1. Home
  2. State Courts
  3. Massachusetts
  4. Essex County Superior Courts
  5. Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al
SEARCH TIPS
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators
Date
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators

Contents

Details Parties Documents Case Events

We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Case Last Refreshed: 6 months ago

Track Case Changes
Download Docket Print Docket

Mazzola, Philip J, filed a(n) Equitable Remedies case represented by Flannagan, Esq., Thomas J, Sheehan, Iii, Esq., William H, against O'Brien, Bonita J, O'Brien, John F, represented by Fine, Esq., Meredith, in the jurisdiction of Essex County, MA, . Essex County, MA Superior Courts with David A. Deakin presiding.

Case Details for Mazzola, Philip J v. O'Brien, Bonita J , et al.

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)

Judge

David A. Deakin

pdf Get Judge Analytics Report

Filing Date

October 17, 2016

Category

Equitable Remedies

Last Refreshed

December 09, 2023

Filing Location

Essex County, MA

Parties for Mazzola, Philip J v. O'Brien, Bonita J , et al.

Plaintiffs

Mazzola, Philip J

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Flannagan, Esq., Thomas J

Sheehan, Iii, Esq., William H

Defendants

O'Brien, Bonita J

O'Brien, John F

Attorneys for Defendants

Fine, Esq., Meredith

Case Documents for Mazzola, Philip J v. O'Brien, Bonita J , et al.

for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Appeal entered in Appeals Court on 08/11/2020 docket number 2020-P-0899

Date: August 11, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Certificate of service of attorney or Pro Se: Alex Harrington, Esq.

Date: October 12, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Witness list Applies To: Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust (Plaintiff); O'Brien, John F (Defendant); O'Brien, Bonita J (Defendant)

Date: February 25, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Certificate of service of attorney or Pro Se: Meredith Fine, Esq.

Date: June 22, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Waiver of jury claim filed by party Applies To: Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust (Plaintiff); O'Brien, John F (Defendant); O'Brien, Bonita J (Defendant)

Date: January 23, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Rescript received from Appeals Court; judgment AFFIRMED ((Milkey, Hand, & Grant, J.J.) (dated October 15, 2021).

Date: November 15, 2021
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

JUDGMENT/ORDER after Rescript: The original judgment (#67.0) is Affirmed. (Milkey, Hand & Grant, J.J.) (dated: October 15, 2021)

Date: November 15, 2021
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Notice of assembly of record sent to Counsel

Date: July 29, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Party(s) file Stipulation Plaintiff Philip J. Mazzola, Trustee of the Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust ("Plaintiff") and Defendants John F. O'Brien and Bonita J. O'Brien (O'Briens" or "Defendants"), by and through their counsel, hereby stipulate to the following: The O'Briens do not have a document from the Plaintiff or his predecessors specifically conveying written permission to drive ATV's on the Plaintiff's property; provided however, that the Defendants contend that the easement conveys that permission. The parties dispute whether the easement itself constitutes written permission for such use. 7/10/2020) Applies To: O'Brien, John F (Defendant); O'Brien, Bonita J (Defendant); Flannagan, Esq., Thomas J (Attorney) on behalf of Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust (Plaintiff)

Date: July 20, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Certification/Copy of Letter of transcript ordered from Court Reporter 01/08/2020 02:00 PM Final Trial Conference, 01/23/2020 09:00 AM Jury Waived Trial, 01/24/2020 09:00 AM Jury Waived Trial, 01/27/2020 09:00 AM Jury Waived Trial, 01/28/2020 09:00 AM Jury Waived Trial (3/18/2020)

Date: March 19, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Notice of appeal filed. Applies To: Flannagan, Esq., Thomas J (Attorney) on behalf of Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust (Plaintiff) (3/12/2020)

Date: March 19, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Request for findings and fact and conclusions of law. filed 2/21/20

Date: February 24, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Request for Jury instructions filed by Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust

Date: January 22, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Request for Jury instructions filed by Defendants John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien

Date: January 21, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Motion in limine to Preclude Defendants From Offering Evidence Or Questioning Witnesses About Plaintiff's Dismissed Divorce Action (filed 1/3/2020)

Date: January 06, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Defendants John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien's Submission of proposed rulings of law

Date: January 21, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

PROPOSED Juror Voir Dire questions filed by: Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust (filed 1/3/2020)

Date: January 06, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Defendants John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien's Motion in Limine To Preclude The Use of Video Evidence.

