Preview
Daniel Da:
EL CTRO} IN eat YF
pr ee - MAHONING
¢
c COURT
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
MAHONING COUNTY, OHIO
DANIEL R. YEMMA, AS TREASURER _ ) CASE NO.
OF MAHONING COUNTY, OHIO )
Mahoning County Courthouse JUDGE
120 Market Street
Youngstown, OH 44503 COMPLAINT FOR COLLECTION OF
DELINQUENT TAXES, ASSESSMENTS
PLAINTIFF PENALTIES AND INTEREST
FORECLOSURE AND EQUITABLE
-vs- RELIEF
UNKNOWN SURVIVING SPOUSE, PARCEL NUMBER 53-221-0-068.00-0
NEXT OF KIN, DEVISEES, LEGATEES,
EXECUTORS, ADMINISTRATORS,
AND PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVES,
IF ANY OF LORENZO ROLLER,
DECEASED
Address unknown
DEFENDANT
Now comes Plaintiff Mahoning County Treasurer Daniel R. Yemma, by and through
undersigned counsel and for his cause of action against the Defendants, state accordingly:
1 Plaintiff is the Treasurer of Mahoning County, Ohio and brings this action in his
capacity as Mahoning County Treasurer.
2. This action is brought pursuant to R.C. §323.25 and/or §5721.18 of the Ohio
Revised Code.
3 The Preliminary Judicial Report prepared in contemplation of this action is attached
hereto as Exhibit A in compliance with Rule 13 of the Mahoning County Local Rules of Practice
and Procedure.
4 A Master List of Delinquent Vacant Tracts and/or Delinquent Land Tax Certificate
has been duly certified by the County Auditor of Mahoning County, Ohio and delivered to the
2024 CV 00698
County Prosecutor of Mahoning County, Ohio for Parcel Number 53-22 1-0-068.00-0, Miltonia
Avenue, vacant Lot No. 46374, Youngstown, OH (the “Property”)
5 That more than sixty days has passed since the Mahoning County Auditor delivered
a delinquent land duplicate to the Plaintiff regarding the Property.
6. That the real property taxes owed on Parcel Number 53-221-0-068.00-0 were
certified delinquent in 2007 and advertised delinquent in 2010.
7. A certified copy of the Delinquent Land Certificate for Parcel Number 53-221-0-
068.00-0 is attached hereto as Exhibit 1 and is incorporated herein.
8 A certified copy of the Auditor’s Tax List and Treasurer’s Duplicate of Real
Property for Parcel Number 53-221-0-068.00-0 is attached hereto as Exhibit 2 and is incorporated
herein.
9 That more than one year has passed since the taxes on the Property were certified
delinquent and the taxes remain unpaid.
10. That the amount of taxes, assessments, charges, penalties and interest (hereinafter
referred to as “Impositions”) which remain due and unpaid on the Property are $176.27 and is a
first and best lien against said Property which is more fully described in the attached Preliminary
Judicial Report (Exhibit A).
ll. Plaintiff further says that Defendant Unknown Surviving Spouse, Next of Kin,
Devisees, Legatees, Executors, Administrators, and Personal Representatives, if any of Lorenzo
Roller, Deceased has or may claim to have some interest in or claim upon the Property, but Plaintiff
not being fully advised as to the extent, if any, of such interest or claim, prays that said Defendant
be required to set up its interest or claim or be forever barred from asserting same against the
within described Property.
2024 CV 00698
12. The Property is delinquent vacant lands as that term is defined in R.C. §5721.01
and/or abandoned lands as that term is defined in R.C. §325.65 and/or nonproductive land as that
term is defined in R.C. §5722.01.
13. Plaintiff states that the value of the taxes, assessments, penalties, interest, and all
other charges and costs of the action exceed the auditor's fair market value of the Property.
14, Therefore, in accordance with R.C. §323.28 (E) and/or R.C. §5721.19 (1), plaintiff,
or on the court's own motion, shall, upon any adjudication of foreclosure, order, without appraisal
and without sale, that the fee simple title of the Property be transferred to and vested in an electing
subdivision as defined in division (A) of section 5722.01. Further, upon the filing for journalization
of the decree of foreclosure, without an appraisal or sale and shall constitute confirmation of the
transfer and thereby terminate any further statutory or common law right of redemption.
15. In the alternative, Plaintiff elects to invoke the alternative redemption period set
forth in R.C. §323.78, and notice is hereby given that if a municipal corporation, township, county,
school district, community development organization, or county land reutilization corporation has
requested title to the parcel, then upon adjudication of foreclosure of the property, the court shall
order, that the equity of redemption and any statutory or common law right of redemption in the
property by its owner shall be forever terminated after the expiration of the alternative redemption
period and that the property shall be transferred by deed directly to the requesting municipal
corporation, township, county, school district, community development corporation, or county
land reutilization corporation without appraisal and without a sale, free and clear of all impositions
and any other liens on the property, which shall be deemed forever satisfied and discharged.
16. In the alternative, because the property is nonproductive land, in the event that the
property is not directly transferred pursuant to R.C. 323.78, if an electing subdivision selects the
2024 CV 00698
property and the parcel is advertised and offered for sale at one sale, but is not sold for want of a
minimum bid, the electing subdivision that selected the nonproductive land shall be deemed to
have submitted the winning bid at such sale, and the property will be deemed sold to the electing
subdivision for no consideration other than the amounts charged under divisions (E) and (F) of
R.C. §5722.03.
17. Plaintiff further states that there is and will be due and payable, and thereby a good
and valid first lien, all taxes, assessments, penalties and interest, accruing subsequent to the
delivery to the Prosecuting Attorney of the Delinquent Land Tax Certificate by the County Auditor
and prior to the date of transfer of the property; that there is also due the sum of One Hundred
Seventy-five Dollars, ($175.00) to be taxed as costs for a Preliminary Judicial Report and the sum
of Fifty Dollars, ($50.00) to be taxed as costs for a Final Judicial Report; and that there is and will
also be due the costs incurred in this proceeding as is deemed proper by the Court.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays that the property described herein be foreclosed; that the
Defendants be required to set up what, if any, interest they may have in said property, or be forever
barred from asserting the same; that upon determination of the amount due for taxes, assessments,
penalties, interest, and charges to date of sale or transfer, the Court will order said property to be
directly conveyed to a municipal corporation, township, county, school district, community
development organization, or county land reutilization corporation or sold by the Sheriff of this
county in accord with the statutes of the State of Ohio; that unless the amount found due the
Plaintiff together with all costs of this proceeding be tendered to the Plaintiff prior to the
conveyance or confirmation of sale, or by the expiration of the alternative right of redemption then
the equity of redemption of said parties shall be foreclosed; that in the event the property is ordered
2024 CV 00698
sold the impositions due and owing on the property be declared a valid first and prior lien upon
the property and that the impositions and costs be paid first from the proceeds of the sale.
