On August 03, 2022 a
Order
was filed
involving a dispute between
Musharbash, Joseph,
and
American Medical Response,
American Medical Response, Inc.,
Cutler, M.D, Aaron,
Does 2-100, Inclusive,
Does 3 -100, Inclusive,
Gibani, M.D, Siraj,
Hide-A-While,
Hide-A-While Lounge,
Musharbash, Susan,
Rancho Cucamonga Fire Protection District,
San Antonio Regional Hospital,
Young, M.D, Richard,
City Of Rancho Cucamonga,
County Of San Bernardino,
for Medical Malpractice Unlimited
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
ELECTRONICALLY RECEIVED - 11/14/2023 1:47 PM -
By: Gloria Portillo. DEPUTY
SUPERIOR COURT OF
KELLY, TROTTER & FRANLEN , Weséwass
BFRH'ano 0.8mm
MICHAEL J. TROTTER (SBN 139034)
J0 LYNN VALOFF (SBN 177081) JAN 3 O 2021;
111 West Ocean Boulevard. 14th Floor
:0“ OBfficethx 12:636' BY "“‘f y, 4
ong eac a ornla 90801 -.4636
, I
Telephone No. (562) 432—5855 / Facsimile No. (562) 432—8785
“mm" U ‘
er.
A~ :5-.—
AL. ozpufii
mitrotterm kellvtrotterxom /ilvaloff(a kellvtrotter.com
Attorneys for Defendants. Siraj Gibani. M.D.. Aaron Cutler, M.D. and Richard Young, M.D.
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO
JOSEPH MUSHARBASH, an individual and as CASE NO.: ClVSBZZl71 I7
Successor-in-lnterest to the Estate
MUSHARBASH,
ofMlCHAEb
IW|
SUMMARY
ORDER RE: MOTION FOR
JUDGMENT AND
Plaintiffs. ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR
SUMMARY ADJUDICATION 0F
VS- DEFENDANT RICHARD YOUNG, M.D.
SAN ANTONIO REGIONAL HOSPITAL; [FILED CONCURRENTLY WITH NOTICE 0F
AMERICAN MEDICAL RESPONSE; SlRAJ MOTION AND MOTION FOR SUMMARY
GIBANL Ml); AARON CUTLER, MIDI; JUDGMENT/SUMMARY ADJUDICATION.
‘ « < SEPARATE STATEMENT UNDISPUTED 0F
RICHARD YOUNG’ M'D" HIDE-AWHth- .
MATERIAL FACTS: DECLARATIONS OF
LOUNGE; and DOES 1'100‘ inCIUSiVC‘ GEOFFREY COLBY. MD. AND 10 LYNN VALOFF.;
EVIDENCE; AND NOTICE 0F LODGMENT]
Defendants.
DATE: January 30, 2024
TIME: 8:30 a.m.
DEPT.: Sl4
ASSIGNED FOR ALL PURPOSES TO:
JUDGE: HON. JEFFREYR. ERICKSON
DEPARTMENT: $14
Complaint Filed: 8/5/22
Trial Date: 6/l7/24
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on January 30, 2024, at 8:30 a.m., in the abovc-captioncd
Court, the Motion for Summary Judgment and alternative Motion for Summary Adjudication
brought by Defendant. Richard Young. M.D., came on regularly for hearing.
E:\l I “6966-01 Pld\MSJN'()LlN(i~PR()P()Sl—.l) ()Rl)H{.l)ocx l
[BRQPQ-S'ED] ORDERRE: MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR
SUMMARY ADJUDICATION ()F DEFENDANT RICHARD YOUNG. MD.
Aficr full consideration of the evidence, oral argument by the parties, all documents
submitted, including the Separate Statement of the moving defendant, the Declarations ofGeoffrey
Colby, MD. and Jo Lynn Valoff. and the authorities submitted by defendant herein,
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED:
“©111th
l. Thc Motion for Summary Judgment of defendant, Richard Young, M.D. is
GRANTED;
2. That plaintiff Joseph Musharbash shall take nothing, and that judgment be entered
in favor of defendant, Richard Young, M.D.;
3. Costs to be determined according to proof.
10 IN THE ALTERNATIVE,
11 After full consideration of the evidence, oral argument by the parties, all documents
12 submitted, including the Separate Statement 0f the moving defendant, the Declarations ofGeoffrey
13 Colby, M.D. and Jo Lynn Valoff, and the authorities submitted by defendants herein, Summary
14 Adjudication is granted as follows:
15 1. No triable issue ofmaterial fact exists and Summary Adjudication is granted on the
16 issue of whether defendant, Richard Young, M.D., complied with the standard of care; or
17 2. No triable issue of material fact exists with regard t0 whether any act or omission
18 by defendant Richard Young, MD. caused plaintiff‘s injuries and damages, and Summary
19 Adjudication is granted on the issue of causation; or
20 3. No triable issue of material fact exists with regard to whether damages for mental
21 anguish, psychological and emotional distress are barred as a matter of law.
