, CA
Section 2 of the Agreement explains the easement as follows: 2. “Grant of Non-Exclusive Ingress and Egress Easement for Developer Parcel.
THIER V. FARAH
30-2017-00956655-CU-PO-CJC
Apr 27, 2018
Orange County, CA
The deeds that created the Upper Easement grant an "access easement" for "ingress and egress" over the Upper Easement. According to the evidence, the Tarantinos knew plaintiff parked on the Upper Easement, but allowed plaintiff to park on the Upper Easement, extending what defendants characterize as a "neighborly accommodation" Citing Heath v.
PATRICIA ANN STADEL, TRUSTEE OF THE PATRICIA ANN STADEL TRUST DATED NOVEMBER 10, 2000 VS. PACIFIC VIEW ESTATES, INC.
37-2015-00035927-CU-OR-CTL
Feb 02, 2017
San Diego County, CA
Real Property
other
Specifically, the Easement Deed states that the Bowers granted the Shelleys “[a]n easement for ingress, egress, driveway, public utility purposes over, under, and across the [Driveway]. Grantors agree to pay one-half of any and all maintenance and/or repair costs of this easement upon occupancy of the residence to be constructed on the property over which this easement passes…” (“the Easement”). (RJN, Exh. 1.)
YATES VS GHADA Y. AFIFI, TRUSTEE OF THE GHADA Y. AFIFI SEPARATE PROPERTY TRUST DATED OCTOBER 30, 2008
CVRI2401669
Nov 06, 2025
Riverside County, CA
The owner of a servient tenement for a nonexclusive easement may make any use of the property that does not unduly interfere with the easement. ( See Dunn v. Pacific Gas & Elec. Co. (1954) 43 Cal. 2d 265.) Owners of the servient tenement may not use their property in a way that obstructs the normal use of the easement ( See Blackmore v. Powell (2007) 150 Cal.
HOMAYOON EBRAHIM-NEHORAY VS FARZIN AGHAIPOUR, ET AL.
21STCV24248
Dec 06, 2024
Los Angeles County, CA
Plaintiff’s complaint includes quiet title causes of action based on deeded easement, easement by prescription, easement by necessity, easement by implication and easement by balancing hardship. Plaintiff now brings this motion for summary adjudication as to the first cause of action for quiet title based on a deeded easement. The Loguzzos and the Scovills (collectively Defendants) oppose the motion.
Keith R. Bankston v. Anthony S. Loguzzo, et al. 16CVP0187
Aug 22, 2017
San Luis Obispo County, CA
As to the 4th Cause of Action (Declaratory Relief), C.E. 70-44 does not create a valid easement because the document does not contain a legal description of the property that is being subjected to the easement. See Plaintiff's Separate Statement of Undisputed Material Facts No. 26.
VENICE INVESTORS VS. CITY OF LOS ANGELES
SC116345
Oct 09, 2018
Los Angeles County, CA
Real Property
Quiet Title
In the present case, Plaintiff has not shown that the easement should be deemed extinguished. Indeed, extinguishment of the easement is improper even where an easement holder use of an easement prevents the servient property owner from making any use of the easement area. (Reichardt, supra, 52 Cal.App.4th at 769.) Rather, the proper remedy under such circumstances is an injunction requiring the easement owner to accommodate the servient tenement’s use of the easement area. (Ibid.)
SAMEC VS RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES SOLUTION INC.
RIC1903005
Jul 08, 2023
Riverside County, CA
In the present case, Plaintiff has not shown that the easement should be deemed extinguished. Indeed, extinguishment of the easement is improper even where an easement holder use of an easement prevents the servient property owner from making any use of the easement area. (Reichardt, supra, 52 Cal.App.4th at 769.) Rather, the proper remedy under such circumstances is an injunction requiring the easement owner to accommodate the servient tenement’s use of the easement area. (Ibid.)
SAMEC VS RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES SOLUTION INC.
RIC1903005
Jul 09, 2023
Riverside County, CA
In the present case, Plaintiff has not shown that the easement should be deemed extinguished. Indeed, extinguishment of the easement is improper even where an easement holder use of an easement prevents the servient property owner from making any use of the easement area. (Reichardt, supra, 52 Cal.App.4th at 769.) Rather, the proper remedy under such circumstances is an injunction requiring the easement owner to accommodate the servient tenement’s use of the easement area. (Ibid.)
