Preview
Murray Tragish, Esq., CSB //80759
LAW OFFICES OF MURRAY TRAGISH
5330 Office Center Court, Suite 72
1405 Commercial Way, Suite 130
Bakersfield, California 93309
Tel: (661) 324-2648
E-Mail:Murray Murraytragish.corn
Ray T. Mullen, Esq., CSB //111852
LAW OFFICE OF RAY T. MULLEN
5330 Office Center Court, Suite 32
Bakersfield, California 93309
Tel: (661) 631-1531
E-Mail:Ray Raymulien.corn
9
Attorneys for Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant: Alder Mini Storage, L.P., a
California limited partnership and
10
Cross-Defendant: Derrel Ridenour
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF KERN, METROPOLITAN DISTRICT, CIVIL DIVISION
14
IS
ALDAR MINI STORAGE, L.P., a California Case No. BCV-20-101265-BCB
limited partnership,
16
NOTICE OF HEARING ON PLAINTIFF'S
MOTION FOR AN ORDER COMPELLING
Plaintiff, DEFENDANT/CROSS-COMPLAINANT:
17
vs. WORLD OF PENTECOST, INC. AKA
18
WORLD OF PENTECOST-LIFE CHURCH
THV ENTERPRISES, a California TO PROVIDE FURTHER WRITTEN
19 corporation; THV HAYIGVARIK, LLC, a RESPONSES AND DOCUMENTS TO
California limited liability company; WORLD DEMAND FOR PRODUCTION OF
20 OF PENTECOST, INC., a California non- DOCUMENTS SET ONE, AND FOR
profit religious corporation, also known as THE IMPOSITION OF MONETARY
SANCTIONS
21 WORLD OF PENTECOST-LIFE CHURCH;
[CCP $ 2031.310(a)(I)(2), CCP
KHACHATUR GHASABYAN, an individual,
$ 2031.310(b)(1)(2); and Rule 3.1345 of
22 also known as CHRIS GHASABYAN; the CRC]
TIGRAN ARUTYUNYAN, an individual; and
23 DOES through 500, inclusive,
1
Date of Hearing: March 22, 2022
24
Time of Hearing: 8:30 a.m.
Defendants. Division: H
25
WORLD OF PENTECOST, INC., a Assigned to the Honorable Bernard C. Barmann
26 Action Filed: June 1, 2020
Cross-Complainant,
First Amended Cross-Complaint: May 24, 2021
27 Trial Date: May 23, 2022
28 vs.
NOTICE OF HEARING ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR AN ORDER COMPELLING DEFENDANT/CROSS-COMPLAINANT: WORLD
OF PENTECOST-LIFE CHURCH TO PROVIDE FURTHER WRITTEN RESPONSES AND DOCUMENTS TO DEMAND FOR
PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS. SET ONE, AND FOR THE IMPOSITION OF MONETARY SANCTIONS
I
ALDAR MINI STORAGE, L.P., a
I
California limited partnership, DERRELL
2 RIDENOUR, an individual, HEIDI NELSON,
an individual, THV ENTERPRISES, a
3 California
California corporation; THV HAYKNARIK,
4
LLC, a limited liability company;
ALDAR MINI STORAGE, L.P., a California
6 limited partnership, KHACHATUR
GHASABYAN, an individual, also known as
6 CHRIS GHASABYAN; TIGRAN
7
ARUTYUNYAN, All Person Unknown,
Claiming any Legal or Equitable Right, Title,
8 Estate, Lien, or Interest in the Property
Described in the Complaint or Cross-
9
Complaint Adverse to Cross-Complainant's
10
Title Thereto, and DOES 1 through 500,
inclusive,
ll
jCrossI-Defendants.
