Preview
MARGO A.
1 MARGO A. RAISON, COUNTY COUNSEL
RAISON, COUNTY COUNSEL
Marshall S.
Marshall Fontes, Chief
S. Fontes, Deputy (SBN
Chief Deputy (SBN 139567)
139567)
Andrew C.
By: Andrew
2 By: C. Hamilton, Deputy (SBN
Hamilton, Deputy 299877)
(SBN 299877)
Kern County
Kern Administrative Center
County Administrative Center
1 1 1 5 Truxtun
3 1115 Truxtun Avenue, Fourth Floor
Avenue, Fourth Floor
Bakersfield, CA
Bakersfield, CA 93301
93301
Telephone: (661)
4 Telephone: 868-3800
(661) 868-3800
Facsimile: (661) 868-3805
Facsimile: (661) 868-3805
5 Email: ahamilton@kerncounty.com
Email: ahamilton@kemcounty.com
for County
Attorneys for
6 Attorneys Kern
County ooff Kern
7
8 SUPERIOR COURT OF
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA
CALIFORNIA
9 FOR THE
FOR COUNTY OF
THE COUNTY KERN
OF KERN
10 COVARRUBIAS ARANDAS
YOLANDA COVARRUBIAS
10 YOLANDA ARANDAS as as Case No.
Case TSC
BCV-22-100680 TSC
No. BCV-22-100680
Successor-in-Interest of
Successor-in-Interest THE ESTATE
o f THE ESTATE OF OF
11 GUADALUPE COVARRUBIAS,
MARIA GUADALUPE
11 MARIA COVARRUBIAS, and
and COUNTY OF
COUNTY KERN’S EVIDENCE
OF KERN’S IN
EVIDENCE IN
ARACELY PACHECO
NORMA ARACELY
NORMA PACHECO as as Successor-
Successor- SUPPORT OF
SUPPORT MOTION FOR
T S MOTION
OF IITS FOR
12
12 in-Interest o f THE
in-Interest of ESTATE OF
THE ESTATE EDGAR
OF EDGAR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR
SUMMARY JUDGMENT SUMMARY
OR SUMMARY
ANTONIO BONILLA
ANTONIO COVARRUBIAS, and
BONILLA COVARRUBIAS, and ADJUDICATION
ADJUDICATION
13 DYLANI
13 DYLANI AZUSENA BONILLA
AZUSENA BONILLA
COVARRUBIAS by
COVARRUBLAS by and through her
and through guardian
her guardian
14 ad
14 ad litem Jennifer Daniela
litem Jennifer Rodriguez Pacheco,
Daniela Rodriguez Pacheco,
and NOE
and NOE ARRON BONILLA COVARRUBIAS
ARRON BONILLA COVARRUBLAS
15 by
15 through his
and through
by and guardian ad
his guardian litem Norma
ad litem Norma
Pacheco, and
Aracely Pacheco,
Aracely IAN ESAU
and IAN BONILLA
ESAU BONILLA
16 COVARRUBIAS by
16 COVARRUBLAS and
by and
his guardian
through his
through guardian adad litem Norma Aracely
litem Norma Aracely
17 Pacheco, and
17 Pacheco, and SCARLETT
SCARLETT SARAI BONILLA
SARAI BONILLA
COVARRUBIAS by
COVARRUBLAS by and through her
and through guardian
her guardian
18 ad litem
18 ad litem Norma Aracely Pacheco,
Norma Aracely and
Pacheco, and
ARIANNA MARIE
ARIANNA MARIE PEREZ
PEREZ by by and her
through her
and through
19 legal
19 Stephanie Diana
guardian Stephanie
legal guardian Diana Perez, and
Perez, and
JADEN
JADEN ANTONIO BONILLA by
ANTONIO BONILLA by and through
and through
220 his legal
0 his Stephanie Diana
guardian Stephanie
legal guardian Perez
Diana Perez
221
1 Plaintiffs,
Plaintiffs,
22
22 vs.
vs.
ROBERTO CARLOS
2233 ROBERTO ROSACORDERO,
CARLOS ROSACORDERO,
EXPRESS, INC.,
LASHER EXPRESS,
LASHER TRANS, INC.,
DJ TRANS,
INC., DJ INC.,
24 GURJANT
24 SINGH, DAISY
GURJANT SINGH, PRITAM
SINGH, PRITAM
DAISY SINGH,
SINGH, KAUR JESMEET,
SINGH, KAUR COUNTY OF
JESMEET, COUNTY OF
KERN, and
2255 KERN, OES 1
DOES
and D through 50,
1 through 50,
226
6 Defendants.
Defendants.
227
7
228
8
–1–
_1_
County ooff Kem’s
County Support ooff its
in Support
Evidence in
Kern’s Evidence for Summary
Motion for
its Motion Judgment
Summary Judgment BCV-22-100680 TSC
BCV-22-100680 TSC
1 JESMEET
JESMEET KAUR,
KAUR,
2 Cross-Complainant,
Cross-Complainant,
3 vs.
vs.
4 ROBERTO ROSACORDERO,
CARLOS ROSACORDERO,
ROBERTO CARLOS
LASHER EXPRESS,
LASHER EXPRESS, INC., DJ TRANS,
INC., DJ INC.,
TRANS, INC.,
5 GURJANT DAISY SINGH,
SINGH, DAISY
GURJANT SINGH, PRITAM
SINGH, PRITAM
COUNTY OF
SINGH, COUNTY
SINGH, KERN, THE
OF KERN, ESTATE
THE ESTATE
6 OF
OF EDGAR BONILLA
ANTONIO BONILLA
EDGAR ANTONIO
COVARRUBIAS and
COVARRUBLAS through 20,
DOES11 through
and DOES 20,
7
Cross-Defendants.
