On June 01, 2016 a
Motion-Secondary
was filed
involving a dispute between
Dbp Investments,
King Plaza Center, Llc,
and
Does 1 - 10, Inclusive,
King Plaza Center,Llc,
Lai, Thanh,
Lien, Sovan,
Quach, Bua,
Voung, Dong,
for (26) Unlimited Other Real Property
in the District Court of San Mateo County.
Preview
1 STEVEN B. PISER, SBN 62414
LAW OFFICES OF STEVEN B. PISER
2 A Professional Corporation
1970 Broaday, Suite 600
3 Oakland, California 94612
Telephone: (510) 835-5582
4
JOHN L. FITZGERALD, SBN 126613
5 LAW OFFICES OF JOHN L. FITZGERALD
177 Bovet Road, Suite 600
6 San Mateo, California 94402
Telephone: (650) 638-2386
7 john j Ifitzgerald law.corn
Attorneys for DBP INVESTMENTS,
a California General Partnership
10
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
12 IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN MATEO
13
DBP INVESTMENTS, a California General ) LEAD CASE NO. CIV538897
14 Partnership, )
) (CONSOLIDATED WITH CASE NO.
15 Plaintiff ) 19CIV07118)
)
16 V. ) DBP INVKSTMKNTS'BJECTION TO
) TENTATIVE STATEMENT OF DECISION
17 KING PLAZA CENTER, LLC, a Delaware )
Limited Liability Company ) DEPT. 21
ls )
Defendant. )
)
)
20 )
)
22
DBP Investments objects to and requests the court delete the following portion of the
23
Court's Tentative Statement of Decision (at page 4) so that it not be included in the Court's
24
Statement of Decision, as it addresses an issue beyond the sole issue in this declaratory relief
25
action, that is, whether the I 997 REA continues to be effective:
26
"That being said, there is no provision in the agreement that precludes time restrictions.
27
To the contrary, Mr. DeVincenzi acknowledged there exists time restrictive parking
Lnn Otttees e/
Ssesen B. Pines 1
DBP INVESTMENTS'osr-TESAt BKIEV OESEETSONS TO TEN TA TlVE STATEMENT Ov BEETS son
currently on the property and there is no reason why through appropriate discussions the
parties cannot work out an acceptable agreement to accommodate both shoppers and
bowlers."
LAW OFFICES OF STEVEN B. PISER
A Professional Corporation
LAW OFFICES 0 . FITZGERALD
DATED: March 23, 2023
JO ZGERALD
Atto or DBP Investments,
aC 'rnia General Partnership
10
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
27
28
Ltnv Ofrteee of
Steven B. Pteev 2
DBP INVKSTMKNTS'OST-TRIAL BRIEF OBJECTIONS TO TENTATIVE STATEMENT OF DECISION
POSASB/EFS450
ATTORNEY OR PARTY WITHOUT ATTORNEY: STATE BAR NO: 126,613 PCR CctlRT USE ONLY
NAME John L. Fitzgerald
Faw NAMM Law Oisces of John L. Fitzgerald
B~REETADDREBR 177 Bovet Road, Suite 600
cnY: San Mateo BTATR CA ztp ccoE; 94402
TELEPHONE Noa 650-638-2386 FAX NO.:
EJJAIL ADDREBM John@II5tzgeraldlew.corn
ATTCRNEY FoR f~f: Plaintiff DBP investments
SUPERIOR COURT OF CAI.IFORNIA, COUNTY OF San Francisco
BTREmADDRFBB:400 County Center
MAILING ADDRESm
clTY AND TIP coDE: Redwood City, CA 94063
BRANCH NAME:
CASE NUMBEP5
P AINTIFF/PETITIONERlrtnp Invnofnnntn C II/538897
JUDICIAL OFFICER;
lxlnn pl nr t I I r
Honorable Robert D. Foiles
DEPARTMENT;
PR6OF OF ELECTRONIC SERVICE
21
1, I am atleast18 yesrs old.
s. My residence or business address is (spe4):
Law ONces of John L. Fitzgerald
177 Bovet Road
Ssn Mateo, CA 94402
b. My electronic service address is (Spec/fy)r
johnfe)lfitzgemldlaw.corn
2 Ielectmnlcslly served the following documents (exact Nfes):
DBP Investment's Objecgon to Tentsfive Statement of Decislpm
~ Ths documents served sre listed in an attachment. (Form POS-050(D)iEFS-050(D) msy be Used for this purpose.)
3. I electmnically served the documents listed in 2 as follows:
a. Name of person served: Steven McLellsn
On behalf of (name or names of pad/es mpmsented, if person sewed /s an attorney)/
King Plaza Center, LLC
b. Electronic service address of person served:
c. On (date): March 23. 2023
~x The documents listed in item 2 were served electronically on the persons snd in ths manner described in an attachment.
(Form POS-050(p)7EF~50(P) may be used for this pup)NATO.)
Date: March 23. 2023
I declare under penalty of petiury under the laws of the State of California that the for i consct.
JOHN L. FITZGERALD
ITYPE OR PRINT NAME OF DECLARANT) r A Lv x TtdfE oF DEOLARANTI
Psae1ot1
Fem Appmved fm OpSonsl Use PROOF OF ELECTRONIC SERVICE Cel. Rufes of Caus, nde 2.251
Judlalel Caunat of Cstfamls amv. aaulmoe.pov
POS-050/EFS.050 IRev. Feafuaa I, 201 n (Proof of Service)Electronic Filing and Service)
POS0050(P)/EFS450(P)
L SHORT TITLE:
DBP Investments, et al
!
CASE NUMSErc
rCIV530807
!
ATTACHINENT TO PROOF OF ELECTRONIC SERVICE (PERSONS SERVED)
(This attachment is for use with form PQS-050fEFS-050.)
NAMES, ADDRESSES, AND OTHER APPLICABLE INFORMATION ABOUT PERSONS SERVED:
Name of Person Served Electronic Service Address Date of Electronic Service
(lf ths person served is an attorney,
the party or psdies mpresented should
also be stated.)
Date: March 23, 2023
Janet Fogarty (King Plaza) jfogartylawfirm@yahoo.corn
Date March 23 2023
Steven B. Piser (DBP) esperanza@stevenpiser.corn&
Data
Date:
Date:
Date:
Date:
Data
Date:
Date:
ATTACHMENT To PROOF OF ELECTRONIC SERVICE (PERSONS SERVED)
Psgs 2 pt 2
F08450(PFEF0050(P) (Proof of Servioetalectronic Fisns snd Ssnrice)
IRev. Feereerr 1, 2011(
Document Filed Date
March 23, 2023
Case Filing Date
June 01, 2016
Category
(26) Unlimited Other Real Property
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
1 STEVEN B. PISER, SBN 62414 LAW OFFICES OF STEVEN B. PISER 2 A Professional Corporation 1970 Broaday, Suite 600 3 Oakland, California 94612 Telephone: (510) 835-5582 4 JOHN L. FITZGERALD, SBN 126613 5 LAW OFFICES OF JOHN L. FITZGERALD 177 Bovet Road, Suite 600 6 San Mateo, California 94402 Telephone: (650) 638-2386 7 john j Ifitzgerald law.corn Attorneys for DBP INVESTMENTS, a California General Partnership 10 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 12 IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN MATEO 13 DBP INVESTMENTS, a California General ) LEAD CASE NO. CIV538897 14 Partnership, ) ) (CONSOLIDATED WITH CASE NO. 15 Plaintiff ) 19CIV07118) ) 16 V. ) DBP INVKSTMKNTS'BJECTION TO ) TENTATIVE STATEMENT OF DECISION 17 KING PLAZA CENTER, LLC, a Delaware ) Limited Liability Company ) DEPT. 21 ls ) Defendant. ) ) ) 20 ) ) 22 DBP Investments objects to and requests the court delete the following portion of the 23 Court's Tentative Statement of Decision (at page 4) so that it not be included in the Court's 24 Statement of Decision, as it addresses an issue beyond the sole issue in this declaratory relief 25 action, that is, whether the I 997 REA continues to be effective: 26 "That being said, there is no provision in the agreement that precludes time restrictions. 27 To the contrary, Mr. DeVincenzi acknowledged there exists time restrictive parking Lnn Otttees e/ Ssesen B. Pines 1 DBP INVESTMENTS'osr-TESAt BKIEV OESEETSONS TO TEN TA TlVE STATEMENT Ov BEETS son currently on the property and there is no reason why through appropriate discussions the parties cannot work out an acceptable agreement to accommodate both shoppers and bowlers." LAW OFFICES OF STEVEN B. PISER A Professional Corporation LAW OFFICES 0 . FITZGERALD DATED: March 23, 2023 JO ZGERALD Atto or DBP Investments, aC 'rnia General Partnership 10 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 27 28 Ltnv Ofrteee of Steven B. Pteev 2 DBP INVKSTMKNTS'OST-TRIAL BRIEF OBJECTIONS TO TENTATIVE STATEMENT OF DECISION POSASB/EFS450 ATTORNEY OR PARTY WITHOUT ATTORNEY: STATE BAR NO: 126,613 PCR CctlRT USE ONLY NAME John L. Fitzgerald Faw NAMM Law Oisces of John L. Fitzgerald B~REETADDREBR 177 Bovet Road, Suite 600 cnY: San Mateo BTATR CA ztp ccoE; 94402 TELEPHONE Noa 650-638-2386 FAX NO.: EJJAIL ADDREBM John@II5tzgeraldlew.corn ATTCRNEY FoR f~f: Plaintiff DBP investments SUPERIOR COURT OF CAI.IFORNIA, COUNTY OF San Francisco BTREmADDRFBB:400 County Center MAILING ADDRESm clTY AND TIP coDE: Redwood City, CA 94063 BRANCH NAME: CASE NUMBEP5 P AINTIFF/PETITIONERlrtnp Invnofnnntn C II/538897 JUDICIAL OFFICER; lxlnn pl nr t I I r Honorable Robert D. Foiles DEPARTMENT; PR6OF OF ELECTRONIC SERVICE 21 1, I am atleast18 yesrs old. s. My residence or business address is (spe4): Law ONces of John L. Fitzgerald 177 Bovet Road Ssn Mateo, CA 94402 b. My electronic service address is (Spec/fy)r johnfe)lfitzgemldlaw.corn 2 Ielectmnlcslly served the following documents (exact Nfes): DBP Investment's Objecgon to Tentsfive Statement of Decislpm ~ Ths documents served sre listed in an attachment. (Form POS-050(D)iEFS-050(D) msy be Used for this purpose.) 3. I electmnically served the documents listed in 2 as follows: a. Name of person served: Steven McLellsn On behalf of (name or names of pad/es mpmsented, if person sewed /s an attorney)/ King Plaza Center, LLC b. Electronic service address of person served: c. On (date): March 23. 2023 ~x The documents listed in item 2 were served electronically on the persons snd in ths manner described in an attachment. (Form POS-050(p)7EF~50(P) may be used for this pup)NATO.) Date: March 23. 2023 I declare under penalty of petiury under the laws of the State of California that the for i consct. JOHN L. FITZGERALD ITYPE OR PRINT NAME OF DECLARANT) r A Lv x TtdfE oF DEOLARANTI Psae1ot1 Fem Appmved fm OpSonsl Use PROOF OF ELECTRONIC SERVICE Cel. Rufes of Caus, nde 2.251 Judlalel Caunat of Cstfamls amv. aaulmoe.pov POS-050/EFS.050 IRev. Feafuaa I, 201 n (Proof of Service)Electronic Filing and Service) POS0050(P)/EFS450(P) L SHORT TITLE: DBP Investments, et al ! CASE NUMSErc rCIV530807 ! ATTACHINENT TO PROOF OF ELECTRONIC SERVICE (PERSONS SERVED) (This attachment is for use with form PQS-050fEFS-050.) NAMES, ADDRESSES, AND OTHER APPLICABLE INFORMATION ABOUT PERSONS SERVED: Name of Person Served Electronic Service Address Date of Electronic Service (lf ths person served is an attorney, the party or psdies mpresented should also be stated.) Date: March 23, 2023 Janet Fogarty (King Plaza) jfogartylawfirm@yahoo.corn Date March 23 2023 Steven B. Piser (DBP) esperanza@stevenpiser.corn& Data Date: Date: Date: Date: Data Date: Date: ATTACHMENT To PROOF OF ELECTRONIC SERVICE (PERSONS SERVED) Psgs 2 pt 2 F08450(PFEF0050(P) (Proof of Servioetalectronic Fisns snd Ssnrice) IRev. Feereerr 1, 2011(