12
13 TO THK ABOVE-ENTITLED COURT, AND TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR
14 ATTORNEYS OF RECORD;
IS
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on March 22, 2022, at 8:30 a.m., or as soon thereafter
16
as the matter may be heard, in Division H of the instant Court, located at 1215 Truxtun Avenue,
17
Bakersfield, California 93301, Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant: ALDAR MINI STORAGE, L.P., 8
18
19 California limited partnership (hereinafter referred to as "Plaintiff', will and hereby does move
20 for an Order Compelling Further Written Responses and Documents to Demand for Production ol
21
Documents, Set One, and For the Imposition of Monetary Sanctions, against Defendant/Cross-
22
Complainant: World of Pentecost-Life Church, Inc. aka World of Pentecost-Life Church
23
24
(hereinafter referred to as "WOP") (hereinafter referred to as the "Motion" )
25 This Motion is made on the grounds that good cause exists pursuant to California Code of Civil
26 Procedure section 2031.310(a)(1)(2), in that the WOP Responses to the Demand for Production ol
27
Documents, Set One, are incomplete, evasive and non-responsive, and fails to provide specific
28
NOTICE OF HEARING ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR AN ORDER COMPELLING DEFENDANT/CROSS
COMPI AINANT: WORLD
OF PENTECOST-LIFE CHURCH TO PROVIDE FURTHER WRITTEN RESPONSES AND DOCUMENTS TO DEMAND
FOR
PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, SET ONE, AND FOR THE IMPOSITION OF MONETARY SANCTIONS
2
statcmcnts o!'OI'» I&cllsonablcCI'I'ortsand inquiries lo ohuiin docunfents in itsalleged olliccs ill
'& 3(I2S Ihlirf'ax Roffd. Bakersfield. Cnlif'ornim rcsponsivc to the Demm&d Ibr Production ol
pl'ovklc!I'lid (k)t.'(in)cols.
l)ocun&cifL&. Sr.'I OIIe. af)d lo
In addition to tlic lorcgoing relief. Plaintil Iseeks thc imposltlon ot monctaD sanctions agmnst
WOI'. as slim&cd bv Imv. (hie to thc continual refusal by WOP to cscrcise good lhith efT()!'I lo obt'ffn
t&
7
documents rcspoi)Rive fo the l1emand lor Production ol Documents. Sct One. and produce
docunfcnts,
'I hl!&
hf()fiol) Ls nlildc I111dbllstxl OPon Ihc Motion m&(l I&ioticc of thc
I.I&.'ru'nlLL suPPoltlng
la
Decl iration ol'lurr«y 'I'rugish.iMcmorandum ol'oints nitd Authoritics, thc Separate Statement ol
Itisputcd 'uid
."vlattcrs. ant alai all oral:uf&l/or (k&cumcntaD ctitlcncc nial m'r&ament as may bc
ls
adduced at lhc tlt'ilc ol hen&lait ol thc Motion.
)',',
Is l)&lied:If(:ITI'l!&Il'1. 2022
R',AW Ill
()I:IIICI.:S ()I& fRRA&
I.A WR(3))IIICI:. Ol) RAY 1'.
'3)I4XGISI.I,,.
Mill.I,L',htb .
17
Murray 1'ragish. I/Attorney Ibr PlaintifT/,"
Cross-Dcfcndluit)l Akkir Ivfini Storage. L..P.. a
Calif'ornia limitcd&Rtfrtffcrshli»ll«d'Cn)ss-
stf Deti:nrlmft: Den&cl I(i(fear&tff)
Si
77
sr&
77
SS
Nt) I'lt I.
&)I' AION&'
II &N AINI II'I 'S RI()
I'I II()&N I'()ll &&N ()l(I)I I( c()SII'I'I
IIN(i I)I I'I NI)AN It& itt)vv ('&)&RII'I. )IN &N I. &I &)I&I
I)
r&f Nfl'('ONI
I I I uI (lit'Iuliir)
I lunif&l.
I tfltifil R rvRII II &\ ltl sf'()Nisi RANI&l)ra lrsll Nis f&&i)f SIANOIr<
PR&&i)t
& I!&)Nr)i'l&&K'I nfl SIN sl
I r»NI.'&Nf)
I I'fit
&< IRII'Osl fir)N t)l
RIONI IAR'i s'rs(IION'I
PROOF OF SERVICE
rt/dar Mini Storage, L.P. vs.THV Enterprises, Inc., et al.
Kern County Superior Court; Case No. BCV-20-101265-BCB
STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF KERN
I am a citizen of the United States and employed in the County of Kern, State of California
and my business
address is 5330 Oflice Center Court, Suite 72, Bakersfield, California 93309; I am over the age of eighteen and not a
party to the within entitled action.
On February 22, 2022, I served the following document(s) described as: NOTICE OF HKARLUG ON
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR AN ORDER COMPELLING DEFENDANT/CROSS-
COMPLAINANT: WORLD OF PENTECOST-LIFE CHURCH TO PROVIDE FURTHER
WRITTEN RESPONSES AND DOCUMENTS TO DEMAND FOR PRODUCTION OF
DOCUMENTS. SKT ONE. AND FOR THE IMPOSITION OF MONETARY SANCTIONS, on the
interested parties to said action or through their attorneys of record, by placing a true copy thereof in a sealed envelope,
addressed as shown be! ow, by the following means:
(By Mail) By placing a true copy thereof, enclosed in a sealed envelope with postage thereon fully prepaid, for
collection and mailing on that date following ordinary business practices, in the United States Mail at the Law
Offices of Murray Tragish, Bakersfield, California, addressed as shown below. I am readily familiar with this
business's practice for collection and processing of correspondence for mailing with the L'.S.
