Online Privacy in California

What Are the Laws on Online Privacy?

The privacy of an individual’s information in California is protected by a number of legal sources, including the U.S. Constitution and Supreme Court rulings, Federal statutes, the California Constitution and California state laws governing information privacy.

Online Privacy - Background

The transmission and storage of personal information in the digital form has enabled entities to collect extensive digital records associated with a particular individual (e.g., emails, birth dates, social security numbers or state ID card information.) In addition online entities can obtain user information such as general location, hardware/software used, and browsing history (in a process known as “web tracking”), and add the info to a user’s stored record.

Records of an individual’s electronic information are used for beneficial purposes like rapid and efficient access to the data by vendors, banks and government entities completing transactions. They are also used for commercial goals like targeting advertising to an individual’s specific taste and interest, and a robust industry has sprung up around the collection and sale of “marketing lists” that let purchasers search the Internet history and commercial activities of their potential audience and reach them via the stored contact info (“list sales”).

Privacy and consumer groups have raised concerns around web tracking, list sales and other electronic info storage; while such practices improve the Internet’s efficiency and the relevance of commercial advertising to its audience, some Internet users feel it violates their sense of personal privacy.

Perhaps more importantly, the collection and storage of personal electronic data has also facilitated unprecedented fraud; such data can be intercepted and accessed by bad actors via the unauthorized accessing of digital spaces (“hacking” or “cracking”). For example, the credit agency Equifax was ‘hacked’ and millions of users’ credit and financial information was exposed online, accessible to anyone with an Internet connection.

The data can then be used to impersonate other individuals, gaining access to their property (e.g., via online banking) or acquiring property in their names (e.g., by obtaining a credit card in another’s name). Such fraudulent behavior is generally known as “identity theft.”

The principal protection against such misuse is encryption, whereby the information is translated into a medium unreadable by anyone without the digital key that re-translates the info into a legible form. In addition, a number of Federal and State laws have been adopted to regulate the practice of acquiring and storing private digital information, as well as requirements to notify users that their information is being collected and stored, how it is being used, and when it has been accessed, either with or without their permission. California has been at the forefront of such legislation.

California Digital Privacy Laws

California Constitution, Article 1, Section 1

The first line of California’s Constitution (after the Preamble) establishes that “All people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights...[including] privacy.”

California Senate Bill 1386 (2003) (“SB 1386”)

Effective July 1, 2003, SB 1386 was a measure adopted to help prevent identity theft by obliging entities who store Internet users’ personal information to notify each individual whose information is accessed without authorization via a security breach.

“Personal information” is defined as the unencrypted record of “an individual’s first name or first initial and last name in combination with” the individual’s:

  • Social security number.
  • Driver’s license number or California Identification Card number.
  • Account number, credit or debit card number, in combination with” any code or password permitting access to the “individual’s financial account.”

Notably, “personal information” does not include “publicly available information that is lawfully made available to the general public from federal, state, or local government records.”

Notice must be delivered either:

  • In writing;
  • Electronically in accordance with 15 U.S. Code § 7001 governing electronic records: In a manner to which the user has consented; or In a manner which is clearly and conspicuously communicated to the user, including updated notice to the user of software and hardware requirements necessary to access the notice;
  • Substituted notice (if the cost of notice exceeds $250,000 for an individual or $500,000 for a class, or if the entity does not have sufficient contact information), including E-mail notice; Conspicuous posting on the web site or at the place of business; Notification vis major statewide media.

Importantly, an entity can be liable for its intentional or negligent failure to notify affected users of a suspected breach.

California Online Privacy Protection Act of 2003 (“CalOPPA”)

Effective since July 1, 2004, California Business and Professions Code §§ 22575-22579 require that commercial entities on the Internet who collect California-based users’ “personally identifiable information” post a conspicuous privacy policy, which must contain several clauses.

Under BPC §22577(a), “personally identifiable information” includes:

  • First and last names;
  • Home or physical address (including street, city or town names);
  • Email addresses;
  • Phone numbers;
  • Social security numbers;
  • A catch-all including “[a]ny other identifier that permits the physical or online contacting of a specific individual”;
  • Information collected and connected to any of the above identifiers.

Under BPC §22577(b), the privacy policy must be “reasonably accessible,” including:

  • Posted on the Website’s: Home page; or First “significant page after entering the Web site”; OR
  • Linked to by a clearly visible icon or text link containing the word “privacy” and placed on the Website’s: Home page; or First “significant page after entering the Web site”.

Under Under BPC §22575(b), the privacy policy must:

  • Identify the categories of personally identifiable information collected;
  • Identify the categories of third-parties with whom the information may be shared;
  • Explain how users can review and request changes to their info collection or sharing;
  • Explain how the entity notifies users of changes to its privacy policy;
  • Identify the policy’s effective date;
  • Disclose (or link to an explanation of) how the entity responds to online mechanisms such as “Do Not Track” or ad-blocking software designed to prevent web tracking.

Anti-Phishing Act of 2005 (CA BPC §§ 22948-22948.3)

The Anti-Phishing Act prohibits anyone from using any electronic messaging to solicit the personal identifying information of a user by “representing itself to be a business without the authority or approval of the business.” The statute authorizes actions by the Attorney General, district attorneys, or private actors adversely affected by a violation.

BPC § 22948.1 defines “identifying information” to include a user’s:

  • Social security number.
  • Driver’s license number.
  • Bank account number.
  • Credit card or debit card number.
  • Personal identification number (PIN).
  • Automated or electronic signature.
  • Unique biometric data.
  • Account password.

Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (“CMIA”)

California Civil Code § 56 applies the requirements of California’s extensive CMIA, regulating the storage and transmission of a patient’s health data (including a requirement the patient provide consent to such transmission), to health info kept or sent in an electronic form.

Consumer Protection Against Computer Spyware Act (CA BPC §§ 22947 - 22947.6)

California’s Consumer Protection Against Computer Spyware Act prohibits intentionally placing spyware on a user’s computer, including deceptive means such as bypassing security measures to prevent spyware installation, concealing the installation of software or falsely representing that spyware is needed to access or view a Website’s data.

Spyware includes software that:

  • Modifies the user’s settings (e.g., bookmarks, default ISP, website home page)
  • Collects personally identifiable information:
    • Via a keystroke-logging function (software that records every key pressed by the user on the keyboard and transmits the information to another party);
    • Containing the user’s browsing history if installed in a deceptive manner; OR
    • That includes the user’s:
      • First name or initial and last name;
      • Credit / debit card or financial account numbers;
      • Password or PIN to a financial account;
      • Social Security number;
      • Info identifying a user’s: Account balances; Overdraft history; Payment history; Browsing history; Home or work address; Purchase record

The Act also prohibits the unauthorized taking control of another user’s computer, including ‘pop-up ads’ without the user’s consent.

Cyber-Bullying / Revenge Porn

“Cyber-bullying” includes a wide range of online harassment activities; included is “cyber-exploitation” (aka “revenge porn”), i.e., the act of posting images of an individual’s image or body without that individual’s consent. Several laws in the penal code prohibit such activity:

California Penal Code §§ 501-501.01 criminalizes the unauthorized access of another’s computer or Internet account (including, e.g., a social media profile) to use, copy, alter or delete their data in virtually any way. The code includes an exemption for incidental violations and data accessing that is “reasonably necessary to the performance of...lawful employment.”

California Penal Code §§ 639 - 653.2:

  • Expand “Peeping Tom” laws to electronic means of viewing and recording;
  • Criminalize the distribution of an image:
    • Containing another identifiable person’s intimate body part or sexual act;
    • When the persons involved understood the image would remain private;
    • The distributor knows the identified person will suffer emotional distress; and
    • The person identified suffers such distress.

The laws exempt images produced in the context of a lawful court or public proceeding.

California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (“CCPA”)

Background: A New Privacy Right

Effective January 1, 2020, the CCPA was adopted by the California legislature unanimously, and in many respects creates new privacy rights for online users residing in California. Prior laws are focused on prohibiting fraud and disclosure of: (i) when personal data is collected; (ii) how it is used; (iii) whether it has been compromised; and (iv) whether they have an opt-out provision. However, none universally require an opt-out provision.

By contrast, the CCPA’s legislative findings indicate that California’s Constitutional Privacy right (supra) includes “the ability of individuals to control the use, including the sale, of their personal information.” Thus the Act not only further regulates users’ right to disclosure by online entities who collect and trade their personal data, it grants users the right to request their data not be sold and even the affirmative right to have it deleted upon request.

Definitions And Applicability

Businesses Covered

The CCPA applies to business entities of all types (including subsidiaries) that:

  • Have annual gross revenues more than $25 million;
  • Derive 50 percent or more of its annual revenues from selling users’ personal info; OR
  • Buy or sell the personal information of 50,000:
    • Users;
    • Households; or
    • Devices.
Personal Information

“Personal information” means information that identifies, relates to, describes, is capable of being associated with, or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household. Personal information includes, but is not limited to, the following:

  • Identifiers such as a:
    • Real name;
    • Alias;
    • Postal address;
    • Unique personal identifier (defined as “a persistent identifier that can be used to recognize a consumer, a family, or a device that is linked to a consumer or family, over time and across different services, including, but not limited to, a device identifier,” including probabilistic identifiers that can make an educated guess as to a consumer’s identity);
    • Internet Protocol address;
    • Email address;
    • Account name;
    • Social Security number;
    • Driver’s license number;
    • Passport number; or
    • Other similar identifiers
  • Any categories of personal information described in subdivision (e) of Section 1798.80;
  • Characteristics of protected classifications under California or federal law;
  • Commercial information, including records of personal property and purchasing histories;
  • Biometric information;
  • Internet or other electronic network activity information, including, but not limited to, browsing history, search history, and information regarding a consumer’s interaction with an Internet Web site, application, or advertisement;
  • Geolocation data;
  • Audio, electronic, visual, thermal, olfactory, or similar information.
  • Professional or employment-related information.
  • Education information that is not publicly available under the Federal Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (20 U.S.C. section 1232g, 34 C.F.R. Part 99).
  • Inferences drawn from any of the information identified in this subdivision to create a profile about a consumer reflecting the consumer’s preferences, characteristics, psychological trends, preferences, predispositions, behavior, attitudes, intelligence, abilities, and aptitudes.

