Complaint,Petition: MICHAEL LEVINE, ET AL. VS MONTALBA ARCHITECTS, INC., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION, ET AL.

• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                Electronically FILED by Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles on 03/06/2023 07:33 PM David W. Slayton, Executive Officer/Clerk of Court, by C. Meeks,Deputy Clerk


                                                                                                                                                                          012 ””•
                                                                                      19SMCV01966


                                           0122340ÿ
                                       ÿÿ6789968 
                                                                                                                                             #ÿÿ$ ÿ%
                                                                                                                                         $ÿ1ÿ$ÿ ÿÿ "
                              ÿ !"
           43&'6(ÿ&3ÿ6)300*(+(4*,4&-
           .$ÿÿ/ !"0ÿ
           +,-.ÿ0ÿ1234562ÿ0778ÿ9:;<5=9>?8
           ™31ÿ,)(ÿÙ('4Úÿ01(*ÿٙÿ6)300632wŒ,'4,4&-
           ÿ$Ûÿ !ÿÿ ! "0
           @ABCDCBÿBFAGHÿCIFJKFILGMÿCJBN
             ÿÿÿÿ™8šÿ›œ—ÿ•ÿ6,Œ(4*,)ÿ*,™0ÿ˜—7ÿ›9ÿ9š 89ÿžÿ—–ÿ —79ÿ7—ÿ9—7œ—žÿ8ÿŸ8šÿ8ÿ˜—ÿÿ7—ÿ7—9 89—ÿÿ›9ÿ¡8š7ÿžÿ›œ—ÿÿ
             ¡8 Ÿÿ9—7œ—žÿ8ÿ›—ÿ¡7899¡8 ¢ÿÿ,ÿ——7ÿ87ÿ›8—ÿ¡ ÿÿ8ÿ78—¡ÿŸ8š¢ÿ™8š7ÿ7—ÿ7—9 89—ÿ š9ÿ£—ÿÿ78 —7ÿ—–ÿ˜87 ÿ˜ÿŸ8šÿ
                ÿ›—ÿ¡8š7ÿ8ÿ›—7ÿŸ8š7ÿ¡9—¢ÿ&›—7—ÿ Ÿÿ£—ÿÿ¡8š7ÿ˜87 ÿ›ÿŸ8šÿ¡ÿš9—ÿ˜87ÿŸ8š7ÿ7—9 89—¢ÿ™8šÿ¡ÿ˜žÿ›—9—ÿ¡8š7ÿ˜87 9ÿžÿ 87—ÿ
