On October 23, 2020 a
Proof of Service
was filed
involving a dispute between
Kharbawy, A. Sameh El,
and
Board Of Trustees Of California State Of University,
Castro, Joseph I.,
Fu, Xuanning,
Hamm, Daryl L.,
Jimenez-Sandoval, Saul,
Zelenzy, Lynnette,
for 15 Unlimited - Other Employment
in the District Court of Fresno County.
Preview
a
FILED by Super
Eleqtronically
6‘
om
Court of California, County of Los Angeles AM Sherri
09:17 R. Carter. Executive Officer/Clerk of Court. by P. McIntyre,Deputy Clerk
Maddox, Bar No. 219091 Fl LEI
Jesse
swam” mm Ur Caiirmma
1 J.
Jmaddox@1cwlega1.com munw a1 L05, “9.91%
‘
2 Nathan T. Jackson, Bar No. 285620 .
_ r
03" 1 89021
rk _
njackson@lcwlegal.com
3 LIEBERT CASSIDY WHITMORE Shem a Cwmwmysm cam: cemmam
4
A Professional Law Corporation
5250 North Palm Ave, Suite 3 10
By.‘_——_—‘ 5E.Salc'vdo
Dewy
"
Fresno, California 93704
5 Telephone: 559.256.7800
Facsimile: 559.449.4535
6
Attorneys for Defendant BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF
7 CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY
8
9 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
‘
10 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES
CE cs 0 2 2 1 4
2 1
11 A. SAMEH EL KHARBAWY, Case No.2 20LBCV00465
10
12 Plaintiff, [ASSIGNED FOR ALL PURPOSES TO HON.
3 MICHAEL P. VICENCIA, DEPT. $26]
Comoration
Suite
93704
Whitmore 13 v.
Ave,
Complaint Filed: October 23, 2020
Law 14
California BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF
Cassidy
Palm
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY; PROOF OF SERVICE
North
15
Professional
DARRYL L. HAMM, an individual;
Liebext
Fresno,
LYNNETTE ZELEZNY, an individual;
A
5250 16 JOSEPH I. CASTRO, an individual;
SAUL JIMENEZ—SANDOVAL, an (*Exempt from filing fees'pursuant to Gov.
17 individual; XUANNING FU, an Code, § 6103.)
individual; AND DOES 1 through 50,
18
Petitioner.
19
20 ///'
21 ///
22 ///
23 ///
1-32.4' ”/III: --.
26 ///
TI; ‘27
"' '
’7//'
1
Proof of Service
moo7-ooa
9s7s9s9.1
\‘r
PROOF OF SERVICE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SACRANIENTO
AWN
I am employed in the County of Sacramento, State of California. I am over the agé of 18
and not a party to the within action; my business address is: 400 Capitol Mall, Suite 1260,
Sacramento, CA 95814.
On March 18, 2021, I served the foregoing dobument(s) described as
\DOONONUI
1. DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE
UNIVERSITY’S REPLY T0 PLAINTIFF A. SAMEH EL KHARBAWY’S OPPOSITION
T0 MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
10 2. DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE
11 UNIVERSITY’S OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF A. SAMEH EL KHARBAWY’S
12 EVIDENCE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT’S MOTION T0 TRANSFER CASE TO
1260
Corporation
95814
Whitmore 13 FRESNO COUNTY
Suite
Law
CA
Mall, 14 3. SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF SILVANA POLGAR IN SUPPORT
Cassidy
15
Sacramento.
Capitol
Professional
0F DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S
Liebert
400
16 IMOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
A
17 4. SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF DR. HONORA CHAPMAN IN
18 SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE
19 UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
20 5. DECLARATION OF MCKENNA GOULD IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
21 BOARD 0F TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
22 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
23 6. DECLARATION OF MADELDVE KEESEY IN SUPPORT OF
.24 I
{DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S
i
,‘OTION TO, TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
26 7. DECLARATION OF ERICH SINIROCK IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
.
