Motion for Case Management in PACIFIC FERTILITY CASES| Trellis.Law

On April 26, 2019 a Party Statement was filed involving a dispute between A., A., A., D., Ahlheim, Kimberly, A., S., B., B., C., A., C., B., C., C., Christ, Alexandra, C., M., D., B., D., D., Doe, Jane, E., E., F., B., F., C., F., F., F., J., Flaherty, Daniel, F., S., G., F., G., G., G., K., H., D., H., G., H., H., H., T., I., I., J., A., J., I., J., J., J., Q., J., R., K., K., L., A., L., B., L., C., L., E., Levin, Rachel, L., H. A., L., I., L., K., L., L., L., T., Luo, Michelle, M., A., M., Amanda, M., K., M., L., M., M., M., N., M., R., Nail, Katharine, Nail, Robert, N., N., N., S., O., J., O., N., O., S., O., X., P., J., Plaintiffs, P., M., P., O., P., R., P., S., Q., P., Q., Q., R., E., Rivera, Sylvia, R., J., Rosenbaum, Amy, R., Q., R., R., S., B., S., Lucas, S., S., T., G., T., M., T., S., T., T., V., U., Wallace, Paul, Walsh, Kelly, W., K., Wong, Lawrence, Wong, Sharlene, W., Q., Y., N., Y., Y., Z., A., Z., Z., and Chart Inc., Chart, Inc., Chart Industries, Inc., A Corporation, Chenette, Philip, Conaghan, Joseph, Does 1-100, Inclusive, Does One Through One Hundred, Does One Through One Hundred, Inclusive, Extron Co., Extron Company, A Corporation, Givens, Carolyn, Herbert, Dr. Carl M., Li, Liyun, Pacific Fertility Center, Pacific Fertility Center, An Unincorporated Entity, Pacific Mso, Llc, Praxair Distribution, Inc., Praxair, Inc., Prelude Fertility, Inc., A Corporation, Ryan, Isabelle, San Francisco Fertility Centers D B A Pacific, Schriock, Eldon, for COORDINATION in the District Court of San Francisco County.

Preview
1 Elizabeth J. Cabraser (State Bar No. 083151)
Lexi J. Hazam (State Bar No. 224457)
2 Sarah R. London (State Bar No. 267083)
Tiseme G. Zegeye (State Bar No. 319927) ELECTRONICALLY
3 LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, LLP
275 Battery Street, 29th Floor
FILED
Superior Court of California,
4 San Francisco, CA 94111-3339 County of San Francisco
Telephone: 415.956.1000 05/08/2023
5 Facsimile: 415.956.1008 Clerk of the Court
BY: VERA MU
Deputy Clerk
6 Plaintiffs’ Liaison Counsel
[Additional Counsel Listed on Signature Page]
7

8 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
9 COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
10

11 COORDINATION PROCEEDING Case No. CJC-19-005021
SPECIAL TITLE (RULE 3.550)
12 JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT
PACIFIC FERTILITY CASES STATEMENT
13
Dept: 613
14 Judge: Hon. Andrew Y.S. Cheng
15

2792212.1
JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT
1 Pursuant to the Court’s April 3, 2023 Order, Plaintiffs in all Coordinated actions, with the
2 exception of Plaintiffs H.H. and D.H., (collectively, “Plaintiffs”), together with Defendants Chart,
3 Inc. (“Chart”), and Praxair Distribution, Inc. and Praxair, Inc. (collectively, “Praxair”)
4 (collectively, “Defendants”), through their respective counsel of record, submit this Joint Case
5 Management Statement to update the Court on the status of the dismissals and the readiness of the
6 JCCP for termination.
7 I. Requests for Dismissal and Termination of JCCP 5021
8 Plaintiffs in all Coordinated actions, with the exception of Plaintiffs H.H. and D.H., have
9 entered into a confidential settlement agreement with Defendant Chart and the terms of the
10 settlement agreement were satisfied on March 20, 2023. 1 On or before April 28, 2023, Plaintiffs
11 in all Coordinated actions, with the exception of Plaintiffs H.H. and D.H., filed Requests for
12 Dismissal as to all Defendants. See Ex. A. The Clerk of the Court has now accepted all Requests
13 for Dismissal. Id.
14 Plaintiffs and Defendants respectfully request that the Court terminate this Coordinated
15 action, JCCP 5021, under Rule 3.545a (“The coordination trial judge may terminate any
16 coordinated action by settlement…”) as only one case will remain, H.H. and D.H. v. Pacific
17 Fertility Center, et al., CGC-19-572788.
18 II. Plaintiffs H.H. and D.H.’s Request to Remand Their Case to Dept. 206
19 All parties stipulate to remanding the action filed by Plaintiffs H.H. and D.H. (represented
20 by the Moya Law Firm) pursuant to CRC 3.542.
21