22 IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED:
23 l. That Plaintiff Joseph Musharbash shall take nothing, and that judgment be entered
24 in favor of defendant, Richard Young, M.D.; and
25 ///
26 ///
27 ///
28 ///
E:\l l l\6966~01\Pld\MSI\YOUNG\PROPOSED ORDERDocx 2
[PRC?OS'BD] ORDER MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR
RE:
SUMMARY ADJUDICATION OF DEFENDANT RICHARD YOUNG, MD.
Preview
ELECTRONICALLY RECEIVED - 11/14/2023 1:47 PM - By: Gloria Portillo. DEPUTY SUPERIOR COURT OF KELLY, TROTTER & FRANLEN , Weséwass BFRH'ano 0.8mm MICHAEL J. TROTTER (SBN 139034) J0 LYNN VALOFF (SBN 177081) JAN 3 O 2021; 111 West Ocean Boulevard. 14th Floor :0“ OBfficethx 12:636' BY "“‘f y, 4 ong eac a ornla 90801 -.4636 , I Telephone No. (562) 432—5855 / Facsimile No. (562) 432—8785 “mm" U ‘ er. A~ :5-.— AL. ozpufii mitrotterm kellvtrotterxom /ilvaloff(a kellvtrotter.com Attorneys for Defendants. Siraj Gibani. M.D.. Aaron Cutler, M.D. and Richard Young, M.D. SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA FOR THE COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO JOSEPH MUSHARBASH, an individual and as CASE NO.: ClVSBZZl71 I7 Successor-in-lnterest to the Estate MUSHARBASH, ofMlCHAEb IW| SUMMARY ORDER RE: MOTION FOR JUDGMENT AND Plaintiffs. ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION 0F VS- DEFENDANT RICHARD YOUNG, M.D. SAN ANTONIO REGIONAL HOSPITAL; [FILED CONCURRENTLY WITH NOTICE 0F AMERICAN MEDICAL RESPONSE; SlRAJ MOTION AND MOTION FOR SUMMARY GIBANL Ml); AARON CUTLER, MIDI; JUDGMENT/SUMMARY ADJUDICATION. ‘ « < SEPARATE STATEMENT UNDISPUTED 0F RICHARD YOUNG’ M'D" HIDE-AWHth- . MATERIAL FACTS: DECLARATIONS OF LOUNGE; and DOES 1'100‘ inCIUSiVC‘ GEOFFREY COLBY. MD. AND 10 LYNN VALOFF.; EVIDENCE; AND NOTICE 0F LODGMENT] Defendants. DATE: January 30, 2024 TIME: 8:30 a.m. DEPT.: Sl4 ASSIGNED FOR ALL PURPOSES TO: JUDGE: HON. JEFFREYR. ERICKSON DEPARTMENT: $14 Complaint Filed: 8/5/22 Trial Date: 6/l7/24 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on January 30, 2024, at 8:30 a.m., in the abovc-captioncd Court, the Motion for Summary Judgment and alternative Motion for Summary Adjudication brought by Defendant. Richard Young. M.D., came on regularly for hearing. E:\l I “6966-01 Pld\MSJN'()LlN(i~PR()P()Sl—.l) ()Rl)H{.l)ocx l [BRQPQ-S'ED] ORDERRE: MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION ()F DEFENDANT RICHARD YOUNG. MD. Aficr full consideration of the evidence, oral argument by the parties, all documents submitted, including the Separate Statement of the moving defendant, the Declarations ofGeoffrey Colby, MD. and Jo Lynn Valoff. and the authorities submitted by defendant herein, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED: “©111th l. Thc Motion for Summary Judgment of defendant, Richard Young, M.D. is GRANTED; 2. That plaintiff Joseph Musharbash shall take nothing, and that judgment be entered in favor of defendant, Richard Young, M.D.; 3. Costs to be determined according to proof. 10 IN THE ALTERNATIVE, 11 After full consideration of the evidence, oral argument by the parties, all documents 12 submitted, including the Separate Statement 0f the moving defendant, the Declarations ofGeoffrey 13 Colby, M.D. and Jo Lynn Valoff, and the authorities submitted by defendants herein, Summary 14 Adjudication is granted as follows: 15 1. No triable issue ofmaterial fact exists and Summary Adjudication is granted on the 16 issue of whether defendant, Richard Young, M.D., complied with the standard of care; or 17 2. No triable issue of material fact exists with regard t0 whether any act or omission 18 by defendant Richard Young, MD. caused plaintiff‘s injuries and damages, and Summary 19 Adjudication is granted on the issue of causation; or 20 3. No triable issue of material fact exists with regard to whether damages for mental 21 anguish, psychological and emotional distress are barred as a matter of law. 22 IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DECREED: 23 l. That Plaintiff Joseph Musharbash shall take nothing, and that judgment be entered 24 in favor of defendant, Richard Young, M.D.; and 25 /// 26 /// 27 /// 28 /// E:\l l l\6966~01\Pld\MSI\YOUNG\PROPOSED ORDERDocx 2 [PRC?OS'BD] ORDER MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR RE: SUMMARY ADJUDICATION OF DEFENDANT RICHARD YOUNG, MD.