Notably, “personal information” does not include publicly available information.

Consumer’s Various Rights In Personal Data Under The CCPA

Right To Have Personal Information Deleted

The CCPA grants online users “The right to request that a business delete any personal information about the consumer which the business has collected from the consumer.” Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.105(a).

Moreover, sub (b) and (c) of § 1798.105(b) provide that the online entity must:

  • Notify users of their right to request that all their personal data be deleted;
  • Comply with any such request, deleting “the consumer’s personal information from its records”; and
  • “[D]irect any service providers” to do the same.

There are exceptions. An online entity can keep the data if it’s “necessary” to:

  • Complete the transaction for which the personal information was collected, provide a good or service requested by the consumer, or reasonably anticipated within the context of a business’s ongoing business relationship with the consumer, or otherwise perform a contract between the business and the consumer;
  • Detect security incidents, protect against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity; or prosecute those responsible for that activity;
  • Debug to identify and repair errors that impair existing intended functionality.
  • Exercise free speech, ensure the right of another consumer to exercise his or her right of free speech, or exercise another right provided for by law.
  • Comply with a lawful search warrant under CA Penal Code §§1546-1546.4;
  • Engage in public, peer-reviewed research that is, inter alia:
    • Pseudonymized and de-identified to prevent individual identification;
    • Include technical safeguards to prevent individual identification;
    • Include business processes to prevent inadvertent release of info;
    • Not be used for any commercial purpose; In the public interest;
    • Adhering to all other applicable ethics and privacy laws;
    • When deleting the data will “render impossible” or “seriously impair” the research;
    • Provided the consumer has informed consent.
  • To enable solely internal uses that are reasonably aligned with the expectations of the consumer based on the consumer’s relationship with the business.
  • Comply with a legal obligation.
  • Otherwise use the consumer’s personal information, internally, in a lawful manner that is compatible with the context in which the consumer provided the information.
“Opt-Out” For Sale of Personal User Data

Generally

Whether or not the sharing of user data with advertisers or other third parties will be “reasonably anticipated within the context of a business’s ongoing business relationship with the consumer” is likely to be hotly contested. But in any case, the CCPA grants users an opt-out: “[Users have t]he right, at any time, to direct a business that sells personal information about the consumer to third parties not to sell the consumer’s personal information.”

“Do Not Sell My Personal Information” Disclosure

Businesses are required to provide information explaining and facilitating the opt-out:

  • On a Webpage with a conspicuous link reading “Do Not Sell My Personal Information”;
  • In the business’ privacy policy; and
  • In any California-focused explanation of consumer’s privacy rights.

After the user’s opt-out, businesses must refrain from contacting a user for 12 months before again requesting that the user authorize the sale of their personal information.

Personal Data of Minors and Opt-In

As a catch-all, online entities with knowledge of users’ ages are prohibited from selling the personal information of individuals less than 16 years of age.

However, users less than 16 years of age can opt-in to the sale of their personal information upon consent of:

  • The users themselves if aged 13 to 16;
  • or The parent or guardian for users less than 13 years of age.

No Discrimination Against Users For Exercising CCPA Rights

In order to preserve its impact, the CCPA prohibits businesses from discriminating against users who exercise their rights under the Act. This includes:

  • Denying goods or services to the consumer;
  • Charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties;
  • Providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if the consumer exercises the consumer’s rights under this title.
  • Suggesting that the consumer will receive a different price or rate for goods or services or a different level or quality of goods or services.

However, businesses can offer differential prices, rates, levels and quality if the difference is “reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data.”

Users’ Financial Interest In Their Personal Data

Perhaps most intriguing about the CCPA is its formalization of a market for personal data by granting users a pecuniary interest in their own personal data.

Businesses can offer financial incentives, including payments to consumers, for the collection, sale or deletion of personal information, provided:

  • The compensation program and opt-out systems are clearly explained in the business’ “Do Not Sell My Personal Information” disclosure;
  • The user can opt-out at anytime;
  • The incentive program is unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious.

Disclosure under the CCPA

The CCPA imposes broad and detailed disclosure requirements on Internet entities that collect users’ personal data, far exceeding the extent offered by previous California law.

Warning before collecting personal data

Prior to any collection of personal data, the Act requires the online entity to disclose:

  • All such categories of personal info; and
  • How each category will be used.
Disclosure of Info Actually Collected, Used and Sold

Moreover, users can request that covered businesses disclose:

  • The categories of personal information the business has actually collected on the user;
  • The categories of personal info sources the business has actually collected on the user;
  • The business or commercial purposes for collecting the user’s personal information;
  • The categories of third persons with whom the user’s personal info was shared; and
  • The specific pieces of the user’s personal information that was collected.

In response to such a user request, the online entity must disclose the info, inter alia:

  • “Promptly,” within 45 days, although extensions may be granted;
  • “Free of charge;
  • In a readily usable format;
  • Divided into two lists:
  • Consumers’ personal information sold in the past 12 months;
  • Personal info disclosed for a business purpose in the past 12 months.
  • Delivered to the addresses the business has on record for the user;
  • Without requiring the user to create an account;
  • Covering all collection, uses and sale for the prior 12-month period;
  • Including the info category under which the information was collected;
  • Including the source category from which the info was collected; and
  • The commercial purpose of collecting that information.
“Do Not Sell My Personal Information” Disclosure

As stated supra, businesses must provide disclosures explaining and facilitating the opt-out by consumers from the sale of their personal information:

  • On a Webpage with a conspicuous link reading “Do Not Sell My Personal Information”;
  • In the business’ privacy policy; and
  • In any California-focused explanation of consumer’s privacy rights.
Disclosure for a One-Time Transaction:

Online businesses engaged in a “single, one-time transaction” are not required to retain personal data if they: Do not sell it; or Link to it “in a manner that would be considered personal information.”

Use of Personal Information For Business Purpose

Online businesses that reveal users’ personal information for a “business purpose” (an operational purpose of the businesses reliant upon that information) must disclose those business purposes upon request by a user. Such purposes may include:

  • Auditing ongoing interactions with the user, including assessing ad impressions, placement and relevance;

  • Security detection and preventing malicious, fraudulent or illegal activity (including the prosecution thereof);

  • Debugging;

  • Short-term, transient use of info that is:

  • Not disclosed to a third party and

  • Not used to build a consumer profile (including ad targeting);

  • Performing services for the business, including:

  • Account maintenance;

  • Payments;

  • Customer Service;

  • Order fulfillment;

  • Customer Verification;

  • Advertising and Marketing

  • Analytics; or

  • A catch-all for similar services on behalf of the business.

  • Internal research for technological development and demonstration.

  • Quality or safety control of a service or device that is owned, made or used by the business to enhance the business’ service or product.

Method of Requesting Disclosure

In order to comply with the Act, online entities that collect personal data must provide and notify users of at least two methods for submitting disclosure requests, including: A toll-free phone number; and An Internet Web site.

Privacy Policy

The business’s Privacy Policy must disclose all of the users’ rights:

  • To request an accounting of their personal data,

  • To request that collect personal data be deleted (apart from several exceptions);

  • To request that the data not be sold; and

  • The right to opt-in or out of financial incentive plans utilizing their data.

The policy’s information must be updated at least once every 12 months.

Enforcement

The Act can be enforced both publicly and privately.

California Attorney General

The California AG can enforce the CPAA:

  • With civil penalties for intentional violations;

  • At up to $7,500 per violation

  • After a 30-day opportunity for the Business to cure the violation.

    Private Cause of Action

    The CPAA provides private actors (including class plaintiffs) with an action to seek:

  • Relief including

  • Statutory damages

  • Between $100 and $750

  • Per incident;

  • Actual damages; and

  • Injunctive relief;

  • For the unauthorized access of their “sensitive” personal information;

  • As a result of the business’ failure to maintain the Act’s security provisions;

  • After giving the business 30 days notice;

  • If the business fails to provide a notice of cure and assurance the cure will continue.

AG Notification: The user / plaintiff must notify the Attorney General 30 days after filing the action, after which the AG can:

  • Opt to pursue the case through the AG’s office instead;
  • Permit the action to proceed;
  • Not respond, thereby permitting the action to proceed.

NOTABLE CASES ON CALIFORNIA PRIVACY LAWS

CalOPPA action barred by Community Decency Act immunity

“Plaintiff’s claims seek to hold Defendant liable for aggregating third party content and for allegedly not removing content...These allegations require the court to treat Defendant as the publisher and/or speaker of content provided by third parties. The second prong for CDA immunity has been established. Turning to the third prong, Plaintiff alleges that “Google is in fact the information content provider” because “Google Search maintains complete control in publishing to its platform...’ But Plaintiff does not allege, as he must to overcome this prong, that Defendant ‘is responsible, in whole or in part, for the creation or development of information provided through the Internet or any other interactive computer service.’ 47 U.S.C. § 230(f)(3) (defining “information content provider”). To the contrary, Plaintiff alleges that ‘Google Search . . . deliberately seek[s] out information to take, archive, and republish.’” Flanders V. Google, Inc. (8/29/2019) (sustaining Plaintiff Google’s demurrer on the basis that Plaintiff’s claim for, inter alia, violations of CalOPPA, were barred by the federal Communications Decency Act immunity clause.) (https://trellis.law/view/RTNsghpUhNOZyuH95waz43vgyfR9uhyhoVUGzpe81HE).

