Pacific Fertility Cases

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-19-574256. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-18-567717. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-18-565570. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

ORDER - STIPULATION AND ORDER TO CONTINUE HEARING ON EXTRON CO.'S MOTION TO QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONS FOR LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION (TRANSACTION ID #64366674)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC20-585212. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585213. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF APPLICATION TO AMEND COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574252) (TRANSACTION ID # 69118593) FILED BY PLAINTIFF R., J. R. (CGC-19-574252) R., J. (CGC-19-574252)

ORDER CONTINUING JANUARY 18, 2023 CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE (TRANSACTION 68917638)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-19-574293. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-18-570347. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STSATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 69646186) FILED BY PLAINTIFF PLAINTIFFS

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-570136) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF S., B. (CGC-18-570136) P., R. (CGC-18-570136) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 64608906) FILED BY PLAINTIFF LEVIN, RACHEL (CGC-18-565570) H., G. (CGC-18-566130) LUO, MICHELLE (CGC-18-567717) FLAHERTY, DANIEL (CGC-18-567717) J., I. (CGC-18-570347) L., K. (CGC-18-570347)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-21-589746. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565458) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF M., R. (CGC-18-565458) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

MINUTES FOR APR-03-2023 10:00 AM

ORDER AFTER CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE (TRANSACTION ID #69722829)

ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION TRIAL JUDGE (FROM PRESIDING JUDGE GARRETT L. WONG)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-578083) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF P., J. (CGC-19-578083) O., J. (CGC-19-578083) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLINT IN CGC-20-585210. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-570397) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF P., M. (CGC-18-570397) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574252) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF R., J. R. (CGC-19-574252) R., J. (CGC-19-574252) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585273. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574257) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF W., Q. (CGC-19-574257) O., X. (CGC-19-574257) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585216. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-19-574307. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

NOTICE OF ENTRY OF ORDER/NOTICE OF RULING FILED (TRANSACTION ID # 64573299) FILED BY DEFENDANT EXTRON CO.

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574256) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF M., L. (CGC-19-574256) O., N. (CGC-19-574256) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME AND EMAIL ADDRESSES (TRANSACTION ID # 64767747) FILED BY DEFENDANT PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC.

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-582302) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF A., D. (CGC-20-585302) J., Q. (CGC-20-585302) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574259) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., T. (CGC-19-574259) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

ORDER CONTINUING CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE (TRANSACTION ID #64621309)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585215. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-19-574290. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565122) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF L., T. (CGC-18-565122) N., S. (CGC-18-565122) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

ORDER CONTINUING MAY 28, 2020 CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE (TRANSACTION ID #64671409)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-19-574282. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-570347) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF J., I. (CGC-18-570347) L., K. (CGC-18-570347) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585277. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-567717) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF LUO, MICHELLE (CGC-18-567717) FLAHERTY, DANIEL (CGC-18-567717) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585241. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-19-574258. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574290) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF Q., Q. (CGC-19-574290) T., T. (CGC-19-574290) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-19-574295. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574295) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF WALSH, KELLY (CGC-19-574295) RIVERA, SYLVIA CGC-19-574295) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-19-574315. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

ORDER GRANTING EX PARTE APPLICATION TO AMEND PLAINTIFFS J.R.R. AND J.R. SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID #69171193)

ORDER - STIPULATION AND ORDER REGARDING NOTICE AND PETITION TO COORDINATE ADD-ON CASES AND ADOPTION OF MASTER COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 64780130)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-570145) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF L., H. A. (CGC-18-570145) W., K. (CGC-18-570145) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585270. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

ORDER & STIPULATION TO DISMISS EXTRON CO. WITHOUT PREJUDICE AND TAKING EXTRON CO.'S MOTION TO QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONS FOR LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION OFF CALENDAR (TRANSACTION ID #64565602)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565616) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF F., S. (CGC-18-565616) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

** REDACTED ** MEMORANDUM OF POINTS & AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66887486) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE

ORDER AFTER REVIEW OF JULY 20-21, 2022 CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENTS (TRANSACTION ID # 67851706)

