On July 10, 2020 a
Summons
was filed
involving a dispute between
Garibay, Christian,
Ramirez, Jose A.,
Menor-Cruz, Moises,
Romero-Neri, Yolanda,
and
City Of Colton, A Government Entity .,
Garibay, Christian,
Ramirez, Jose A.,
San Bernardino County, A Government Entity,
for Wrongful Death Non-Motor Vehicle Unlimited
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
o r
POS 010
FOR COURT USE ONLY
ATTORNEY pR PAR7Y WITHOU7 ATTORNEY Name State Bar
numberand address
DAVID F MAKKABI SBN 249825
ESQ
KARiA RUIZESQ SBN 269598
DANIEL P QOSE ESQ 5BN 100702
MAKKABI LAW GROUP APC
9dS4 WItSHtRE BOULEVARQ St71TE 90d
SUpERIOR COUR7 OF LiFORNIA
BEVER Y HI S cn 902 t 2
NO
COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO
TE EPNONE 310 887 044 FAX NOOptiona0 31 Q8 7 8409 SAN BERNtARDINO DiSTRICT
E MA i L ADD R
55 Opffonol
ATTORNEYFOR Name PLAINTIFFSMOISES MENOR CRUZ an individual in
and as successor
interest ta the estate of LES
lE DENISE MENOR ROMERO decedentet al CT o7 2020
SUPERIORCOURTOPCALIFORNIA COUNTYOF SAN BERNARDINp
S TREETADDRE55247 WE5T THlRD 5fREET
MAI ING AODRESS247 WEST THlRD STREET
cITYANDZIPCODE SAN BERNARDINO CA92415 021q LISABE H MARTI EpUTy
BRANCh NAME AN BERNARD4N0 DfSTRtCT COURCHOUSE
PLAINTIFFPETiTIONER MOISES MENOR CRUZ an individuai
and in interest
as successor to the CASE NUMBER
estateof MENOR RdMERO
ESLIE pENiSE decedentet al CIVD52013878
dE ENDfiNT1RE5PQNDENT CHRISTIAN GARIBAYan individual
Ref No or file No
PROOF OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS
4921057 MEn Oft vGARIaAVJ
ISeparate proof of servite rs required for each parry served
1 At the time of service I
was at least 18 years of age and nc t a party to this action
2 Iserved coies ofi
a X summons
b 0 complaint
c Q Alternative Dispufe Resoiutia
ADR package
d 0 Civil Case Cover Sheet
served in complex cases only
e cross camplaint
N
f other ADDiTIONAL PIAINTIFF S
specify dncumentsJ ATTACHMENT ADDITIONALDEFENOANT S ATTACHMENT CERTIFICATEOF
ASSIGNMEN7 ALTF RNATIVE DISPUTE RESOlUTION SH
ET NOTICE Of 7ftIAL S TTING CONFER
NCF
3 a
Partyserved name
specify documenis
rrs shown on
of party served rC J
SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY government entity
b Person other than the party in item 3a
served on behalf of an entity or as an authorized agent
and not a perso r under item 5b on
whom substituted service was made
specijy name and re
rtionship io the party named in rCem 30
4 Address where the party was served
385 N ARRdWHEAD AVE 5econd FloarSAN BERNARDINO CA 92415
5 iservedthe partycheck proper bax
a
by personai service
ipersanaily delivered the documents listed an item 2 to the party or person autharized ta
ice
receive sen for
af proeess fihe
party 1 on date 2 at time
b X by substituted service On
date Wed Sep 30 2020 at time 01 30 PM ileft the documents listed in
tem 2 with or in the presence of ntrme and citle or relarionship to persan inditated in ltem 3
Documents left with Lorraine Rubalcava
deputy clerkAge 55 Ethnicity
HispanicGender Female Weight175 Height 5 1 Hair
BlackEyes BIaCk
1 X
businessa persan ateast 18 years o
age appa ently in charge at the
office or us
ai p ace af business af the person to
be servedIinformed him or her ofthe general nature ofthe papers
Qj Q home a cornpetent member of the
householdat least 18 years of age
at the dwelling house or usual place of abode of
the par yiinformed him ar her of the general
nature af the papers
3j Q physical address unknown
a person at least
18 years of age apparently in charge at the usual mailing address af the
person to be
served other than a
United States Postal Service post office
box i informed him or her of the general nature
af che papers
4 X Ithereafter mailed
by frst class
pastage prepaidcopies of Che documents ta the persan to be
servedat the place
tt e eqpies were
wrtiere eR Code CivProc 475 20 1 thedc date
mailed cumentson
Wed Sep 30 202Q
from ciry RIVERSIQE CALIFORNiA or a dedaratior of mailing is attached
5 0 Iattch a declaratian of diligence sCating acCions taken
first Co actempt
personal service
FormAdopted
forMandatory use PROC7F OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS Page 1 of
ju d icial Cou
n dl of Californ ia
Cpd e of Civ ii Procedu re
417 10
POS Oid Rev 1 2007
January
yi
CASE NUMBER
interest to the
PETITIONER MOISES MENOR CRUZ anindividual and