Class Action Liability For Data Breach Due To Employee’s Falling For Phishing Scam

“Defendant failed to properly safeguard and protect the information and negligently disclosed it to cybercriminals ORDER RE: MOTION FOR FINAL APPROVAL OF CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT; MOTION FOR ATTORNEY’ FEES AND COSTS when one of Defendant’s employees responded to an Internet “phishing” scam by forwarding the 2 2016 Form W-2’s for all of Defendant’s current and former employees to unknown 3 cybercriminals...The Complaint sets forth the following causes of action: 1) Negligence; (2) Violation of Unfair Competition Law; and (3) Declaratory Judgment.” Cheyteshia Matthews vs. Attorney Fees and Costs EhealthInsurance Services, 2017-1-CV-305656 (8/7/2019) (https://trellis.law/ruling/2017-1-CV-305656/cheyteshia-matthews-vs-attorney-fees-and-costs-ehealthinsurance-services/20190907f0a68c).

“Revenge Porn” distributor not liable because images had already been distributed

“Civil Code § 1708.85 provides for a private cause of action “against a person who intentionally distributes by any means a photograph, film, videotape, recording, or any other reproduction of another, without the other’s consent, if (1) the person knew that the other person had a reasonable expectation that the material would remain private, (2) the distributed material exposes an intimate body part of the other person, or shows the other person engaging in an act of intercourse, oral copulation, sodomy, or other act of sexual penetration, and (3) the other person suffers general or special damages as described in Section 48a.” (Civ. Code § 1708.85(a).) However, there shall be no liability if the distributed material was previously distributed by another person. (Civ. Code § 1708.85(c)(6).)

“In this case, the FAC claims that Nair, who Plaintiff shared the alleged content with, admitted that he shared the intimate content with several individuals, including Defendant Corbett who shared the content with additional people...The FAC then alleges that Lipnicki also received copies of the photos and videos and distributed them to other parties and to SAG-AFTRA… Based on these allegations, Lipnicki argues that he cannot be held liable under Civil Code § 1708.85 because the FAC explicitly states that the alleged content was first distributed by Nair before there was any involvement from Lipnicki. Plaintiff does not oppose Lipnicki’s contention that the subject material was previously distributed by another person.

“Therefore, based on the plain language of Civil Code § 1708.85, Lipnicki cannot be held liable under this statute where the FAC alleges that the distributed material was previously distributed by another defendant. (Civ. Code § 1708.85(c)(6); see also Maclsaac v. Waste Management Collection and Recycling, Inc. (2005) 134 Cal.App.4th 1076, 1083[‘We give the words of the statute ‘a plain and commonsense meaning’ unless the statute specifically defines the words to give them a special meaning.’].”) Bryan James vs. Ash Hair, et al, 19STCV11848 (8/4/2019) (https://trellis.law/ruling/19STCV11848/bryan-james-vs-ash-nair-et-al/20190904d6aaa5).

No Requirement Under “Revenge Porn” Statute that the Image be Distributed Widely

“[T]here is no requirement under this specially enacted revenge porn statute, § 1708.85, that the material be “widely published”, as there is to impose liability for the tort of public disclosure of private facts. (See Hill, 7 Cal.4th at 27.) “Here, the complaint alleges a conspiracy between defendant Russell and the Gracie defendants and alleges distribution: from defendant Russell to defendant Cesar Gracie at a dinner gathering...by Cesar Gracie to Jane Doe’s ex-husband’s brother...by Cesar to Jane Doe’s ex-husband and ex-husband’s sister...by Cesar to Rose Gracie...by Russell to individuals at Cesar Gracie’s martial arts academy...and by Russell or the Gracies to various parties, including members of the Martial Arts community in Brazil, by posting the photo on a Whats App Message... “Russell argues that all of this merely amounts to an allegation that she distributed the photograph once, to a single person, defendant Cesar Gracie; and that Gracie did all the further distribution. However, that argument ignores the allegation...that “defendants, or some of them” posted copies of the photograph in WhatsApp messages addressed to various third parties including members of the Martial Arts community in Brazil and the allegation...that Russell distributed it to people at Cesar Gracie’s martial arts academy. “The court concludes that the complaint alleges sufficient distribution under § 1708.85 for pleading purposes, even if none of the actions of defendant Cesar Gracie are attributable to Russell. Thus, the general demurrer is overruled.” Doe vs. Gracie, MSC19-01160 - (11/22/2019) (https://trellis.law/ruling/MSC19-01160/doe-vs-gracie/20191122186367).

Limits of Discovery of Electronic Private Information From a Cell Phone

“Although it is arguable that some of plaintiff's texts and/or calls might have some relevance to this matter (i.e., for example, whether the school contacted her the day of German's death and whether a voicemail was left), defendant did not seek only this relevant information. The request is simply astoundingly overbroad and not at all tailored to seek admissible evidence. Similarly, the only social media accounts German used were Facebook and Sarahah. However, there is no reason to think that all communications on those accounts have any bearing on this lawsuit.

“Consequently, because the discovery is overbroad and necessarily encompasses irrelevant and private information, the motion to compel is denied.” Guzman Vs King Chavez Academy Of Excellence Corporation, 37-2018-00023857-CU-PO-CTL (5/16/2019) (https://trellis.law/ruling/37-2018-00023857-CU-PO-CTL/guzman-vs-king-chavez-academy-of-excellence-corporation/20190516604eab).

Class Action Settlement For Data Breach

“The court concludes that the class action settlement, which includes up to $500,000 for out-of-pocket unreimbursed expenses due to the potential data breach (at up to $3,000 per person) and one year of Kroll identity protection coverage, monitoring and reimbursement coverage for identity theft losses, at no cost to Class Claimants, is fair, adequate and reasonable, and approves the following specific awards:

“$350,000 to plaintiff’s counsel for plaintiff’s attorneys’ fees and costs, as requested; $7,500 to plaintiff John Chamberlain as an enhancement award, as requested; and $22,500 to the Administrator, ILYM Group, Inc., as requested.

“The total amount that will be payable to all class members if they are paid the amount to which they are entitled pursuant to the judgment is $500,000.” Chamberlain Vs. SRI International, 30-2017-00949761-CU-NP-CXC (10/11/2019) (https://trellis.law/ruling/30-2017-00949761-CU-NP-CXC/chamberlain-vs-sri-international/20191011be703e).

Rulings for Privacy – Online in California

Internet users have no expectation of privacy in the&IP addresses of the websites they visit because they should know that this information is provided to and used by Internet service providers for the specific purpose of directing the routing of information&.

  • Name

    MILTITA CASILLAS VS TRANSITIONS OPTICAL, INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    23STCV30742

  • Hearing

    Sep 09, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Here, the main issue pressed in the Demurrer (IP address privacy) is related to existing California law. [E]-mail and Internet users have no expectation of privacy in the to/from addresses of their messages or the IP addresses of the websites they visit because they should know that this information is provided to and used by Internet service providers for the specific purpose of directing the routing of information&. ( People v. Stipo (2011) 195 Cal.App.4th 664, 669 [focusing on U.S.

  • Name

    MONICA SANCHEZ VS MGIC INVESTMENT CORPORATION, A WISCONSIN CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    24STCV21788

  • Hearing

    Jun 05, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

(b)(1) Implement a usage and privacy policy in order to ensure that the collection, use, maintenance, sharing, and dissemination of ALPR information is consistent with respect for individuals' privacy and civil liberties. The usage and privacy policy shall be available to the public in writing, and, if the ALPR operator has an Internet Web site, the usage and privacy policy shall be posted conspicuously on that Internet Web site.

  • Name

    MATA VS. DIGITAL RECOGNITION NETWORK INC

  • Case No.

    37-2021-00023321-CU-MC-CTL

  • Hearing

    Sep 15, 2023

  • County

    San Diego County, CA

The Motion (ROA # 150) of Plaintiff Guillermo Mata ("Plaintiff") for an order to Compel Responses to Special Interrogatories propounded to Defendant DIGITAL RECOGNITION NETWORK, INC. ("Defendant"), is GRANTED IN PART and DENIED IN PART.

  • Name

    MATA VS. DIGITAL RECOGNITION NETWORK INC

  • Case No.

    37-2021-00023321-CU-MC-CTL

  • Hearing

    Jan 05, 2024

  • County

    San Diego County, CA

Digital fingerprints function as persistent digital stamps that are extremely difficult for visitors to detect or modify. 24. Each time a fingerprinted visitor, including Plaintiff, encounters X Corp.s tracking infrastructure anywhere on the internet , like the SDK on Defendants Website, the visitor (and Plaintiffs) previous profile can be instantly recognized and updated .

  • Name

    BRIAN BLAKER VS MPARTICLE, INC.

  • Case No.

    25STCV14539

  • Hearing

    Jan 21, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Digital fingerprints function as persistent digital stamps that are extremely difficult for visitors to detect or modify. 24. Each time a fingerprinted visitor, including Plaintiff, encounters X Corp.s tracking infrastructure anywhere on the internet , like the SDK on Defendants Website, the visitor (and Plaintiffs) previous profile can be instantly recognized and updated .

  • Name

    BRIAN BLAKER VS MPARTICLE, INC.

  • Case No.

    25STCV14539

  • Hearing

    Jun 04, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Internet users rely on third-party equipment to engage in communication, and thus Internet users have no expectation of privacy in the to/from addresses of their messages or the IP addresses of the websites they visit because they should know that this information is provided to and used by Internet service providers for the specific purpose of directing the routing of information. ( Forrester , 512 F.3d at 510.)