SUPPLEMENTAL CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (CGC-19-572788) (TRANSACTION ID # 67846980) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) H., D. (CGC-19-572788)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-570397. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574385) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 65955442) FILED BY PLAINTIFF CHRIST, ALEXANDRA (SF CASE NO. CGC-19-574385) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DECLARATION OF JULIE Y. PARK IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66887486) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE

MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66887486) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE

** REDACTED *** DECLARATION OF ERIN M. BOSMAN IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66887486) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE

AMENDED PROOF OF SERVICE (TRANSACTION ID # 65935727) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) H., D. (CGC-19-572788)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574223) (TRANSACTION ID # 67862125) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574223) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66034934) FILED BY PLAINTIFF S., B. B. (CGC-19-574223) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

PROOF OF SERVICE (CGC-19-574223) (TRANSACTION ID # 67862125) FILED BY PLAINTIFF S., B. B. (CGC-19-574223)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-570136. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-566130) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66046044) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., G. (CGC-18-566130) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-573610. (TRANSACTION ID # 69918249)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574282) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66046044) FILED BY PLAINTIFF R., Q. (CGC-19-574282) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

PROOF OF SERVICE (CGC-18-567247) (TRANSACTION ID # 67862164) FILED BY PLAINTIFF M., AMANDA (CGC-18-567247) S., LUCAS (CGC-18-567247)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-568436) (TRANSACTION ID # 67937005) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19574410) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66046044) FILED BY PLAINTIFF B., B. (CGC-19-574410) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-574314. (TRANSACTION ID # 69949959)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574258) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66046044) FILED BY PLAINTIFF T., S. (CGC-19-574258) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-574257. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

PROOF OF SERVICE (TRANSACTION ID # 67938231) FILED BY OTHER PLAINTIFFS' LIAISON COUNSEL

PROOF OF SERVICE BY ELECTRONIC MAIL OF REQUEST OF DISMISSALS (TRANSACTION ID # 67937675) FILED BY PLAINTIFF LEVIN, RACHEL (CGC-18-565570) H., G. (CGC-18-566130) A., A. (CGC-18-566820) J., I. (CGC-18-570347) L., K. (CGC-18-570347) H., H. (CGC-19-572788) R., Q. (CGC-19-574282) T., S. (CGC-19-574258) B., B. (CGC-19-574410) Q., P. (CGC-19-574307) AHLHEIM, KIMBERLY (SF CASE NO. CGC-20-585213) Z., A. (SF CASE NO. CGC-20-585214) A., D. (CGC-20-585302) J., Q. (CGC-20-585302) Q., Q. (CGC-19-574290) T., T. (CGC-19-574290) WALSH, KELLY (CGC-19-574295) Y., Y. (CGC-19-574315) Z., Z. (CGC-19-574315) C., C. (CGC-20-585212) D., D. (CGC-20-585212) E., E. (CGC-20-585210) G., F. (CGC-20-585210) F., F. (CGC-20-585273) G., G. (CGC-20-585273) I., I. (CGC-20-585270) J., J. (CGC-20-585268) K., K. (CGC-20-585268) P., O. (CGC-20-585218) C., B. (CGC-20-585218) J., R. (CGC-20-585241) D., B. (CGC-20-585241) R., R. (CGC-20-585211) S., S. (CGC-20-585211) ROSENBAUM, AMY (CGC-20-585277)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ONLY. (CGC-18-567247) (TRANSACTION ID # 69912369) AS TO DEFENDANT CHART INDUSTRIES, INC., A CORPORATION

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-574216. (TRANSACTION ID # 69949959)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585213) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-573610. (TRANSACTION ID # 69931566)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE (CGC) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574223) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565570) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66046044) FILED BY PLAINTIFF LEVIN, RACHEL (CGC-18-565570) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-585214) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574307) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66046044) FILED BY PLAINTIFF Q., P. (CGC-19-574307) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-574312. (TRANSACTION ID # 69949959)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565215) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574293) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585213) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66061205) FILED BY PLAINTIFF AHLHEIM, KIMBERLY (SF CASE NO. CGC-20-585213) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585214) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66061205) FILED BY PLAINTIFF Z., A. (SF CASE NO. CGC-20-585214) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-565215. (TRANSACTION ID # 69949959)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-20-585214. (TRANSACTION ID # 69953225)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585215) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66061205) FILED BY PLAINTIFF N., N. (SF CASE NO. CGC-20-585215) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574216) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565882) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574336) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66137874) FILED BY PLAINTIFF G., K. (CGC-19-574336) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED, INCLUSIVE PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ALL DEFENDANTS IN CGC-19-574385. (TRANSACTION ID # 69957636)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-567247) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66132794) FILED BY PLAINTIFF M., AMANDA (CGC-18-567247) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