Date: January 06, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

List of exhibits (VIDEO EXHIBITS)

Date: February 18, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

other document, returned SERVED Return of Service for Witness Subpoena for Roberta Mazzola. Served at the last and usual place of abode at 383 Russell Street Carlisle, MA 01741. filed 2/4/20 Applies To: Fine, Esq., Meredith (Attorney) on behalf of O'Brien, Bonita J (Defendant)

Date: February 06, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Findings of Fact and Rulings of Law: For the foregoing reasons, the court concludes that the O'Briens' operation of ATV's over the right of way constitutes neither an overburdening of the easement nor a nuisance, as that term is defined in the law. The court therefore orders that judgment enter for the defendants and that the injunction imposed in this case by this court (Feeley, J.) in 2017 be vacated. Dated: 2/21/2020 Judge: Deakin, Hon. David A Findings Of Fact, Rulings of Law, and Order for Judgment

Date: February 24, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Defendants John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien files proposed Findings of Fact Applies To: O'Brien, John F (Defendant); O'Brien, Bonita J (Defendant)

Date: February 18, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

List of exhibits

Date: January 28, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Defendants John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien files proposed Rulings of Law Applies To: O'Brien, John F (Defendant); O'Brien, Bonita J (Defendant)

Date: February 18, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

other document, returned SERVED Return of Service for Witness Subpoena for Samuel J. Nigro. Served in hand 1/14/20 at 3:01 PM at 8 Fisherman Way Gloucester, MA 01930. filed 2/4/20 Applies To: Fine, Esq., Meredith (Attorney) on behalf of O'Brien, Bonita J (Defendant)

Date: February 06, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

other document, returned SERVED Return of Service for Witness Subpoena for Donna Bruno. Served in hand 1/15/2020 at 12:40 PM at 109 Chestnut Street Lynnfield, MA 01940. filed 2/4/20 Applies To: Fine, Esq., Meredith (Attorney) on behalf of O'Brien, John F (Defendant)

Date: February 06, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Motion for Required Finding on Liability on Counts I and II

Date: January 28, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Defendants John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien's Request for A Directed Verdict

Date: January 28, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Motion in limine for Judicial Notice Of Mass.Gen.Laws C.90B, SS21 To 35, And 323 CMR SS3.01, 3.02, 3.03 And 3.10 (filed 1/3/2020)

Date: January 06, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Summons, returned SERVED Return of Trial Summons for Officer Ryan Lennon, Massachusetts Department of Environmental Police (filed in court 1/24/20) Applies To: Fine, Esq., Meredith (Attorney) on behalf of O'Brien, John F (Defendant)

Date: January 27, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Summons, returned SERVED Return of Trial Summons for Daniel J. Buoniconti, Esq., Keeper of Records, Wingaersheek Improvement Association (filed in court 1/24/20) Applies To: Fine, Esq., Meredith (Attorney) on behalf of O'Brien, John F (Defendant)

Date: January 27, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

ORDER: In construing the scope of the easement, the court holds that the easement in question does not prohibit the reasonable use of motorized vehicles to get to and from Wingaersheek Beach "for bathing, beaching and mooring of boats and for all other purposes for which a beach is used."

Date: January 27, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Juror Voir Dire questions filed by: Defendant John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien Request For Voir Dire Question (filed 1/3/2020)

Date: January 03, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Summons, returned SERVED Return of Trial Summons for Kenneth Whittaker (filed in court 1/24/20) Applies To: Fine, Esq., Meredith (Attorney) on behalf of O'Brien, John F (Defendant)

Date: January 27, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Joint Pre-Trial Memorandum filed:

Date: September 16, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Submission of proposed rulings of law

Date: January 22, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Motion in limine to Preclude Defendants From Offering Evidence Of Any Purported Gloucester District Court Decision Or Judgment Regarding Easement Rights (filed 1/3/2020)

Date: January 06, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Motion in limine to Preclude Defendants From Attempting To Impeach The Credibility Of Witnesses With Evidence Of Prior Bad Acts (filed 1/3/2020)

Date: January 06, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Received from Defendant O'Brien, Bonita J: Answer with claim for trial by jury;

Date: June 22, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Notice to Clerk of the Appeals Court of Assembly of Record

Date: July 29, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Appeal: Statement of the Case on Appeal (Cover Sheet).

Date: July 29, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Appeal: Party's Letter received re: no transcript on appeal Applies To: Flannagan, Esq., Thomas J (Attorney) on behalf of Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust (Plaintiff)

Date: July 20, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

JUDGMENT for Defendant(s), John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien after trial without jury, the complaint of the Plaintiff(s), Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust is dismissed on the merits and the defendant(s) will recover statutory costs.

Date: February 24, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion for a Preliminary Injunction (#13.0): ALLOWED Upon payment of $90.00. See Order issued this date. Judge: Feeley, Hon. Timothy Q

Date: October 17, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

MEMORANDUM & ORDER: Judge: Feeley, Hon. Timothy Q Judge: Feeley, Hon. Timothy Q Memorandum And Order On Plaintiff's Motion For Preliminary Injunction. ORDER FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION. Upon payment of the appropriate fee, defendants John F. O'Brien and Bonita J. O'Brien, their tenants, lessees, lawful invitees, and guests, including but not limited to son John O'Brien and daughter Wendy O'Brien, and all person in active participation with them who receive actual notice of this Preliminary Injunction, are hereby prohibited and enjoined from using, idling, and parking ATV's, and any other motor vehicles, at, across, on and over any portion of the Mazzola property at 17 Wingaersheek Road, Gloucester, Massachusetts, including by not limited to, that portion of the property burdened by a nominal fifteen (15') foot easement along the northwest boundary of the property from Wingaersheek Road to Coffins Beach. Timothy Q Feeley, Associate Justice of the Superior Court. October 17, 2017 Judge: Feeley, Hon. Timothy Q

Date: October 17, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion to Strike Defendants' Sur-Reply (#15.0): ALLOWED Allowed without prejudice to oral argument Judge: Feeley, Hon. Timothy Q

Date: October 13, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Affidavit of Paul Bruno Applies To: Fine, Esq., Meredith (Attorney) on behalf of O'Brien, John F (Defendant)

Date: September 28, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Affidavit of Philip J Mazzola Applies To: Fine, Esq., Meredith (Attorney) on behalf of O'Brien, John F (Defendant)

Date: September 28, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Opposition to to Motion for a Preliminary Injunction filed by John F O'Brien Applies To: Fine, Esq., Meredith (Attorney) on behalf of O'Brien, John F (Defendant)

Date: September 28, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Affidavit of Philip J Mazzola

Date: September 28, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Alex Harrington, Esq.Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Memorandum in support of Motion for a Preliminary Injunction

Date: September 28, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff(s) Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Motion for a Preliminary Injunction

Date: September 28, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion to EXTEND DISCOVERY DEADLINE AND OTHER TRACKING ORDER DEADLINES. (#12.0): ALLOWED 8/9/17 ALLOWED. TRACKING ORDER DEADLINES SHALL BE EXTENDED 60 DAYS.

