Preview
BUR
BUR L 000638-18
L 000638-18 06/29/2018 Pg 1Pgof 1
4 ofTrans
4 TransID: ID: LCV20181144263
LCV20181410428
-o: J.S.C. 0824
'Hon. Aimee R. Belgard, Page 3 of 6 201 E-06-29 11r57:33 EDT 1 609951 From: Kristine Camarda
REED SMITH I,LP the Court
Formed h the Ste e o.l l)etqv,are
Fited $ith
Diane A. Bettino. Iisqr"rire (03-12419q1)
l)aniel Mateo. Esquire (026331993) luN 2e 2018
David G. i\.{urphy',I;stluire (06982?013)
Princcton F'orrestal Vi Ilage AloeeB.Bclgrd'J.!G'
136 Main Slreet. Suitc 250
Princeton, NJ 08540
Tel. (60s) 5 I.1-5954
Irax (609.1 9-s 1-0824
.Attorncys lor Dct'cndants Anrcri Crcdit Finaucial Services,
Inc. d,4:ia (ilVf Financial and Danie} Ilercc
JI]TIIRIY I][LLO,
; SI]PERIOR CTOURT OF NEW JERSEY
Plaintifl, , law oivstoN
BURI-I]'{GTON COTJN.IY
l)ochct tr"o- L-0006] 8- I 8
CADII-I.AC, A DIVISION OF GI-|NLIR:\l-
MOTOR.S CO\1PANY. ET AI,, GENETIAI, (.livil
Aclion
MOIORS H0LDINGS, t.l.C: GENIIRAI-
MOTORS LLC. IIOI-MAN L]ADII,I,AC, A
DIVIS]ON OI-. I IOt,\4AN AU,TOI\,{OTIVE,
INC: ESIS GEN-I:R;\I- IvIOTOIIS. A
WLIOLLYOUAiED SUBSIDIARY OF I}IE
CI lullB CORPOR;\I lON ; KI:iRIlllCK
CADII-LAC. tr',,v(l; GllNllRAI- MO-IORS S'[IP[it,ATIO\ AND PROPoSE,T}
FINzL\iCIr\1, COMPANY, lNC, A WIIOLLY CONSENT ORDER II,EGAI(DING
OUAI.D SUBSIDIARY O[ CI]NERAL PI,ATNTIFF"S FILI'NG A SECONI)
MOIORS CO,rvI PANlf: AII{S IIP'I. D.lCl rT\{ENDT,D CO}T PI,A TN'I'
MARY T. BARRA, I)AN"llil- UERCE,
MEI-NDr| K. IIOLMAN. MICTIAEL
SCrlwAB, STEVEN N4z\l)DERli. CHRIS C.
ROI.'FIJ\I, JOSI]UA PITI:IS'f L.R^
JOI IN/JANI] DoUS II1. I O AND/OR .AI]C
CORPOR-{TJONS #1.1 O, FICTIT]OT]S
COIU,OI{r\l-IONS AND/OII
COMTlERC IAI,, EN'f ITIf]S, J/S'\
Def'endan1s.
BUR
BUR L 000638-18
L 000638-18 06/29/2018 Pg 2Pgof 2
4 ofTrans
4 TransID: ID: LCV20181144263
LCV20181410428
-o: 'Hon. Aimee R Belgard, J.SC. Page 4 of 6 201A-06-29 1 1:57:33 EDT 1 609951 0824 From: Kristine Camarda
WHEREA.S on Marc}l 22, 2018, Plajnlil'f llled the original Complaint in this Actiorr.
