On October 23, 2020 a
Proof of Service
was filed
involving a dispute between
Kharbawy, A. Sameh El,
and
Board Of Trustees Of California State Of University,
Castro, Joseph I.,
Fu, Xuanning,
Hamm, Daryl L.,
Jimenez-Sandoval, Saul,
Zelenzy, Lynnette,
for 15 Unlimited - Other Employment
in the District Court of Fresno County.
Preview
‘
.
FILED by Supu:
Eiigctronic'ally PM
Court of California. County of Los Angeles on 03/01/2021 03:59 byE.SalcidoDeputy Clerk
Sherri R. Carter. Executive OfficerlClerk of Court.
1 Jesse J. Maddox, Bar No. 219091
jmaddox@1cwlegal.com
2 Nathan T. Jackson, Bar No. 285620
nj ackson@lcwlegal.com
3 LIEBERT CASSIDY WHITMORE
A Professional Law Corporation
4 400 Capitol Mall, Suite 1260
Sacramento, CA 95 8 14
5 Telephone: 916-584-7000
Facsimile: 916-584-7083
6
Attorneys for Defendant BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF
7 CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY
8
9 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
10 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES .
-21CE 6602214
11 A. SAMEH EL KHARBAWY, Case No.2 20LBCV00465
a
12 Plaintiff, [ASSIGNED FOR ALL PURPOSES TO HON.
g
“g
§ ¢ MICHAEL P. VICENCIA, DEPT. 826]
g; 13 v.
g g
g 8 E 2 Complaint Filed: October 23, 2020
.3)?! a?
L3, 14 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF
g g E
i5”, CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY; PROOF 0F SERVICE
E g g E
15 DARRYL L. HAMM, an individual;
g <33
g g LYNNETTE ZELEZNY, an individual;
"‘
i
8 16 JOSEPH I. CASTRO, an individual;
SAUL JIMENEZ-SANDOVAL, an (*Exempt from filing fees pursuant to Gov.
17 individual; XUANNING FU, an Code, § 6103.)
individual; AND DOES 1 through 50,
18
Defendants.
19
20 ///
21 ///
22 ///
23 ///
24 ///
-’-
i"
452.5% J
~--
(M;
;;:-.;2,7,l., _,
'
2.8;. ///
.1
r
Proof of Sérvi'ce
9555703.1 FRoo7-oos
PROOF OF SERVICE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SACRAMENTO
Iam employed in the County of Sacramento, State of California. Iam over the age of 18
and not a barty to the within action; my business address is: 400 Capitol Mall, Suite 1260,
Sacramento,
\OOOQONM-tht—I
CA 95814.
On March 1, 2021, I served the foregoing document(s) described as
1. DEFENDANT BOARD 0F TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE
UNIVERSITY’S NOTICE 0F MOTION AND MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE T0
FRESNO COUNTY; MEMORANDUM 0F POINTS AND AUTHORITIES
2. DECLARATION OF JESSE J. MADDOX IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, FRESNO’S MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE T0
I
FRESNO COUNTY
p—tptr-Ar—lr—Ay—A
MADONr—Io
1260
Cotporation
95814
Whitmore
3. DECLARATION 0F NATHAN T. JACKSON IN SUPPORT OF
Suite
Law
CA
Mall,
DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S
Cassidy
Sacramento.
Capitol
Professional
MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE T0 FRESNO COUNTY
Liebert
400 4. DECLARATION 0F MARYLOU MENDOZA— MILLER IN SUPPORT OF
A
DEFENDANT CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION T0 TRANSFER CASE
TO FRESNO COUNTY
NNNNr—dr—np—np—n
5. DECLARATION 0F DARRYL HAMM IN SUPPORT 0F DEFENDANT
WNHODOOQQ
BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
TRANSFER CASE T0 FRESNO COUNTY
6. DECLARATION 0F DR. JOSEPH CASTRO IN SUPPORT OF
DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S
m \i'iMOTION T0 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
mica-
t~3 7 1'
DECLARATION 0F DR. LYNNETTE ZELEZNY IN SUPPORT 0F
no .
'sim
“DEFENDANT BOARD O_F. TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S
.1:" "
MoTION To TRANSFER CASE To FRESNO COUNTY
2
Proof of Service
9555703.1 FR007-003
1 8. IDECLARATION OF DR. SAUL JIMENEZ—SANDOVAL IN SUPPORT OF
DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S
AWN MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
9. DECLARATION OF DR. XUANNING FU IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
\OOOQO\&JI
10. DECLARATION 0F DR. HONORA CHAPMAN IN SUPPORT OF
DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S
MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
10 11. DECLARATION OF HOLLY SOWLES IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
11 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
12 TRANSFER CASE T0 FRESNO COUNTY
1260
DECLARATION OF SILVANA POLGAR IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
Corporation
95814
Whitmore 13 12.
Suite
Law
CA
Mall, HA BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
Cassidy
15
Sacramento,
Capitol
Professional
TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
Liebert
A
400
16 13. DECLARATION OF ELIZABETH KAO IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
17 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
18 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
19 14. DECLARATION OF DR. DENNIS NEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
20 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
21 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
22 15. DECLARATION OF STEPHANIE RYAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
23 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
H ~
24 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
m V, I
16 DECLARATION 0F ANDREA HARVEY 1N SUPPORT 0F DEFENDANT
'
26 BOARD 0F TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION T0
‘-
zmANSFER CASE T0 FRESNO COUNTY
;';-~‘";‘;2.7,;
:; :
"
...-':
.v'.
13;, I II ~ __ ~
.3
Proof of Service"
95557011 FR007-003
1 17. DECLARATION OF DR. JEAN MILLAR IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
2 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
3 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
4 18. DECLARATION 0F DR. RUDOLPH SANCHEZ IN SUPPORT OF
5 DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S
6 MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
7 19. DECLARATION OF MARTIN VALENCIA IN SUPPORT OF
8 DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S
9 MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
I
10 20. DECLARATION OF KIRSTEN K. COREY IN SUPPORT OF
11 DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S
12 MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY
1260
REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT
Comoration
95814
Whitmorc 13 21.
Suite
Law
CA
Mall, 14 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO
Cassidy
15
Sacramento.
Capitol
Professional
TRANSFER CASE T0 FRESNO COUNTY.
Liebert
400
16 in the manner checked below on all interested parties in this action addressed as follows:
A
17 Andrew Hillier
Paul Garcia
18 Hillier Law
600 W. Broadway, Suite 700
19 San Diego, CA 92101
telephone: 619.500.7906
20 facsimile: 619.839.3895
email: andrew@ahillierlaw.com;
21 paul@ahillierlaw.com
22 E (BY OVERNIGHT MAIL) By overnight courier, I arranged for the above-referenced
document(s) to be delivered to an authorized overnight courier service, FedEx, for
'
23 delivery to the addressee(s) above, in an envelope or package designated by the
overnight courier service with delivery fees paid or provided for.
‘_(BY ELECTRONIC SERVICE) By electronically mailing a true and correct copy
through ‘Lie‘bert Cassidy Whitmore’ s electromc mail system fiom
mw1bbenhorst@1cwlegal com to the email address(es) set forth above.
'
I did not
receive, within a reasonable time afier the transmission, any electronic message or
other indication that the transmission was unsuccessful
7_
'4
Proof of Service
95557011 FR007-003
Executed on March 1, 2021, at Sacramento, California.
Ideclare under penalty of perjury under the laws 0f the State of California that the
foregoing is true and correct.
vb (Out. 01km U égeuu-ivfijk
Mariana Wibbenhorst
1260'
l4
Corporation
Whilmore
958
Suilc
CA
Mall.
Law
Cassidy
Sacramento.
