Preview
:* _© @
TTT
| ATTORNEYORPARTYWITHOUT ATTORNEYyee sates Bar number,
and address): FORCOURT voruf22
‘AndrewDaniel Weaver, Esq.(S.B. #318935)
ScottCole & Associates,APC FILED
§55 12th Street,Suite 1725
Oakland, California 94607 ALAMEDA COUNTY
TELEPHONENO.:G 10) 891-9800 " raxno: (510) 891-7030
ATTORNEYFOR (Name: Plaintiff
Mark Tirman MAY 2° 2019
SUPERIOR COURT OFCALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF Alameda .
streetavoress: 1225 Fallon Street ERK OR
FH! pA PRION COURT
MAILING
ADDRESS:
~
ciryanozipcove:Oakland, California 94612 \B Nwis A. .
BRANCH Name:Rene C. Davidson Courthouse
CASE NAME:
Tirman v. PPH Franchise Holdings, LLC
CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Compiex Case Designation CASENUMBER:
Unlimited [_} Limited L__] counter CJ Joinder Ra l4 bv BAYT
(Amount : (Amount JUDGE:
demanded demanded is: Filedwith first
appearance bydefendant
exceeds $25,000) $25,000 orless) (Cal,Rules ofCourt, rule3.402) DEPT:
items 1-6 below must be completed (See instructions
on page 2).
1. Check one box below forthe case type thatbest describesthiscase:
Auto Tort Contract ProvisionallyComplexCivilLitigation
“Auto(22) CL] Breachof contractwarranty
(06) (Cal.Rulesof Court,rules 3.400-3.403)
Uninsuredmotorist(46) L_] Rule 3.740collections
(09) (__] antitrustrTrade
regulation
(03)
Other PI/PD/WD (PersonalInjury/Property CL] Othercollections
(09) _ Construction
defect (10)
Damage/Wrongful Death).Tort L_] insurancecoverage(18) [__] Mass tort
(40)
Asbestos(04) (] othercontract(37) [_] securities
litigation
(2B)
Productliability
(24) Real Property [_] Environmentat/Toxic
fort
(30)
Medicalmalpractice
(45) [] Eminentdomain/Inverse L] insurancecoverage dlaims
arising
fromthe
[_] otherPyPDAWD (23) condemnation(14) above listed
provisionally
complexcase
Non-PU/PDIWD (Other)
Tort [J] wrongfuleviction
(33) types(41)
CL] Businesstort/unfair
businesspractice
(07) LC] Otherrealproperty(26). Enforcement ofJudgment!
C] Civil
rights
(08) Unlawful Detainer : [J Enforcementof judgment(20)
L_] Defamation(13) Commercial (31) MiscellaneousCivilComplaint
[_] Fraud(16) (_] Residential
(32) L_] rico 727)
[| Intellectual
property
(19) C4 Drugs (38) L_] other complaint(aot
Specified
above) (42)
[__] Professional
negligence(25) JudicialReview MiscellaneousGivilPetitian
L_] othernon-PyPDAND tort(35) CJ Assetforfeiture
(05) Partnership
and corpsrategovernance(21)
Employment CJ Petition
re:arbitration
award(11) [_] Otherpetition
(notspecified
above)(43)
Wrongful termination
(36) LC] Writofmandate (02) ,
Otheremployment (15) [J Otherjudicial
review(39)
2. This case LJ is LY | isnot .complex under rule3.400 ofthe California
Rules of Court.If the
case is complex,mark the
factorsrequiringexceptionaljudicialmanagement:
a.= Large number ofseparately represented parties d.[_] Large number ofwitnesses
b.[-_] Extensive motion practiceraisingdifficult
or novel —_e.
[__] Coordination withrelatedactions pendjng inone ormore courts
issues thatwill
be time-consuming to resolve. in othercounties,states,or countries, pr in
a federalcourt
c.L_] Substantialamountof documentary evidence- tL] Substantial postjudgment judicial
supelvision
3. Remedies sought (check allthatapply):a. v1 monetary b.Fal nonmonetary; declaratoryor injunctive
relief oc. EJ punitive
4. Number of causes ofaction (specify):Five (5)
5. This case Wi is Ci isnot aclass action suit.
6. If thereareany known relatedcases, file
and serve a noticeof relatedcase. (You may use form CM-015.)
