On September 04, 2018 a
Judge Benson Recusal Per CCP 170.1 - Judge's Recusal Per CCP 170.1
was filed
involving a dispute between
Coulombe, Julie,
and
Butte County Probation,
for (15) Unlimited Other Employment
in the District Court of Butte County.
Preview
-
_
.
_ _
1775 Concord Ave
Superlor Court of Callfornla
'
Chico CA 95928
County of Butte Civil
. 530-532-7009
Re: Coulombe, Julie vs Butte County Probation
Case Number: 18CV02884 l
l -.,..
r: a‘?
“ f
l v
i "r-M)
£1150 L
Recusal of Judge F;
Pursuant to CCP 170.1 .L
Basis for Disqualification:
II]
'
I have personal knowledge of the disputed facts. (A judge deemed to have personal knowledge if the
judge or a spouse or relative islikely to be a witness.) CCP 170.1(a)(1)(A)
[:l l have served as a lawyer in this proceeding or represented or advised one of the parties inanother
proceeding involving the Same issues. -(Ajudge is deemed to have served as a lawyer in the proceedings
if within the past two (2) years (a) a party was a client ofthe judge or the judge's firm, or (b) a lawyer in the
'
case was in practice‘ with thejudge.) CCP 170.1(a)(2)(A) . .
El l have, or my spouse or minor child has, a financial interest In the subject matter or in a party.
. CCP 170.1(a)(3)(A)
El lor my spouse _or relative is a party. CCP 170.1(a)(4)
III A laWyer in the proceeding or an attorney in practice with one of the lawyers is my spouse, a former
spouse, child, sibling, or parent, or has such relationship with my spouse.
III lbelieve my recusal would further the interest ofjustice. CCP 170.1(a)(6)(A)(i)
[:1 lbelieve there is a substantial doubt as to my capacity to be impartial. CCP 170.1(a)(6)(A)(ii)
[E/Aperson
'
aware of the facts might reasonably entertain a doubt that l would be able to be impartial.
CCP'170.1(a)(6)(A)(iii)
I] lheard this case, and cannot participate in appellate review of it. CCP 170.1(b)
IQ/l am recusing myself for the reason stated above.
II] l am mat recusing'myself because: The above basis for disqualification having been disclosed, the
parties have indicated they wish to WAIVE the disqualification. Counsel are to submit a written waiver
reciting the basis for disqualification and signed by all parties and their counsel. (Personal bias or
prejudice concerning a party and a judge's involvement as an attorney or witness CANNOT BE WAlVED.)
CCP 170.3(b)
‘
Date: filth?
Q
'
Hon.
We
Stephen E. Benson,
Judge of the Superior Court
CC: Presiding Judge
Document Filed Date
September 13, 2018
Case Filing Date
September 04, 2018
Category
(15) Unlimited Other Employment
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
- _ . _ _ 1775 Concord Ave Superlor Court of Callfornla ' Chico CA 95928 County of Butte Civil . 530-532-7009 Re: Coulombe, Julie vs Butte County Probation Case Number: 18CV02884 l l -.,.. r: a‘? “ f l v i "r-M) £1150 L Recusal of Judge F; Pursuant to CCP 170.1 .L Basis for Disqualification: II] ' I have personal knowledge of the disputed facts. (A judge deemed to have personal knowledge if the judge or a spouse or relative islikely to be a witness.) CCP 170.1(a)(1)(A) [:l l have served as a lawyer in this proceeding or represented or advised one of the parties inanother proceeding involving the Same issues. -(Ajudge is deemed to have served as a lawyer in the proceedings if within the past two (2) years (a) a party was a client ofthe judge or the judge's firm, or (b) a lawyer in the ' case was in practice‘ with thejudge.) CCP 170.1(a)(2)(A) . . El l have, or my spouse or minor child has, a financial interest In the subject matter or in a party. . CCP 170.1(a)(3)(A) El lor my spouse _or relative is a party. CCP 170.1(a)(4) III A laWyer in the proceeding or an attorney in practice with one of the lawyers is my spouse, a former spouse, child, sibling, or parent, or has such relationship with my spouse. III lbelieve my recusal would further the interest ofjustice. CCP 170.1(a)(6)(A)(i) [:1 lbelieve there is a substantial doubt as to my capacity to be impartial. CCP 170.1(a)(6)(A)(ii) [E/Aperson ' aware of the facts might reasonably entertain a doubt that l would be able to be impartial. CCP'170.1(a)(6)(A)(iii) I] lheard this case, and cannot participate in appellate review of it. CCP 170.1(b) IQ/l am recusing myself for the reason stated above. II] l am mat recusing'myself because: The above basis for disqualification having been disclosed, the parties have indicated they wish to WAIVE the disqualification. Counsel are to submit a written waiver reciting the basis for disqualification and signed by all parties and their counsel. (Personal bias or prejudice concerning a party and a judge's involvement as an attorney or witness CANNOT BE WAlVED.) CCP 170.3(b) ‘ Date: filth? Q ' Hon. We Stephen E. Benson, Judge of the Superior Court CC: Presiding Judge