1. Home
  2. State Courts
  3. New York
  4. New York County Supreme Courts
  5. Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities
SEARCH TIPS
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators
Date
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators

Contents

Details Parties Documents Case Events

We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individual

Case Last Refreshed: 8 months ago

Track Case Changes
Download Docket Print Docket

Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, filed a(n) Agency Action - Administrative case against Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, The City Of New York, (total of 5) See All represented by Katzen, Jessica Lynn, in the jurisdiction of New York County. This case was filed in New York County Superior Courts with Erika M. Edwards presiding.

Case Details for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated v. Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity , et al.

Case Number

(Subscribe to View)

Judge

Erika M. Edwards

pdf Get Judge Analytics Report

Filing Date

March 03, 2023

Category

Special Proceedings - Cplr Article 78

Last Refreshed

November 23, 2023

Practice Area

Administrative

Filing Location

New York County, NY

Matter Type

Agency Action

Parties for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated v. Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity , et al.

Plaintiffs

Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated

Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Defendants

Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity

Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity

Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity

John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

The City Of New York

Attorneys for Defendants

Katzen, Jessica Lynn

Case Documents for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated v. Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity , et al.

for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION

Date: October 16, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

NOTICE OF ENTRY

Date: October 17, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: August 08, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - B  (Motion #002)

Date: August 07, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #002)

Date: August 07, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: August 07, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

NO FEE AUTHORIZATION (LETTER/ORDER/AFFIRMATION)

Date: June 15, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - P  (Motion #002)

Date: June 15, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY  (Motion #002)

Date: June 15, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130  (Motion #001)

Date: May 25, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #002)

Date: June 06, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION

Date: June 06, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

NO FEE AUTHORIZATION (LETTER/ORDER/AFFIRMATION)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - M  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - O  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - N  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - K  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - L  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - J  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - I  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - H  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - G  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - F  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - C  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - E  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - D  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - B  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

NOTICE OF MOTION  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION  (Motion #002)

Date: May 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130  (Motion #001)

Date: May 02, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130

Date: April 11, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

STIPULATION - ADJOURNMENT OF MOTION -IN SUBMISSIONS PART -RM 130

Date: March 24, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - A  (Motion #001)

Date: March 08, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE

Date: March 08, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

RJI -RE: NOTICE OF PETITION

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

NOTICE OF PETITION

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - J

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - G

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - I

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - H

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - F

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - E

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - C

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - D

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - C

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - B

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - B

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - A

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

AFFIDAVIT OR AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

EXHIBIT(S)  - A

Date: March 03, 2023
for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated, Shalom Katz Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated V. The City Of New York, Department Of Transportation Commissioner Ydanis Rodriguez, Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, Deputy Commissioner For Treasury And Payment Services Jeffrey Shear Both Individually And In His Official Capacity, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Transportation Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Department Of Finance Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe New York City Parking Violations Bureau Employees Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities, John And Jane Doe Parking Violations Bureau Administrative Law Judges Both Individually And In Their Official Capacities

PETITION

Date: March 03, 2023

Case Events for Arabella Palma Individually, And On Behalf Of All Others Similarly Situated v. Department Of Finance Commissioner Preston Niblack Both Individually And In His Official Capacity , et al.

Date Type Description
October 17, 2023 NOTICE OF ENTRY
View Document
October 16, 2023 DECISION + ORDER ON MOTION
View Document
August 08, 2023 LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
View Document
August 07, 2023 EXHIBIT(S) - B (Motion #002)
Closeup of NOL
View Document
August 07, 2023 EXHIBIT(S) - A (Motion #002)
NOL issued 8-3-23
View Document
August 07, 2023 LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
View Document
June 15, 2023 NO FEE AUTHORIZATION (LETTER/ORDER/AFFIRMATION)
View Document
June 15, 2023 EXHIBIT(S) - P (Motion #002)
Exhibit P - Google Maps Images
View Document
June 15, 2023 MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN REPLY (Motion #002)
Reply MOL in Further Support of MTD
View Document
June 06, 2023 EXHIBIT(S) - A (Motion #002)
DOT Images
View Document
See all events