SAMEC VS RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES SOLUTION INC.
RIC1903005
Jul 10, 2023
Riverside County, CA
In the context of a private easement, “[t]he conveyance of an easement limited to roadway use grants a right of ingress and egress and a right of unobstructed passage to the holder of the easement. A roadway easement does not include the right to use the easement for any other purpose.” (Schmidt v. Bank of Am., N.A. (2014) 223 Cal.App.4th 1489, 1505.) Vierra argues that Rechlin has misused the Easement by using it for long-term storage, rather than ingress and egress.
NEIANI LEA VIERRA V. CHRISTOPHER RECHLIN, ANNEMARIE RECHLIN
18CVP-0003
May 01, 2018
San Luis Obispo County, CA
Even if defendant could prove the parties intended to replace the recorded easement with the Cates easement, that easement does not achieve its purpose, and does not provide Tarlton access to his property. Third, plaintiff asserts that even if a recorded easement could be legally extinguished with an alternative, no alternative easement exists that would provide Tarlton with access. Further, an express, recorded easement is not extinguished merely due to the existence of an alternative. (Murphy v.
JOHN C TARLTON VS GREGORY B STANISLAWSKI ET AL
18CV03919
Oct 25, 2021
Santa Barbara County, CA
Demurrer to the 1st Cause of Action for Interference With Easement/Encroachment SCE alleges both an express easement and a prescriptive easement over the Property. Even assuming arguendo that Severns' request for judicial notice is sufficient to negate SCE's allegations of an express easement [ a finding the Court is not making], it does not negate SCE's allegations of a prescriptive easement over the Property.
SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA EDISON CO VS. SEVERNS
56-2013-00437692-CU-OR-VTA
Sep 16, 2013
Ventura County, CA
Real Property
other
The complaint alleges both an equitable easement and a prescriptive easement. There is a difference between the two. An equitable easement allows for exclusive use of the property in return for which the propertys owner must be compensated. If the use underlying the equitable easement ever ceases, though, the property is returned to the original owner and the easement evaporates.
YALE BARON, ET AL. VS RAMIN GABBAI
23SMCV01058
Jun 21, 2023
Los Angeles County, CA
Michelle Bowers stated that she did not realize that the Driveway Easement Deed lacked a reference to “successors and assigns,” which was included in the Water Easement Deed, but she always intended that both the Driveway Easement and Water Easement would just “go with the house, whoever was going to buy the house,” and never thought that the easement rights would end. (Yateses’ Exh. 7, Depo. of Michelle Bowers, 23:21-27:12.)
YATES VS GHADA Y. AFIFI, TRUSTEE OF THE GHADA Y. AFIFI SEPARATE PROPERTY TRUST DATED OCTOBER 30, 2008
CVRI2401669
Apr 14, 2026
Riverside County, CA
The claims for negligence and nuisance do not depend on the validity of the disputed easement. Plaintiffs allege sufficient facts for interference with easement and for declaratory relief. Defendant argues the easement agreement is invalid. She contends that plaintiffs cannot show they are entitled to an exclusive easement and are therefore left with a purported grant for easement (i.e. the Easement Agreement) that has no ascertainable scope. (Demurrer, p. 9.)
SIMA ASHRAFI, ET AL. VS SANDRA MARIANA VIDAL
22STCV30058
Apr 25, 2023
Los Angeles County, CA
The inconsistency between the description of the easement alleged in the Complaint and the easement sought additionally raises questions as to whether the utility easement sought in judgment exceeds the relief pled in the Complaint and therefore cannot be awarded. Accordingly, the evidence provided is still not sufficient to meet plaintiffs’ burden in demonstrating the elements required for the appurtenant easement sought pursuant to Civil Code section 1001.
BDHOV, LP, A CALIFORNIA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP VS. ANDREW BENITEZ, SR
24CECG04880
Oct 30, 2025
Fresno County, CA
Extinguishment of an easement is an extreme and powerful remedy which is utilized only when use of the easement has been rendered essentially impossible. Reichardt v. Hoffman (1997) 52 Cal. App. 4th 754, 767. Section 811 authorizes extinguishment of an easement only where the easement owner performs or authorizes an act which permanently prevents use of the easement. Id.
