Preview
CAUSE NO. 2015-47031
BREITBURN OPERATING, LP, § THE DISTRICT COURT
Plaintiff/Counter Defendant, §
§
ROGER D. PARSONS, IN HIS
CAPACITY AS TRUSTEE OF THE
LL&E ROYALTY TRUST, § HARRIS COUNTY, TEXAS
Defendant/Counter Plaintiff, §
§
MAVERICK NATURAL §
RESOURCES, LLC, et al., §
Third Party Defendants. § 133RD JUDICIAL DISTRICT
PLAINTIFF/COUNTER DEFENDANT BREITBURN OPERATING LP’S
AND THE BREITBURN THIRD PARTY DEFENDANTS’
IFTH AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
Breitburn Operating, and the Breitburn Third Party Defendants respectfully submit the
accompanying fifth amended list of trial exhibits. Breitburn Operating, LP and the Breitburn
Third Party Defendants reserve the right add remove trial exhibits response preliminary
trial exhibit lists and evidence offered by the other parties.
Dated: November 29, 2023 Respectfully submitted,
ECK EDDEN
By: /s/ Geoff A. Gannaway
Geoff A. Gannaway
State Bar No. 24036617
ggannaway@beckredden.com
Allison Standish Miller
State Bar No. 24046440
amiller@beckredden.com
Joel T. Towner
State Bar No. 24083978
jtowner@beckredden.com
Mary Kate Raffetto
State Bar No. 24098296
mkraffetto@beckredden.com
Bilma Canales
State Bar No. 24109687
bcanales@beckredden.com
McKinney Street, Suite 4500
Houston, Texas
Telephone No. (713) 3700
Facsimile No. (713) 3720
—
HMAD AVITSANOS ENSING PLLC
Joseph Ahmad
Texas Bar No.
joeahmad@azalaw.com
Ryan Hackney
Texas Bar No.
rhackney@azalaw.com
Emily Adler
Texas Bar No.
eadler@azalaw.com
Jarmonique Smith
Texas Bar No. 24110374
McKinney Street, Suite 2500
Houston, Texas
Telephone No. (713) 655 1101
Facsimile No. (713) 0062
Attorneys For Plaintiff/Counter Defendant
Breitburn Operating LP, successor
interest QRE Operating, LLC and Third
Party Defendants Breitburn Management
Company, LLC, Breitburn Energy
Partners, LP, QR Energy, LP, and
Maverick Natural Resources, LLC
CERTIFICATE SERVICE
I hereby certify that on November 29, 2023 a true and correct copy of the foregoing
instrument was served on all known counsel of record accordance with the Texas Rules of Civil
Procedure via e-service or email
John H. Kim Joseph Thompson III
David Toy Andrew Raber
David McDougal Porter Hedges
The Kim Law Firm 1000 Main Street, 36th Floor
4309 Yoakum, Suite 2000 Houston, Texas 77002
Houston, Texas 77006 joe.thompson@porterhedges.com
jhk@thekimlawfirm.com Attorneys for Third Party Defendants
dtoy@thekimlawfirm ConocoPhillips Company, Burlington
david@thekimlawfirm Resources Trading, LLC, and the
Attorneys for Defendant/Counter-Plaintiff/ Louisiana Land & Exploration
Third-Party Plaintiff Roger D. Parsons Company, LLC
as Trustee of the LL&E Royalty Trust
/s/ Geoff Gannaway
Geoff Gannaway
The Breitburn Parties'
Fifth Amended Exhibit List
File
Exhibit # Date Bates Doc. Description Offered Objected Admitted
Extension
Conveyance Overriding Royalty Interests The Louisiana Land
PX0001 2014_02_14 BREIT_0002848‐BREIT_0002883 and Exploration Company (Book 1793 page 727)
Unit Agreement Jay and Little Escambia Creek Fields, Unit
Santa Rosa and Escambia Counties, Florida and Escambia
PX0002 1973_08_20 BREIT_0006096‐BREIT_0006141 County, Alabama [Book Page 543]
Unit Operating Agreement. Jay and Little Escambia Creek Fields
Unit. Santa Rosa and Escambia Counties, Florida and Escambia
PX0003 1973_08_20 BREIT_0007252‐BREIT_0007335 County, Alabama. Smackover Norphlet Oil Pool
PX0004 1983_06_01 COPQRE00020063‐COPQRE00020078 Agreement General Partnership LL&E Royalty Partnership
PX0005 1983_06_01 COPQRE00020135‐COPQRE00020713 LL&E Royalty Trust Agreement
Unit Agreement for Jay and Little Escambia Creek Fields (Fla.