Date: August 09, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Joint Motion to extend discovery deadline and other tracking order deadlines

Date: August 03, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Meredith Fine, Esq.'s Reply Memorandum in support of Motion for a Preliminary Injunction Applies To: Fine, Esq., Meredith (Attorney) on behalf of O'Brien, John F (Defendant)

Date: September 28, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Service Returned for Defendant O'Brien, John F: Service made at last and usual;

Date: November 18, 2016
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

ORDER: For the foregoing reasons, the O'Brien's Motion to dismiss the complaint is DENIED

Date: June 07, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion to postpone hearing (#7.0): ALLOWED clerk shall set a new hearing date for the motion to dismiss

Date: February 08, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

John F O'Brien's Memorandum in support of of law to motion to dismiss

Date: December 23, 2016
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Opposition to to defendants filed by Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust

Date: December 23, 2016
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Defendant(s) John F O'Brien's Motion to Dismiss

Date: December 23, 2016
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Original civil complaint filed. EXHIBITS ON FILE

Date: October 17, 2016
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Service Returned for 10/28/16 Defendant O'Brien, Bonita J: Service made at last and usual; 8 Sand sdollar Circle, Gloucester Ma

Date: November 18, 2016
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Exhibits returned per Order of the Clerk A Exhibit Receipt was generated and sent to: Plaintiff, Attorney: Thomas J Flannagan, Esq. MacLean Holloway Doherty & Sheehan, PC 8 Essex Center Drive, Peabody, MA 01960

Date: August 13, 2020
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion to Extend Discovery Deadline And other Tracking Order Deadlines (#22.0): ALLOWED Parties' joint Motion to extend discovery deadlines is ALLOWED. Judge: Howe, Hon. Janice W

Date: March 30, 2018
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Motion to Strike Defendant's Sur-Reply.

Date: October 12, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Defendants John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien's Joint Motion to Extend Discovery Deadlines. filed 5/16/18

Date: May 22, 2018
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion to continue Trial and Final Trial Conference, and Joint Motion To Schedule A Pre-Trial Conference. (#32.0): ALLOWED 7/3/19. ALLOWED. Judge: Feeley, Hon. Timothy Q

Date: July 05, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

ADR Report filed

Date: June 27, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff, Defendant Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust, John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien's Joint Stipulation, Motion to continue Trial And Final Trial Conference And Joint Motion To Schedule A pre-Trial Conference (filed via fax)

Date: July 03, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion to convert pre-trial conference to status conference (#27.0): ALLOWED the parties should expect that a FPTC and a trial date will be set. (4/23/19)

Date: April 24, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

ADR Referral issued. parties would like to participate in the conciliation program

Date: May 20, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

ADR Referral issued. Applies To: Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust (Plaintiff); O'Brien, John F (Defendant); O'Brien, Bonita J (Defendant)

Date: May 03, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Thomas J Flannagan, Esq., Meredith Fine, Esq.'s Memorandum Parties Conciliation Memorandum

Date: June 27, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Defendant(s) John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien's Motion for Protective Order. filed 2/11/19

Date: February 12, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion for A protective Order (#26.0): DENIED 2/14/19. DENIED - this case is 2 years old and should not be delayed further for depositions of persons other than Mr. O'Brien. Judge: Feeley, Hon. Timothy Q

Date: February 15, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Opposition to to Defendant's Motion for a Protective Order filed by Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust

Date: February 12, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff, Defendant Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust, John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien's Joint Motion to convert pre-trial conference to status conference (4/23/19)

Date: April 24, 2019
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff, Defendant Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust, John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien's Joint Motion to Extend Discovery Deadline And Other Tracking Order Deadlines

Date: December 14, 2018
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion of Extend Discovery Deadline and other Tracking Order Deadlines (#25.0): ALLOWED discovery extended to 3/31/19 Judge: Feeley, Hon. Timothy Q

Date: December 18, 2018
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion to extend discovery deadlines (#24.0): ALLOWED Allowed with assent. Judge: Drechsler, Hon. Thomas

Date: August 16, 2018
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff, Defendants Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust, John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien's Joint Motion to Extend Discovery Deadline and Other Tracking Order Deadlines filed 3/19/18

Date: March 22, 2018
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Certificate of service of attorney or Pro Se: Alex Harrington, Esq. filed 2/15/18