             ˜87 8ÿÿ›—ÿ6˜87ÿ68š79ÿ3—ÿ0—˜v— ÿ6——7ÿ¤¤¤¥¦§¨©ª«¬­§¥¦®¥̄§°±²³´­µ³´¶"·ÿŸ8š7ÿ¡8šŸÿ ÿ£77Ÿ·ÿ87ÿ›—ÿ¡8š7›8š9—ÿ
             —7—9ÿŸ8š¢ÿÿÿ'˜ÿŸ8šÿ¡8ÿŸÿ›—ÿ˜–ÿ˜——·ÿ9¸ÿ›—ÿ¡8š7ÿ¡—7¸ÿ˜87ÿÿ˜——ÿœ—7ÿ˜87 ¢ÿ'˜ÿŸ8šÿž8ÿ8ÿ˜—ÿŸ8š7ÿ7—9 89—ÿ8ÿ —·ÿŸ8šÿ Ÿÿ
              89—ÿ›—ÿ¡9—ÿ£Ÿÿž—˜š·ÿžÿŸ8š7ÿ–—9·ÿ 8—Ÿ·ÿžÿ78 —7Ÿÿ Ÿÿ£—ÿ¸—ÿ›8šÿ˜š7›—7ÿ7–ÿ˜78 ÿ›—ÿ¡8š7¢ÿ
             ÿÿÿÿÿ&›—7—ÿ7—ÿ8›—7ÿ—–ÿ7—¹š7— —9¢ÿ™8šÿ Ÿÿÿ8ÿ¡ ÿÿ87—Ÿÿ7–›ÿ Ÿ¢ÿ'˜ÿŸ8šÿž8ÿ8ÿ̧8 ÿÿ87—Ÿ·ÿŸ8šÿ Ÿÿÿ8ÿ¡ ÿÿ
             87—Ÿÿ7—˜—77ÿ9—7œ¡—¢ÿ'˜ÿŸ8šÿ¡8ÿ˜˜87žÿÿ87—Ÿ·ÿŸ8šÿ Ÿÿ£—ÿ—–£—ÿ˜87ÿ˜7——ÿ—–ÿ9—7œ¡—9ÿ˜78 ÿÿ8 78˜ÿ—–ÿ9—7œ¡—9ÿ
               78–7 ¢ÿ™8šÿ¡ÿ8¡—ÿ›—9—ÿ8 78˜ÿ–78š 9ÿÿ›—ÿ6˜87ÿŒ—–ÿ0—7œ¡—9ÿº—£ÿ9—ÿ¤¤¤¥́®¤µ³´¶¦®´«­§©¬«®¥§©¯"·ÿ›—ÿ6˜87ÿ
             68š79ÿ3—ÿ0—˜v— ÿ6——7ÿ¤¤¤¥¦§¨©ª«¬­§¥¦®¥̄§°±²³´­µ³´¶"·ÿ87ÿ£Ÿÿ¡8¡–ÿŸ8š7ÿ8¡ÿ¡8š7ÿ87ÿ¡8šŸÿ£7ÿ998¡8¢ÿÿ43&(-ÿ&›—ÿ
             ¡8š7ÿ›9ÿÿ9š87Ÿÿ—ÿ˜87ÿœ—žÿ˜——9ÿžÿ¡899ÿ8ÿŸÿ9—— —ÿ87ÿ7£78ÿ 7žÿ8˜ÿ»”•·•••ÿ87ÿ 87—ÿÿÿ¡œÿ¡9—¢ÿ&›—ÿ¡8š7¼9ÿ
              —ÿ š9ÿ£—ÿžÿ£—˜87—ÿ›—ÿ¡8š7ÿÿž9 99ÿ›—ÿ¡9—¢
            ÿÿÿÿÿ«³¬³ÿ½¾ÿ¿$ÿ ÿ ÿÀ³²¶¨Á²ÿÀ³ÿ¨³ÿ́³ÿ³¬ª©³¯¨³¬ÿ³²ª®ÿ¦«ª®¦«Ã¬ÿÄÿ¶®¶³³́²ÿ́³¯®³́²ÿ¶®©®ÿ¶©³²³¬ª®©ÿ̈¬®ÿ©³²¶¨³²ª®ÿ¶§©ÿ³²Â©«ª§ÿ
            ³¬ÿ³²ª®ÿ¦§©ª³ÿÄÿµ®¦³©ÿ¨³ÿ²³ÿ³¬ª©³¯¨³ÿ̈¬®ÿ¦§¶«®ÿ®ÿ́ÿ¦§¬ª©®À³Å®¬À®¬ª³¥ÿÿ¬®ÿ¦®©ª®ÿ§ÿ̈¬®ÿ́´®Å®À®ÿª³³́­Ã¬«¦®ÿ¬§ÿ́§ÿ¶©§ª³¯³¬¥ÿÿ$¨ÿ©³²¶¨³²ª®ÿ
            ¶§©ÿ³²¦©«ª§ÿª«³¬³ÿ¨³ÿ³²ª®©ÿ³¬ÿ­§©Å®ª§ÿ́³¯®ÿ́¦§©©³¦ª§ÿ²«ÿÀ³²³®ÿ¨³ÿ¶©§¦³²³¬ÿ²¨ÿ¦®²§ÿ³¬ÿ́®ÿ¦§©ª³¥ÿÿ²ÿ¶§²«Æ³́ÿ¨³ÿµ®Ä®ÿ̈¬ÿ­§©Å¨´®©«§ÿ¨³ÿ
            ¨²ª³Àÿ¶¨³À®ÿ̈²®©ÿ¶®©®ÿ²¨ÿ©³²¶¨³²ª®¥ÿÿÿ1¨³À³ÿ³¬¦§¬ª©®©ÿ³²ª§²ÿ­§©Å¨´®©«§²ÿÀ³ÿ́®ÿ¦§©ª³ÿÄÿÅDzÿ«¬­§©Å®¦«Ã¬ÿ³¬ÿ³ÿ́³¬ª©§ÿÀ³ÿĨÀ®ÿÀ³ÿ́®²ÿ
            §©ª³²ÿÀ³ÿ®´«­§©¬«®ÿÈ ¢9š¡87—¢¡¢–8œÉÊÿ³¬ÿ́®ÿÆ«Æ´«§ª³¦®ÿÀ³ÿ́³Ä³²ÿÀ³ÿ²¨ÿ¦§¬À®À§ÿ§ÿ³¬ÿ́®ÿ¦§©ª³ÿ¨³ÿ́³ÿ¨³À³ÿÅDzÿ¦³©¦®¥ÿÿ$«ÿ¬§ÿ¶¨³À³ÿ