Ala.) by and between Exxon, Louisiana Land and Exploration,
PX0006 1973_08_20 LLETX 005711‐LLETX and Chevron [Book Page 313]
Conveyance of Overriding Royalty Interests ‐ The Louisiana Land
and Exploration Company [Book 1793 page 727][Book 643, Page
PX0007 1983_06_28 LLETX_000011‐LLETX_000046 611]
Unit Operating Agreement for Jay and Little Escambia by and
between Exxon, Louisiana Land and Exploration, and Chevron
PX0008 1973_08_20 STFLE015343‐STFLE015426 [Book 772, Page 459]
Email from Mulkey Lockwood re: 0114 Jay NPI Calculation
PX0009‐01 2014_02_20 BREIT_0003634‐BREIT_0003635 MSG December (Production) Audit.xlsx
Jay NPI Calculation December (Production)
PX0009‐02 2014_01_31 BREIT_0003635 Audit.xlsx
PX0010‐01 2014_05_05 BREIT_0003671‐BREIT_0003672 MSG ail from Mulkey Pownell RE: NPI balances
Jay NPI Calculation 2014 March 2014 (Production)
PX0010‐02 2014_04_31 BREIT_0003672 Revised.xlsx
Email from Mulkey Barilleau re: Jay NPI Calculation
PX0011‐01 2014_06_19 BREIT_0003691‐BREIT_0003692 MSG April (Production) Revised.xlsx
Jay NPI Calculation 2014 April (Production)
PX0011‐02 2014_05_31 BREIT_0003692 Revised.xlsx
Email from Mulkey Barilleau re: Jay NPI Calculation
PX0012‐01 2014_06_19 BREIT_0003695‐BREIT_0003696 MSG 2014 ‐ February 2014 (Production).xlsx
PX0012‐02 2014_03_31 BREIT_0003696 Jay NPI Calculation 2014 February (Production).xlsx
Email from Shipman Delano re: Jay NPI Calculation
2014 ‐ April 2014 (Production) ‐ Revised ‐ From his drive after
PX0013‐01 2014_07_08 BREIT_0003722‐BREIT_0003724 MSG updates.xlsx
The Breitburn Parties'
Fifth Amended Exhibit List
File
Exhibit # Date Bates Doc. Description Offered Objected Admitted
Extension
Jay NPI Calculation 2014 April (Production)
PX0013‐02 2014_06_30 BREIT_0003724 Revised.xlsx
Email from Shipman K. Reihle re: G18 0714 Jay NPI Calc
PX0014‐01 2014_08_05 BREIT_0003772‐BREIT_0003773 MSG Revised.xlsx
PX0014‐02 2014_07_31 BREIT_0003773 G18 ‐ 0714 Jay NPI Calc Revised.xlsx
PX0015‐01 2014_09_09 BREIT_0003788‐BREIT_0003790 MSG Email from Shipman K. Reihle re: Aug PM Jay NPI Calc
PX0015‐02 2014_06_30 BREIT_0003790 G18 0814 Jay NPI_@ 06‐30‐14‐ GSL Revisions.xlsx
PX0016 2014_06_30 BREIT_0003833 G18 Jay NPI_@ 06‐30‐14‐ GSL Revisions.xlsx
PX0017 2015_01_31 BREIT_0007156 Jay NPI_@ 12.31_BBEP.xlsx
PX0018 2015_02_29 BREIT_0007163 Jay NPI_@ 1.31.15.xlsx
PX0019 2015_03_31 BREIT_0007172 Jay NPI_@ 2.28_BBEP.xlsx
PX0020 2015_04_30 BREIT_0007177 Jay NPI_@ 3.31_BBEP.xlsx
PX0021 2014_11_30 BREIT_0007233 Jay NPI_@ 10.31.xlsx
PX0022 2014_12_31 BREIT_0007241 Jay NPI_@ 11.30.xlsx Jay Field NPI Flow Chart
PX0023 2014_09_30 BREIT_0007904 XLSX Jay NPI_@ 08.31.XLSX
PX0024 2014_10_31 BREIT_0007907 XLSX Jay NPI_@ 08.31 Version.XLSX
Jay NPI Calculation 2014 January 2014 (Production)
PX0025 2014_02_00 BREIT_0025390 (2).xlsx
PX0026 2021_07_31 BREIT_0034681 0721 Jay NPI_@06.30.xlsx
PX0027 2021_08_31 BREIT_0034682 0821 Jay NPI@07.31.xlsx
PX0028 2021_09_00 BREIT_0034683 291 Jay NPI_@08.31
PX0029 2015_05_00 BREIT_0034684 Jay NPI_@ 4.30_HC.xlsx
PX0030 2015_06_00 BREIT_0034685 Jay NPI_@ 5.31_V4.xlsx
PX0031 2015_07_00 BREIT_0034686 Jay NPI_@ 6.30_Revised_V2.xlsx
PX0032 2015_08_00 BREIT_0034687 Jay NPI_@ 7.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0033 2015_09_00 BREIT_0034688 Jay NPI_@ 8.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0034 2015_10_00 BREIT_0034689 Jay NPI_@ 9.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0035 2015_11_00 BREIT_0034690 Jay NPI_@10.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0036 2015_12_00 BREIT_0034691 Jay NPI_@11.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0037 2016_01_00 BREIT_0034692 Jay NPI_@12.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0038 2016_02_00 BREIT_0034693 0216 Jay NPI_@1.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0039 2016_03_00 BREIT_0034694 Jay NPI_@ 2.29_Revised.xlsx