Postal Service,
and in the ordinary course of businesscorrespondence would be deposited with the U.S. PostalService the
same day it was placed for collection and processing.
Attomev for Defendant/Cross-Defendant: Khachartur Ghasabvan AKA Chris Ghasabvan
Ronald D. Dessy, Esq.
Dessy k. Dessy APC
1301 "L" Street
Bakersfield, California 93301
California
Defendant/Cross-Defendant: THV Enter@rises. Inc.
Agent for Service of Process: Gayane Arutyunyun
3025 Fairfax Road
Bakersfield, 93306
Defendant/Cross-Defendant: THV Havknarik I-LC
Agent for Service of Process: Tigran Arutyunyun
725 Bohlig Road
Glendale, California 91207
Defendant/Cross-Defendant: Tiuran Arutvunvan
725 Bohlig Road
Glendale, California91207
Defendant: World Of Pentecost. Inc. aka World of Pentecost-Life Church
cio Kurt Johnson and Linda Johnson .
13061 Rosedale Highway
Bakersfield, California93314
Attornevs for Cross-Comnlainant: World of Pentecost. Inc.
Thomas M. Alexander, Jr. Esq. Thomas M. Alexander, Jr. Esq.
Alexander Law Offices Thomas Alexander Law Offices
468 N. Camden Drive, Suite 200 226 East Sixth Street
Beverly Hills, California90210 Beaumont, California 92223
Page I of 2
XX (By Electronic Service) Complying with California Code of Civil Procedure t)10106, caused each such
document(s) to be electronically served from amygcr,murraytragish.corn to each addressee below. The file
transmission was reported as complete and a copy of the receipt will be maintained with the original
document(s) in our office.
Rond oggrrr!sol.corn
I Ronald D. Dessy, Esq.
K;&r&c&r»u&son70&crag»ua&hoon& Kurt Johnson (World of Pentecost, Inc.)
aloes&uicrslsn ~ag&naihcom Thomas Alexanders, Jr., Esq.
arui; u»;m t&g& an~rdyahoo.con& Tigran Arutyuuyun
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California
that the foregoing is true and
correct, and that I am employed in the office of a member of the Bar of this Court at whose direction the
service was made. Executed on Pebruary 22, 2022
Page 2 of 2
Preview
Murray Tragish, Esq., CSB //80759 LAW OFFICES OF MURRAY TRAGISH 5330 Office Center Court, Suite 72 1405 Commercial Way, Suite 130 Bakersfield, California 93309 Tel: (661) 324-2648 E-Mail:Murray Murraytragish.corn Ray T. Mullen, Esq., CSB //111852 LAW OFFICE OF RAY T. MULLEN 5330 Office Center Court, Suite 32 Bakersfield, California 93309 Tel: (661) 631-1531 E-Mail:Ray Raymulien.corn 9 Attorneys for Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant: Alder Mini Storage, L.P., a California limited partnership and 10 Cross-Defendant: Derrel Ridenour SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF KERN, METROPOLITAN DISTRICT, CIVIL DIVISION 14 IS ALDAR MINI STORAGE, L.P., a California Case No. BCV-20-101265-BCB limited partnership, 16 NOTICE OF HEARING ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR AN ORDER COMPELLING Plaintiff, DEFENDANT/CROSS-COMPLAINANT: 17 vs. WORLD OF PENTECOST, INC. AKA 18 WORLD OF PENTECOST-LIFE CHURCH THV ENTERPRISES, a California TO PROVIDE FURTHER WRITTEN 19 corporation; THV HAYIGVARIK, LLC, a RESPONSES AND DOCUMENTS TO California limited liability company; WORLD DEMAND FOR PRODUCTION OF 20 OF PENTECOST, INC., a California non- DOCUMENTS SET ONE, AND FOR profit religious corporation, also known as THE IMPOSITION OF MONETARY SANCTIONS 21 WORLD OF PENTECOST-LIFE CHURCH; [CCP $ 2031.310(a)(I)(2), CCP KHACHATUR GHASABYAN, an individual, $ 2031.310(b)(1)(2); and Rule 3.1345 of 22 also known as CHRIS GHASABYAN; the CRC] TIGRAN ARUTYUNYAN, an individual; and 23 DOES through 500, inclusive, 1 Date of Hearing: March 22, 2022 24 Time of Hearing: 8:30 a.m. Defendants. Division: H 25 WORLD OF PENTECOST, INC., a Assigned to the Honorable Bernard C. Barmann 26 Action Filed: June 1, 2020 Cross-Complainant, First Amended Cross-Complaint: May 