Related Content in New York County

Case

In The Matter Of A Proceeding Under Article 78 Of The Cplr For A Writ Of Mandamus Rosenberg & Estis, P.C. of David Miller a/k/a David C. Miller v. Daniele Chinea in her official capacity as Judge of the Civil Court of the City of New York
Jul 10, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156299/2024

Case

In The Matter Of The Application Of Jackson Cheng , For a Judgment under Article 78 of the Civil Practice Law and Rules v. Edward A Caban as the Police Commissioner of the City of New York and as Chairman of the Board of Trustees of the Police Pension Fund, Article II, The Board Of Trustees Of The New York City Police Pension Fund, Article Ii
Jul 10, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156281/2024

Case

John Sudnik, Thomas Richardson v. City Of New York For A Judgment and Order Under Article 78 of the Civil Practice Law and Rules
Jul 15, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156388/2024

Case

Security Wholesalers, Inc. D/B/A Sherlock Security Systems v. Kevin D. Kim AS COMMISSIONER OF THE NEW YORK CITY SMALL BUSINESS SERVICES, Hasan Mir as EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF NEW YORK CITY SMALL BUSINESS SERVICES, CERTIFICATION UNIT, New York City Small Business Services, New York City Division Of Financial Opportunity
Jul 16, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156496/2024

Case

Joseph Calise v. Adolfo Carrion, As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Housing Preservation And Development, East Midtown Plaza Housing Company Inc.
Jul 16, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156475/2024

Case

Chatham 22 Realty Corp., American Fu Jian Dong Qi United Center, Inc. v. City Of New York, New York City Water Board, New York City Department Of Environmental Protection
Jul 10, 2024 | Eric Schumacher | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156270/2024

Case

Jumanne D Williams individually as a bus rider, and as Public Advocateof the City of New York, Roopdai Julie Davis as a bus rider, and on behalf of a class of subway riders similarly situated, Richard Davis as a bus rider, and as President of Local 100, Transport Workers Union of America, John Paul Paul Patifio as Brooklyn Bus Department Vice President of Local 100, Transport Workers Union of America, Donald Yates as MABSTOA Department Vice President, Transport Workers Union of America v. Janno Lieber as Chief Executive Officer of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Demetrius Crichlow as Interim President of the New York City Transit Authority
Jul 17, 2024 | Arthur F. Engoron | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156447/2024

Case

Matthew Binstock, Yaira Singer a/k/a Rachel Yaika Singer v. New York City Department Of Health And Mental Hygiene
Jul 15, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156402/2024

Case

In The Matter Of The Application Of 59 Audubon Avenue, Llc For A Judgment Under Article 78 Of The Civil Practice Law And Rules v. Preston Niblack in his capacity as THE COMMISSIONER OF FINANCE OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK, City Of New York
Jul 10, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156271/2024

Case

In The Matter Of The Application Of Surveillance Technology Oversight Project For a Judgment Pursuant to Article 78 of the Civil Practice Law and Rules v. Metropolitan Transportation Authority
Jul 17, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156519/2024

Case

In The Matter Of The Application Of Edward Mullane For a Judgment under Article 78 of the Civil Practice Law and Rules v. Edward A Caban as the Police Commissioner of the City of New York and as Chairman of the Board of Trustees of the Police Pension Fund, Article II, The Board Of Trustees Of The New York City Police Pension Fund, Article Ii
Jul 12, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156375/2024

Document

Marie Vincent, Carolina Tejeda, Mary Cronneit, Susan Acks v. Mayor Eric Adams, The City Of New York
Feb 14, 2024 | Lyle E. Frank | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 450563/2024

Document

Marie Vincent, Carolina Tejeda, Mary Cronneit, Susan Acks v. Mayor Eric Adams, The City Of New York
Feb 14, 2024 | Lyle E. Frank | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 450563/2024

Document

Daniel Binch, Kieran Brown, Mikhael Kozmava v. New York University
Feb 18, 2019 | Lynn R. Kotler | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 159944/2019

Document

John Sudnik, Thomas Richardson v. City Of New York For A Judgment and Order Under Article 78 of the Civil Practice Law and Rules
Jul 15, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156388/2024

Document

Joseph Calise v. Adolfo Carrion, As Commissioner Of The New York City Department Of Housing Preservation And Development, East Midtown Plaza Housing Company Inc.
Jul 16, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156475/2024

Document

Crewfacilities.Com, Llc v. City Of New York, The New York City Office Of Emergency Management, The Contract Dispute Resolution Board Of The New York City Office Of Administrative Trials And Hearings
Dec 28, 2023 | Andrea Masley | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 162516/2023

Document

Jumanne D Williams individually as a bus rider, and as Public Advocateof the City of New York, Roopdai Julie Davis as a bus rider, and on behalf of a class of subway riders similarly situated, Richard Davis as a bus rider, and as President of Local 100, Transport Workers Union of America, John Paul Paul Patifio as Brooklyn Bus Department Vice President of Local 100, Transport Workers Union of America, Donald Yates as MABSTOA Department Vice President, Transport Workers Union of America v. Janno Lieber as Chief Executive Officer of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Demetrius Crichlow as Interim President of the New York City Transit Authority
Jul 17, 2024 | Arthur F. Engoron | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156447/2024

Document

In The Matter Of The Application Of Edward Mullane For a Judgment under Article 78 of the Civil Practice Law and Rules v. Edward A Caban as the Police Commissioner of the City of New York and as Chairman of the Board of Trustees of the Police Pension Fund, Article II, The Board Of Trustees Of The New York City Police Pension Fund, Article Ii
Jul 12, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156375/2024

Document

Chatham 22 Realty Corp., American Fu Jian Dong Qi United Center, Inc. v. City Of New York, New York City Water Board, New York City Department Of Environmental Protection
Jul 10, 2024 | Eric Schumacher | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156270/2024

Document

Chatham 22 Realty Corp., American Fu Jian Dong Qi United Center, Inc. v. City Of New York, New York City Water Board, New York City Department Of Environmental Protection
Jul 10, 2024 | Eric Schumacher | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156270/2024

Document

In The Matter Of The Application Of Jackson Cheng , For a Judgment under Article 78 of the Civil Practice Law and Rules v. Edward A Caban as the Police Commissioner of the City of New York and as Chairman of the Board of Trustees of the Police Pension Fund, Article II, The Board Of Trustees Of The New York City Police Pension Fund, Article Ii
Jul 10, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156281/2024

Document

Security Wholesalers, Inc. D/B/A Sherlock Security Systems v. Kevin D. Kim AS COMMISSIONER OF THE NEW YORK CITY SMALL BUSINESS SERVICES, Hasan Mir as EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF NEW YORK CITY SMALL BUSINESS SERVICES, CERTIFICATION UNIT, New York City Small Business Services, New York City Division Of Financial Opportunity
Jul 16, 2024 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156496/2024

Document

Jumanne D Williams individually as a bus rider, and as Public Advocateof the City of New York, Roopdai Julie Davis as a bus rider, and on behalf of a class of subway riders similarly situated, Richard Davis as a bus rider, and as President of Local 100, Transport Workers Union of America, John Paul Paul Patifio as Brooklyn Bus Department Vice President of Local 100, Transport Workers Union of America, Donald Yates as MABSTOA Department Vice President, Transport Workers Union of America v. Janno Lieber as Chief Executive Officer of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Demetrius Crichlow as Interim President of the New York City Transit Authority
Jul 17, 2024 | Arthur F. Engoron | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 156447/2024

Document

Crewfacilities.Com, Llc v. City Of New York, The New York City Office Of Emergency Management, The Contract Dispute Resolution Board Of The New York City Office Of Administrative Trials And Hearings
Nov 12, 2018 | Andrea Masley | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 | 162516/2023
Request redaction

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.