On October 23, 2020 a
Motion-Secondary
was filed
involving a dispute between
Kharbawy, A. Sameh El,
and
Board Of Trustees Of California State Of University,
Castro, Joseph I.,
Fu, Xuanning,
Hamm, Daryl L.,
Jimenez-Sandoval, Saul,
Zelenzy, Lynnette,
for 15 Unlimited - Other Employment
in the District Court of Fresno County.
Preview
-___l.............._____ fi W.
0W1
x. .‘_ _ y. A
'
Ell—eé 's-‘FILED
by Superior Court of California. County of Los Angeles
09:17AM Sherri by P. Mclntyrepeputy‘Clerk
R. Carter. Executive Oficer/Clerk o! Court,
~
:.//'—' -
f-
,
,"i
“*1
1 Jesse J. Maddox, Bar No. 219091
FILED
Jmadd°x@l°W1egal-°°m Swarm: Emmi nr Camramia
2 Nathan T. Jackson, Bar No. 285620 cgumyur Lag Amazes
'~
njackson@lcwlegal.com
'
3 LIEBERT CASSIDY WHITMORE O_BHBE‘Q O_Z1
T? A Professional Law Corporation Emu“ mW-Em‘m ?hm” am "“3“”
_ _
V
1
‘
"
‘
4 5250‘Norlh Palm Ave,
Fresno, California 93704
Suite 310
'
fly:
E. 851cm Wm
5 Telephone: 559.256.7800
Facsimile: 559. 449 .4535
6
Attorneys for Defendant BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF
7 CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY
8
>
9 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
10 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES .
21 CE‘CG 02214
11 A. SAME_H EL KHARBAWY, Case No.: 20LBCV00465
g2 12 , Plaintiff,
'
[ASSIGNED FOR ALL PURPOSES To
"E '3
g MICHAEL VICENCIA, DEPT. 826]
e g h
E' u: l3 V
g I
. I
L: e;.r_=
Complaint Filed: October 23. 2020
5 3'5 14 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF
Ega CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY; DECLARATION OF SARAH OSBORNE IN
g
a g 15 DARRYL L. HAMM, an individual; SUPPORT 0F DEFENDANT BOARD OF
ha 2
g LYNNETTE ZELEZNY, an individual; TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE
i3
n
IE3 16 JOSEPH I.CASTRO, an individual; UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO TRANSFER
SAUL IIMENEZ-SANDOVAL, an CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
17 individual; XUANNING FU; an
individual; AND DOES 1 through 50,
18 . Date: March 25, 2021
Petitioner. Time: 8:30 am
19 ‘
Dept.: $26
'
20
21
>
22 .
.1,SARAH OSBORNE, declare as rou'ows:
‘
23‘ have personal knowledge of each matter stated herein, and
l. I if called upon to do so
24 Icould and would competently testify to each matter sci forth here'in.
I
25 ,
2 -
I am former student at California State University, Fresno (“Fresno State").
26 Plaintiff was one of my professors, and Ican speak to the negative experiences Ihad with him as
27 a professor. I was also interviewed _aspart of whal Iunderstand was an investigation into
i
28 Plaintiff's conduct a_s a professor, and Ican speak lo the statements Imade during that interview.
:
' '
"
1
g
fl Inl
,
<
.,-,
'
II
1 3. Ireside in Fresno Comlty, Califomia. do not have a residence in Los Angeles
N County, and it would b6,disruptive to my personal and professional life if Ihad loappear in Los
w Allgeles County for proceedings relating to Plaintist lawsuit. Ihave full-lime job and rwo
# youngchildren (both under five) whom I provide primary care for.
M 4. . I have never interacted with Plaintiff in Los Angclcs County.
G I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of‘lhc state of California that the
foregoing is tr'ueand correct.
OG-fl
Executed on March ___, 2021,. in Fresno Couhty, California.
E“
\O
10
11.
12v
I
j
'
'
_
W?
V Sarah O&ome
6g I
y
Suilc4310
Corpomlion
93704
l3
Ave,
Law l4
California
Palm
’15
Professional
Noah
Frcsno.
5250 l6
A
l7
18
-
19
_
xi;
.
-
20
21v
22
23'
24
2.5'
_
'
27
2‘8 .'
W
THE DOCUMENT TO WHICH THIS CERTIFICATE IS
ATTACHED IS A FULL. TRUE, AND CORRECT COPY
OF THE ORIGINAL ON FILE AND OF RECORD IN
MY OFFICE.