24, 2021 27 Trial Date: May 23, 2022 28 vs. NOTICE OF HEARING ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR AN ORDER COMPELLING DEFENDANT/CROSS-COMPLAINANT: WORLD OF PENTECOST-LIFE CHURCH TO PROVIDE FURTHER WRITTEN RESPONSES AND DOCUMENTS TO DEMAND FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS. SET ONE, AND FOR THE IMPOSITION OF MONETARY SANCTIONS I ALDAR MINI STORAGE, L.P., a I California limited partnership, DERRELL 2 RIDENOUR, an individual, HEIDI NELSON, an individual, THV ENTERPRISES, a 3 California California corporation; THV HAYKNARIK, 4 LLC, a limited liability company; ALDAR MINI STORAGE, L.P., a California 6 limited partnership, KHACHATUR GHASABYAN, an individual, also known as 6 CHRIS GHASABYAN; TIGRAN 7 ARUTYUNYAN, All Person Unknown, Claiming any Legal or Equitable Right, Title, 8 Estate, Lien, or Interest in the Property Described in the Complaint or Cross- 9 Complaint Adverse to Cross-Complainant's 10 Title Thereto, and DOES 1 through 500, inclusive, ll jCrossI-Defendants. 12 13 TO THK ABOVE-ENTITLED COURT, AND TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR 14 ATTORNEYS OF RECORD; IS NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that on March 22, 2022, at 8:30 a.m., or as soon thereafter 16 as the matter may be heard, in Division H of the instant Court, located at 1215 Truxtun Avenue, 17 Bakersfield, California 93301, Plaintiff/Cross-Defendant: ALDAR MINI STORAGE, L.P., 8 18 19 California limited partnership (hereinafter referred to as "Plaintiff', will and hereby does move 20 for an Order Compelling Further Written Responses and Documents to Demand for Production ol 21 Documents, Set One, and For the Imposition of Monetary Sanctions, against Defendant/Cross- 22 Complainant: World of Pentecost-Life Church, Inc. aka World of Pentecost-Life Church 23 24 (hereinafter referred to as "WOP") (hereinafter referred to as the "Motion" ) 25 This Motion is made on the grounds that good cause exists pursuant to California Code of Civil 26 Procedure section 2031.310(a)(1)(2), in that the WOP Responses to the Demand for Production ol 27 Documents, Set One, are incomplete, evasive and non-responsive, and fails to provide specific 28 NOTICE OF HEARING ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR AN ORDER COMPELLING DEFENDANT/CROSS COMPI AINANT: WORLD OF PENTECOST-LIFE CHURCH TO PROVIDE FURTHER WRITTEN RESPONSES AND DOCUMENTS TO DEMAND FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, SET ONE, AND FOR THE IMPOSITION OF MONETARY SANCTIONS 2 statcmcnts o!'OI'» I&cllsonablcCI'I'ortsand inquiries lo ohuiin docunfents in itsalleged olliccs ill '& 3(I2S Ihlirf'ax Roffd. Bakersfield. Cnlif'ornim rcsponsivc to the Demm&d Ibr Production ol pl'ovklc!I'lid (k)t.'(in)cols. l)ocun&cifL&. Sr.'I OIIe. af)d lo In addition to tlic lorcgoing relief. Plaintil Iseeks thc imposltlon ot monctaD sanctions agmnst WOI'. as slim&cd bv Imv. (hie to thc continual refusal by WOP to cscrcise good lhith efT()!'I lo obt'ffn t& 7 documents rcspoi)Rive fo the l1emand lor Production ol Documents. Sct One. and produce docunfcnts, 'I hl!& hf()fiol) Ls nlildc I111dbllstxl OPon Ihc Motion m&(l I&ioticc of thc I.I&.'ru'nlLL suPPoltlng la Decl iration ol'lurr«y 'I'rugish.iMcmorandum ol'oints nitd Authoritics, thc Separate Statement ol Itisputcd 'uid ."vlattcrs. ant alai all oral:uf&l/or (k&cumcntaD ctitlcncc nial m'r&ament as may bc ls adduced at lhc tlt'ilc ol hen&lait ol thc Motion. )',', Is l)&lied:If(:ITI'l!&Il'1. 2022 R',AW Ill ()I:IIICI.:S ()I& fRRA& I.A WR(3))IIICI:. Ol) RAY 1'. '3)I4XGISI.I,,. Mill.I,L',htb . 