Date: May 2, 2019
Andrew Daniel Weaver, Esq. » Li. CZ ee a ey sees
(TYPEORPRINTNAME) (SIGNATURE
OF PARTYORATTORNEYFOR PARTY)
NOTICE
« Piaintiff
must file
thiscover sheet withthe first
paperfiled intheaction orproceeding (except smallclaims odses or cases filed
under the Probate Code, Family Code, or Welfare and Institutions
Code). (Cal.Rules ofCourt, rule3.220.)F ailure
to file
may result
insanctions.
® Filethiscover sheet inadditiontoany cover sheet required bylocalcourt rule.
* If this
case iscomplex under rule3.400 etseq. ofthe California
Rules of Court,you must serve a copy of thi 5
coversheet on all
otherpartiesto theaction orproceeding.
* Unless thisiis
a collections
case under rule3.740 ora complex case,this coversheet willbe used forstatisti cal
purposes Only.erora
e 1 of 2
FormAdopted Use
for Mandatory CIVIL Cc ASE COVER SHEET Rules
Cal. rues
of Court, 3.220,
2.30, 3. 740;
3.400-3,403,
Judicial
Council
of Califomia Cal. of Judicial Administration,
Standards std, 3.10
CM-010
[Rev.
July1, 2007) www.courtinfo.ca.gov
CM-010
INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO COMPLETE THE COVER SHEET
To Plaintiffsand Others Filing First Papers. Ifyou are filing
a firstpaper (forexample, a complaint) ina civil
case, you must
complete and file,
along withyour first
paper,the CivilCase Cover Sheet contained on page 1. This informationwillbe used tocompile
statistics
about the types and numbers of cases filed.
You must complete items 1through 6 on the sheet. Initem 1,you must check
one box forthe case typethat bestdescribes the case. {f thecase fits
both a general and a more specifictype ofcase listedinitem 1,
check the more specificone. If
the case has multiplecauses of action,check the box thatbest indicatesthe primary cause ofaction.
To assistyou incompleting the sheet,examples ofthe cases that belong under each case type initem 1 arg provided below. A cover
sheet must be filedonly withyour initial
paper. Failuretofilea cover sheetwith the first
paper filed
in a civil
case may subjecta party,
itscounsel,or both tosanctions under rules2.30 and 3.220 ofthe Califomia Rules ofCourt.
To Parties inRule 3.740 Collections Cases. A “collectionscase" under rule 3.740 isdefined as an actionfor recovery ofmoney
owed ina sum statedto be certainthatisnot more than$25,000, exclusive ofinterestand attorney'sfees,arisingfrom a transactionin
which property, services,ormoney was acquired on credit.A collections
case does not includean actionseeking the following:(1)tort
damages, (2) punitivedamages, (3) recovery of real property, (4) recovery of personal property, or (5) a prejudgment writof
attachment. The identification
of a case as a rule 3.740 collectionscase on thisform means thatitwillbe exempt from the general
time-for-servicerequirements and case management rules,unless adefendant files
a responsive pleading! A rule 3.740 collections
case willbe subjectto therequirements forservice and obtaininga judgment inrule3.740.
To Parties InComplex Cases. In complex cases only,partiesmust alsouse the Civil
Case Cover Sheet to designate whether the
case is complex. ifa plaintiff
believes the case iscomplex under rule3.400 of the California
Rules ofCourt] thismust be indicated by
completing the appropriateboxes initems 1 and 2.If aplaintiff
designates a case as complex, the cover sheet must be served with the
complaint on al!partiestothe action. A defendant may fileand serve no laterthan thetime of itsfirst appearancea joinderin the
plaintiffs
designation,a counter-designationthat thecase isnotcomplex, or,if the
plaintiff
has made no designation,a designationthat
the case iscomplex.
CASE TYPES AND EXAMPLES
Auto Tort Contract Provisionally Cqmplex
CivilLitigation
(Cal.