as su in
cessor
PLAINTIFF
CIVDS2013878
estateofLESLIEDENISE MENOR ROMERO decedent et al
DEFENDANTlRESPONDENT CHRISTIAN GARIBAYan individual
S c
by mail and acknowledgment of receipt of service
irnailed the documents listed in item 2 to the party to the address shown in item
4 by first dass mail postage
prepaid
1 on date 2 from ciry
t3 with two copies of the Notice and Acknowledgment of Receipt and a postage paid retum envelope addressed to me
Annch
Civ Proc A1530
Notice
completed andAcknowledgementof ReceiptCode
4 Q to an address outside California
with return receipt requested
Code CivProc 415 40
d by other meansspecify means oJservice and authorizing code section
Q Additional
page descnbing service is attached
6 The Notice to ihe Person Served
on the summons was completed as follows
a as an individual
defendant
b as theperson sued under the fictitious name
ofspecify
c as occupant
d Q On behalfof specify SAN BFRNARDINO COUNTY a government entity
under the following Code of Civii
Procedure section
416 10 415 95 business organization form unknown
Q corporation
Q 41620 defunctcorporation
0 41660 minor
416 30jointstock
company association
0 416J0 ward or conservatee
416 40associationorpartnership 416 90 authorized person
415 46 occupant
Q 416 50 public
entity
XQ other a government entity
7 Person who served papers
a Name JULIE ANNE SORENSEN CALIFORNIA REGISTEREDPROCESS SERVER
b Address EXCALIBUR ATTORNEY SERVICES 231 EALFSSANDRO BOU EVARD SUITE A368 RIVERSIDFCA 92508
c Telephonenumber 877 378 3843
d The fee for
service was 130 00completed service o e faad address
e am
t 0 not a registered California process server
2 Q exempt from registration under
iusiness and Professions Code section 72350 b
3 X a registered California process server
i owner employee independent contractor
ii Registration NoPS 001726
iii County RIVERSIDE
8 0 1declare under penalty of perjury under the laws
of the State of California
that the foregoing is true and correct
or
9 Iam a California sheriff or marshal and I certify that the foregoing is true and correct
1
Date 09 30 2020
JULiE ANNE SORENSEN CAIIFORNIA REGISTERED PROCESS SERVER
NAME OF PERSON WHO SERVED PAPERS SHERIFF OR MARSHAL NATU
POS 010 Rev
January12007J PROOF OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS age of7
Document Filed Date
October 07, 2020
Case Filing Date
July 10, 2020
Category
Wrongful Death Non-Motor Vehicle Unlimited
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
o r POS 010 FOR COURT USE ONLY ATTORNEY pR PAR7Y WITHOU7 ATTORNEY Name State Bar numberand address DAVID F MAKKABI SBN 249825 ESQ KARiA RUIZESQ SBN 269598 DANIEL P QOSE ESQ 5BN 100702 MAKKABI LAW GROUP APC 9dS4 WItSHtRE BOULEVARQ St71TE 90d SUpERIOR COUR7 OF LiFORNIA BEVER Y HI S cn 902 t 2 NO COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO TE EPNONE 310 887 044 FAX NOOptiona0 31 Q8 7 8409 SAN BERNtARDINO DiSTRICT E MA i L ADD R 55 Opffonol ATTORNEYFOR Name PLAINTIFFSMOISES MENOR CRUZ an individual in and as successor interest ta the estate of LES lE DENISE MENOR ROMERO decedentet al CT o7 2020 SUPERIORCOURTOPCALIFORNIA COUNTYOF SAN BERNARDINp S TREETADDRE55247 WE5T THlRD 5fREET MAI ING AODRESS247 WEST THlRD STREET cITYANDZIPCODE SAN BERNARDINO CA92415 021q LISABE H MARTI EpUTy BRANCh NAME AN BERNARD4N0 DfSTRtCT COURCHOUSE PLAINTIFFPETiTIONER MOISES MENOR CRUZ an individuai and in interest as successor to the CASE NUMBER estateof MENOR RdMERO ESLIE pENiSE decedentet al CIVD52013878 dE ENDfiNT1RE5PQNDENT CHRISTIAN GARIBAYan individual Ref No or file No PROOF OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS 4921057 MEn Oft vGARIaAVJ ISeparate proof of servite rs required for each parry served 1 At the time of service I was at least 18 years of age and nc t a party to this action 2 Iserved coies ofi a X summons b 0 complaint c Q Alternative Dispufe Resoiutia ADR package d 0 Civil Case Cover Sheet served in complex cases only e cross camplaint N f other ADDiTIONAL PIAINTIFF S specify dncumentsJ ATTACHMENT ADDITIONALDEFENOANT S ATTACHMENT CERTIFICATEOF ASSIGNMEN7 ALTF RNATIVE DISPUTE RESOlUTION SH ET NOTICE Of 7ftIAL S TTING CONFER NCF 3 a Partyserved name specify documenis rrs shown on of party served rC J SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY government entity b Person other than the party in item 3a