On March 06, 2019 a
Trial
was filed
involving a dispute between
Hyle, John,
and
Aguilar, Elia M,
Rodriguez, Arianna Athena,
Rodriguez, Arianne Athena,
Rodriguez, David J,
for PI Motor Vehicle
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
\u \a
ugh
Tracy W. Goldberg, State Bar No. 128681 t
KEITH L. SHOJI & ASSOCIATES summoa'iAu‘aT‘apcDAumm
Employees of the Law Department COUNTY 0F SAN BERNARDINO
SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company
1600 Iowa Avenue, Suite 200
Riverside, California 92507 DEC 19 2023
Telephone: (951) 328-2000 / Fax: (855) 811-3889
Email Address: Shoji@StateFarm.com
BY
Attorneys for Defendant(s) Arianne DEBRAPEDHOSADEPU"
Athena Rodriguez, David J. Rodriguez,
and Elia M. Aguilar
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO
JOHN HYLE, No.2 CIVDS 1907037
Plaintiff,
Nmm‘CdNéO‘DmNOUI#WNd°@mNOUIhO-DN
ARIANNA ATHENA RODRIGUEZ,
v. (3m JUDGMENT
DAVID J. RODRIGUEZ, ELIA M. Complaint Filed: 03/06/19
AGUILAR, Trial Date: 10/23/23
Defendants.
i
This action came on for trial on October 23, 2023, in Department
NNNNNNNN—LAAAAAAd—LA
$27 of the San Bernardino County Superior Court, the Honorable Thomas
ORHGRNN
S. Garza, Judge presiding; Plaintiff John Hyle appearing along with his
counsel of record Lauren Vogt and Lynn P. Whitlock, and defendant
Arianna Athena Rodriguez appearing along with her attorneys of record
Tracy W. Goldberg and Heather K. Gray and David Erghelegiu of Keith L.
Shoji and Associates.
A jury of twelve individuals was regularly impaneled and sworn.
FAXED Witnesses were sworn and testified. After hearing the evidence and
arguments of counsel and having been duly instructed by the court. the
cause was submitted to the jury with directions to return a verdict. The
Nm jury deliberated and rendered its verdict on November 14, 2023.
_ 1
_
(PROPOSED) JUDGMENT
\a \u
The jury found in favor of plaintiff and against the defendant as
follows:
Question No. 1: Was Arianna Athena Rodriguez negligent?
ANSWER: YES
Question No. 2: Was Arianna Athena Rodriguez negligence a substantial
O‘DmeU’I-th-fi
factor in causing harm to John Hyle?
ANSWER: YES
Question No. 3: What are John Hyle’s damages?
a. Past economic loss
loss earnings: $0
medical expenses: $2,407.00
b. Past noneconomic loss, including
physical pain and mental suffering $0
Total: $2,407.00
It appearing by reason of said verdict that plaintiff John Hyle is
entitled to judgment against defendant Arianna Athena Rodriguez.
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGES AND DECREED
that said plaintiff John Hyle shall and does have judgment against
defendant, Arianna Athena Rodriguez in the amount of two thousand four
hundred and seven dollars ($2,407.00).
DATED: No mbequj_ 2023
Hon/THOMAS s. GARZAQDGE
- 2 -
(PROPOSED) JUDGMENT
Document Filed Date
December 19, 2023
Case Filing Date
March 06, 2019
Category
PI Motor Vehicle
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
\u \a ugh Tracy W. Goldberg, State Bar No. 128681 t KEITH L. SHOJI & ASSOCIATES summoa'iAu‘aT‘apcDAumm Employees of the Law Department COUNTY 0F SAN BERNARDINO SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company 1600 Iowa Avenue, Suite 200 Riverside, California 92507 DEC 19 2023 Telephone: (951) 328-2000 / Fax: (855) 811-3889 Email Address: Shoji@StateFarm.com BY Attorneys for Defendant(s) Arianne DEBRAPEDHOSADEPU" Athena Rodriguez, David J. Rodriguez, and Elia M. Aguilar SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO JOHN HYLE, No.2 CIVDS 1907037 Plaintiff, Nmm‘CdNéO‘DmNOUI#WNd°@mNOUIhO-DN ARIANNA ATHENA RODRIGUEZ, v. (3m JUDGMENT DAVID J. RODRIGUEZ, ELIA M. Complaint Filed: 03/06/19 AGUILAR, Trial Date: 10/23/23 Defendants. i This action came on for trial on October 23, 2023, in Department NNNNNNNN—LAAAAAAd—LA $27 of the San Bernardino County Superior Court, the Honorable Thomas ORHGRNN S. Garza, Judge presiding; Plaintiff John Hyle appearing along with his counsel of record Lauren Vogt and Lynn P. Whitlock, and defendant Arianna Athena Rodriguez appearing along with her attorneys of record Tracy W. Goldberg and Heather K. Gray and David Erghelegiu of Keith L. Shoji and Associates. A jury of twelve individuals was regularly impaneled and sworn. FAXED Witnesses were sworn and testified. After hearing the evidence and arguments of counsel and having been duly instructed by the court. the cause was submitted to the jury with directions to return a verdict. The Nm jury deliberated and rendered its verdict on November 14, 2023. _ 1 _ (PROPOSED) JUDGMENT \a \u The jury found in favor of plaintiff and against the defendant as follows: Question No. 1: Was Arianna Athena Rodriguez negligent? ANSWER: YES Question No. 2: Was Arianna Athena Rodriguez negligence a substantial O‘DmeU’I-th-fi factor in causing harm to John Hyle? ANSWER: YES Question No. 3: What are John Hyle’s damages? a. Past economic loss loss earnings: $0 medical expenses: $2,407.00 b. Past noneconomic loss, including physical pain and mental suffering $0 Total: $2,407.00 It appearing by reason of said verdict that plaintiff John Hyle is entitled to judgment against defendant Arianna Athena Rodriguez. NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGES AND DECREED that said plaintiff John Hyle shall and does have judgment against defendant, Arianna Athena Rodriguez in the amount of two thousand four hundred and seven dollars ($2,407.00). DATED: No mbequj_ 2023 Hon/THOMAS s. GARZAQDGE - 2 - (PROPOSED) JUDGMENT