Capitol
Professional
NMNNHp—tp—dr—Ar—Ap—tp—ny—ty—tp‘
Liebelt
400
A
mNt-‘OKOOOQOxUI-PMNP‘O
‘I
N “:9
.5
['0 gn
5
Proof of Service
95557011 FR007—003
ICAT E IS
TO WHICH THIS CERTIF
THE DOCUMENT D CORRECT COPY
A LL, TRUE. AN
OF RECORD lN
CHED IS FU
ATTA
L ON FILE AND
OF THE ORIGNA
mu
I
MYOFFICE. JUN 1 4
ATTEST: SHERRI R. CARTER
the Supe rior
/Clerk of
Executive foicey os Angeles.
Co of a
Preview
‘ . FILED by Supu: Eiigctronic'ally PM Court of California. County of Los Angeles on 03/01/2021 03:59 byE.SalcidoDeputy Clerk Sherri R. Carter. Executive OfficerlClerk of Court. 1 Jesse J. Maddox, Bar No. 219091 jmaddox@1cwlegal.com 2 Nathan T. Jackson, Bar No. 285620 nj ackson@lcwlegal.com 3 LIEBERT CASSIDY WHITMORE A Professional Law Corporation 4 400 Capitol Mall, Suite 1260 Sacramento, CA 95 8 14 5 Telephone: 916-584-7000 Facsimile: 916-584-7083 6 Attorneys for Defendant BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF 7 CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY 8 9 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA 10 COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES . -21CE 6602214 11 A. SAMEH EL KHARBAWY, Case No.2 20LBCV00465 a 12 Plaintiff, [ASSIGNED FOR ALL PURPOSES TO HON. g “g § ¢ MICHAEL P. VICENCIA, DEPT. 826] g; 13 v. g g g 8 E 2 Complaint Filed: October 23, 2020 .3)?! a? L3, 14 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF g g E i5”, CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY; PROOF 0F SERVICE E g g E 15 DARRYL L. HAMM, an individual; g <33 g g LYNNETTE ZELEZNY, an individual; "‘ i 8 16 JOSEPH I. CASTRO, an individual; SAUL JIMENEZ-SANDOVAL, an (*Exempt from filing fees pursuant to Gov. 17 individual; XUANNING FU, an Code, § 6103.) individual; AND DOES 1 through 50, 18 Defendants. 19 20 /// 21 /// 22 /// 23 /// 24 /// -’- i" 452.5% J ~-- (M; ;;:-.;2,7,l., _, ' 2.8;. /// .1 r Proof of Sérvi'ce 9555703.1 FRoo7-oos PROOF OF SERVICE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SACRAMENTO Iam employed in the County of Sacramento, State of California. Iam over the age of 18 and not a barty to the within action; my business address is: 400 Capitol Mall, Suite 1260, Sacramento, \OOOQONM-tht—I CA 95814. On March 1, 2021, I served the foregoing document(s) described as 1. DEFENDANT BOARD 0F TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S NOTICE 0F MOTION AND MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE T0 FRESNO COUNTY; MEMORANDUM 0F POINTS AND AUTHORITIES 2. DECLARATION OF JESSE J. MADDOX IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY, FRESNO’S MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE T0 I FRESNO COUNTY p—tptr-Ar—lr—Ay—A MADONr—Io 1260 Cotporation 95814 Whitmore 3. DECLARATION 0F NATHAN T. JACKSON IN SUPPORT OF Suite Law CA Mall, DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S Cassidy Sacramento. Capitol Professional MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE T0 FRESNO COUNTY Liebert 400 4. DECLARATION 0F MARYLOU MENDOZA— MILLER IN SUPPORT OF A DEFENDANT CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION T0 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY NNNNr—dr—np—np—n 5. DECLARATION 0F DARRYL HAMM IN SUPPORT 0F DEFENDANT WNHODOOQQ BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE T0 FRESNO COUNTY 6. DECLARATION 0F DR. JOSEPH CASTRO IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S m \i'iMOTION T0 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY mica- t~3 7 1' DECLARATION 0F DR. LYNNETTE ZELEZNY IN SUPPORT 0F no . 