Exhibit,Appendix: Tobias Shelley as SHERIFF OF ONONDAGA COUNTY v. The Onondaga County Legislature, The County Of Onondaga

On June 06, 2023 a Exhibit,Appendix was filed involving a dispute between Tobias Shelley As Sheriff Of Onondaga County, and The County Of Onondaga, The Onondaga County Legislature, for Special Proceedings - CPLR Article 78 in the District Court of Onondaga County.

Preview
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023 03:59 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023

EXHIBIT A
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

STATE OF NEW YORK
SUPREME COURT: COUNTY OF ONONDAGA

TOBIAS SHELLEY as SHERIFF OF ONONDAGA
COUNTY
Index No
Petitioner,
PETITION
vs.

THE ONONDAGA COUNTY LEGISLATURE
AND THE COUNTY OF ONONDAGA,

Respondents

The Petitioner, TOBIAS SHELLET as SHERIFF OF ONONDAGA COUNTI by

and through his undersigned counsel, Adams Leclat LLP, states as follows:

1. This petition seeks relief under Article 78 of the New York Civil Practice Law

and Rules ("CPLR"), and alternatively a judgment under CPLR 3001 declaring that

Onondaga County Local Law No. I-2023 was illegally enacted, and is invalid and

unenforceable as it was not passed by the electorate via mandatory referendum as required by

New York Municipal Home Rule Law $ 23 when a locallaw curtails the power of an elected

oflicial.

A. The Parties

2. Petitioner Tobias Shelley is the Sheriff of Onondaga County ("Sheriff

Shelley"), elected by the voters of Onondaga Counry with his principal place of business at

407 South State Street, Syracuse, New York, and brings this Article 78 proceeding and action

for declaratory judgment in his capacity as Sheriff.

1 of 8
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

3. Respondent Onondaga County Legislature ("Legislature") is the governing

legislative body of Onondaga County, with its principal place of business at 401 Montgomery

Street, Syracuse, New York.

4. Respondent Counfy of Onondaga is a municipal corporation duly organtzed

and existing under the laws of the State of New York, with its principal place of business at

427 Montgomery Street, Syracuse, New York.

B. Jurisdiction and Yenue

5. Venue is proper under CPLR 506(b) as Onondaga County is within the judicial

district where the material events took place and where Respondents have their principal

offices.

6. New York has personal jurisdiction over the parties as all parties have a

principal place of business within New York.

C. Background

7. Onondaga County has fwo facilities that house inmates: a penitentiary called

Jamesville Correctional Faciliry also known as the Onondaga County Correctional Faciliry

located at6660 East Seneca Turnpike, Jamesville, New York ("Jamesville CorrectionaT"), and

a jail called Patrick J. Corbett Justice Center, also known as the Onondaga County Justice

Center, located at 555 South State Sueet, Syracuse, New York ("Justice Center").

8. This petition involves a dispute over Sheriff Shelley's power to operate,

supervise, tepa:.r, secure, and otherwise control Jamesville Correctional.

9. Prior to 2077 , conffol over the fwo facilities was divided between the Sheriff

and the Onondaga County Executive. Under Article XVIII of the Onondaga County
Administrative Code, responsibility for the "operation, maintenance, supervision, repat,

2 of 8
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

custodial care and security of the Onondaga County penitentiary and penitentiary farm

[Jamesville Correctional]" fell to the Department of Correction, under the direction of a

Commissioner of Correction, appointed by the County Executive. Under Article X of the

Onondaga County Administrative Code, responsibility for "operation, maintenance,

supervision, repat, custodial care and security of the Onondaga County jail [Justice Center]"

fell to the Sheriff.

10. In 2017, the Legislature enacted Local Law No. 74-2017, amending the
Onondaga County Charter and the Onondaga County Administrative Code.

11. The amendment created a "Corrections Division" within the "Office of the

Sheriff," giving the Office of the Sheriff responsibility for the "operation, maintenance,

supervision, repatr, custodial care and security of the Onondaga County penitentiary faciliry

[Jamesville Correctional] . "

12. Under Local Law No. 74-2017, accordingly, operational control of Jamesville

Correctional was transferred from the County Executive to the Sheriff.

13. Because Local Law No. 74-2017 involved transferring, curtailing, and

abolishing a power of the County Executive, as acknowledged by its express terms, it required

passage from the electorate via mandatory referendum in order to take effect, under New York

Municipal Home Rule Law $ 23.

14. The local law was submitted to the electors of Onondaga County at a general

election in the fall of 2077 andpassed. Local Law No. 74-2017 was effective as of January 7,

2018.

15. Accordingly, as of January 1,2018 through the present, the Onondaga County

Sheriff has maintained control of the two facilities within Onondaga County that house

3 of 8
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

inmates: the Justice Center (which the Sheriff controlled prior to 2077), and Jamesville

Correctional (which the Sheriff gained conffol as of January 1,2018).

D. Current Controversy
16. On February 7, 2023, the Legislature passed Onondaga County Local Law

No. l-2023, which purported to abolished, ffansfer, and curtail the Onondaga County Sheriff

of his power to operate, maintain, supervise, repat, provide custodial care, and secure

Jamesville Correctional.

17. Local Law No. 1-2023 expressed the Legislature's intent at the time to close

Jamesville Correctional and eliminate the Onondaga County Sheriff's power to manage the

same.

18. Specifically, Local Law No. I-2023 claimed a shift in "incarceruted individual

population trends and the resultant need for closure of the county penitentiary facility

[Jamesville Correctional] . "

19. Local Law No. I-2023 struck Section 1003 of the Onondaga County Charter

that was enacted by Local Law No. 14-2017, and replaced it with a new section 1003 that

eliminated the Onondaga Sheriff's power to head and operate Jamesville Correctional,

leaving in place only the Onondaga's Sheriff's power to head and operate the Justice Center.

20. Local Law No. l-2023 struck section 10.04 of Article X of the Onondaga
County Administrative Code which imbued the Office of the Sheriff with responsibility for

the "operation, maintenance supervision, repatr, custodial care and security of the Onondaga

County penitentiary faciliry" and amended section 10.03 of the Onondaga County

Administrative Code in such a manner as to eliminate the Onondaga Sheriff's power to head

4 of 8
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

and operate Jamesville Correctional, leaving in place only the Onondaga's Sheriff's power to

head and operate the Justice Center.

27. Local Law No. I-2023 was not submitted for the approval of the Onondaga

Counfy electors via mandatory referendum, as required and prescribed by New York

Municipal Home Rule Law $ 23.

FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
(For Declaratory Judgment that Local Law No. l-2023Is Invalid and
Unenforceable)

22. Sheriff Shelley repeats andrealleges the allegations set forth inparagraphs 1

through 2l above as if fully set forth herein.

23. Under New York Municipal Home Rule Law $ 23, a local law is subject to

mandatory referendum when it "abolishes, transfers or curtails any power of an elective
officer. "

24. Onondaga County Sheriff Shelley is an elective officer.

25. By eliminating conffol of the "operation, maintenance supervision, repat,

custodial care and security of the Onondaga County penitentiary facility [Jamesville

Correctional]," Local Law No. 1-2023 abolishes, transfers, and curtails a power of the

Onondaga County Sheriff.

26. Therefore, Local Law No. 1-2023 is invalid without a mandatory referendum

in which the electors of Onondaga County vote for its approval.

27. Petitioner has no adequate remedy at law.

28. Based on the foregoing, Sheriff Shelley is entitled to a declatatory judgment

that Local Law No. I-2023 is invalid and unenforceable.

5 of 8
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION
(Finding Local Law No. l-2023Invalid and Unenforceable under Article 78)

29. Sheriff Shelley repeats andrealleges the allegations set forth inparagraphs 1

through 28.

30. The Onondaga County Legislature's attempt at enacting Local Law No. 7-2023

is subject to judicial review under Article 78 of the CPLR, and specifically the questions

contemplated by CPLR 7803, subdivisions 1-3.

31. The Onondaga County Legislature failed to perform its duty by attempting to

enact Local Law No. 1-2023 without requiring it to be subject to mandatory referendum for

approval as required by New York Municipal Home Rule Law $ 23.

32. The Onondaga County Legislature proceeded in excess of its jurisdiction by

attemptihg to enact Local Law No. 7-2023 without a mandatory referendum for approval as

required by New York Municipal Home Rule Law $ 23.

33. The Onondaga County Legislature attempted to enact Local Law No. l-2023

in violation of lawful procedure by failing to subject the locallaw to amandatory referendum

for approval as required by New York Municipal Home Rule Law $ 23.

34. Based on the foregoing, Sheriff Shelley is entitled to a determination that Local

Law No. l-2023 is invalid and unenforceable.