.27:
-—‘:'BOARD
OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
'.‘-28.:‘
TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY-
:2
Proof of Service
9578989.1 FR007-003
8. DECLARATION 0F CORI BRADBURY IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
BOARD OF TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION‘TO
TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
9. DECLARATION OF TOM ZIMMERMAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
10. DECLARATION 0F SARAH OSBORNE IN SUPPORT 0F DEFENDANT
BOARD 0F TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
10 11. DECLARATION OF EDLIN CUTTS IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
11 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
12 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
1260
l4
Corporation
Whitmorc
958
13 in the manner checked below on allinterested panics in this action addressed as follows:
Suite
CA
LawMall, 14 Andrew Hillier
'Cassidy
Paul Garcia
Sacmmento‘
Capitol
15
Professional
Hillier Law
Lieben
600 W. Broadway, Suite 700
A
400
16 San Diego, CA 92-101
telephone: 619.500.7906
17 facsimile: 619.839.3895
email: andrew@ahillier1aw.com;
18 paul@ahi11ier1aw.com
19 M (BY OVERNIGHT MAIL) By overnight coun'er, I arranged for the above-referenced
document(s) to be delivered to an authorized overnight courier service, FedEx, for
20 delivery to the addressee(s) above, in an envelope or package designated by the
overnight coun'er service with delivery fees paid or provided for.
21
M (BY ELECTRONIC SERVICE) By electronically mailing a true and correct copy
22 through Liebert Cassidy Whitmore’s electronic mail system fiom
mwibbenhorst@lcwlega1.com to the email address(es) set forth above. Idid not
23 receive, within a reasonable time afier the transmission, any electronic message or
other indication that the transmission was unsuccessful.
2.4
-‘
1'
..
.
Exécfitedz 2021,
o'niMa‘ijclhy'l‘S, at Sacramento, California.
|
'
p25
d I
V
A
'zl‘declare'find‘e; pénglty ofpefiury under the laws Yof the State of California that the
26
foregoing is true and correct. ‘
'
QMQJu‘Q/LKQ
Mariana Wibbenhorst
U Vane» “fl
“28'
'3
,_
Proof of Service
9578989.] FR007—003
THE DOCUMENT TO WHICH THlS CERTIFICATE IS
-
a
'
----------------------
I.
ATTACHED IS A FULL. TRUE. AND CORRECT COPY
Q,
z ¢“~
'
OF THE ORIGINAL ON FILE AND OF RECORD IN
i'gzg MY OFFICE. 4,
‘
.35: ATTEST: JUN 1 4 2021
fig SHERRI R. CARTER
‘
Executive Officer/Clerk of the Superior
fl
"
i
CO u
I
I ‘. ‘6 u L geles_
1:3: $4,5-
mas . £3“ B DEPUTY
Preview
a FILED by Super Eleqtronically 6‘ om Court of California, County of Los Angeles AM Sherri 09:17 R. Carter. Executive Officer/Clerk of Court. by P. McIntyre,Deputy Clerk Maddox, Bar No. 219091 Fl LEI Jesse swam” mm Ur Caiirmma 1 J. Jmaddox@1cwlega1.com munw a1 L05, “9.91% ‘ 2 Nathan T. Jackson, Bar No. 285620 . _ r 03" 1 89021 rk _ njackson@lcwlegal.com 3 LIEBERT CASSIDY WHITMORE Shem a Cwmwmysm cam: cemmam 4 A Professional Law Corporation 5250 North Palm Ave, Suite 3 10 By.‘_——_—‘ 5E.Salc'vdo Dewy " Fresno, California 93704 5 Telephone: 559.256.7800 Facsimile: 559.449.4535 6 Attorneys for Defendant BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF 7 CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY 8 9 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA ‘ 10 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES CE cs 0 2 2 1 4 2 1 11 A. SAMEH EL KHARBAWY, Case No.2 20LBCV00465 10 12 Plaintiff, [ASSIGNED FOR ALL PURPOSES TO HON. 3 MICHAEL P. VICENCIA, DEPT. $26] Comoration Suite 93704 Whitmore 13 v. Ave, Complaint Filed: October 23, 2020 Law 14 California BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF Cassidy Palm CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY; PROOF OF SERVICE North 15 Professional DARRYL L. HAMM, an individual; Liebext Fresno, LYNNETTE ZELEZNY, an individual; A 5250 16 JOSEPH I. CASTRO, an individual; SAUL JIMENEZ—SANDOVAL, an (*Exempt from filing fees'pursuant to Gov. 17 individual; XUANNING FU, an Code, § 6103.) individual; AND DOES 1 through 50, 18 Petitioner. 19 20 ///' 21 /// 22 /// 23 /// 1-32.4' ”/III: --. 26 /// TI; ‘27 "' ' ’7//' 1 Proof of Service moo7-ooa 9s7s9s9.1 \‘r PROOF OF SERVICE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SACRANIENTO AWN I am employed in the County of Sacramento, State of California. I am over the agé of 18 and not a party to the within action; my business address is: 400 Capitol Mall, Suite 1260, Sacramento, CA 95814. On March 18, 2021, I served the foregoing dobument(s) described as \DOONONUI 1. DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S REPLY T0 PLAINTIFF A. SAMEH EL KHARBAWY’S OPPOSITION T0 MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 10 2. DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE 11 UNIVERSITY’S OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF A. SAMEH EL KHARBAWY’S 12 EVIDENCE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT’S MOTION T0 TRANSFER CASE TO 1260 Corporation 95814 Whitmore 13 FRESNO COUNTY Suite Law CA Mall, 14 3. SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF SILVANA POLGAR IN SUPPORT Cassidy 15 Sacramento. Capitol Professional 0F DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S Liebert 400 16 IMOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY A 17 4. SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF DR. HONORA CHAPMAN IN 18 SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE 19 UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 20 5. DECLARATION OF MCKENNA GOULD IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT 21 BOARD 0F TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO 22 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 23 6. DECLARATION OF MADELDVE KEESEY IN SUPPORT OF .24 I {DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S i ,‘OTION TO, TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 26 7. DECLARATION OF ERICH SINIROCK IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT . .27: -—‘:'BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO '.‘-28.:‘ TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY- :2 Proof of Service 9578989.1 FR007-003 8. DECLARATION 0F CORI BRADBURY IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION‘TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 9. DECLARATION OF TOM ZIMMERMAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 10. DECLARATION 0F SARAH OSBORNE IN SUPPORT 0F DEFENDANT BOARD 0F TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 10 11. DECLARATION OF EDLIN CUTTS IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT 11 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO 12 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 1260 l4 Corporation Whitmorc 958 13 in the manner checked below on allinterested panics in this action addressed as follows: Suite CA LawMall, 14 Andrew Hillier 'Cassidy Paul Garcia Sacmmento‘ Capitol 15 Professional Hillier Law Lieben 600 W. Broadway, Suite 700 A 400 16 San Diego, CA 92-101 telephone: 619.500.7906 17 facsimile: 619.839.3895 email: andrew@ahillier1aw.com; 18 paul@ahi11ier1aw.com 19 M (BY OVERNIGHT MAIL) By overnight coun'er, I arranged for the above-referenced document(s) to be delivered to an authorized overnight courier service, FedEx, for 20 delivery to the addressee(s) above, in an envelope or package designated by the overnight coun'er service with delivery fees paid or provided for. 21 M (BY ELECTRONIC SERVICE) By electronically mailing a true and correct copy 22 through Liebert Cassidy Whitmore’s electronic mail system fiom mwibbenhorst@lcwlega1.com to the email address(es) set forth above. Idid not 23 receive, within a reasonable time afier the transmission, any electronic message or other indication that the transmission was unsuccessful. 2.4 -‘ 1' .. . Exécfitedz 2021, o'niMa‘ijclhy'l‘S, at Sacramento, California. | ' p25 d I V A 'zl‘declare'find‘e; pénglty ofpefiury under the laws Yof the State of California that the 26 foregoing is true and correct. ‘ ' QMQJu‘Q/LKQ Mariana Wibbenhorst U Vane» “fl “28' '3 ,_ Proof of Service 9578989.] FR007—003 THE DOCUMENT TO WHICH THlS CERTIFICATE IS - a ' ---------------------- I. ATTACHED IS A FULL. TRUE. AND CORRECT COPY Q, z ¢“~ ' OF THE ORIGINAL ON FILE AND OF RECORD IN i'gzg MY OFFICE. 4, ‘ .35: ATTEST: JUN 1 4 2021 fig SHERRI R. CARTER ‘ Executive Officer/Clerk of the Superior fl " i CO u I I ‘. ‘6 u L geles_ 1:3: $4,5- mas . £3“ B DEPUTY