  • Name

    MONICA SANCHEZ VS CARS.COM INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    24STCV13201

  • Hearing

    Jan 27, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Purposeful Av a ilment In the context of internet activity for jurisdictional purposes, the California Supreme Court adopted the sliding scale test set forth as follows: At one end of the spectrum are situations where a defendant clearly does business over the Internet. If the defendant enters into contracts with residents of a foreign jurisdiction that involve the knowing and repeated transmission of computer files over the Internet, personal jurisdiction is proper. [Citation.]

  • Name

    MILTITA CASILLAS VS SAGE SOFTWARE, INC., A VIRGINIA ENTITY

  • Case No.

    24STCV04145

  • Hearing

    Apr 11, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

In Forrester , the court held that e-mail and Internet users have no expectation of privacy in the to/from addresses of their messages or the IP addresses of the websites they visit because they should know that this information is provided to and used by Internet service providers for the specific purpose of directing the routing of information.

  • Name

    JERRY AVILES VS HITACHI VANTARA LLC, A DELAWARE ENTITY, WITH ITS PRINCIPAL PLACE OF BUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA,

  • Case No.

    24STCV19162

  • Hearing

    Aug 28, 2025

  • Judge

    Echo Dawn Ryan

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Defendant first argues Plaintiff fails to allege an invasion of privacy. The Court disagrees. Plaintiff adequately alleges Defendant invaded Plaintiffs privacy by publishing pornographic photographs of Plaintiff online without Plaintiffs knowledge or consent.

  • Name

    JANE DOE VS JOSEPH PAUL MARTIN SINARD

  • Case No.

    25SMCV03676

  • Hearing

    Mar 04, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The Legislatures drafting in related provisions confirms that it knows how to regulate internet-based activity when it wishes to do so. Specifically, the Legislature has expressly referenced internet or online communications and services when extending protections beyond traditional telephonic technologies. For example, the California Legislature added Cal. Penal Code § 632.01 in 2017.

  • Name

    EMILY RODRIGUEZ VS INK AMERICA INTERNATIONAL GROUP LLC, A CALIFORNIA ENTITY,

  • Case No.

    25STCV15350

  • Hearing

    Dec 10, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION: CONSTITUTIONAL INVASION OF PRIVACY A claim for constitutional invasion of privacy requires (1) a legally protected privacy interest, (2) a reasonable expectation of privacy, and (3) an intrusion so serious as to constitute an egregious breach of social norms. (See Hernandez v. Hillsides, Inc . (2009) 47 Cal.4th 272, 287.) AHF contends its Notice of Privacy Practices informed patients that PHI would be used to assess and improve services.

  • Name

    JOHN DOE, VS AIDS HEALTHCARE FOUNDATION

  • Case No.

    24STCV19345

  • Hearing

    Jan 14, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Given the foregoing, the court is inclined to require Defense Counsel to conduct a mandatory internet sweep as described in the OSC and at Defense Counsels expense. The court is also inclined to impose a monetary sanction. III. CONCLUSION The court will hear from the parties regarding the OSC Re: Mandatory Internet Sweep and potential monetary sanctions at the hearing.

  • Case No.

    24STCV13689

  • Hearing

    Jun 29, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

the California Invasion of Privacy Act – California Penal Code 632.7) in the Complaint by Plaintiff Silvia Garcia ("Plaintiff"), is sustained without leave to amend.

  • Case No.

    37-2023-00005775-CU-CR-CTL

  • Hearing

    Jul 14, 2023

  • County

    San Diego County, CA

In essence, Plaintiff seeks an order directing nonparty online intermediaries to remove content from their platforms. Plaintiff seeks to do this without providing notice to the nonparty intermediaries. [1] The court cannot grant this relief. Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act (47 U.S.C., § 230) (herein, Section 230) grants widespread immunity from suit to companies known as Internet Intermediaries (herein, Intermediaries) for content they publish online.

  • Name

    NICHOLAS BUTTA VS BILLIE LEE SGROI-PROFFITT

  • Case No.

    BC720060

  • Hearing

    Feb 20, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Plaintiff filed an amended putative class-action complaint against Defendant Princess Cruise Lines, Ltd. for (1) violation of the California Invasion of Privacy Act, Penal Code § 631; (2) violation of the California Invasion of Privacy Act, Penal Code § 632; and (3) Invasion of Privacy under California’s Constitution.

  • Name

    LING TANDIAN VS. PRINCESS CRUISE LINES, LTD.

  • Case No.

    C24-00621

  • Hearing

    Nov 07, 2024

  • County

    Contra Costa County, CA

For example, the Pavlovich Court did not focus its inquiry solely on the posting of source code containing propriety information on an Internet Web site accessible to any person with Internet access.

  • Name

    MILTITA CASILLAS VS HANESBRANDS INC., A MARYLAND CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    24STCV01291

  • Hearing

    Jul 15, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

INTRODUCTION Plaintiff Samantha Brustin moves ex parte for an order (1) sealing portions of the documents filed by Defendant Petrol Advertising, Inc. on May 27 and 28, 2026; (2) issuing an Order to Show Cause (OSC) Re Contempt for Defendants willful disobedience of the protective order entered by the court on July 28, 2025; (3) issuing an OSC Re Mandatory Internet Sweep to immediately contact all online legal databases and docket aggregators (including but not limited to Trellis, Law360, Lexis,

  • Case No.

    24STCV13689

  • Hearing

    Jun 04, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

They also assert that Perez has a privacy right in his insurance records. The party asserting a privacy right must establish a legally protected privacy interest, an objectively reasonable expectation of privacy in the given circumstances, and a threatened intrusion that is serious. ( Williams v. Superior Court (2017) 3 Cal.5th 531, 532.)

  • Name

    VICTOR MANUEL ABELAR, AN INDIVIDUAL, ET AL. VS SIGNATURE FLOORING, INC., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    24PSCV04358

  • Hearing

    Mar 02, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Meanwhile, the California Online Privacy Protection Act of 2003 (COPPA) regulates online privacy and balances concerns unique to online commerce. COPPA provides that [a]n operator of a commercial Web site or online service that collects personally identifiable information through the Internet about individual consumers residing in California who use or visit its commercial Web site or online service shall conspicuously post its privacy policy on its Web site . . . . (Bus. & Prof. Code, § 22575, subd.

  • Name

    ARTHUR EDWARD EZOR VS NEIL JEFFERY KANTOR, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    24NNCV04166

  • Hearing

    Apr 10, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

(35 Ohio Jur. 3d Defamation and Privacy § 176.) And the matter disclosed in this case was the association of Plaintiff in his professional capacity as a physician and in his capacity as an internet pop cultural commentator. Such an association is no more objectively offensive with the evidence that Plaintiff now presents than it was with his prior showing. Plaintiffs showing as to intrusion upon seclusion likewise remains lacking.

  • Name

    DR. MISHA MUTIZWA VS TWITTER, INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    23STCP00424

  • Hearing

    Apr 12, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The district court held that an application was not required because [n]umbers dialed by a telephone are not the subject of a reasonable expectation of privacy, and their interception does not violate the 4th Amendment. ( Digital Analyzer, supra, 885 F.Supp. 197 at p. 199.)

  • Name

    ANNE HEITING, AN INDIVIDUAL VS TAYLOR FRESH FOODS, INC., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    24STCV12891

  • Hearing

    Jul 29, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Stipo (2011) 195 Cal.App.4th 664, 669 [holding that an internet user had no legitimate expectation of privacy in subscriber information provided to an Internet service provider, including information identifying the user of an IP address]; People v. Evenson (2016) 4 Cal.App.5th 1020, 1026, fn. 4 [computer users have no reasonable expectation of privacy in to/from addresses of their messages or [ ] IP addresses of [ ] websites they visit].)

  • Name

    EMILY RODRIGUEZ VS IMDB.COM, INC.

  • Case No.

    24STCV14922

  • Hearing

    Mar 24, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Allegations in the Complaint Plaintiff Jose Gutierrez, a resident of California, is a consumer privacy advocate and tester who works to ensure that companies abide by the privacy obligations imposed by federal law. (FAC ¶ 4.) Defendant Bokf, NA, is an Oklahoma company that provides consumers access to online personal and commercial banking. (Id. ¶ 5.) Plaintiff alleges that Defendants website utilizes de-anonymization spyware from LeadFeeder to reveal the identity of visitors to the site.

  • Name

    JOSE GUTIERREZ, AN INDIVIDUAL VS BOKF NA, AN OKLAHOMA COMPANY

  • Case No.

    23STCV22629

  • Hearing

    Jan 16, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Violations of California Invasion of Privacy Act (Penal Code § 638.51, et seq.) The California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA), specifically Penal Code § ¿ 638.51, prohibits any person from install[ing] or us[ing] a pen register or a trap and trace device without first obtaining a court order.

  • Name

    MICHAEL SANDOVAL VS THE BEVERLY COLLECTION, INC., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    25VECV06215

  • Hearing

    Feb 09, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Plaintiffs counsel also states that Defendants online Privacy Policy named Angi Privacy Policy, available on its Website, version 8.3, which states that it was Effective February 15th 2024 to May 31st 2024, which coincides with the time of Plaintiffs visit to the Website, expressly addresses the rights of Californians under the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018& as amended by the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020& (Ferrell Decl., ¶ 8.)

  • Name

    REBEKA RODRIGUEZ VS ANGIE'S LIST, INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    24STCV13458

  • Hearing

    Oct 23, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Defendant contends that by clicking the "NEXT" button on the online offer webpage, Plaintiffs manifested assent to the terms of service, because elsewhere on the same page is language that reads: By clicking "next," you consent, acknowledge, and agree to the following: Our Terms and Conditions. Privacy Policy, and to receive important notices and other communications electronically.

  • Case No.

    37-2023-00012108-CU-BT-CTL

  • Hearing

    Jan 19, 2024

  • County

    San Diego County, CA

“This express right is broader than the implied federal right to privacy.” (Id.) “The California privacy right protects the speech and privacy rights of individuals who wish to promulgate their information and ideas in a public forum while keeping their identities secret, and limits what courts can compel through civil discovery.” (Id.)