EQUITY TRUST COMPANY CUSTODIAN FBO HAMID LIAGHAT IRA VS JUDITH R BENSON TRUSTEE OF THE SURVIVORS TRUST OF THE BENSON FAMILY TRUST DATED OCTOBER 18 1985
37-2021-00024685-CU-OR-CTL
Jan 27, 2023
San Diego County, CA
Rather, they argue that Plaintiff lost their right to the easement for several reasons: 1) Plaintiff failed to satisfy a condition subsequent of the easement; 2) the easement terminated due to non-use; 3) the easement terminated due to adverse possession; 4) Plaintiffs proposed use of the easement is inconsistent with its original stated purpose; and 5) Plaintiff has unclean hands.
1525 COLORADO, LLC VS MANIBEN CORP., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION, ET AL.
23STCV22497
May 14, 2025
Los Angeles County, CA
The road leading from Defendants’ home to Pleasant Hill Road is a roadway ingress/egress easement that the three houses jointly possess. That easement does not appear to be at issue in this proceeding. Instead, in the general area of the orange circle is the so-called ‘2005 easement.’ The ‘2005 easement’ was entered into by prior owners of the two properties.
SENGENDO ET AL VS ELLIOTT
MSC21-02565
Jun 14, 2023
Contra Costa County, CA
Defendant also asserts that the land at issue is not a floating easement. A floating easement is an expressly granted easement that is not specifically defined to a location. (Southern California Edison Co. v. Severns (2019) 39 Cal.App.5th 815, 823.) Despite Plaintiffs argument, the TAC does not allege an express easement from one party to another.
TEJEDA VS GSPUROHIT PROPERTIES, LLC
CVSW2310634
Feb 11, 2025
Riverside County, CA
An order requiring the Haddads to remove the dirt and rocks placed on the easement to obstruct the easement.
BEN HADDAD VS. MONROE RE, LLC
C23-02292
May 31, 2024
Contra Costa County, CA
Under California law, an easement may be extinguished through abandonment or through the servient estate reacquiring the easement by adverse possession.
LE-YOUNG LEE VS. CONSUELO Z. MORAN
EC065044
Sep 15, 2017
Los Angeles County, CA
Real Property
Quiet Title
The FAC alleges four causes of action for Quiet Title – Relocation of Easement, Quiet Title – Easement by Prescription, Declaratory Relief, and Injunctive Relief. Defendants demur here to Plaintiff’s second cause of action for a prescriptive easement on the grounds that it fails to state a cause of action.
ALLAN R. PEREIRA V. FRANK S. ROOT
17CV-0417
Nov 14, 2018
San Luis Obispo County, CA
Here, Plaintiffs are seeking an injunction maintaining the status quo that would prevent Defendants from building additional items within the easement area. If Defendants were to build additional items within the easement area it could obstruct Plaintiffs’ use of the easement. Such harm interferes with Plaintiffs’ rights to use the easement area. In contrast, Defendants will not be harmed if they are temporarily prevented from adding additional items to the easement area.
PATEL VS. NCA CAPITAL
MSC19-00547
Sep 11, 2019
Contra Costa County, CA
This evidence creates a triable issue of material fact as to whether the parties intended to subordinate the conservation easement, the speculation of plaintiff’s expert William Hutton as to the bank’s intent (paras. 12-15) notwithstanding. The court also notes that DeJoria would not have the power to subordinate the conservation easement, because he was not – nor could he be under the statutory scheme -- the holder of the easement (CC 815.3), as a private party cannot hold a conservation easement.
CANYON VINEYARD ESTATES I, LLC VS JOHN PAUL DEJORIA, ET AL.,
SC128181
Mar 20, 2019
Los Angeles County, CA
Real Property
Quiet Title
An easement is also abandoned if, for a period of 20 years or more, the easement is not used, there is no separate tax assessment of the easement, and no instrument creating, reserving, transferring or otherwise evidencing the easement is recorded. (Civ. Code § 887.050.) Under that section, an abandoned easement is unenforceable and is deemed to have expired. (Id.) An easement by grant can be lost by prescription. Glatts v. Henson (1948) 31 Cal.2d 368, 371; Sevier v.
BORSH VS SALTZMAN
37-2020-00009503-CU-OR-CTL
Sep 15, 2020
San Diego County, CA
Real Property
other
This occurred long after Chevron claims it believed in 2007 that the easement was no longer necessary. Likewise, Chevron does not dispute that it paid rent on the Pipeline Easement Agreement for the entirety of the easement term, even beyond 2007, a time when it now asserts it believed the easement was unnecessary.