WHEREFORE, the Petitioner demands judgment granting the Petition and declaring

Onondaga County Local Law No. 1-2023 to be invalid and unenforceable, for the costs and

disbursements of this action, and for such other and further relief as the Court deems just and

proper.

6 of 8
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

DATED: Iune 6,2023 ADAMS LE LAIR LLP

By
Paul Leclair,
Ryan Lefkowitz, Esq.
Att orn ey s for Pe tit i oner
288. Main Street, Suite 1500
Rochester, NY 14614
(s8s) 327-4104
Fax: (585) 327-4200
ple clatr @adamsle cl air. I aw
rle fkowitz @adamslecl air. aw
1

7 of 8
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
1 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

VERIFICATION

STATE OF NEW YORK)
couNTY oF MONROE) SS

PAUL L. LECLAIR, ESQ., being duly sworn, deposes and says that:

He is a paftner in the law firm of ADAMS LECLAIR LLR attorneys for Petitioner Tobias

Shelley, as Sheriff of Onondaga County in the within proceeding, that he has read the

foregoing Petition and knows the contents thereof, and that the same is ffue to deponent's

own knowledge, except as to matters therein stated to be alleged upon information and belief,

and as to those matters deponent believes them to be ffue. This verification is not made by

Petitioner because Petitioner is not within the County of Monroe, which is the County where

your deponent maintains an office for the practice of law.

PaulL. Leclatr

Sworn to before me this
G*L day of June,2023

6H/-7//;/
Notary Public

EDITH M. CORNISH
NOTARY PUBLIC, State of New York
No' 01CO6191717
(
." $HiXlilX l$l,::"f; f'",:?%,,04
',

8 of 8
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
2 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

STATE OF NEW YORK
SUPREME COURT: COUNTY OF ONONDAGA

TOBIAS SHELLEX as SHERIFF OF ONONDAGA
COUNTY
407 South State Sffeet Index No
Syracuse, New York 13202,
NOTICE OF PETITION
Petitioner

THE ONONDAGA COUNTY LEGISLATURE
401 Montgomery Street
Syracuse, New York 13202

THE COUNTY OF ONONDAGA
42IMontgomery Street
Syracuse, New York 13202,

Respondents

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that upon the annexed Petition verified on the 6th day of

June, 2023, the Affidavit of Tobias Shelley, swom to on June 5, 2023, together with the

exhibits annexed to the Affidavit, an application will be made by Petitioner Tobias Shelley as

Sheriffof Onondaga County, by his attorneys ADAMS LECLAIR LLP, ata Special Term to

be held at the Onondaga County Courthouse,40I Montgomery Street, Syracuse, New York,

13202, on the 11th day of July 2023, at 10:00 a.m., or as soon thereafter as counsel may be

heard, for an order and judgment granting the Petition and declaring Onondaga County Local

Law No. L-2023 to be invalid and unenforceable, for the costs and disbursements of this

action, and for such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper.

PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that, pursuant to CPLR $ 7804(c), a verified

answer and supporting affrdavits, if any, must be served by July 6,2023.

1 of 2
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
2 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

PLEASE TAKE FURTIIER NOTICE that, pursuant to CPLR $ 7804(c), a reply and

supporting affidavits, if any, must be served by July t0,2023

DATED: June 6,2023 ADAMS LECLAIR L P

By:
Paul Leclair, Esq.
Ryan Lefkowitz, Esq.
Attorney s for Petitioner
28E. Main Sffeet, Suite 1500
Rochester, NY 14614
(s8s) 327-4104
Fax: (585) 327-4200
pIe clarr @adams le cl a ir. aw
1

rle fkowitz @adamslecl a ir. I aw

2 of 2
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
4 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

EXHIBIT 1
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
4 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

LOCAL LAW NO. 14 - 2017

A LOCAL LAW AMENDING THE ONONDAGA COUNTY CHARTER AND ADMINISTRATIVE
CODE REGARDING THE ONONDAGA COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTION

BE IT ENACTED BY THE COUNTY LEGISLATURE OF THE COUNTY OF ONONDAGA,
AS FOLLOWS:

Section 1. Amendment.

(a) The Onondaga County Charter, being Local Law No. 1-1961, as previously amended, is hereby
further amended as follows:

Article XVIII, entitled "Department of Correction", is to be stricken in its entirety.

"Sheriff"
Article X, entitled is amended so as to add the following language as section 1003 thereof:

CORRECTIONS DIVISION; CHIEF DEPUTY.