  • Name

    DFCU BANK LIMITED VS JOHN DOES

  • Case No.

    19STCV35240

  • Hearing

    Jul 29, 2020

Appx. 605 [no expectation of privacy in IP address and internet subscriber information]; U.S. v. Gottesfeld (D.Mass. 2018) 319 F.Supp.3d 548 [use of pen register did not violate Fourth Amendment rights because no reasonable expectation of privacy in IP address routing information]; U.S. v. Knowles (D.S.C. 2016) 207 F.Supp.3d 585 [no reasonable expectation of privacy in IP address which a user voluntarily provides to third parties every time she uses the internet]; Heeger v. Facebook, Inc.

  • Name

    SILVIA GARCIA VS DIVERSIFIED FOODSERVICE SUPPLY, LLC, A DELAWARE ENTITY

  • Case No.

    24STCV19784

  • Hearing

    Jun 24, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Plaintiff's Complaint, on behalf of himself and a putative class, alleges invasion of privacy under California's Invasion of Privacy Act ("CIPA"), asserting causes of action for (1) violation of Penal Code § 631; and (2) violation of Penal Code § 632.7 Defendant moves to compel arbitration on an individual basis. Defendant relies on an Arbitration Agreement set forth in 23andMe's Terms of Service.

  • Case No.

    37-2022-00051047-CU-MT-CTL

  • Hearing

    Jul 21, 2023

  • County

    San Diego County, CA

Defendant also maintains the prior notice in John Muir’s Website Privacy Policy, precludes a reasonable expectation of privacy.

  • Name

    ROBIN BARBOUR VS. JOHN MUIR HEALTH

  • Case No.

    C22-01693

  • Hearing

    Dec 29, 2022

  • County

    Contra Costa County, CA

Even with marginal relevance the right to privacy soundly outweighs both need and relevance. Plaintiff could have limited the inquiry to records for the “two items” if he knows the dates – his assertion of evidence is rather vague. Instead he chose to seek every record for a ten-year period. It is an undue burden on privacy. The motions are granted.

  • Name

    ADAN FLORES VS TELFER PAVEMENT TECHNOLOGIES, LLC, A LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    19STCV22409

  • Hearing

    Jul 02, 2020

Discussion Allegations in the First Amended Complaint The First Amended Complaint alleges a single cause of action for violation of the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) at Penal Code section 638.51(a). Plaintiff alleges that Defendant secretly deployed spyware at its website, www.plivo.com/ (the Website) that accesses visitors devices and installed tracking spyware before obtaining consent to do so, and then monitors and reports visitors online habits after they leave the Website.

  • Name

    REBEKA RODRIGUEZ VS PLIVO INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION WITH ITS PRINCIPAL PLACE OF BUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA

  • Case No.

    24STCV08972

  • Hearing

    Oct 02, 2024

  • Judge

    Echo Dawn Ryan

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

(RR Shoes) pursuant to a September 18, 2023, Complaint alleging claims of (1) Violations of the California Invasion of Privacy Act (Cal. Penal Code § 631) and (2) Violations of the California Invasion of Privacy Act (Cal. Penal Code § 632.7). The claims arise from the following allegations.

  • Name

    MIGUEL A. LICEA VS RACK ROOM SHOES, INC., A NORTH CAROLINA CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    23STCV22458

  • Hearing

    Apr 15, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Co.¿(1994) 8 Cal.4th 30, 43.)¿ The Court must “balance the public need against the weight of the privacy right” and only¿serious¿invasions of privacy will bar discovery.¿ (Crab Addison, Inc. v. Superior Court¿(2008) 169 Cal.App.4th 958, 966.)¿ There is not an egregious invasion of privacy every time there is a request for private information and courts must “place the burden on the party asserting a privacy interest to establish its extent and seriousness of the prospective invasion.”¿ (Williams v.

  • Name

    EMMA STONE VS THE CITY OF LOS ANGELES, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    20STCV40267

  • Hearing

    Jul 06, 2021

For instance, Byang argues that the subpoena is moot based upon its claim has a borrower/lender relationship with Digital Horizon and the funds were part of a repayment. Byangs claim, however, does not negate Plaintiffs ability to test that theory with its subpoena. Otherwise, the significant relevance of the banking records overrides Byangs corporate privacy interest.

  • Name

    JINWAN SHEN, ET AL. VS LINGXIAO LI, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    24SMCV00651

  • Hearing

    Jul 01, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Although First Digital Surveillance failed to serve any objection to the Deposition Subpoena, First Digital Surveillance failed to appear on the noticed deposition date of January 19, 2021. (Baladejo Decl., ¶ 4, Ex. 2.) First Digital Surveillance has also failed to produce the requested documents. (Baladejo Decl., ¶¶ 5.)

  • Name

    CHRISTOPHER CONNER VS DEL AMO HOSPITAL, INC., ET AL.

  • Case No.

    20STCV30336

  • Hearing

    Mar 26, 2021

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

  • Type

    Other

  • Sub Type

    Intellectual Property

DIGITAL RECOGNITION NETWORK INC [E-FILE] CASE CATEGORY: Civil - Unlimited CASE TYPE: Misc Complaints - Other EVENT TYPE: Summary Judgment / Summary Adjudication (Civil) CAUSAL DOCUMENT/DATE FILED: Motion for Summary Judgment and/or Adjudication, 01/25/2024 1. The Motion (ROA # 214, 272) of Defendant Digital Recognition Network, Inc.

  • Name

    MATA VS. DIGITAL RECOGNITION NETWORK INC

  • Case No.

    37-2021-00023321-CU-MC-CTL

  • Hearing

    Apr 25, 2024

  • County

    San Diego County, CA

DIGITAL RECOGNITION NETWORK INC [E-FILE] CASE CATEGORY: Civil - Unlimited CASE TYPE: Misc Complaints - Other EVENT TYPE: Summary Judgment / Summary Adjudication (Civil) CAUSAL DOCUMENT/DATE FILED: Motion for Summary Judgment and/or Adjudication, 01/25/2024 1. The Motion (ROA # 214, 272) of Defendant Digital Recognition Network, Inc.

  • Name

    MATA VS. DIGITAL RECOGNITION NETWORK INC

  • Case No.

    37-2021-00023321-CU-MC-CTL

  • Hearing

    May 03, 2024

  • County

    San Diego County, CA

They say this request is frivolous for any number of reasons including: that the defendants have admitted they have not been on the easement; that there are real privacy issues; that their Dell desk top used by Mr.

  • Name

    WILLIAMS V KLINGER

  • Case No.

    1306795

  • Hearing

    Mar 30, 2010

Analogously, e-mail and Internet users have no expectation of privacy in the to/from addresses of their messages or the IP addresses of the websites they visit because they should know that this information is provided to and used by Internet service providers for the specific purpose of directing the routing of information. ( U.S. v. Forrester (9th Cir. 2008) 512 F.3d 500, 510; see also Brown v. Google LLC (N.D. Cal. 2023) 685 F.Supp.3d 909, 941 [no exception of privacy in IP address]; Heeger v.

  • Name

    MONICA SANCHEZ VS LETTER FOUR, INC., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION, WITH ITS PRINCIPAL PLACE OF BUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA,

  • Case No.

    24STCV18924

  • Hearing

    Apr 17, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The rule applied Pavlovich is, when the scope of personal jurisdiction is based on Internet use, courts use a sliding scale analysis [1] described as follows: At one end of the spectrum are situations where a defendant clearly does business over the Internet. If the defendant enters into contracts with residents of a foreign jurisdiction that involve the knowing and repeated transmission of computer files over the Internet, personal jurisdiction is proper. [Citation.]

  • Name

    JOSE JESUS LICEA VS ROCKET MORTGAGE, LLC, A MICHIGAN LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY

  • Case No.

    24STCV02041

  • Hearing

    May 09, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Nor, save for objecting to the production of personal tax returns, has Plaintiff substantiated his claim of invasion of privacy. (See Williams v. Superior Court (2017) 3 Cal.5th 531, 552 [established framework for evaluating potential invasions of privacy requires party asserting a privacy right to establish a legally protected privacy interest, an objectively reasonable expectation of privacy in the given circumstances, and a threatened intrusion that is serious].)

  • Name

    2024CUBC021884 HAMID SABOUR VS SAEID SABOUR

  • Case No.

    2024CUBC021884

  • Hearing

    Sep 23, 2025

Defendant first argues that Plaintiff had no reasonable expectation of privacy in messages he sent to Defendant through the internet. Defendant relies on the federal district court case Campbell v. Facebook Inc., 77 F. Supp. 3d 836, 848 (N.D. Cal. 2014). There, the Court addressed whether email communications could be deemed confidential under section 632 of the California Invasion of Privacy Act.

  • Case No.

    22STCV19747

  • Hearing

    Nov 28, 2022

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The Labor Code defines a print shoot employee as an individual hired for a period of limited duration¿to render services relating to or supporting a still image shoot, including film or digital photography, for use in print, digital, or internet media. (Labor Code §201.6, subd.[ a][1 ] .) A¿print shoot employee¿is entitled to receive payment of the wages earned and unpaid at the time of termination by the next regular payday. (Lab . Code §201.6, subd. [b] .)

  • Name

    KAROL SANTOS VS DELTA GALIL USA, INC.

  • Case No.

    25SMCV00076

  • Hearing

    Aug 27, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Therefore, the invasion of privacy claim is adequately pled. CONCLUSION Defendants demurrer is OVERRULED. [1] Defendant attempts to contradict this allegation by introducing evidence of Intercoms actual privacy policy. Such factual disputes cannot be considered on a demurrer. Plaintiffs reference to the privacy policy does not entitle Defendant to introduce extrinsic evidence of it on a demurrer.