22 Dated: May 5, 2023 By: /s/
Sarah R. London
23

26
1
Defendants Pacific MSO, Prelude, Pacific Fertility Center, and the individual physicians
27 reached a settlement agreement with Claimants in late August 2021. The terms of the settlement
were fulfilled in late July 2022 and in August and September 2022, Plaintiffs in all Coordinated
28 actions filed Requests for Dismissal as to Defendants Pacific MSO, Prelude, Pacific Fertility
Center, and the individual physicians only. -2-
2792212.1
JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT
1 Elizabeth J. Cabraser (State Bar No. 083151)
ecabraser@lchb.com
2 Lexi J. Hazam (State Bar No. 224457)
3 lhazam@lchb.com
Sarah R. London (State Bar No. 267083)
4 slondon@lchb.com
Tiseme G. Zegeye (State Bar No. 319927)
5 tzegeye@lchb.com
LIEFF CABRASER HEIMANN & BERNSTEIN, LLP
6 275 Battery Street, 29th Floor
7 San Francisco, CA 94111-3339
T: 415.956.1000
8 F: 415.956.1008
E: slondon@lchb.com
9
Plaintiffs’ Liaison Counsel
10

11 By: /s/
Doris Cheng
12
Michael A. Kelly
13
Doris Cheng
14 WALKUP MELODIA KELLY & SCHOENBERGER
650 California St, 26th Floor
15 San Francisco, CA 94108
T: 415.889.2919
16 F: 415.391.6965
E: mkelly@WalkupLawOffice.com
17
E: dcheng@WalkupLawOffice.com
18
Plaintiffs’ Liaison Counsel
19

20 By: /s/
Nancy Hersh
21
Nancy Hersh
22 Kate Hersh-Boyle
HERSH & HERSH P.C.
23
601 Van Ness Avenue, Suite 2080
24 San Francisco, California 94102
T: 415.441.5544
25 F: 415.441.7586
E: nhersh@hershlaw.com
26 E: khershboyle@hershlaw.com
27

28
-3-
2792212.1
JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT
1
By: /s/
2 Anne Marie Murphy
3 Anne Marie Murphy
COTCHETT, PITRE & MCCARTHY, LLP
4
840 Malcolm Road, #200
5 Burlingame, CA 94010
T: 650.697.6000
6 F: 650.697.0577
E: amurphy@cpmlegal.com
7

8 By: /s/
9 John J. Duffy (SB No. 6224834)
Kevin M. Ringel (SB No. 6308106)
10
SWANSON, MARTIN & BELL, LLP
11 330 N Wabash, Suite 3300
Chicago, Illinois 60611
12 T: 312.321.9100
F: 312.321.0990
13 E: jduffy@smbtrials.com
14 E: kringel@smbtrials.com

16 Counsel for Defendant Chart
17 By: /s/
18 Michael J. Kanute
Tarifa Laddon
19
FAEGRE DRINKER BIDDLE & REATH LLP
20 1800 Century Park East, Suite 1500
Los Angeles, California 90067
21 T: 310.203.4000
F: 310.203.1285
22 E: mike.kanute@faegredrinker.com
E: tarifa.laddon@faegredrinker.com
23