served on behalf of an entity or as an authorized agent and not a perso r under item 5b on whom substituted service was made specijy name and re rtionship io the party named in rCem 30 4 Address where the party was served 385 N ARRdWHEAD AVE 5econd FloarSAN BERNARDINO CA 92415 5 iservedthe partycheck proper bax a by personai service ipersanaily delivered the documents listed an item 2 to the party or person autharized ta ice receive sen for af proeess fihe party 1 on date 2 at time b X by substituted service On date Wed Sep 30 2020 at time 01 30 PM ileft the documents listed in tem 2 with or in the presence of ntrme and citle or relarionship to persan inditated in ltem 3 Documents left with Lorraine Rubalcava deputy clerkAge 55 Ethnicity HispanicGender Female Weight175 Height 5 1 Hair BlackEyes BIaCk 1 X businessa persan ateast 18 years o age appa ently in charge at the office or us ai p ace af business af the person to be servedIinformed him or her ofthe general nature ofthe papers Qj Q home a cornpetent member of the householdat least 18 years of age at the dwelling house or usual place of abode of the par yiinformed him ar her of the general nature af the papers 3j Q physical address unknown a person at least 18 years of age apparently in charge at the usual mailing address af the person to be served other than a United States Postal Service post office box i informed him or her of the general nature af che papers 4 X Ithereafter mailed by frst class pastage prepaidcopies of Che documents ta the persan to be servedat the place tt e eqpies were wrtiere eR Code CivProc 475 20 1 thedc date mailed cumentson Wed Sep 30 202Q from ciry RIVERSIQE CALIFORNiA or a dedaratior of mailing is attached 5 0 Iattch a declaratian of diligence sCating acCions taken first Co actempt personal service FormAdopted forMandatory use PROC7F OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS Page 1 of ju d icial Cou n dl of Californ ia Cpd e of Civ ii Procedu re 417 10 POS Oid Rev 1 2007 January yi CASE NUMBER interest to the PETITIONER MOISES MENOR CRUZ anindividual and as su in cessor PLAINTIFF CIVDS2013878 estateofLESLIEDENISE MENOR ROMERO decedent et al DEFENDANTlRESPONDENT CHRISTIAN GARIBAYan individual S c by mail and acknowledgment of receipt of service irnailed the documents listed in item 2 to the party to the address shown in item 4 by first dass mail postage prepaid 1 on date 2 from ciry t3 with two copies of the Notice and Acknowledgment of Receipt and a postage paid retum envelope addressed to me Annch Civ Proc A1530 Notice completed andAcknowledgementof ReceiptCode 4 Q to an address outside California with return receipt requested Code CivProc 415 40 d by other meansspecify means oJservice and authorizing code section Q Additional page descnbing service is attached 6 The Notice to ihe Person Served on the summons was completed as follows a as an individual defendant b as theperson sued under the fictitious name ofspecify c as occupant d Q On behalfof specify SAN BFRNARDINO COUNTY a government entity under the following Code of Civii Procedure section 416 10 415 95 business organization form unknown Q corporation Q 41620 defunctcorporation 0 41660 minor 416 30jointstock company association 0 416J0 ward or conservatee 416 40associationorpartnership 416 90 authorized person 415 46 occupant Q 416 50 public entity XQ other a government entity 7 Person who served papers a Name JULIE ANNE SORENSEN CALIFORNIA REGISTEREDPROCESS SERVER b Address EXCALIBUR ATTORNEY SERVICES 231 EALFSSANDRO BOU EVARD SUITE A368 RIVERSIDFCA 92508 c Telephonenumber 877 378 3843 d The fee for service was 130 00completed service o e faad address e am t 0 not a registered California process server 2 Q exempt from registration under iusiness and Professions Code section 72350 b 3 X a registered California process server i owner employee independent contractor ii Registration NoPS 001726 iii County RIVERSIDE 8 0 1declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct or 9 Iam a California sheriff or marshal and I certify that the foregoing is true and correct 1 Date 09 30 2020 JULiE ANNE SORENSEN CAIIFORNIA REGISTERED PROCESS SERVER NAME OF PERSON WHO SERVED PAPERS SHERIFF OR MARSHAL NATU POS 010 Rev January12007J PROOF OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS age of7