On May 16, 2022 a
EXHIBIT(S) - A - Stipulated Errata Sheet For Transcript of December 19, 2023 Proceedings
was filed
involving a dispute between
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.,,
and
Mpeg La, L.L.C.,,
for Commercial - Contract - Commercial Division
in the District Court of New York County.
Preview
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 01:01 PM INDEX NO. 656312/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 262 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
--------------------------------------------------------------------- x
:
SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD., :
:
: Index No. 656312/2022
Plaintiff, :
: Hon. Melissa A. Crane, J.S.C.
vs. : Part 60
:
MPEG LA, L.L.C., :
:
:
:
:
Defendant. :
:
--------------------------------------------------------------------- x
ERRATA SHEET FOR THE TRANSCRIPT OF THE PROCEEDINGS BEFORE
JUSTICE CRANE ON DECEMBER 19, 2023
Page Line Original Correction Reason
3 22 allocution allocation Transcription
Error
4 15-16 there are about 87 percent there are about—87 percent Transcription
of the licensors voted in of the licensors voted in Error
favor of the amendment. favor of the amendment.
4 18 a entity an entity Spelling Error
4 24 there is only 11 votes on there is only 1 vote on Transcription
changing the allocation changing the allocation Error
5 3 with this voting, with this voting procedure, Transcription
Error
6 10 Mr. Shin: These Mr. Shin - These Transcription
Error
6 11-12 at 183 to 84. at pages 183 to 184. Transcription
Error
6 13 Mr. Hong: No Mr. Hong – No Transcription
Error
6 14 at 55. at page 55. Transcription
Error
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 01:01 PM INDEX NO. 656312/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 262 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024
6 23 50 percent fifty (50) percent Transcription
Error
6 24 amended definition Amended Definition Transcription
Error
7 21 anyway any way Spelling Error
7 22 publically publicly Spelling Error
8 1 decide decided Transcription
Error
8 11 6.3 of the AAL section 6.3 of the AAL Transcription
Error
8 22 counsels's counsel's Spelling Error
9 4 be belt be a belt Transcription
Error
9 6 ridge rigged Transcription
Error
9 12 It’s I It’s: I Transcription
Error
10 1 MPEG LA says all we MPEG LA says, “all we need Transcription
need is three fourths is three fourths” Error
10 2 Because their Because of their Transcription
Error
10 7 worse worst Transcription
Error
10 12-13 group of licenses that group of Licensors that Transcription
collectively receive 80 collectively received 80 Error
percent of the royalties the percent of the royalties over
the
11 7 just tally just a tally Transcription
Error
11 14 required 75 required to receive 75 Clarification
11 21 you can do it for you can only do it for Clarification
12 1 verba verbiage Transcription
Error
12 20 respectively respectfully Transcription
Error
13 4-5 rights that parties that rights of parties that Transcription
Error
13 9 has enjoined those parties hasn’t joined those parties Transcription
Error
2
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 01:01 PM INDEX NO. 656312/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 262 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024
13 25 got the right had the right Transcription
Error
14 2 actions of nonparties in a actions of nonparties to this Transcription
contract lawsuit in a contract Error
15 7 you've to determine you've got to determine Transcription
Error
15 10-11 performing his obligations performing its obligations Transcription
Error
15 11 under the licensing under the licensing Transcription
administrator, administrator agreement, Error
16 7 do the licensor sue the licensors Transcription
Error
16 19-20 licensors decide to vote licensors decided to vote Transcription
Error
16 23 the voting was tallied. the vote was tallied. Transcription
Error
17 4 6.2.1 6.3.1 Clarification
19 9 born borne Spelling Error
20 14 And to the extent that we And to that extent that we Transcription
need to in order to need to, in order to Error
21 1-2 counsel also counsel also Transcription
mischaracterized Licensing mischaracterized Licensing Error
Administrator Section 5.2. Administrator Agreement
Section 5.2.
22 9 LAA AAL Transcription
Error
22 19 I don’t think it’s clear I don’t think it’s clever Transcription
Error
23 16 It must be a merger clause There must be a merger Transcription
clause Error
23 22 as the way as to the way Transcription
Error
24 3 terminated licensors’ share terminated licensors’ shares Transcription
Error
24 7 thank you “thank you” Transcription
Error
25 8 I’ve changed my mind I’ll change my mind Transcription
Error
25 23 were not met. were not met? Transcription
Error
26 1-2 obligations under the obligations under the Transcription
licensing administrator licensing administrator Error
3
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 01:01 PM INDEX NO. 656312/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 262 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024
agreement because as to agreement? Because, as to
that, that,
27 10 is Samsung were entitled is if Samsung was entitled Transcription
Error
27 12 position confirmed by Mr. position is confirmed by Mr. Transcription
Horns’s affidavit Horn’s affidavit Error
27 20 First, Samsung has no First, Samsung has no rights Transcription
rights under the AAL under AAL Section Error
Section
27 22 once it terminates, once it terminated, Transcription
Error
27 24 under Section 5 under the Section 5 Transcription
apportionment apportionment Error
28 4 read a really peculiar reach a really peculiar Transcription
conclusion conclusion Error
28 23 include agreement among include agreement among Transcription
the licensors 7.2.2 licensors section 7.2.2 Error
29 4 amendment provision amended provision Transcription
Error
29 21 pursuant to Section 5 pursuant to the Section 5 Transcription
allocation allocation Error
30 3 Article 5 doesn’t apply in Article 5 doesn’t apply to Transcription
Samsung. Samsung. Error
30 20 can not cannot Spelling Error
31 9-10 Samsung adds to the Samsung adds to the Transcription
contractual language, it contractual language, it says Error
says that from each that “from each sublicensee”
sublicensee. Really means really means from each
from each sublicensee sublicensee based
based
31 22-23 It provides for a single It provides for a single Transcription
termination. A single apportionment. Error
apportionment.
32 14 but do have an obligation but does have an obligation Transcription
Error
33 10 patent law, patent laws, Transcription
Error
33 14-15 for patent that are included for patents that are included Transcription
Error
34 12 two paths. two paths -- Transcription
Error
34 22 to the licensee to the licensees Transcription
Error
4
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 01:01 PM INDEX NO. 656312/2022
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 262 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024
36 13-14 nonparties to the nonparties to the lawsuit. Mistake
agreement.
37 3 warrant weren’t Transcription
Error
39 7 903,611 $903,611 Clarification
39 11 needs to. needs to do. Transcription
Error
40 9 payment payments Transcription
Error
Dated: February 7, 2024
/s/ Owen F. Roberts
Michael B. Carlinsky
William B. Adams
Owen F. Roberts
51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor
New York, New York 10010
(212) 849-7000
michaelcarlinsky@quinnemanuel.com
williamadams@quinnemanuel.com
owenroberts@quinnemanuel.com
Kevin Hardy (pro hac vice pending)
1300 I Street, N.W., Suite 900
Washington, DC 20005
(202) 538-8000
kevinhardy@quinnemanuel.com
Attorneys for Plaintiff Samsung Electronics Co.,
LTD.
/s/ Garrard R. Beeney
Garrard R. Beeney
Austin P. Mayron
Morgan R. Knudtsen
SULLIVAN & CROMWELL LLP
125 Broad Street
New York, New York 10004
Telephone: (212) 558-4000
Fax: (212) 558-3588
Attorneys for Defendant MPEG LA, L.L.C.
5
Document Filed Date
February 07, 2024
Case Filing Date
May 16, 2022
Category
Commercial - Contract - Commercial Division
Status
Disposed-Court Date/Application Pending
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 01:01 PM INDEX NO. 656312/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 262 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK --------------------------------------------------------------------- x : SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD., : : : Index No. 656312/2022 Plaintiff, : : Hon. Melissa A. Crane, J.S.C. vs. : Part 60 : MPEG LA, L.L.C., : : : : : Defendant. : : --------------------------------------------------------------------- x ERRATA SHEET FOR THE TRANSCRIPT OF THE PROCEEDINGS BEFORE JUSTICE CRANE ON DECEMBER 19, 2023 Page Line Original Correction Reason 3 22 allocution allocation Transcription Error 4 15-16 there are about 87 percent there are about—87 percent Transcription of the licensors voted in of the licensors voted in Error favor of the amendment. favor of the amendment. 4 18 a entity an entity Spelling Error 4 24 there is only 11 votes on there is only 1 vote on Transcription changing the allocation changing the allocation Error 5 3 with this voting, with this voting procedure, Transcription Error 6 10 Mr. Shin: These Mr. Shin - These Transcription Error 6 11-12 at 183 to 84. at pages 183 to 184. Transcription Error 6 13 Mr. Hong: No Mr. Hong – No Transcription Error 6 14 at 55. at page 55. Transcription Error FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 01:01 PM INDEX NO. 656312/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 262 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 6 23 50 percent fifty (50) percent Transcription Error 6 24 amended definition Amended Definition Transcription Error 7 21 anyway any way Spelling Error 7 22 publically publicly Spelling Error 8 1 decide decided Transcription Error 8 11 6.3 of the AAL section 6.3 of the AAL Transcription Error 8 22 counsels's counsel's Spelling Error 9 4 be belt be a belt Transcription Error 9 