Respectfully Submitted
GINA DEGENOVA, Prosecutor of
Mahoning County, Ohio
/s/ Thomas N. Michaels
Thomas N. Michaels (0067820)
Karen Markulin Gaglione (0059616)
Assistant Prosecuting Attorneys
Attorneys for Plaintiff
21 W. Boardman Street, 6" Floor
Youngstown, OH 44503
330-740-2330 (Telephone)
330-740-2366 (Fax)
tmichaels@mahoningcountyoh.gov
2024 CV 00698
Men,
Preliminary Judicial Report
4 First American Title”
ISSUED BY
First American Title Insurance Company
Judicial Report REPORT NUMBER
5007339-0059290e
Guaranteed Party Name: Mahoning County Prosecutor File No.: WJ-24-00134
Guaranteed Party Address: 21 West Boardman Street, 6th Floor Effective Date: March 8, 2024
City, State, Zip: Youngstown, OH 44503
Pursuant to your request for a Preliminary Judicial Report (hereinafter "the Report") for use in judicial proceedings, FIRST
AMERICAN TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY (Hereinafter "the Company”) hereby guarantees in an amount not to exceed
$25,000.00 that it has examined in the public records in Mahoning County, Ohio as to the land described in Schedule A
that the record title to the land is at the date hereof vested in Lorenzo Roller by instrument recorded in Deed Volume 545,
Page 220 and free from all encumbrances, liens or defects of record, except as shown in Schedule B.
This is a guarantee of the record title only and is made for the use and benefit of the Guaranteed Party and the purchaser
at judicial sale thereunder and is subject to the Exclusions from Coverage, the Exceptions contained in Schedule B and
the Conditions and Stipulations contained herein.
This Report shall not be binding or valid until it has been signed by either an authorized agent or representative of the
Company and Schedules A and B have been attached hereto.
Issuing Agent: Western Reserve Title & Escrow, Inc.
Agent Account No.: 10238053
Address: 725 Boardman-Canfield Rd. Bid. Q
City, State, Zip: Boardman, OH 44512
Telephone: (330)758-3650
in Witness Whereof, First American Title Insurance Company has caused its corporate name to be hereunto affixed by its
authorized officers as of Date of Policy shown in Schedule A.
First American Title Insurance Company
Dunyf
Mbox
DennisJ. Gilmore
President
Jeffrey S. Robinson
Secretary
ae
Western Reserve Title & Escrow, Inc.
a This jacket was created electronically and constitutes an original
Daryl J. Kirtley, Authorized Signatory document
A
Form 6007339 (7-1-14) Page 1 of 2 | Preliminary Judicial Report (4-15-10)
2024 CV 00698 Ohio
CONDITIONS AND STIPULATIONS OF THIS PRELIMINARY JUDICIAL REPORT
Definition of Terms. ‘of other compensation for a matter covered by this Repo or
(8) “Guaranteed Party The party or parties named herein actual notice someone cigims an interest in the Land covere
‘or the purchaser at judicial sale. by this Report.
{d) “Guaranteed Claimant’. Guaranteed Party claiming loss Extent of Liability
or damage hereunder. The lability of the Company shall in no case exoged in gi the
iQ ‘Land’. The land described spectically or by reference in amount stated herein and shail in si cases be limite:
Schedule A, and improvements affixed thereto, which by actual 103s, including but not limited to attorneys fees
law constitute real property; provided however the term costs of defense, only of the Guaranteed Party. Any and 3)
“and” does not include any property beyond the lines of payments under this Report shail reduce the amount cf this
the area specifically described or referred to in Schedule Report pro tanto and the Company's liability shail terminate
A, for any right, title, interest, estate, or easement in when the total amount of the Report has been paid.
abutting streets, toads, avenues, lanes, ways or Optionsto Pay or Otherwise Settle Claims; Termination of
waterways. Liability
) ‘Public Records’: Those records under state statute and, The Company in its sole discretion shall nave the folowing
if 3 United States District Court resides in the county in options:
which the Land Is situated, the records of the clerk of the fa) To pay or tender to the Guaranteed Claimant the 3 if
United States District Court, which impart constructive of the Report or the balance remaining thereof, ie any
notice of matters relating to real property to purchasers attorneys fees, costs or expenses paid by the Company
for value without knowledge and which are required to be to the date of tender. If this option & exercised
maintained in certain public offices in the county in which lisbilty of the Company under this Report termin:
the land is situated. including but not limited to any labiity fer. attern: 3 fees.
Determination of Liability ot any costs of defense or prosecution of any iitig
This Report together with any Final Judicial Report or any ib) To pay or otherwise settle with other parties for in the
Supplement or Endorsement thereof, issued by the Company name of the Guaranteed Claimant any claims guaranteed
is the entire contract between the Guaranteed Party and the by this Report.
Company. i} To continue, re-open or initiate any judicial proceeding in
Any claim of monetary loss or damage, whether or not based order to adjudicate any claim covered oy this Report
on negligence, and which arises out of the status of the title to The Company shall have the right to select coun: ts
the estaie or interest guaranteed hereby or any action choice (subject to the right of the Guaranteed ©:
asserting such claim, shail be restricted to this Report. object for reasonable cause) to. represent the
Liability of Company Guaranteed Claimant and will not pay the fees of
This Report is a guarantee of the tecord title of the Land only, other counsel,
as disclosed by an examination of the Public Records herein ig) To pay or tender to the Guarsnteed Cisimant the
defined, difference between the value of the estate or interest 33
Notice of Ciaim to be given by Guaranteed Claimant guaranteed and the value of the estate or interest su
in case knowledge shail come to the Guaranteed Party of any to the defect, len or encumbrance guaranteed agai
lien, encumbrance, defect, or other claim of tite guaranteed this Report.
against and not excepted in this Report, whether in a legal 7. Notices
proceeding or otherwise, the Guaranteed Party shall notify the All notices required to be given to the Company shall be 9)
Company within a teasonabie time in writing and secure to the promptly and any statements in writing required to be
Company the right to oppose such proceeding or clsim, or to furnished to the Company shal be addressed te First
temove said lien, encumbrance or defect at as own cost. Any American Title insurance Company, Attn: Claims National
action for the payment of any loss under this Report must be Intake Center, 1 First American Way, Santa Ana.
commenced within one year after the Guaranteed Party California 92707. Phone 888-632-1642
receives actual notice that they may be required to pay money
EXCLUSIONS FROM COVERAGE
The Company assumes no liability under this Report for any 42 The Company assumes no lisbilty under this Report f the
loss, cost or damage resulting from any physica! condition of proper form or execution of any pleadings or other doz 8
the Land. to be filed in any judicia! proceedings.
