Preview
INDEX NO. E2023004004
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 32 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/20/2023
MONROE COUNTY CLERK’S OFFICE THIS IS NOT A BILL. THIS IS YOUR RECEIPT.
Receipt # 3644015
Book Page CIVIL
Return To: No. Pages: 10
ESTHER S. GABRIEL
333 W. Washington Street Instrument: EXHIBIT(S)
Suite 200
Syracuse, NY 13202 Control #: 202311200774
Index #: E2023004004
Date: 11/20/2023
ESL Federal Credit Union Time: 12:44:40 PM
Shufelt, Eileen M.
John Doe and/or Mary Roe
Total Fees Paid: $0.00
Employee:
State of New York
MONROE COUNTY CLERK’S OFFICE
WARNING — THIS SHEET CONSTITUTES THE CLERKS
ENDORSEMENT, REQUIRED BY SECTION 317-a(5) &
SECTION 319 OF THE REAL PROPERTY LAW OF THE
STATE OF NEW YORK. DO NOT DETACH OR REMOVE.
JAMIE ROMEO
MONROE COUNTY CLERK
MI
INDH&x HOE 228023001004
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 32 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/20/2023
EXHIBIT WK”
rt POO hk INDIEXNG E 2823003000004
MONRO OUN
NYBC Fe aD OE COUNTY CLERK 0 RECELVED
DAP ZO29005 904 2023
NYSCEF Doc. NO. 14 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 08/01/2023
Harris Beach, PLLC 333 Wusr Wasninaron Sracer, Sutrs 200 Syracuse, NY 13202
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE Client's File No.:
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Index Number: 2023004004
CALINTV AE MANA Dato File July 20, 2023
eae ESL Federal Credit Union,
vs Plaintif(sy/Petitoner(s)
mee Eileen M. Shufelt aka Bileen M. Shufelt aka Eileen M. Shufet, et al.
Detendanl(s)/Respondent(s)
STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE , SS.:
The undersigned being duly sworn deposes and says: that deponent Is not a party to this action, is over 18 years of age and
resides in the State of New York. That on the following date: July 31, 2023 , at the following time: 9:17 AM :
at 77 Windsor Road, Rochester, NY 14612 deponent served the within
Notice of Electronic Filing and Certificate of Merit Pursuant to CPLR 2012-b
[X] Papers so served were properly endorsed with the Index Number and date of filing,
Upon: Elleen M. Shufelt aka Elleen M. Shufelt aka Elleen M. Shufet .
Cinatviduat By delivering a true copy thereof to sald recipient personally; deponent knew the person so served to be the Individual described therein, .
[gRosponsibio By delivering to and leaving with Josh Shufelt , Son/Co--Occupant
Person Relationship
a true copy thereof, a person of sultable age and discretion. Sald premises being the defendant / respondent's
[x] dwelling place [ ] place of business/employment [ ] last known address within the State. [ ] usual place of abode
ma A copy thereof was deposited in a postpald, properly addressed envelope, marked “Personal and Confidential" In a depository maintained
by the U, S, P, S, and malled to the above address on July 31, 2023
[Corporation By delivering to and leaving with sald Individual to be
LLC / LLP who specifically stated he/she was authorized to accept service on benall of the Corporation/Government Agency/EntIty,
[CAffixing By affixing a true copy thereof to the door,being the defendantrespondent's [ } dwelling place [| place of business/employment
‘To Door [ ] last known address within the Stale, [ ] usual place of abode
Clprevious Deponent previously attempted to serve the above named defendantrespondent on:
Attempts
Description Sex: Male Color of skin: White Color of halr: Brown Age: 24-32 Yrs Helght: 56". 519"
of Reciplont weight: 140-170 Other , Beard/Mustache
Features:
| asked the person spoken to whether the defendant/respondent was In active military service and recelved a negative reply. The person
(KMilitary spoken with wore ordinary civilian clothes and no military uniform. The source of my information and the grounds of my bellef are the
Servic conversations and observations defendant/respondent narrated above. Upon information and bellef, | aver that the reciplent Is not In
military sarvica
[other
AY 5/92
Sworn to before me on
NOTARY PUBLIC
CASSANDRA RK RABE PROCESS SERVER LICENSE #.
Notary Public - State of New York
No, O1RA6439208 Work Order # 2059840
Qualified in Monroe08/20/2026
County:
PZ
Commission Expires:
Papen Cuast NY, LLC, 349 W. Commercia Street, Surre 2360, East Rocnester, NY 14445
2 of 2
Q0
MONRO hk WV
5
INDIEXNG E 2823003000004
OUN [207
NYSC TED
NYSCEF
NOMONROE
DOC. NO.
COUNTY CLERK 08/01/2023 12:0 PM] RECE
ANSCEIV
E ' nbasER
2042003
15
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 08/01/2023
SUPREME COURT OF STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR
(Single Attorney Authorizing Filing Agent Entit
y)
see 4 Esther S. Gabriel Esq,, ( Attorney Registration No.
Jam
play GASP
‘ized
Aose 1D 808
user of the New York State Courts Electronic Piling .