PROOF OF SERVICE (TRANSACTION ID # 66887486) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574260) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF L., I. (CGC-19-574260) L., E. (CGC-19-574260) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

REMITTITUR AFFIRMED A158155 DIV 1

ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE

EX PARTE APPLICATION FOR ORDER TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT, PROOF OF SERVICE (CGC-19-574252) (TRANSACTION ID # 69118593) FILED BY PLAINTIFF R., J. R. (CGC-19-574252) R., J. (CGC-19-574252)

DECLARATION OF DORIS CHENG IN SUPPORT OF EX PARTE APPLICATION TO AMEND COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574252) (TRANSACTION ID # 69118593) FILED BY PLAINTIFF R., J. R. (CGC-19-574252) R., J. (CGC-19-574252)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574251) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF M., A. (CGC-19-574251) M., K. (CGC-19-574251) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 69648575) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) H., D. (CGC-19-572788)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-569718) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF L., B. (CGC-18-569718) A., S. (CGC-18-569718) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-570019) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF L., C. (CGC-18-570019) C., M. (CGC-18-570019) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-567042) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF F., C. (CGC-18-567042) F., J. (CGC-18-567042) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

ORDER GRANTING PETITION FOR COORDINATION; DENYING REQUEST FOR STAY IN PART; AND RECOMMENDING SAN FRANCISCO SUPERIOR COURT AS THE SITE FOR THE COORDINATED PROCEEDINGS.

ORDER LIFTING STAY

ORDER ADVANCING CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE AND MOTION TO QUASH (TRANSACTION ID #64522805)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-19-574410. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION TRIAL JUDGE (FROM CHIEF JUSTICE OF CALIFORNIA AND CHAIR OF THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL)

ORDER - STIPULATION AND ORDER TO CONTINUE HEARING ON EXTRON CO.'S MOTION TO QUASH SERVICE OF SUMMONS FOR LACK OF PERSONAL JURISDICTION (TRANSACTION ID # 64431999)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-18-566130. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585218. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585268. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

AMENDMENT TO SHORT FORM COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (CGC-19-574252) PER FEB-09-23 ORDER (TRANSACTION ID # 69640240) FILED BY PLAINTIFF R., J. R. (CGC-19-574252) R., J. (CGC-19-574252)

DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585302. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-569870) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF F., B. (CGC-18-569870) R., J. (CGC-18-569870) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

ORDER - GENERAL ORDER RE COORDINATION PROCEEDING REASSIGNMENT; AUTHORIZATION TO REASSIGN CASES AND PROCEEDINGS (TRANSACTION ID #64478905)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574254) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF T., M. (CGC-19-574254) T., G. (CGC-19-574254) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

ORDER ASSIGNING COORDINATION MOTION JUDGE AND SETTING HEARING

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565459) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF DOE, JANE (CGC-18-565459) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-566820) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF P., S. (CGC-18-566820) A., A. (CGC-18-566820) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585304. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574251) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

PROOF OF SERVICE BY ELECTRONIC MAIL (CGC-19-574385) (TRANSACTION ID # 69957636) FILED BY PLAINTIFF C., A. (CGC-18-565215)

NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS OR OTHER CONTACT INFORMATION (TRANSACTION ID # 66920652) FILED BY ATTORNEY COWDEN, MARC G

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574312) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66147021) FILED BY PLAINTIFF R., E. (CGC-19-574312) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED, INCLUSIVE PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 69976523) (TRANSACTION ID # 69976523) FILED BY PLAINTIFF PLAINTIFFS AS TO DEFENDANT PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC.