The Company assumes no fiabilty under this Report for any 5 The Company assumes no liability under this Report for an
Joss, cost or damage resulting from any typographical, clerical loss, cost, or damage resulting from the failure to coy
of other errorsin the Public Records. serve on any parties shown in Schedule B of the Preliminary
The Company assumes no fisbilty under the Report for Judicial Report and the Final Judicial Report or any
matters affecting title subsequent to the date of this Report or ‘Supplemental Report issued thereto.
the Final Judicial report or any supplement thereto.
Form 5007339 (7-1-14) Page 2 of 2 Preliminary Judicial Report (4-15-10)
2024 CV 00698 Ohio
+ AMER,
4 Preliminary Judicial Report
First American Title™ ne
ISSUED BY
First American Title Insurance Company
Schedule A
REPORT NUMBER
5007339-0059290e
File No.: WJ-24-00134
DESCRIPTION OF THE LAND
Situated in the City of Youngstown, County of Mahoning, and State of Ohio
And known as City Lot Number Forty-six Thousand Three Hundred Seventy-four (46374) as Lots are now numbered in
said City, and formerly known as Lot Number Fifteen (15) of the Mason Jacobs Sub-division, Plat of which is recorded in
Volume 14 of Maps, at Page 213, Mahoning County Records.
Said City Lot Number Forty-six Thousand Three Hundred Seventy-four (46374) fronts Fifty (50) feet on the South line of
Miltonia Avenue, and extends back of even width, a distance of One Hundred Fifty (150) feet.
Parcel Number(s): 53-221-0-068.00-0
Legal description derived from Deed Volume 545 , Page 220 Mahoning County records.
The property address and tax parcel identification number listed herein are provided solely for informational purposes,
without warranty as to accuracy or compieteness.
Property Address: 3115 Miltonia Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44505
Form 5007339-A (9-1-14) Page 1 of 1 Preliminary Judicial Report (4-15-10)
Ohio - Schedule A
2024 CV 00698
etme,
+ Preliminary Judicial Report
First American Title”
ISSUED BY
First American Title Insurance Company
Schedule B
REPORT NUMBER
5007339-0059290e
File No.: WJ-24-00134
EXCEPTIONS
The matters shown below are exceptions to this Preliminary Judicial Report and the Company assumes no liability arising
therefrom.
Easements, restrictions, setback lines, declarations, conditions, covenants, reservations and rights-of-way, if any
that were filed for record prior to the lien being foreclosed.
NOTE: A search for uncertified special tax assessments has not been performed.
"NOTE": Delinquent sewer bills, water bills, charges for weed cutting, cleaning up trash and other nuisance
abatement charges, zoning or code violations that may become a lien on the real estate. No liability is assumed by
the Company for ascertaining the status of these charges. The proposed insured is cautioned to obtain the current
status of these charges if any.
PPN: 53-221-0-068.00-0
DELINQUENT: $173.56
Taxes for the first half of 2023 in the amount of $2.91 are not paid.
Taxes for the last half of 2023 in the amount of $2.91 are a lien but not yet due and payable.
Taxes for the year 2024 are a lien but not yet due and payable.
No examination has been made for special assessments not appearing on the Treasurer's current tax duplicate.
INSURANCE FRAUD WARNING: ANY PERSON WHO, WITH INTENT TO DEFRAUD OR KNOWING THAT HE.
IS FACILITATING A FRAUD AGAINST AN INSURER, SUBMITS AN APPLICATION OR FILES A CLAIM
CONTAINING A FALSE OR DECEPTIVE STATEMENT IS GUILTY OF INSURANCE FRAUD.
Form 5007339-B (9-1-14} Page 1 of 1 Preliminary Judicial Report (4-15-10)
Ohio - Schedule B
2024 CV 00698
3/25/2024 DELINQUENT LAND CERTIFICATE
YEAR 2024 Mahoning COUNTY, OHIO
CERT NO. 0
YOUNGSTOWN CITY YOUNGSTOWN C PARCEL NO. 53-221-0-068.00-0
TO THE COUNTY PROSECUTOR,
( HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THE TAXES, ASSESSMENTS, AND PENALTIES UPON THE TRACT OF LAND,
CITY OR TOWN LOT CERTIFIED DELINQUENT FOR THE NON-PAYMENT OF TAXES, SITUATED IN THE
TAXING DISTRICT OF YOUNGSTOWN CITY YOUNGSTOWN CSD, ENTERED ON THE CURRENT TAX LIST IN
THE NAME OF ROLLER LORENZO WHOSE TAX MAILING NAME/ADDRESS iS:
ROLLER LORENZO 3115 MILTONIA AVE YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44505
AND SAID REAL PROPERTY IS DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS, TO WIT:
DESCRIPTION: LOT 46374
FRONT FT: 0.00 STREET: 3115 MILTONIA AVE FEET DEEP: 0.00 ACRES: 0.17
HAVE NOT BEEN PAID FOR A PERIOD OF ONE YEAR AND SAID TRACT OF LAND, CITY OR TOWN LOTIS
NOW CERTIFIED DELINQUENT AND PLACED ON THE LIST OF DELINQUENT LANDS, AND THAT TAXES,
ASSESSMENTS, AND PENALTIES AMOUNT TO $173.36.
Ralph T. Meacham, CPA
COUNTY AUDITOR
360 LAND VALUE
BUILDING VALUE
350 TOTAL VALUE
5.82 CURRENT YEAR DELQ TAX
0,00 FIRST HALF PENALTY
0.00 SECOND HALF PENALTY
46.33 INTEREST
127.03 PRIOR YEAR DELQ TAX
9.00 PRIOR YEAR DELQ SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS
DATE CERTIFIED: 2007 PROSECUTOR:
DATE ADVERTISED: 2010 REV. CODE SEC. $721.13
a Ft
aa 88
2024 CV 00698
[hereby certify that is a true and exact copy of the original Delinquent Land Certificate delivered
to the Mahoning County Prosecutor’s Office as kept in the records of the Mahoning County
Anditor’s Office.
Ralph T. Meacham, Mahoning County Auditor
xh. 4 Ce
By (Ap oroF irsctor of Taxation
Date
_akfz
2024 CV 00698
AUDITOR'S TAX LIST AND TREASURER'S DUPLICATE OF REAL PROPERTY 12288
YOUNGSTOWN CITY YOUNGSTOWN CSD - TAX DISTRICT 53 FULL RATE 80,3300 FOR TAX YEAR 2023 Mahoning AGRIRES 0.334487 INDICOM 0.105343,
PARCEL. CREE RGRES Neighborhood "ABIUSTMENTS ‘DECEMBER ABIOSTHENTS TORE “ABIUSTMENTS. BARE PRD ReMARRS
‘MAP NUMBER DELINQUENCIES: 0 De "EMBER TAX TO dh
ROUTING NUMBER PROPERTY DESCRIPTION womesTEAD} DELINOUENCIES: TAK
LENDER CODE LOT No, REDUGT
NAME AND ADDRESS, BAND, BUILOING. TOTAL CALE
53-221-0-087.00-0 Res 510 0.17200 83000 470.68 0.00 40.18 9.00 140.18 9.00 CHG 2902937
LOT 49378 0.00 00 B81 0.00 8.00 gue
Lender: 205 Lot 46375 0.00 0.00 8.90 0.00 Bat BC
MILTONA 0:00 0.00 0.00
NAZE Wi IAMS LUCRETIA 0.09 0.00 0.00 00 OM
622 MISTL 470.68 0.00 8.50 9.00 8.00 0.00 cH
UNSSTOWN OH 44511 9.00 84.48 8.00 9.00 NET
000 3,490 0.00 0.00 9.00 0.00 0.09
CERT DEL 2019 9:00 0.00
. weeneee 0.00 PEN
3.00 3.80 PD
83-221-0-087,00-0 37 GENCY Gt
a=. 554,58 84.48. -
0.90 CH
1h 9.00 9.00 0.00 0.09 INT
wo o 0.00 o EN
-
0.00 6.00 0.09 0.00 9.00 9,00 BD
43.98 448. 5.48,
‘0.06 0.00 ed 005
568.58 86.96 85.98 BAL 740.48
69-221-0-088.00-0 Res 500 0.17200 63000 109.98 0.00 482 9.00 9,00 CHS hise2a38
0.00 181 6.00 16t RE
Lor asare 9.00 0.90 0.30 9.00 0.30 900 Nec
Lander 0 Let 48974 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
LER Li iaSONA 0.00 0.00 9.00
SUS MILTON EN 9.00 6.99 0.00
9.00 6.09 HOM
8:00 CHI
YOUNGSTOWN Gl 4asos 408.96 231 0.00 294 8.00 Ner
120 2.00 60 9.00 8.00 INF
CERT DEL 2007 ae 97 . 6.00 o - - -
8.00 6.99 0.90 0.00 9.00 0.00 eo
173.36, 231 291 BAL
0.00 0.06 0.00" PD 0.65
173,36 291 2.91 BAL 173.48
53-221-0-069,00-0 Res 500 0.17200 S300 108.96 9.00 4,82 0.00 4.82 9.00 HG 1902939
61 0.00 181 0.0 CRE
LOT 48973, 0.00 9,00 O30 0.00 0.00
Lender: 400 Lot 46973 50x 150 9.00 908 00 0.00 9.00
MOORE MILDRED C & MILTONA 0.00 6.05 9.00 9.00 9.00 8.00 HOM
WILLIAMS 0.00 8.00 9.00 0.00
HHooRe mDRED 6 ‘00 291 0.00 294 0.00 NET
120 ‘00 0,09 boo
YOUNGSTOWN OH Aasot CERT DEL 2007 2.00 6.00
oe - wane -0.00 PEN
=
6.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 PD
473.36. 294 2.94
0.00 0.06 0.00 PD
473.38 2.91 291 BAL 479.18
53-221-0-070,00-0 Res 0.17200 63000 100.98 9.09 0.00 9.00 1902940
0.00 0.00 181 0.00 481 0.00 CRE
LOT aggre 9.30 0.00 Nec
Lot 48372 9.00 8.00 O00 0.00 9.00
MOORE MILDRED O& cron 0.00 8.00 9.00 9.00 HOM
WILUA LE 6.00 0.09 8.00
MOORE MILDRED C 108.98 0.00 291 2ot 9.00 NET
120 120 46.33 G00 2.00
CLEVELAND OH 44501, CERT DEL 2007 - 77 6.00 6.00 0.00 0°00 PEN
- - -
0.00 0.00 9.00 0.00 PD
573.36. 29 91
‘0.00 6.00 PD oae
473.38 291 284 BAL 179.48
83-221-0-07 1.00-0 Res 510 0.17200 63000 2.00 175.52 2.00 175.52 0.0 CHE 2902841
0.00 0.00 0,00 9.00 RE
OT 46371 .00 403 0.00 44.03 9.00
Lot 4Ba71 6.00 9.00 0.00 0.00
TATE ANDERSON uR MILTONA 0.00 0.00 0.99 9.00 9.09 HOM
268 0.00 9.00 8.00
UPEALO NY 14514 0.00 106. ceeeee 405.78
480 3,880 4370 -
8.00 0.00 9.00 0.08 0.00 0.00 PD
58+221-0-071,00-0 - ‘TORT EMERGENCY $17 a wane ¢ 05, --
6.00 ‘etd
ewe - 1.48 5.00 iS
a oe
9.00 0.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00
3.48 4.48, BAL
0.00 0.00 eb 8.00
9.00 107.26 407.5 BAL 214.52
g ag ae ea
aee 8 2024 CV 00698
ey it g
: i i}
isB &
2
I hereby certify that is a true and exact copy of the original page 12288 for the City of Youngstown,
Youngstown City School District parcels on the Auditor’s Tax List and Duplicate of Real Property,
as kept in the records of the Mahoning County Auditor’s Office.
Ralph T. Meacham, Mahoning County Auditor
~
phYouid ¢oa, Director of Taxation
Date Shela _———
2024 CV 00698
Preview
Daniel Da: EL CTRO} IN eat YF pr ee - MAHONING ¢ c COURT IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS MAHONING COUNTY, OHIO DANIEL R. YEMMA, AS TREASURER _ ) CASE NO. OF MAHONING COUNTY, OHIO ) Mahoning County Courthouse JUDGE 120 Market Street Youngstown, OH 44503 COMPLAINT FOR COLLECTION OF DELINQUENT TAXES, ASSESSMENTS PLAINTIFF PENALTIES AND INTEREST FORECLOSURE AND EQUITABLE -vs- RELIEF UNKNOWN SURVIVING SPOUSE, PARCEL NUMBER 53-221-0-068.00-0 NEXT OF KIN, DEVISEES, LEGATEES, EXECUTORS, ADMINISTRATORS, AND PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVES, IF ANY OF LORENZO ROLLER, DECEASED Address unknown DEFENDANT Now comes Plaintiff Mahoning County Treasurer Daniel R. Yemma, by and through undersigned counsel and for his cause of action against the Defendants, state accordingly: 1 Plaintiff is the Treasurer of Mahoning County, Ohio and brings this action in his capacity as Mahoning County Treasurer. 2. This action is brought pursuant to R.C. §323.25 and/or §5721.18 of the Ohio Revised Code. 3 The Preliminary Judicial Report prepared in contemplation of this action is attached hereto as Exhibit A in compliance with Rule 13 of the Mahoning County Local Rules of Practice and Procedure. 4 A Master List of Delinquent Vacant Tracts and/or Delinquent Land Tax Certificate has been duly certified by the County Auditor of Mahoning County, Ohio and delivered to the 2024 CV 00698 County Prosecutor of Mahoning County, Ohio for Parcel Number 53-22 1-0-068.00-0, Miltonia Avenue, vacant Lot No. 46374, Youngstown, OH (the “Property”) 5 That more than sixty days has passed since the Mahoning County Auditor delivered a delinquent land duplicate to the Plaintiff regarding the Property. 6. That the real property taxes owed on Parcel Number 53-221-0-068.00-0 were certified delinquent in 2007 and advertised delinquent in 2010. 7. A certified copy of the Delinquent Land Certificate for Parcel Number 53-221-0- 068.00-0 is attached hereto as Exhibit 1 and is incorporated herein. 8 A certified copy of the Auditor’s Tax List and Treasurer’s Duplicate of Real Property for Parcel Number 53-221-0-068.00-0 is attached hereto as Exhibit 2 and is incorporated herein. 9 That more than one year has passed since the taxes on the Property were certified delinquent and the taxes remain unpaid. 10. That the amount of taxes, assessments, charges, penalties and interest (hereinafter referred to as “Impositions”) which remain due and unpaid on the Property are $176.27 and is a first and best lien against said Property which is more fully described in the attached Preliminary Judicial Report (Exhibit A). ll. Plaintiff further says that Defendant Unknown Surviving Spouse, Next of Kin, Devisees, Legatees, Executors, Administrators, and Personal Representatives, if any of Lorenzo Roller, Deceased has or may claim to have some interest in or claim upon the Property, but Plaintiff not being fully advised as to the extent, if any, of such interest or claim, prays that said Defendant be required to set up its interest or claim or be forever barred from asserting same against the within described Property. 2024 CV 00698 12. The Property is delinquent vacant lands as that term is defined in R.C. §5721.01 and/or abandoned lands as that term is defined in R.C. §325.65 and/or nonproductive land as that term is defined in R.C. §5722.01. 13. Plaintiff states that the value of the taxes, assessments, penalties, interest, and all other charges and costs of the action exceed the auditor's fair market value of the Property. 14, Therefore, in accordance with R.C. §323.28 (E) and/or R.C. §5721.19 (1), plaintiff, or on the court's own motion, shall, upon any adjudication of foreclosure, order, without appraisal and without sale, that the fee simple title of the Property be transferred to and vested in an electing subdivision as defined in division (A) of section 5722.01. Further, upon the filing for journalization of the decree of foreclosure, without an appraisal or sale and shall constitute confirmation of the transfer and thereby terminate any further statutory or common law right of redemption. 15. In the alternative, Plaintiff elects to invoke the alternative redemption period set forth in R.C. §323.78, and notice is hereby given that if a municipal corporation, township, county, school district, community development organization, or county land reutilization corporation has requested title to the parcel, then upon adjudication of foreclosure of the property, the court shall order, that the equity of redemption and any statutory or common law right of redemption in the property by its owner shall be forever terminated after the expiration of the alternative redemption period and that the property shall be transferred by deed directly to the requesting municipal corporation, township, county, school district, community development corporation, or county land reutilization corporation without appraisal and without a sale, free and clear of all impositions and any other liens on the property, which shall be deemed forever satisfied and discharged. 16. In the alternative, because the property is nonproductive land, in the event that the property is not directly transferred pursuant to R.C. 323.78, if an electing subdivision selects the 2024 CV 00698 property and the parcel is advertised and offered for sale at one sale, but is not sold for want of a minimum bid, the electing subdivision that selected the nonproductive land shall be deemed to have submitted the winning bid at such sale, and the property will be deemed sold to the electing subdivision for no consideration other than the amounts charged under divisions (E) and (F) of R.C. §5722.03. 17. Plaintiff further states that there is and will be due and payable, and thereby a good and valid first lien, all taxes, assessments, penalties and interest, accruing subsequent to the delivery to the Prosecuting Attorney of the Delinquent Land Tax Certificate by the County Auditor and prior to the date of transfer of the property; that there is also due the sum of One Hundred Seventy-five Dollars, ($175.00) to be taxed as costs for a Preliminary Judicial Report and the sum of Fifty Dollars, ($50.00) to be taxed as costs for a Final Judicial Report; and that there is and will also be due the costs incurred in this proceeding as is deemed proper by the Court. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays that the property described herein be foreclosed; that the Defendants be required to set up what, if any, interest they may have in said property, or be forever barred from asserting the same; that upon determination of the amount due for taxes, assessments, penalties, interest, and charges to date of sale or transfer, the Court will order said property to be directly conveyed to a municipal corporation, township, county, school district, community development organization, or county land reutilization corporation or sold by the Sheriff of this county in accord with the statutes of the State of Ohio; that unless the amount found due the Plaintiff together with all costs of this proceeding be tendered to the Plaintiff prior to the conveyance or confirmation of sale, or by the expiration of the alternative right of redemption then the equity of redemption of said parties shall be foreclosed; that in the event the property is ordered 2024 CV 00698 sold the impositions due and owing on the property be declared a valid first and prior lien upon the property and that the impositions and costs be paid first from the proceeds of the sale. Respectfully Submitted GINA DEGENOVA, Prosecutor of Mahoning County, Ohio /s/ Thomas N. Michaels Thomas N. Michaels (0067820) Karen Markulin Gaglione (0059616) Assistant Prosecuting Attorneys Attorneys for Plaintiff 21 W. Boardman Street, 6" Floor Youngstown, OH 44503 330-740-2330 (Telephone) 330-740-2366 (Fax) tmichaels@mahoningcountyoh.gov 2024 CV 00698 Men, Preliminary Judicial Report 4 First American Title” ISSUED BY First American Title Insurance Company Judicial Report REPORT NUMBER 5007339-0059290e Guaranteed Party Name: Mahoning County Prosecutor File No.: WJ-24-00134 Guaranteed Party Address: 21 West Boardman Street, 6th Floor Effective Date: March 8, 2024 City, State, Zip: Youngstown, OH 44503 Pursuant to your request for a Preliminary Judicial Report (hereinafter "the Report") for use in judicial proceedings, FIRST AMERICAN TITLE INSURANCE COMPANY (Hereinafter "the Company”) hereby guarantees in an amount not to exceed $25,000.00 that it has examined in the public records in Mahoning County, Ohio as to the land described in Schedule A that the record title to the land is at the date hereof vested in Lorenzo Roller by instrument recorded in Deed Volume 545, Page 220 and free from all encumbrances, liens or defects of record, except as shown in Schedule B. This is a guarantee of the record title only and is made for the use and benefit of the Guaranteed Party and the purchaser at judicial sale thereunder and is subject to the Exclusions from Coverage, the Exceptions contained in Schedule B and the Conditions and Stipulations contained herein. This Report shall not be binding or valid until it has been signed by either an authorized agent or representative of the Company and Schedules A and B have been attached hereto. Issuing Agent: Western Reserve Title & Escrow, Inc. Agent Account No.: 10238053 Address: 725 Boardman-Canfield Rd. Bid. Q City, State, Zip: Boardman, OH 44512 Telephone: (330)758-3650 in Witness Whereof, First American Title Insurance Company has caused its corporate name to be hereunto affixed by its authorized officers as of Date of Policy shown in Schedule A. First American Title Insurance Company Dunyf Mbox DennisJ. Gilmore President Jeffrey S. Robinson Secretary ae Western Reserve Title & Escrow, Inc. a This jacket was created electronically and constitutes an original Daryl J. Kirtley, Authorized Signatory document A Form 6007339 (7-1-14) Page 1 of 2 | Preliminary Judicial Report (4-15-10) 2024 CV 00698 Ohio CONDITIONS AND STIPULATIONS OF THIS PRELIMINARY JUDICIAL REPORT Definition of Terms. ‘of other compensation for a matter covered by this Repo or (8) “Guaranteed Party The party or parties named herein actual notice someone cigims an interest in the Land covere ‘or the purchaser at judicial sale. by this Report. {d) “Guaranteed Claimant’. Guaranteed Party claiming loss Extent of Liability or damage hereunder. The lability of the Company shall in no case exoged in gi the iQ ‘Land’. The land described spectically or by reference in amount stated herein and shail in si cases be limite: Schedule A, and improvements affixed thereto, which by actual 103s, including but not limited to attorneys fees law constitute real property; provided however the term costs of defense, only of the Guaranteed Party. Any and 3) “and” does not include any property beyond the lines of payments under this Report shail reduce the amount cf this the area specifically described or referred to in Schedule Report pro tanto and the Company's liability shail terminate A, for any right, title, interest, estate, or easement in when the total amount of the Report has been paid. abutting streets, toads, avenues, lanes, ways or Optionsto Pay or Otherwise Settle Claims; Termination of waterways. Liability ) ‘Public Records’: Those records under state statute and, The Company in its sole discretion shall nave the folowing if 3 United States District Court resides in the county in options: which the Land Is situated, the records of the clerk of the fa) To pay or tender to the Guaranteed Claimant the 3 if United States District Court, which impart constructive of the Report or