12325880 ). Thereby authori ize any employee of
ID to file document ts on my behalf and at my directi who possessesa filing agent
which I am counsel 1 of record through the NYSCEF on, as afi linga; nt, in any e-filed matter in
Uniform Rules for the Trial Courts, system, as p: ided in Section 202,5-b ofthe
This authorization extends to anyly consensual matter in which
consented to e-filing, to any mandato!ry matter in which I have previously
T have recorded my Tepresentation, and
to any y matterin which I may autho: rize the filing agent
fat to record my consent or representa! tion
‘This authorization extends to any and all documents
agent for filing in any such matter, This authorization, postedI generate and submit to the
each matter in which I am counsel of, record, shall be deemed toonce on the NYSCEF: website aa to
accom
in that matter by the filing agent, pany any document filed
This authorization also extends to matters of payment, which the filing agent may make
elther by debiting an account the filiny ig agent maintains s with the County Clerk
e-filing county or by debiting an account I maintain with the County of any authorized
ling county. Clerk of any authorized e
‘This authorization regarding this fill ing agent shall contin
on a prescribedform delivered to the E-Filing Resource ue until I revoke it inwriting
.
Dated; October 3, 2022
‘Syracuse, NY 13202
Signature City, State and Zip Code
Esther 8. Gabriel, Esq. 315-214-2016
Print Name Phone
Hanis Beach PLLG
egabriel@harrisbeach.com
Firm/Department E-Mail Address
333 West Washington Street, Suite 200
Soa
Street Address
(6/6/13)
lof1
hk INDIEXNG E 2823003000004
:NYS IMONROE COUNTY CLERK 04/29/2023 O1 PM RECEIVED NYSE Fico 923
004
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 4 SUPREME COURT RECE Glass ActlanbLLG 4/29/2023
County Monroe File Date 4/19/23 Affidavit # 477844
Index # E2023004004
Plaintiff(s): ESL Federal Credit Union AFFIDAVIT OF
SERVICE OF
Defendant(s): against SUMMONS, VERIFIED
Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, et. al. COMPLAINT, NOTICE
OF PENDENCY, E-FILE
NOTICE, 1303
NOTICE-HELP FOR
STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE
HOMEOWNERS**
Cynthia T. Chasse, being duly sworn, dey poses and says; depone
nt is not a party herein, | am over 18 years of age and
reside in the state of New York.
That on Wednesday, April 26, 2023 at 8: (08 pm at 77 Windsor
Road, Rochester, NY 14612, | served the within
Summons, Verified Complaint, Notice of Pendency, E-File Notice,
1303 Notice-Help for Homeowners*** on Eileen M.
Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, defendant therein nai med.
INDIVIDUAL by deliveri
ng a true copy of each to said defendant personally; depon
ent knew the person so served to be
DLXBZ<] the person described as said defendant therein. She identifi
ed herself.
CORPORATION
Oo
SUITABLE
AGE
Oo
AFFIXING TO
DOOR, ETC.
Oo
MAILING TO
RESIDENCE
Oo
MAILING TO
BUSINESS
Oo Sex Skin type Hair type Attributes Age Height Weight
0 Mate White Skin BW Black Hair O Balding 1 14-20 Yrs.
& Female Black Skin (Under 5' 1) Under 100 Lbs.
Brown Hair C1 Beard 21-36 Yrs. 50 t i2 100-130 Lbs.
DESCRIPTION C1 Yellow Skin 1] Blonde Hair "3° O 131-160
0) 36-50 Yrs. O54 Lbs.
qO White
XN Brown Skin Gray Hair CI Mustache
51-65 Yrs. Sig" O 161-200 Lbs.
O Red Skin Red Hair O Glasses 0 Over 65 Yrs. O] Over 6" O Over 200 Lbs.
Hair
Other features:
& Papers were endorsed with the index numb er and date of filing
shown above. Papers were served in
compliance with RPAPL Section 1303.
MILITARY
SERVICE To my best knowledge, information and belief after rea sonable
inquiry, the said defendant at the time of
&l service was not engaged in military service of the Unit led States.
“in Foreclosure in bold fourteen-point type and printed on color
paper, that is
complaint, and the title of the notice printed in bold twenty-point type in com; . other than the color of the summons and verified
ince with RPAPL Sect 1303.
Sworn to before me “G
a 2 70. Lh Cynthia T. Chasse
Yet |
LORNA M. DAVI As agent for Class Action LLC
NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF NEW YORK
nal
Registration No. 01DA6033422
Qualified In Monroe County
I"‘Ssinmtssion Expires Novers ao 6,
2 of 2
INDIEXNG E 2823003000004
NY@ fe MONROE COUNTY C. LED
Rat 2023 02 :01 PM) RECE TV EDORPSEEE2029999005:20023
iS ACUON LLU
NYSCEF DOC. NO. RECE A ESS ANBOBELS « 29/2003
County Monroe File Date 4/19/23 Index # E2023004004
Plaintiff(s) ESL Federal Credit Union AFFIDAVIT OF
SERVICE OF
Defendant(s): against SUMMONS,
COMPLAINT, E-FILE
Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, et. al
NOTICE, AND
CERTIFICATE OF MERIT
STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE
Cynthia T. Chasse, being duly sworn, deposes and says; deponent is not a party herein, | am over 18 years of age and
reside in the state of New York.