  • Name

    ANNE HEITING, AN INDIVIDUAL VS THRYV, INC., A TEXAS CORPORATION

  • Case No.

    24STCV00914

  • Hearing

    Jun 03, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Invasion of Privacy under the California Constitution (3rd C/A) "[A] plaintiff alleging an invasion of privacy in violation of the state constitutional right to privacy must establish each of the following: (1) a legally protected privacy interest; (2) a reasonable expectation of privacy in the circumstances; and (3) conduct by defendant constituting a serious invasion of privacy. [¶] Whether a legally recognized privacy interest is present in a given case is a question of law to be decided by the court.

  • Name

    AMANDA FRITSZCHE VS. EERO, LLC

  • Case No.

    C24-01301

  • Hearing

    Mar 13, 2025

  • County

    Contra Costa County, CA

Morel (1st Cir. 2019) 922 F.3d 1, 9 [defendant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in her IP address because an internet user generates the IP data . . . only by making the affirmative decision to access a website]; U.S. v. Caira (7th Cir. 2016) 833 F.3d 803, 806 [IP addresses are broadcast far and wide in the course of normal internet use; hence there is no reasonable expectation of privacy in IP address]; U.S. v. Wellbeloved-Stone (4th Cir. 2019) 777 Fed. Appx. 605; U.S. v.

  • Name

    MARIELITA PALACIOS VS OMNIPET, INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION,

  • Case No.

    24STCV23260

  • Hearing

    Jun 18, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

In the context of internet activity for jurisdictional purposes, the California Supreme Court adopted the sliding scale test set forth as follows: At one end of the spectrum are situations where a defendant clearly does business over the Internet. If the defendant enters into contracts with residents of a foreign jurisdiction that involve the knowing and repeated transmission of computer files over the Internet, personal jurisdiction is proper. [Citation.]

  • Name

    MARIELITA PALACIOS VS THE HABERDASH GROUP INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION,

  • Case No.

    24STCV20114

  • Hearing

    Jun 27, 2025

  • Judge

    Echo Dawn Ryan

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The CPRA, which amends the CCPA, added additional privacy protections, including the right to correct inaccurate information and the right to limit the use and disclosure of sensitive personal information. The CCPA and CPRA indicate a legislative intent, outside of CIPA, to regulate and protect Californians internet privacy while also considering the necessity of collection and processing of user data.

  • Name

    MARIELITA PALACIOS VS GORGIAS INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION, WITH ITS PRINCIPAL PLACE OF BUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA,

  • Case No.

    24STCV11310

  • Hearing

    Apr 15, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Tarek objected asserting that Plaintiffs Subpoena invades its privacy and that the Subpoena is overbroad. The party asserting a privacy right must establish a legally protected privacy interest, an objectively reasonable expectation of privacy in the given circumstances, and a threatened intrusion that is serious. ( Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Assn. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1, 35-37.)

  • Name

    JINWAN SHEN, ET AL. VS LINGXIAO LI, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    24SMCV00651

  • Hearing

    Apr 21, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The defendant is requested on receipt of this Tentative Ruling to forward same in digital format to sbs@sbslawsf.com. As a result of the COVID-19 emergency, all attorneys and parties are required to appear remotely. Hearings will be conducted by videoconference using Zoom. To appear at the hearing, go to the court's website at sfsuperiorcourt.org under "Online Services," navigate to "Tentative Rulings," and click on the appropriate link, or dial the corresponding phone number.

  • Name

    RAVIN SKONDIN VS. PG&E CORPORATION ET AL

  • Case No.

    CGC18570858

  • Hearing

    Dec 22, 2020

  • County

    San Francisco County, CA

(b)(1); City of Los Angeles, supra, 9 Cal.App.5th at p. 288; Digital Music News LLC, supra, 226 Cal.App.4th at p. 224; Hecht, Solberg, Robinson, Goldberg & Bagley LLP, supra, 137 Cal.App.4th at p. 595; see Dauis Decl. [filed 1/30/2023], Ex. J, 12/19/2022 e-mail from Dauis; see also plaintiff’s sup. sep. statement, p. 20, ll. 10 – 16.) The Court declines to award sanctions to either party. (Code Civ. Proc., §§ 2023.010, 2033.030, 2031.310, subd. (h).)

  • Case No.

    CV-2022-0779

  • Hearing

    May 11, 2023

  • County

    Yolo County, CA

Plaintiff alleges that the Nohr defendants recorded photos and videos of her inside her house in various stages of undress “and other reposes,” and that Bardessono published such photos and videos on internet websites.

  • Name

    DISIENO V. NOHR ET AL.

  • Case No.

    20CV02397

  • Hearing

    Jun 27, 2023

Morel (1st Cir. 2019) 922 F.3d 1, 9 [defendant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in her IP address because an internet user generates the IP data . . . only by making the affirmative decision to access a website]; U.S. v. Caira (7th Cir. 2016) 833 F.3d 803, 806 [IP addresses are broadcast far and wide in the course of normal internet use; hence there is no reasonable expectation of privacy in IP address]; U.S. v. Wellbeloved-Stone (4th Cir. 2019) 777 Fed. Appx. 605; U.S. v.

  • Name

    REBEKA RODRIGUEZ VS FIRST AMERICAN FINANCIAL CORPORATION, A DELAWARE CORPORATION, WITH ITS PRINCIPAL PLACE OF BUSINESS IN CALIFORNIA,

  • Case No.

    24STCV05383

  • Hearing

    Apr 30, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Morel (1st Cir. 2019) 922 F.3d 1, 9 [defendant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in her IP address because an internet user generates the IP data . . . only by making the affirmative decision to access a website]; U.S. v. Caira (7th Cir. 2016) 833 F.3d 803, 806 [IP addresses are broadcast far and wide in the course of normal internet use; hence there is no reasonable expectation of privacy in IP address]; U.S. v. Wellbeloved-Stone (4th Cir. 2019) 777 Fed. Appx. 605; U.S. v.

  • Name

    EMILY RODRIGUEZ VS REFUEL AGENCY, INC.

  • Case No.

    24STCV16581

  • Hearing

    Apr 30, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Here, the size of the text warning the consumer that "By signing up you agree to BallerTV Terms of Use and Privacy Policy" is relatively small, especially relative to the the surrounding text, which included words like "Email," "Password," and "Create Account." The language "By signing up you agree to BallerTV Terms of Use and Privacy Policy" is light gray, except the bolded and black words Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, contrasted with white background. The language is notably more difficult to read.

  • Case No.

    37-2022-00044840-CU-BT-CTL

  • Hearing

    Feb 02, 2024

  • County

    San Diego County, CA

This would encompass a complete record of the internet activities of an entire family. Compelling a party to produce the private internet usage data, billing records, and device information of her or a non- party is a violation of their privacy rights. Defendant claims to have identified some specific IP addresses used to access its systems. Defendant has less intrusive means of obtaining specific information tailored to those IP addresses.

  • Name

    ARMATO VS MORE HEALTH, INC.

  • Case No.

    CVME2402547

  • Hearing

    Nov 15, 2025

  • County

    Riverside County, CA

This would encompass a complete record of the internet activities of an entire family. Compelling a party to produce the private internet usage data, billing records, and device information of her or a non- party is a violation of their privacy rights. Defendant claims to have identified some specific IP addresses used to access its systems. Defendant has less intrusive means of obtaining specific information tailored to those IP addresses.

  • Name

    ARMATO VS MORE HEALTH, INC.

  • Case No.

    CVME2402547

  • Hearing

    Nov 16, 2025

  • County

    Riverside County, CA

This would encompass a complete record of the internet activities of an entire family. Compelling a party to produce the private internet usage data, billing records, and device information of her or a non- party is a violation of their privacy rights. Defendant claims to have identified some specific IP addresses used to access its systems. Defendant has less intrusive means of obtaining specific information tailored to those IP addresses.

  • Name

    ARMATO VS MORE HEALTH, INC.

  • Case No.

    CVME2402547

  • Hearing

    Nov 17, 2025

  • County

    Riverside County, CA

Forrester (9th Cir. 2008) 512 F.3d 500, 510, the Ninth Circuit held Internet users have no expectation of privacy in the to/from addresses of their messages or the IP addresses of the websites they visit because they should know that this information is provided to and used by Internet service providers for the specific purpose of directing the routing of information. ( Ibid. ) Similarly, in Heeger v. Facebook, Inc . (N.D.Cal. 2020) 509 F.

  • Name

    MILTITA CASILLAS VS ZAPPOS.COM LLC, A DELAWARE ENTITY

  • Case No.

    24STCV14880

  • Hearing

    Nov 13, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

However, where a privacy right is concerned, discovery is limited to that which is “directly relevant to the plaintiff’s claim and essential to the fair resolution of the lawsuit.” ( Davis v. Superior Court (1992) 7 Cal.App.4th 1008, 1014.) Litigants have a constitutionally protected right to privacy in their medical records. ( Davis , supra , 7 Cal.App.4th at p. 1014; Harris v. Superior Court , (1992) 3 Cal.App.4th 661, 665.)

  • Name

    VANESSA CHATFIELD VS SAMANTHA STAITMAN ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC708715

  • Hearing

    Jul 30, 2021

Plaintiff's argument that Section 632.7 should be extended to website internet communication is not reasonable. Legislation has not changed the scope of Section 632.7 despite regular amendments to statutes under the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) since Internet usage became widespread in the 1990s. Chat features on websites have been around long before Section 632.7 was amended on January 21, 2023.

  • Case No.

    37-2023-00009235-CU-CR-CTL

  • Hearing

    Jun 30, 2023

  • County

    San Diego County, CA

Plaintiff contends that she has had difficulty in obtaining employment because the records for this case remain available via a public internet search of Plaintiffs name for nearly 7 years. She asserts that she cannot request to remove this information from the parties uploading this information to their public records websites internet search engines without an order from a presiding Judge.