PX0040 2016_04_00 BREIT_0034695 Jay NPI_@ 3.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0041 2016_05_00 BREIT_0034696 Jay NPI_@ 4.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0042 2016_06_00 BREIT_0034697 Jay NPI_@ 5.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0043 2016_07_00 BREIT_0034698 Jay NPI_@ 6.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0044 2016_08_00 BREIT_0034699 Jay NPI_@ 7.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0045 2016_09_00 BREIT_0034700 Jay NPI_@ 8.31_Revised.xlsx
The Breitburn Parties'
Fifth Amended Exhibit List
File
Exhibit # Date Bates Doc. Description Offered Objected Admitted
Extension
PX0046 2016_10_00 BREIT_0034701 Jay NPI_@ 9.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0047 2016_11_00 BREIT_0034702 Jay NPI_@10.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0048 2016_12_00 BREIT_0034703 Jay NPI_@11.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0049 2017_01_00 BREIT_0034704 Jay NPI_@12.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0050 2017_02_00 BREIT_0034705 0217 Jay NPI_@1.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0051 2017_03_00 BREIT_0034706 Jay NPI_@ 2.28_Revised.xlsx
PX0052 2017_04_00 BREIT_0034707 Jay NPI_@ 3.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0053 2017_05_00 BREIT_0034708 Jay NPI_@ 4.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0054 2017_06_00 BREIT_0034709 Jay NPI_@ 5.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0055 2017_07_00 BREIT_0034710 Jay NPI_@ 6.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0056 2017_08_00 BREIT_0034711 Jay NPI_@ 7.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0057 2017_09_00 BREIT_0034712 Jay NPI_@ 8.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0058 2017_10_00 BREIT_0034713 Jay NPI_@ 9.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0059 2017_11_00 BREIT_0034714 Jay NPI_@10.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0060 2017_12_00 BREIT_0034715 Jay NPI_@11.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0061 2018_01_00 BREIT_0034716 Jay NPI_@12.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0062 2018_02_00 BREIT_0034717 Jay NPI_@01.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0063 2018_03_00 BREIT_0034718 Jay NPI_@02.28_Revised.xlsx
PX0064 2018_04_00 BREIT_0034719 Jay NPI_@03.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0065 2018_05_00 BREIT_0034720 Jay NPI_@04.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0066 2018_06_00 BREIT_0034721 Jay NPI_@05.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0067 2018_07_00 BREIT_0034722 Jay NPI_@06.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0068 2018_08_00 BREIT_0034723 Jay NPI_@ 7.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0069 2018_09_00 BREIT_0034724 Jay NPI_@ 8.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0070 2018_10_00 BREIT_0034725 Jay NPI_@ 9.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0071 2018_11_00 BREIT_0034726 Jay NPI_@10.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0072 2018_12_00 BREIT_0034727 Jay NPI_@11.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0073 2019_01_00 BREIT_0034728 Jay NPI_@12.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0074 2019_02_00 BREIT_0034729 Jay NPI_@01.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0075 2019_03_00 BREIT_0034730 Jay NPI_@02.28_Revised.xlsx