Cross-Defendants.
8 ROBERTO ROSACORDERO,
CARLOS ROSACORDERO,
ROBERTO CARLOS
LASHER EXPRESS,
LASHER INC., and
EXPRESS, INC., PRITAM
and PRITAM
9 SINGH,
STNGH,
Cross-Complainants,
Cross-Complainants,
10
10 vs.
VS.
DJ TRANS,
DJ INC., GURJANT
TRANS, INC., GURJANT SINGH, DAISY
SINGH, DAISY
11
11 SINGH,
STNGH, KAUR COUNTY OF
JESMEET, COUNTY
KAUR JESMEET, OF
KERN, and
KERN, through 50,
MOES 11 through
and MOES 50,
12
12
Cross-Defendants.
Cross-Defendants.
13
13
14
14 Pursuant to
Pursuant California Rules
to California Court, rule
Rules ooff Court, rule 3.1350, the County
3.1350, the Kern hereby
County ooff Kern hereby submits its
submits its
15 Evidence
15 support ooff its
in support
Evidence in Motion for
its Motion Summary Judgment
for Summary or Summary
Judgment or Summary Adjudication or Both.
Adjudication or Both.
16
16 EVIDENCE
EVIDENCE
17
17 DOCUMENT
DOCUMENT BATES
BATES
18
18 Request forJudicial
Request for Notice
JudicialNotice COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
19
19 00001 -00004
00001 -00004
220
0 A—
Exhibit A
Exhibit Summary of
– Summary Proceedings May
of Proceedings 1987
18, 1987
May 18, COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
221
1 00023
00005- 00023
00005-
22
22 B—
Exhibit B
Exhibit Summary of
– Summary March 9,
Proceedings March
of Proceedings 2010
9, 2010 COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
2233 00024-00043
00024-00043
24
24 Exhibit C -- Plaintiff’s
Exhibit C Plaintiff’s Second Complaint
Amended Complaint
Second Amended COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
2255 00044-00076
00044-00076
226
6 D—
Exhibit D
Exhibit Plaintiff’ss First
– Plaintiff Complaint
Amended Complaint
First Amended COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
227
7 00077-00105
00077-00105
228
8
–2–
_2_
County Kern’s Evidence
County ooff Kem’s Support ooff its
in Support
Evidence in for Summary
Motion for
its Motion Judgment
Summary Judgment BCV-22-100680 TSC
BCV-22-100680 TSC
1
Declaration
Declaration of AndrewCC.
ofAndrew Hamilton
. Hamilton COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
2
00106-00108
00106-00108
3
Exhibit A –— Relevant
Exhibit A Portions ooff the
Relevant Portions the Deposition Transcript of
Deposition Transcript o f California COK-MSJ-
California COK—MSJ-
4
Highway Patrol
Highway Justin Aparicio
Officer Justin
Patrol Officer taken on
Aparicio taken April 17,
on April 2023, and
17, 2023, and relevant 00109-00147
relevant 00109-00147
5
portions Exhibit 16.
portions ooff Exhibit 16.
6
Exhibit B
Exhibit Relevant Portions
B -- Relevant o f the
Portions of Deposition Transcript
the Deposition o f California
Transcript of COK-MSJ-
California COK—MSJ-
7
Patrol Officer
Highway Patrol
Highway Christina Mendez
Officer Christina on January
taken on
Mendez taken January 18, 2024, and
18, 2024, 00148-00209
relevant 00148-00209
and relevant
8
portions Exhibit 31.
portions ooff Exhibit 31.
9
Exhibit Relevant Portions
C -- Relevant
Exhibit C of the
Portions of Transcript of
Deposition Transcript
the Deposition o f Pritam COK-MSJ-
Pritam COK—MSJ-
10
10
taken on
Singh taken
Singh on May 24, 2023.
May 24, 2023. 00210-00229
00210-00229
11
11
Exhibit D
Exhibit of the
Portions of
Relevant Portions
D -- Relevant Transcript of
Deposition Transcript
the Deposition o f Pardeep COK-MSJ-
Pardeep COK—MSJ-
12
12
Singh taken
Singh on January
taken on 25, 2023.
January 25, 2023. 00230-00263
00230-00263
13
13
Exhibit E
Exhibit Portions of
Relevant Portions
E -- Relevant Deposition Transcript
the Deposition
of the Blanca COK—MSJ-
Transcript ooff Blanca COK-MSJ-
14
14
Trujillo taken on
Trujillo taken January 26,
on January 26, 2023.
2023. 00264-00277
00264-00277
15
15
Exhibit FF -- Relevant
Exhibit of the
Portions of
Relevant Portions Deposition Transcript
the Deposition of Gurjant
Transcript of COK-MSJ-
Gurjant COK—MSJ-
16
16
Singh taken on
Singh taken January 10,
on January 2023.