Date: February 20, 2018
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion to Extend Discovery Deadline And Other Tracking Order Deadlines. (#21.0): ALLOWED The parties joint motion to extend discovery deadline and other tracking order deadlines is ALLOWED. Judge: Howe, Hon. Janice W

Date: February 21, 2018
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Endorsement on Motion to Extend Discovery Deadlines (#23.0): ALLOWED Defendants' Assented-to motion to extend discovery deadline is Allowed. Judge: Howe, Hon. Janice W

Date: May 24, 2018
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Certificate of service of attorney or Pro Se: William H Sheehan, III, Esq.Bonita J O'Brien Affidavit of Service for 10/18/17 in hand service and by leaving a copy at 8 Sand Dollar Circle, Gloucester, MA 01930 for Preliminary Injunction Memorandum and on Plaintiff's Motion for Preliminary Injunction Applies To: O'Brien, Bonita J (Defendant)

Date: October 26, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff, Defendants Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust, John F O'Brien, Bonita J O'Brien's Joint Motion to Extend Discovery Deadline And Other Tracking Order Deadlines. filed 2/15/18

Date: February 20, 2018
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Plaintiff Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust's Joint Motion to extend discovery deadline and other tracking order deadlines

Date: October 25, 2017
for Philip J Mazzola Trustee Of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust Vs. O'Brien, John F Et Al

Certificate of service of attorney or Pro Se: William H Sheehan, III, Esq.John F O'Brien Affidavit of Service for 10/18/17 in hand service and by leaving a copy at 8 Sand Dollar Circle, Gloucester, MA 01930 for Preliminary Injunction Memorandum and on Plaintiff's Motion for Preliminary Injunction Applies To: O'Brien, John F (Defendant)

Date: October 26, 2017

Case Events for Mazzola, Philip J v. O'Brien, Bonita J , et al.

Date Type Description
November 15, 2021 Docket Event Rescript received from Appeals Court; judgment AFFIRMED ((Milkey, Hand, & Grant, J.J.) (dated October 15, 2021).
View Document
November 15, 2021 Docket Event JUDGMENT/ORDER after Rescript: The original judgment (#67.0) is Affirmed. (Milkey, Hand & Grant, J.J.) (dated: October 15, 2021)
View Document
August 13, 2020 Docket Event Exhibits returned per Order of the Clerk A Exhibit Receipt was generated and sent to: Plaintiff, Attorney: Thomas J Flannagan, Esq. MacLean Holloway Doherty & Sheehan, PC 8 Essex Center Drive, Peabody, MA 01960
View Document
August 13, 2020 Docket Event Exhibits Returned
August 11, 2020 Docket Event Appeal entered in Appeals Court on 08/11/2020 docket number 2020-P-0899
View Document
July 29, 2020 Docket Event Notice of assembly of record sent to Counsel
View Document
July 29, 2020 Docket Event Notice to Clerk of the Appeals Court of Assembly of Record
View Document
July 29, 2020 Docket Event Appeal: Statement of the Case on Appeal (Cover Sheet).
View Document
July 20, 2020 Docket Event Party(s) file Stipulation Plaintiff Philip J. Mazzola, Trustee of the Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust ("Plaintiff") and Defendants John F. O'Brien and Bonita J. O'Brien (O'Briens" or "Defendants"), by and through their counsel, hereby stipulate to the following: The O'Briens do not have a document from the Plaintiff or his predecessors specifically conveying written permission to drive ATV's on the Plaintiff's property; provided however, that the Defendants contend that the easement conveys that permission. The parties dispute whether the easement itself constitutes written permission for such use. 7/10/2020) Applies To: O'Brien, John F (Defendant); O'Brien, Bonita J (Defendant); Flannagan, Esq., Thomas J (Attorney) on behalf of Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust (Plaintiff)
View Document
July 20, 2020 Docket Event Appeal: Party's Letter received re: no transcript on appeal Applies To: Flannagan, Esq., Thomas J (Attorney) on behalf of Philip J Mazzola Trustee of The Seventeen Wingaersheek Realty Trust (Plaintiff)
View Document
See all events
Request redaction

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.