On February 08, 2017 a Party Notice was filed involving a dispute between Autozone Parts, Inc., Dorman Products, Inc., Idsc Holdings, Llc, Mitchell Repair Information Company, Llc, Mountain View Tire & Service, Inc., North Coast Bearings, Llc, Rb Distribution, Inc., Twin City Fire Insurance Company, Donnelly, Dylan, and Autozone, Inc., Autozone Parts, Inc., Dorman Products, Inc., Eastwood Garage, Inc., Mcmahon'S Rv Superstore, Inc., Mitchell, Trey, Mountain View Tire & Service, Inc., North Coast Bearings Llc, Pleasure-Way Industries Ltd, Donnelly, Dylan, North Coast Bearings, Llc, Pleasure-Way Industries, Ltd., Rb Distribution, Inc., Roes 1 Through 100, for PI personal injury not MV in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
August 07, 2020
February 08, 2017
PI personal injury not MV
Closed
ANGLIN FLEWELLING RASMUSSEN CAMPBELL & TRYT Attorney
Anglin, Flewelling, Rasmussen, Campbell &Trytten Attorney
Anglin, Flewelling, Rasmussen, Campbell &Trytten Attorney for the Defendant
AUTOZONE INC Erroneously Sued As
AUTOZONE, INC. Defendant
AutoZone Parts, Inc. Cross Appellant In 1st X-appeal
AutoZone Parts, Inc. Respondent
AUTOZONE PARTS, INC Cross Defendant
AUTOZONE PARTS, INC. Cross Complainant
AUTOZONE PARTS, INC. Cross Defendant
AUTOZONE PARTS, INC. Defendant
CONV Conversion Event
DELAWARE MITCHELL INTERNATIONAL, INC Doing Business As
Donnelly, Dylan Cross Respondent In 1st X-appeal
Donnelly, Dylan Respondent
DONNELLY, DYLAN Plaintiff
Dorman Products, Inc. Cross Respondent In 1st X-appeal
Dorman Products, Inc. Respondent
DORMAN PRODUCTS, INC. Cross Complainant
DORMAN PRODUCTS, INC. Cross Defendant
DORMAN PRODUCTS, INC. Defendant
EASTWOOD GARAGE, INC Cross Defendant
EASTWOOD GARAGE, INC. Defendant
Friedenthal, Heffernan & Brown, LLP Attorney
Friedenthal, Heffernan & Brown, LLP Attorney for the Defendant
Haight Brown & Bonesteel Attorney
Haight Brown & Bonesteel Attorney for the Defendant
Hall Huguenin LLP Attorney for the Defendant
IDSC HOLDINGS, LLC Cross Complainant
IDSC HOLDINGS, LLC Cross Defendant
London Fischer LLP Attorney
LONDON FISCHER LLP Attorney
LONDON FISCHER LLP Attorney for the Appellant
Manning & Kass Ellrod Ramirez Trester LLP Attorney
Manning & Kass Ellrod Ramirez Trester LLP Attorney for the Defendant
MATHENY SEARS LINKERT & JAIME LLP Attorney
MATHENY SEARS LINKERT & JAIME LLP Attorney for the Defendant
MCMAHON'S RV SUPERSTOE,INC, AUTOZONE PARTS , INC, DORMAN PRODUCTS, INC NORTH COAST BEA Cross Defendant
MCMAHON'S RV SUPERSTORE, INC. Defendant
MITCHELL Doing Business As
MITCHELL1 Doing Business As
MITCHELL 1 Doing Business As
MITCHELL 1 ONLINE Doing Business As
MITCHELL 1 REPAIR INFORMATION COMPANY, LLC Doing Business As
MITCHELL 1 REPAIR ONLINE Doing Business As
MITCHELL INTERNATIONAL, INC Cross Defendant
MITCHELL INTERNATIONAL, INC. Cross Defendant
MITCHELL REPAIR INFORMATION COMPANY, LLC Cross Complainant
MITCHELL REPAIR INFORMATION COMPANY, LLC Cross Defendant
MITCHELL REPAIR INFORMATION COMPNY, LLC Cross Defendant
MITCHELL, TREY Defendant
MOES 1 THROUGH 100 Cross Defendant
MOUNTAIN VIEW TIRE & SERVICE, INC Cross Defendant
MOUNTAIN VIEW TIRE & SERVICE, INC. Cross Complainant
MOUNTAIN VIEW TIRE & SERVICE, INC. Defendant
Murchison & Cumming Attorney
Murchison & Cumming Attorney for the Defendant
North Coast Bearings, LLC Cross Respondent In 1st X-appeal
North Coast Bearings, LLC Respondent
NORTH COAST BEARINGS LLC Defendant
NORTH COAST BEARINGS, LLC Cross Complainant
Panish Shea & Boyle Attorney
Panish Shea & Boyle Attorney for the Plaintiff
Pleasure-Way Industries, Ltd. Cross Respondent In 1st X-appeal
Pleasure-Way Industries, Ltd. Respondent
Pleasure-Way Industries, LTD Cross Respondent In 1st X-appeal
PLEASURE-WAY INDUSTRIES LTD Cross Defendant
PLEASURE-WAY INDUSTRIES LTD Defendant
PLEASURE-WAY INDUSTRIES, LTD Cross Defendant
RB Distribution, Inc. Cross Respondent In 1st X-appeal
RB Distribution, Inc. Respondent
RB DISTRIBUTION, INC. Cross Complainant
RB DISTRIBUTION, INC. Cross Defendant
Roes 1 through 100 Respondent
ROES 1 THROUGH 100 Cross Defendant