SAN DIEGO UNIFIED PORT DISTRICT VS CHEVRON USA INC
37-2015-00033680-CU-CO-CTL
Oct 19, 2017
San Diego County, CA
Contract
Contract - Other
The McCune Property is the dominant tenement to a recorded landscape easement dated March 1, 1999, (Easement Agreement) to which the SWI Property is the servient tenement. (FAC, ¶ 8 & exhibit 1.) The easement is a landscape easement over an approximately 10 foot strip of land (Landscape Strip) on the SWI Property adjacent to the McCune Property. (Ibid.) The easement is limited to McCune’s right to maintain and grow trees, bushes, and hedges (Foliage) for landscape purposes. (Ibid.)
SARA MILLER MCCUNE VS STUART WHITMAN
17CV03519
Dec 20, 2017
Santa Barbara County, CA
Where an appurtenant easement is involved, the easement remains attached to the dominant tenement even though the deed does not describe the easement, and successors of the owner of the dominant tenement can enforce the easement even though it is not specifically mentioned in their deeds. ( Moylan v. Dykes (1986) 181 Cal App 3d 561.)
PASSMORE PROPERTIES, LLC., A CALIFORNIA LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY VS MICHAEL W FONG, AS TRUSTEE OF THE CIOPPA- FONG LIVING TRUST DATED JUNE 18, 2022, ET AL.
22STCV25294
Jun 13, 2025
Echo Dawn Ryan
Los Angeles County, CA
An express or implied easement carries with it secondary easement rights necessary to the exercise of the principal easement right by the dominant estate owner. (Ward v. Monrovia (1940) 16 Cal.2d 815, 821-822.) “[A] secondary easement which accompanies a principal easement is no more than the right to do such things as are necessary to the enjoyment of the principal easement…” (Los Angeles v. Howard (1966) 244 Cal.App.2d 538, 543.)
NIST VS FARRELL
MSC21-02445
Dec 18, 2024
Contra Costa County, CA
However, as in Vieira , the existence of a gate does not necessarily provide notice to easement holders that Patel possessed the easement in a manner adverse to their rights. The record shows that no one used the easement after Patel built the gate in 2015, and there is no evidence that easement holders during 944 Bentons ownership had occasion to object. Patels declaration merely states that 944 Benton never used the easement.
1525 COLORADO, LLC VS MANIBEN CORP., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION, ET AL.
23STCV22497
Oct 29, 2025
Los Angeles County, CA
Express Easement An express easement is a written conveyance of certain interests or reservations in property held by a grantor to a grantee. An easement may, but need not be, recorded. (Civ. Code. §§ 801-813.) Defendants correctly identify that the deed conveying the easement to Plaintiff was granted after the Russes conveyed the property to Plaintiff, when they had no interest in the property at issue.
MARK WINITSKY VS SUSAN NAYLOR, ET AL.
25SMCV03173
Oct 28, 2025
Los Angeles County, CA
Defendants Moving Argument Defendants argue that Winitsky does not hold an express easement over the driveway because the Gusses, who sold Winitsky his property, did not own the easement they purportedly conveyed to Winitsky. (Demurrer, p. 8.) Defendants also claim that Plaintiff does not state sufficient facts to support his claims for implied easement, prescriptive easement, nuisance, and invasion of privacy. (Demurrer, pp. 10-15.)
MARK WINITSKY VS SUSAN NAYLOR, ET AL.
25SMCV03173
Apr 21, 2026
Los Angeles County, CA
Under common law, the abandonment of an express easement requires a manifest “intent to forswear all future conforming uses of the easement.” Faus v. Los Angeles (1967) 67 Cal.2d 350, 363.
198309
Apr 02, 2022
Shasta County, CA
Under common law, the abandonment of an express easement requires a manifest “intent to forswear all future conforming uses of the easement.” Faus v. Los Angeles (1967) 67 Cal.2d 350, 363.
198309
Apr 08, 2022
Shasta County, CA
Under common law, the abandonment of an express easement requires a manifest “intent to forswear all future conforming uses of the easement.” Faus v. Los Angeles (1967) 67 Cal.2d 350, 363.
198309
Apr 03, 2022
Shasta County, CA
Under common law, the abandonment of an express easement requires a manifest “intent to forswear all future conforming uses of the easement.” Faus v. Los Angeles (1967) 67 Cal.2d 350, 363.
