On May 06, 2019 a
Party Discovery
was filed
involving a dispute between
Anthony L Perez, Successor-In-Interest To The Estate Of Jordan Lee Perez,
Perez, Anthony L,
Perez, Sandra L,
Sandra L Perez, Successor-In-Interest To The Estate Of Jordan Lee Perez,
and
Abongwa M.D., Chenue,
Barcega M.D., Besh R,
Bravo M.D, Thomas P,
Brown M.D., Lance A,
Collins M.D., Chelsea L,
Does 2-200, Inclusive,
Fteeh M.D., Gamil,
Kheradpour M.D., Albert,
Kim M.D., Tommy Y,
Klooster M.D., Marquelle J,
Kong, P.A., Yuthana,
Li M.D., Natasha Y,
Loma Linda University Children'S Hospital A Nonprofit Corporation,
Loma Linda University Health A Nonprofit Corporation,
Loma Linda University Medical Center A Nonprofit Corporation,
Mehta M.D., Khyati P,
Peterson M.D., Sarah C,
Pichon M.D., Pilar D,
Richter, David,
Sadanand M.D., Venkatraman,
Suterwala M.D., Batul,
Thorp M.D., Andrea W,
Zimmerman M.D, Kimberly R,
Zouros M.D., Alexander,
for Complaint for Medical Malpractice
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
V \y
Gordon L. Dayton, Esq., (SBN: 208379)
LAW OFFICES OF GORDON L. DAYTON
41856 Ivy Street, Suite 214
Murrieta, CA 92562
Telephone (951) 296-5303 °
Facsimile (951) 296-5319
r—
E D
LUPERsOR coum or CAL IFORNIA
Attorney for Plaintiffs, ANTHONY L. PEREZ n
OWE: gfigfimggmggmo
" ‘ ’
and SANDRA L. PEREZ
HJN 1 8 2021
"V .. . J32. LilgmjgHEPLWY
m W..-
I
N100: I: r) [)wvm
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT 0F THE STATE 0F CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO
ANTHONY L. PEREZ, an individual, SANDRA L. Case No. CIVD51913814
10 PEREZ, an individual, ANTHONY L. PEREZ,
ESTATE OF JORDAN
Successor—in-Interest to the SEPARATE STATEMENT IN SUPPORT 0F
11 LEE PEREZ, andSANDRA L. PEREZ, Successor- NOTICE 0F MOTION AND MOTION TO
in-Interest t0 the ESTATE OF JORDAN LEE COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO
12 PEREZ REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF
DOCUMENTS, SET ONE, AND FOR $2600 IN
13 Plaintiffs, MONETARY SANCTIONS
14 Filed Concurrently with Notice of Motion and
vs. Motion to Compel Further Responses to
15 Request for Production of Documents, Set One,
and for $2600 in Monetary Sanctions.
16 LOMA LINDA UNIVERSITY HEALTH, a
nonprofit corporation; LOMA LINDA [California Rules of Court (“CRC”), Rule 3.1345]
17 UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER, a nonprofit
corporation; LOMA LINDA UNIVERSITY
18 CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL a nonprofit corporation; Date: July 26, 2021
ALBERT KHERADPOUR M.D., an individual; Time: 9:00 a.m.
19 CHENUE ABONGWA M.D., an individual; Dept: 523
CHELSEA L. COLLINS M.D., an individual;
20 BATUL SUTERWALA M.D., an individual;
VENKATRAMAN SADANAND M.D., an
21 individual; ALEXANDER ZOUROS M.D, an Trial Date: None Assigned
individual; YUTHANA KONG, P.A., an Action Filed: May 6, 2019
22 individual; PILAR D. PICHON M.D., an
individual; GAMIL FTEEH M.D., an individual;
23 THOMAS P. BRAVO M.D., an individual;
MARQUELLE J. KLOOSTER M.D., an
24 individual; KHYATI P. MEHTA M.D., an
1
SEPARATE STATEMENT IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES
TO REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS AND FOR MONETARY SANCTIONS
individual; KIMBERLY R. ZIMMERMAN M.D.,
an individual;SARAH C. PETERSON M.D., an
individual; BESH R. BARCEGA M.D., an
individual; NATASHA Y. LI M.D., an individual;
LANCE A. BROWN M.D., an individual;
TOMMY Y. KIM M.D., an individual; ANDREA
W. THORP M.D, an individual; DAVID RICHTER
M.D., an individual, and DOES 2-200, inclusive,
Defendants.
SEPARATE STATEMENT
Plaintiff submits this separate statement in support of notice of motion and motion to compel
further responses to request for production of documents, Set One, and for $2600 in monetary
10 sanction in compliance with CRC, Rule 3.1345.
11 General Objegtions:
12 Legal and Factual Reason§ for Compelling Further Response:
13 General objections, by definition, are “too general” to be properly made. CCP § 2031.310(a)
14 (3). Even though several Requests may be objectionable on the same ground they may not be
15 objected t0 as a group. Hogan and Weber, California Civil Discovery (2d. ed 2009) § 518. Plaintiff
16 requests the Court order Defendant t0 provide further responses, without any improper general or
17 blanket objections.