            ¶®¯®©ÿ́®ÿ¦¨§ª®ÿÀ³ÿ¶©³²³¬ª®¦«Ã¬Êÿ¶«À®ÿ®ÿ́²³¦©³ª®©«§ÿÀ³ÿ́®ÿ¦§©ª³ÿ¨³ÿ́³ÿÀÁÿ̈¬ÿ­§©Å¨´®©«§ÿÀ³ÿ³Ë³¬¦«Ã¬ÿÀ³ÿ¶®¯§ÿÀ³ÿ¦¨§ª®²¥ÿÿ$«ÿ¬§ÿ¶©³²³¬ª®ÿ²¨ÿ
            ©³²¶¨³²ª®ÿ®ÿª«³Å¶§Êÿ¶¨³À³ÿ¶³©À³©ÿ³ÿ́¦®²§ÿ¶§©ÿ«¬¦¨Å¶´«Å«³¬ª§ÿÄÿ́®ÿ¦§©ª³ÿ́³ÿ¶§À©Çÿ¨«ª®©ÿ²¨ÿ²¨³À́§ÊÿÀ«¬³©§ÿÄÿÆ«³¬³²ÿ²«¬ÿÅDzÿ®À°³©ª³¬¦«®¥ÿ
            ÿÿÿÿÿÌ®Äÿ§ª©§²ÿ©³Â¨«²«ª§²ÿ́³¯®³́²¥ÿÿ²ÿ©³¦§Å³¬À®Æ³́ÿ¨³ÿ́´®Å³ÿ®ÿ̈¬ÿ®Æ§¯®À§ÿ«¬Å³À«®ª®Å³¬ª³¥ÿÿ$«ÿ¬§ÿ¦§¬§¦³ÿ®ÿ̈¬ÿ®Æ§¯®À§Êÿ¶¨³À³ÿ́´®Å®©ÿ®ÿ̈¬ÿ
            ²³©°«¦«§ÿÀ³ÿ©³Å«²«Ã¬ÿ®ÿ®Æ§¯®À§²¥ÿÿ$«ÿ¬§ÿ¶¨³À³ÿ¶®¯®©ÿ®ÿ̈¬ÿ®Æ§¯®À§Êÿ³²ÿ¶§²«Æ³́ÿ¨³ÿ¦¨Å¶´®ÿ¦§¬ÿ́§²ÿ©³Â¨«²«ª§²ÿ¶®©®ÿ§Æª³¬³©ÿ²³©°«¦«§²ÿ́³¯®³́²ÿ
            ¯©®ª¨«ª§²ÿÀ³ÿ̈¬ÿ¶©§¯©®Å®ÿÀ³ÿ²³©°«¦«§²ÿ́³¯®³́²ÿ²«¬ÿ­«¬³²ÿÀ³ÿ́¨¦©§¥ÿÿ1¨³À³ÿ³¬¦§¬ª©®©ÿ³²ª§²ÿ̄©¨¶§²ÿ²«¬ÿ­«¬³²ÿÀ³ÿ́¨¦©§ÿ³¬ÿ³ÿ́²«ª«§ÿ¤³ÆÿÀ³ÿ
            ®´«­§©¬«®ÿ³¯®ÿ́$³©°«¦³²ÊÿÈ ¢ ›— ¡˜87¢87–É·ÿ³¬ÿ³ÿ́³¬ª©§ÿÀ³ÿĨÀ®ÿÀ³ÿ́®²ÿ§©ª³²ÿÀ³ÿ®´«­§©¬«®ÿÈ ¢9š¡87—¢¡¢–8œÉ·ÿ§ÿ
            §¬«Á¬À§²³ÿ³¬ÿ¦§¬ª®¦ª§ÿ¦§¬ÿ́®ÿ¦§©ª³ÿ§ÿ³ÿ́¦§³́¯«§ÿÀ³ÿ®Æ§¯®À§²ÿ́§¦®³́²¥ÿ.$0ÿ1§©ÿ́³ÄÊÿ́®ÿ¦§©ª³ÿª«³¬³ÿÀ³©³¦µ§ÿ®ÿ©³¦´®Å®©ÿ́®²ÿ¦¨§ª®²ÿÄÿ́§²ÿ
            ¦§²ª§²ÿ³Ë³¬ª§²ÿ¶§©ÿ«Å¶§¬³©ÿ̈¬ÿ̄©®°®Å³¬ÿ²§Æ©³ÿ¦¨®Ấ¨«³©ÿ©³¦¨¶³©®¦«Ã¬ÿÀ³ÿÍξʾ¾¾ÿÃÿÅDzÿÀ³ÿ°®´§©ÿ©³¦«Æ«À®ÿųÀ«®¬ª³ÿ̈¬ÿ®¦¨³©À§ÿ§ÿ̈¬®ÿ
            ¦§¬¦³²«Ã¬ÿÀ³ÿ®©Æ«ª©®Ï³ÿ³¬ÿ̈¬ÿ¦®²§ÿÀ³ÿÀ³©³¦µ§ÿ¦«°«¥́ÿ«³¬³ÿ¨³ÿ¶®¯®©ÿ³ÿ́¯©®°®Å³¬ÿÀ³ÿ́®ÿ¦§©ª³ÿ®¬ª³²ÿÀ³ÿ¨³ÿ́®ÿ¦§©ª³ÿ¶¨³À®ÿÀ³²³¦µ®©ÿ³ÿ́¦®²§¥
           LMNÿOPQNÿPOSÿPSSTNUUÿY\ÿVMNÿ]YZTVÿ_U<ÿ                                                                 4ÜÝ;Lÿÿ7395ÿ݆ÿ2345ÿ„mBC@ÿGC@FHgdk<ÿ=>C@eBAÿEAÿGHICJK
           =cFÿdC@eBAÿjÿEgBAhhgidÿEAÿFHÿhCBkAÿAIJK                                             ÿ!ÿ"ÿ#!$%ÿ&'$$()ÿ*!")ÿ$ÿ"
           ìùßùáÿúÿßûøúàâøßÿ5ÿúüâùÿúÿ3úéÿ÷âÿáûáéÿ5ÿíááàûÿøûûéÿúüàùúüéá 2345ÿ789:5;<ÿ=>?@ABCÿEAFÿGHICJK
            ô88ÿíüàùúâÿ6ßèÿíááàûÿøûûéèÿ÷ÿðïð                                                           OPGQBRSOPTT
           LMNÿOPQNRÿPSSTNUURÿPOSÿVNWNXMYONÿOZQ[NTÿY\ÿ]TYUU^]YQXWP_OPOV̀UÿPVVYTONaRÿYTÿ]TYUU^]YQXWP_OPOVÿb_VMYZVÿPOÿPVVYTONaRÿ_U<
           =cFÿdC@eBAfÿFHÿEgBAhhgidÿjÿAFÿd?@ABCÿEAÿkAFlmCdCÿEAFÿHeCnHECÿEAFÿÿhCdkBHEA@HdEHdkAfÿCÿEAFÿhCdkBHEA@HdEHdkAÿopAÿdCÿkgAdAÿ
           HeCnHECfÿAIJKÿÞß
                          ÿ ààáâÿäåÿæçâáàèÿæéêåÿëìíîÿïðñòóôõÿöÿ÷àøéùúùûáÿ÷ûéüßèÿæéêåÿëìíîÿôýýïïôõ
            ìþàøâÿáûÿ0ÿ1øâ2ÿ334ÿ5ÿïðôóóÿì6ÿ÷7ß7øßÿìùàááùèÿìüøùáÿï8ðèÿîá9þúàùÿíáß7èÿßûøúàâøßÿïòòðÿ5ÿÿëóýõÿ8ó58óýïÿæÿßßûéüßéþàøâÿáûøâ2å7úÿöÿ
            7ßßøûàúúéþàøâÿáûøâ2å7ú                                                                                             RÿqNXZVa
           q3L5<                                                                2WNTrRÿ[a                                           =sEtpdkCJ
           =ÐAhÑHJ                                                              =uAhBAkHBgCJ
           =ÐCBÿBCCmÿCmÿIAB’ghAÿCmÿkÑgIÿIp@@CdIfÿpIAÿ€TYY\ÿY\ÿ4NTz_]NÿY\ÿ4ZQQYOUÿ=mCB@ÿÒÓuÔÕÖÕJ‘Jÿÿ
           =ÒHBHÿBpAeHÿEAÿAdkBAnHÿEAÿAIkHÿhgkHkgidÿpIAÿAFÿmCB@pFHBgCÿ€TYY\ÿY\ÿ4NTz_]NÿY\ÿ4ZQQYOUÿ=ÒÓuÔÕÖÕJ‘J
                                             43&'6(ÿ&3ÿ&v(ÿw()034ÿ0()x(*-ÿyYZÿPTNÿUNTzNS
             ˆ453“Š                          |{ D PUÿPOÿ_OS_z_SZPWÿ]TYUU^SN\NOSPOV{
                                             }{ D PUÿVMNÿXNTUYOÿUZNSÿZOSNTÿVMNÿ\_]V_V_YZUÿOPQNÿY\ÿ=IAhgmjJK
                                                   ~{ D YOÿ[NMPW\ÿY\ÿ=IAhgmjJK
                                                     ZOSNT