17 Murray 1'ragish. I/Attorney Ibr PlaintifT/," Cross-Dcfcndluit)l Akkir Ivfini Storage. L..P.. a Calif'ornia limitcd&Rtfrtffcrshli»ll«d'Cn)ss- stf Deti:nrlmft: Den&cl I(i(fear&tff) Si 77 sr& 77 SS Nt) I'lt I. &)I' AION&' II &N AINI II'I 'S RI() I'I II()&N I'()ll &&N ()l(I)I I( c()SII'I'I IIN(i I)I I'I NI)AN It& itt)vv ('&)&RII'I. )IN &N I. &I &)I&I I) r&f Nfl'('ONI I I I uI (lit'Iuliir) I lunif&l. I tfltifil R rvRII II &\ ltl sf'()Nisi RANI&l)ra lrsll Nis f&&i)f SIANOIr< PR&&i)t & I!&)Nr)i'l&&K'I nfl SIN sl I r»NI.'&Nf) I I'fit &< IRII'Osl fir)N t)l RIONI IAR'i s'rs(IION'I PROOF OF SERVICE rt/dar Mini Storage, L.P. vs.THV Enterprises, Inc., et al. Kern County Superior Court; Case No. BCV-20-101265-BCB STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF KERN I am a citizen of the United States and employed in the County of Kern, State of California and my business address is 5330 Oflice Center Court, Suite 72, Bakersfield, California 93309; I am over the age of eighteen and not a party to the within entitled action. On February 22, 2022, I served the following document(s) described as: NOTICE OF HKARLUG ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR AN ORDER COMPELLING DEFENDANT/CROSS- COMPLAINANT: WORLD OF PENTECOST-LIFE CHURCH TO PROVIDE FURTHER WRITTEN RESPONSES AND DOCUMENTS TO DEMAND FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS. SKT ONE. AND FOR THE IMPOSITION OF MONETARY SANCTIONS, on the interested parties to said action or through their attorneys of record, by placing a true copy thereof in a sealed envelope, addressed as shown be! ow, by the following means: (By Mail) By placing a true copy thereof, enclosed in a sealed envelope with postage thereon fully prepaid, for collection and mailing on that date following ordinary business practices, in the United States Mail at the Law Offices of Murray Tragish, Bakersfield, California, addressed as shown below. I am readily familiar with this business's practice for collection and processing of correspondence for mailing with the L'.S. Postal Service, and in the ordinary course of businesscorrespondence would be deposited with the U.S. PostalService the same day it was placed for collection and processing. Attomev for Defendant/Cross-Defendant: Khachartur Ghasabvan AKA Chris Ghasabvan Ronald D. Dessy, Esq. Dessy k. Dessy APC 1301 "L" Street Bakersfield, California 93301 California Defendant/Cross-Defendant: THV Enter@rises. Inc. Agent for Service of Process: Gayane Arutyunyun 3025 Fairfax Road Bakersfield, 93306 Defendant/Cross-Defendant: THV Havknarik I-LC Agent for Service of Process: Tigran Arutyunyun 725 Bohlig Road Glendale, California 91207 Defendant/Cross-Defendant: Tiuran Arutvunvan 725 Bohlig Road Glendale, California91207 Defendant: World Of Pentecost. Inc. aka World of Pentecost-Life Church cio Kurt Johnson and Linda Johnson . 13061 Rosedale Highway Bakersfield, California93314 Attornevs for Cross-Comnlainant: World of Pentecost. Inc. Thomas M. Alexander, Jr. Esq. Thomas M. Alexander, Jr. Esq. Alexander Law Offices Thomas Alexander Law Offices 468 N. Camden Drive, Suite 200 226 East Sixth Street Beverly Hills, California90210 Beaumont, California 92223 Page I of 2 XX (By Electronic Service) Complying with California Code of Civil Procedure t)10106, caused each such document(s) to be electronically served from amygcr,murraytragish.corn to each addressee below. The file transmission was reported as complete and a copy of the receipt will be maintained with the original document(s) in our office. Rond oggrrr!sol.corn I Ronald D. Dessy, Esq. K;&r&c&r»u&son70&crag»ua&hoon& Kurt Johnson (World of Pentecost, Inc.) aloes&uicrslsn ~ag&naihcom Thomas Alexanders, Jr., Esq. arui; u»;m t&g& an~rdyahoo.con& Tigran Arutyuuyun I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct, and that I am employed in the office of a member of the Bar of this Court at whose direction the service was made. Executed on Pebruary 22, 2022 Page 2 of 2