  • Name

    CHRISTINE MINNIG VS M-S CASH DRAWER CORPORATION ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC548065

  • Hearing

    Jun 06, 2022

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The remaining requests at issue are for Plaintiffs internet browsing history, text messages, etc. Plaintiff alleges Defendant failed to reimburse a percentage of her phone and internet bills that were used for work purposes. Defendant asserts these documents are necessary to determine this percentage of time. The Court disagrees. Plaintiffs phone bills range from $30.00 to $105.00 per month; her internet bill is under $45.00 per month.

  • Name

    KAREN BOBADILLA, VS NORDSTROM CARD SERVICES, INC., ET AL.

  • Case No.

    23STCV02398

  • Hearing

    Jan 23, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The Court finds that Bentec has set forth specific facts showing good cause justifying the sought discovery, and plaintiff has not met his burden to justify his privacy objections. (Code Civ. Proc., §§ 2017.010, 2031.310, subd. (b)(1); Lopez v. Watchtower Bible & Tract Society of New York, Inc. (2016) 246 Cal.App.4th 566, 591; Digital Music News LLC v. Superior Court (2014) 226 Cal.App.4th 216, 224, disapproved on other grounds by Williams v. Superior Court (2017) 3 Cal.5th 531; Kirkland v.

  • Case No.

    CV-2023-1394

  • Hearing

    May 14, 2024

  • County

    Yolo County, CA

VP presents no evidence that Plaintiffs were told what VP would do with those photos or that they would be posted on a publicly accessible internet site, and Plaintiffs deny they were told that the photos would be posted on the internet. (See Plaintiffs’ response to SSF No. 21.)

  • Name

    LUCKIE VS MATZA

  • Case No.

    RG20061220

  • Hearing

    Jul 18, 2024

  • County

    Alameda County, CA

The Complaint alleges causes of action for (1) California Unauthorized Access to Computer Data Act, (2) California Invasion of Privacy Act, (3) California Invasion of Privacy, (4) intrusion upon seclusion, and (5) publication of private information.

  • Name

    BRYAN DIAZ VS RINGLOGIX,LLC, A FLORIDA ENTITY

  • Case No.

    23STCV14805

  • Hearing

    Oct 16, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

However, defense counsel did state Defendants’ willingness to enter into a Protective Order. ( Id. ) Privacy Plaintiff contends that the Subpoenas seek medical information protected by Plaintiff’s privacy rights. Plaintiff raises two main issues regarding the Subpoenas: (1) the Subpoenas are not limited in terms of the parts of the body at issue in this case; and (2) the Subpoenas request information from any and all dates.

  • Name

    JORGE PEDROZA VS DANIELA ANGULO, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    21STCV04106

  • Hearing

    Oct 19, 2021

( Id. ) The Court noted that the alleged defamatory statements were already on the internet and in the public record and, by filing a civil lawsuit, parties like the plaintiffs generally lost their reasonable expectation of privacy. ( Id. ) Fourth, the Court noted the Roe case was against two private individuals and not against a school or government entity.

  • Name

    AWKO DOE 66, ET AL. VS GLENDALE UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT, A PUBLIC ENTITY, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    25NNCV05309

  • Hearing

    Mar 27, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

INTERNET TRUCKSTOP GROUP, LLC, et al. Defendants. Case No.: 24STCV00465 Hearing Date: May 2, 2024 [ TENTATIVE] order RE: Defendant Internet Truckstop Group, LLCS demurrer to THE complaint On January 8, 2024, Plaintiff Karla Huff (Plaintiff) filed the instant action for invasion of privacy against Defendant Internet Truckstop Group, LLC (Defendant). On April 19, 2024, Plaintiff timely filed a First Amended Complaint.

  • Name

    KARLA HUFF VS INTERNET TRUCKSTOP GROUP, LLC

  • Case No.

    24STCV00465

  • Hearing

    May 02, 2024

  • Judge

    Echo Dawn Ryan

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

On October 25 2023, Plaintiff filed a complaint for Comprehensive Computer Data and Access Fraud Act, California Invasion of Privacy Act (Penal Code section 638.51), California Invasion of Privacy Act (Penal Code section 631), Invasion of Privacy, and Intrusion Upon Seclusion. On December 4, 2023, Plaintiff filed a first amended complaint for California Invasion of Privacy Act (Penal Code section 638.51) RULING : Sustained with Leave to Amend. Request for Judicial Notice: Granted.

  • Name

    JOSE LICEA VS HICKORY FARMS LLC, A DELAWARE ENTITY

  • Case No.

    23STCV26148

  • Hearing

    Mar 13, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

There, the California Supreme Court took on a personal jurisdiction analysis where the only meaningful contacts involved internet use. ( Id. at p. 274.)

  • Name

    MIGUEL ESPARZA VS IREDALE COSMETICS, INC

  • Case No.

    24STCV25717

  • Hearing

    Feb 01, 2025

Full compliance with these requests would likely result in voluminous production of irrelevant materials, as well as production that unjustifiably intrudes into the third-party privacy rights of Feis employees and contractors. Yu has not adequately shown the relevance of the requested materials outweighs the privacy interests of third parties. DENIED. Yu may resubmit narrowed versions of these requests.

  • Name

    JUSTIN YU VS RARI CAPITAL INFRASTRUCTURE, LLC, A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    22SMCV01367

  • Hearing

    Dec 19, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

TENTATIVE RULING: (1) PLAINTIFF JACLYN BRIZZI'S MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO FORM INTERROGATORIES PROPOUNDED TO DEFENDANT DIGITAL MEDIA SOLUTIONS, LLC (SET ONE), (2) PLAINTIFF JACLYN BRIZZI'S MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION PROPOUNDED TO DEFENDANT DIGITAL MEDIA SOLUTIONS, LLC (SET ONE), (3) PLAINTIFF JACLYN BRIZZI'S MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS PROPOUNDED TO DEFENDANT DIGITAL MEDIA SOLUTIONS, LLC (SET ONE), and (4) PLAINTIFF

  • Name

    BRIZZI VS DIGITAL MEDIA SOLUTIONS LLC [E-FILE]

  • Case No.

    37-2020-00027447-CU-OE-CTL

  • Hearing

    Aug 12, 2021

The only relevant records are those in which patients indicated that they were referred by the website or the Internet. Referrals by some other means, eg radio, family members, friends, are neither relevant, nor likely to lead to the discovery of evidence. (CCP § 2017.010.) Plaintiff has agreed to have all patient names redacted to protect the patients’ privacy.

  • Name

    DON K KOBASHIGAWA D D S ET AL VS R MCKAY D D S INC ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC624715

  • Hearing

    Mar 24, 2017

In the context of internet activity for jurisdictional purposes, the California Supreme Court adopted the sliding scale test set forth as follows: At one end of the spectrum are situations where a defendant clearly does business over the Internet. If the defendant enters into contracts with residents of a foreign jurisdiction that involve the knowing and repeated transmission of computer files over the Internet, personal jurisdiction is proper. [Citation.]

  • Name

    MARIELITA PALACIOS VS THE HABERDASH GROUP INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION,

  • Case No.

    24STCV20114

  • Hearing

    Feb 27, 2025

  • Judge

    Echo Dawn Ryan

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The Legislature enacted the Invasion of Privacy Act to protect the right of privacy of the people of this state. ( Tavernetti v. Superior Court (1978) 22 Cal.3d 187, 193.)

  • Name

    MIGUEL ESPARZA VS GOLDSILVER LLC, A NEW YORK ENTITY

  • Case No.

    23STCV19517

  • Hearing

    Feb 23, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Defendant’s privacy objection has some merit. Third parties unquestionably have a right of privacy in financial records, and documents kept by their employers. There must be a compelling need for such records that strongly outweighs their privacy interests. Any request for such records must be narrowly tailored considering their privacy rights. Life Technologies Corp. v. Superior Court (2011) 197 Cal.App.4th 640, 655; Digital Music News LLC v.

  • Name

    MATHIS VS PERKINS & MARIE CALLENDER’S LLC

  • Case No.

    30-2015-00824878-CU-PO-CJC

  • Hearing

    Apr 07, 2017

The party asserting a privacy right must establish a legally protected privacy interest, an objectively reasonable expectation of privacy in the given circumstances, and a threatened intrusion that is serious. ( Id . at 35–37.)

  • Name

    CHRISTOPHER BONILLA VS CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION, A PUBLIC ENTITY, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    19STCV21215

  • Hearing

    Jan 06, 2021

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

  • Type

    Personal Injury/ Tort

  • Sub Type

    other

The Court finds that the subpoena is overbroad and violates Plaintiffs right to privacy. The Court quashes the subpoena served on Christie Digital. 2. Subpoenas served on schools Plaintiff does not acknowledge that Defendants withdrew the original subpoenas served on the schools on August 14, 2023, and issued new subpoenas to the schools on October 11, 2023. Plaintiffs moving and reply papers both address only the original set of subpoenas.

  • Name

    AUSTIN RICHARD MORENO VS JOHN JOSEPH KEITH, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    21STCV40269

  • Hearing

    Nov 22, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Plaintiff argues that a further response is necessary because Axonify is the subscription-based online learning platform Ralphs uses to train its employees and track their training progress, including safe practices to respond to spills on the sales floor. Ralphs argues that the RPDs seek data that the store does not retain and the training materials are subject to the store and its employees proprietary and privacy rights.

  • Name

    HARRY GRAY VS LUIS MIGUEL PALOMINO, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    23BBCV02727

  • Hearing

    Oct 10, 2025

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The state Constitution expressly grants Californians a right of privacy. (Cal. Const., art. I § 1.) Protection of informational privacy is the provision's central concem. (Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Assn. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1, 35.) A plaintiff, by initiating litigation, does not waive his or her expectation of privacy in the use of his personal digital devices, including cell phones, text messages and email messages. (Carpenter v. United States (2018) 138 S.