DECLARATION / CLRA VENUE DECLARATION PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA CODE SECTION 1780(D) (CGC-19-574312) (TRANSACTION ID # 66147021) FILED BY PLAINTIFF R., E. (CGC-19-574312)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574410) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

MOTION / NOTICE OF MOTION & MOTION TO REMAND ACTION FOR FURTHER PRETRIAL PROCEEDINGS AND TRIAL (CGC-19-572788) (TRANSACTION ID # 70200345) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) H., D. (CGC-19-572788) HEARING SET FOR JUL-12-2023 AT 02:00 PM IN DEPT 613

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-569870) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-569718) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574216) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66147021) FILED BY PLAINTIFF J., A. (CGC-19-574216) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED, INCLUSIVE PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-570136) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66923524) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215) HEARING SET FOR SEP-23-2021 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPT 613

OPPOSITION TO SETTLING DEFENDANTS? MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT-REDACTED VERSION (TRANSACTION ID # 66923524) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

DECLARATION / CLRA VENUE DECLARATION PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA CODE SECTION 1780(D) (CGC-19-574216) (TRANSACTION ID # 66147021) FILED BY PLAINTIFF J., A. (CGC-19-574216)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-567042) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO REMAND ACTION FOR FURTHER PRETRIAL PROCEEDINGS AND TRIAL (CGC-19-572788) (TRANSACTION ID # 70200345) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) H., D. (CGC-19-572788)

DECLARATION OF JOHN J. DUFFY IN SUPPORT OF CHART INC.?S OPPOSITION TO SETTLING DEFENDANTS? MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66923524) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585212) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565215) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66147021) FILED BY PLAINTIFF C., A. (CGC-18-565215) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED, INCLUSIVE PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

ORDER GRANTING APPLICATION TO APPEAR AS COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE FOR ATTORNEY KEVIN RINGEL (TRANSACTION ID # 66968274) FILED BY COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-570145) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

ORDER TERMINATING JCCP (TRANSACTION ID #70797916)

SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF ERIN M. BOSMAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS PACIFIC MSL, LLC, PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC., PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER, JOSEPH CONAGHAN AND PFC PHYSICIANS REPLY BRIEF TO MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66971730) FILED BY DEFENDANT PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC.

DECLARATION OF KAT STILLMAN IN SUPPORT OF RENEWED MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66991738) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585268) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-567717) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585215) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-578083) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-21-589746) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574252) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

ORDER DENYING WITHOUT PREJUDICE THE SETTLING DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO SEAL (1) PORTIONS OF THE MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES ISO MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT; (2) PORTIONS OF THE ERIN M. BOSMAN DECLARATION; AND (3) THE ENTIRE MASTER SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66976858)

PROOF OF SERVICE (TRANSACTION ID # 66971730) FILED BY DEFENDANT PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC.

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585216) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-574256) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565570) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

MOTION / NOTICE OF MOTION & RENEWED MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66991738) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE HEARING SET FOR NOV-19-2021 AT 09:00 AM IN DEPT 613

DECLARATION OF JULIE Y. PARK IN SUPPORT OF RENEWED MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66991738) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE

MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF RENEWED MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66991738) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574254) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

PROOF OF SERVICE (TRANSACTION ID # 66991738) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574307) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574290) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF UNOPPOSED MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF SEPTEMBER 23, 2021 HEARING TRANSCRIPT (TRANSACTION ID # 67018167) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-570397) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-585304) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

MOTION / NOTICE OF MOTION & UNOPPOSED MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF SEPTEMBER 23, 2021 HEARING TRANSCRIPT (TRANSACTION ID # 67018167) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH HEARING SET FOR NOV-19-2021 AT 09:00 AM IN DEPT 613

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585218) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

PROOF OF SERVICE (TRANSACTION ID # 67018167) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574282) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574257) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 67082358) FILED BY PLAINTIFF PLAINTIFFS

ORDER AFTER REVIEW OF JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID #67085735)