That on Wednesday, April 26, 2023 at 8:08 pm at 77 Windsor Road, Rochester, NY 14612, | served the within
Summons, Complaint, E-File Notice, and Certificate of Merit on Quinn Shufelt s/h/a Jane Doe, defendant therein named
INDIVIDUAL,
Oo
CORPORATION
O
by delivering thereat a true copy of each to Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, (mother), a person
SUITABLE
AGE of suitable age and discretion. Said premises is defendant's-actual-place-of-business-dwelling
place-usual place of abode-within the state.
Xl
AFFIXING TO
DOOR, ETC.
O
MAILING TO.
On 4/27/2023, deponent enclosed a copy of same in a first class postpaid properly addressed envelope
RESIDENCE marked "Personal and Confidential" in an official depository under the exclusive care and custody of the
United States Post Office in the State of New York to the defendant at defendant's last known address,
x at 77 Windsor Road, Rochester, NY 14612.
MAILING TO
BUSINESS
QO Sex Skin type lair typ Attribute Age Height Weight
0 Male White Skin @ Black Hair Balding 1] 14-20 Yrs. Under 5° 1 Under 100 Lbs.
i Female 1 Black Skin 1 Brown Hair 0 Beard 1 21-35 Yrs. & 5'0"-5'3" BY 100-130 Los.
DESCRIPTION (1 Yellow Skin O Blonde Hair 1 Mustache 1 36-50 Yrs. 0 54"5'8" 1 131-160 Lbs.
1 Brown Skin O Gray Hair 81-65 Yrs. Os5'9"-6'0" 1 161-200 Lbs.
O Red Skin O Red Hair O Glasses (1 Over 65 Yrs. [1 Over 6 Over 200 Lbs.
1 White Hair
Other features:
Oo
MILITARY
SERVICE To my best knowledge, information and belief after reasonable inquiry, the said defendant at the time of
xX service was not engaged in military service of the United States.
Derek
Sworn to before me on Ia Lee CZ,
Cynthia T. Chasse
Yale|
—~TORNA M.j. DAVI As agent for Class Action LLC
PUBLIC, STATE OF NEW vor |
J
| som
Registration No, 01DA6033422
Qualified in Monroe Gounty
seion Expires Novemnbe! 20,
2 of 2
hk INDIEXNG E 2823003000004
OUN [207
NY BD LONROE COUNTY CLERK 04 /2023 02:01 PM RECELVEND
RPS EE AOR99 98H 9933
NYSCEF DOC. NO SUPREME COURT RECEIVED Glase AstionuyhG /2023
Affidavit # 477846
County Monroe File Date 4/19/23 Index # E2023004004
Plaintiff(s): ESL Federal Credit Union
Defendant(s): against AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING
Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, et. al
STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE SS
Dylan J. Frankel, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
That | am not a party to this action, am over eighteen (18) years, and reside in the state of New York.
That on April 28, 2023, Deponent mailed a copy of the Summons in this action on the defendant listed
below by first class mail in an envelope bearing the legend “personal and confidential" and not
indicating on the outside of the envelope that the communication is from an attorney or concerns an
alleged debt. Said mailing was made to the defendant's residence, place-ef business Jast knewn
address.
Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet
77 Windsor Road
Rochester, NY 14612
| believe the above statements are true and correct to the best of my knowledge.
5h Dylan J. Frankel
As agent for Class Action LLC
Sworn to before me on, April 28, 2023
2 “|
a é‘
Notary
“—~TORNA M. DAL
| NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF NEW YORK
No, G1DA6033422
‘Qualified in Montae Gout
‘ommission Expires Novern! eS
2 of 2
OUN v ny 0 0 INDIEXNG E 2823003000004
NY. OE COUNTY CLE:BR Od 729) 2023 02:01 PM RECELVEN
RPE R222 09S99 119.23
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 7 SUPREME COURT RECEIVED ClassAptiond LG /2023
Affidavit # 477992
County Monroe File Date 4/19/23 Index # £2023004004
Plaintiff(s): ESL Federal Credit Union
AFFIDAVIT OF DELIVERY
Defendant(s): against OF RPAPL §1303 NOTICE
Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, et. al. ON TENANT
STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE SS:
Dylan J. Frankel, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
That I am not a party to this action, am over eighteen (18) years, and reside in the state of New
York.
That I mailed a copy of Notice required by RPAPL. §1303, which Notice, as delivered, was printed
on pink paper, the title of the Notice appeared to be in bold 20-point type, and the text appeared to
be in bold, 14-point type on the Defendant/Tenant named herein, in the following manner addressed
to:
Quinn Shufelt
77 Windsor Road
Rochester, NY 14612
As the premises has less than five units and the identity of the Tenant is known, | deposited said
Notice pursuant to RPAPL §1303 by depositing, in an official depository under the exclusive care and
custody of the United States post office in the State of New York a true copy of said Notice in a
postpaid, properly addressed envelope by first-class mail, addressed to the above-named
Defendant/Tenant on April 28, 2023.