On and after January 1, 2018, there shall be a Corrections Division under the supervision of the Office of
the Sheriff, who shall appoint a chief deputy to be the head of such department on the basis of administrative
experience and qualifications for the duties of office, consistent with requirements of applicable law. The
chief deputy shall have and exercise all the powers and duties now or hereafter conferred or imposed upon

county penitentiary superintendents by any applicable law. Such officer shall perform such other and
related duties as shall be required or delegated to him by the Sheriff, the County Executive, or County
Legislature.

(b) The Onondaga County Administrative Code, being Local Law No. 1-1975, as previously amended,
is hereby further amended as follows:

Article XVIII, entitled "Department of Correction", is to be stricken in its entirety.

Article X, entitled "Sheriff", is amended to add the following language as a new Section 10.04, with the

previously sections 10.04 through 10.08, to be renumbered, increasing by one, starting with former 10.04

being renumbered as 10.05, and so forth.

10.04 CORRECTIONS DIVISION; CHIEF DEPUTY.

(a) Within the Office of the Sheriff, there shall be a Corrections Division under the direction of a chief

deputy, appointed in a manner consistent with all applicable laws, including Section 1003 of the Onondaga

County Charter.

(b) Except as may otherwise be provided in the Charter or this Code, the chief deputy
shall:

(i) be responsible for the operation, maintenance, supervision, repair, custodial care and security of the
Onondaga County penitentiary facility;

(ii) be responsible for the receipt, housing, care, custody, control and employment of all inmates sentenced
or assigned to such facilities or otherwise housed therein;
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
4 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

(iii) initiate, implement and coordinate programs for the rehabilitation, education and training of inmates
sentenced or assigned to such facilities or otherwise housed herein;

(iv) initiate, implement and coordinate programs for the distribution of food and other products
manufactured or produced within such facilities;

(v) have all the powers and perform all the duties now or hereafter conferred or imposed by law.

Section 2. Effective Date.

This local law shall take effect January 1, 2018, consistent with the provisions of the Municipal Home Rule
Law, subject to a mandatory referendum.

This local law shall not be effective until and unless it is approved as a proposition at referendum. A
proposition on the amendment to the Charter and Administrative Code shall be submitted to the electors of
Onondaga County at the next general election.

LL - Sheriff & Corrections
KMB
dak

ADOPTED

AUG 3 1 2017

I HEREBY CERTlFY THAT THE FOREGOING IS A TRUE AND
EXACT COPY OF LEGISLATION DULY ADOPTED BY THE
COUNTY LEGISLATURE OF ONONDAGA COUNTY ON THE

... DAY OF.
, 20 .

CLERK, COUNTY LEGISLATURE
3 1 93 ONONDAGA COUNTY, NEW YORK
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
6 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

EXHIBIT 3
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
6 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

LOCAL LAW NO. 1 - 2023

A LOCAL LAW AMENDING THE ONONDAGA COUNTY CHARTER AND ADMINISTRATIVE
CODE REGARDING THE ONONDAGA COUNTY SHERIFF

BE IT ENACTED BY THE COUNTY LEGISLATURE OF THE COUNTY OF ONONDAGA,
AS FOLLOWS:

Section 1. Findings. The Onondaga County Sheriff is tasked with delivering services as provided for
within the Onondaga County Charter, Onondaga County Administrative Code and applicable laws. The
nature and scope of services provided by the Sheriff has evolved due to changes in law and policy, resulting
in shifting incarcerated individual population trends and the resultant need for closure of the county
penitentiary facility. To that end, this Onondaga County Legislature hereby desires to amend the Onondaga
County Charter and Administrative Code to enable the Sheriff to address these changes and more effectively
coordinate and deliver needed services, allowing for delivery of higher quality services and better allocation
of limited resources for the benefit of the residents of Onondaga County.

Section 2. The Onondaga County Charter, being Local Law No. 1 of 1961, as previously amended, hereby
is further amended to strike Section 1003 in its entirety and substitute the following:

Section 1003. CHIEF DEPUTY OF CUSTODY.

There shall be a chief deputy of custody, under the supervision of the Office of the Sheriff, who shall be
the head of the county jail, appointed by the Sheriff on the basis of administrative experience and
qualifications for the duties of the office, consistent with requirements of applicable law. The chief deputy
shall have and exercise all the powers and duties now or hereafter conferred or imposed upon a chief
administrative officer of a county jail by any applicable law. Such officer shall perform such other and
related duties as shall be required or delegated to him by the Sheriff, the County Executive, or County
Legislature.

