Progressive Credit Union vs. Pabla, Piara S et al

Party(s) file Stipulation of Dismissal The parties stipulate that this action shall be dismissed with prejudice. Applies To: Progressive Credit Union (Plaintiff); Pabla, Piara S (Defendant); Pabla, Kulwinder K (Defendant); Baba Nanak Cab, Inc. (Defendant); Shiva Ji Cab, Inc. (Defendant); Nahar Singh Cab, Inc. (Defendant); Pabla, Gurdeep (Defendant); Dass, Jasmine (Defendant)

Endorsement on Motion to Continue Hearings (Settlement Pending) (50.0): ALLOWED (Dated: 1/30/18) notice sent 1/31/18 Judge: Leibensperger, Hon. Edward P

Defendant Progressive Credit Unions Motion to continue Hearings (Settlement Pending)

Opposition to Defendants Motion for Leave to File Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Progressive Credit Union

Letters Rogatory (COPY): RE: Lewis Snapper of 35 Hyacinth Road, Nashua, NH 03062. Dated: November 9, 2017. Original mailed to Attorney Jennifer Pinkham on 11/20/17. Judge: Freniere, Hon Diane

ORDER: COPY OF ISSUANCE OF COMMISSION OF LEWIS SNAPPER: This matter having come before the Court on the Defendants Motion for Issuance of a Commission and Letter Rogatory to order Lewis Snapper of 35 Hyacinth Road, Nashua, NH 03062, pursuant to G.L. c. 223A, sec 10 and upon good cause being shown to appear for and testify at a deposition, as set forth in the attached Exhibit B, Attachment 1. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT: 1. Defendants Motion for Issuance of a Commission and Letter Rogatory is hereby ALLOWED. IT IS HEREBY FURTHER ORDERED THAT: 2. All court reporters or stenographers authorized to administer oaths in the State of New Hampshire are hereby appointed a Commissioner to administer an oath and record the deposition testimony of Lewis Snapper of 35 Hyacinth Road, Nashua, NH 03062, pursuant to the applicable rules and consistent with the Commission. Dated: November 9, 2017. Original mailed to Attorney Jennifer Pinkham on 11/20/17. Judge: Freniere, Hon Diane

Endorsement on Motion for Issuance of Commission and Letter Rogatory to Out-of-State Witness (41.0): ALLOWED ALLOWED: The Order shall issue. Dated: November 9, 2017. Notices mailed 11/20/17. Judge: Freniere, Hon Diane

Piara S Pabla, Kulwinder K Pabla, Baba Nanak Cab, Inc., Shiva Ji Cab, Inc.s Memorandum in opposition to plaintiff Progressive Credit Unions Motion for Summary Judgment (Ref 33)

Opposition to Purported Assented to Motion For Issuance of a Commission and Letter Rogatory filed by Progressive Credit Union

Plaintiff Progressive Credit Unions Notice of defendants failure to file opposition to plaintiffs Motion for summary judgment (ref 33)

Defendant Piara S Pabla, Kulwinder K Pabla, Baba Nanak Cab, Inc., Shiva Ji Cab, Inc., Gurdeep Pablas Motion for issuance of a commission and letter rogatory to out-of-state witness (Nashua, NH)

Endorsement on Motion for Clarification Regarding Order (40.0): ALLOWED This Courts order of allowing Plaintiffs motion to coordinate dispositive motion hearings was NOT intended to grant the Defendants any reprieve from the discovery and summay judgment deadlines imposed by Judge Barrett. The Defendants shall serve its opposition to the Plaintiffs summary judgment motion, if any, by November 3, 2017 (in light of todays date) and Plaintiff shall have fourteen days to provide a reply brief. (Dated: 10/31/17) notice sent 11/1/17 Judge: Freniere, Hon Diane

Plaintiff Progressive Credit Unions Motion for Clarification Regarding Order

Endorsement on Motion to coordinate dispositive motion hearings (39.0): ALLOWED both motions will be heard on February 1, 2018 if then properly before the court. Summary Judgment paper if any shall be filed by January 25, 2018 Judge: Freniere, Hon Diane

Plaintiff Progressive Credit Unions Motion to coordinate dispostive motion hearings.