Auto(22)-PersonalInjury/Property Breachof Contract/Warranty
(06) Rules ofCourt Rules
3.400-3.403)
Damage/Wrongful Death Breachof Rental/Lease Antitrust/Trade
Regulation(03)
UninsuredMotorist(46)
(/f the Contract
(notunlawfuldetainer ion Defect(10)
case involves
an uninsured orwrongfuleviction) ClaimstnvglvingMass Tort(40)
motorist
claimsubjectto Contract/Warranty
Breach-Seller SecuritiesLitigation
(28)
arbitration,
checkthisitem Plaintiff
(notfraudor negligence) Environmental/Toxic
Tort(30)
insteadof Auto) NegligentBreachofContract/ Insurance Coverage
Claims
Other PI/PD/WD (Persona!Injury/ Warranty (arising
fromprovisionally
complex
PropertyDamage/Wrongful Death) OtherBreach of Contract/Warranty case listed
above)(41)
Tort Collections
(e.g.,
money owed, open Enforcement af Judgment
Asbestos (04) bookaccounts)(09) Enforcement ofJudgment (20)
Asbestos Property
Damage Collection
Case—SellerPlaintiff Abstractof Judgment(Outof
AsbestosPersonalInjury/ OtherPromissoryNote/Colfections County)
WrongfulDeath Case Confessionof Judgment(non-
InsuranceCoverage (notprovisionally domesticrelations)
ProductLiability
(notasbestosor
toxic/environmental)
(24) complex) (18) Sister State
Judgment
MedicalMalpractice(45) Auto Subrogation Administrative
Agency Award
MedicalMalpractice— Other Coverage (notjunpaid
taxes)
Physicians& Surgeons OtherContract(37) Petition/Certification
ofEntryof
OtherProfessional
HealthCare Contractual
Fraud Judgment onUnpald Taxes
Malpractice OtherContractDispute Other Enforcement
ofJudgment
Real Property Cape
OtherPI/PD/WD (23)
Eminent Domain/Inverse Miscelfaneous|Civil
Complaint
PremisesLiability
(e.g.,
slip
andfall) Condemnation (14) RICO (27)
Intentional
BodilyInjury/PDAVD WrongfulEviction(33) _ Other. Complaint
(notspecified
above)|(42)
(e.g.,
assault,
vandalism) OtherReal Property(e.g.,
quiettitle)
(26)
Intentional
Inflictlon
of Declardtory
ReliefOnly
Writ ofPossessionofReal Property Injunctive
Relief
Only (non-
EmotionalDistress Mortgage Foreclosure
hatassment)
NegligentInfliction
of QuietTitle
EmotionalDistress Mechanics Lien
OtherReal Property(not
eminent
OtherPI/PDAWD Other Gommercial
Complaint
domain,landiord/tenant,
or
Case (non-tort/non-complex)
Non-PI/PD/WD (Other)Tort foreclosure)
OtherGivilComplaint
BusinessTort/Unfair
Business Unlawful Detainer (non-torl/non-complex)
Practice
(07) Commercial(31)
Miscellaneous|Civil
Petition
Civil
Rights(e.g.,
discrimination, Residential
(32) Partnership)
and Corporate
falsearrest)
(notcivil Drugs(38)(if the
caseinvolvesillegal Governance (21)
harassment)(08) drugs,check this
item;otherwise, OtherPetition
(notspecified
Defamation(e.g.,
slander,libel) reportasCommercial or Residential) above) (43)
(13) JudicialReview Civil
Hdrassment
Fraud (16) AssetForfeiture
(05) Workplace Violence
Intellectual
Property
(19) Petition
Re:Arbitration
Award (11) Elder/DependentAdult
Professional
Negligence(25) WritofMandate (02) Abuse
LegalMalpractice Writ-Administrative
Mandamus Election
Contest
OtherProfessional
Malpractice Writ-Mandamus onLimitedCourt
Petition
forName Change
(notmedicalor legal) Case Matter Petition
forRellef
From Late
OtherNon-PI/PD/WD Tort(35) Writ-OtherLimitedCourtCase Claim
Employment Review - OtherGivilPetition
WrongfulTermination(36) OtherJudicial
Review (39)
OtherEmployment (15) Review ofHealthOfficer
Order
Noticeof Appeal-Labor
CommissionerAppeals
CM-010{Rav.