PX0076 2019_04_00 BREIT_0034731 Jay NPI_@ 03.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0077 2019_05_00 BREIT_0034732 Jay NPI_@ 04.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0078 2019_06_00 BREIT_0034733 Jay NPI_@ 05.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0079 2019_07_00 BREIT_0034734 Jay NPI_@ 06.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0080 2019_08_00 BREIT_0034735 Jay NPI_@ 07.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0081 2019_09_00 BREIT_0034736 Jay NPI_@ 08.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0082 2019_10_00 BREIT_0034737 Jay NPI_@ 09.30_Revised.xlsx
PX0083 2019_11_00 BREIT_0034738 Jay NPI_@ 10.31.xlsx
The Breitburn Parties'
Fifth Amended Exhibit List
File
Exhibit # Date Bates Doc. Description Offered Objected Admitted
Extension
PX0084 2019_12_00 BREIT_0034739 Jay NPI_@ 11.30.xlsx
PX0085 2020_01_00 BREIT_0034740 Jay NPI_@ 12.31.xlsx
PX0086 2020_02_00 BREIT_0034741 Jay NPI_@01.31_Revised.xlsx
PX0087 2020_03_00 BREIT_0034742 0320 Jay NPI_@02.29.xlsx
PX0088 2020_04_00 BREIT_0034743 0420 Jay NPI_@03.31.xlsx
PX0089 2020_05_00 BREIT_0034744 0520 Jay NPI_@04.30.xlsx
PX0090 2020_06_00 BREIT_0034745 0620 Jay NPI_@05.31.xlsx
PX0091 2020_07_00 BREIT_0034746 0720 Jay NPI_@06.30.xlsx
PX0092 2020_08_00 BREIT_0034747 0820 Jay NPI_@07.31.xlsx
PX0093 2020_09_00 BREIT_0034748 0920 Jay NPI_@08.31.xlsx
PX0094 2020_10_00 BREIT_0034749 1020 Jay NPI_@09.30.xlsx
PX0095 2020_11_00 BREIT_0034750 1120 Jay NPI_@10.31.xlsx
PX0096 2020_12_00 BREIT_0034751 1220 Jay NPI_@11.30.xlsx
PX0097 2020_01_00 BREIT_0034752 0121 Jay NPI_@12.31.xlsx
PX0098 2020_02_00 BREIT_0034753 0221 Jay NPI_@01.31.xlsx
PX0099 2020_03_00 BREIT_0034754 0321 Jay NPI_@02.28.xlsx
PX0100 2020_04_00 BREIT_0034755 0421 Jay NPI_@03.31.xlsx
PX0101 2021_05_00 BREIT_0034756 0521 Jay NPI_@04.30.xlsx
PX0102 2021_06_00 BREIT_0034757 0621 Jay NPI_@05.31.xlsx
PX0103 2021_07_00 BREIT_0034758 0721 Jay NPI_@06.30.xlsx
PX0104 2021_08_00 BREIT_0034759 0821 Jay NPI_@07.31.xlsx
PX0105 2021_09_00 BREIT_0034760 0921 Jay NPI_@08.31.xlsx
PX0106 2021_10_31 BREIT_0034761 1021 Jay NPI_@09.30.xlsx
PX0107 2021_11_00 BREIT_0034762 1121 Jay NPI_@10.31.xlsx
PX0108 2021_12_00 BREIT_0034763 1221 Jay NPI_@11.30.xlsx
PX0109 2022_01_00 BREIT_0058409 0122 Jay NPI_@12.31.xlsx
PX0110 2021_09_00 BREIT_0058413 0921 Jay NPI_@08.31.xlsx
PX0111 2021_10_00 BREIT_0058415 1021 Jay NPI_@09.30.xlsx
PX0112 2021_11_00 BREIT_0058417 1121 Jay NPI_@10.31.xlsx
PX0113 2021_12_00 BREIT_0058419 1221 Jay NPI_@11.30.xlsx
PX0114 2022_02_00 BREIT_0058420 Jay NPI_@01.22 Workbook.xlsx
PX0115 2022_03_16 BREIT_0059752 0122 Jay NPI_@12.31.xlsx
PX0116 2023_01_00 BREIT_0059753 Jay NPI_@1222.xlsx
PX0117 2022_04_19 BREIT_0059754 0222 Jay NPI_@01.22.xlsx
PX0118 2023_04_20 BREIT_0059755 Jay NPI_@0123.xlsx
PX0119 2022_05_20 BREIT_0059756 0322 Jay NPI_@02.22.xlsx
PX0120 2023_05_18 BREIT_0059757 Jay NPI_@0223.xlsx
PX0121 2022_04_00 BREIT_0059758 0422 Jay NPI_@03.22.xlsx
The Breitburn Parties'
Fifth Amended Exhibit List
File
Exhibit # Date Bates Doc. Description Offered Objected Admitted
Extension
PX0122 2023_06_20 BREIT_0059759 Jay NPI_@0323.xlsx
PX0123 2022_05_00 BREIT_0059760 0522 Jay NPI_@04.22.xlsx
PX0124 2023_08_07 BREIT_0059761 Jay NPI_@0423.xlsx
PX0125 2022_06_00 BREIT_0059762 0622 Jay NPI_@05.22.xlsx
PX0126 2023_08_17 BREIT_0059763 Jay NPI_@0523.xlsx
PX0127 2022_07_00 BREIT_0059764 Jay NPI_@0622.xlsx
PX0128 2022_08_00 BREIT_0059765 Jay NPI_@0722.xlsx
PX0129 2022_09_00 BREIT_0059766 Jay NPI_@0822.xlsx
PX0130 2022_10_00 BREIT_0059767 Jay NPI_@0922.xlsx
PX0131 2023_11_00 BREIT_0059768 Jay NPI_@1022.xlsx
PX0132 2022_12_00 BREIT_0059769 Jay NPI_@1122.xlsx
PX0133 2015_00_00 BREIT_0059862 ARGRTRJAY_2015 (GL Data)
PX0134 2018_00_00 BREIT_0059866 ARGRTRJAY_2018 File (GL Data)
PX0135 2017_03_08 BREIT_0013760 Jay NPI_@ 12.31.xlsx
PX0136 2015_03_18 BREIT_0013784 Jay NPI_@ 12.31.xlsx
PX0137 2016_03_18 BREIT_0014122 Jay NPI_@ 12.31.xlsx
PX0138 2012_05_10 BREIT_0015539 Historical Jay NPI_4.14_3.15.xlsx
PX0139 2020_02_19 BREIT_0019420 Jay NPI_@ 11.30.xlsx
PX0140 2018_10_16 BREIT_0025305 Jay NPI_@ 0731_Revised_For Review.xlsx
PX0141 2021_03_15 BREIT_0030730 0121 Jay NPI_@12.31
PX0142 0000_00_00 BREIT_0033873 0621 Jay NPI_@05.31
PX0143 2019_01_01 BREIT_0033880 Jay NPI YE202 Escrow Calculation
PX0144 2022_11_00 BREIT_0059697 Jay NPI_@1022.xlsx
PX0145 2022_12_00 BREIT_0059698 Jay NPI_@1122.xlsx
PX0146 2023_01_00 BREIT_0059699 Jay NPI_@1222.xlsx
PX0147 2023_02_00 BREIT_0059700 Jay NPI_@0123.xlsx
PX0148 2023_03_00 BREIT_0059701 Jay NPI_@0223.xlsx
PX0149 2016_00_00 BREIT_0059863 ARGRTRJAY_2016 (GL Data)
PX0150 2017_00_00 BREIT_0059864 ARGRTRJAY_2017 (GL Data)
PX0151 2018_00_00 BREIT_0059865 ARGRTRJAY_2018 File (GL Data)
PX0152 2019_00_00 BREIT_0059867a ARGRTRJAY_2019 (GL Data).xlsx
PX0153 2020_00_00 BREIT_0059868 ARGRTRJAY_2020 (GL Data)
PX0154 2021_00_00 BREIT_0059869 ARGRTRJAY_2021 (GL Data)
PX0155 2022_00_00 BREIT_0059870 ARGRTRJAY_2022 (GL Data)
PX0156 2023_00_00 BREIT_0059871 ARGRTRJAY_2023 (GL Data)
PX0157‐01 2014_06_16 LLETX_030386‐LLETX_030387 MSG Email from Mulkey Abraham re: May Jay NPI
PX0157‐02 2014_06_16 LLETX_030387 0514 Jay NPI.xlsx
PX0158‐01 2014_09_30 LLETX_030412‐LLETX_030413 MSG Email from K. Reihle Abraham re: Aug Jay NPI
The Breitburn Parties'
Fifth Amended Exhibit List
File
Exhibit # Date Bates Doc. Description Offered Objected Admitted
Extension
PX0158‐02 2014_09_12 LLETX_030413 Jay NPI Calculation 2014_Final.xlsx
Email from K. Reihle Parsons and Abraham re: Jay NPI
PX0159‐01 2015_08_19 LLETX_030478‐LLETX_030479 MSG Calculation May 2015
PX0159‐02 2015_08_19 LLETX_030479 Jay NPI_@ 5.31.xlsx
PX0160 0000‐00‐00 MARTINDALE_ 00000888 Section.xls
Email from K. Reihle Parsons and Abraham re: Jay NPI
PX0161‐01 2017_04_20 LLETX_031136‐LLETX_031137 MSG Calculation January 2017
PX0161‐02 2017_04_20 LLETX_031137 Jay NPI_@ 1.31.xlsx
Email from Thompson Patel and Roden re: Meeting
PX0162‐01 2012_01_19 BREIT_0016898‐ BREIT_0016901 MSG Follow‐Up
PX0162‐02 2012_01_19 BREIT_0016901 NPI Summary Calculation Trustee 1.19.12.xlsx
PX0163‐01 2012_01_03 LLETX_028479‐LLETX_028491 MSG Email from Paxton Abraham re: 2009 Trust reports
Distribution Calculation Fee Lands Royalties January 2010
PX0163‐02 2010_01_00 LLETX_028480 xls Production
PX0163‐03 2010_05_00 LLETX_028481 xls LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary May Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Calculation September 2010
PX0163‐04 2010_09_00 LLETX_028482 xls Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary November 2009
PX0163‐05 2009_11_00 LLETX_028483 xls Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary October 2009
PX0163‐06 2009_10_00 LLETX_028484 xls Production
PX0163‐07 2010_04_00 LLETX_028485 xls LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary April 2010 Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary December 2010
PX0163‐08 2010_12_00 LLETX_028486 xls Production
Distribution Calculation Fee Lands Royalties February 2010
PX0163‐09 2010_02_00 LLETX_028487 xls Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Calculation August 2010
PX0163‐10 2010_08_00 LLETX_028488 xls Production
PX0163‐11 2010_07_00 LLETX_028489 xls LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Calculation July 2010 Production