10, 2023. 00278-00295
00278-00295
17
17
Exhibit G
Exhibit Portions ooff the
Relevant Portions
G -- Relevant Deposition Transcript
the Deposition Transcript of Daisy Singh
of Daisy COK-MSJ-
Singh COK—MSJ-
18
18
taken on
taken January 10,
on January 2023
10, 2023 00296-00312
00296-00312
19
19
Declarationoof
Declaration f Ivan Castaneda
IvanCastaneda COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
220
0
00313-00315
00313-00315
221
1
Declarationof
Declaration Bedolla
AlejandroBedolla
ofAlejandro COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
22
22
00316-00318
003 16-00318
2233
A—
Exhibit A
Exhibit Roads Web
– Roads List 11/20/2021
Complaints List
Web Complaints 11/20/2021 COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
24
24
00319-00322
003 19-00322
2255
Exhibit BB -- Roads
Exhibit Web Complaints
Roads Web and Responses
Complaints and 2/18/2015
Responses 2/ 18/2015 COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
226
6
00323-00347
00323-00347
227
7
228
8
–3–
_3_
County ooff Kem’s
County in Support
Evidence in
Kern’s Evidence Motion for
its Motion
Support ooff its Judgment
Summary Judgment
for Summary BCV-22-100680 TSC
BCV-22-100680 TSC
1
Declaration
Declaration of Grey
BruceGrey
ofBruce COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
2
00348-00350
00348-00350
3
A—
Exhibit A
Exhibit Encroachment Permit
– Encroachment Permit COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
4
00351-00364
00351-00364
5
Exhibit — Street
B –
Exhibit B Street Standards
Standards COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
6
00365-00468
003 65-00468
7
Declaration Gomez
SalvadorGomez
DeclarationofofSalvador COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
8
00469-00472
00469-00472
9
A—
Exhibit A
Exhibit – South
South Union Builts
As- Builts
Union As- COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
10
10
00473-00481
00473-00481
11
11
B—
Exhibit B
Exhibit Collision Summary
– Collision Report
Summary Report COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
12
12
00482-00486
00482-00486
13
13
Declaration Bowden
DouglasBowden
DeclarationofofDouglas COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
14
14
00487-00490
00487-00490
15
15
A—
Exhibit A
Exhibit – Traffic Data 1988-2021-0429
Traffic Data 1988-2021-0429 COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
16
16
00491-00492
00491-00492
17
17
B—
Exhibit B
Exhibit Traffic Data
– Traffic Data 1988-2020-0916
1988-2020-0916 COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
18
18
00493-00494
00493-00494
19
19
C—
Exhibit C
Exhibit – Traffic 1988-2019-1119
Data 1988-2019-1119
Traffic Data COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
220
0
00495-00496
00495-00496
221
1
D—
Exhibit D
Exhibit Traffic Data
– Traffic Data 1988-2018-0418
1988-2018-0418 COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
22
22
00497-00498
00497-00498
2233
Exhibit EE —
Exhibit Traffic Data
– Traffic 1988-2017-0706
Data 1988-2017-0706 COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
24
24
00499-00500
00499-00500
2255
Exhibit Traffic Data
– Traffic
Exhibit FF — Data 1988-2016-1004
1988-2016-1004 COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
226
6
00501-00502
00501-00502
227
7
228
8
4:—
–4–
County Kern’s Evidence
County ooff Kern’s Support ooff its
in Support
Evidence in for Summary
Motion for
its Motion Judgment
Summary Judgment BCV-22-100680 TSC
BCV-22-100680 TSC
1
Exhibit
Exhibit G Traffic Data
G –— Traffic Data 1988-2016-0427
1988-2016-0427 COK-MSJ-
COK—MSJ-
2
00503-00504
00503 -00504
3
4
DATED: March
DATED: 2024
21, 2024
March 21, Respectfully Submitted,
Respectfully Submitted,
5
MARGO A.
MARGO RAISON
A. RAISON
6
By: 32%.,
By: $9.44,»
___________________________
7 Andrew C
Andrew Hamilton, Deputy
C.. Hamilton, Deputy
for County
Attorneys for
Attorneys Kern
County ooff Kern
8
9
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
17
17
18
18
19
19
220
0
221
1
22
22
2233
24
24
2255
226
6
227
7
228
8
–5–
_5_
County Kern’s Evidence
County ooff Kern’s Support ooff its
in Support
Evidence in for Summary
Motion for
its Motion Judgment
Summary Judgment BCV-22-100680 TSC
BCV-22-100680 TSC
MARGO A.
1 MARGO A. RAISON, COUNTY COUNSEL
RAISON, COUNTY COUNSEL
Marshall S.
Marshall Fontes, Chief
S. Fontes, Deputy (SBN
Chief Deputy (SBN 139567)
139567)
Andrew C.
By: Andrew
2 By: C. Hamilton, Deputy (SBN
Hamilton, Deputy 299877)
(SBN 299877)
Kern County
Kern Administrative Center
County Administrative Center
1 1 1 5 Truxtun
3 1115 Truxtun Avenue, Fourth Floor
Avenue, Fourth Floor
Bakersfield, CA
Bakersfield, CA 93301
93301
Telephone: (661)
4 Telephone: 868-3800
(661) 868-3800
Facsimile: (661) 868-3805
Facsimile: (661) 868-3805
5 Email: ahamilton@kerncounty.com
Email: ahamilton@kemcounty.com
Attorneys for
6 Attorneys County ooff Kern
for County Kern from filing
[Exempt from
[Exempt filing fees, Code, §§ 6103]
Gov. Code,
fees, Gov. 6103]
7
8
SUPERIOR COURT
SUPERIOR OF CALIFORNIA
COURT OF CALIFORNIA
9
FOR THE
FOR COUNTY OF
THE COUNTY KERN
OF KERN
10
10
COVARRUBIAS ARANDAS
YOLANDA COVARRUBIAS
YOLANDA ARANDAS as as Case No.
Case TSC
BCV-22-100680 TSC
No. BCV-22-100680
Successor-in-Interest of
11 Successor-in-Interest
11 THE ESTATE
o f THE ESTATE OF OF
GUADALUPE COVARRUBIAS,
MARIA GUADALUPE
MARIA COVARRUBIAS, and
and REQUEST FOR
REQUEST JUDICIAL NOTICE
FOR JUDICIAL IN
NOTICE IN
12
12 NORMA ARACELY PACHECO
NORMA ARACELY PACHECO as as Successor-
Successor- SUPPORT OF COUNTY
SUPPORT OF COUNTY OF KERN’S
OF KERN’S
in-Interest ooff THE
in-Interest ESTATE OF
THE ESTATE EDGAR
OF EDGAR MOTION FOR
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT;
SUMMARY JUDGEMENT;
13 ANTONIO BONILLA
13 ANTONIO COVARRUBIAS, and
BONILLA COVARRUBIAS, and MOTION FOR COSTS
MOTION FOR C O S T S OF DEFENSE
OF DEFENSE
DYLANI BONILLA
AZUSENA BONILLA
DYLANI AZUSENA UNDER CODE OF
UNDER CODE CIVIL PROCEDURE
OF CIVIL PROCEDURE
14 COVARRUBIAS by
14 COVARRUBLAS by and
and through her guardian
through her guardian 1038
1038
ad Jennifer Daniela
litem Jennifer
ad litem Daniela Rodriguez Pacheco,
Rodriguez Pacheco,
15
15 and NOE ARRON
and NOE ARRON BONILLA
BONILLA Filed with:
concurrently with:
Filed concurrently
COVARRUBIAS by
COVARRUBLAS by and through his
and through guardian
his guardian Notice of
Notice Motion and
of Motion Motionfor
and Motion Summary
for Summary
16 ad litem
16 ad Aracely Pacheco,
Norma Aracely
litem Norma Pacheco, and IAN
and IAN Judgment
Judgment
ESAU BONILLA
ESAU COVARRUBIAS by
BONILLA COVARRUBLAS and
by and Separate of Undisputed
Statement of
Separate Statement Facts;
Undisputed Facts;
17
17 through guardian ad
his guardian
through his Norma Aracely
litem Norma
ad litem Aracely Evidence in
Evidence Support of
in Support Judgment;
Summary Judgment;
of Summary
Pacheco, and
Pacheco, and SCARLETT
SCARLETT SARAI BONILLA
SARAI BONILLA Declaration of
Declaration Hamilton;
Andrew Hamilton;
of Andrew
18 COVARRUBIAS by
18 COVARRUBLAS by and through her
and through guardian
her guardian Declaration of
Declaration Salvador Gomez;
of Salvador Gomez;
ad litem
ad litem Norma Aracely Pacheco,
Norma Aracely and
Pacheco, and Declaration of
Declaration Ivan Castaneda;
of Ivan Castaneda;
19 ARIANNA MARIE
19 ARIANNA MARIE PEREZ
PEREZ by through her
and through
by and her Declaration Bruce Gray;
of Bruce
Declaration of Gray;
legal
legal guardian Stephanie Diana
guardian Stephanie Diana Perez, and
Perez, and Declaration of Douglas
Declaration of Bowden;.
Douglas Bowden;.
220 BONILLA by
ANTONIO BONILLA
JADEN ANTONIO
0 JADEN through
and through
by and
his legal
his Diana Perez,
Stephanie Diana
guardian Stephanie
legal guardian Perez, Judge: Hon. Thomas
Judge: Hon. S. Clark
Thomas S. Clark
2211 Department: 17
Department: 17
Plaintiffs,
Plaintiffs, Date: June 12,
Date: June 2024
1 2 , 2024
22
22 Time: 8:30 aa.m.
Time: 8:30 m.
vs.
vs.
2233 Action Filed:
Action March 221,
Filed: March 2022
1 , 2022
ROBERTO CARLOS
ROBERTO ROSACORDERO,
CARLOS ROSACORDERO, Trial Date:
Trial Set
None Set
Date: None
24 LASHER
24 EXPRESS, INC.,
LASHER EXPRESS, INC., DJ INC.,
TRANS, INC.,
DJ TRANS,
GURJANT SINGH,
GURJANT SINGH, DAISY PRITAM
SINGH, PRITAM
DAISY SINGH,
25 SINGH,
25 SINGH, KAUR JESMEET, COUNTY
KAUR JESMEET, COUNTY OF OF
KERN, and
KERN, and D OES 1
DOES through 50,
1 through 50,
2266
Defendants.
Defendants.
2277
228
8
–1–
_1_
to Take
Request to Notice In
Judicial Notice
Take Judicial In Support County ooff Kern’s
Support ooff County MSJ
Kern’s MSJ BCV-22-100680-TSC
COK-MSJ-00001
Request
COK-M§SY0?668°JF8
1 JESMEET
JESMEET KAUR,
KAUR,
2 Cross-Complainant,
Cross-Complainant,
3 vs.
vs.
4 ROBERTO ROSACORDERO,
CARLOS ROSACORDERO,
ROBERTO CARLOS
LASHER EXPRESS,
LASHER EXPRESS, INC., DJ TRANS,
INC., DJ INC.,
TRANS, INC.,
5 GURJANT DAISY SINGH,
SINGH, DAISY
GURJANT SINGH, PRITAM
SINGH, PRITAM
COUNTY OF
SINGH, COUNTY
SINGH, KERN, THE
OF KERN, ESTATE
THE ESTATE
6 OF
OF EDGAR BONILLA
ANTONIO BONILLA
EDGAR ANTONIO
COVARRUBIAS
COVARRUBLAS andand DOES 20,
through 20,
DOES11 through
7
Cross-Defendants.
Cross-Defendants.
8 ROBERTO ROSACORDERO,
CARLOS ROSACORDERO,
ROBERTO CARLOS
LASHER EXPRESS,
LASHER EXPRESS, INC., and
INC., PRITAM
and PRITAM
9 SINGH,
STNGH,
10
10 Cross-Complainants,
Cross-Complainants,
11
11 vs.
vs.
12
12 DJ INC., GURJANT
TRANS, INC.,
DJ TRANS, GURJANT SI
Preview
MARGO A. 1 MARGO A. RAISON, COUNTY COUNSEL RAISON, COUNTY COUNSEL Marshall S. Marshall Fontes, Chief S. Fontes, Deputy (SBN Chief Deputy (SBN 139567) 139567) Andrew C. By: Andrew 2 By: C. Hamilton, Deputy (SBN Hamilton, Deputy 299877) (SBN 299877) Kern County Kern Administrative Center County Administrative Center 1 1 1 5 Truxtun 3 1115 Truxtun Avenue, Fourth Floor Avenue, Fourth Floor Bakersfield, CA Bakersfield, CA 93301 93301 Telephone: (661) 4 Telephone: 868-3800 (661) 868-3800 Facsimile: (661) 868-3805 Facsimile: (661) 868-3805 5 Email: ahamilton@kerncounty.com Email: ahamilton@kemcounty.com for County Attorneys for 6 Attorneys Kern County ooff Kern 7 8 SUPERIOR COURT OF SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA CALIFORNIA 9 FOR THE FOR COUNTY OF THE COUNTY KERN OF KERN 10 COVARRUBIAS ARANDAS YOLANDA COVARRUBIAS 10 YOLANDA ARANDAS as as Case No. Case TSC BCV-22-100680 TSC No. BCV-22-100680 Successor-in-Interest of Successor-in-Interest THE ESTATE o f THE ESTATE OF OF 11 GUADALUPE COVARRUBIAS, MARIA GUADALUPE 11 MARIA COVARRUBIAS, and and COUNTY OF COUNTY KERN’S EVIDENCE OF KERN’S IN EVIDENCE IN ARACELY PACHECO NORMA ARACELY NORMA PACHECO as as Successor- Successor- SUPPORT OF SUPPORT MOTION FOR T S MOTION OF IITS FOR 12 12 in-Interest o f THE in-Interest of ESTATE OF THE ESTATE EDGAR OF EDGAR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR SUMMARY JUDGMENT SUMMARY OR SUMMARY ANTONIO BONILLA ANTONIO COVARRUBIAS, and BONILLA COVARRUBIAS, and ADJUDICATION ADJUDICATION 13 DYLANI 13 DYLANI AZUSENA BONILLA AZUSENA BONILLA COVARRUBIAS by COVARRUBLAS by and through her and through guardian her guardian 14 ad 14 ad litem Jennifer Daniela litem Jennifer Rodriguez Pacheco, Daniela Rodriguez Pacheco, and NOE and NOE ARRON BONILLA COVARRUBIAS ARRON BONILLA COVARRUBLAS 15 by 15 through his and through by and guardian ad his guardian litem Norma ad litem Norma Pacheco, and Aracely Pacheco, Aracely IAN ESAU and IAN BONILLA ESAU BONILLA 16 COVARRUBIAS by 16 COVARRUBLAS and by and his guardian through his through guardian adad litem Norma Aracely litem Norma Aracely 17 Pacheco, and 17 Pacheco, and SCARLETT SCARLETT SARAI BONILLA SARAI BONILLA COVARRUBIAS by COVARRUBLAS by and through her and through guardian her guardian 18 ad litem 18 ad litem Norma Aracely Pacheco, Norma Aracely and Pacheco, and ARIANNA MARIE ARIANNA MARIE PEREZ PEREZ by by and her through her and through 19 legal 19 Stephanie Diana guardian Stephanie legal guardian Diana Perez, and Perez, and JADEN JADEN ANTONIO BONILLA by ANTONIO BONILLA by and through and through 220 his legal 0 his Stephanie Diana guardian Stephanie legal guardian Perez Diana Perez 221 1 Plaintiffs, Plaintiffs, 22 22 vs. vs. ROBERTO CARLOS 2233 ROBERTO ROSACORDERO, CARLOS ROSACORDERO, EXPRESS, INC., LASHER EXPRESS, LASHER TRANS, INC., DJ TRANS, INC., DJ INC., 24 GURJANT 24 SINGH, DAISY GURJANT SINGH, PRITAM SINGH, PRITAM DAISY SINGH, SINGH, KAUR JESMEET, SINGH, KAUR COUNTY OF JESMEET, COUNTY OF KERN, and 2255 KERN, OES 1 DOES and D through 50, 1 through 50, 226 6 Defendants. Defendants. 227 7 228 8 –1– _1_ County ooff Kem’s County Support ooff its in Support Evidence in Kern’s Evidence for Summary Motion for its Motion Judgment Summary Judgment BCV-22-100680 TSC BCV-22-100680 TSC 1 JESMEET JESMEET KAUR, KAUR, 2 Cross-Complainant, Cross-Complainant, 3 vs. vs. 4 ROBERTO ROSACORDERO, CARLOS ROSACORDERO, ROBERTO CARLOS LASHER EXPRESS, LASHER EXPRESS, INC., DJ TRANS, INC., DJ INC., TRANS, INC., 5 GURJANT DAISY SINGH, SINGH, DAISY GURJANT SINGH, PRITAM SINGH, PRITAM COUNTY OF SINGH, COUNTY SINGH, KERN, THE OF KERN, ESTATE THE ESTATE 6 OF OF EDGAR BONILLA ANTONIO BONILLA EDGAR ANTONIO COVARRUBIAS and COVARRUBLAS through 20, DOES11 through and DOES 20, 7 Cross-Defendants. Cross-Defendants. 8 ROBERTO ROSACORDERO, CARLOS ROSACORDERO, ROBERTO CARLOS LASHER EXPRESS, LASHER INC., and EXPRESS, INC., PRITAM and PRITAM 9 SINGH, STNGH, Cross-Complainants, Cross-Complainants, 10 10 vs. VS. DJ TRANS, DJ INC., GURJANT TRANS, INC., GURJANT SINGH, DAISY SINGH, DAISY 11 11 SINGH, STNGH, KAUR COUNTY OF JESMEET, COUNTY KAUR JESMEET, OF KERN, and KERN, through 50, MOES 11 through and MOES 50, 12 12 Cross-Defendants. Cross-Defendants. 