July 1, 2007} Page2 of 2
CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET
Preview
:* _© @ TTT | ATTORNEYORPARTYWITHOUT ATTORNEYyee sates Bar number, and address): FORCOURT voruf22 ‘AndrewDaniel Weaver, Esq.(S.B. #318935) ScottCole & Associates,APC FILED §55 12th Street,Suite 1725 Oakland, California 94607 ALAMEDA COUNTY TELEPHONENO.:G 10) 891-9800 " raxno: (510) 891-7030 ATTORNEYFOR (Name: Plaintiff Mark Tirman MAY 2° 2019 SUPERIOR COURT OFCALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF Alameda . streetavoress: 1225 Fallon Street ERK OR FH! pA PRION COURT MAILING ADDRESS: ~ ciryanozipcove:Oakland, California 94612 \B Nwis A. . BRANCH Name:Rene C. Davidson Courthouse CASE NAME: Tirman v. PPH Franchise Holdings, LLC CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET Compiex Case Designation CASENUMBER: Unlimited [_} Limited L__] counter CJ Joinder Ra l4 bv BAYT (Amount : (Amount JUDGE: demanded demanded is: Filedwith first appearance bydefendant exceeds $25,000) $25,000 orless) (Cal,Rules ofCourt, rule3.402) DEPT: items 1-6 below must be completed (See instructions on page 2). 1. Check one box below forthe case type thatbest describesthiscase: Auto Tort Contract ProvisionallyComplexCivilLitigation “Auto(22) CL] Breachof contractwarranty (06) (Cal.Rulesof Court,rules 3.400-3.403) Uninsuredmotorist(46) L_] Rule 3.740collections (09) (__] antitrustrTrade regulation (03) Other PI/PD/WD (PersonalInjury/Property CL] Othercollections (09) _ Construction defect (10) Damage/Wrongful Death).Tort L_] insurancecoverage(18) [__] Mass tort (40) Asbestos(04) (] othercontract(37) [_] securities litigation (2B) Productliability (24) Real Property [_] Environmentat/Toxic fort (30) Medicalmalpractice (45) [] Eminentdomain/Inverse L] insurancecoverage dlaims arising fromthe [_] otherPyPDAWD (23) condemnation(14) above listed provisionally complexcase Non-PU/PDIWD (Other) Tort [J] wrongfuleviction (33) types(41) CL] Businesstort/unfair businesspractice (07) LC] Otherrealproperty(26). Enforcement ofJudgment! C] Civil rights (08) Unlawful Detainer : [J Enforcementof judgment(20) L_] Defamation(13) Commercial (31) MiscellaneousCivilComplaint [_] Fraud(16) (_] Residential (32) L_] rico 727) [| Intellectual property (19) C4 Drugs (38) L_] other complaint(aot Specified above) (42) [__] Professional negligence(25) JudicialReview MiscellaneousGivilPetitian L_] othernon-PyPDAND tort(35) CJ Assetforfeiture (05) Partnership and corpsrategovernance(21) Employment CJ Petition re:arbitration award(11) [_] Otherpetition (notspecified above)(43) Wrongful termination (36) LC] Writofmandate (02) , Otheremployment (15) [J Otherjudicial review(39) 2. This case LJ is LY | isnot .complex under rule3.400 ofthe California Rules of Court.If the case is complex,mark the factorsrequiringexceptionaljudicialmanagement: a.= Large number ofseparately represented parties d.[_] Large number ofwitnesses b.[-_] Extensive motion practiceraisingdifficult or novel —_e. [__] Coordination withrelatedactions pendjng inone ormore courts issues thatwill be time-consuming to resolve. in othercounties,states,or countries, pr in a federalcourt c.L_] Substantialamountof documentary evidence- tL] Substantial postjudgment judicial supelvision 3. Remedies sought (check allthatapply):a. v1 monetary b.Fal nonmonetary; declaratoryor injunctive relief oc. EJ punitive 4. Number of causes ofaction (specify):Five (5) 5. This case Wi is Ci isnot aclass action suit. 6. If thereareany known relatedcases, file and serve a noticeof relatedcase. (You may use form CM-015.) Date: May 2, 2019 Andrew Daniel Weaver, Esq. » Li. CZ ee a ey sees (TYPEORPRINTNAME) (SIGNATURE OF PARTYORATTORNEYFOR PARTY) NOTICE « Piaintiff must file thiscover sheet withthe first paperfiled intheaction orproceeding (except smallclaims odses or cases filed under the Probate Code, Family Code, or Welfare and Institutions Code). (Cal.Rules ofCourt, rule3.220.)F ailure to file may result insanctions. ® Filethiscover sheet inadditiontoany cover sheet required bylocalcourt rule. * If this case iscomplex under rule3.400 etseq. ofthe California Rules of Court,you must serve a copy of thi 5 coversheet on all otherpartiesto theaction orproceeding. * Unless thisiis a collections case under rule3.740 ora complex case,this coversheet willbe used forstatisti cal purposes Only.erora e 1 of 2 FormAdopted Use for Mandatory CIVIL Cc ASE COVER SHEET Rules Cal. rues of Court, 3.220, 2.30, 3. 740; 3.400-3,403, Judicial Council of Califomia Cal. of Judicial Administration, Standards std, 3.10 CM-010 [Rev. July1, 2007) www.courtinfo.ca.gov CM-010 INSTRUCTIONS ON HOW TO COMPLETE THE COVER SHEET To Plaintiffsand Others Filing First Papers. Ifyou are filing a firstpaper (forexample, a complaint) ina civil case, you must complete and file, along withyour first paper,the CivilCase Cover Sheet contained on page 1. This informationwillbe used tocompile statistics about the types and numbers of cases filed. You must complete items 1through 6 on the sheet. Initem 1,you must check one box forthe case typethat bestdescribes the case. {f thecase fits both a general and a more specifictype ofcase listedinitem 1, check the more specificone. If the case has multiplecauses of action,check the box thatbest indicatesthe primary cause ofaction. To assistyou incompleting the sheet,examples ofthe cases that belong under each case type initem 1 arg provided below. A cover sheet must be filedonly withyour initial paper. Failuretofilea cover sheetwith the first paper filed in a civil case may subjecta party, itscounsel,or both tosanctions under rules2.30 and 3.220 ofthe Califomia Rules ofCourt. To Parties inRule 3.740 Collections Cases. A “collectionscase" under rule 3.740 isdefined as an actionfor recovery ofmoney owed ina sum statedto be certainthatisnot more than$25,000, exclusive ofinterestand attorney'sfees,arisingfrom a transactionin which property, services,ormoney was acquired on credit.A collections case does not includean actionseeking the following:(1)tort damages, (2) punitivedamages, (3) recovery of real property, (4) recovery of personal property, or (5) a prejudgment writof attachment. The identification of a case as a rule 3.740 collectionscase on thisform means thatitwillbe exempt from the general time-for-servicerequirements and case management rules,unless adefendant files a responsive pleading! A rule 3.740 collections case willbe subjectto therequirements forservice and obtaininga judgment inrule3.740. To Parties InComplex Cases. In complex cases only,partiesmust alsouse the Civil Case Cover Sheet to designate whether the case is complex. ifa plaintiff believes the case iscomplex under rule3.400 of the California Rules ofCourt] thismust be indicated by completing the appropriateboxes initems 1 and 2.If aplaintiff designates a case as complex, the cover sheet must be served with the complaint on al!partiestothe action. A defendant may fileand serve no laterthan thetime of itsfirst appearancea joinderin the plaintiffs designation,a counter-designationthat thecase isnotcomplex, or,if the plaintiff has made no designation,a designationthat