18 DEMAND FOR PRODUCTION OF DOQUMENTS NO. 1
19 A11 DOCUMENTS, including, but not limited to, ELECTRONICALLY STORED
20 INFORMATION, RELATING TO any CLINICAL CRITERIA SOFTWARE utilized by YOU
21 RELATING TO JORDAN’s patient care during the INCIDENT.
22 RELATED DEFINITIONS U§ED=
23 “YOU” and “YOUR” includes you, your agents, your employees, your insurance
24 companies, their agents, their employees, your attorneys, your accountants, your
2
SEPARATE STATEMENT IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES
TO REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS AND FOR MONETARY SANCTIONS
Preview
V \y Gordon L. Dayton, Esq., (SBN: 208379) LAW OFFICES OF GORDON L. DAYTON 41856 Ivy Street, Suite 214 Murrieta, CA 92562 Telephone (951) 296-5303 ° Facsimile (951) 296-5319 r— E D LUPERsOR coum or CAL IFORNIA Attorney for Plaintiffs, ANTHONY L. PEREZ n OWE: gfigfimggmggmo " ‘ ’ and SANDRA L. PEREZ HJN 1 8 2021 "V .. . J32. LilgmjgHEPLWY m W..- I N100: I: r) [)wvm IN THE SUPERIOR COURT 0F THE STATE 0F CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO ANTHONY L. PEREZ, an individual, SANDRA L. Case No. CIVD51913814 10 PEREZ, an individual, ANTHONY L. PEREZ, ESTATE OF JORDAN Successor—in-Interest to the SEPARATE STATEMENT IN SUPPORT 0F 11 LEE PEREZ, andSANDRA L. PEREZ, Successor- NOTICE 0F MOTION AND MOTION TO in-Interest t0 the ESTATE OF JORDAN LEE COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO 12 PEREZ REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, SET ONE, AND FOR $2600 IN 13 Plaintiffs, MONETARY SANCTIONS 14 Filed Concurrently with Notice of Motion and vs. Motion to Compel Further Responses to 15 Request for Production of Documents, Set One, and for $2600 in Monetary Sanctions. 16 LOMA LINDA UNIVERSITY HEALTH, a nonprofit corporation; LOMA LINDA [California Rules of Court (“CRC”), Rule 3.1345] 17 UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER, a nonprofit corporation; LOMA LINDA UNIVERSITY 18 CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL a nonprofit corporation; Date: July 26, 2021 ALBERT KHERADPOUR M.D., an individual; Time: 9:00 a.m. 19 CHENUE ABONGWA M.D., an individual; Dept: 523 CHELSEA L. COLLINS M.D., an individual; 20 BATUL SUTERWALA M.D., an individual; VENKATRAMAN SADANAND M.D., an 21 individual; ALEXANDER ZOUROS M.D, an Trial Date: None Assigned individual; YUTHANA KONG, P.A., an Action Filed: May 6, 2019 22 individual; PILAR D. PICHON M.D., an individual; GAMIL FTEEH M.D., an individual; 23 THOMAS P. BRAVO M.D., an individual; MARQUELLE J. KLOOSTER M.D., an 24 individual; KHYATI P. MEHTA M.D., an 1 SEPARATE STATEMENT IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS AND FOR MONETARY SANCTIONS individual; KIMBERLY R. ZIMMERMAN M.D., an individual;SARAH C. PETERSON M.D., an individual; BESH R. BARCEGA M.D., an individual; NATASHA Y. LI M.D., an individual; LANCE A. BROWN M.D., an individual; TOMMY Y. KIM M.D., an individual; ANDREA W. THORP M.D, an individual; DAVID RICHTER M.D., an individual, and DOES 2-200, inclusive, Defendants. SEPARATE STATEMENT Plaintiff submits this separate statement in support of notice of motion and motion to compel further responses to request for production of documents, Set One, and for $2600 in monetary 10 sanction in compliance with CRC, Rule 3.1345. 11 General Objegtions: 12 Legal and Factual Reason§ for Compelling Further Response: 13 General objections, by definition, are “too general” to be properly made. CCP § 2031.310(a) 14 (3). Even though several Requests may be objectionable on the same ground they may not be 15 objected t0 as a group. Hogan and Weber, California Civil Discovery (2d. ed 2009) § 518. Plaintiff 16 requests the Court order Defendant t0 provide further responses, without any improper general or 17 blanket objections. 18 DEMAND FOR PRODUCTION OF DOQUMENTS NO. 1 19 A11 DOCUMENTS, including, but not limited to, ELECTRONICALLY STORED 20 INFORMATION, RELATING TO any CLINICAL CRITERIA SOFTWARE utilized by YOU 21 RELATING TO JORDAN’s patient care during the INCIDENT. 22 RELATED DEFINITIONS U§ED= 23 “YOU” and “YOUR” includes you, your agents, your employees, your insurance 24 companies, their agents, their employees, your attorneys, your accountants, your 2 SEPARATE STATEMENT IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES TO REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS AND FOR MONETARY SANCTIONS