On August 24, 2012 a
Motion,Ex Parte
was filed
involving a dispute between
Vaughan, Daniel & Karen,
and
Vaughn, Aaron,
Vaughn, Lacy,
for Modify - Custody
in the District Court of Smith County.
Preview
1N THE INTEREST 0F §- __
--
v11; THE DISTRICT COURT 0F
TRISTAN VAUGHAN, m§143% I
5
(__.
TANNER VAUGHAN, — L-
TARIN VAUGHAN, § SMITH COUNTY, TEXAS
TRINITY VAUGHAN, §
§
CHILDREN § 321ST JUDICIAL DISTRICT
TEXAS DEPARTMENT 0F FAMILY AND PROTECTIVE SERVICES MOTION TO
STRIKE PETITION IN INTERVENTION
TEXAS DEPARTMENT 0F FAMILY AND PROTECTIVE SERVICES
(hereinafter "the Department") asks the Court to strike Intervene: Broylcs’ Petition in
Intervention.
A. Introduction
l. Petitioner is the TEXAS DEPARTMENT 0F FAMILY AND PROTECTIVE
SERVICES; Respondents are LACY VAUGHAN, AARON VAUGHAN, Intervenor
ROBERT MINATREA, [ntcrvenors DANIEL VAUGHAN and KAREN VAUGHAN and
Intervenors MICHAEL BROYLES and KRISTIN BROYLES.
2. Petitioner sued Respondents for protection 0f the children.
3. Discovery in this suit isgoverned by a Level 2 discovery control plan. The discovery
period ended 0n July 26, 2013.
4. This case isset for hearing on August 15, 2012 at 3:30 pm.
B. Facts
5. On July 18, 2013, lntervenor filed a Petition in Intervention that requests sole managing
conservatorship, termination and adoption with [he children, Tarin and Trinity Vaughan.
Motion to Strike 3690813683 l 369
Page1
msl
C. Argument And Authorities
6. The Court should strike a petition in intervention if the intervenor could not have brought
all0r pan 0f the same action in its own name. See Guaranty Fed. Sav. Bank v. Horseshoe
Operating C0., 793 S.W.2d 652, 657 (Tex. 1990); E & B Carpet Millx v. State, 776 S.W.2d 286,
290 (Tex. App.—-Austin 1989, writ dism'd). Intervenors could not have brought all or part Ofthis
action in their own name because intervenors Broyles do not meet standing under §102.003, TFC
nor have the Broyles had substantial past contact under §102.004 and §102.005, Texas Family
Code.
PRAYER
For these reasons, the Department asks the Court to set this Motion for hearing and, after
the hearing, strike Intervenor's Petition in Intervention.
Re?!) ctfully Sixpmitted,
lLrUUl \m u. wu—e
‘J
PATRICE SAVAGE
Attorney for Texas Department of
Family and Protective Services
Texas Bar No. 17688230
2130 Alpine Road
Lon gview, Texas 75601
Office No.: 903-233-5210
Facsimile No.: 903-233-5250
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
This is to certify that a true and correct copy of the above document was served 0n the
following in accordance with the Texas Rules 0f Civil Procedure on the 9th day 0f
August. 2013.
Jarrod Heath, Attorney for Mother
100 Independence Place, Suite 207
Tyler, TX 75703
F-903 253-0558
HC law @ gmail.com
J arrod .
Motion to Stn’ke 369v08-3683/ 369
Page 2 msl
Cameron Castleberry, Attorney for Father
422 S. Spring Street
Tyler, TX 75702
Facsimile: (903) 595-1009
castleberry@castleberrylawum
Jennifer Deen, Attorney Ad Litem for Children
109 W. Ferguson
Tyler, TX 75710
Facsimile: (903) 597—7322
gdecn@att.net; tammye@bain-files.com
CASA, Guardian Ad Litem of Children
Facsimile: (903) 597—0691
marlene@casaforkidsofemrq
Amanda Allman-Minatrea, Attorney for Intervenor Robert Minatrea
406 South Washington
Marshall, TX 75670
Fax (903) 923-8197
Alicia Cashell Barkley, Attorney for lntervenor Vaughans
217 W. Houston
Tyler, TX 75702
(903) 597-5664
alicia@aliciacashelixom; kristen©aliciacashellxom
Michael K. Hogan, Attorney for Intervenors Broyles
123 E. Houston
Tyler, TX 75702
Fax (903') 597-3870 ---\
l .
i
.-
\
-"
l,- r
/
I
'
-
,v
._la -..._lr[_l.-
I
I,
If
U”
._
:1,
LIA
[I LEM!” t’\i‘J/_J-5;
\-_
PA'I‘R ICE S AVAGIE
Motion to Strike 36908-3683 l 369
Page 3 ms!