Piara S Pabla, Kulwinder K Pabla, Baba Nanak Cab, Inc., Shiva Ji Cab, Inc., Gurdeep Pablas Memorandum in opposition to 38 motion.

Progressive Credit Unions Memorandum of law in support of 38 motion.

Plaintiff Progressive Credit Unions Motion to dismiss defendants counterclaims under MRCP 12(b)(6)

Amended Answer Counterclaims and Jury Demand Applies To: Pinkham, Esq., Jenifer M (Attorney) on behalf of Baba Nanak Cab, Inc., Nahar Singh Cab, Inc., Pabla, Gurdeep, Pabla, Kulwinder K, Pabla, Piara S, Shiva Ji Cab, Inc. (Defendant)

Endorsement on Motion to amend the answer and present counterlcaim (34.0): ALLOWED After hearing

General correspondence regarding plaintiff PCUs motion for summary judgment (Plaintiffs scheduling request re: motion for summary judgment)

Opposition to motion to amend answer filed by Kulwinder K Pabla, Baba Nanak Cab, Inc., Shiva Ji Cab, Inc., Nahar Singh Cab, Inc. Applies To: Progressive Credit Union (Plaintiff)

Affidavit of compliance with Superior Court Rule 9A Applies To: Pinkham, Esq., Jenifer M (Attorney) on behalf of Pabla, Piara S (Defendant)

Defendant Piara S Pabla, Kulwinder K Pabla, Baba Nanak Cab, Inc., Shiva Ji Cab, Inc.s Motion to amend answer to present counterclaim

Endorsement on Motion for Defendants Under MRCP Rule 56(f) (33.0): ALLOWED Defendants motion is allowed. The Plaintiffs Rule 56 motion shall be heard no later than August 1st 2017. There shall be no further extensions granted to the defendants with respect to the hearing of the plaintiffs Rule 56 motion. (Dated: 5/1/17) notice sent 5/3/17

Opposition to 33 motion. filed by Progressive Credit Union

Defendant Piara S Pabla, Kulwinder K Pabla, Baba Nanak Cab, Inc., Shiva Ji Cab, Inc., Gurdeep Pablas Motion for under MRCP Rule 56(f)

ORDER: ORDER ON DEFENDANTS EMERGENCY MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE MOTION UNDER MASS. R. CIV. P. 56(f) After review, including consideration of plaintiffs opposition (Docket 30), Defendants Emergency Motion for Leave to File Motion under Mass. R. Civ. P. 56(f) (Docket 31) is ALLOWED in part and DENIED in part. So much of the motion as seeks delay of the Courts consideration of Plaintiff Progressive Credit Unions Motion for Summary Judgment (Plaintiffs Motion) (Docket 29) under Mass. R. Civ. P. 56(f) is DENIED without prejudice on the existing record. Treating defendants motion as one for an extension of time for defendants to respond to Plaintiffs Motion in light of the extenuating circumstances of defendants counsels vacation and trial schedule, it is ALLOWED. Defendants shall serve their response to Plaintiffs Motion as required under Superior Court Rule 9A(b)(5) by April 17, 2017. Nothing in this Order bars defendants from filing a properly supported motion for relief under Mass. R. Civ. P. 56(f) in addition to or as part of their response to Plaintiffs Motion. Plaintiff shall file the combined documents with respect to Plaintiffs Motion (other than original documents already filed as Docket s 29-29.4) by April 28, 2017. The hearing on Plaintiffs Motion shall remain as previously scheduled on May 8, 2017. Dated: March 28, 2016 Peter B. Krupp Justice of the Superior Court Entered and copies sent 3/29/17

Endorsement on Motion for Leave to File Motion Under MRCP Rule 56(f) (31.0): Other action taken After review, ALLOWED in part and DENIED without prejudice in part. See Order of same date. (Dated: 3/28/17) notice sent 3/29/17

Defendant Piara S Pabla, Kulwinder K Pabla, Baba Nanak Cab, Inc., Shiva Ji Cab, Inc., Nahar Singh Cab, Inc., Gurdeep Pabla, Jasmine Dasss EMERGENCY Motion for leave to file motion under MRCP 56(f)

Opposition to to defendants emergency motion for leave to file motion under Mass R Civ p 56 filed by Progressive Credit Union

Affidavit of compliance with Superior Court Rule 9A and receipt of no opposition in timely fashion. Applies To: Siegal, Esq., Jack Irving (Attorney) on behalf of Progressive Credit Union (Plaintiff)

Plaintiff Progressive Credit Unions Statement of undisputed material facts

Progressive Credit Unions Memorandum of law in support of P29 motion.

Plaintiff Progressive Credit Unions Motion for summary judgment, MRCP 56

Received from Defendant Pabla, Piara S: Answer with claim for trial by jury;

Plaintiff, Defendant Progressive Credit Union, Piara S Pabla, Kulwinder K Pabla, Baba Nanak Cab, Inc., Shiva Ji Cab, Inc., Gurdeep Pabla, Nahar Singh Cab, Inc.s Assented to Motion to Remove Default And File Answer Late

MEMORANDUM ORDER: MEMORANDUM OF DECISION AND ORDER ON PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR ATTACHMENT AND PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION: (See scanned image - 11 pages): ORDER: For the foregoing reasons, it is hereby ORDERED that: (1) Progressives Motion for Preliminary Injunction with respect to the Marital Home, located at 34 Flint Street, Somerville, Massachusetts is ALLOWED. Piara and Kulwinder Pabla are hereby enjoined from selling, transferring, or encumbering in any way their interest in 34 Flint Street, Somerville, Massachusetts, until further order of the Court; (2) Progressives Motion for Preliminary Injunction with respect to the taxi medallions is ALLOWED. Piara and Kulwinder Pabla and any entities owned or controlled by them, including Baba Nanak Cab, Inc., Shiva Ji Cab, Inc., and Nahar Singh Cab, Inc., are hereby enjoined by selling, transferring or encumbering any and all taxi medallion licenses, including City of Boston Medallion numbers 790, 1706, 919, 1597, 743 and 747, and City of Cambridge Medallion numbers 17 and 50 until further order of the Court; (3) Progressives Motion for Preliminary Injunction with respect to the following vehicles: (1) 2014 Camaro; (2) 2011 Lexus; (3) 2009 Toyota Tacoma; and (4) 2008 Land Rover is DENIED; (4) Progressives Motion for Preliminary Injunction with respect to 3 OConnor Lane, Woburn, Massachusetts and 142 Lincoln Street, Revere, Massachusetts, is DENIED; (5) Progressives Motion for Attachment is DENIED in its entirety. Dated 11/9/16. Copies mailed 11/14/16.

Service Returned for Defendant Pabla, Gurdeep: Service made in hand; 7/18/16, 2 Oliver Street, 10th Floor, Boston, MA 0209

Service Returned for Defendant Dass, Jasmine: Service made at last and usual; 7/20/16, 12 Vernon Street, Apt. 2, Wakefield, MA 01880 and by first class mail to same

Service Returned for Defendant Pabla, Kulwinder K: Service made in hand; 7/12/16, 3 OConnor Lane, Woburn, MA 01801

Service Returned for Defendant Pabla, Piara S: Service made in hand; 7/18, 2 Oliver Street, 10th Floor, Boston, MA 02109 and in hand to wife on 7/12/16 at 3 OConnor Lane, Woburn, MA 01801

Service Returned for Defendant Shiva Ji Cab, Inc.: Service made in hand; 7/12/16, 3 OConnor Lane, Woburn, MA 01801

Service Returned for Defendant Nahar Singh Cab, Inc.: Service made in hand; 7/12/16, 3 OConnor Lane, Woburn, MA 01801

Service Returned for Defendant Baba Nanak Cab, Inc.: Service made in hand; 7/12/16, 3 OConnor Lane, Woburn, MA 01801

Original civil complaint filed.