  • Name

    SCOTT HANOVER, ET AL VS CANDICE BRUNER, ET AL

  • Case No.

    21CV02585

  • Hearing

    May 02, 2024

  • County

    Santa Cruz County, CA

The state Constitution expressly grants Californians a right of privacy. (Cal. Const., art. I § 1.) Protection of informational privacy is the provision's central concem. (Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Assn. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1, 35.) A plaintiff, by initiating litigation, does not waive his or her expectation of privacy in the use of his personal digital devices, including cell phones, text messages and email messages. (Carpenter v. United States (2018) 138 S.

  • Name

    SCOTT HANOVER, ET AL VS CANDICE BRUNER, ET AL

  • Case No.

    21CV02585

  • Hearing

    May 03, 2024

  • County

    Santa Cruz County, CA

The state Constitution expressly grants Californians a right of privacy. (Cal. Const., art. I § 1.) Protection of informational privacy is the provision's central concem. (Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Assn. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1, 35.) A plaintiff, by initiating litigation, does not waive his or her expectation of privacy in the use of his personal digital devices, including cell phones, text messages and email messages. (Carpenter v. United States (2018) 138 S.

  • Name

    SCOTT HANOVER, ET AL VS CANDICE BRUNER, ET AL

  • Case No.

    21CV02585

  • Hearing

    May 06, 2024

  • County

    Santa Cruz County, CA

The state Constitution expressly grants Californians a right of privacy. (Cal. Const., art. I § 1.) Protection of informational privacy is the provision's central concem. (Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Assn. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1, 35.) A plaintiff, by initiating litigation, does not waive his or her expectation of privacy in the use of his personal digital devices, including cell phones, text messages and email messages. (Carpenter v. United States (2018) 138 S.

  • Name

    SCOTT HANOVER, ET AL VS CANDICE BRUNER, ET AL

  • Case No.

    21CV02585

  • Hearing

    May 08, 2024

  • County

    Santa Cruz County, CA

The state Constitution expressly grants Californians a right of privacy. (Cal. Const., art. I § 1.) Protection of informational privacy is the provision's central concem. (Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Assn. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1, 35.) A plaintiff, by initiating litigation, does not waive his or her expectation of privacy in the use of his personal digital devices, including cell phones, text messages and email messages. (Carpenter v. United States (2018) 138 S.

  • Name

    SCOTT HANOVER, ET AL VS CANDICE BRUNER, ET AL

  • Case No.

    21CV02585

  • Hearing

    May 04, 2024

  • County

    Santa Cruz County, CA

The state Constitution expressly grants Californians a right of privacy. (Cal. Const., art. I § 1.) Protection of informational privacy is the provision's central concem. (Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Assn. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1, 35.) A plaintiff, by initiating litigation, does not waive his or her expectation of privacy in the use of his personal digital devices, including cell phones, text messages and email messages. (Carpenter v. United States (2018) 138 S.

  • Name

    SCOTT HANOVER, ET AL VS CANDICE BRUNER, ET AL

  • Case No.

    21CV02585

  • Hearing

    May 07, 2024

  • County

    Santa Cruz County, CA

The state Constitution expressly grants Californians a right of privacy. (Cal. Const., art. I § 1.) Protection of informational privacy is the provision's central concem. (Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Assn. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1, 35.) A plaintiff, by initiating litigation, does not waive his or her expectation of privacy in the use of his personal digital devices, including cell phones, text messages and email messages. (Carpenter v. United States (2018) 138 S.

  • Name

    SCOTT HANOVER, ET AL VS CANDICE BRUNER, ET AL

  • Case No.

    21CV02585

  • Hearing

    May 05, 2024

  • County

    Santa Cruz County, CA

Defendants have not met their burden to show a compelling need for additional discovery, i.e., that such documents are directly relevant to the issue of causation of plaintiff’s emotional distress damages, which is so strong as to outweigh plaintiff’s privacy rights when these two competing interests are carefully balanced. Digital Music News LLC v. Superior Court (2014) 226 Cal. App. 4th 216, 229. Plaintiff is ordered to give notice of the ruling.

  • Name

    MEDAL VS. FLORENCE CRITTENTON SERVICES ORANGE COUNTY

  • Case No.

    30-2016-00869659-CU-WT-CJC

  • Hearing

    Jun 08, 2017

Generally, companies enjoy no right to financial privacy under the United States or California Constitutions. (See United States v. Morton Salt Co. (1950) 338 U.S. 632, 652¿ [[C]orporations can claim no equality with individuals in the enjoyment of a right to privacy]; Roberts v. Gulf Oil Corp. (1983) 147 Cal. App. 3d 770, 791 [The [California] constitutional provision [concerning the right to privacy] simply does not apply to corporations. The provision protects the privacy rights of people.].)

  • Name

    JINWAN SHEN, ET AL. VS LINGXIAO LI, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    24SMCV00651

  • Hearing

    Jan 15, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Defendant also fails to demonstrate how the request is oppressive or violates Defendants' or Defendant's employees' privacy. Defendant also asserts the employee handbook contains trade secrets. To address this concern, and that of privacy, Plaintiff offered to enter into a protective order. Defendant does not explain how a proper protective order would not address its privacy or trade secret concerns. The Court orders production of the employee handbook subject to an "attorneys' eye only" protective order.

  • Name

    HAYE VS JIMMIE JOHNSON KEARNY MESA CHEVROLET

  • Case No.

    37-2019-00049465-CU-PO-CTL

  • Hearing

    Oct 01, 2020

Right to Privacy Discovery can be limited if it infringes on the right of privacy. The state Constitution expressly grants Californians a right of privacy. (Cal. Const., art. I, § 1.) Protection of informational privacy is the provision's central concern. [Citation omitted.] In Hill , we established a framework for evaluating potential invasions of privacy.

  • Name

    ELIA ROSA MERCADO LEIVA VS MICKEY VASQUEZ, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    21STCV35189

  • Hearing

    Oct 26, 2023

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Plaintiff objects on the grounds that the subpoenas: (1) violate Plaintiff right to privacy in his medical records an d seek records unrelated to his injuries, conditions, and body parts at issue in the case; (2) violate the physician-patient privilege and/or psychotherapist-patient privilege and the subpoenas are not narrowly tailored to address the documents pertinent to this case; (3) violate his right of privacy in financial information and documentation, as they seek billing, financial, and insurance records

  • Name

    DAVID MARCUS KING VS ROBIN RAMON HA RIVERA, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    23BBCV01414

  • Hearing

    Jan 26, 2024

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Plaintiff’s counsel’s claim that Plaintiff only took online classes is insufficient to demonstrate this. Defendant’s counsel reasonable met and conferred with Plaintiff’s counsel in asking for Plaintiff’s counsel to produce documents with necessary redactions in order to protect Plaintiff’s privacy. It does not appear Plaintiff was amenable to this reasonable suggestion. The Court finds a protective order is properly issued in order to protect Plaintiff’s privacy interests.

  • Name

    MATTHEW LEE VS EDWARD WEILBACHER

  • Case No.

    BC722751

  • Hearing

    Nov 13, 2020

Third Cause of Action (Invasion of Privacy.) Plaintiff alleges: 116. Plaintiff has a legally protected privacy interests, as recognized by the California Constitution, CIPA, and common law. 117.

  • Name

    PRECILA BALABBO VS WILDFLOWER BRANDS, LLC

  • Case No.

    25STCV20971

  • Hearing

    Apr 06, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

Defendant argues that Plaintiff fails to plead any substantial invasion of the asserted privacy interest, as the present case, related to the tracking and selling of internet user data, is unlike the conventional circumstances in which intrusion upon privacy is found. (Demurrer at pp. 45.)

  • Name

    MIGUEL ESPARZA VS S&B FILTERS, INC., A CALIFORNIA CORPORATION,

  • Case No.

    25STCV15352

  • Hearing

    Jul 20, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

There is not an egregious invasion of privacy every time there is a request for private information and courts must “place the burden on the party asserting a privacy interest to establish its extent and seriousness of the prospective invasion.” (Williams v. Superior Court (2017) 3 Cal.5th 531, 557.)

  • Name

    HEATHER REYES ET AL VS JENNIFER GOODNIGHT ET AL

  • Case No.

    BC665080

  • Hearing

    Feb 11, 2020

On or before July 21, 2026, Defendant DIGITAL BRANDS GROUP, INC. shall serve the Privilege Log. Plaintiff to give notice. I. BACKGROUND On July 29, 2025, CENTURY CITY MALL, LLC (Plaintiff) filed a Complaint against DIGITAL BRANDS GROUP, INC (Defendant), FOR ALTER EGO ACTION ON JUDGMENT. Plaintiff alleges that it seeks to add Defendant as an alter ego to a Judgment against Plaintiffs former tenant Bailey 44, LLC, for over $1.4 million.

  • Name

    CENTURY CITY MALL, LLC, A DELAWARE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY VS DIGITAL BRANDS GROUP, INC., A DELAWARE CORPORATION, ET AL.

  • Case No.

    25STCV22236

  • Hearing

    Jul 16, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA

The court found that Motorolas privacy statement specifically identified California privacy laws, which was evidence of express aiming at California residents. ( Id . at 8.) However, Petitioner has not proffered admissible evidence of Respondents privacy policies aimed at California residents. C. Petitioner is entitled to a continuance to conduct jurisdictional discovery.

  • Name

    VIVEK SHAH VS IDACORP, INC., AN IDAHO CORPORATION,

  • Case No.

    26STCP00326

  • Hearing

    May 05, 2026

  • County

    Los Angeles County, CA