nanring L-adillac, a Division of Gencral Motors Compan-y, ct al.. General Motors }loldings,
l-LC; General Motors Ll..C, [{olman Cadillac, a Dir.'ision of I'lolrran Automotive, Inc.; ESIS
General Motorc, a Wholly Ormed Subsidiall, o1' the Chubb Corporation: Kerbeck Cadillac,
Inc.: Ceneral Motors l;inancial Company, Inc.. a Wholly Oxned Subsidiary of Ceneral Motors
Compan_v-; Airsept. lnc.; Mary T. Bana, Daniel Berce. Melinda K. I'Iolman, Miehael Schwab,
Steven Maddem, Chris C. Rofliy, .loshua Preister. John/Jane Does #I-10 and/or ABC
Corporations # l - 10,l-ictitious Corporations, and/or Commercial L)nlities, J/S/A as Dcibndants;
IYIIEREAS on April I l.2018, Plaintiff llled the First Amended Complaint:
WIIER-EAS on Mai, I7. 201 8 and May 24. 2018. respectivell,. Defcndants Kerbeck
Cadillac, Inc. and AirSept, Inc. ansr+ered Plaintifls F'irst Amencled Cornplaint" and Def'cndant
Kerbeck Cadillac, Inc. filcd an amcndc'd answcl'on .lune 27, 201 8l
WIIIi,REAS betrveen May 21. 2018 and Junc 18,2018, Dclbndants Gcncral Motors
Compan.v-,, Gcncral iv{otors I{oldings LI-C, General Motors l"LC, AmeriCrcdit Filancial
Scrvices. Inc. d/b/a GM l:inancial and Daniel Ilcrce, Flolman Cladillac. h4elinda K. I{olman,
Michael Schu'nb, Mary 1'. Ilana, ilSIS. Inc., Chris C. Rof}'e_v. .Ioshua Prsistcr, Kerbeck Cladillac
and Airscpt, Inc. filed motions to dismiss Plaintiff s F'irst Amended Complaint:
WIIEREAS on June i,2018, I'laintitffilcd correspondcnce *ith the Courl seeking an
adjouinment and requesting lhat certain motions Uled by Det'endants be lrealL-d rrs sumnur),
judgmcnt motions:
}I,HEREAS on Junc 8, 2018. the Court cntered a flasc }v'lanagement Ordcr lbr this
Acliolt. setting the retunr date and ol'al argument fcr Defendarls' nrotions to disnriss to June 1a
2OlEl
2
BUR
BUR L 000638-18
L 000638-18 06/29/2018 Pg 3Pgof 3
4 ofTrans
4 TransID: ID: LCV20181144263
LCV20181410428
-o; 'Hon. Aimee R. Belgard, J.S.C. Paqe 5 of 6 2018-06'29 1 1:57:33 EDT 1 609 951 0824 From: Kristine camarda
WIIEIIDAS Plaindff opposed Doltndanls' motions to dismiss;
WHBREAS on June 20, 2018, i'laint.illf filed a \4otion Seeking l-eave to Arnend the
l"irst Amended Complaill spccifically rcqucsting Isavc to; (l) rcvise t1rpographical errors:
(2) correct the naoles of D€ferdants Stcven 4adde.m, I'lolman ,{u1oorotlve, lnc,, and ESIS
Gcneral V{otors; (3) add individual del'enclants to thq "Counts" scction ofhis complaint; (4) add
'Iamnry Ward as a l)el'endanl to tho Action; and (5) add counts to the Aotion as they rclate to
De1'enda:rt AmeriCredit Financial Services, Inc. d,ltrla GM l'inancial and Daniel Berce:
IT IS I{EIIIIBY STIPLTL.{TIID AliD AGIlliliD, by thc Partios, through thcir
undcrsigncd counsel. subject to Courl approval. and for other good cause shownl
Defbndants, without waiving any of ficir claims or dcl'enses, shall not oppose
Plaintill's lvlotion Seeking Leave lo Arnend the First Arnended Complaint:
2 Plaintiffs lv{olion Seeking L-eave to Amend the First Amendcd Conrplaint is
hereby GRANTED;
J I'laintllf shatl filc and sen e thc Secorrd Arnended Complaint cnclosed in
Plaintit't's Motion Seeking [,e0ve to Amend the First Arnended Complaint within
thirty (30) days of thc datc o1'this Order:
I Dcl'cndants shall anslr'er. nove. or othenvisc respond to Plainrill.s Second
Anrended (lomplaiut rvithin thirtv (30) days ol filing andror docketing of the
Second Arnendcd Corlplaint on e-Courts. and rvith lhe court to thcrcalter set a
brie fine schedule and oral argument date fbr all of the pcnding molionsi and
5. i'laintii'islrall not makc or scck lcave 1o nraks amendments lo thc Sccon
Anrended Com plainr, 4S ta +^L CLE K.fs
ir
IVHIiITEFOIIE,
-td\r
Ily rcquc stt hat t
Lt e Court elrtcr an ordcr approving
thc tcmis ol'the above STIPULATION
I'T IS So ORDEREI)
oated: Lrne fJ. zOt 8 t/.