'sim “DEFENDANT BOARD O_F. TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S .1:" " MoTION To TRANSFER CASE To FRESNO COUNTY 2 Proof of Service 9555703.1 FR007-003 1 8. IDECLARATION OF DR. SAUL JIMENEZ—SANDOVAL IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S AWN MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 9. DECLARATION OF DR. XUANNING FU IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY \OOOQO\&JI 10. DECLARATION 0F DR. HONORA CHAPMAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 10 11. DECLARATION OF HOLLY SOWLES IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT 11 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO 12 TRANSFER CASE T0 FRESNO COUNTY 1260 DECLARATION OF SILVANA POLGAR IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT Corporation 95814 Whitmore 13 12. Suite Law CA Mall, HA BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO Cassidy 15 Sacramento, Capitol Professional TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY Liebert A 400 16 13. DECLARATION OF ELIZABETH KAO IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT 17 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO 18 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 19 14. DECLARATION OF DR. DENNIS NEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT 20 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO 21 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 22 15. DECLARATION OF STEPHANIE RYAN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT 23 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO H ~ 24 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY m V, I 16 DECLARATION 0F ANDREA HARVEY 1N SUPPORT 0F DEFENDANT ' 26 BOARD 0F TRUSTEES 0F CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION T0 ‘- zmANSFER CASE T0 FRESNO COUNTY ;';-~‘";‘;2.7,; :; : " ...-': .v'. 13;, I II ~ __ ~ .3 Proof of Service" 95557011 FR007-003 1 17. DECLARATION OF DR. JEAN MILLAR IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT 2 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO 3 TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 4 18. DECLARATION 0F DR. RUDOLPH SANCHEZ IN SUPPORT OF 5 DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S 6 MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 7 19. DECLARATION OF MARTIN VALENCIA IN SUPPORT OF 8 DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S 9 MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY I 10 20. DECLARATION OF KIRSTEN K. COREY IN SUPPORT OF 11 DEFENDANT BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S 12 MOTION TO TRANSFER CASE TO FRESNO COUNTY 1260 REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT Comoration 95814 Whitmorc 13 21. Suite Law CA Mall, 14 BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY’S MOTION TO Cassidy 15 Sacramento. Capitol Professional TRANSFER CASE T0 FRESNO COUNTY. Liebert 400 16 in the manner checked below on all interested parties in this action addressed as follows: A 17 Andrew Hillier Paul Garcia 18 Hillier Law 600 W. Broadway, Suite 700 19 San Diego, CA 92101 telephone: 619.500.7906 20 facsimile: 619.839.3895 email: andrew@ahillierlaw.com; 21 paul@ahillierlaw.com 22 E (BY OVERNIGHT MAIL) By overnight courier, I arranged for the above-referenced document(s) to be delivered to an authorized overnight courier service, FedEx, for ' 23 delivery to the addressee(s) above, in an envelope or package designated by the overnight courier service with delivery fees paid or provided for. ‘_(BY ELECTRONIC SERVICE) By electronically mailing a true and correct copy through ‘Lie‘bert Cassidy Whitmore’ s electromc mail system fiom mw1bbenhorst@1cwlegal com to the email address(es) set forth above. ' I did not receive, within a reasonable time afier the transmission, any electronic message or other indication that the transmission was unsuccessful 7_ '4 Proof of Service 95557011 FR007-003 Executed on March 1, 2021, at Sacramento, California. Ideclare under penalty of perjury under the laws 0f the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct. vb (Out. 01km U égeuu-ivfijk Mariana Wibbenhorst 1260' l4 Corporation Whilmore 958 Suilc CA Mall. Law Cassidy Sacramento. Capitol Professional NMNNHp—tp—dr—Ar—Ap—tp—ny—ty—tp‘ Liebelt 400 A mNt-‘OKOOOQOxUI-PMNP‘O ‘I N “:9 .5 ['0 gn 5 Proof of Service 95557011 FR007—003 ICAT E IS TO WHICH THIS CERTIF THE DOCUMENT D CORRECT COPY A LL, TRUE. AN OF RECORD lN CHED IS FU ATTA L ON FILE AND OF THE ORIGNA mu I MYOFFICE. JUN 1 4 ATTEST: SHERRI R. CARTER the Supe rior /Clerk of Executive foicey os Angeles. Co of a