On June 30, 2010 a
Motion,Ex Parte
was filed
involving a dispute between
Arata, Thomas,
Leake, Joseph,
Owyang, Rich,
Pecot, Johna,
Taylor, Oscar,
Tilton, Stephen,
and
Does 1-100,
Does 1 To 100,
Mcdaniels, Shedrick,
San Francisco Deputy Sheriff'S Association,
San Francisco Deputy Sheriff'S Association, A,
San Francisco Deputy Sheriff'S Foundation,
Savage, Brian,
Wong, David,
Zehner, Michael,
for civil
in the District Court of San Francisco County.
Preview
IU
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
Document Scanning Lead Sheet |
Jun-21-2016 10:03 am ,
Case Number: CGC-10-501168
Filing Date: Jun-21-2016 9:59
Filed by: ROSIE NOGUERA
Image: 05444253
ORDER
JOHNA PECOT et al VS. SAN FRANCISCO DEPUTY SHERIFF'S ASSOCIATION,
Aetal '
001005444253
Instructions:
Please place this sheet on top of the document to be scanned.Lawrence D. Murray (SBN 77536)
MURRAY & ASSOCIATES
1781 Union Street
San Francisco, CA 94123
Tel: (415) 673-0555
Fax: (415) 928-4084
Attorney for Defendants: DAVID WONG,
MICHAEL ZEHNER, BRIAN SAVAGE
FILE
Superior Court of California
‘County of San Francisco
JUN 2 12016
CLERK OF THE COURT
By . eputy Clerk
and SHEDRICK McDANIELS
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO
JOHNA PECOT, THOMAS ARATA, RICH
OWYANG, STEPHEN TILTON, JOSEPH
LEAKE, and OSCAR TAYLOR, Individually
and on behalf of all other similarly situated,
Case No. CGC — 10 -501168
We
[proposed} Order On Motion to Amend The
Pleadings and/or Proceedings by Striking Out
Plaintiff Thomas Arata’s Name and/ or
Plaintiffs, Correcting A Mistake; and Motions To Change
v. Attorneys
SAN FRANCISCO DEPUTY SHERIFF’S Date: June 21, 2016
ASSOCIATION, a California Nonprofit Time: 9:30 a.m.
Corporation, SAN FRANCISCO DEPUTY Dept: 302
SHERIFF’S FOUNDATION, a California Reserv 0510621-6 :
Nonprofit Corporation, DAVID WONG, an
individual, MICHAEL ZEHNER, an individual, Complaint
BRIAN SAVAGE, an individual, SHEDRICK Filed: June 30,2010 '
McDANIELS, an individual, and DOES 1-100, Trial: June 27, 2016
Defendants.
The above entitled matter having come on for hearing on June 21, 2016, at 9:30 am in
Department 302, before the Honorable Hordd Kohn _ I : .
Judge of the Superior Court on PLAINTIFF THOMAS ARATA'S Motions To 1) lamend The Pleadings
and 2) To Change Attorney. Counsel for Plaintiff Thomas Arata having contested the tentative ruling
and the parties, through their attorneys having appears for hearing;
The matter having been taken under submission, and FOR GOOD CAUSE LACKING,
Pecot, et al. vs. SFDSA, et al.; San Francisco Superior Court No: CGC — 10 — 501168 Page 1
Order On Motion to Amend Striking Plaintiff Thomas Arata’s Name and Motions To Change AttorneysPlaintiff Thomas Arata's motion to strike his name from the case is denied, but Mr. Arata may file a
dismissal of all the claims alleged by him. There is an insufficient showing that Mr. Arata was included
as a plaintiff by mistake without his knowledge. Nor are the interests of justice served by allowing Mr.
Arata at this late date in the litigation to be treated as if he was never a plaintiff. However, there is no bar}
to Mr. Arata dismissing all of his claims.
me Glan at
JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT
HAROLD KAHN :
Pecot, et al. vs. SFDSA, et al.; San Francisco Superior Court No: CGC — 10 - 501168 ! Page 2
Order On Motion to Amend Striking Plaintiff Thomas Arata’s Name and Motions To Change Attorneys
Document Filed Date
June 21, 2016
Case Filing Date
June 30, 2010
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
IU SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO Document Scanning Lead Sheet | Jun-21-2016 10:03 am , Case Number: CGC-10-501168 Filing Date: Jun-21-2016 9:59 Filed by: ROSIE NOGUERA Image: 05444253 ORDER JOHNA PECOT et al VS. SAN FRANCISCO DEPUTY SHERIFF'S ASSOCIATION, Aetal ' 001005444253 Instructions: Please place this sheet on top of the document to be scanned.Lawrence D. Murray (SBN 77536) MURRAY & ASSOCIATES 1781 Union Street San Francisco, CA 94123 Tel: (415) 673-0555 Fax: (415) 928-4084 Attorney for Defendants: DAVID WONG, MICHAEL ZEHNER, BRIAN SAVAGE FILE Superior Court of California ‘County of San Francisco JUN 2 12016 CLERK OF THE COURT By . eputy Clerk and SHEDRICK McDANIELS SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO JOHNA PECOT, THOMAS ARATA, RICH OWYANG, STEPHEN TILTON, JOSEPH LEAKE, and OSCAR TAYLOR, Individually and on behalf of all other similarly situated, Case No. CGC — 10 -501168 We [proposed} Order On Motion to Amend The Pleadings and/or Proceedings by Striking Out Plaintiff Thomas Arata’s Name and/ or Plaintiffs, Correcting A Mistake; and Motions To Change v. Attorneys SAN FRANCISCO DEPUTY SHERIFF’S Date: June 21, 2016 ASSOCIATION, a California Nonprofit Time: 9:30 a.m. Corporation, SAN FRANCISCO DEPUTY Dept: 302 SHERIFF’S FOUNDATION, a California Reserv 0510621-6 : Nonprofit Corporation, DAVID WONG, an individual, MICHAEL ZEHNER, an individual, Complaint BRIAN SAVAGE, an individual, SHEDRICK Filed: June 30,2010 ' McDANIELS, an individual, and DOES 1-100, Trial: June 27, 2016 Defendants. The above entitled matter having come on for hearing on June 21, 2016, at 9:30 am in Department 302, before the Honorable Hordd Kohn _ I : . Judge of the Superior Court on PLAINTIFF THOMAS ARATA'S Motions To 1) lamend The Pleadings and 2) To Change Attorney. Counsel for Plaintiff Thomas Arata having contested the tentative ruling and the parties, through their attorneys having appears for hearing; The matter having been taken under submission, and FOR GOOD CAUSE LACKING, Pecot, et al. vs. SFDSA, et al.; San Francisco Superior Court No: CGC — 10 — 501168 Page 1 Order On Motion to Amend Striking Plaintiff Thomas Arata’s Name and Motions To Change AttorneysPlaintiff Thomas Arata's motion to strike his name from the case is denied, but Mr. Arata may file a dismissal of all the claims alleged by him. There is an insufficient showing that Mr. Arata was included as a plaintiff by mistake without his knowledge. Nor are the interests of justice served by allowing Mr. Arata at this late date in the litigation to be treated as if he was never a plaintiff. However, there is no bar} to Mr. Arata dismissing all of his claims. me Glan at JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT HAROLD KAHN : Pecot, et al. vs. SFDSA, et al.; San Francisco Superior Court No: CGC — 10 - 501168 ! Page 2 Order On Motion to Amend Striking Plaintiff Thomas Arata’s Name and Motions To Change Attorneys