ORDER GRANTING RENEWED MOTION TO SEAL PORTIONS OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID #67113406)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585241) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585211) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585277) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565458) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574336) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS PACIFIC MSO, LLC, PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC, PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER, JOSEPH CONAGHAN AND PFC PHYSICIANS' MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT - REDACTED VERSION (TRANSACTION ID #67115244)

EX PARTE APPLICATION OF DEFENDANT CHART INC. FOR AN ORDER EXTENDING TIME TO FILE PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDATE FROM ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR A DETERMINATION OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES; DECLARATION OF KEVIN M. RINGEL (TRANSACTION ID # 67145804) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-19-574336. (TRANSACTION ID # 69882256)

APPLICATION TO ADMIT COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE - JOHN DUFFY (CGC-18-565215) (TRANSACTION ID # 69888951) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

ORDER DENYING EX PARTE APPLICATION OF DEFENDANT CHART INC. FOR AN ORDER EXTENDING TIME TO FILE PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDATE FROM ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR A DETERMINATION OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT ((TRANSACTION ID #67160609)

APPLICATION TO ADMIT COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE - KEVIN RINGEL (CGC-18-565215) (TRANSACTION ID # 69888951) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART, INC.

NOTICE OF APPEAL (TRANSACTION ID # 67253235) FILED BY APPELLANT CHART, INC.

ORDER AFTER REVIEW OF JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT (TRANSACTION #65675355)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585210) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF E., E. (CGC-20-585210) G., F. (CGC-20-585210) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574315) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF Y., Y. (CGC-19-574315) Z., Z. (CGC-19-574315) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 65666602) FILED BY PLAINTIFF LEVIN, RACHEL (CGC-18-565570) H., G. (CGC-18-566130) LUO, MICHELLE (CGC-18-567717) J., I. (CGC-18-570347) L., K. (CGC-18-570347)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585273) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF F., F. (CGC-20-585273) G., G. (CGC-20-585273) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

ORDER DENYING PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDATE OR OTHER EXTRAORDINARY RELIEF A164120 DIV 1

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585270) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-20-585270) I., I. (CGC-20-585270) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

ORDER ADVANCING MAY 29, 2020 CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE (TRANSACTION ID # 64830505)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585212) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF C., C. (CGC-20-585212) D., D. (CGC-20-585212) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

CLERK'S NOTICE OF FILING OF NOTICE OF APPEAL

APPLICATION TO ADMIT COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE - MARGARET REDSHAW (CGC-18-565215) (TRANSACTION ID # 69888951) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-20-585211. (TRANSACTION ID # 69879737)

NOTICE DESIGNATING RECORD ON APPEAL (TRANSACTION ID # 67278733) FILED BY APPELLANT CHART, INC.

SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY, (CGC-18-565215) (TRANSACTION ID # 65690634): COWDEN, MARC G SUBSTITUTED FOR LANE, MOLLY MORIARTY AS ATTORNEY FOR CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

PROOF OF SERVICE (CGC-19-572788) (TRANSACTION ID # 67521835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) H., D. (CGC-19-572788)

APPLICATION TO ADMIT COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE - KRISTINE C REVEILLE (CGC-18-565215) (TRANSACTION ID # 69888951) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ONLY IN CGC-18-568436. (TRANSACTION ID # 69889352) AS TO PLAINTIFF M., N. (CGC-18-568436) L., A. (CGC-18-565882)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585268) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF J., J. (CGC-20-585268) K., K. (CGC-20-585268) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

ORDER CONTINUING CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE (TRANSACTION ID # 67313375)

NOTICE OF DEFAULT ON APPEAL SENT TO APPELLANT CHART, INC.

NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS (TRANSACTION ID # 65697764) FILED BY ATTORNEY LADDON, TARIFA B.

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE COMPLAINT IN CGC-19-574223. (TRANSACTION ID # 69908417)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585216) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF L., L. (CGC-20-585216) M., M. (CGC-20-585216) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-569870. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585304) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF NAIL, KATHARINE (CGC-20-585304) NAIL, ROBERT (CGC-20-585304) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

NOTICE TO REPORTER TO PREPARE TRANSCRIPT

APPLICATION TO ADMIT COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE / APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER ADMITTING KEVIN RINGEL, ESQ. AND JOHN DUFFY, ESQ. AS COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE; DECLARATION OF ADAM M. STODDARD, ESQ. (TRANSACTION ID # 65759257) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

NOTICE OF CHANGE IN HANDLING ATTORNEY (TRANSACTION ID # 67389098) FILED BY DEFENDANT PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC.