the balance remaining thereof, ie any notice of matters relating to real property to purchasers attorneys fees, costs or expenses paid by the Company for value without knowledge and which are required to be to the date of tender. If this option & exercised maintained in certain public offices in the county in which lisbilty of the Company under this Report termin: the land is situated. including but not limited to any labiity fer. attern: 3 fees. Determination of Liability ot any costs of defense or prosecution of any iitig This Report together with any Final Judicial Report or any ib) To pay or otherwise settle with other parties for in the Supplement or Endorsement thereof, issued by the Company name of the Guaranteed Claimant any claims guaranteed is the entire contract between the Guaranteed Party and the by this Report. Company. i} To continue, re-open or initiate any judicial proceeding in Any claim of monetary loss or damage, whether or not based order to adjudicate any claim covered oy this Report on negligence, and which arises out of the status of the title to The Company shall have the right to select coun: ts the estaie or interest guaranteed hereby or any action choice (subject to the right of the Guaranteed ©: asserting such claim, shail be restricted to this Report. object for reasonable cause) to. represent the Liability of Company Guaranteed Claimant and will not pay the fees of This Report is a guarantee of the tecord title of the Land only, other counsel, as disclosed by an examination of the Public Records herein ig) To pay or tender to the Guarsnteed Cisimant the defined, difference between the value of the estate or interest 33 Notice of Ciaim to be given by Guaranteed Claimant guaranteed and the value of the estate or interest su in case knowledge shail come to the Guaranteed Party of any to the defect, len or encumbrance guaranteed agai lien, encumbrance, defect, or other claim of tite guaranteed this Report. against and not excepted in this Report, whether in a legal 7. Notices proceeding or otherwise, the Guaranteed Party shall notify the All notices required to be given to the Company shall be 9) Company within a teasonabie time in writing and secure to the promptly and any statements in writing required to be Company the right to oppose such proceeding or clsim, or to furnished to the Company shal be addressed te First temove said lien, encumbrance or defect at as own cost. Any American Title insurance Company, Attn: Claims National action for the payment of any loss under this Report must be Intake Center, 1 First American Way, Santa Ana. commenced within one year after the Guaranteed Party California 92707. Phone 888-632-1642 receives actual notice that they may be required to pay money EXCLUSIONS FROM COVERAGE The Company assumes no liability under this Report for any 42 The Company assumes no lisbilty under this Report f the loss, cost or damage resulting from any physica! condition of proper form or execution of any pleadings or other doz 8 the Land. to be filed in any judicia! proceedings. The Company assumes no fiabilty under this Report for any 5 The Company assumes no liability under this Report for an Joss, cost or damage resulting from any typographical, clerical loss, cost, or damage resulting from the failure to coy of other errorsin the Public Records. serve on any parties shown in Schedule B of the Preliminary The Company assumes no fisbilty under the Report for Judicial Report and the Final Judicial Report or any matters affecting title subsequent to the date of this Report or ‘Supplemental Report issued thereto. the Final Judicial report or any supplement thereto. Form 5007339 (7-1-14) Page 2 of 2 Preliminary Judicial Report (4-15-10) 2024 CV 00698 Ohio + AMER, 4 Preliminary Judicial Report First American Title™ ne ISSUED BY First American Title Insurance Company Schedule A REPORT NUMBER 5007339-0059290e File No.: WJ-24-00134 DESCRIPTION OF THE LAND Situated in the City of Youngstown, County of Mahoning, and State of Ohio And known as City Lot Number Forty-six Thousand Three Hundred Seventy-four (46374) as Lots are now numbered in said City, and formerly known as Lot Number Fifteen (15) of the Mason Jacobs Sub-division, Plat of which is recorded in Volume 14 of Maps, at Page 213, Mahoning County Records. Said City Lot Number Forty-six Thousand Three Hundred Seventy-four (46374) fronts Fifty (50) feet on the South line of Miltonia Avenue, and extends back of even width, a distance of One Hundred Fifty (150) feet. Parcel Number(s): 53-221-0-068.00-0 Legal description derived from Deed Volume 545 , Page 220 Mahoning County records. The property address and tax parcel identification number listed herein are provided solely for informational purposes, without warranty as to accuracy or compieteness. Property Address: 3115 Miltonia Avenue, Youngstown, OH 44505 Form 5007339-A (9-1-14) Page 1 of 1 Preliminary Judicial Report (4-15-10) Ohio - Schedule A 2024 CV 00698 etme, + Preliminary Judicial Report First American Title” ISSUED BY First American Title Insurance Company Schedule B REPORT NUMBER 5007339-0059290e File No.: WJ-24-00134 EXCEPTIONS The matters shown below are exceptions to this Preliminary Judicial Report and the Company assumes no liability arising therefrom. Easements, restrictions, setback lines, declarations, conditions, covenants, reservations and rights-of-way, if any that were filed for record prior to the lien being foreclosed. NOTE: A search for uncertified special tax assessments has not been performed. "NOTE": Delinquent sewer bills, water bills, charges for weed cutting, cleaning up trash and other nuisance abatement charges, zoning or code violations that may become a lien on the real estate. No liability is assumed by the Company for ascertaining the status of these charges. The proposed insured is cautioned to obtain the current status of these charges if any. PPN: 53-221-0-068.00-0 DELINQUENT: $173.56 Taxes for the first half of 2023 in the amount of $2.91 are not paid. Taxes for the last half of 2023 in the amount of $2.91 are a lien but not yet due and payable. Taxes for the year 2024 are a lien but not yet due and payable. No examination has been made for special assessments not appearing on the Treasurer's current tax duplicate. INSURANCE FRAUD WARNING: ANY PERSON WHO, WITH INTENT TO DEFRAUD OR KNOWING THAT HE. IS FACILITATING A FRAUD AGAINST AN INSURER, SUBMITS AN APPLICATION OR FILES A CLAIM CONTAINING A FALSE OR DECEPTIVE STATEMENT IS GUILTY OF INSURANCE FRAUD. Form 5007339-B (9-1-14} Page 1 of 1 Preliminary Judicial Report (4-15-10) Ohio - Schedule B 2024 CV 00698 3/25/2024 DELINQUENT LAND CERTIFICATE YEAR 2024 Mahoning COUNTY, OHIO CERT NO. 0 YOUNGSTOWN CITY YOUNGSTOWN C PARCEL NO. 53-221-0-068.00-0 TO THE COUNTY PROSECUTOR, ( HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THE TAXES, ASSESSMENTS, AND PENALTIES UPON THE TRACT OF LAND, CITY OR TOWN LOT CERTIFIED DELINQUENT FOR THE NON-PAYMENT OF TAXES, SITUATED IN THE TAXING DISTRICT OF YOUNGSTOWN CITY YOUNGSTOWN CSD, ENTERED ON THE CURRENT TAX LIST IN THE NAME OF ROLLER LORENZO WHOSE TAX MAILING NAME/ADDRESS iS: ROLLER LORENZO 3115 MILTONIA AVE YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44505 AND SAID REAL PROPERTY IS DESCRIBED AS FOLLOWS, TO WIT: DESCRIPTION: LOT 46374 FRONT FT: 0.00 STREET: 3115 MILTONIA AVE FEET DEEP: 0.00 ACRES: 0.17 HAVE NOT BEEN PAID FOR A PERIOD OF ONE YEAR AND SAID TRACT OF LAND, CITY OR TOWN LOTIS NOW CERTIFIED DELINQUENT AND PLACED ON THE LIST OF DELINQUENT LANDS, AND THAT TAXES, ASSESSMENTS, AND PENALTIES AMOUNT TO $173.36. Ralph T. Meacham, CPA COUNTY AUDITOR 360 LAND VALUE BUILDING VALUE 350 TOTAL VALUE 5.82 CURRENT YEAR DELQ TAX 0,00 FIRST HALF PENALTY 0.00 SECOND HALF PENALTY 46.33 INTEREST 127.03 PRIOR YEAR DELQ TAX 9.00 PRIOR YEAR DELQ SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS DATE CERTIFIED: 2007 PROSECUTOR: DATE ADVERTISED: 2010 REV. CODE SEC. $721.13 a Ft aa 88 2024 CV 00698 [hereby certify that is a true and exact copy of the original Delinquent Land Certificate delivered to the Mahoning County Prosecutor’s Office as kept in the records of the Mahoning County Anditor’s Office. Ralph T. Meacham, Mahoning County Auditor xh. 4 Ce By (Ap oroF irsctor of Taxation Date _akfz 2024 CV 00698 AUDITOR'S TAX LIST AND TREASURER'S DUPLICATE OF REAL PROPERTY 12288 YOUNGSTOWN CITY YOUNGSTOWN CSD - TAX DISTRICT 53 FULL RATE 80,3300 FOR TAX YEAR 2023 Mahoning AGRIRES 0.334487 INDICOM 0.105343, PARCEL. CREE RGRES Neighborhood "ABIUSTMENTS ‘DECEMBER ABIOSTHENTS TORE “ABIUSTMENTS. BARE PRD ReMARRS ‘MAP NUMBER DELINQUENCIES: 0 De "EMBER TAX TO dh ROUTING NUMBER PROPERTY DESCRIPTION womesTEAD} DELINOUENCIES: TAK LENDER CODE LOT No, REDUGT NAME AND ADDRESS, BAND, BUILOING. TOTAL CALE 53-221-0-087.00-0 Res 510 0.17200 83000 470.68 0.00 40.18 9.00 140.18 9.00 CHG 2902937 LOT 49378 0.00 00 B81 0.00 8.00 gue Lender: 205 Lot 46375 0.00 0.00 8.90 0.00 Bat BC MILTONA 0:00 0.00 0.00 NAZE Wi IAMS LUCRETIA 0.09 0.00 0.00 00 OM 622 MISTL 470.68 0.00 8.50 9.00 8.00 0.00 cH UNSSTOWN OH 44511 9.00 84.48 8.00 9.00 NET 000 3,490 0.00 0.00 9.00 0.00 0.09 CERT DEL 2019 9:00 0.00 . weeneee 0.00 PEN 3.00 3.80 PD 83-221-0-087,00-0 37 GENCY Gt a=. 554,58 84.48. - 0.90 CH 1h 9.00 9.00 0.00 0.09 INT wo o 0.00 o EN - 0.00 6.00 0.09 0.00 9.00 9,00 BD 43.98 448. 5.48, ‘0.06 0.00 ed 005 568.58 86.96 85.98 BAL 740.48 69-221-0-088.00-0 Res 500 0.17200 63000 109.98 0.00 482 9.00 9,00 CHS hise2a38 0.00 181 6.00 16t RE Lor asare 9.00 0.90 0.30 9.00 0.30 900 Nec Lander 0 Let 48974 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 LER Li iaSONA 0.00 0.00 9.00 SUS MILTON EN 9.00 6.99 0.00 9.00 6.09 HOM 8:00 CHI YOUNGSTOWN Gl 4asos 408.96 231 0.00 294 8.00 Ner 120 2.00 60 9.00 8.00 INF CERT DEL 2007 ae 97 . 6.00 o - - - 8.00 6.99 0.90 0.00 9.00 0.00 eo 173.36, 231 291 BAL 0.00 0.06 0.00" PD 0.65 173,36 291 2.91 BAL 173.48 53-221-0-069,00-0 Res 500 0.17200 S300 108.96 9.00 4,82 0.00 4.82 9.00 HG 1902939 61 0.00 181 0.0 CRE LOT 48973, 0.00 9,00 O30 0.00 0.00 Lender: 400 Lot 46973 50x 150 9.00 908 00 0.00 9.00 MOORE MILDRED C & MILTONA 0.00 6.05 9.00 9.00 9.00 8.00 HOM WILLIAMS 0.00 8.00 9.00 0.00 HHooRe mDRED 6 ‘00 291 0.00 294 0.00 NET 120 ‘00 0,09 boo YOUNGSTOWN OH Aasot CERT DEL 2007 2.00 6.00 oe - wane -0.00 PEN = 6.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 PD 473.36. 294 2.94 0.00 0.06 0.00 PD 473.38 2.91 291 BAL 479.18 53-221-0-070,00-0 Res 0.17200 63000 100.98 9.09 0.00 9.00 1902940 0.00 0.00 181 0.00 481 0.00 CRE LOT aggre 9.30 0.00 Nec Lot 48372 9.00 8.00 O00 0.00 9.00 MOORE MILDRED O& cron 0.00 8.00 9.00 9.00 HOM WILUA LE 6.00 0.09 8.00 MOORE MILDRED C 108.98 0.00 291 2ot 9.00 NET 120 120 46.33 G00 2.00 CLEVELAND OH 44501, CERT DEL 2007 - 77 6.00 6.00 0.00 0°00 PEN - - - 0.00 0.00 9.00 0.00 PD 573.36. 29 91 ‘0.00 6.00 PD oae 473.38 291 284 BAL 179.48 83-221-0-07 1.00-0 Res 510 0.17200 63000 2.00 175.52 2.00 175.52 0.0 CHE 2902841 0.00 0.00 0,00 9.00 RE OT 46371 .00 403 0.00 44.03 9.00 Lot 4Ba71 6.00 9.00 0.00 0.00 TATE ANDERSON uR MILTONA 0.00 0.00 0.99 9.00 9.09 HOM 268 0.00 9.00 8.00 UPEALO NY 14514 0.00 106. ceeeee 405.78 480 3,880 4370 - 8.00 0.00 9.00 0.08 0.00 0.00 PD 58+221-0-071,00-0 - ‘TORT EMERGENCY $17 a wane ¢ 05, -- 6.00 ‘etd ewe - 1.48 5.00 iS a oe 9.00 0.00 0.00 8.00 0.00 0.00 3.48 4.48, BAL 0.00 0.00 eb 8.00 9.00 107.26 407.5 BAL 214.52 g ag ae ea aee 8 2024 CV 00698 ey it g : i i} isB & 2 I hereby certify that is a true and exact copy of the original page 12288 for the City of Youngstown, Youngstown City School District parcels on the Auditor’s Tax List and Duplicate of Real Property, as kept in the records of the Mahoning County Auditor’s Office. Ralph T. Meacham, Mahoning County Auditor ~ phYouid ¢oa, Director of Taxation Date Shela _——— 2024 CV 00698