198309
Apr 05, 2022
Shasta County, CA
Under common law, the abandonment of an express easement requires a manifest “intent to forswear all future conforming uses of the easement.” Faus v. Los Angeles (1967) 67 Cal.2d 350, 363.
198309
Apr 04, 2022
Shasta County, CA
Under common law, the abandonment of an express easement requires a manifest “intent to forswear all future conforming uses of the easement.” Faus v. Los Angeles (1967) 67 Cal.2d 350, 363.
198309
Apr 06, 2022
Shasta County, CA
Defendants contend the alleged view easement is not an enforceable negative easement; reports the only easement location that is described in the grant deed is the South 30 feet of Parcel One, adjacent to and north of the plaintiffs’ property; nevertheless the plaintiffs claim a view easement “over the entirety of defendants property;” contend plaintiffs cannot “enlarge” the easement location; therefore, plaintiffs cannot allege a view easement over the entire property; that the alleged view easement is not
MARGARET DENT ET AL VS ALAN VAN VLIET ET AL
1402236
Aug 28, 2012
Santa Barbara County, CA
The Courts jurisdiction to grant an equitable or implied easement burdening SETA, LLCs property a. The City of Los Angeles Storm Drain Easement It is undisputed that the City holds a storm drain easement appurtenant to the part of SETAs property at issue. Plaintiff argues that this easement is publicly enforceable because it is a storm drain easement in the public interest. (Plaintiffs brief, pp. 4-5.) Not so.
SETA LLC, A CALIFORNIA LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY VS JAMIE H. LIEBERMAN, ET AL.
21SMCV01056
Mar 06, 2026
Los Angeles County, CA
The Meaghers’ evidence establishes that they have repeatedly sought to obtain Creason’s approval for the fence, but that Creason has refused to provide such approval unless the property description of the Primary Easement is modified. The parties’ Settlement and Easement Agreement does not require that the property description of the Primary Easement be modified, or that a new survey of Defendant’s property or the Primary Easement be completed.
MEAGHER VS CREASON
RG16802578
Jan 25, 2024
Alameda County, CA
It provides a “driveway easement” burdening the property at 1660 Spring Street (1660 Spring) for “vehicular and pedestrian ingress, egress, and access …” (Driveway Easement). The agreement giving rise to the Driveway Easement provides, in part: “[1664 Spring]’s use of the Driveway Easement shall be exclusive, and [1660 Spring] shall not grant or assign to other private parties any ingress, egress, and access rights in the Driveway Easement Strip.”
KATHLEEN D. MCBRIDE V. BYRON C. SMITH, ET AL.
26-63368
Feb 14, 2019
Napa County, CA
Equitable Easement A Court has discretion to grant an equitable easement only if the party seeking an easement shows that (1) the need for an easement was innocent and not the result of the willful act of the party seeking the easement; (2) the property owner will not be irreparably injured by the easement, and (3) the hardship to the party seeking the easement is greatly disproportionate to the hardship caused to the servient owner over whose property the easement is granted. (Shoen v.
GREG HART VS THOMAS MILWAY
MSC19-00771
May 19, 2021
Contra Costa County, CA
The easement in this case was created and recorded by the original landowners of Parcel A and Parcel B. Request for Judicial Notice, Ex. C at 2 (“Creation of Original Easement”).
PRASHANTH MACHAIAH VS. BRIAN K
MSC16-00706
Aug 01, 2016
Contra Costa County, CA
owners supersedes individual agreements between adjoining property owners and their respective tenants, whether exclusive use of a non-exclusive easement (as contemplated by Slice House) exceeds the grant of the easement at issue, and whether Plaintiff has a right to demand payment in exchange for use of its easement that overburdens the easement and exceeds the scope of its grant.
CASTRO VALLEY INVESTMENT GROUP, LLC, A CALIFORNIA LIMITED LIA...
24CV075116
Jul 25, 2024
Alameda County, CA
Williams has placed an iron fence around much, but not all of the easement. Williams’ claim to adverse possession is complicated because Zerlins’ easement was never intended to be exclusive. So, mere open and notorious possession of the driveway is insufficient because that is entirely consistent with the easement. To be adverse to the exercise of the easement, the use must substantially interfere with the easement. Clearly the iron fence and gate have done that for part of the easement but not all.
