1. Home
  2. State Courts
  3. New York
  4. Albany County Supreme Courts
  5. Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)
SEARCH TIPS
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators
Date
"" "23STCV06307" Exact match of phrase
* negligen* Match anything after the *
( ) "motion" AND ("dismiss" OR "summary") Grouping of terms
~ "motion to dismiss"~3 Maximum number of positions allowed between matching words
AND "damages" AND "injuries" AND "relief" Both terms must appear in document
OR "modify" OR "amend" Either terms can appear in document
judge:last-name judge:Abbot Filter by a specific judge name.
party:party-name party:"Apple inc" Filter by a specific party name.
To learn more visit - https://support.trellis.law/boolean-operators

Contents

Details Parties Documents Case Events

We are checking for the latest updates in this case. We will email you when the process is complete.

Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Pa

Case Last Refreshed: 9 months ago

Track Case Changes
Download Docket Print Docket

Town Of Brookhaven, filed a(n) Agency Action - Administrative case represented by Calica, Robert Marvin, Serfaty, Judah, against Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning & Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary Affected Party Under Cplr 1001, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture & Markets, represented by Armentano, John C., Butler, Philip Arthur, Frank, Andrew Gerard, Hopkins, Timothy James, Morgan, Elizabeth, (total of 5) See All in the jurisdiction of Albany County, NY, . Albany County, NY Superior Courts .

Case Details for Town Of Brookhaven v. Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning & Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary Affected Party Under Cplr 1001 , et al.

Case Number

(Subscribe to View) Track Case Changes

Filing Date

October 13, 2022

Category

Special Proceedings - Cplr Article 78

Last Refreshed

July 26, 2023

Practice Area

Administrative

Filing Location

Albany County, NY

Matter Type

Agency Action

Parties for Town Of Brookhaven v. Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning & Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary Affected Party Under Cplr 1001 , et al.

Plaintiffs

Town Of Brookhaven

Attorneys for Plaintiffs

Calica, Robert Marvin

Serfaty, Judah

Defendants

Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning & Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary Affected Party Under Cplr 1001

Delea Sod Farms, Inc.

Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture & Markets

Attorneys for Defendants

Armentano, John C.

Butler, Philip Arthur

Frank, Andrew Gerard

Hopkins, Timothy James

Morgan, Elizabeth

Case Documents for Town Of Brookhaven v. Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning & Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary Affected Party Under Cplr 1001 , et al.

for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

PETITION

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - C

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

RJI -RE: NOTICE OF PETITION

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - I

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - B

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - H

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - G

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - D

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - E

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - A

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

NOTICE OF PETITION

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - F

Date: October 13, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE

Date: October 24, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE

Date: October 24, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)

Date: November 01, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

AFFIRMATION/AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE

Date: October 24, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

NOTICE OF APPEARANCE (POST RJI)

Date: November 08, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - - (Stipulation of Adjournment - Attachment to November 14, 2022 Letter to Chief Clerk David B. Cardona

Date: November 14, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE (Letter to Chief Clerk David B. Cardona confirming adjournment and attaching stipulation of adjournm

Date: November 14, 2022
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - A-1

Date: January 04, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - F

Date: January 04, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - A-2

Date: January 04, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - B

Date: January 04, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

PETITION (AMENDED)

Date: January 04, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - D

Date: January 04, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - C

Date: January 04, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

MEMORANDUM

Date: January 04, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - G

Date: January 04, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - E

Date: January 04, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS - CERTIFIED

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS - CERTIFIED

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

AFFIDAVIT

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - 2

Date: February 14, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

ANSWER IN SPECIAL PROCEEDING

Date: February 14, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT

Date: February 14, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

AFFIDAVIT

Date: February 14, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS - CERTIFIED

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

EXHIBIT(S)  - 1

Date: February 14, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

ANSWER IN SPECIAL PROCEEDING

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS - CERTIFIED

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS - CERTIFIED

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

ANSWER IN SPECIAL PROCEEDING

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS - CERTIFIED

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

AFFIRMATION

Date: February 15, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE

Date: March 16, 2023
for Town Of Brookhaven V. Richard A. Ball Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Agriculture &Amp; Markets, Delea Sod Farms, Inc., Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning &Amp; Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary/Affected Party Under Cplr 1001(A)

STIPULATION - BRIEFING SCHEDULE

Date: March 16, 2023

Case Events for Town Of Brookhaven v. Central Pine Barrens Joint Planning & Policy Commission Additional Respondent Joined As Necessary Affected Party Under Cplr 1001 , et al.

Date Type Description
March 16, 2023 LETTER / CORRESPONDENCE TO JUDGE
View Document
March 16, 2023 STIPULATION - BRIEFING SCHEDULE
View Document
February 15, 2023 TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS - CERTIFIED
(Administrative Record Volume 3 of 6)
View Document
February 15, 2023 TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS - CERTIFIED
(Administrative Record Volume 6 of 6)
View Document
February 15, 2023 AFFIDAVIT
(Affidavit of Kathleen E. Tylutki with exhibit)
View Document
February 15, 2023 MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
View Document
February 15, 2023 MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
Respondent Delea Sod Farms, Inc.'s Memo of Law i/o/t Petition
View Document
February 15, 2023 TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS - CERTIFIED
(Administrative Record Volume 1 of 6)
View Document
February 15, 2023 ANSWER IN SPECIAL PROCEEDING
Respondent Delea Sod Farms, Inc.'s Verified Answer w Objections
View Document
February 15, 2023 TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS - CERTIFIED
(Administrative Record Volume 2 of 6)
View Document
See all events
Request redaction

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.