OLA.I]LE A ER. GA.RI) J.S.C
3
BUR
BUR L 000638-18
L 000638-18 06/29/2018 Pg 4Pgof 4 ofTrans
4 TransID: ID: LCV20181144263
LCV20181410428
-or 'Hon. Aimee R. Belgard,J.S.C. Page 6 of 6 2018-06-29 1'1:57:33EDT 1 609951 0824 From: Kristine Camarda
The undcrsignet{ lrereby consetrt to the form and enlry of the within Stipalalion and Order:
JEF'FITI'}'I}ELLO ITEED SMITII I,LP
.I Daniel Matco, Dsq.
l.+3 l1street David Ci. N'lurphy, Esq.
lidgcrvirler l']art.NJ 0801 0 136 Mair.r Street
Pro Sc l'luinrifJ' Princeton. NJ 08540
A ttorneys.fit Defc ntlnnt.t,4 me.riCre dit
f'intnciul Se rfices. ]nc. d/bi'a GM F-incncial
tnd l)t:tnie I Bcvce
RICCI TYIIRIiI-I, JOIINSON & (;RI'Y WII,S()N EI,SI'IT T{0SKOWITZ
ELDIVI-4.N & DI(]KER LI,P
Fran (]I s J. Cley.
Monica V.
Bsq.
Pennisi Marsico. Esq.
Barbara
Benjanrin
II.
4
Keliy. Iisq.
S. Muzi, Esq.
Tmcie Ilock lvlecleiros. Iisq. 200 Campr-rs Dril,e
Willorv Ridge Executive Otfice Park Florhaur I'>ark. NJ 07932
750 Roule 73, South Suite 202[t A tlrrrne.ys Jitr Deftndanl ,4irSeJsl Inc
Miulton, N.l 08053
-for Defendants
Attorne.y,.t Gene ral fulotors
Comptny, Generd ,\'lotors Holclings LI-(),
Genertrl lr{otrtrs LI,C. ESIS, Ilolntsn ('adill*.
lt{elindu K llolman and it{ichael Schv,trb.
l,Iar-,- T', Ilarra,
Chris C. Rdfet. Joshua
Preister und Kerbeck Ctxlilloc. Int'.
.+
Preview
BUR BUR L 000638-18 L 000638-18 06/29/2018 Pg 1Pgof 1 4 ofTrans 4 TransID: ID: LCV20181144263 LCV20181410428 -o: J.S.C. 0824 'Hon. Aimee R. Belgard, Page 3 of 6 201 E-06-29 11r57:33 EDT 1 609951 From: Kristine Camarda REED SMITH I,LP the Court Formed h the Ste e o.l l)etqv,are Fited $ith Diane A. Bettino. Iisqr"rire (03-12419q1) l)aniel Mateo. Esquire (026331993) luN 2e 2018 David G. i\.{urphy',I;stluire (06982?013) Princcton F'orrestal Vi Ilage AloeeB.Bclgrd'J.!G' 136 Main Slreet. Suitc 250 Princeton, NJ 08540 Tel. (60s) 5 I.1-5954 Irax (609.1 9-s 1-0824 .Attorncys lor Dct'cndants Anrcri Crcdit Finaucial Services, Inc. d,4:ia (ilVf Financial and Danie} Ilercc JI]TIIRIY I][LLO, ; SI]PERIOR CTOURT OF NEW JERSEY Plaintifl, , law oivstoN BURI-I]'{GTON COTJN.IY l)ochct tr"o- L-0006] 8- I 8 CADII-I.AC, A DIVISION OF GI-|NLIR:\l- MOTOR.S CO\1PANY. ET AI,, GENETIAI, (.livil Aclion MOIORS H0LDINGS, t.l.C: GENIIRAI- MOTORS LLC. IIOI-MAN L]ADII,I,AC, A DIVIS]ON OI-. I IOt,\4AN AU,TOI\,{OTIVE, INC: ESIS GEN-I:R;\I- IvIOTOIIS. A WLIOLLYOUAiED SUBSIDIARY OF I}IE CI lullB CORPOR;\I lON ; KI:iRIlllCK CADII-LAC. tr',,v(l; GllNllRAI- MO-IORS S'[IP[it,ATIO\ AND PROPoSE,T} FINzL\iCIr\1, COMPANY, lNC, A WIIOLLY CONSENT ORDER II,EGAI(DING OUAI.D SUBSIDIARY O[ CI]NERAL PI,ATNTIFF"S FILI'NG A SECONI) MOIORS CO,rvI PANlf: AII{S IIP'I. D.lCl rT\{ENDT,D CO}T PI,A TN'I' MARY T. BARRA, I)AN"llil- UERCE, MEI-NDr| K. IIOLMAN. MICTIAEL SCrlwAB, STEVEN N4z\l)DERli. CHRIS C. ROI.'FIJ\I, JOSI]UA