That | deposited the same by certified mail/return receipt requested #7022 1670 0001 0432 9992
with the United States Post Office on April 28, 2023.
| believe the above statements are true and correct to the best of my knowledge.
ly
Dylan J. Frankel
Sworn to before me on, April 28, 2023. As agent for Class Action LLC
L
Notary |
2)
LORNA M. DAV
PT
“
i
© Ln
NOTARY PI STATEOF NEW YORK
Registration No, 01DA6033422
‘Qualified in Monroe County
enSi omission Expires Noverrtb:
—= 2 of 2
Q0 OUN hk WV INDIEXNG E 2823003000004
NYg MONROE COUNTY CLERK 04 2023 0. 201 PM} RECEIVEDION¥S
GBF 20200992028
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 8 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/29/2023
SUPREME COURT,QF STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF
STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR
E INTC
‘Single Attorney Authorizing Individual Filing Agent)
ATTN A: Esq., ( Attorney Registration No.
) am an authorized user of the New York State Courts Electronic Filing
System (“NYS ”) (User ID ). [hereby authorize
(“the filing agent”) to utilize his/her
NYSCEF filing agent ID to file documents on my behalf and at my direction in any e-filed matter
in which I am counsel of record through the NYSCEF system, as provided in Section 202.5-b of
the Uniform Rules for the Trial Courts.
This authorization extends to any consensual matter in which I have previously
consented to e-filing, to any mandatory matter in which I have recorded my representation, and
to any matter in which I may authorize the filing agent to record my consent or representation
in the NYSCEF system.
This authorization extends to any and all documents I generate and submit to the filing
agent for filing in any such matter. This authorization, posted once on the NYSCEF website as to
each matter in which I am counsel of record, shall be deemed to accompany any document filed
in that matter by the filing agent.
This authorization also extends to matters of payment, which the filing agent may make
either by debiting an account the filing agent maintains with the County Clerk of any authorized
e-filing county or by debiting an account I maintain with the County Clerk of any authorized e-
filing county.
This authorization ing this filing agent shall continue until I revoke it in writing
on a prescribed form delivered to the E-Filing Resource Center.
Dated: -29 -
MW fools, way 1 Heo
Signat City, Sat and ‘eS
Print Name Phone
LAcY are.bn Up
Firm/Department
MRIEN® LCT LAr? BN) CW
E-Mail Address
1Sd EWA $4
Street Address
(6/6/13)
2 of 2
OUN INDIEXNG E 2823003000004
E_ COUNTY CLERK 0570472083 02 RECELVENO
RARER 0299949845193
NYSCEF DOC. NO RECE. 5/04/2023
ayaa
County Monroe File Date 4/19/23 Index # E2023004004
EWDED
Plaintiff(s): ESL Federal Credit Union AFFIDAVIT OF
SERVICE OF
Defendant(s): against SUMMONS,
COMPLAINT, E-FILE
Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, et. al
NOTICE, CERTIFICATE
OF MERIT, 1303
NOTICE-HELP FOR
STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE HOMEOWNERS***
Cynthia T. Chasse, being duly sworn, deposes and says; deponent is not a party herein, | am over 18 years of age and
reside in the state of New York.
That on Wednesday, April 26, 2023 at 8:08 pm at 77 Windsor Road, Rochester, NY 14612, | served the within
Summons, Complaint, E-File Notice, Certificate of Merit, 1303 Notice-Help for Homeowners*** on Eileen M. Shufelt
a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, defendant therein named.
INDIVIDUAL, by delivering a true copy of each to said defendant personally; deponent knew the person so served to be
XM the person described as said defendant therein. She identified herself.
CORPORATION
O
SUITABLE
AGE
O
AFFIXING TO
DOOR, ETC.
O
MAILING TO.
RESIDENCE
O
MAILING TO
BUSINESS
Oo Sex Skin type Hair type Attributes Age Height Wei
O Male I White Skin Black Hair O Balding C1 14-20 Yrs. Under 5° O Under 100 Lbs.
fd Female Black Skin C1 Brown Hair 121-35 Yrs. fa 5'0"-5'3" 100-130 Lbs.
O Beara
DESCRIPTION (Yellow Skin [1] Blonde Hair 1 Mustache 1 36-50 Yrs. O5'4".5'8" 131-160 Lbs.
(Brown Skin D Gray Hair 51-65 Yrs 0 5'9"-6'0" (1 161-200 Lbs.
(1 Red Skin O Red Hair O Glasses 1 Over
65 Yrs. [] Over 6' 1 Over 200 Lbs.
O White Hair
Other features:
X Papers were endorsed with the index number and date of filing shown above. Papers were served in
compliance with RPAPL Section 1303.
MILITARY
SERVICE To my best knowledge, information and belief after reasonable inquiry, the said defendant at the time of
>SZWY| service was not engaged in military service of the United States.
**in Foreclosure in bold fourteen-point type and printed on color paper, that is o) r than the color of the summons and complaint,
and the title of the notice printed in bold twenty-point type in compliance with R! L Sect 1303.
worms br 70 Lh Cynthia T. Chasse
'S agent for Class Action LLC
Sbfa3|
LORNA M.DAV
NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF NEW YORK
Registration No. 01DA6033422
Qualified in Monroe County
saion Expires Nevemb 0
2 of 2
Preview
INDEX NO. E2023004004 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 32 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/20/2023 MONROE COUNTY CLERK’S OFFICE THIS IS NOT A BILL. THIS IS YOUR RECEIPT. Receipt # 3644015 Book Page CIVIL Return To: No. Pages: 10 ESTHER S. GABRIEL 333 W. Washington Street Instrument: EXHIBIT(S) Suite 200 Syracuse, NY 13202 Control #: 202311200774 Index #: E2023004004 Date: 11/20/2023 ESL Federal Credit Union Time: 12:44:40 PM Shufelt, Eileen M. John Doe and/or Mary Roe Total Fees Paid: $0.00 Employee: State of New York MONROE COUNTY CLERK’S OFFICE WARNING — THIS SHEET CONSTITUTES THE CLERKS ENDORSEMENT, REQUIRED BY SECTION 317-a(5) & SECTION 319 OF THE REAL PROPERTY LAW OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK. DO NOT DETACH OR REMOVE. JAMIE ROMEO MONROE COUNTY CLERK MI INDH&x HOE 228023001004 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 32 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/20/2023 EXHIBIT WK” rt POO hk INDIEXNG E 2823003000004 MONRO OUN NYBC Fe aD OE COUNTY CLERK 0 RECELVED DAP ZO29005 904 2023 NYSCEF Doc. NO. 14 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 08/01/2023 Harris Beach, PLLC 333 Wusr Wasninaron Sracer, Sutrs 200 Syracuse, NY 13202 AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE Client's File No.: SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK Index Number: 2023004004 CALINTV AE MANA Dato File July 20, 2023 eae ESL Federal Credit Union, vs Plaintif(sy/Petitoner(s) mee Eileen M. Shufelt aka Bileen M. Shufelt aka Eileen M. Shufet, et al. Detendanl(s)/Respondent(s) STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE , SS.: The undersigned being duly sworn deposes and says: that deponent Is not a party to this action, is over 18 years of age and resides in the State of New York. That on the following date: July 31, 2023 , at the following time: 9:17 AM : at 77 Windsor Road, Rochester, NY 14612 deponent served the within Notice of Electronic Filing and Certificate of Merit Pursuant to CPLR 2012-b [X] Papers so served were properly endorsed with the Index Number and date of filing, Upon: Elleen M. Shufelt aka Elleen M. Shufelt aka Elleen M. Shufet . Cinatviduat By delivering a true copy thereof to sald recipient personally; deponent knew the person so served to be the Individual described therein, . [gRosponsibio By delivering to and leaving with Josh Shufelt , Son/Co--Occupant Person Relationship a true copy thereof, a person of sultable age and discretion. Sald premises being the defendant / respondent's [x] dwelling place [ ] place of business/employment [ ] last known address within the State. [ ] usual place of abode ma A copy thereof was deposited in a postpald, properly addressed envelope, marked “Personal and Confidential" In a depository maintained by the U, S, P, S, and malled to the above address on July 31, 2023 [Corporation By delivering to and leaving with sald Individual to be LLC / LLP who specifically stated he/she was authorized to accept service on benall of the Corporation/Government Agency/EntIty, [CAffixing By affixing a true copy thereof to the door,being the defendantrespondent's [ } dwelling place [| place of business/employment ‘To Door [ ] last known address within the Stale, [ ] usual place of abode Clprevious Deponent previously attempted to serve the above named defendantrespondent on: Attempts Description Sex: Male Color of skin: White Color of halr: Brown Age: 24-32 Yrs Helght: 56". 519" of Reciplont weight: 140-170 Other , Beard/Mustache Features: | asked the person spoken to whether the defendant/respondent was In active military service and recelved a negative reply. The person (KMilitary spoken with wore ordinary civilian clothes and no military uniform. The source of my information and the grounds of my bellef are the Servic conversations and observations defendant/respondent narrated above. Upon information and bellef, | aver that the reciplent Is not In military sarvica [other AY 5/92 Sworn to before me on NOTARY PUBLIC CASSANDRA RK RABE PROCESS SERVER LICENSE #. Notary Public - State of New York No, O1RA6439208 Work Order # 2059840 Qualified in Monroe08/20/2026 County: PZ Commission Expires: Papen Cuast NY, LLC, 349 W. Commercia Street, Surre 2360, East Rocnester, NY 14445 2 of 2 Q0 MONRO hk WV 5 INDIEXNG E 2823003000004 OUN [207 NYSC TED NYSCEF NOMONROE DOC. NO. COUNTY CLERK 08/01/2023 12:0 PM] RECE ANSCEIV E ' nbasER 2042003 15 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 08/01/2023 SUPREME COURT OF STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR (Single Attorney Authorizing Filing Agent Entit y) see 4 Esther S. Gabriel Esq,, ( Attorney Registration No. Jam play GASP ‘ized Aose 1D 808 user of the New York State Courts Electronic Piling . 