On May 10, 115 a
No Value
was filed
involving a dispute between
Llerena, Ashel Alexander,
and
Granny'S Garden Ii Inc,
Rodriguez Chavez, Adrian,
for CIRCUIT CIVIL
in the District Court of Osceola County.
Preview
Filing # 193081406 E-Filed 03/01/2024 09:08:12 AM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
NINTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND
FOR OSCEOLA COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE NO. 2020 CA 002872 AN
ASBEL ALEXANDER LLERENA,
Plaintiff,
v.
ADRIAN RODRIGUEZ CHAVEZ AND
GRANNY’S GARDEN II, INC.,
Defendants.
/
DEFENDANTS’ SECOND AMENDED ANNOTATED LIST OF TRIAL EXHIBITS FOR
THE COURT’S MARKING
Objections Key:
(1) Admissibility (7) Relevance
(2) Authenticity (8) Unfair Prejudice
(3) Hearsay (9) Augmentation of Exhibit
(4) Immaterial (10)Court’s Ruling
(5) Lack of Foundation (11)All Other Objections
(6) Overly broad
COURT EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION DATE OF OPPOSING
ID LTR. NO. DOCUMENT COUNSEL’S
OBJ/INITIALS
1 Medical Records – Orlando 11/13/2009
Regional Medical Center
2 Medical Records – Joint 12/09/2019
Maneuvers Chiropractic Center, thru
PA 04/03/2020
3 Diagnostic Records – 12/10/2019
Akumin/Advanced Diagnostic thru
Group 03/27/2023
4 Medical Records – Integrity 01/24/2020
Medical Group thru
08/01/2022
COURT EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION DATE OF OPPOSING
ID LTR. NO. DOCUMENT COUNSEL’S
OBJ/INITIALS
5 Medical Records – Bud Docs 10/13/2020
thru
01/12/2022
6 Medical Records – Orlando 09/09/2021
Health – St. Cloud Hopsital
7 Medical Records – Spine & 02/20/2023
Orthopedic Specialists of thru
Central Florida 08/09/2023
8 Medical Records – Spine & 08/17/2023
Orthopedic Specialists of
Tampa
9 Medical Bill – Joint Maneuvers 12/09/2019
Chiropractic Center, PA thru
04/03/2020
10 Medical Bill – 12/10/2019
Akumin/Advanced Diagnostic thru
Group 03/27/2023
11 Medical Bill – BudDocs 10/13/2020
thru
01/12/2022
12 Medical Bill – Integrity Medical 01/24/2020
Group thru
08/01/2022
13 Medical Bill – Spine & 02/20/2023
Orthopedic Specialists of thru
Central Florida 08/09/2023
14 Medical Bill – Spine & 08/17/2023
Orthopedic Specialist of Tampa
15 Letter of Protection – Joint 12/09/2019
Maneuvers Chiropractic Center,
PA
16 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 12/10/2019
Advanced Diagnostic Group
17 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 12/30/2019
Advanced Diagnostic Group
18 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 12/04/2020
Advanced Diagnostic Group
19 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 08/19/2021
Advanced Diagnostic Group
20 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 06/06/2022
Advanced Diagnostic Group
21 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 02/23/2023
Advanced Diagnostic Group
COURT EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION DATE OF OPPOSING
ID LTR. NO. DOCUMENT COUNSEL’S
OBJ/INITIALS
22 Letter of Protection – Integrity 01/24/2020
Medical Group
23 Diagnostic films – Akumin/ Multiple dates
Advanced Diagnostic Group
24 Surveillance report 01/24/2022
thru
01/25/2022
25 Surveillance report 06/30/2022
26 Surveillance report 04/08/2023
27 Surveillance video 01/24/2022
thru
01/25/2022
28 Surveillance video 04/08/2023
29 Social Media – Facebook Multiple Dates
30 Social Media – Twitter Multiple Dates
31 Intentionally left blank
32 Social Media – Linked In
33 Photographs
34 Body cam footage
35 Discovery – Plaintiff’s 02/15/2021
Unverified Answers to
Defendants’ First Set of
Interrogatories
36 Discovery – Plaintiff’s 02/08/2023
Unverified Answers/Objections
to Defendants’ Updated
Interrogatories
37 Discovery – Plaintiff’s 07/21/2023
Unverified Answers/Objections
to Defendants’ Boecher
Interrogatories
38 Discovery – Plaintiff’s 01/15/2024
Unverified Answers/ Objections
to Defendants’ Supplemental
Interrogatories
39 Discovery – Plaintiff’s 01/15/2024
Unverified Answers/Objections
to Defendants’ Social Media
Interrogatories
40 Exhibit Removed – Intentionally
left blank
41 Curriculum Vitae of Marc Kaye,
MD
COURT EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION DATE OF OPPOSING