24 Attorneys for Defendants Praxair Distribution, Inc.,
and Praxair, Inc.
25

28
-4-
2792212.1
JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT
1 CERTIFICATE OF ELECTRONIC SERVICE
2
On May 8, 2023, I, TISEME G. ZEGEYE, electronically served the Joint Case
3
Management Statement, via File&ServeXpress, on the recipients designated on the Transaction
4
Receipt located on the File&ServeXpress website.
5
Dated: May 8, 2023 By: /s/ Ashley Freeman
6 ASHLEY FREEMAN
7

28
-5-
2792212.1
JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT
EXHIBIT A
PFC State Court Dismissals
Date Transaction
Case Original Case Operative Add-On Petition Date Dismissal Number for Processing
Name Number County of Origin and Order Filed Dismissal status Law Firm
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add-
On
Cases And Adoption Of
A.A. v. Master Complaint Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-19-574293 San Francisco 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
A.Z. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585214 San Francisco On Cases 5/4/2023 69953225 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Kimberly Ahlheim v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585213 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
B.B. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-19-574410 San Francisco On 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
C.C. and D.D. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585212 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
D.A. and Q.J. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585302 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
E.E. and F.G. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585210 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
F.F. and G.G. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585273 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
G.H. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-18-566130 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
H.H. and I.I. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585270 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
I.J. and K.L. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-18-570347 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
J.J. and K.K. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585268 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2021.08.20 Stipulation And
K.L. v. Order Regarding Add-On Case Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-21-589746 San Francisco E Add-On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
L.L. and M.M. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585216 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
L.M. and N.O. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-19-574256 San Francisco On 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Rachel Levin v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-18-565570 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Michelle Luo and Daniel Flaherty v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-18-567717 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020. 08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
N.N. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585215 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Katharine Nail and Robert Nail v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585304 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
O.P. and B.C. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585218 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
P.Q. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-19-574307 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Q.Q. and T.T. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-19-574290 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Q.R. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-19-574282 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
R.J. and B.D. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585241 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020. 08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
R.R. and S.S. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585211 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Amy Rosenbaum and Paul Wallace v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-20-585277 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
S.T. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-19-574258 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Kelly Walsh and Sylvia Rivera v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-19-574295 San Francisco On Cases 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Y.Y. and Z.Z. v. Petition To Coordinate Add- Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-19-574315 San Francisco On 4/24/2023 69879737 Accepted Bernstein
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add-
On Cases And Adoption Of Cotchett, Pitre &
A.M. v. Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-18-567247 San Francisco Master Complaint 4/25/2023 69912369 Accepted McCarthy, LLP (“CPM”)
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add-
On Cases And Adoption Of Cotchett, Pitre &
B.S.S. v. Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-19-574223 San Francisco Master Complaint 4/27/2023 69908417 Accepted McCarthy, LLP (“CPM”)
2019.04.26 Joint Stipulation
And Order To Consolidate
A.C. v. Pacific Fertility Center, et al CGC-19-574385 San Francisco Cases 5/4/2023 69957636 Accepted Eisenberg Law
2019.05.29 Order granting
A.C. v. Pacific Fertility Center, et al CGC-18-565215 San Francisco Petition to Coordinate 4/28/2023 69922122 Accepted Hersh & Hersh
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add-
E.R. v. Pacific Fertility Center, et al CGC-19-574312 San Francisco On 4/28/2023 69922122 Accepted Hersh & Hersh
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add-
A.J. v. Pacific Fertility Center, et al CGC-19-574216 San Francisco On 4/28/2023 69922122 Accepted Hersh & Hersh
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add-
R.P. v. Pacific Fertility Center, et al CGC-19-574314 San Francisco On 4/28/2023 69922122 Accepted Hersh & Hersh
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
A.L. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-565882 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
A.M. & K.M. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-19-574251 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
B.F. & J.R. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-569870 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
B.L. & S.A. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-569718 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
B.S. & R.P. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-570136 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
C.F. & J.F. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-567042 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
C.L. & M.C. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-570019 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
DOE, JANE v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-565459 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
H.A.L. & K.W. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
al. CGC-18-570145 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
I.L. & E.L. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-19-574260 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
J.P. & J.O. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-19-578083 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
J.R.R. & J.R. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-19-574252 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
M.P. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-570397 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
M.T. & G.T. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-19-574254 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
Q.W. & X.O. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-19-574257 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
R.M. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-565458 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
S.F. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-565616 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
S.P. & A.A. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-566820 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
T.H. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-19-574259 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add- Walkup Melodia Kelly &
T.L. & S.N. v. Prelude Fertility Inc., et. al. CGC-18-565122 San Francisco On 4/27/2023 69909710 Accepted Schoenberger
2020.03.02 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add-
On
Cases And Adoption Of
S.O. & N.Y. v. Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-19-573610 San Francisco Master Complaint 5/1/2023 69931566 Accepted Rains Lucia Stern
Da Vega Fisher
N.M, et al. v. Pacific Fertility Center, et al. CGC-18-568436 San Francisco Not an add-on case 4/25/2023 69889352 Accepted Mechtenberg LLP
2020.08.27 Stipulation And
Order Regarding Notice And
Petition To Coordinate Add-
K.G. v. Pacific Fertility Center et al. CGC-19-574336 San Francisco On 4/24/2023 69882256 Accepted The Veen Firm