12325880 ). Thereby authori ize any employee of ID to file document ts on my behalf and at my directi who possessesa filing agent which I am counsel 1 of record through the NYSCEF on, as afi linga; nt, in any e-filed matter in Uniform Rules for the Trial Courts, system, as p: ided in Section 202,5-b ofthe This authorization extends to anyly consensual matter in which consented to e-filing, to any mandato!ry matter in which I have previously T have recorded my Tepresentation, and to any y matterin which I may autho: rize the filing agent fat to record my consent or representa! tion ‘This authorization extends to any and all documents agent for filing in any such matter, This authorization, postedI generate and submit to the each matter in which I am counsel of, record, shall be deemed toonce on the NYSCEF: website aa to accom in that matter by the filing agent, pany any document filed This authorization also extends to matters of payment, which the filing agent may make elther by debiting an account the filiny ig agent maintains s with the County Clerk e-filing county or by debiting an account I maintain with the County of any authorized ling county. Clerk of any authorized e ‘This authorization regarding this fill ing agent shall contin on a prescribedform delivered to the E-Filing Resource ue until I revoke it inwriting . Dated; October 3, 2022 ‘Syracuse, NY 13202 Signature City, State and Zip Code Esther 8. Gabriel, Esq. 315-214-2016 Print Name Phone Hanis Beach PLLG egabriel@harrisbeach.com Firm/Department E-Mail Address 333 West Washington Street, Suite 200 Soa Street Address (6/6/13) lof1 hk INDIEXNG E 2823003000004 :NYS IMONROE COUNTY CLERK 04/29/2023 O1 PM RECEIVED NYSE Fico 923 004 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 4 SUPREME COURT RECE Glass ActlanbLLG 4/29/2023 County Monroe File Date 4/19/23 Affidavit # 477844 Index # E2023004004 Plaintiff(s): ESL Federal Credit Union AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF Defendant(s): against SUMMONS, VERIFIED Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, et. al. COMPLAINT, NOTICE OF PENDENCY, E-FILE NOTICE, 1303 NOTICE-HELP FOR STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE HOMEOWNERS** Cynthia T. Chasse, being duly sworn, dey poses and says; depone nt is not a party herein, | am over 18 years of age and reside in the state of New York. That on Wednesday, April 26, 2023 at 8: (08 pm at 77 Windsor Road, Rochester, NY 14612, | served the within Summons, Verified Complaint, Notice of Pendency, E-File Notice, 1303 Notice-Help for Homeowners*** on Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, defendant therein nai med. INDIVIDUAL by deliveri ng a true copy of each to said defendant personally; depon ent knew the person so served to be DLXBZ<] the person described as said defendant therein. She identifi ed herself. CORPORATION Oo SUITABLE AGE Oo AFFIXING TO DOOR, ETC. Oo MAILING TO RESIDENCE Oo MAILING TO BUSINESS Oo Sex Skin type Hair type Attributes Age Height Weight 0 Mate White Skin BW Black Hair O Balding 1 14-20 Yrs. & Female Black Skin (Under 5' 1) Under 100 Lbs. Brown Hair C1 Beard 21-36 Yrs. 50 t i2 100-130 Lbs. DESCRIPTION C1 Yellow Skin 1] Blonde Hair "3° O 131-160 0) 36-50 Yrs. O54 Lbs. qO White XN Brown Skin Gray Hair CI Mustache 51-65 Yrs. Sig" O 161-200 Lbs. O Red Skin Red Hair O Glasses 0 Over 65 Yrs. O] Over 6" O Over 200 Lbs. Hair Other features: & Papers were endorsed with the index numb er and date of filing shown above. Papers were served in compliance with RPAPL Section 1303. MILITARY SERVICE To my best knowledge, information and belief after rea sonable inquiry, the said defendant at the time of &l service was not engaged in military service of the Unit led States. “in Foreclosure in bold fourteen-point type and printed on color paper, that is complaint, and the title of the notice printed in bold twenty-point type in com; . other than the color of the summons and verified ince with RPAPL Sect 1303. Sworn to before me “G a 2 70. Lh Cynthia T. Chasse Yet | LORNA M. DAVI As agent for Class Action LLC NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF NEW YORK nal Registration No. 01DA6033422 Qualified In Monroe County I"‘Ssinmtssion Expires Novers ao 6, 2 of 2 INDIEXNG E 2823003000004 NY@ fe MONROE COUNTY C. LED Rat 2023 02 :01 PM) RECE TV EDORPSEEE2029999005:20023 iS ACUON LLU NYSCEF DOC. NO. RECE A ESS ANBOBELS « 29/2003 County Monroe File Date 4/19/23 Index # E2023004004 Plaintiff(s) ESL Federal Credit Union AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF Defendant(s): against SUMMONS, COMPLAINT, E-FILE Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, et. al NOTICE, AND CERTIFICATE OF MERIT STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE Cynthia T. Chasse, being duly sworn, deposes and says; deponent is not a party herein, | am over 18 years of age and reside in the state of New York. That on Wednesday, April 26, 2023 at 8:08 pm at 77 Windsor Road, Rochester, NY 14612, | served the within Summons, Complaint, E-File Notice, and Certificate of Merit on Quinn Shufelt s/h/a Jane Doe, defendant therein named INDIVIDUAL, Oo CORPORATION O by delivering thereat a true copy of each to Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, (mother), a person SUITABLE AGE of suitable age and discretion. Said premises is defendant's-actual-place-of-business-dwelling place-usual place of abode-within the state. Xl AFFIXING TO DOOR, ETC. O MAILING TO. On 4/27/2023, deponent enclosed a copy of same in a first class postpaid properly addressed envelope RESIDENCE marked "Personal and Confidential" in an official depository under the exclusive care and custody of the United States Post Office in the State of New York to the defendant at defendant's last known address, x at 77 Windsor Road, Rochester, NY 14612. MAILING TO BUSINESS QO Sex Skin type lair typ Attribute Age Height Weight 0 Male White Skin @ Black Hair Balding 1] 14-20 Yrs. Under 5° 1 Under 100 Lbs. i Female 1 Black Skin 1 Brown Hair 0 Beard 1 21-35 Yrs. & 5'0"-5'3" BY 100-130 Los. DESCRIPTION (1 Yellow Skin O Blonde Hair 1 Mustache 1 36-50 Yrs. 0 54"5'8" 1 131-160 Lbs. 1 Brown Skin O Gray Hair 81-65 Yrs. Os5'9"-6'0" 1 161-200 Lbs. O Red Skin O Red Hair O Glasses (1 Over 65 Yrs. [1 Over 6 Over 200 Lbs. 1 White Hair Other features: Oo MILITARY SERVICE To my best knowledge, information and belief after reasonable inquiry, the said defendant at the time of xX service was not engaged in military service of the United States. Derek Sworn to before me on Ia Lee CZ, Cynthia T. Chasse Yale| —~TORNA M.j. DAVI As agent for Class Action LLC PUBLIC, STATE OF NEW vor | J | som Registration No, 01DA6033422 Qualified in Monroe Gounty seion Expires Novemnbe! 20, 2 of 2 hk INDIEXNG E 2823003000004 OUN [207 NY BD LONROE COUNTY CLERK 04 /2023 02:01 PM RECELVEND RPS EE AOR99 98H 9933 NYSCEF DOC. NO SUPREME COURT RECEIVED Glase AstionuyhG /2023 Affidavit # 477846 County Monroe File Date 4/19/23 Index # E2023004004 Plaintiff(s): ESL Federal Credit Union Defendant(s): against AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, et. al STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE SS Dylan J. Frankel, being duly sworn, deposes and says: That | am not a party to this action, am over eighteen (18) years, and reside in the state of New York. That on April 28, 2023, Deponent mailed a copy of the Summons in this action on the defendant listed below by first class mail in an envelope bearing the legend “personal and confidential" and not indicating on the outside of the envelope that the communication is from an attorney or concerns an alleged debt. Said mailing was made to the defendant's residence, place-ef business Jast knewn address. Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet 77 Windsor Road Rochester, NY 14612 | believe the above statements are true and correct to the best of my knowledge. 5h Dylan J. Frankel As agent for Class Action LLC Sworn to before me on, April 28, 2023 2 “| a é‘ Notary “—~TORNA M. DAL | NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF NEW YORK No, G1DA6033422 ‘Qualified in Montae Gout ‘ommission Expires Novern! eS 2 of 2 OUN v ny 0 0 INDIEXNG E 2823003000004 NY. OE COUNTY CLE:BR Od 729) 2023 02:01 PM RECELVEN RPE R222 09S99 119.23 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 7 SUPREME COURT RECEIVED ClassAptiond LG /2023 Affidavit # 477992 County Monroe File Date 4/19/23 Index # £2023004004 Plaintiff(s): ESL Federal Credit Union AFFIDAVIT OF DELIVERY Defendant(s): against OF RPAPL §1303 NOTICE Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, et. al. ON TENANT STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE SS: Dylan J. Frankel, being duly sworn, deposes and says: That I am not a party to this action, am over eighteen (18) years, and reside in the state of New York. That I mailed a copy of Notice required by RPAPL. §1303, which Notice, as delivered, was printed on pink paper, the title of the Notice appeared to be in bold 20-point type, and the text appeared to be in bold, 14-point type on the Defendant/Tenant named herein, in the following manner addressed to: Quinn Shufelt 77 Windsor Road Rochester, NY 14612 As the premises has less than five units and the identity of the Tenant is known, | deposited said Notice pursuant to RPAPL §1303 by depositing, in an official depository under the exclusive care and custody of the United States post office in the State of New York a true copy of said Notice in a postpaid, properly addressed envelope by first-class mail, addressed to the above-named Defendant/Tenant on April 28, 2023. That | deposited the same by certified mail/return receipt requested #7022 1670 0001 0432 9992 with the United States Post Office on April 28, 2023. | believe the above statements are true and correct to the best of my knowledge. ly Dylan J. Frankel Sworn to before me on, April 28, 2023. As agent for Class Action LLC L Notary | 2) LORNA M. DAV PT “ i © Ln NOTARY PI STATEOF NEW YORK Registration No, 01DA6033422 ‘Qualified in Monroe County enSi omission Expires Noverrtb: —= 2 of 2 Q0 OUN hk WV INDIEXNG E 2823003000004 NYg MONROE COUNTY CLERK 04 2023 0. 