Section 3. Section 10.03 of the Onondaga County Administrative Code, being Local Law No. 1 of 1975,
as previously amended, referenced herein as the “Administrative Code”, hereby is further amended to insert
the following language at the beginning of Section 10.03 (b):

The Sheriff shall appoint a chief deputy of custody in a manner consistent with applicable laws, including
Section 1003 of the Onondaga County Charter. Except as may otherwise be provided in the Charter or this
Code, the chief deputy shall: be responsible for the operation, maintenance, supervision, repair, custodial
care and security of the Onondaga County jail; be responsible for the receipt, housing, care, custody, control
and employment of all inmates sentenced or assigned to the jail or otherwise housed therein; initiate,
implement and coordinate programs for the rehabilitation, education and training of inmates sentenced or
assigned to such jail or otherwise housed herein; initiate, implement and coordinate programs for the
distribution of food and other products manufactured or produced within such jail; and have all the powers
and perform all the duties now or hereafter conferred or imposed by law.

Section 4. The Administrative Code is further amended to strike Section 10.04 in its entirety.

Section 5. The Administrative Code is further amended to strike the word “Corrections” from Section
3.03B (2).
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
6 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

Section 6. Except as specifically amended herein, the Onondaga County Charter and Administrative Code
shall remain in full force and effect. This local law shall be construed in such a way so as not to diminish
or curtail powers held by any elected official within County government.

Section 7. Severability. If any clause, sentence, paragraph, section or part of this local law shall be
adjudged by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, the judgment shall not affect, impair or
invalidate the remainder hereof, but shall be confined in its operation to the clause, sentence, paragraph or
section or part hereof directly involved in the controversy in which the judgment shall have been rendered.

Section 8. Effective Date. This Local Law shall take effect immediately and shall be filed consistent with
the provisions of New York State Municipal Home Rule Law.

PASSED 2/7/23

I hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and exact copy
of the legislation duly adopted by the County Legislature
of Onondaga County on the 7th day of February 2023.

Clerk, County Legislature

Corrections LL BMY/KBF dak 1.9.2023
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
5 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

EXHIBIT 2
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 22
5 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/19/2023
06/06/2023

Onondaga County Legislature
JAMIE McNAMARA JAMES J. ROWLEY TAMMY BARBER
Clerk Chairman Deputy Clerk

401 Montgomery Street • Court House • Room 407 • Syracuse, New York 13202
Phone: 315.435.2070 • Fax: 315.435.8434 • www.ongov.net/legislature

WAYS & MEANS COMMITTEE MINUTES – JANUARY 31, 2023
BRIAN F. MAY, CHAIRMAN

MEMBERS PRESENT: Mr. Ryan, Mr. Burtis, Ms. Abbott, Mr. Knapp, Mrs. Ervin, Mr. Kinne
ALSO ATTENDING: Chairman Rowley, Ms. Cody, Ms. Kuhn, Dr. Chase, Mr. Bush, Mr. Garland; also
see attached

Chair May called the meeting to order at 11:41 a.m. The minutes of the previous meeting had been distributed,
and there were no objections to waiving the reading. There were no corrections to the minutes, and the minutes
were approved.

1. APPOINTMENTS:
a. Confirming Appointment to the Syracuse/Onondaga County Planning Board (Donald Radke)
(Sponsored by Mr. Burtis)

A motion was made by Mr. Burtis, seconded by Mrs. Ervin, to approve this item. Passed unanimously;
MOTION CARRIED.

b. Confirming Reappointments to the Onondaga County Soil and Water Conservation District Board
(Craig S. Dennis, David Coburn) (Sponsored by Ms. Abbott)

A motion was made by Ms. Abbott, seconded by Mr. Knapp, to approve this item. Passed unanimously;
MOTION CARRIED.