4 .202]
ATTEST: JUN 1
SHERRI B. CARTER
Executive Oflicer/Clerk of the Superior
Co Iomna. County oi Los les.
B / DEPUTY
"|\ \~
“‘uuu-ufl‘“
Document Filed Date
March 18, 2021
Case Filing Date
October 23, 2020
Category
15 Unlimited - Other Employment
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
-___l.............._____ fi W. 0W1 x. .‘_ _ y. A ' Ell—eé 's-‘FILED by Superior Court of California. County of Los Angeles 09:17AM Sherri by P. Mclntyrepeputy‘Clerk R. Carter. Executive Oficer/Clerk o! Court, ~ :.//'—' - f- , ,"i “*1 1 Jesse J. Maddox, Bar No. 219091 FILED Jmadd°x@l°W1egal-°°m Swarm: Emmi nr Camramia 2 Nathan T. Jackson, Bar No. 285620 cgumyur Lag Amazes '~ njackson@lcwlegal.com ' 3 LIEBERT CASSIDY WHITMORE O_BHBE‘Q O_Z1 T? A Professional Law Corporation Emu“ mW-Em‘m ?hm” am "“3“” _ _ V 1 ‘ " ‘ 4 5250‘Norlh Palm Ave, Fresno, California 93704 Suite 310 ' fly: E. 851cm Wm 5 Telephone: 559.256.7800 Facsimile: 559. 449 .4535 6 Attorneys for Defendant BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF 7 CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY 8 > 9 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 10 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES . 21 CE‘CG 02214 11 A. SAME_H EL KHARBAWY, Case No.: 20LBCV00465 g2 12 , Plaintiff, ' [ASSIGNED FOR ALL PURPOSES To "E '3 g MICHAEL VICENCIA, DEPT. 826] e g h E' u: l3 V g I . I L: e;.r_= Complaint Filed: October 23. 2020 5 3'5 14 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF Ega CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY; DECLARATION OF SARAH OSBORNE IN g a g 15 DARRYL L. HAMM, an individual; SUPPORT 0F DEFENDANT BOARD OF ha 2 g LYNNETTE ZELEZNY, an individual; TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE i3 n IE3 16 JOSEPH I.CASTRO, an individual; UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO TRANSFER SAUL IIMENEZ-SANDOVAL, an CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 17 individual; XUANNING FU; an individual; AND DOES 1 through 50, 18 . Date: March 25, 2021 Petitioner. Time: 8:30 am 19 ‘ Dept.: $26 ' 20 21 > 22 . .1,SARAH OSBORNE, declare as rou'ows: ‘ 23‘ have personal knowledge of each matter stated herein, and l. I if called upon to do so 24 Icould and would competently testify to each matter sci forth here'in. I 25 , 2 - I am former student at California State University, Fresno (“Fresno State"). 26 Plaintiff was one of my professors, and Ican speak to the negative experiences Ihad with him as 27 a professor. I was also interviewed _aspart of whal Iunderstand was an investigation into i 28 Plaintiff's conduct a_s a professor, and Ican speak lo the statements Imade during that interview. : ' ' " 1 g fl Inl , < .,-, ' II 1 3. Ireside in Fresno Comlty, Califomia. do not have a residence in Los Angeles N County, and it would b6,disruptive to my personal and professional life if Ihad loappear in Los w Allgeles County for proceedings relating to Plaintist lawsuit. Ihave full-lime job and rwo # youngchildren (both under five) whom I provide primary care for. M 4. . I have never interacted with Plaintiff in Los Angclcs County. G I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of‘lhc state of California that the foregoing is tr'ueand correct. OG-fl Executed on March ___, 2021,. in Fresno Couhty, California. E“ \O 10 11. 12v I j ' ' _ W? V Sarah O&ome 6g I y Suilc4310 Corpomlion 93704 l3 Ave, Law l4 California Palm ’15 Professional Noah Frcsno. 5250 l6 A l7 18 - 19 _ xi; . - 20 21v 22 23' 24 2.5' _ ' 27 2‘8 .' W THE DOCUMENT TO WHICH THIS CERTIFICATE IS ATTACHED IS A FULL. TRUE, AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL ON FILE AND OF RECORD IN MY OFFICE. 4 .202] ATTEST: JUN 1 SHERRI B. CARTER Executive Oflicer/Clerk of the Superior Co Iomna. County oi Los les. B / DEPUTY "|\ \~ “‘uuu-ufl‘“