201 PM} RECEIVEDION¥S GBF 20200992028 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 8 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 04/29/2023 SUPREME COURT,QF STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF STATEMENT OF AUTHORIZATION FOR E INTC ‘Single Attorney Authorizing Individual Filing Agent) ATTN A: Esq., ( Attorney Registration No. ) am an authorized user of the New York State Courts Electronic Filing System (“NYS ”) (User ID ). [hereby authorize (“the filing agent”) to utilize his/her NYSCEF filing agent ID to file documents on my behalf and at my direction in any e-filed matter in which I am counsel of record through the NYSCEF system, as provided in Section 202.5-b of the Uniform Rules for the Trial Courts. This authorization extends to any consensual matter in which I have previously consented to e-filing, to any mandatory matter in which I have recorded my representation, and to any matter in which I may authorize the filing agent to record my consent or representation in the NYSCEF system. This authorization extends to any and all documents I generate and submit to the filing agent for filing in any such matter. This authorization, posted once on the NYSCEF website as to each matter in which I am counsel of record, shall be deemed to accompany any document filed in that matter by the filing agent. This authorization also extends to matters of payment, which the filing agent may make either by debiting an account the filing agent maintains with the County Clerk of any authorized e-filing county or by debiting an account I maintain with the County Clerk of any authorized e- filing county. This authorization ing this filing agent shall continue until I revoke it in writing on a prescribed form delivered to the E-Filing Resource Center. Dated: -29 - MW fools, way 1 Heo Signat City, Sat and ‘eS Print Name Phone LAcY are.bn Up Firm/Department MRIEN® LCT LAr? BN) CW E-Mail Address 1Sd EWA $4 Street Address (6/6/13) 2 of 2 OUN INDIEXNG E 2823003000004 E_ COUNTY CLERK 0570472083 02 RECELVENO RARER 0299949845193 NYSCEF DOC. NO RECE. 5/04/2023 ayaa County Monroe File Date 4/19/23 Index # E2023004004 EWDED Plaintiff(s): ESL Federal Credit Union AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF Defendant(s): against SUMMONS, COMPLAINT, E-FILE Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, et. al NOTICE, CERTIFICATE OF MERIT, 1303 NOTICE-HELP FOR STATE OF NEW YORK, COUNTY OF MONROE HOMEOWNERS*** Cynthia T. Chasse, being duly sworn, deposes and says; deponent is not a party herein, | am over 18 years of age and reside in the state of New York. That on Wednesday, April 26, 2023 at 8:08 pm at 77 Windsor Road, Rochester, NY 14612, | served the within Summons, Complaint, E-File Notice, Certificate of Merit, 1303 Notice-Help for Homeowners*** on Eileen M. Shufelt a/k/a Eileen M. Shufet, defendant therein named. INDIVIDUAL, by delivering a true copy of each to said defendant personally; deponent knew the person so served to be XM the person described as said defendant therein. She identified herself. CORPORATION O SUITABLE AGE O AFFIXING TO DOOR, ETC. O MAILING TO. RESIDENCE O MAILING TO BUSINESS Oo Sex Skin type Hair type Attributes Age Height Wei O Male I White Skin Black Hair O Balding C1 14-20 Yrs. Under 5° O Under 100 Lbs. fd Female Black Skin C1 Brown Hair 121-35 Yrs. fa 5'0"-5'3" 100-130 Lbs. O Beara DESCRIPTION (Yellow Skin [1] Blonde Hair 1 Mustache 1 36-50 Yrs. O5'4".5'8" 131-160 Lbs. (Brown Skin D Gray Hair 51-65 Yrs 0 5'9"-6'0" (1 161-200 Lbs. (1 Red Skin O Red Hair O Glasses 1 Over 65 Yrs. [] Over 6' 1 Over 200 Lbs. O White Hair Other features: X Papers were endorsed with the index number and date of filing shown above. Papers were served in compliance with RPAPL Section 1303. MILITARY SERVICE To my best knowledge, information and belief after reasonable inquiry, the said defendant at the time of >SZWY| service was not engaged in military service of the United States. **in Foreclosure in bold fourteen-point type and printed on color paper, that is o) r than the color of the summons and complaint, and the title of the notice printed in bold twenty-point type in compliance with R! L Sect 1303. worms br 70 Lh Cynthia T. Chasse 'S agent for Class Action LLC Sbfa3| LORNA M.DAV NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF NEW YORK Registration No. 01DA6033422 Qualified in Monroe County saion Expires Nevemb 0 2 of 2