13 13 14 14 Pursuant to Pursuant California Rules to California Court, rule Rules ooff Court, rule 3.1350, the County 3.1350, the Kern hereby County ooff Kern hereby submits its submits its 15 Evidence 15 support ooff its in support Evidence in Motion for its Motion Summary Judgment for Summary or Summary Judgment or Summary Adjudication or Both. Adjudication or Both. 16 16 EVIDENCE EVIDENCE 17 17 DOCUMENT DOCUMENT BATES BATES 18 18 Request forJudicial Request for Notice JudicialNotice COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 19 19 00001 -00004 00001 -00004 220 0 A— Exhibit A Exhibit Summary of – Summary Proceedings May of Proceedings 1987 18, 1987 May 18, COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 221 1 00023 00005- 00023 00005- 22 22 B— Exhibit B Exhibit Summary of – Summary March 9, Proceedings March of Proceedings 2010 9, 2010 COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 2233 00024-00043 00024-00043 24 24 Exhibit C -- Plaintiff’s Exhibit C Plaintiff’s Second Complaint Amended Complaint Second Amended COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 2255 00044-00076 00044-00076 226 6 D— Exhibit D Exhibit Plaintiff’ss First – Plaintiff Complaint Amended Complaint First Amended COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 227 7 00077-00105 00077-00105 228 8 –2– _2_ County Kern’s Evidence County ooff Kem’s Support ooff its in Support Evidence in for Summary Motion for its Motion Judgment Summary Judgment BCV-22-100680 TSC BCV-22-100680 TSC 1 Declaration Declaration of AndrewCC. ofAndrew Hamilton . Hamilton COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 2 00106-00108 00106-00108 3 Exhibit A –— Relevant Exhibit A Portions ooff the Relevant Portions the Deposition Transcript of Deposition Transcript o f California COK-MSJ- California COK—MSJ- 4 Highway Patrol Highway Justin Aparicio Officer Justin Patrol Officer taken on Aparicio taken April 17, on April 2023, and 17, 2023, and relevant 00109-00147 relevant 00109-00147 5 portions Exhibit 16. portions ooff Exhibit 16. 6 Exhibit B Exhibit Relevant Portions B -- Relevant o f the Portions of Deposition Transcript the Deposition o f California Transcript of COK-MSJ- California COK—MSJ- 7 Patrol Officer Highway Patrol Highway Christina Mendez Officer Christina on January taken on Mendez taken January 18, 2024, and 18, 2024, 00148-00209 relevant 00148-00209 and relevant 8 portions Exhibit 31. portions ooff Exhibit 31. 9 Exhibit Relevant Portions C -- Relevant Exhibit C of the Portions of Transcript of Deposition Transcript the Deposition o f Pritam COK-MSJ- Pritam COK—MSJ- 10 10 taken on Singh taken Singh on May 24, 2023. May 24, 2023. 00210-00229 00210-00229 11 11 Exhibit D Exhibit of the Portions of Relevant Portions D -- Relevant Transcript of Deposition Transcript the Deposition o f Pardeep COK-MSJ- Pardeep COK—MSJ- 12 12 Singh taken Singh on January taken on 25, 2023. January 25, 2023. 00230-00263 00230-00263 13 13 Exhibit E Exhibit Portions of Relevant Portions E -- Relevant Deposition Transcript the Deposition of the Blanca COK—MSJ- Transcript ooff Blanca COK-MSJ- 14 14 Trujillo taken on Trujillo taken January 26, on January 26, 2023. 2023. 00264-00277 00264-00277 15 15 Exhibit FF -- Relevant Exhibit of the Portions of Relevant Portions Deposition Transcript the Deposition of Gurjant Transcript of COK-MSJ- Gurjant COK—MSJ- 16 16 Singh taken on Singh taken January 10, on January 2023. 10, 2023. 00278-00295 00278-00295 17 17 Exhibit G Exhibit Portions ooff the Relevant Portions G -- Relevant Deposition Transcript the Deposition Transcript of Daisy Singh of Daisy COK-MSJ- Singh COK—MSJ- 18 18 taken on taken January 10, on January 2023 10, 2023 00296-00312 00296-00312 19 19 Declarationoof Declaration f Ivan Castaneda IvanCastaneda COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 220 0 00313-00315 00313-00315 221 1 Declarationof Declaration Bedolla AlejandroBedolla ofAlejandro COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 22 22 00316-00318 003 16-00318 2233 A— Exhibit A Exhibit Roads Web – Roads List 11/20/2021 Complaints List Web Complaints 11/20/2021 COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 24 24 00319-00322 003 19-00322 2255 Exhibit BB -- Roads Exhibit Web Complaints Roads Web and Responses Complaints and 2/18/2015 Responses 2/ 18/2015 COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 226 6 00323-00347 00323-00347 227 7 228 8 –3– _3_ County ooff Kem’s County in Support Evidence in Kern’s Evidence Motion for its Motion Support ooff its Judgment Summary Judgment for Summary BCV-22-100680 TSC BCV-22-100680 TSC 1 Declaration Declaration of Grey BruceGrey ofBruce COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 2 00348-00350 00348-00350 3 A— Exhibit A Exhibit Encroachment Permit – Encroachment Permit COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 4 00351-00364 00351-00364 5 Exhibit — Street B – Exhibit B Street Standards Standards COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 6 00365-00468 003 65-00468 7 Declaration Gomez SalvadorGomez DeclarationofofSalvador COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 8 00469-00472 00469-00472 9 A— Exhibit A Exhibit – South South Union Builts As- Builts Union As- COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 10 10 00473-00481 00473-00481 11 11 B— Exhibit B Exhibit Collision Summary – Collision Report Summary Report COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 12 12 00482-00486 00482-00486 13 13 Declaration Bowden DouglasBowden DeclarationofofDouglas COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 14 14 00487-00490 00487-00490 15 15 A— Exhibit A Exhibit – Traffic Data 1988-2021-0429 Traffic Data 1988-2021-0429 COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 16 16 00491-00492 00491-00492 17 17 B— Exhibit B Exhibit Traffic Data – Traffic Data 1988-2020-0916 1988-2020-0916 COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 18 18 00493-00494 00493-00494 19 19 C— Exhibit C Exhibit – Traffic 1988-2019-1119 Data 1988-2019-1119 Traffic Data COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 220 0 00495-00496 00495-00496 221 1 D— Exhibit D Exhibit Traffic Data – Traffic Data 1988-2018-0418 1988-2018-0418 COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 22 22 00497-00498 00497-00498 2233 Exhibit EE — Exhibit Traffic Data – Traffic 1988-2017-0706 Data 1988-2017-0706 COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 24 24 00499-00500 00499-00500 2255 Exhibit Traffic Data – Traffic Exhibit FF — Data 1988-2016-1004 1988-2016-1004 COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 226 6 00501-00502 00501-00502 227 7 228 8 4:— –4– County Kern’s Evidence County ooff Kern’s Support ooff its in Support Evidence in for Summary Motion for its Motion Judgment Summary Judgment BCV-22-100680 TSC BCV-22-100680 TSC 1 Exhibit Exhibit G Traffic Data G –— Traffic Data 1988-2016-0427 1988-2016-0427 COK-MSJ- COK—MSJ- 2 00503-00504 00503 -00504 3 4 DATED: March DATED: 2024 21, 2024 March 21, Respectfully Submitted, Respectfully Submitted, 5 MARGO A. MARGO RAISON A. RAISON 6 By: 32%., By: $9.44,» ___________________________ 7 Andrew C Andrew Hamilton, Deputy C.. Hamilton, Deputy for County Attorneys for Attorneys Kern County ooff Kern 8 9 10 10 11 11 12 12 13 13 14 14 15 15 16 16 17 17 18 18 19 19 220 0 221 1 22 22 2233 24 24 2255 226 6 227 7 228 8 –5– _5_ County Kern’s Evidence County ooff Kern’s Support ooff its in Support Evidence in for Summary Motion for its Motion Judgment Summary Judgment BCV-22-100680 TSC BCV-22-100680 TSC MARGO A. 1 MARGO A. RAISON, COUNTY COUNSEL RAISON, COUNTY COUNSEL Marshall S. Marshall Fontes, Chief S. Fontes, Deputy (SBN Chief Deputy (SBN 139567) 139567) Andrew C. By: Andrew 2 By: C. Hamilton, Deputy (SBN Hamilton, Deputy 299877) (SBN 299877) Kern County Kern Administrative Center County Administrative Center 1 1 1 5 Truxtun 3 1115 Truxtun Avenue, Fourth Floor Avenue, Fourth Floor Bakersfield, CA Bakersfield, CA 93301 93301 Telephone: (661) 4 Telephone: 868-3800 (661) 868-3800 Facsimile: (661) 868-3805 Facsimile: (661) 868-3805 5 Email: ahamilton@kerncounty.com Email: ahamilton@kemcounty.com Attorneys for 6 Attorneys County ooff Kern for County Kern from filing [Exempt from [Exempt filing fees, Code, §§ 6103] Gov. Code, fees, Gov. 6103] 7 8 SUPERIOR COURT SUPERIOR OF CALIFORNIA COURT OF CALIFORNIA 9 FOR THE FOR COUNTY OF THE COUNTY KERN OF KERN 10 10 COVARRUBIAS ARANDAS YOLANDA COVARRUBIAS YOLANDA ARANDAS as as Case No. Case TSC BCV-22-100680 TSC No. BCV-22-100680 Successor-in-Interest of 11 Successor-in-Interest 11 THE ESTATE o f THE ESTATE OF OF GUADALUPE COVARRUBIAS, MARIA GUADALUPE MARIA COVARRUBIAS, and and REQUEST FOR REQUEST JUDICIAL NOTICE FOR JUDICIAL IN NOTICE IN 12 12 NORMA ARACELY PACHECO NORMA ARACELY PACHECO as as Successor- Successor- SUPPORT OF COUNTY SUPPORT OF COUNTY OF KERN’S OF KERN’S in-Interest ooff THE in-Interest ESTATE OF THE ESTATE EDGAR OF EDGAR MOTION FOR MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT; SUMMARY JUDGEMENT; 13 ANTONIO BONILLA 13 ANTONIO COVARRUBIAS, and BONILLA COVARRUBIAS, and MOTION FOR COSTS MOTION FOR C O S T S OF DEFENSE OF DEFENSE DYLANI BONILLA AZUSENA BONILLA DYLANI AZUSENA UNDER CODE OF UNDER CODE CIVIL PROCEDURE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 14 COVARRUBIAS by 14 COVARRUBLAS by and and through her guardian through her guardian 1038 1038 ad Jennifer Daniela litem Jennifer ad litem Daniela Rodriguez Pacheco, Rodriguez Pacheco, 15 15 and NOE ARRON and NOE ARRON BONILLA BONILLA Filed with: concurrently with: Filed concurrently COVARRUBIAS by COVARRUBLAS by and through his and through guardian his guardian Notice of Notice Motion and of Motion Motionfor and Motion Summary for Summary 16 ad litem 16 ad Aracely Pacheco, Norma Aracely litem Norma Pacheco, and IAN and IAN Judgment Judgment ESAU BONILLA ESAU COVARRUBIAS by BONILLA COVARRUBLAS and by and Separate of Undisputed Statement of Separate Statement Facts; Undisputed Facts; 17 17 through guardian ad his guardian through his Norma Aracely litem Norma ad litem Aracely Evidence in Evidence Support of in Support Judgment; Summary Judgment; of Summary Pacheco, and Pacheco, and SCARLETT SCARLETT SARAI BONILLA SARAI BONILLA Declaration of Declaration Hamilton; Andrew Hamilton; of Andrew 18 COVARRUBIAS by 18 COVARRUBLAS by and through her and through guardian her guardian Declaration of Declaration Salvador Gomez; of Salvador Gomez; ad litem ad litem Norma Aracely Pacheco, Norma Aracely and Pacheco, and Declaration of Declaration Ivan Castaneda; of Ivan Castaneda; 19 ARIANNA MARIE 19 ARIANNA MARIE PEREZ PEREZ by through her and through by and her Declaration Bruce Gray; of Bruce Declaration of Gray; legal legal guardian Stephanie Diana guardian Stephanie Diana Perez, and Perez, and Declaration of Douglas Declaration of Bowden;. Douglas Bowden;. 220 BONILLA by ANTONIO BONILLA JADEN ANTONIO 0 JADEN through and through by and his legal his Diana Perez, Stephanie Diana guardian Stephanie legal guardian Perez, Judge: Hon. Thomas Judge: Hon. S. Clark Thomas S. Clark 2211 Department: 17 Department: 17 Plaintiffs, Plaintiffs, Date: June 12, Date: June 2024 1 2 , 2024 22 22 Time: 8:30 aa.m. Time: 8:30 m. vs. vs. 2233 Action Filed: Action March 221, Filed: March 2022 1 , 2022 ROBERTO CARLOS ROBERTO ROSACORDERO, CARLOS ROSACORDERO, Trial Date: Trial Set None Set Date: None 24 LASHER 24 EXPRESS, INC., LASHER EXPRESS, INC., DJ INC., TRANS, INC., DJ TRANS, GURJANT SINGH, GURJANT SINGH, DAISY PRITAM SINGH, PRITAM DAISY SINGH, 25 SINGH, 25 SINGH, KAUR JESMEET, COUNTY KAUR JESMEET, COUNTY OF OF KERN, and KERN, and D OES 1 DOES through 50, 1 through 50, 2266 Defendants. Defendants. 2277 228 8 –1– _1_ to Take Request to Notice In Judicial Notice Take Judicial In Support County ooff Kern’s Support ooff County MSJ Kern’s MSJ BCV-22-100680-TSC COK-MSJ-00001 Request COK-M§SY0?668°JF8 1 JESMEET JESMEET KAUR, KAUR, 2 Cross-Complainant, Cross-Complainant, 3 vs. vs. 4 ROBERTO ROSACORDERO, CARLOS ROSACORDERO, ROBERTO CARLOS LASHER EXPRESS, LASHER EXPRESS, INC., DJ TRANS, INC., DJ INC., TRANS, INC., 5 GURJANT DAISY SINGH, SINGH, DAISY GURJANT SINGH, PRITAM SINGH, PRITAM COUNTY OF SINGH, COUNTY SINGH, KERN, THE OF KERN, ESTATE THE ESTATE 6 OF OF EDGAR BONILLA ANTONIO BONILLA EDGAR ANTONIO COVARRUBIAS COVARRUBLAS andand DOES 20, through 20, DOES11 through 7 Cross-Defendants. Cross-Defendants. 8 ROBERTO ROSACORDERO, CARLOS ROSACORDERO, ROBERTO CARLOS LASHER EXPRESS, LASHER EXPRESS, INC., and INC., PRITAM and PRITAM 9 SINGH, STNGH, 10 10 Cross-Complainants, Cross-Complainants, 11 11 vs. vs. 12 12 DJ INC., GURJANT TRANS, INC., DJ TRANS, GURJANT SI