the case iscomplex. CASE TYPES AND EXAMPLES Auto Tort Contract Provisionally Cqmplex CivilLitigation (Cal. Auto(22)-PersonalInjury/Property Breachof Contract/Warranty (06) Rules ofCourt Rules 3.400-3.403) Damage/Wrongful Death Breachof Rental/Lease Antitrust/Trade Regulation(03) UninsuredMotorist(46) (/f the Contract (notunlawfuldetainer ion Defect(10) case involves an uninsured orwrongfuleviction) ClaimstnvglvingMass Tort(40) motorist claimsubjectto Contract/Warranty Breach-Seller SecuritiesLitigation (28) arbitration, checkthisitem Plaintiff (notfraudor negligence) Environmental/Toxic Tort(30) insteadof Auto) NegligentBreachofContract/ Insurance Coverage Claims Other PI/PD/WD (Persona!Injury/ Warranty (arising fromprovisionally complex PropertyDamage/Wrongful Death) OtherBreach of Contract/Warranty case listed above)(41) Tort Collections (e.g., money owed, open Enforcement af Judgment Asbestos (04) bookaccounts)(09) Enforcement ofJudgment (20) Asbestos Property Damage Collection Case—SellerPlaintiff Abstractof Judgment(Outof AsbestosPersonalInjury/ OtherPromissoryNote/Colfections County) WrongfulDeath Case Confessionof Judgment(non- InsuranceCoverage (notprovisionally domesticrelations) ProductLiability (notasbestosor toxic/environmental) (24) complex) (18) Sister State Judgment MedicalMalpractice(45) Auto Subrogation Administrative Agency Award MedicalMalpractice— Other Coverage (notjunpaid taxes) Physicians& Surgeons OtherContract(37) Petition/Certification ofEntryof OtherProfessional HealthCare Contractual Fraud Judgment onUnpald Taxes Malpractice OtherContractDispute Other Enforcement ofJudgment Real Property Cape OtherPI/PD/WD (23) Eminent Domain/Inverse Miscelfaneous|Civil Complaint PremisesLiability (e.g., slip andfall) Condemnation (14) RICO (27) Intentional BodilyInjury/PDAVD WrongfulEviction(33) _ Other. Complaint (notspecified above)|(42) (e.g., assault, vandalism) OtherReal Property(e.g., quiettitle) (26) Intentional Inflictlon of Declardtory ReliefOnly Writ ofPossessionofReal Property Injunctive Relief Only (non- EmotionalDistress Mortgage Foreclosure hatassment) NegligentInfliction of QuietTitle EmotionalDistress Mechanics Lien OtherReal Property(not eminent OtherPI/PDAWD Other Gommercial Complaint domain,landiord/tenant, or Case (non-tort/non-complex) Non-PI/PD/WD (Other)Tort foreclosure) OtherGivilComplaint BusinessTort/Unfair Business Unlawful Detainer (non-torl/non-complex) Practice (07) Commercial(31) Miscellaneous|Civil Petition Civil Rights(e.g., discrimination, Residential (32) Partnership) and Corporate falsearrest) (notcivil Drugs(38)(if the caseinvolvesillegal Governance (21) harassment)(08) drugs,check this item;otherwise, OtherPetition (notspecified Defamation(e.g., slander,libel) reportasCommercial or Residential) above) (43) (13) JudicialReview Civil Hdrassment Fraud (16) AssetForfeiture (05) Workplace Violence Intellectual Property (19) Petition Re:Arbitration Award (11) Elder/DependentAdult Professional Negligence(25) WritofMandate (02) Abuse LegalMalpractice Writ-Administrative Mandamus Election Contest OtherProfessional Malpractice Writ-Mandamus onLimitedCourt Petition forName Change (notmedicalor legal) Case Matter Petition forRellef From Late OtherNon-PI/PD/WD Tort(35) Writ-OtherLimitedCourtCase Claim Employment Review - OtherGivilPetition WrongfulTermination(36) OtherJudicial Review (39) OtherEmployment (15) Review ofHealthOfficer Order Noticeof Appeal-Labor CommissionerAppeals CM-010{Rav. July 1, 2007} Page2 of 2 CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET