Preview
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
CAUSE NO. C-2866-22-J
DEAN A. BROWN AND DONNA § IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF
M. DAVIS §
Plaintiffs, §
§
§ 430th JUDICIAL DISTRICT
VS. §
§
§
MURPHY WALL PRODUCTS §
INTERNATIONAL, INC. and §
ADRIAN MENDOZA § HIDALGO COUNTY, TEXAS
Defendants.
PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED PRELIMINARY EXHIBIT LIST
Plaintiffs Dean A. Brown and Donna M. Davis hereby designate the following
exhibits to be introduced at the trial of the above styled and numbered cause. Plaintiffs
expressly reserve the right to object to inadmissible exhibits during trial of this matter,
and do not by providing this list, purport to sponsor each and every exhibit as admissible
evidence.
PLAINTIFFS, DEAN A. BROWN AND DONNA M. DAVIS AMENDED
PRELIMINARY TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED
1. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 1 - Murphy Wall
Product Inc. Employee Manuel (Defendants
000219-000291)
2. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 2 - Murphy Driver's
Manuel (Defendants 000629-000674)
3. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 3 - Title 49 CFR
391.21 (05/31/2022) Application for Employment
4. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 4 - Employment
Application Q File Checklist (Defendants 000304-
000327)
5. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 5 - Title 49 CFR
391.23 (05/31/2022) Investigation and Inquiries
6. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 6 - Texas Department
of Public Safety Certified Abstract Records
Page 1
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED
7. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 7 - Texas Peace
Officer's Crash Report
8. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 8 - Truck Video
9. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 9 - Accident Protocol
and Report Form (Defendants 000606-000609)
10. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 10 - Statement of
Adrian Mendoza (Defendants 000545-000546)
11. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 11 - V.T.C.A.
Transportation Code - Maximum Speed
Requirement
12. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 12 - V.T.C.A.
Transportation Code - Following Distance PDF
13. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 13 - Mendoza's
Smith Training Evaluation and Certificate
(Defendants 000623-000628)
14. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 14 - NOT MARKED
15. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 15 - E-Mail
Correspondence (Defendants 000413)
16. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 16 - Colored
photograph (Brown 610353-000156)
17. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 17 - Colored
photographs (Defendants 000376-000387)
18. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 18 - Texas Peace
Officer's Crash Report - 2018
19. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 19 -Adrian Mendoza
Original Application - RETAINED
20. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 1 - Texas Peace Officer's
Crash Report
21. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 2 - Crash Report Code
Sheet
22. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 3 - Transportation Code
Section 545.351
23. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 4 - Dash Cam Video
(Bates 548)
24. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 5 - Dash Cam
Screenshot
25. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 6 - Dash Cam
Screenshot
Page 2
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED
26. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 7 - Dash Cam
Screenshot
27. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 8 - Transportation Code
Section 545.062
28. Mercado, Trooper Juan Def DX 1 - Set of
Photographs
29. Mercado, Trooper Juan Def DX 2 - Set of
Photographs (Bates 142-150)
30. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 1 - DriverDirect on
Road Defensive Driving Course (Defendants
000624 to 000628)
31. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 2 - Texas Peace
Officer
's Crash Report dated 07/07/2022 (Brown 610353-
000001 to 000005)
32. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 3 - Texas Peace
Officer's Crash Report dated 02/20/2018
33. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 4 - Texas
Department of Public Safety - Certified Abstract
Record
34. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 5 - T-Mobile call
log records
35. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 6 - T-Mobile
Interpreting Records
36. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 7 - Body Cam
Video
37. Crash Report Plaintiffs 000001-5
38. Fin Rec by Aff Acadian EMS Plaintiffs 000006-8
39. Med Rec by Aff Acadian EMS Plaintiffs 000009-14
40. Radiology Rec Christus Spohn Beeville Plaintiffs
000015
41.
Fin Rec by Aff Signature RX Plaintiffs 000016-17
42. Fin Rec by Aff Texas Regional Clinic Plaintiffs
000018-20
43. Med Rec by Aff Texas Regional Clinic Plaintiffs
000021-29
44.
Med Rec by Aff Signature RX Plaintiffs 000030-31
45.
Fin Rec by Aff Memorial MRI Plaintiffs 000032-39
Page 3
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED
46.
Med Rec by Aff Memorial MRI Plaintiffs 000040-49
47.
Med Rec by Aff Christus Spohn Beeville Plaintiffs
000050-104
48. Fin Rec by Aff Christus Spohn Beeville Plaintiffs
000105-106
49.
Fin Rec by Aff Miramar Pain Treatment Ctr
Plaintiffs 000107-108
50.
Med Rec by Aff Miramar Pain Treatment Ctr
Plaintiffs 000109-118
51. Fin Rec by Aff Humpal Phy Therapy Plaintiffs
000119-121
52. Med Rec by Aff Humpal Phy Therapy Plaintiffs
000122-131
53.
TDL of Dean Brown Plaintiffs 000140
54.
Scene Photos Plaintiffs 000142-150
55.
Photos Video of White TT Plaintiffs 000151-155
56. Photo of Dean Brown at the hospital Plaintiffs
000156
57.
2017 Income Tax Return Plaintiffs 000157-164
58.
2018 Income Tax Return Plaintiffs 000165-175
59.
2020 Income Tax Return Plaintiffs 000176-196
60.
2021 Income Tax Return Plaintiffs 000197-220
61.
Dean Brown BEFORE Photographs Plaintiffs
000221-254
62. W2-2022 & Paystub 02/11/23-02/17/23 Plaintiffs
000255-256
63. Med Rec by Aff Tracy Snow Mills DO Plaintiffs
000257-259
64. Fin Rec by Aff Texas Regional Clinic Plaintiffs
000260-264
Page 4
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED
65.
Med Rec by Aff Texas Regional Clinic Plaintiffs
000265-279
66.
Fin Rec by Aff Signature RX Plaintiffs 000280-282
67.
Med Rec by Aff Signature RX Plaintiffs 000283-285
68. Med Rec by Aff Christus Trinity Padre Island
Clinic-DR. TRACY SNOW MILLS Plaintiffs 000286-
332
69.
Profit or Loss from Business Plaintiffs 000333-339
70.
DPS Crash Exchange Plaintiffs 000340-341
71. Fin Rec by Aff Christus Family Medicine-Padre
Island-DR. TRACY SNOW MILLS Plaintiffs 000342-
344
72.
Radiology Rec Memorial MRI Plaintiffs 000347-348
73. 2018 Adrian Mendoza previous crash report
Plaintiffs 000349-357
74. 2022-08-30 TXDPS Cert Driving Record re Adrian
Mendoza Plaintiffs 000358-361
75.
MCCS Completed – redacted Plaintiffs 000362-373
76.
TxIRP Completed -redacted Plaintiffs 000374-384
77. TxIRP-Filenet Completed-redacted Plaintiffs
000385-420
78.
Indresano Consult Report Plaintiffs 000421-423
79.
Fairchild CV Plaintiffs 000424-429
80.
Grill CV Plaintiffs 000433-445
81.
Grill Report Plaintiffs 000446-477
82.
Grill Appendix B Plaintiffs 000478-479
Page 5
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED
83.
Radiology Rec Memorial MR Plaintiffs 000506-507
84. TMobile Recs by DWQ re: Adrian Mendoza
Plaintiffs 000508
85. Tmobile Recs by DWQ re: Adrian Mendoza-
Spreadsheet Plaintiffs 000509
86.
TxDOT Recs by DWQ-TxDot Crash Report
Plaintiffs 000510
87. TxDOT Recs by DWQ-CD 1-Photos CD 2-Video
Plaintiffs 000511
88. Fin Rec by Aff Complete Pain Solutions Plaintiffs
000512-514
89. Med Rec by Aff Complete Pain Solutions Plaintiffs
000515-521
90.
Christus Surgical Hospital-SCE Plaintiffs 000522
91.
Inresano-SCE Plaintiffs 000523
92.
Synergy Surgical-SCE Plaintiffs 000524
93. Med Rec by Aff Complete Pain Solutions Plaintiffs
000525-534
94.
Fin Rec by Aff Indresano Plaintiffs 000535-536
95.
Med Rec by Aff Dr Indresano Plaintiffs 000537-540
96.
Med Rec by Complete Pain Solutions Plaintiffs
000541-550
97.
Letter from James Temple 000551
98.
Letter from Ricco Tetzlaff 000552
99.
Fin Rec by Aff ASP Cares 000553-554
100. Employee Manual Defendants Defendants 000219-
291
Page 6
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED
101.
Maintenance Defendants Defendants 000298-303
102.
Q-File Defendants Defendants 000304-327
103.
Adrian Mendoza personnel Defendants 000328-375
104.
Photos of vehicle Defendants 000376-387
105.
Ticket Defendants 000394-395
106.
Citation and petition Defendants 000398-406
107.
Drug and alcohol test Defendants 000407-408
108.
Adrian Drug Test Results after accident Defendants
000409-410
109.
Alcohol and drug testing -more legible copy
Defendants 000411-412
110.
HR Email Defendants 000413
111.
Driver Logs and Inspection Reports Defendants
000414-544
112.
Statement of A. Mendoza Defendants 000545-546
113.
Accident Register Defendants 00057
114.
Truck Video Defendants 000548
115.
Truck Video Defendants 000605
116.
Accident Protocol and reporting form Defendants
000606-609
117.
Accident Register Defendants 000610
Page 7
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED
118.
Route map Defendants 000611
119.
Vehicle Inspection Reports Defendants 000612-613
120.
Mendoza's MVRS Defendants 000614-620
121.
Mendoza's medical certification Defendants 000621
122. Mendoza's Safety Training Material Defendants
000622-628
123.
Driver's manual Defendants 000626-674
124.
Invoice of delivery Defendants 000675
125.
Record of repair Defendants 000676
126. DWQs Med Records/Billing Records Defendants
000722-832
127.
Citation Recvd for Vehicle Defendants 000833-835
128. Driver Meeting and Materials Defendants 000836-
841
129.
Guillermos Accident Info Form-Redacted
Defendants 000842
130.
Mendoza MVR 05272022-Redacted Defendants
000843
131. Santos Purchase Order-Redacted Defendants
000844
132. Employment by DWQ TNT Crane & Rigging-
Defendants
133.
Phone Recs by DWQ AT&T- Defendants
134. Claims File by DWQ Blue Cross Blue Shield-
Defendants
135. Med Rec by DWQ Acadian Ambulance-
Defendants
136.
Fin Rec by DWQ Acadian Ambulance- Defendants
Page 8
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED
137.
Med Rec by DWQ Signature RX- Defendants
138.
Fin Rec by DWQ Signature RX- Defendants
139.
Med Rec by DWQ TRC- Defendants
140.
Radiology by DWQ TRC- Defendants
141.
Fin Rec by DWQ TRC- Defendants
142.
Med Rec by DWQ Memorial MRI- Defendants
143.
Radiology by DWQ Memorial MRI- Defendants
144.
Fin Rec by DWQ Memorial MRI- Defendants
145. Med Rec by DWQ Christus Spohn Beeville-
Defendants
146. Radiology Rec by DWQ Christus Spohn Beeville-
Defendants
147. Fin Rec by DWQ Christus Spohn Beeville-
Defendants
148. Med Rec by DWQ Mirmar Interventional Pain-
Defendants
149. Radiology Rec by DWQ Mirmar Interventional
Pain- Defendants
150. Fin Rec by DWQ Mirmar Interventional Pain-
Defendants
151.
Med Rec by DWQ Humpal PT- Defendants
152.
Radiology Rec by DWQ Humpal PT- Defendants
153.
Fin Rec by DWQ Humpal PT- Defendants
154. Three Rivers Highway Patrol Office Recs by DWQ-
Defendant
Plaintiffs further incorporate the Exhibit List and exhibits provided by the
Defendants.
Page 9
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
Pursuant to Rule 193.7 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, Plaintiffs hereby
gives actual notice to all parties that they intends to use any and all documents produced
by all parties in response to written discovery, attached to depositions as exhibits, or
produced for inspection in this case at any hearing or at the trial on the merits.
Plaintiffs reserve the right to contest the admissibility of all the foregoing
documents in accordance with the Texas Rules of Evidence and the Texas Rules of Civil
Procedure.
Plaintiffs reserve the right to amend this list upon discovery of additional exhibits.
Further, Plaintiffs hereby reserve the right to amend and/or supplement this Exhibit List.
Respectfully submitted,
LILES WHITE PLLC
500 N. Water St., Suite 800
Corpus Christi, TX 78401-0232
Tel: 361.826.0100
Fax: 361.826.0101
Filing Notifications: efiling@lileswhite.com
By:
Brendan T. Villanueva
State Bar No. 24086960
brendan@lileswhite.com
Stuart R. White
State Bar No. 24075268
stuart@lileswhite.com
Kevin W. Liles
State Bar No. 00798329
kevin@lileswhite.com
Celeste Baltierra
State Bar No. 24095479
Celeste@lileswhite.com
Rob George
rob@lileswhite.com
E-Filing Notifications Only To:
efiling@lileswhite.com
AND
Raymond L. Thomas
State Bar No. 19865350
rthomas@raythomaspc.com
Page 10
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
Olegario Garcia
State Bar No. 24069759
ogarcia@raythomaspc.com
RAY THOMAS, PLLC
4900-B N. 10th Street
McAllen, Texas 78504
Tel: 956.632.5033
Fax: 956.540.5631
ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that on November 29, 2023, I electronically filed the foregoing with
the Clerk of the Court by using CM-ECF system, which will send a notice of filing to all
counsel accepting electronic notice and listed below, and additional service as identified
below. I further certify that all parties not receiving or accepting electronic notices via
ECF were served a copy by either Electronic Mail; US First Class Mail; Certified
Mail/RRR and or via Facsimile.
Via email:
Page 11
Electronically Filed
11/29/2023 11:37 AM
Hidalgo County District Clerks
Reviewed By: Kristina Morin
Peter C. Blomquist
Matthew R. Gelina
Zachary Z. Robichaux
David L. Jones
Hartline Barger, LLP
1980 Post Oak Blvd. Suite 1800,
Houston, TX 77056
Service email: trv@hartlinebarger.com
Attorney for Defendants
Jessica Z. Barger
E. Marie Jamison
Ruben Garza
Wright Close & Barger, LLP
One Riverway, Suite 2200
Houston, Texas 77056
Attorney for Defendants
By:
Brendan T. Villanueva
Page 12
Automated Certificate of eService
This automated certificate of service was created by the efiling system.
The filer served this document via email generated by the efiling system
on the date and to the persons listed below. The rules governing
certificates of service have not changed. Filers must still provide a
certificate of service that complies with all applicable rules.
SHARON LUCE on behalf of Stuart White
Bar No. 24075268
sharon@lileswhite.com
Envelope ID: 82049146
Filing Code Description: Exhibit
Filing Description: Plaintiffs' Amended Preliminary Exhibit List
Status as of 11/29/2023 2:10 PM CST
Associated Case Party: DeanA.Brown
Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status
KEVIN LILES KEVIN@LILESWHITE.COM 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Raymond LThomas rthomas@raythomaspc.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Olegario Garcia ogarcia@raythomaspc.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Associated Case Party: Adrian Mendoza
Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status
Matthew Gelina mgelina@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Service Trv trv@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Peter CBlomquist pblomquist@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Megan JRothermel mrothermel@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Zachary Robichaux zrobichaux@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
David LJones djones@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Case Contacts
Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status
Theresa Cahoon tcahoon@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Stuart White 24075268 efiling@lileswhite.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
David Jones djones@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Sharon Luce sharon@lileswhite.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Luisa Flores Lflores@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
STUART WHITE STUART@LILESWHITE.COM 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Automated Certificate of eService
This automated certificate of service was created by the efiling system.
The filer served this document via email generated by the efiling system
on the date and to the persons listed below. The rules governing
certificates of service have not changed. Filers must still provide a
certificate of service that complies with all applicable rules.
SHARON LUCE on behalf of Stuart White
Bar No. 24075268
sharon@lileswhite.com
Envelope ID: 82049146
Filing Code Description: Exhibit
Filing Description: Plaintiffs' Amended Preliminary Exhibit List
Status as of 11/29/2023 2:10 PM CST
Case Contacts
STUART WHITE STUART@LILESWHITE.COM 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Jessica Barger barger@wrightclosebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
E. Marie Jamison jamison@wrightclosebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Brendan TVillanueva brendan@lileswhite.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Ruben Garza garza@wrightclosebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Michelle Heigelmann heigelmann@wrightclosebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Jillian Cyrus-Ray cyrus@wrightclosebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT
Associated Case Party: Murphy Wall Products International, Inc.
Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status
Cicely Benoit cbenoit@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM ERROR
Preview
Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin CAUSE NO. C-2866-22-J DEAN A. BROWN AND DONNA § IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF M. DAVIS § Plaintiffs, § § § 430th JUDICIAL DISTRICT VS. § § § MURPHY WALL PRODUCTS § INTERNATIONAL, INC. and § ADRIAN MENDOZA § HIDALGO COUNTY, TEXAS Defendants. PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED PRELIMINARY EXHIBIT LIST Plaintiffs Dean A. Brown and Donna M. Davis hereby designate the following exhibits to be introduced at the trial of the above styled and numbered cause. Plaintiffs expressly reserve the right to object to inadmissible exhibits during trial of this matter, and do not by providing this list, purport to sponsor each and every exhibit as admissible evidence. PLAINTIFFS, DEAN A. BROWN AND DONNA M. DAVIS AMENDED PRELIMINARY TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED 1. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 1 - Murphy Wall Product Inc. Employee Manuel (Defendants 000219-000291) 2. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 2 - Murphy Driver's Manuel (Defendants 000629-000674) 3. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 3 - Title 49 CFR 391.21 (05/31/2022) Application for Employment 4. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 4 - Employment Application Q File Checklist (Defendants 000304- 000327) 5. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 5 - Title 49 CFR 391.23 (05/31/2022) Investigation and Inquiries 6. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 6 - Texas Department of Public Safety Certified Abstract Records Page 1 Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED 7. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 7 - Texas Peace Officer's Crash Report 8. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 8 - Truck Video 9. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 9 - Accident Protocol and Report Form (Defendants 000606-000609) 10. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 10 - Statement of Adrian Mendoza (Defendants 000545-000546) 11. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 11 - V.T.C.A. Transportation Code - Maximum Speed Requirement 12. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 12 - V.T.C.A. Transportation Code - Following Distance PDF 13. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 13 - Mendoza's Smith Training Evaluation and Certificate (Defendants 000623-000628) 14. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 14 - NOT MARKED 15. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 15 - E-Mail Correspondence (Defendants 000413) 16. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 16 - Colored photograph (Brown 610353-000156) 17. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 17 - Colored photographs (Defendants 000376-000387) 18. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 18 - Texas Peace Officer's Crash Report - 2018 19. Smith, Corp. Rep. Tammy DX 19 -Adrian Mendoza Original Application - RETAINED 20. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 1 - Texas Peace Officer's Crash Report 21. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 2 - Crash Report Code Sheet 22. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 3 - Transportation Code Section 545.351 23. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 4 - Dash Cam Video (Bates 548) 24. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 5 - Dash Cam Screenshot 25. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 6 - Dash Cam Screenshot Page 2 Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED 26. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 7 - Dash Cam Screenshot 27. Mercado, Trooper Juan DX 8 - Transportation Code Section 545.062 28. Mercado, Trooper Juan Def DX 1 - Set of Photographs 29. Mercado, Trooper Juan Def DX 2 - Set of Photographs (Bates 142-150) 30. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 1 - DriverDirect on Road Defensive Driving Course (Defendants 000624 to 000628) 31. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 2 - Texas Peace Officer 's Crash Report dated 07/07/2022 (Brown 610353- 000001 to 000005) 32. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 3 - Texas Peace Officer's Crash Report dated 02/20/2018 33. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 4 - Texas Department of Public Safety - Certified Abstract Record 34. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 5 - T-Mobile call log records 35. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 6 - T-Mobile Interpreting Records 36. Mendoza, Adrian 07/24/23 DX 7 - Body Cam Video 37. Crash Report Plaintiffs 000001-5 38. Fin Rec by Aff Acadian EMS Plaintiffs 000006-8 39. Med Rec by Aff Acadian EMS Plaintiffs 000009-14 40. Radiology Rec Christus Spohn Beeville Plaintiffs 000015 41. Fin Rec by Aff Signature RX Plaintiffs 000016-17 42. Fin Rec by Aff Texas Regional Clinic Plaintiffs 000018-20 43. Med Rec by Aff Texas Regional Clinic Plaintiffs 000021-29 44. Med Rec by Aff Signature RX Plaintiffs 000030-31 45. Fin Rec by Aff Memorial MRI Plaintiffs 000032-39 Page 3 Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED 46. Med Rec by Aff Memorial MRI Plaintiffs 000040-49 47. Med Rec by Aff Christus Spohn Beeville Plaintiffs 000050-104 48. Fin Rec by Aff Christus Spohn Beeville Plaintiffs 000105-106 49. Fin Rec by Aff Miramar Pain Treatment Ctr Plaintiffs 000107-108 50. Med Rec by Aff Miramar Pain Treatment Ctr Plaintiffs 000109-118 51. Fin Rec by Aff Humpal Phy Therapy Plaintiffs 000119-121 52. Med Rec by Aff Humpal Phy Therapy Plaintiffs 000122-131 53. TDL of Dean Brown Plaintiffs 000140 54. Scene Photos Plaintiffs 000142-150 55. Photos Video of White TT Plaintiffs 000151-155 56. Photo of Dean Brown at the hospital Plaintiffs 000156 57. 2017 Income Tax Return Plaintiffs 000157-164 58. 2018 Income Tax Return Plaintiffs 000165-175 59. 2020 Income Tax Return Plaintiffs 000176-196 60. 2021 Income Tax Return Plaintiffs 000197-220 61. Dean Brown BEFORE Photographs Plaintiffs 000221-254 62. W2-2022 & Paystub 02/11/23-02/17/23 Plaintiffs 000255-256 63. Med Rec by Aff Tracy Snow Mills DO Plaintiffs 000257-259 64. Fin Rec by Aff Texas Regional Clinic Plaintiffs 000260-264 Page 4 Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED 65. Med Rec by Aff Texas Regional Clinic Plaintiffs 000265-279 66. Fin Rec by Aff Signature RX Plaintiffs 000280-282 67. Med Rec by Aff Signature RX Plaintiffs 000283-285 68. Med Rec by Aff Christus Trinity Padre Island Clinic-DR. TRACY SNOW MILLS Plaintiffs 000286- 332 69. Profit or Loss from Business Plaintiffs 000333-339 70. DPS Crash Exchange Plaintiffs 000340-341 71. Fin Rec by Aff Christus Family Medicine-Padre Island-DR. TRACY SNOW MILLS Plaintiffs 000342- 344 72. Radiology Rec Memorial MRI Plaintiffs 000347-348 73. 2018 Adrian Mendoza previous crash report Plaintiffs 000349-357 74. 2022-08-30 TXDPS Cert Driving Record re Adrian Mendoza Plaintiffs 000358-361 75. MCCS Completed – redacted Plaintiffs 000362-373 76. TxIRP Completed -redacted Plaintiffs 000374-384 77. TxIRP-Filenet Completed-redacted Plaintiffs 000385-420 78. Indresano Consult Report Plaintiffs 000421-423 79. Fairchild CV Plaintiffs 000424-429 80. Grill CV Plaintiffs 000433-445 81. Grill Report Plaintiffs 000446-477 82. Grill Appendix B Plaintiffs 000478-479 Page 5 Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED 83. Radiology Rec Memorial MR Plaintiffs 000506-507 84. TMobile Recs by DWQ re: Adrian Mendoza Plaintiffs 000508 85. Tmobile Recs by DWQ re: Adrian Mendoza- Spreadsheet Plaintiffs 000509 86. TxDOT Recs by DWQ-TxDot Crash Report Plaintiffs 000510 87. TxDOT Recs by DWQ-CD 1-Photos CD 2-Video Plaintiffs 000511 88. Fin Rec by Aff Complete Pain Solutions Plaintiffs 000512-514 89. Med Rec by Aff Complete Pain Solutions Plaintiffs 000515-521 90. Christus Surgical Hospital-SCE Plaintiffs 000522 91. Inresano-SCE Plaintiffs 000523 92. Synergy Surgical-SCE Plaintiffs 000524 93. Med Rec by Aff Complete Pain Solutions Plaintiffs 000525-534 94. Fin Rec by Aff Indresano Plaintiffs 000535-536 95. Med Rec by Aff Dr Indresano Plaintiffs 000537-540 96. Med Rec by Complete Pain Solutions Plaintiffs 000541-550 97. Letter from James Temple 000551 98. Letter from Ricco Tetzlaff 000552 99. Fin Rec by Aff ASP Cares 000553-554 100. Employee Manual Defendants Defendants 000219- 291 Page 6 Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED 101. Maintenance Defendants Defendants 000298-303 102. Q-File Defendants Defendants 000304-327 103. Adrian Mendoza personnel Defendants 000328-375 104. Photos of vehicle Defendants 000376-387 105. Ticket Defendants 000394-395 106. Citation and petition Defendants 000398-406 107. Drug and alcohol test Defendants 000407-408 108. Adrian Drug Test Results after accident Defendants 000409-410 109. Alcohol and drug testing -more legible copy Defendants 000411-412 110. HR Email Defendants 000413 111. Driver Logs and Inspection Reports Defendants 000414-544 112. Statement of A. Mendoza Defendants 000545-546 113. Accident Register Defendants 00057 114. Truck Video Defendants 000548 115. Truck Video Defendants 000605 116. Accident Protocol and reporting form Defendants 000606-609 117. Accident Register Defendants 000610 Page 7 Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED 118. Route map Defendants 000611 119. Vehicle Inspection Reports Defendants 000612-613 120. Mendoza's MVRS Defendants 000614-620 121. Mendoza's medical certification Defendants 000621 122. Mendoza's Safety Training Material Defendants 000622-628 123. Driver's manual Defendants 000626-674 124. Invoice of delivery Defendants 000675 125. Record of repair Defendants 000676 126. DWQs Med Records/Billing Records Defendants 000722-832 127. Citation Recvd for Vehicle Defendants 000833-835 128. Driver Meeting and Materials Defendants 000836- 841 129. Guillermos Accident Info Form-Redacted Defendants 000842 130. Mendoza MVR 05272022-Redacted Defendants 000843 131. Santos Purchase Order-Redacted Defendants 000844 132. Employment by DWQ TNT Crane & Rigging- Defendants 133. Phone Recs by DWQ AT&T- Defendants 134. Claims File by DWQ Blue Cross Blue Shield- Defendants 135. Med Rec by DWQ Acadian Ambulance- Defendants 136. Fin Rec by DWQ Acadian Ambulance- Defendants Page 8 Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin PX # DESCRIPTION OFFERED OBJECTION ADMITTED 137. Med Rec by DWQ Signature RX- Defendants 138. Fin Rec by DWQ Signature RX- Defendants 139. Med Rec by DWQ TRC- Defendants 140. Radiology by DWQ TRC- Defendants 141. Fin Rec by DWQ TRC- Defendants 142. Med Rec by DWQ Memorial MRI- Defendants 143. Radiology by DWQ Memorial MRI- Defendants 144. Fin Rec by DWQ Memorial MRI- Defendants 145. Med Rec by DWQ Christus Spohn Beeville- Defendants 146. Radiology Rec by DWQ Christus Spohn Beeville- Defendants 147. Fin Rec by DWQ Christus Spohn Beeville- Defendants 148. Med Rec by DWQ Mirmar Interventional Pain- Defendants 149. Radiology Rec by DWQ Mirmar Interventional Pain- Defendants 150. Fin Rec by DWQ Mirmar Interventional Pain- Defendants 151. Med Rec by DWQ Humpal PT- Defendants 152. Radiology Rec by DWQ Humpal PT- Defendants 153. Fin Rec by DWQ Humpal PT- Defendants 154. Three Rivers Highway Patrol Office Recs by DWQ- Defendant Plaintiffs further incorporate the Exhibit List and exhibits provided by the Defendants. Page 9 Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin Pursuant to Rule 193.7 of the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure, Plaintiffs hereby gives actual notice to all parties that they intends to use any and all documents produced by all parties in response to written discovery, attached to depositions as exhibits, or produced for inspection in this case at any hearing or at the trial on the merits. Plaintiffs reserve the right to contest the admissibility of all the foregoing documents in accordance with the Texas Rules of Evidence and the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure. Plaintiffs reserve the right to amend this list upon discovery of additional exhibits. Further, Plaintiffs hereby reserve the right to amend and/or supplement this Exhibit List. Respectfully submitted, LILES WHITE PLLC 500 N. Water St., Suite 800 Corpus Christi, TX 78401-0232 Tel: 361.826.0100 Fax: 361.826.0101 Filing Notifications: efiling@lileswhite.com By: Brendan T. Villanueva State Bar No. 24086960 brendan@lileswhite.com Stuart R. White State Bar No. 24075268 stuart@lileswhite.com Kevin W. Liles State Bar No. 00798329 kevin@lileswhite.com Celeste Baltierra State Bar No. 24095479 Celeste@lileswhite.com Rob George rob@lileswhite.com E-Filing Notifications Only To: efiling@lileswhite.com AND Raymond L. Thomas State Bar No. 19865350 rthomas@raythomaspc.com Page 10 Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin Olegario Garcia State Bar No. 24069759 ogarcia@raythomaspc.com RAY THOMAS, PLLC 4900-B N. 10th Street McAllen, Texas 78504 Tel: 956.632.5033 Fax: 956.540.5631 ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on November 29, 2023, I electronically filed the foregoing with the Clerk of the Court by using CM-ECF system, which will send a notice of filing to all counsel accepting electronic notice and listed below, and additional service as identified below. I further certify that all parties not receiving or accepting electronic notices via ECF were served a copy by either Electronic Mail; US First Class Mail; Certified Mail/RRR and or via Facsimile. Via email: Page 11 Electronically Filed 11/29/2023 11:37 AM Hidalgo County District Clerks Reviewed By: Kristina Morin Peter C. Blomquist Matthew R. Gelina Zachary Z. Robichaux David L. Jones Hartline Barger, LLP 1980 Post Oak Blvd. Suite 1800, Houston, TX 77056 Service email: trv@hartlinebarger.com Attorney for Defendants Jessica Z. Barger E. Marie Jamison Ruben Garza Wright Close & Barger, LLP One Riverway, Suite 2200 Houston, Texas 77056 Attorney for Defendants By: Brendan T. Villanueva Page 12 Automated Certificate of eService This automated certificate of service was created by the efiling system. The filer served this document via email generated by the efiling system on the date and to the persons listed below. The rules governing certificates of service have not changed. Filers must still provide a certificate of service that complies with all applicable rules. SHARON LUCE on behalf of Stuart White Bar No. 24075268 sharon@lileswhite.com Envelope ID: 82049146 Filing Code Description: Exhibit Filing Description: Plaintiffs' Amended Preliminary Exhibit List Status as of 11/29/2023 2:10 PM CST Associated Case Party: DeanA.Brown Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status KEVIN LILES KEVIN@LILESWHITE.COM 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Raymond LThomas rthomas@raythomaspc.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Olegario Garcia ogarcia@raythomaspc.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Associated Case Party: Adrian Mendoza Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status Matthew Gelina mgelina@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Service Trv trv@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Peter CBlomquist pblomquist@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Megan JRothermel mrothermel@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Zachary Robichaux zrobichaux@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT David LJones djones@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Case Contacts Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status Theresa Cahoon tcahoon@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Stuart White 24075268 efiling@lileswhite.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT David Jones djones@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Sharon Luce sharon@lileswhite.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Luisa Flores Lflores@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT STUART WHITE STUART@LILESWHITE.COM 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Automated Certificate of eService This automated certificate of service was created by the efiling system. The filer served this document via email generated by the efiling system on the date and to the persons listed below. The rules governing certificates of service have not changed. Filers must still provide a certificate of service that complies with all applicable rules. SHARON LUCE on behalf of Stuart White Bar No. 24075268 sharon@lileswhite.com Envelope ID: 82049146 Filing Code Description: Exhibit Filing Description: Plaintiffs' Amended Preliminary Exhibit List Status as of 11/29/2023 2:10 PM CST Case Contacts STUART WHITE STUART@LILESWHITE.COM 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Jessica Barger barger@wrightclosebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT E. Marie Jamison jamison@wrightclosebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Brendan TVillanueva brendan@lileswhite.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Ruben Garza garza@wrightclosebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Michelle Heigelmann heigelmann@wrightclosebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Jillian Cyrus-Ray cyrus@wrightclosebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM SENT Associated Case Party: Murphy Wall Products International, Inc. Name BarNumber Email TimestampSubmitted Status Cicely Benoit cbenoit@hartlinebarger.com 11/29/2023 11:37:11 AM ERROR