ROES 1 THROUGH 50, INCLUSIVE Cross Defendant
Selman Breitman LLP Attorney
Severson & Werson Attorney
Severson & Werson Attorney for the Defendant
SEVERSON & WERSON Attorney
SNAP-ON BUSINESS SOLUTIONS, INC. Cross Defendant
SNAP-ON BUSINESS SOLUTIONS (SYNCATA), INC. Cross Defendant
SNAP-ON DIAGNOSTICS Cross Defendant
SNAP-ON DIAGNOSTICS Doing Business As
SNAP-ON EQUIPMENT, INC. Cross Defendant
SNAP-ON, INCORPORATED Cross Defendant
SNAP-ON LOGISTICS COMPANY Cross Defendant
SNAP-ON SECURECORP, INC. Cross Defendant
SNAP-ON TECHONOLOGIES, INC. Cross Defendant
SYNCATA CORPORATION Cross Defendant
Twin City Fire Insurance Company Appellant
Twin City Fire Insurance Company Cross Respondent In 1st X-appeal
TWIN CITY FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY Cross Complainant
Wade & Lowe Attorney for the Defendant
Daniel Dunbar Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Brian Panish Attorneys for Plaintiffs
William Dunbar Attorney
Gary Smith Attorneys for Defendants
Kevin Heffernan Attorney
Richard Miller Attorneys for Defendants
Paul Stephan Attorney
Alexander Behar Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Sevan Gobel Attorney
Alexander Barna Attorney
James Kahn Attorney
Richard Endres Attorney
Nicholas Davila Attorney
Peter Dubrawski Attorney
Sharon Collier Attorneys for Defendants
John Wilkerson Attorney
Leslie Fales Attorneys for Defendants
Bruce Cleeland Attorney
Elizabeth Handelin Attorneys for Defendants
Patrick Bollig Attorneys for Defendants
Daniel Friedenthal Attorney
Kerry Franich Attorneys for Defendants
Jonathan Slipp Attorneys for Defendants
Anthony Ellrod Attorney
Daniel Reardon Attorney
Taline Bazaz Attorney
Robert Rosvall Attorneys for Defendants
John Griffin Attorneys for Defendants
Kathleen Heffernan Attorneys for Defendants
Daniel Ip Attorney
Brian Hannemann Attorney
Daniel Wessner Attorney
Sharon Corda Attorney
Matthew Pero Attorney
John Wilson Attorney
Jonathan So Attorneys for Defendants
Todd Sorrell Attorney
Daniel Friedman Attorneys for Defendants
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Please wait a moment while we load this page.
Preview
1 BRUCE M CLEELAND State Bar No 100524 SUPERIOR COURT OF CUALIFORN bcleeland@hbblaw com COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO SAN RFRNARDINn CIVI n nc ON 2 JOHN WILKERSON State Bar No 201383 jwilkerson@hbblaw com Q7 2 2 3 HAIGHT BROWN BONESTEEL LLP p rCf 3880 Lemon Street Suite 410 Q C 4 Riverside CA 92501 Telephone 951 341 8300 5 Facsimile Syivia Guajardo 951 341 8309 6 SHARON C COLLIER State Bar No 203450 scc@severson com 7 KERRY W FRANICH State Bar No 245857 kwf@severson com 8 SEVERSON WERSON A Professional Corporation 9 One Embarcadero Center Suite 2600 San Francisco California 94111 10 Telephone 415 398 3344 Facsimile 415 956 0439 11 Attorneys for Cross Complainant Cross Defendant 12 AUTOZONE PARTS INC 13 14 SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA 15 COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT 16 17 DYLAN DONNELLY Case No CIVDS1702333 18 Hon John M Tomberlin Plaintiff Dept S33 19 vs MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND 20 AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF EASTWOOD GARAGE INC et al MOTION FOR A JUDGMENT 21 NOTWITHSTANDING THE VERDICT Defendants BY CROSS COMPLAINANT CROSS 22 DEFENDANT AUTOZONE PARTS INC 23 Date September 17 2020 AND RELATED CROSS ACTIONS Time 9 00 AM 24 Dept 5 33 25 Action Filed February 8 2017 O Trial Date July 30 2019 26 Judgment Entered July 23 2020 27 28 cBi2 00000ss 13469377 1 MOTION FOR JNOV i 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Pa e 2 3 I INTRODUCTION 5 6 4 II THE LEGAL STANDARD ON A JNOV MOTION 6 5 III THE COURT SHOULD ENTER A JNOV A There Was No Substantial Evidence Of Causation 7 6 7 B Without Carnahan Dorman Had No Expert To Show Causation 9 8 C There Was No Substantial Evidence That Dorman Suffered Any RecoverableDamages 10 9 12 IV CONCLUSION 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Gai2 00000ss 2 13469377 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS