On March 21, 2019 a
Miscellaneous
was filed
involving a dispute between
Mahaffey, Ashley,
Mahaffey, Brian,
and
Colorama Wholesale Nursery,
Medina, Jose,
Wilson, Richard,
for Personal Injury Motor Vehicle Unlimited
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
CM 010
FOR COURT USE ONLY
ATTORNEY OR PARTY WITHOUT ATTORNEY Name Stat number and address
ROBERT WEINSTEIN ESQ 140412
ROBERT WEINSTEIN ASS
12401 Wilshire Blvd Ste 200 r
a t t m
Los Angeles CA 90025 4 c i
TELEPHONE NO 31O 2 I J J IC2 Fnx n o 310 7 85 3922
i n eC3
PLAINTIFFS BRIAN MAHAFFEY ASHLEY MAHAFFEY Ft
ATTORNeYFOR Name
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN BERNARD INO gAw s
s41 r
STREETADDRESS 247 W2St 3rd Street
MAILINGADDRESS 247 WeSt 3rd Street
CITYANDZIPCODE SaT7 Bernardino CA 92415 Y
1Ji
sr aNCHNnMe CIVIL DIVISION x
f l
f4 t al
CASE N 4nnE MAHAFFEY V WILSON
CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Complex Case Designation CASE NUMBER
Unlimited Q Limited Counter
Amount Amount 0 Q Joinder
UDGE
demanded demanded is Filed with first appearance by defendant
exceeds 25 000 25 000 or less Cal Rules of Court rule 3 402 DEPT
Items 1 6 below must be completed see instructions on page 2
1 Check one box below for the case type that best describes this case
Auto Tort Contract Provisionally Complex Civil Litigation
Auto 22 Breach of contracUwarranty 06 Cal Rules of Court rules 3 400 3 403
Uninsured motorist 46 Rule 3 740 collections 09 Antitrust Trade regulation 03
Other collections 09 Construction defect 10
Other PI PD VND Personal Injury Property Insurance coverage 18 Mass tort 40
Damage Wrongful Death Tort
Other contract 37 Securities litigation 28
Asbestos 04
Environmental Toxic tort 30
Product 24 Real Property
liability Insurance coverage claims arising from the
Medical malpractice 45 Q Eminent domain Inverse
above listed provisionally complex case
Other PI PD WD 23 condemnation 14
types 41
Wrongful eviction 33
Non PI PDWD Other Tort
Other real property 26 Enforcement of Judgment
Business tort unfair business practice 07
Civil rights 08 Unlawful Detainer
Q Enforcement ofjudgment 20
Defamation 13 Commercial 31 Misceilaneous Civil Complaint
Fraud 16 Residential 32 RICO 27
Intellectual property 19 Drugs 38 Other complaint not specified above 42
Professional negligence 25
Judicial Review Miscellaneous Civil Petition
Other non PI PDVVD tort 35
Asset forfeiture 05 Partnership and corporate governance 21
Petition re arbitration award 11 Other petition not specified above 43
Employment
Wrongful termination 36 Writ of mandate 02
Other employment 15 Other judicial review 39
2 This case Q is is not complex under rule 3 400 of the California Rules of Court If the case is complex mark the
factors requiring exceptional judicial management
Large d Large number of witnesses
a number of separately represented parties
b Extensive motion practice raising difficult or novel e Coordination with related actions pending in one or more courts
issues that will be time consuming to resolve in other counties states or countries or in a federal court
c Q Substantial amount of documentary evidence f Q Substantiai postjudgment judicial supervision
3 Remedies sought check all that apply a monetary b Q nonmonetary declaratory or injunctive relief c Q punitive
4 Number of causes of action s ecify ONE
5 This case is 0 is not a class action suit
6 If there are any known related cases file and serve a notice of related case You may use form C 015
Date March 18 2019
ROBERT W TNSTFTN S
SI TURE OF PARTY OR ATTORNEY FOR PARTY
TYPE OR PRINT NAME
NOTICE
Plaintiff must file this cover sheet with the first paper filed in the action or proceeding except small claims cases or cases filed
under the Probate Code Family Code or Welfare and Institutions Code Cal Rules of Court rule 3 220 Failure to file may result
in sanctions
File this cover sheet in addition to any cover sheet required by local court rule
If this case is complex under rule 3 400 et seq of the California Rules of Court you must serve a copy of this cover sheet on all
other parties to the action or proceeding
Unless this is a collections case under rule 3 740 or a complex case this cover sheet will be used for statistical purposes only
Page 1 of 2
Form a dopted for Mandatory Use
fc rt n neu i
CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Cal Rules of Court rules 2 30 3 220 3 400 3 403 3 740
Cal Standards of Judicial Administration std 3 10
Judicial Couneil of Cal rfomia W o in ca gov
CM 010 Rev July 1 2007J
ESSENTIAL ORMS
CM Q10
INSTRUCTtONS 4N HOW TO COMPLETE THE CflVER SHEET
To Plaintiffs and Others Filing First Papers If yau are filing a first paper for exampie a camplaint in a civil case yau must
compiete and file along with your first paper the Civi1 Case Cover Sheet cantained on page 1 This informa ion wilt be used to compile
s afistics abaut the types and numbers of cases filed You must complete items 1 thraugh 6 on the sheet in item 1 you must check
one box for the case type that best describes the case If the case fits both a general and a more specific type of case listed in item 1
check the more specific ane if the case has muitipie causes af action check he bax that best indicates the primary cause of actian
Ta assist you in completing the sheet examples of the cases that beiang under each case type in item 1 are provided below A cover
sheet must be filed only with yaur initial paper Failure ta file a caver sheet with the first paper filed in a civil case may subject a party
its counsel or bath to sanctians under rules 230 and 3 22Q of the Galifornia Rules of Caurt
To Parties in Rule 3 740 Collections Cases A collections case under rule 3 740 is defined as an actian for recovery of money
owed in a sum stated to be certain that is not more than 25 OOQ exclusive of interest and attorney s fees arising from a transaction in
which property services or money was acquired on credit A collections case does not include an action seeking the fo8awing 1 tort
damages 2 punitive damages 3 recovery of rea property 4 recovery of ersonal property or 5 a prejudgment writ of
a tachment 7he identification af a case as a rufe 3 740 collectians case on this form means that it will be exempt from the general
time for service requirements and case management rules unless a defendant files a respansive pleading A rule 3 740 collections
case wili be subject to the requirements for service and obtaining a judgment in rule 3 740
To Parties in Camplex Cases In complex cases only parties must also use the Civi Case Cover Sheet to designate whether the
case is complex If a plaintiff believes the case is complex under rule 3 4Q0 of fhe California f2utes of Court this rnust be indicated by
completing the appropr ate baxes in items 1 and 2 If a plaintiff designates a case as complex the cover sheet must be served with the
camplamt on aU parties to the action A defendant may file and serve no later than the time of its first appearance a joinder in the
plaintiffs designation a caunter designation that the case is nat complex or if the pfaintiff has made no designafion a designafion that
the case is complex
CASE TYPES AND EXANlP ES
Auto Contract
Tort
Auto 22 Personal Injur rlProperty Breach of ContracUWarrant 06 Provisionally Complex Civil Litigation Cal
Breach af Rentall ease Rules ot Court Rules 3 400 3 403
DamagelWrongful death
not unlawful detainer AntitrustlTrade Re9 ulation 03 1
Uninsured Motorist 46 if the Gontract
or wrangful eviction Construction Defect 10
case involves an uninsured
mofarisf ctaim subjecf fo ContractlWarranty Breach SelEer s Involving Mass Tort 40
Plaintiff not fraud or negligence Securities Litigation 28
arbitration check this item
Negligent Breachof ContracU Environmentallfaxic Tort 30
instead ofAuto
Warrant Insarance Coverage Claims
OtherPUPD WD Personal Injury Ofher Breach of Con ract Warranty arising from provisionally camplex
case type listed above 41
Praperty DamagelWrongful Death Callections e g money owed open
Tart baok accounts 09 Enfarcemenf of Judgment
Asbestas 04 Collection Case Seller PlaintiTf Enforcement of Judgment 20
Asbestos Property Damage Other Promissary Note Collections Abstract of Judgment Out of
Asbestos Persona Injury Case flun y
Wrongful Death Insurance Coverage jnot provisionally Confession af Judgment nan
Product Liability not asbestos or complex 18 domestic relations
toxic nviranmental 24 Auto Subrag8tion Sister State Judgment
Medical Malpractice 45 Other Coverage
Administrative Agency Award
Medical Malpractice Other Contract 37 nat unpaid taxes
Physicians Surgeons Contractual Fraud PetitionlGertificatian of Entry of
Other Frofessianal liealth Gare Other Contract Dispute Judgment on t7npaid Taxes
Malpractice Other Enforcement of Judgment
Real Property
Other PI PD WD 23 Case
Er inent Domain inverse
Premises iability e g slip Miscellaneaus Givil Complaint
Condemnation 14
and fall RICO 27
Wrangful Eviction 33
Intentional Bodily Injury PD WD Other Rea Other Complaint nat specified
e vandalism
Property e g quiet title 26
g assault a6ove 42
Writ of Passession of Real Property
intentional Inffiction of
Mortgage Foreclosure Declaratory Relief Only
Emotional Distress
Quiet Title Injunctive Relief Only non
Negligent lnfliction of harassmenf
Other Real Praperty not eminent
Emotional Dis ress Mechanics Lien
domain landlard tenant or
Other PI Pp WD
foreclosure Other Commercial Complaint
Non Pt1PDlWD Other 7ort Gase non tortlnon complex
Unlawful detalner
Business TortJUnfair Business Other Civil Com pI aint
Commercial 31
Practice p7 non tort non comp ex
Residentia 32
Civil Rights e g discrimination Miscellaneous C vi1 Petitian
Drugs 3 if the case involves illega
false arrest nat civil
drugs check this item atherwise Partnership and Corporate
harassment 08 Governance 21
port as Commercial or ResidentiaQ
C efamation e g sfander libel p her Petition naf specified
JudicialReview
above 43
Asset Forfeiture 05
Fraud 16 Civil Harassment
Petition Re Arbitration Award 11
lntelleckua Property 19 Warkplace Vialence
Prafessianal Neg li g ence 25 Writ af Mandate Q2
IderJDependent Adult
Legal Malpractice Writ Administrative Mandamus Abuse
Writ Mandamus on Limited Court
Other Professional Malpractice Election Cantest
Case Matter
not medicai or Jegal Petition for tVame Change
Writ Other Limited Court Case
Other Non PI PD WD Tart 35 Petition for Relief from Late
Review
Claim
Employment Other Judicial Review 39
dther Civil Petition
Wrongful Termination 36 Review of Health Officer Order
Other Employment 15 Notice of Appeal Labor
Commissioner Appeals
CM 010 Rev July 1 zoo t CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Page 2 of 2
r
ESSENTIAL FORINS
Document Filed Date
March 21, 2019
Case Filing Date
March 21, 2019
Category
Personal Injury Motor Vehicle Unlimited
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
CM 010 FOR COURT USE ONLY ATTORNEY OR PARTY WITHOUT ATTORNEY Name Stat number and address ROBERT WEINSTEIN ESQ 140412 ROBERT WEINSTEIN ASS 12401 Wilshire Blvd Ste 200 r a t t m Los Angeles CA 90025 4 c i TELEPHONE NO 31O 2 I J J IC2 Fnx n o 310 7 85 3922 i n eC3 PLAINTIFFS BRIAN MAHAFFEY ASHLEY MAHAFFEY Ft ATTORNeYFOR Name SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN BERNARD INO gAw s s41 r STREETADDRESS 247 W2St 3rd Street MAILINGADDRESS 247 WeSt 3rd Street CITYANDZIPCODE SaT7 Bernardino CA 92415 Y 1Ji sr aNCHNnMe CIVIL DIVISION x f l f4 t al CASE N 4nnE MAHAFFEY V WILSON CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Complex Case Designation CASE NUMBER Unlimited Q Limited Counter Amount Amount 0 Q Joinder UDGE demanded demanded is Filed with first appearance by defendant exceeds 25 000 25 000 or less Cal Rules of Court rule 3 402 DEPT Items 1 6 below must be completed see instructions on page 2 1 Check one box below for the case type that best describes this case Auto Tort Contract Provisionally Complex Civil Litigation Auto 22 Breach of contracUwarranty 06 Cal Rules of Court rules 3 400 3 403 Uninsured motorist 46 Rule 3 740 collections 09 Antitrust Trade regulation 03 Other collections 09 Construction defect 10 Other PI PD VND Personal Injury Property Insurance coverage 18 Mass tort 40 Damage Wrongful Death Tort Other contract 37 Securities litigation 28 Asbestos 04 Environmental Toxic tort 30 Product 24 Real Property liability Insurance coverage claims arising from the Medical malpractice 45 Q Eminent domain Inverse above listed provisionally complex case Other PI PD WD 23 condemnation 14 types 41 Wrongful eviction 33 Non PI PDWD Other Tort Other real property 26 Enforcement of Judgment Business tort unfair business practice 07 Civil rights 08 Unlawful Detainer Q Enforcement ofjudgment 20 Defamation 13 Commercial 31 Misceilaneous Civil Complaint Fraud 16 Residential 32 RICO 27 Intellectual property 19 Drugs 38 Other complaint not specified above 42 Professional negligence 25 Judicial Review Miscellaneous Civil Petition Other non PI PDVVD tort 35 Asset forfeiture 05 Partnership and corporate governance 21 Petition re arbitration award 11 Other petition not specified above 43 Employment Wrongful termination 36 Writ of mandate 02 Other employment 15 Other judicial review 39 2 This case Q is is not complex under rule 3 400 of the California Rules of Court If the case is complex mark the factors requiring exceptional judicial management Large d Large number of witnesses a number of separately represented parties b Extensive motion practice raising difficult or novel e Coordination with related actions pending in one or more courts issues that will be time consuming to resolve in other counties states or countries or in a federal court c Q Substantial amount of documentary evidence f Q Substantiai postjudgment judicial supervision 3 Remedies sought check all that apply a monetary b Q nonmonetary declaratory or injunctive relief c Q punitive 4 Number of causes of action s ecify ONE 5 This case is 0 is not a class action suit 6 If there are any known related cases file and serve a notice of related case You may use form C 015 Date March 18 2019 ROBERT W TNSTFTN S SI TURE OF PARTY OR ATTORNEY FOR PARTY TYPE OR PRINT NAME NOTICE Plaintiff must file this cover sheet with the first paper filed in the action or proceeding except small claims cases or cases filed under the Probate Code Family Code or Welfare and Institutions Code Cal Rules of Court rule 3 220 Failure to file may result in sanctions File this cover sheet in addition to any cover sheet required by local court rule If this case is complex under rule 3 400 et seq of the California Rules of Court you must serve a copy of this cover sheet on all other parties to the action or proceeding Unless this is a collections case under rule 3 740 or a complex case this cover sheet will be used for statistical purposes only Page 1 of 2 Form a dopted for Mandatory Use fc rt n neu i CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Cal Rules of Court rules 2 30 3 220 3 400 3 403 3 740 Cal Standards of Judicial Administration std 3 10 Judicial Couneil of Cal rfomia W o in ca gov CM 010 Rev July 1 2007J ESSENTIAL ORMS CM Q10 INSTRUCTtONS 4N HOW TO COMPLETE THE CflVER SHEET To Plaintiffs and Others Filing First Papers If yau are filing a first paper for exampie a camplaint in a civil case yau must compiete and file along with your first paper the Civi1 Case Cover Sheet cantained on page 1 This informa ion wilt be used to compile s afistics abaut the types and numbers of cases filed You must complete items 1 thraugh 6 on the sheet in item 1 you must check one box for the case type that best describes the case If the case fits both a general and a more specific type of case listed in item 1 check the more specific ane if the case has muitipie causes af action check he bax that best indicates the primary cause of actian Ta assist you in completing the sheet examples of the cases that beiang under each case type in item 1 are provided below A cover sheet must be filed only with yaur initial paper Failure ta file a caver sheet with the first paper filed in a civil case may subject a party its counsel or bath to sanctians under rules 230 and 3 22Q of the Galifornia Rules of Caurt To Parties in Rule 3 740 Collections Cases A collections case under rule 3 740 is defined as an actian for recovery of money owed in a sum stated to be certain that is not more than 25 OOQ exclusive of interest and attorney s fees arising from a transaction in which property services or money was acquired on credit A collections case does not include an action seeking the fo8awing 1 tort damages 2 punitive damages 3 recovery of rea property 4 recovery of ersonal property or 5 a prejudgment writ of a tachment 7he identification af a case as a rufe 3 740 collectians case on this form means that it will be exempt from the general time for service requirements and case management rules unless a defendant files a respansive pleading A rule 3 740 collections case wili be subject to the requirements for service and obtaining a judgment in rule 3 740 To Parties in Camplex Cases In complex cases only parties must also use the Civi Case Cover Sheet to designate whether the case is complex If a plaintiff believes the case is complex under rule 3 4Q0 of fhe California f2utes of Court this rnust be indicated by completing the appropr ate baxes in items 1 and 2 If a plaintiff designates a case as complex the cover sheet must be served with the camplamt on aU parties to the action A defendant may file and serve no later than the time of its first appearance a joinder in the plaintiffs designation a caunter designation that the case is nat complex or if the pfaintiff has made no designafion a designafion that the case is complex CASE TYPES AND EXANlP ES Auto Contract Tort Auto 22 Personal Injur rlProperty Breach of ContracUWarrant 06 Provisionally Complex Civil Litigation Cal Breach af Rentall ease Rules ot Court Rules 3 400 3 403 DamagelWrongful death not unlawful detainer AntitrustlTrade Re9 ulation 03 1 Uninsured Motorist 46 if the Gontract or wrangful eviction Construction Defect 10 case involves an uninsured mofarisf ctaim subjecf fo ContractlWarranty Breach SelEer s Involving Mass Tort 40 Plaintiff not fraud or negligence Securities Litigation 28 arbitration check this item Negligent Breachof ContracU Environmentallfaxic Tort 30 instead ofAuto Warrant Insarance Coverage Claims OtherPUPD WD Personal Injury Ofher Breach of Con ract Warranty arising from provisionally camplex case type listed above 41 Praperty DamagelWrongful Death Callections e g money owed open Tart baok accounts 09 Enfarcemenf of Judgment Asbestas 04 Collection Case Seller PlaintiTf Enforcement of Judgment 20 Asbestos Property Damage Other Promissary Note Collections Abstract of Judgment Out of Asbestos Persona Injury Case flun y Wrongful Death Insurance Coverage jnot provisionally Confession af Judgment nan Product Liability not asbestos or complex 18 domestic relations toxic nviranmental 24 Auto Subrag8tion Sister State Judgment Medical Malpractice 45 Other Coverage Administrative Agency Award Medical Malpractice Other Contract 37 nat unpaid taxes Physicians Surgeons Contractual Fraud PetitionlGertificatian of Entry of Other Frofessianal liealth Gare Other Contract Dispute Judgment on t7npaid Taxes Malpractice Other Enforcement of Judgment Real Property Other PI PD WD 23 Case Er inent Domain inverse Premises iability e g slip Miscellaneaus Givil Complaint Condemnation 14 and fall RICO 27 Wrangful Eviction 33 Intentional Bodily Injury PD WD Other Rea Other Complaint nat specified e vandalism Property e g quiet title 26 g assault a6ove 42 Writ of Passession of Real Property intentional Inffiction of Mortgage Foreclosure Declaratory Relief Only Emotional Distress Quiet Title Injunctive Relief Only non Negligent lnfliction of harassmenf Other Real Praperty not eminent Emotional Dis ress Mechanics Lien domain landlard tenant or Other PI Pp WD foreclosure Other Commercial Complaint Non Pt1PDlWD Other 7ort Gase non tortlnon complex Unlawful detalner Business TortJUnfair Business Other Civil Com pI aint Commercial 31 Practice p7 non tort non comp ex Residentia 32 Civil Rights e g discrimination Miscellaneous C vi1 Petitian Drugs 3 if the case involves illega false arrest nat civil drugs check this item atherwise Partnership and Corporate harassment 08 Governance 21 port as Commercial or ResidentiaQ C efamation e g sfander libel p her Petition naf specified JudicialReview above 43 Asset Forfeiture 05 Fraud 16 Civil Harassment Petition Re Arbitration Award 11 lntelleckua Property 19 Warkplace Vialence Prafessianal Neg li g ence 25 Writ af Mandate Q2 IderJDependent Adult Legal Malpractice Writ Administrative Mandamus Abuse Writ Mandamus on Limited Court Other Professional Malpractice Election Cantest Case Matter not medicai or Jegal Petition for tVame Change Writ Other Limited Court Case Other Non PI PD WD Tart 35 Petition for Relief from Late Review Claim Employment Other Judicial Review 39 dther Civil Petition Wrongful Termination 36 Review of Health Officer Order Other Employment 15 Notice of Appeal Labor Commissioner Appeals CM 010 Rev July 1 zoo t CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Page 2 of 2 r ESSENTIAL FORINS