Document Filed Date
August 12, 2013
Case Filing Date
August 24, 2012
Category
Modify - Custody
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
1N THE INTEREST 0F §- __ -- v11; THE DISTRICT COURT 0F TRISTAN VAUGHAN, m§143% I 5 (__. TANNER VAUGHAN, — L- TARIN VAUGHAN, § SMITH COUNTY, TEXAS TRINITY VAUGHAN, § § CHILDREN § 321ST JUDICIAL DISTRICT TEXAS DEPARTMENT 0F FAMILY AND PROTECTIVE SERVICES MOTION TO STRIKE PETITION IN INTERVENTION TEXAS DEPARTMENT 0F FAMILY AND PROTECTIVE SERVICES (hereinafter "the Department") asks the Court to strike Intervene: Broylcs’ Petition in Intervention. A. Introduction l. Petitioner is the TEXAS DEPARTMENT 0F FAMILY AND PROTECTIVE SERVICES; Respondents are LACY VAUGHAN, AARON VAUGHAN, Intervenor ROBERT MINATREA, [ntcrvenors DANIEL VAUGHAN and KAREN VAUGHAN and Intervenors MICHAEL BROYLES and KRISTIN BROYLES. 2. Petitioner sued Respondents for protection 0f the children. 3. Discovery in this suit isgoverned by a Level 2 discovery control plan. The discovery period ended 0n July 26, 2013. 4. This case isset for hearing on August 15, 2012 at 3:30 pm. B. Facts 5. On July 18, 2013, lntervenor filed a Petition in Intervention that requests sole managing conservatorship, termination and adoption with [he children, Tarin and Trinity Vaughan. Motion to Strike 3690813683 l 369 Page1 msl C. Argument And Authorities 6. The Court should strike a petition in intervention if the intervenor could not have brought all0r pan 0f the same action in its own name. See Guaranty Fed. Sav. Bank v. Horseshoe Operating C0., 793 S.W.2d 652, 657 (Tex. 1990); E & B Carpet Millx v. State, 776 S.W.2d 286, 290 (Tex. App.—-Austin 1989, writ dism'd). Intervenors could not have brought all or part Ofthis action in their own name because intervenors Broyles do not meet standing under §102.003, TFC nor have the Broyles had substantial past contact under §102.004 and §102.005, Texas Family Code. PRAYER For these reasons, the Department asks the Court to set this Motion for hearing and, after the hearing, strike Intervenor's Petition in Intervention. Re?!) ctfully Sixpmitted, lLrUUl \m u. wu—e ‘J PATRICE SAVAGE Attorney for Texas Department of Family and Protective Services Texas Bar No. 17688230 2130 Alpine Road Lon gview, Texas 75601 Office No.: 903-233-5210 Facsimile No.: 903-233-5250 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE This is to certify that a true and correct copy of the above document was served 0n the following in accordance with the Texas Rules 0f Civil Procedure on the 9th day 0f August. 2013. Jarrod Heath, Attorney for Mother 100 Independence Place, Suite 207 Tyler, TX 75703 F-903 253-0558 HC law @ gmail.com J arrod . Motion to Stn’ke 369v08-3683/ 369 Page 2 msl Cameron Castleberry, Attorney for Father 422 S. Spring Street Tyler, TX 75702 Facsimile: (903) 595-1009 castleberry@castleberrylawum Jennifer Deen, Attorney Ad Litem for Children 109 W. Ferguson Tyler, TX 75710 Facsimile: (903) 597—7322 gdecn@att.net; tammye@bain-files.com CASA, Guardian Ad Litem of Children Facsimile: (903) 597—0691 marlene@casaforkidsofemrq Amanda Allman-Minatrea, Attorney for Intervenor Robert Minatrea 406 South Washington Marshall, TX 75670 Fax (903) 923-8197 Alicia Cashell Barkley, Attorney for lntervenor Vaughans 217 W. Houston Tyler, TX 75702 (903) 597-5664 alicia@aliciacashelixom; kristen©aliciacashellxom Michael K. Hogan, Attorney for Intervenors Broyles 123 E. Houston Tyler, TX 75702 Fax (903') 597-3870 ---\ l . i .- \ -" l,- r / I ' - ,v ._la -..._lr[_l.- I I, If U” ._ :1, LIA [I LEM!” t’\i‘J/_J-5; \-_ PA'I‘R ICE S AVAGIE Motion to Strike 36908-3683 l 369 Page 3 ms!