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585218) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF P., O. (CGC-20-585218) C., B. (CGC-20-585218) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

PROOF OF SERVICE (CGC-19-572788) (TRANSACTION ID # 67477340) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) H., D. (CGC-19-572788)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-565616. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585277) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF ROSENBAUM, AMY (CGC-20-585277) WALLACE, PAUL (CGC-20-585277) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

APPLICATION TO ADMIT COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE / NOTICE OF APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER ADMITTING JOHN DUFFY, ESQ. AND KEVIN RINGEL, ESQ. AS COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE (TRANSACTION ID # 65759257) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585241) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF J., R. (CGC-20-585241) D., B. (CGC-20-585241) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585211) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66331835) FILED BY PLAINTIFF R., R. (CGC-20-585211) S., S. (CGC-20-585211) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION (CGC-19-572788); EACH SIDE TO BEAR THEIR OWN FEES AND COSTS (TRANSACTION ID # 67477340) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-567042. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-565122. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-5774259. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE (CGC-19-574258 CONSOLIDATED IN LEAD CASE: CGC-18-565215) (TRANSACTION ID # 65823238) AS TO PLAINTIFF V., U. (CGC-19-574258 CONSOLIDATED IN LEAD CASE: CGC-18-565215)

ORDER - STIPULATION AND ORDER: MASTER COMPLAINT AND SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (TRANSACTION ID # 65771470)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-570145. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

CERTIFICATION NOTICE

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-565882. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-570019. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE AS TO ENTIRE ACTION (CGC-19-572788); EACH SIDE TO BEAR THEIR OWN FEES AND COSTS (TRANSACTION ID # 67521835) AS TO DEFENDANT SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-574260. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

ORDER AFTER REVIEW OF JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66514622)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-21-589746) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66876283) FILED BY PLAINTIFF L., K. (CGC-21-589746) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR, INC. CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215) PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE HERBERT, DR. CARL M. AN INDIVIDUAL SCHRIOCK, DR. ELDON D. AN INDIVIDUAL CONAGHAN, DR. JOSEPH AN INDIVIDUAL

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT AND REQUEST FOR 90-DAY CONTINUANCE (TRANSACTION ID # 66510973) FILED BY OTHER PLAINTIFFS' LIAISON COUNSEL

NOTICE NOTICE OF APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER ADMITTING NATHAN WIDELL, ESQ., CHRISTOPHER GRIFFIN, ESQ., TAYLOR VAN HOVE, ESQ., AND MARGARET REDSHAW, ESQ., AS COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE (TRANSACTION ID # 65857319) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT AND REQUEST FOR 60 DAY CONTINUANCE (TRANSACTION ID # 66816447) FILED BY OTHER PLAINTIFFS' LIAISON COUNSEL

ORDER - STIPULATION AND ORDER REGARDING NOTICE AND PETITION TO COORDINATE ADD-ON CASES (TRANSACTION ID # 65883615)

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 67845459) FILED BY OTHER PLAINTIFFS' LIAISON COUNSEL

ORDER AFTER REVIEW OF JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66819312)

APPLICATION TO ADMIT COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE / APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER ADMITTING NATHAN WIDELL, ESQ., CHRISTOPHER GRIFFIN, ESQ., TAYLOR VAN HOVE, ESQ. AND MARGARET REDSHAW, ESQ., AS COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE; DECLARATION OF ADAM M. STODDARD, ESQ. (TRANSACTION ID # 65857319) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-569718. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-578083. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-566820. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-574252. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

ORDER - STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER FOR HIGHLY SENSITIVE CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION (TRANSACTION ID #65996172)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-565458. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF ADAM M. STODDARD, ESQ. IN SUPPORT OF APPLICATION FOR AN ORDER ADMITTING NATHAN WIDELL, ESQ., CHRISTOPHER GRIFFIN, ESQ., TAYLOR VAN HOVE, ESQ. AND MARGARET REDSHAW, ESQ., AS COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE (TRANSACTION ID # 65860509) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

ORDER VACATING CASE MANGEMENT CONFERENCE (TRANSACTION ID #67805449)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-567247) (TRANSACTION ID # 67862164) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

ORDER - STIPULATION AND ORDER REGARDING ADD-ON CASE (TRANSACTION ID # 66870141)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-18-565459. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

MOTION / NOTICE OF MOTION & MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66887486) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE HEARING SET FOR SEP-23-2021 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPT 613

MOTION / NOTICE OF MOTION & MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66887486) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE HEARING SET FOR SEP-23-2021 AT 10:30 AM IN DEPT 613

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-574254. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE ENTIRE ACTION IN CGC-19-574251. (TRANSACTION ID # 69909710)

REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT - VOLUME 1 (TRANSACTION ID # 66887486) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE

CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 67843000) FILED BY OTHER PLAINTIFFS' LIAISON COUNSEL

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-568436) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 65907269) FILED BY OTHER PLAINTIFFS' LIAISON COUNSEL

REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT - VOLUME 2 (TRANSACTION ID # 66887486) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER HERBERT, CARL SCHRIOCK, ELDON CHENETTE, PHILIP GIVENS, CAROLYN LI, LIYUN RYAN, ISABELLE

ORDER AFTER REVIEW OF JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 65912018)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-567247) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574293) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66046044) FILED BY PLAINTIFF A., A. (CGC-19-574293) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE

-REVISED WITH EXHIBITS-EX PARTE APPLICATION OF DEFENDANT CHART INC. FOR AN ORDER EXTENDING TIME TO FILE PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDATE FROM ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR A DETERMINATION OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES; DECLARATION OF KEVIN M. RINGEL (TRANSACTION ID # 67145900) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574314) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565616) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574258) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565122) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-566820) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574259) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

OPPOSITION TO CHART INC EX PARTE TO EXTEND TIME TO FILE PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDATE (TRANSACTION ID # 67156929) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC CONAGHAN, JOSEPH PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

PROOF OF SERVICE BY ELECTRONIC MAIL (TRANSACTION ID # 67156929) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC CONAGHAN, JOSEPH PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574295) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574315) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574385) (TRANSACTION ID # 68076684) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

PROOF OF SERVICE (CGC-19-574385) (TRANSACTION ID # 68076684) FILED BY PLAINTIFF CHRIST, ALEXANDRA (SF CASE NO. CGC-19-574385)

NOTICE SENT TO ATTORNEY JOHN DUFFY TO PAY PRO HAC VICE RENEWAL FEE BY OCT-26-2022

NOTICE SENT TO ATTORNEY KEVIN RINGEL TO PAY PRO HAC VICE RENEWAL FEE BY OCT-26-2022

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-573610) (TRANSACTION ID # 68307595) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

ORDER CERTIFYING OPINION FOR PUBLICATION NO CHANGE IN JUDGMENT A158155 DIV 1 (SEE SCAN FOR DETAILS)

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 68868997) FILED BY OTHER PLAINTIFFS' LIAISON COUNSEL

SUPPLEMENTAL CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT AS TO PLAINTIFFS H.H. D.H. (CGC19572788) (TRANSACTION ID # 68875199) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) H., D. (CGC-19-572788)

PROOF OF SERVICE (CGC19572788) (TRANSACTION ID # 68875199) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) H., D. (CGC-19-572788)

DECLARATION OF MARIO A. MOYA IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO REMAND ACTION FOR FURTHER PRETRIAL PROCEEDINGS AND TRIAL (CGC-19-572788) (TRANSACTION ID # 70200345) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) H., D. (CGC-19-572788)

PROOF OF SERVICE (CGC-19-572788) (TRANSACTION ID # 70200345) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) H., D. (CGC-19-572788)