Case Info

Judge

Andrew Y.S. Cheng Track Judge’s New Case

Case No.

(Subscribe to View)

Document Filed Date

May 08, 2023

Case Filing Date

April 26, 2019

County

Parties

A., A. Plaintiff
A., D. Plaintiff
AHLHEIM, KIMBERLY Plaintiff
A., S. Plaintiff
B., B. Plaintiff
BOSMAN, ERIN MCCALMON Attorney for the Defendant
C., A. Plaintiff
CABRASER, ELIZABETH JOAN Attorney
CABRASER, ELIZABETH JOAN Attorney for the Plaintiff
C., B. Plaintiff
C., C. Plaintiff
CHAIR, JUDICIAL COUNCIL OF CALIFORNIA Attorney
CHART INC. Defendant
CHART, INC. Appellant
CHART, INC. Defendant
CHART INDUSTRIES, INC., A CORPORATION Defendant
CHENETTE, PHILIP Defendant
CHRIST, ALEXANDRA Plaintiff
C., M. Plaintiff
CONAGHAN, JOSEPH Defendant
COWDEN, MARC G Attorney for the Appellant
COWDEN, MARC G Attorney for the Defendant
DA VEGA, MATTHEW Attorney for the Plaintiff
D., B. Plaintiff
D., D. Plaintiff
DE SAINT PHALLE, EUSTACE Attorney for the Plaintiff
DOE, JANE Plaintiff
DOES 1-100, INCLUSIVE Defendant
DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED Defendant
DOES ONE THROUGH ONE HUNDRED, INCLUSIVE Defendant
DUFFY, JOHN Attorney for the Defendant
E., E. Plaintiff
EISENBERG, NEIL DANIEL Attorney for the Plaintiff
EXTRON CO. Defendant
EXTRON COMPANY, A CORPORATION Defendant
F., B. Plaintiff
F., C. Plaintiff
F., F. Plaintiff
F., J. Plaintiff
FLAHERTY, DANIEL Plaintiff
F., S. Plaintiff
G., F. Plaintiff
G., G. Plaintiff
GIVENS, CAROLYN Defendant
G., K. Plaintiff
H., D. Plaintiff
HERBERT, DR. CARL M. Defendant
HERSH, NANCY LEE Attorney for the Plaintiff
H., G. Plaintiff
H., H. Plaintiff
HOLDER, JAMES K. Attorney for the Defendant
H., T. Plaintiff
I., I. Plaintiff
J., A. Plaintiff
J., I. Plaintiff
J., J. Plaintiff
J., Q. Plaintiff
J., R. Plaintiff
KELLY, MICHAEL ALBERT Attorney for the Plaintiff
K., K. Plaintiff
L., A. Plaintiff
LABEL, ANTHONY L. Attorney for the Plaintiff
LADDON, TARIFA B. Attorney for the Defendant
LANE, MOLLY MORIARTY Attorney for the Defendant
L., B. Plaintiff
L., C. Plaintiff
L., E. Plaintiff
LEVIN, RACHEL Plaintiff
L., H. A. Plaintiff
L., I. Plaintiff
LI, LIYUN Defendant
L., K. Plaintiff
L., L. Plaintiff
LONDON, SARAH R. Attorney for the Plaintiff
L., T. Plaintiff
LUO, MICHELLE Plaintiff
M., A. Plaintiff
M., AMANDA Plaintiff
M., K. Plaintiff
M., L. Plaintiff
M., M. Plaintiff
M., N. Plaintiff
MOYA, MARIO A. Attorney for the Plaintiff
M., R. Plaintiff
MURPHY, ANNIE MARIE Attorney for the Plaintiff
NAIL, KATHARINE Plaintiff
NAIL, ROBERT Plaintiff
N., N. Plaintiff
N., S. Plaintiff
O., J. Plaintiff
O., N. Plaintiff
O., S. Plaintiff
O., X. Plaintiff
PACIFIC FERTILITY CASES Other
PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER Defendant
PACIFIC FERTILITY CENTER, AN UNINCORPORATED ENTITY Defendant
PACIFIC MSO, LLC Defendant
PICCHI, JOSEPH S. Attorney for the Defendant
P., J. Plaintiff
PLAINTIFFS Plaintiff
PLAINTIFFS' LIAISON COUNSEL Other
P., M. Plaintiff
P., O. Plaintiff
P., R. Plaintiff
PRAXAIR DISTRIBUTION, INC. Defendant
PRAXAIR, INC. Defendant
PRELUDE FERTILITY, INC., A CORPORATION Defendant
P., S. Plaintiff
Q., P. Plaintiff
Q., Q. Plaintiff
R., E. Plaintiff
RINGEL, KEVIN Attorney for the Defendant
RIVERA, SYLVIA Plaintiff
R., J. Plaintiff
ROSENBAUM, AMY Plaintiff
ROSENBERG-WOHL, DAVID MICHAEL Attorney for the Plaintiff
R., Q. Plaintiff
R., R. Plaintiff
RYAN, ISABELLE Defendant
SAN FRANCISCO FERTILITY CENTERS D/B/A PACIFIC Defendant
S., B. Plaintiff
SCHRIOCK, ELDON Defendant
S., LUCAS Plaintiff
S., S. Plaintiff
T., G. Plaintiff
T., M. Plaintiff
T., S. Plaintiff
T., T. Plaintiff
V., U. Plaintiff
WALLACE, PAUL Plaintiff
WALSH, KELLY Plaintiff
W., K. Plaintiff
WONG, LAWRENCE Plaintiff
WONG, SHARLENE Plaintiff
W., Q. Plaintiff
Y., N. Plaintiff
Y., Y. Plaintiff
Z., A. Plaintiff
Z., Z. Plaintiff
Anne Murphy Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Kathleen Hersh-Boyle Attorney
Doris Cheng Attorney
Rebecca Hoberg Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Adam Stoddard Attorneys for Defendants
Lexi Hazam Attorney
Tiseme Zegeye Attorney
William Tarantino Attorneys for Defendants
Julie Park Attorneys for Defendants
David McDowell Attorneys for Defendants
Aaron Schultz Attorneys for Defendants
Michael Ornstil Attorney
Montana Baker Attorney
Adrienne Publicover Attorney
John Bollier Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Annie Wu Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Julia Peng Attorney
Andrew Cheng Attorney
Michael Jaeger Attorneys for Defendants
Matthew Fisher Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Margaret Reyes Attorneys for Defendants
Marc Cohen Attorney
Linda Scaparotti Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Christopher Griffin Attorney
Steven Brewer Attorneys for Plaintiffs
John Feder Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Adam Polk Attorney
Sukhwinder Bajwa Attorney
Benjamin Smith Attorneys for Defendants
David Schrader Attorneys for Defendants
Megan Suehiro Attorneys for Defendants
Trevor Tan Attorney
Amy Zeman Attorney
Eric Gibbs Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Adam Wolf Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Nina Gliozzo Attorney
John Bicknell Attorney
Geoffrey Munroe Attorney
Andrew Lo Attorney

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.

Party Statement: PACIFIC FERTILITY CASES

Preview

Related Topics

Case Info

Parties