PITI:IS'f L.R^ JOI IN/JANI] DoUS II1. I O AND/OR .AI]C CORPOR-{TJONS #1.1 O, FICTIT]OT]S COIU,OI{r\l-IONS AND/OII COMTlERC IAI,, EN'f ITIf]S, J/S'\ Def'endan1s. BUR BUR L 000638-18 L 000638-18 06/29/2018 Pg 2Pgof 2 4 ofTrans 4 TransID: ID: LCV20181144263 LCV20181410428 -o: 'Hon. Aimee R Belgard, J.SC. Page 4 of 6 201A-06-29 1 1:57:33 EDT 1 609951 0824 From: Kristine Camarda WHEREA.S on Marc}l 22, 2018, Plajnlil'f llled the original Complaint in this Actiorr. nanring L-adillac, a Division of Gencral Motors Compan-y, ct al.. General Motors }loldings, l-LC; General Motors Ll..C, [{olman Cadillac, a Dir.'ision of I'lolrran Automotive, Inc.; ESIS General Motorc, a Wholly Ormed Subsidiall, o1' the Chubb Corporation: Kerbeck Cadillac, Inc.: Ceneral Motors l;inancial Company, Inc.. a Wholly Oxned Subsidiary of Ceneral Motors Compan_v-; Airsept. lnc.; Mary T. Bana, Daniel Berce. Melinda K. I'Iolman, Miehael Schwab, Steven Maddem, Chris C. Rofliy, .loshua Preister. John/Jane Does #I-10 and/or ABC Corporations # l - 10,l-ictitious Corporations, and/or Commercial L)nlities, J/S/A as Dcibndants; IYIIEREAS on April I l.2018, Plaintiff llled the First Amended Complaint: WIIER-EAS on Mai, I7. 201 8 and May 24. 2018. respectivell,. Defcndants Kerbeck Cadillac, Inc. and AirSept, Inc. ansr+ered Plaintifls F'irst Amencled Cornplaint" and Def'cndant Kerbeck Cadillac, Inc. filcd an amcndc'd answcl'on .lune 27, 201 8l WIIIi,REAS betrveen May 21. 2018 and Junc 18,2018, Dclbndants Gcncral Motors Compan.v-,, Gcncral iv{otors I{oldings LI-C, General Motors l"LC, AmeriCrcdit Filancial Scrvices. Inc. d/b/a GM l:inancial and Daniel Ilcrce, Flolman Cladillac. h4elinda K. I{olman, Michael Schu'nb, Mary 1'. Ilana, ilSIS. Inc., Chris C. Rof}'e_v. .Ioshua Prsistcr, Kerbeck Cladillac and Airscpt, Inc. filed motions to dismiss Plaintiff s F'irst Amended Complaint: WIIEREAS on June i,2018, I'laintitffilcd correspondcnce *ith the Courl seeking an adjouinment and requesting lhat certain motions Uled by Det'endants be lrealL-d rrs sumnur), judgmcnt motions: }I,HEREAS on Junc 8, 2018. the Court cntered a flasc }v'lanagement Ordcr lbr this Acliolt. setting the retunr date and ol'al argument fcr Defendarls' nrotions to disnriss to June 1a 2OlEl 2 BUR BUR L 000638-18 L 000638-18 06/29/2018 Pg 3Pgof 3 4 ofTrans 4 TransID: ID: LCV20181144263 LCV20181410428 -o; 'Hon. Aimee R. Belgard, J.S.C. Paqe 5 of 6 2018-06'29 1 1:57:33 EDT 1 609 951 0824 From: Kristine camarda WIIEIIDAS Plaindff opposed Doltndanls' motions to dismiss; WHBREAS on June 20, 2018, i'laint.illf filed a \4otion Seeking l-eave to Arnend the l"irst Amended Complaill spccifically rcqucsting Isavc to; (l) rcvise t1rpographical errors: (2) correct the naoles of D€ferdants Stcven 4adde.m, I'lolman ,{u1oorotlve, lnc,, and ESIS Gcneral V{otors; (3) add individual del'enclants to thq "Counts" scction ofhis complaint; (4) add 'Iamnry Ward as a l)el'endanl to tho Action; and (5) add counts to the Aotion as they rclate to De1'enda:rt AmeriCredit Financial Services, Inc. d,ltrla GM l'inancial and Daniel Berce: IT IS I{EIIIIBY STIPLTL.{TIID AliD AGIlliliD, by thc Partios, through thcir undcrsigncd counsel. subject to Courl approval. and for other good cause shownl Defbndants, without waiving any of ficir claims or dcl'enses, shall not oppose Plaintill's lvlotion Seeking Leave lo Arnend the First Arnended Complaint: 2 Plaintiffs lv{olion Seeking L-eave to Amend the First Amendcd Conrplaint is hereby GRANTED; J I'laintllf shatl filc and sen e thc Secorrd Arnended Complaint cnclosed in Plaintit't's Motion Seeking [,e0ve to Amend the First Arnended Complaint within thirty (30) days of thc datc o1'this Order: I Dcl'cndants shall anslr'er. nove. or othenvisc respond to Plainrill.s Second Anrended (lomplaiut rvithin thirtv (30) days ol filing andror docketing of the Second Arnendcd Corlplaint on e-Courts. and rvith lhe court to thcrcalter set a brie fine schedule and oral argument date fbr all of the pcnding molionsi and 5. i'laintii'islrall not makc or scck lcave 1o nraks amendments lo thc Sccon Anrended Com plainr, 4S ta +^L CLE K.fs ir IVHIiITEFOIIE, -td\r Ily rcquc stt hat t Lt e Court elrtcr an ordcr approving thc tcmis ol'the above STIPULATION I'T IS So ORDEREI) oated: Lrne fJ. zOt 8 t/. OLA.I]LE A ER. GA.RI) J.S.C 3 BUR BUR L 000638-18 L 000638-18 06/29/2018 Pg 4Pgof 4 ofTrans 4 TransID: ID: LCV20181144263 LCV20181410428 -or 'Hon. Aimee R. Belgard,J.S.C. Page 6 of 6 2018-06-29 1'1:57:33EDT 1 609951 0824 From: Kristine Camarda The undcrsignet{ lrereby consetrt to the form and enlry of the within Stipalalion and Order: JEF'FITI'}'I}ELLO ITEED SMITII I,LP .I Daniel Matco, Dsq. l.+3 l1street David Ci. N'lurphy, Esq. lidgcrvirler l']art.NJ 0801 0 136 Mair.r Street Pro Sc l'luinrifJ' Princeton. NJ 08540 A ttorneys.fit Defc ntlnnt.t,4 me.riCre dit f'intnciul Se rfices. ]nc. d/bi'a GM F-incncial tnd l)t:tnie I Bcvce RICCI TYIIRIiI-I, JOIINSON & (;RI'Y WII,S()N EI,SI'IT T{0SKOWITZ ELDIVI-4.N & DI(]KER LI,P Fran (]I s J. Cley. Monica V. Bsq. Pennisi Marsico. Esq. Barbara Benjanrin II. 4 Keliy. Iisq. S. Muzi, Esq. Tmcie Ilock lvlecleiros. Iisq. 200 Campr-rs Dril,e Willorv Ridge Executive Otfice Park Florhaur I'>ark. NJ 07932 750 Roule 73, South Suite 202[t A tlrrrne.ys Jitr Deftndanl ,4irSeJsl Inc Miulton, N.l 08053 -for Defendants Attorne.y,.t Gene ral fulotors Comptny, Generd ,\'lotors Holclings LI-(), Genertrl lr{otrtrs LI,C. ESIS, Ilolntsn ('adill*. lt{elindu K llolman and it{ichael Schv,trb. l,Iar-,- T', Ilarra, Chris C. Rdfet. Joshua Preister und Kerbeck Ctxlilloc. Int'. .+