6 ridge rigged Transcription Error 9 12 It’s I It’s: I Transcription Error 10 1 MPEG LA says all we MPEG LA says, “all we need Transcription need is three fourths is three fourths” Error 10 2 Because their Because of their Transcription Error 10 7 worse worst Transcription Error 10 12-13 group of licenses that group of Licensors that Transcription collectively receive 80 collectively received 80 Error percent of the royalties the percent of the royalties over the 11 7 just tally just a tally Transcription Error 11 14 required 75 required to receive 75 Clarification 11 21 you can do it for you can only do it for Clarification 12 1 verba verbiage Transcription Error 12 20 respectively respectfully Transcription Error 13 4-5 rights that parties that rights of parties that Transcription Error 13 9 has enjoined those parties hasn’t joined those parties Transcription Error 2 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 01:01 PM INDEX NO. 656312/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 262 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 13 25 got the right had the right Transcription Error 14 2 actions of nonparties in a actions of nonparties to this Transcription contract lawsuit in a contract Error 15 7 you've to determine you've got to determine Transcription Error 15 10-11 performing his obligations performing its obligations Transcription Error 15 11 under the licensing under the licensing Transcription administrator, administrator agreement, Error 16 7 do the licensor sue the licensors Transcription Error 16 19-20 licensors decide to vote licensors decided to vote Transcription Error 16 23 the voting was tallied. the vote was tallied. Transcription Error 17 4 6.2.1 6.3.1 Clarification 19 9 born borne Spelling Error 20 14 And to the extent that we And to that extent that we Transcription need to in order to need to, in order to Error 21 1-2 counsel also counsel also Transcription mischaracterized Licensing mischaracterized Licensing Error Administrator Section 5.2. Administrator Agreement Section 5.2. 22 9 LAA AAL Transcription Error 22 19 I don’t think it’s clear I don’t think it’s clever Transcription Error 23 16 It must be a merger clause There must be a merger Transcription clause Error 23 22 as the way as to the way Transcription Error 24 3 terminated licensors’ share terminated licensors’ shares Transcription Error 24 7 thank you “thank you” Transcription Error 25 8 I’ve changed my mind I’ll change my mind Transcription Error 25 23 were not met. were not met? Transcription Error 26 1-2 obligations under the obligations under the Transcription licensing administrator licensing administrator Error 3 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 01:01 PM INDEX NO. 656312/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 262 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 agreement because as to agreement? Because, as to that, that, 27 10 is Samsung were entitled is if Samsung was entitled Transcription Error 27 12 position confirmed by Mr. position is confirmed by Mr. Transcription Horns’s affidavit Horn’s affidavit Error 27 20 First, Samsung has no First, Samsung has no rights Transcription rights under the AAL under AAL Section Error Section 27 22 once it terminates, once it terminated, Transcription Error 27 24 under Section 5 under the Section 5 Transcription apportionment apportionment Error 28 4 read a really peculiar reach a really peculiar Transcription conclusion conclusion Error 28 23 include agreement among include agreement among Transcription the licensors 7.2.2 licensors section 7.2.2 Error 29 4 amendment provision amended provision Transcription Error 29 21 pursuant to Section 5 pursuant to the Section 5 Transcription allocation allocation Error 30 3 Article 5 doesn’t apply in Article 5 doesn’t apply to Transcription Samsung. Samsung. Error 30 20 can not cannot Spelling Error 31 9-10 Samsung adds to the Samsung adds to the Transcription contractual language, it contractual language, it says Error says that from each that “from each sublicensee” sublicensee. Really means really means from each from each sublicensee sublicensee based based 31 22-23 It provides for a single It provides for a single Transcription termination. A single apportionment. Error apportionment. 32 14 but do have an obligation but does have an obligation Transcription Error 33 10 patent law, patent laws, Transcription Error 33 14-15 for patent that are included for patents that are included Transcription Error 34 12 two paths. two paths -- Transcription Error 34 22 to the licensee to the licensees Transcription Error 4 FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 02/07/2024 01:01 PM INDEX NO. 656312/2022 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 262 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 02/07/2024 36 13-14 nonparties to the nonparties to the lawsuit. Mistake agreement. 37 3 warrant weren’t Transcription Error 39 7 903,611 $903,611 Clarification 39 11 needs to. needs to do. Transcription Error 40 9 payment payments Transcription Error Dated: February 7, 2024 /s/ Owen F. Roberts Michael B. Carlinsky William B. Adams Owen F. Roberts 51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor New York, New York 10010 (212) 849-7000 michaelcarlinsky@quinnemanuel.com williamadams@quinnemanuel.com owenroberts@quinnemanuel.com Kevin Hardy (pro hac vice pending) 1300 I Street, N.W., Suite 900 Washington, DC 20005 (202) 538-8000 kevinhardy@quinnemanuel.com Attorneys for Plaintiff Samsung Electronics Co., LTD. /s/ Garrard R. Beeney Garrard R. Beeney Austin P. Mayron Morgan R. Knudtsen SULLIVAN & CROMWELL LLP 125 Broad Street New York, New York 10004 Telephone: (212) 558-4000 Fax: (212) 558-3588 Attorneys for Defendant MPEG LA, L.L.C. 5