DECLARATION / CLRA VENUE DECLARATION PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA CODE SECTION 1780(D) (CGC-18-565215) (TRANSACTION ID # 66147021) FILED BY PLAINTIFF C., A. (CGC-18-565215)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574314) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66147021) FILED BY PLAINTIFF P., R. (CGC-19-574314) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED, INCLUSIVE PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-570019) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585302) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

ORDER RE JULY 12, 2023 HEARING (TRANSACTION ID #70270381)

DECLARATION / CLRA VENUE DECLARATION PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA CODE SECTION 1780(D) (CGC-19-574314) (TRANSACTION ID # 66147021) FILED BY PLAINTIFF P., R. (CGC-19-574314)

REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION TO SETTLING DEFENDANTS? MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT ? VOLUME 1 (TRANSACTION ID # 66923524) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

ORDER RE JULY 12, 2023 CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE (TRANSACTION ID #70334888)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585210) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

ORDER GRANTING MOTION OF PLAINTIFFS H.H. & D.H. TO REMAND ACTION FOR FURTHER PRETRIAL PROCEEDINGS AND TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID #70334888)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-578788) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66147291) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., H. (CGC-19-572788) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED, INCLUSIVE PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574260) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-574312) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585273) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY, (TRANSACTION ID # 70356709): LANE, MOLLY MORIARTY SUBSTITUTED FOR COWDEN, MARC G AS ATTORNEY FOR CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-572788) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66147339) FILED BY PLAINTIFF H., D. (CGC-19-572788) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED, INCLUSIVE PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

MINUTES FOR JUL-12-2023 2:00 PM

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-573610) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66206961) FILED BY PLAINTIFF O., S. (SF CASE NO. CGC-19-573610) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED, INCLUSIVE PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION TO SETTLING DEFENDANTS? MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT ? VOLUME 2 (TRANSACTION ID # 66923524) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-19-573610) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66206961) FILED BY PLAINTIFF Y., N. (SF CASE NO. CGC-19-573610) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED, INCLUSIVE PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66218788) FILED BY OTHER PLAINTIFFS' LIAISON COUNSEL

ORDER AFTER JULY 12, 2023 CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE (TRANSACTION ID #70386660)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-568436) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66220957) FILED BY PLAINTIFF M., N. (CGC-18-568436) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

ORDER GRANTING APPLICATION TO APPEAR AS COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE FOR ATTORNEY JOHN DUFFY (TRANSACTION ID # 66968274) FILED BY COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

PROOF OF SERVICE BY MAIL

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-566130) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-20-585270) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

REPLY BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS PACIFIC MSL, LLC, PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC., PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER, JOSEPH CONAGHAN AND PFC PHYSICIANS MOTION FOR APPROVAL OF GOOD FAITH SETTLEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66971730) FILED BY DEFENDANT PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC.

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE BY MOLLY MORIARTY LANE (TRANSACTION ID # 70502758) FILED BY DEFENDANT CHART INC. (CGC-18-565215)

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-568436) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66220961) FILED BY PLAINTIFF L., A. (CGC-18-568436) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

ORDER AFTER REVIEW OF JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT (TRANSACTION ID # 66226714)

ORDER & AMENDED STIPULATON ADOPTING PROTECTIVE ORDER ENTERED IN COORDINATED PROCEEDING CASE NO. CJC-19-005021 (TRANSACTION ID #70592880)

DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-570347) (TRANSACTION ID # 67975525) AS TO DEFENDANT PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER

** REDACTED ** DECLARATION OF JULIE Y. PARK IN SUPPORT OF UNOPPOSED MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PORTIONS OF SEPTEMBER 23, 2021 HEARING TRANSCRIPT (TRANSACTION ID # 67018167) FILED BY DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CONAGHAN, JOSEPH

SHORT FORM COMPLAINT (CGC-18-565882) AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL (TRANSACTION ID # 66240382) FILED BY PLAINTIFF L., A. (CGC-18-565882) AGAINST DEFENDANT PACIFIC MSO, LLC PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. PRAXAIR, INC. PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC. CHART, INC. PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED

REMITTITUR DISMISSED (A164472 DIV 1) (APPEAL FILED 1/21/22)