ID LTR. NO. DOCUMENT COUNSEL’S
OBJ/INITIALS
42 Curriculum Vitae of John A.
Jenkins, MD
43 Vendor History for National Life
Care Planners
44 Deposition Transcript – Asbel 08/13/2021
Alexander Llerena with exhibit
45 Deposition Transcript – Dr. 12/14/2023
Donald Behrmann with exhibit
46 Deposition Transcript – 01/08/2024
Silmarie Acevedo
47 Deposition Transcript – Timothy 01/16/2024
Bundy, D.O., CLCP, ATC with
exhibits
48 Deposition Transcript – Asbel 01/18/2024
Alexander Llerena
49 Deposition Transcript – Marc 02/28/2024
Kaye, MD (Transcript to be
received and may include
exhibits)
50 Deposition Transcript – Timothy 03/06/2024
Bundy, D.O., CLCP, ATC
(Transcript to be received and
may include exhibits)
• Defendant reserves the right to enter in any discovery responses and production
documents filed by any party in this case.
• The above-described annotated trial exhibits were disclosed to the Plaintiff via
Dropbox and previously disclosed during the exhibit exchange/attorney meeting.
Defendant also reserves the right to Amend this Annotated Exhibit List as trial
deposition testimony is currently ongoing.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 1st day of March, 2024, a true and correct copy
of the foregoing was filed with the Clerk of Osceola County by using the Florida Courts e-
Filing Portal, which will send an automatic e-mail message to the following parties
registered with the e-Filing Portal system: Melissa Alzate, Esq., Morgan & Morgan, P.A.,
malzate@forthepeople.com; imerlos@forthepeople.com; anajera@forthepeople.com,
198 Broadway Avenue, Kissimmee, FL 34741, (407) 452-1597/(407) 452-1623 (F),
Attorney for Plaintiff, Asbel Alexander Llerena.
COLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A.
Counsel for Defendant ADRIAN RODRIGUEZ
CHAVEZ AND GRANNY'S GARDEN II, INC.
Tower Place, Suite 400
1900 Summit Tower Boulevard
Orlando, Florida 32810
Telephone (321) 972-0011
Facsimile (321) 972-0099
Primary e-mail: scott.shelton@csklegal.com
Secondary e-mail: gary.lewis@csklegal.com
Alternate e-mail:
sandra.mcintosh@csklegal.com
By: /s/ Gary L. Lewis
SCOTT A. SHELTON
Florida Bar No.: 36486
GARY L. LEWIS
Florida Bar No.: 158887
Document Filed Date
March 05, 2024
Case Filing Date
May 10, 115
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
Filing # 193081406 E-Filed 03/01/2024 09:08:12 AM IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE NINTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN AND FOR OSCEOLA COUNTY, FLORIDA CASE NO. 2020 CA 002872 AN ASBEL ALEXANDER LLERENA, Plaintiff, v. ADRIAN RODRIGUEZ CHAVEZ AND GRANNY’S GARDEN II, INC., Defendants. / DEFENDANTS’ SECOND AMENDED ANNOTATED LIST OF TRIAL EXHIBITS FOR THE COURT’S MARKING Objections Key: (1) Admissibility (7) Relevance (2) Authenticity (8) Unfair Prejudice (3) Hearsay (9) Augmentation of Exhibit (4) Immaterial (10)Court’s Ruling (5) Lack of Foundation (11)All Other Objections (6) Overly broad COURT EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION DATE OF OPPOSING ID LTR. NO. DOCUMENT COUNSEL’S OBJ/INITIALS 1 Medical Records – Orlando 11/13/2009 Regional Medical Center 2 Medical Records – Joint 12/09/2019 Maneuvers Chiropractic Center, thru PA 04/03/2020 3 Diagnostic Records – 12/10/2019 Akumin/Advanced Diagnostic thru Group 03/27/2023 4 Medical Records – Integrity 01/24/2020 Medical Group thru 08/01/2022 COURT EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION DATE OF OPPOSING ID LTR. NO. DOCUMENT COUNSEL’S OBJ/INITIALS 5 Medical Records – Bud Docs 10/13/2020 thru 01/12/2022 6 Medical Records – Orlando 09/09/2021 Health – St. Cloud Hopsital 7 Medical Records – Spine & 02/20/2023 Orthopedic Specialists of thru Central Florida 08/09/2023 8 Medical Records – Spine & 08/17/2023 Orthopedic Specialists of Tampa 9 Medical Bill – Joint Maneuvers 12/09/2019 Chiropractic Center, PA thru 04/03/2020 10 Medical Bill – 12/10/2019 Akumin/Advanced Diagnostic thru Group 03/27/2023 11 Medical Bill – BudDocs 10/13/2020 thru 01/12/2022 12 Medical Bill – Integrity Medical 01/24/2020 Group thru 08/01/2022 13 Medical Bill – Spine & 02/20/2023 Orthopedic Specialists of thru Central Florida 08/09/2023 14 Medical Bill – Spine & 08/17/2023 Orthopedic Specialist of Tampa 15 Letter of Protection – Joint 12/09/2019 Maneuvers Chiropractic Center, PA 16 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 12/10/2019 Advanced Diagnostic Group 17 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 12/30/2019 Advanced Diagnostic Group 18 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 12/04/2020 Advanced Diagnostic Group 19 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 08/19/2021 Advanced Diagnostic Group 20 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 06/06/2022 Advanced Diagnostic Group 21 Letter of Protection – Akumin/ 02/23/2023 Advanced Diagnostic Group COURT EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION DATE OF OPPOSING ID LTR. NO. DOCUMENT COUNSEL’S OBJ/INITIALS 22 Letter of Protection – Integrity 01/24/2020 Medical Group 23 Diagnostic films – Akumin/ Multiple dates Advanced Diagnostic Group 24 Surveillance report 01/24/2022 thru 01/25/2022 25 Surveillance report 06/30/2022 26 Surveillance report 04/08/2023 27 Surveillance video 01/24/2022 thru 01/25/2022 28 Surveillance video 04/08/2023 29 Social Media – Facebook Multiple Dates 30 Social Media – Twitter Multiple Dates 31 Intentionally left blank 32 Social Media – Linked In 33 Photographs 34 Body cam footage 35 Discovery – Plaintiff’s 02/15/2021 Unverified Answers to Defendants’ First Set of Interrogatories 36 Discovery – Plaintiff’s 02/08/2023 Unverified Answers/Objections to Defendants’ Updated Interrogatories 37 Discovery – Plaintiff’s 07/21/2023 Unverified Answers/Objections to Defendants’ Boecher Interrogatories 38 Discovery – Plaintiff’s 01/15/2024 Unverified Answers/ Objections to Defendants’ Supplemental Interrogatories 39 Discovery – Plaintiff’s 01/15/2024 Unverified Answers/Objections to Defendants’ Social Media Interrogatories 40 Exhibit Removed – Intentionally left blank 41 Curriculum Vitae of Marc Kaye, MD COURT EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION DATE OF OPPOSING ID LTR. NO. DOCUMENT COUNSEL’S OBJ/INITIALS 42 Curriculum Vitae of John A. Jenkins, MD 43 Vendor History for National Life Care Planners 44 Deposition Transcript – Asbel 08/13/2021 Alexander Llerena with exhibit 45 Deposition Transcript – Dr. 12/14/2023 Donald Behrmann with exhibit 46 Deposition Transcript – 01/08/2024 Silmarie Acevedo 47 Deposition Transcript – Timothy 01/16/2024 Bundy, D.O., CLCP, ATC with exhibits 48 Deposition Transcript – Asbel 01/18/2024 Alexander Llerena 49 Deposition Transcript – Marc 02/28/2024 Kaye, MD (Transcript to be received and may include exhibits) 50 Deposition Transcript – Timothy 03/06/2024 Bundy, D.O., CLCP, ATC (Transcript to be received and may include exhibits) • Defendant reserves the right to enter in any discovery responses and production documents filed by any party in this case. • The above-described annotated trial exhibits were disclosed to the Plaintiff via Dropbox and previously disclosed during the exhibit exchange/attorney meeting. Defendant also reserves the right to Amend this Annotated Exhibit List as trial deposition testimony is currently ongoing. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 1st day of March, 2024, a true and correct copy of the foregoing was filed with the Clerk of Osceola County by using the Florida Courts e- Filing Portal, which will send an automatic e-mail message to the following parties registered with the e-Filing Portal system: Melissa Alzate, Esq., Morgan & Morgan, P.A., malzate@forthepeople.com; imerlos@forthepeople.com; anajera@forthepeople.com, 198 Broadway Avenue, Kissimmee, FL 34741, (407) 452-1597/(407) 452-1623 (F), Attorney for Plaintiff, Asbel Alexander Llerena. COLE, SCOTT & KISSANE, P.A. Counsel for Defendant ADRIAN RODRIGUEZ CHAVEZ AND GRANNY'S GARDEN II, INC. Tower Place, Suite 400 1900 Summit Tower Boulevard Orlando, Florida 32810 Telephone (321) 972-0011 Facsimile (321) 972-0099 Primary e-mail: scott.shelton@csklegal.com Secondary e-mail: gary.lewis@csklegal.com Alternate e-mail: sandra.mcintosh@csklegal.com By: /s/ Gary L. Lewis SCOTT A. SHELTON Florida Bar No.: 36486 GARY L. LEWIS Florida Bar No.: 158887