WILLIAMS V KLINGER
1306795
Aug 17, 2010
Santa Barbara County, CA
When a grantor or owner of a conservation easement has shown that a party has threatened injury or actually injured a conservation easement, the owner or grantor of the conservation easement may enforce the terms of the easement by injunctive relief granted by any court of competent jurisdiction. The terms of the statute are permissive and not mandatory.
CANYON VINEYARD ESTATES I, LLC VS JOHN PAUL DEJORIA, ET AL.,
SC128181
Aug 11, 2020
Los Angeles County, CA
Real Property
Quiet Title
Therefore, Defendants conclude that the claims for easement by necessity and implication both fail. Easement by Necessity “An easement by necessity ‘ “arises by operation of law when a grantor conveys land that is completely shut off from access to any road by land retained by the grantor or by land of the grantor and that of a stranger . . . .
SKOUMBAS VS KLAMMCZYNSKA
MSC17-02007
Jun 20, 2018
Contra Costa County, CA
The Willsons argue that recording the prescriptive easement will turn it into an express easement.
MICHELLE BARKER VS. JAMES WILLSON
MSC21-00819
Mar 28, 2025
Contra Costa County, CA
As an alternative to a judgment granting Plaintiffs rights to the Zeff Property via an easement by express easement or by implied easement, Plaintiffs seek an (sic) judgment granting them an equitable easement for the continued use of the Zeff Easement for ingress and egress, roadway and incidental purposes that shall run with the land and be binding on all Defendants and their successors-in-interest. 33.
BOBBIE REIF, ET AL. VS STEVEN A. KAUFFMAN, ET AL.
20SMCV00426
Jul 31, 2024
Los Angeles County, CA
Express Easement Defendant argues that Plaintiff cannot establish the probable validity of her real property claim. It is undisputed that in 1966, in a transaction between Anthony and Cordia Radetich and Maurice and Lois Reid, an easement was recorded in a grant deed (the Radetich Easement).
TARA DEMARCO VS 2315 LOMA VISTA LLC, ET AL.
23STCV05340
May 13, 2025
Los Angeles County, CA
The Court finds that the agreement to remove any obstructions in the easement areas includes the removal of the rocks, plants and irrigation, as well as, the stone/rock retaining wall near the street from the easement area and the stone/rock retaining wall closer to the top of the pathway. These items are obstructions in the easement area and must be removed from the easement area. The wooden retaining wall near the gate does not need to be removed.
HOOSHMAND VS MAHONEY
MSC15-01138
Aug 08, 2019
Contra Costa County, CA
discretion to grant an equitable easement.
LOPEZ VS REYES
CVPS2104141
Oct 23, 2024
Riverside County, CA
The parties dispute the degree of obstruction on the easement and whether Plaintiffs had the ability to access the Reif property by way of the easement.
BOBBIE REIF, ET AL. VS STEVEN A. KAUFFMAN, ET AL.
20SMCV00426
Aug 01, 2023
Los Angeles County, CA
Their property is encumbered by an easement. The easement was created in 2000 as part of approval of a subdivision map. (FAC ¶¶ 5-6.) The easement is known as “S-3 Access Condition” and includes the following language: “private right-of-way easement shall be left open for pedestrian access between Happy Valley Road and Glen Road”. (FAC ¶6.)
MSC20-01130
Jan 07, 2022
Contra Costa County, CA
Statutory Abandonment of Easement California Civil Code section 887.040 provides that “the owner of real property subject to an easement” shall bring an action in the superior court of the county in which the real property subject to the easement is located “to establish the abandonment of the easement and to clear record title of the easement.” (Civil Code § 887.040(a)-(b).)
TARZANA FIVE PROPERTIES, LLC VS ALICIA ALVAREZ
20VECV01142
Apr 20, 2021
Los Angeles County, CA
Real Property
Quiet Title
Statutory Abandonment of Easement California Civil Code section 887.040 provides that “the owner of real property subject to an easement” shall bring an action in the superior court of the county in which the real property subject to the easement is located “to establish the abandonment of the easement and to clear record title of the easement.” (Civil Code § 887.040(a)-(b).)
TARZANA 5 PROPERTIES, LLC VS ARASH AMINI, ET AL.
20VECV00878
Apr 20, 2021
Los Angeles County, CA
Real Property
Quiet Title
Statutory Abandonment of Easement California Civil Code section 887.040 provides that “the owner of real property subject to an easement” shall bring an action in the superior court of the county in which the real property subject to the easement is located “to establish the abandonment of the easement and to clear record title of the easement.” (Civil Code § 887.040(a)-(b).)
TARZANA FIVE PROPERTIES, LLC, A CALIFORNIA LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY VS MARCELO POSTERNAK, ET AL.
20VECV01141
Apr 20, 2021
Los Angeles County, CA
Real Property
Quiet Title
Statutory Abandonment of Easement California Civil Code section 887.040 provides that “the owner of real property subject to an easement” shall bring an action in the superior court of the county in which the real property subject to the easement is located “to establish the abandonment of the easement and to clear record title of the easement.” (Civil Code § 887.040(a)-(b).)
TARZANA FIVE PROPERTIES , LLC, A CALIFORNIA LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, VS LINDA DENNINGER, ET AL.
20VECV01140
Apr 20, 2021
Los Angeles County, CA
Real Property
Quiet Title
Here, the parties agree that the Easement Agreement expressly granted LPZ Owners an easement over PCMA’s Private Streets (“the Easement”).
ZENDA ESTATE, LLC VS APRIL FRANCESCA SANDERS ET AL
CVPS2407985
Jan 06, 2026
Riverside County, CA
The District alleges that it previously granted a company, PacTel Mobile Access, an easement over a portion of the School grounds to construct and maintain facilities related to mobile cellular communications. The easement was recorded on April 11, 1989, and the District is informed and believes that after assignments, transfers or otherwise defendant Los Angeles SMSA Limited Partnership dba Verizon Wireless (“Verizon”) is the current entity having the rights under the easement to use the easement area.
VALLE LINDO SCHOOL DISTRICT VS LOS ANGELES SMSA LIMITED
18GDCV00110
May 31, 2019
Los Angeles County, CA
Real Property
Quiet Title
Despite plaintiffs easement over the property, they do not allege sufficient facts to show they have a possessory interest in the property. The exclusivity of an easement is not so much a binary attribute either an easement is exclusive or it is not as a matter of degree. [Citation.] Exclusivity in this context includes two aspects: who may be excluded and the uses or area from which they may be excluded. [Citation.]
SIMA ASHRAFI, ET AL. VS SANDRA MARIANA VIDAL
22STCV30058
Dec 13, 2024
Los Angeles County, CA
Smiths demurrer does not argue Meehan fails to allege the basic elements for prescriptive easement. Smith contends this cause of action fails because Meehan seeks an exclusive easement by prescription. The law generally prohibit[s] the acquisition of an easement by prescription where the easement would deprive the property owner of all or most practical uses of the easement area. ( Romero v. Shih (2024) 15 Cal.5th 680, 696.)
JACOB DAVID SMITH VS CHANCIE ELIZABETH ANN MEEHAN
23STCV30780
Nov 07, 2024
Los Angeles County, CA
entryway to allow Plaintiffs free access to the Easement Area.
RICCIOTTI VS. AGUILAR
30-2020-01176092
Feb 04, 2021
Orange County, CA
Those causes of action are: (1) quiet title re deeded easement; (2) quiet title re equitable easement; (3) unreasonable interference with easement; and (4) tortious interference with business relationship. This case relates to the parties’ dispute over an access and utility easement over defendants’ parcel appurtenant to plaintiffs’ two parcels on 30th Avenue in Live Oak (“parcels 56 and 57”).
PLANET56, LLC, ET AL VS KEVIN O'DONOUGHE, ET AL
24CV01796
Oct 20, 2024
Santa Cruz County, CA
Those causes of action are: (1) quiet title re deeded easement; (2) quiet title re equitable easement; (3) unreasonable interference with easement; and (4) tortious interference with business relationship. This case relates to the parties’ dispute over an access and utility easement over defendants’ parcel appurtenant to plaintiffs’ two parcels on 30th Avenue in Live Oak (“parcels 56 and 57”).
PLANET56, LLC, ET AL VS KEVIN O'DONOUGHE, ET AL
24CV01796
Oct 21, 2024
Santa Cruz County, CA
Those causes of action are: (1) quiet title re deeded easement; (2) quiet title re equitable easement; (3) unreasonable interference with easement; and (4) tortious interference with business relationship. This case relates to the parties’ dispute over an access and utility easement over defendants’ parcel appurtenant to plaintiffs’ two parcels on 30th Avenue in Live Oak (“parcels 56 and 57”).
PLANET56, LLC, ET AL VS KEVIN O'DONOUGHE, ET AL
24CV01796
Oct 22, 2024
Santa Cruz County, CA
Those causes of action are: (1) quiet title re deeded easement; (2) quiet title re equitable easement; (3) unreasonable interference with easement; and (4) tortious interference with business relationship. This case relates to the parties’ dispute over an access and utility easement over defendants’ parcel appurtenant to plaintiffs’ two parcels on 30th Avenue in Live Oak (“parcels 56 and 57”).
PLANET56, LLC, ET AL VS KEVIN O'DONOUGHE, ET AL
24CV01796
Oct 23, 2024
Santa Cruz County, CA
Those causes of action are: (1) quiet title re deeded easement; (2) quiet title re equitable easement; (3) unreasonable interference with easement; and (4) tortious interference with business relationship. This case relates to the parties’ dispute over an access and utility easement over defendants’ parcel appurtenant to plaintiffs’ two parcels on 30th Avenue in Live Oak (“parcels 56 and 57”).
PLANET56, LLC, ET AL VS KEVIN O'DONOUGHE, ET AL
24CV01796
Oct 25, 2024
Santa Cruz County, CA
Those causes of action are: (1) quiet title re deeded easement; (2) quiet title re equitable easement; (3) unreasonable interference with easement; and (4) tortious interference with business relationship. This case relates to the parties’ dispute over an access and utility easement over defendants’ parcel appurtenant to plaintiffs’ two parcels on 30th Avenue in Live Oak (“parcels 56 and 57”).
PLANET56, LLC, ET AL VS KEVIN O'DONOUGHE, ET AL
24CV01796
Oct 24, 2024
Santa Cruz County, CA
The community driveway easement is seen to add a third party to the agreement the City of LA. The LADBS form shows that the City of LA obtains rights in determining whether the easement can continue to exist. The easement thus turns the current two-party easement into a three-party easement.
MAHTAB GHARACHEHDAGY VS IRINA GRINBLAT, AS AN INDIVIDUAL AND AS TRUSTEE FOR THE IRINA GRINBLAT TRUST
23VECV02577
Apr 24, 2024
Los Angeles County, CA
The Third Amended Complaint still fails to allege a definite oral easement or interference with particular rights. A grant of an oral easement may overcome the statute of frauds if formed by an executed oral agreement.
BEDFORD VS CPF BDA, LLC, A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
CVPS2201699
Aug 31, 2023
Riverside County, CA
The Habibi parcel is burdened by a 20-foot wide easement for access in favor of the Soofer parcel and the Burney Trust parcel is burdened by a 30-foot wide easement for access in favor of the Habibi and Soofer parcels. For over forty years, use of the 20-foot easement area and the 30-foot easement area was limited to an approximately twelve-and-one-half foot wide paved driveway.
JOANNE HABIBI ET AL VS RAMIN SOOFER ET AL
1383317
Apr 19, 2012
Santa Barbara County, CA
The court explained the difference between a stairway easement and a normal easement: “An easement, in the true sense of the word, is an interest in real estate, and survives the destruction of a part of the servient tenement when there is anything remaining upon which the easement may operate.
GREG HART VS THOMAS MILWAY
MSC19-00771
Aug 16, 2023
Contra Costa County, CA
Defendant Sebring’s reply also argues that he has a right to fully improve a driveway easement and the legal standard is not necessity. He further argues in the reply that because every other property owner has allowed the Diablo Trail road easement to be paved, the easement granted over plaintiff’s land must necessarily have granted the use of the easement by means of a paved road and, therefore, a paved easement can not be a trespass.
BERNSTEIN V. SEBRING
PC-20140070
Jul 28, 2017
El Dorado County, CA
The Demurrer relates to Plaintiff Gary Lane and Raelene Lane’s Complaint for (1) easement by necessity; (2) equitable easement; (3) quiet title; (4) prescriptive easement; (5) quiet title; and (6) preliminary and permanent injunction.
GARY LANE VS. JACOB SOLOMON
C23-01582
Nov 09, 2023
Contra Costa County, CA
"Access Easement"); 2.
7903 BALBOA LLC VS 7868 BALBOA ENTERPRISES LLC
37-2018-00058777-CU-OR-CTL
Jan 24, 2019
San Diego County, CA
Real Property
other
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.