Distribution Calculation Fee Lands Royalties June 2010
PX0163‐12 2010_06_00 LLETX_028490 xls Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary March 2010
PX0163‐13 2010_03_00 LLETX_028491 xls Production
PX0164‐01 2012_01_03 LLETX_028492‐LLETX_028504 MSG Email from Paxton Abraham re: 2009 Trust reports
The Breitburn Parties'
Fifth Amended Exhibit List
File
Exhibit # Date Bates Doc. Description Offered Objected Admitted
Extension
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary September 2009
PX0164‐02 2009_09_00 LLETX_028493 xls Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary August 2009
PX0164‐03 2009_08_00 LLETX_028494 xls Production
PX0164‐04 2009_07_00 LLETX_028495 xls LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary July Production
PX0164‐05 2009_06_00 LLETX_028496 xls LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary June 2009 Production
PX0164‐06 2009_00_00 LLETX_028497 xls LL&E Year Report
PX0164‐07 2009_05_00 LLETX_028498 xls LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary May Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary November 2008
PX0164‐08 2008_11_00 LLETX_028499 xls Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary October 2008
PX0164‐09 2008_10_00 LLETX_028500 xls Production
PX0164‐10 2009_04_00 LLETX_028501 xls LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary April 2009 Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary March 2009
PX0164‐11 2009_03_00 LLETX_028502 xls Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary December 2008
PX0164‐12 2008_12_00 LLETX_028503 xls Production
LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Summary February 2009
PX0164‐13 2009_02_00 LLETX_028504 xls Production
PX0165 2014_12_00 BREIT_0007753 Energy, Jay Unit COPAS Overhead Rate
PX0166 2014_12_00 BREIT_0007756 Energy, LL&E Management Fee
PX0167 2018_01_01 BREIT_0007861 COPAS Jay Overhead Calc 2018.xlsx
Email from K. McCarthy Mulkey, al. re: Duplication
PX0168 2014_02_28 BREIT_0011565‐BREIT_0011574 MSG Overhead Fee
Email from Mulkey briaduit@aol.com, Parsons and
PX0169‐01 2014_02_28 BREIT_0011575‐BREIT_0011584 MSG Abraham re: Duplication Overhead Fee
PX0169‐02 2014_02_28 BREIT_0011583 Jay NPI Audit Revised.xlsx
PX0169‐03 2014_02_28 BREIT_0011584 Jay Well Rates.xlsx
PX0170 2013_09_23 BREIT_0011622‐BREIT_0011623 MSG Email from Roden Parsons, al. re: Audit Responses
PX0171 2019_06_19 BREIT_0016210 Jay LOS 5.2014 3.2019.xlsx
PX0172 0000_00_00 BREIT_0016211 Jay NPI Overhead Calculations.xlsx
PX0173 0000_00_00 BREIT_0016212 Jay Calculation.xlsx
PX0174 0000_00_00 BREIT_0016213‐BREIT_0016262 Jay Plant Calculation Support
PX0175 2019_12_00 BREIT_0016330 Copy COPAS Jay Overhead Calc (003).xlsx
PX0176 2012_09_11 BREIT_0019568‐BREIT_0019569 MSG Email from Wheeler A. Moreno RE: [EXTERNAL]
The Breitburn Parties'
Fifth Amended Exhibit List
File
Exhibit # Date Bates Doc. Description Offered Objected Admitted
Extension
PX0177 2016_04_05 BREIT_0020966 COPAS Jay Overhead‐LL&E.xlsx
Email from Fleischer Drakeaud re: Quantum 11/12
PX0178 2013_11_26 BREIT_0022055‐BREIT_0022058 Overhead Calculation
Email from Lamb Valenti re: Jay Plant COPAS
PX0179‐01 2015_04_09 BREIT_0025219 MSG Average
PX0179‐02 2015_01_31 BREIT_0025220 Jay NPI_@ 12.31_BBEP.xlsx
COPAS Overhead Adjustment Factors and Overhead Rate
PX0180 2021_02_22 BREIT_0030300‐BREIT_0030302 Calculator
The Louisiana Land and Exploration Company Computation of
Royalty Income for LL&E Royalty Trust for Quarter Ended
PX0181 2002_06_30 COPQRE00005614‐COPQRE00005618 June 30, 2002
The Louisiana Land and Exploration Company Computation
Royalty Income for LL&E Royalty Trust for the Three‐Months
PX0182 2006_09_30 COPQRE00006149‐COPQRE00006154 Ended September 30, 2006
PX0183‐01 2006_12_21 COPQRE00009004‐COPQRE00009005 Email from K. Bennett Colvin re: LRT Reports
PX0183‐02 2006_12_21 COPQRE00009005 rpt0612.xlsx
LL&E Royalty Trust (Jay Field) Schedule Monthly Net Profits
PX0184 0000_00_00 COPQRE00009019 Calculation Trust Imputed Net Profit Volumes
Email from K. Bennett sarah.c.newell@bankofny.com re:
PX0185‐01 2007_10_05 COPQRE00009025‐COPQRE00009029 LL&E 3rd Reports
PX0185‐02 2007_00_00 COPQRE00009027 LL&E Royalty Trust Third Quarter Worksheet
PX0185‐03 2007_00_00 COPQRE00009028 LL&E Royalty Trust Third Quarter Worksheet
LL&E Royalty Trust Schedule of Monthly Net Profits an
Calculation Trust Imputed Net Profit Volumes First Quarter
PX0185‐04 2007_00_00 COPQRE00009029 Distributions
PX0186 2007_01_02 COPQRE00009886‐COPQRE00009887 Email from Hoyt K. Bennett re: LL&E Royalty Trust 9/30/04
PX0187 2008_06_10 COPQRE00011085 LL&E Royalty Trust Schedule Overhead Charges
PX0188 1990_00_00 COPQRE00062316‐COPQRE00062384 LL&E Royalty Trust Annual Report and Form 10‐K
LL&E Royalty Trust Worksheet for Capital & LOE Expense
December, 1998 Accounting / January, 1999 Report / February,
PX0189 1999_02_00 COPQRE00063249 Distribution
LL&E Royalty Trust Schedule of Monthly Net Profits &
Calculation Trust Imputed Net Profit Volume; Second Quarter
PX0190 1999_00_00 COPQRE00063264 Distributions
The Louisiana Land and Exploration Company Computation
Royalty Income for LL&E Royalty Trust for the Year Ended
PX0191 2000_12_31 COPQRE00063531‐COPQRE00063535 December 2000
The Breitburn Parties'
Fifth Amended Exhibit List
File
Exhibit # Date Bates Doc. Description Offered Objected Admitted
Extension
PX0192 2000_10_00 COPQRE00063564 LL&E Royalty Trust Schedule Overhead Charges
PX0193 2000_11_00 COPQRE00063565 LL&E Royalty Trust Schedule Overhead Charges
LL&E Royalty Trust Schedule of Overhead Charges July 2002
Production / August 2002 Accounting / September 2002 Report
PX0194 2002_10_00 COPQRE00064280 October Distribution
Miller & Lents, Ltd. Estimates of Proved Reserves and Future
Net Revenues for the LL&E Royalty Trust as September 30,
PX0195 2008_03_19 LLETX 006872‐LLETX 2007
Email from K. McCarthy K. Mulkey, Parsons and
PX0196 2014_02_17 LLETX_011505‐LLETX_011510 .msg Abraham re: Duplication Overhead Fees
Email from K. McCarthy Mulkey, Parsons and Abraham
PX0197 2014_02_17 LLETX_013917‐LLETX_013922 .msg re: Jay Field NPI August
LL&E Royalty Trust ‐ Schedule of Monthly Net Profits and
Calculation Trust Imputed Net Profit Volumes ‐ First Quarter
PX0198 2001_12_27 LLETX_014124 .tiff Distributions
PX0199 2001_10_00 LLETX_014128/LRTCOP00000021 .tiff LL&E Royalty Trust Distribution Calculation October 2001
LL&E Royalty Trust Schedule of Overhead Charges ‐ October
Production/November 2001 Accounting, December 2001
PX0200 2001_01_00 LLETX_014275/LRTCOP00000168 .tiff Report/January 2001 Distribution
Letter from Burlington Resources to Ginger Morris regarding
LLETX_016520 (LRTCOP00002413)‐ Distribution Calculation Package for the Month May
PX0201 1998_07_23 LLETX_016525 (LRTCOP00002418) Wire Transfer August 5, 1998
Letter from Burlington Resources to Ginger Morris regarding
LLETX_016532 (LRTCOP00002425)‐ Distribution Calculation Package for the month March 1998,
PX0202 1998_05_22 LLETX_016537 (LRTCOP00002430) Wire Transfer take place June 1998
Letter from Burlington Resources to Ginger Morris regarding
LLETX_016544 (LRTCOP00002437)‐ Distribution Calculation Package for the month January, 1998,
PX0203 1998_03_26 LLETX_016549 (LRTCOP00002442) Wire Transfer will take place April 1998
Letter from Burlington Resources to Ginger Morris regarding
Distribution Calculation Package for the Month December,
PX0204 1998_02_19 LLETX_016550 (LRTCOP00002443) .tiff 1997
LL&E Royalty Trust Worksheet for LOE Capital Costs for
March, 1998 Activity/April, 1998 Accounting/May, 1998
PX0205 1998_00_00 LLETX_016601 (LRTCOP00002494) .tiff Report/June, 1998 Distribution
PX0206 1998_01_00 LLETX_017165 (LRTCOP00003058) .tiff Jay Field "Overhead" January, 1998
LL&E Royalty Trust Schedule Overhead Charges for March,
PX0207 1998_00_00 LLETX_017766 (LRTCOP00003659) .tiff Production / April, 1998 Accounting/ May, 1998 Report
The Breitburn Parties'
Fifth Amended Exhibit List
File
Exhibit # Date Bates Doc. Description Offered Objected Admitted
Extension
LL&E Royalty Trust Schedule Overhead Charge Adjustments
PX0208 1998_00_00 LLETX_017767 (LRTCOP00003660) .tiff for May, Report/ March,1998 Activity
PX0209 2012_10_10 LLETX_029337‐LLETX_029373 Email from Oberst Abraham re: Revised Report_LL&E
PX0210‐01 2012_11_20 LLETX_031238‐LLETX_031239 MSG Email from Oberst Abraham re: FW: Model
00_67 99‐Jay Field LLE Royalty Trust Model 12‐31‐
PX0210‐02 2012_11_20 LLETX_031239 2011_10082012‐Sent Erik Abraham11202012.xlsx
PX0211 1998_08_00 LRTCOP00003441 LL&E Royalty Trust Schedule Overhead Charges
PX0212 2001_04_17 LRTCOP00005041 LL&E Royalty Trust Overhead Analysis
MARTINDALE_ 00004677‐MARTINDALE_
PX0213 1973_08_20 Jay Field Accounting Procedure
PX0214 2022_04_15 none Webpage Martindale Consultants, Inc. Todd Attalla
Webpage Martindale Consultants, Inc. COPAS Annual
PX0215 2022_04_17 none Overhead Adjustment Factors
PX0216 2000_02_09 COPQRE00064132 Email from A. Meek Falconi re: LRT Reserve Report
Letter from A. Taylor (Bracewell) to G. Roden Re: Marticons
Review Jay Field Overriding Royalty Payments LL&E Royalty
PX0217 2014_02_14 BREIT_0001470‐BREIT_0001472 Trust
MARTINDALE_00003997‐ Email from Attalla W. P. Martindale, Burnette,
PX0218 2009_02_09 MARTINDALE_00004000 Downing re: Jay Field Gas Plant Costs
MARTINDALE_00004009‐ Email from Burnette Attalla, Burnette, Downing,
PX0219 2009_02_10 MARTINDALE_00004011 W. P. Martindale re: Jay Field Gas Plant Costs
Email from Adkins Roden, cc: Ulrich FW Jay Field
PX0220 2011_01_12 BREIT_0004439‐BREIT_0004441 MSG Findings
BREIT_0011732‐BREIT_0011735, Email from Roden Parsons, Abraham, cc: Wimberly
PX0221 2013_09_19 BREIT_0011737‐BREIT_0011741 re: Audit Responses
Email from Stamp Attalla re: 11/09 Jay Suspended
PX0222 2011_01_25 BREIT_0038337‐BREIT_0038370 Operations Detail
Email from Attalla Stamp, bcc: Ulrich re: IR Jay Gas
MARTINDALE_00007007‐ Plant and Treating Facility Payroll Documentation [see native
PX0223 2010_11_15 MARTINDALE_00007008 MSG attachment]
PX0224 2010_11_25 MARTINDALE_00007008 Plant and Treating Facility Payroll Sample.xlsx
Email from Valenti Mulkey re: Update NPI Model [see
PX0225 2014_02_14 BREIT_0003592‐BREIT_0003601 native attachments]
PX0226 2014_05_12 BREIT_0003600 Jay NPI Updated 2014‐02‐14.xlsx
Jay QRM Trust Model QRM_YE2013 2014‐01‐31 NSAI Model
PX0227 2014_05_13 BREIT_0003601 for Acct Sens 2014‐02‐14run.xlsx
Email from Magilton Mulkey RE: Jay NPI Special Cost
PX0228 2014_05_12 BREIT_0012308 MSG Escrow
The Breitburn Parties'
Fifth Amended Exhibit List
File
Exhibit # Date Bates Doc. Description Offered Objected Admitted
Extension
Email from Magilton Mulkey, cc: Roden, DeLano,
PX0229 2015_05_28 BREIT_0012347 MSG Burgher, T. Pownell, A. Chau re: JAY NPI ‐‐ Special Cost Escrow
PX0230 2014_05_13 BREIT_0013677‐BREIT_0013682 Email from Dillard A. Valukas re: LL&E Royalty Trust
Email from Magilton russeldk@wellsfargo.com re: Wells
PX0231