On January 27, 2020 a
Verdict
was filed
involving a dispute between
Hardy, Illya,
Hardy, Johanna Barlund,
Topline K9 Services,
and
Animal Emergency Clinic,
Rios, Dvm, Grace,
for Personal Injury Non-Motor Vehicle Unlimited
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
Drioflmfi
.—
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF " o ‘
I
N -
FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARD u‘-'
w
A
ILLYA HARDY, an individual; Case No. CIV DS 2002744
JOHANNA BARLUND HARDY, an g Dept. $28
O\.U‘I
individual; TOPLINE K9 SERVICES,
Action Filin Date: January 27,2020
Plaintiffs, ) Trial Date: eptember 25, 2023
fl
vs. [Prom SPECIAL VERDICT
00
GRACE RIOS, D.V.M., an Individual;
\O ANIMAL EMERGENCY CLINIC; and g
DOES 1- 50, inclusive,
O.
Defendants.
— g
N
w
We, the jury in the above entitled action, find the following special verdict
->
0n the following questions submitted to us:
m
O\
\)
\o.m
o
fl
W.N
A
U1
Special Verdict - Page l of 10
I. Special Verdict Re: Liabilityfor Negligence
AW.N
Question No. l :
Was either defendant negligent in the diagnosis or treatment of the plaintiffs’
dog, Chaya?
Answer "yes" or "no" for each individual defendant:
N.ow
Grace Rios, DVM Answer: NO
00 Animal Emergency Clinic Answer: N0
10 If you answered Question No. 1
"no" as to both defendants, proceed to
1r Question No. 3. If you answered "yes" to Question No. 1 as to any defendant, then
12 answer the next question.
13
14 Question No. 2:
15 As to any defendant for whom your answer to Question No. 1 was “yes,”
16 was the negligence of that defendant a substantial factor in causing harm t0 Chaya?
17 Answer "yes" or "no":
18 Grace Rios, DVM Answer:
19. Animal Emergency Clinic Answer:
20
21 If you answered Question No. 2 "no" as t0 both defendants, proceed to
22 Question No. 3.
23
24
25
Special Verdict - Page 2 of 10
Document Filed Date
November 08, 2023
Case Filing Date
January 27, 2020
Category
Personal Injury Non-Motor Vehicle Unlimited
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
Drioflmfi .— SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF " o ‘ I N - FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARD u‘-' w A ILLYA HARDY, an individual; Case No. CIV DS 2002744 JOHANNA BARLUND HARDY, an g Dept. $28 O\.U‘I individual; TOPLINE K9 SERVICES, Action Filin Date: January 27,2020 Plaintiffs, ) Trial Date: eptember 25, 2023 fl vs. [Prom SPECIAL VERDICT 00 GRACE RIOS, D.V.M., an Individual; \O ANIMAL EMERGENCY CLINIC; and g DOES 1- 50, inclusive, O. Defendants. — g N w We, the jury in the above entitled action, find the following special verdict -> 0n the following questions submitted to us: m O\ \) \o.m o fl W.N A U1 Special Verdict - Page l of 10 I. Special Verdict Re: Liabilityfor Negligence AW.N Question No. l : Was either defendant negligent in the diagnosis or treatment of the plaintiffs’ dog, Chaya? Answer "yes" or "no" for each individual defendant: N.ow Grace Rios, DVM Answer: NO 00 Animal Emergency Clinic Answer: N0 10 If you answered Question No. 1 "no" as to both defendants, proceed to 1r Question No. 3. If you answered "yes" to Question No. 1 as to any defendant, then 12 answer the next question. 13 14 Question No. 2: 15 As to any defendant for whom your answer to Question No. 1 was “yes,” 16 was the negligence of that defendant a substantial factor in causing harm t0 Chaya? 17 Answer "yes" or "no": 18 Grace Rios, DVM Answer: 19. Animal Emergency Clinic Answer: 20 21 If you answered Question No. 2 "no" as t0 both defendants, proceed to 22 Question No. 3. 23 24 25 Special Verdict - Page 2 of 10