Questions from the committee to Mr. Morgan:
 Is everything listed (bond resolutions) in the CIP?
o Correct

 Can the county use cash for any of these items should the county find they can down the road?
o Yes, assuming they are approved today
o As Finance closes out 2022, they will evaluate funding smaller projects with cash
o That decision will be made before closing out 2022; it can be done at any time during the year
o Expectation is that they will use cash for any projects under $1M; cannot commit, but most likely it will be the case

 Where will the county be with fund balance?
o Do not know yet; working with Mr. Masterpole and Comptroller’s Office to close books
o All expenditure accruals are posted, then will work on ensuring everything looks good
o Revenues still need to be posted
o Also waiting on 2 sales tax payments; initial idea of where the county is ending the year will be another 2-3 weeks

 Is the county on track budget vs actuals?
o Forecast brought over during budget projected $50M surplus; expect to be in that range

 If surplus were at $50M, what would the ballpark for fund balance be?
o Legislature appropriated $70M of fund balance in 2022, which brought it down to $130M
o Theoretically adding another $50M would make it upwards of $180M
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
WAYS
NYSCEF & MEANS
DOC. NO. COMMITTEE
5
22 MINUTES – January 31, 2023 2
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/06/2023
10/19/2023
 What if the county pays cash for some projects instead of bonding?
o It would come off the top if those decisions are made before closing the books
o Most likely will look to use cash for smaller capital projects; amount of money would not move the needle much
o Legislature requested the language be inserted to all bond resolutions allowing the CFO and County Executive to
make the decision (on whether to use cash) based on assessment of the finances
o County will be well over 15% mark (for fund balance)
o Comfortable recommending to County Executive to use cash for projects that are within the $1M or less range

 If there are issues with this process, the committee can reevaluate at a later date
 All items in CIP, have been discussed a few times and have gone through respective program committees
 Committees job to approve these with terms and conditions, allowing finance to use cash when possible

2. EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS (E911): Kevin Spraker, Deputy Commissioner
a. BOND: A Resolution Authorizing E911 Tower Site Shelter Rehabilitation in and for the County of
Onondaga, New York, at a Maximum Estimated Cost of $1,091,000, and Authorizing the Issuance
of $1,091,000 Bonds of Said County to Pay Costs Thereof ($1,091,000) (Sponsored by Mr. Olson)

 Funding to replace AC units, doors and other items at tower shelters
 16 tower shelters that provide radio system service and antennas for public safety radio for police and EMS
 In place since 2006; have seen issues with AC units; working with Facilities to keep up and running
 Doors – weather not helping with rotting or keeping rodents and mice out of shelters; would like to replace
 Have used grant money to fund some items; other items will be funded through capital project

A motion was made by Mr. Knapp, seconded by Mr. Burtis, to approve this item. Passed unanimously;
MOTION CARRIED.

3. SHERIFF: Chief Melissa Berlinski
a. BOND: A Resolution Authorizing the Purchase and Installation of Security Operation and Inmate
Information Systems at the Justice Center in and for the County of Onondaga, New York, at a
Maximum Estimated Cost of $7,513,000, and Authorizing the Issuance of $7,513,000 Bonds of Said
County to Pay Costs Thereof ($7,513,000) (Sponsored by Mr. Olson)

 Upgrade BlackCreek system, running on Windows 7 (not supported); if fails, would be back to key and lock system
 Install and upgrade detainee monitoring system – bracelets for incarcerated to be integrated into system
 Replace SallyPort Jail System with new system
 Lot of cameras are analog and antiquated; trying to move to digital
 About 1 year to complete process

A motion was made by Mr. Kinne, seconded by Mrs. Ervin, to approve this item. Passed unanimously;
MOTION CARRIED.

Mr. Wixson took the Facilities Management agenda items out of order.

4. FACILITIES MANAGEMENT: Archie Wixson, Commissioner
c. BOND: A Resolution Authorizing the Center for Forensic Science Building Rehabilitation in and
for the County of Onondaga, New York, at a Maximum Estimated Cost of $2,615,000, and
Authorizing the Issuance of $2,615,000 Bonds of Said County to Pay Costs Thereof ($2,615,000)
(Sponsored by Ms. Cody)

 Improvements to technology - fingerprinting, identification, ballistics, and other processes where technologies have
improved and program needs to change; full renovation of 3rd floor including all technologies
 2 years ago had design done; Director of Laboratories, Ms. Ho and her team confirmed design is satisfactory

A motion was made by Mrs. Ervin, seconded by Ms. Abbott, to approve this item. Passed unanimously;
FILED: ONONDAGA COUNTY CLERK 10/19/2023
06/06/2023 03:59
04:31 PM INDEX NO. 005761/2023
WAYS
NYSCEF & MEANS
DOC. NO. COMMITTEE
5
22 MINUTES – January 31, 2023 3
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 06/06/2023
10/19/2023

MOTION CARRIED.

b. BOND: A Resolution Authorizing Rehabilitation/Construction of Improvements at the OnCenter
Facility in and for the County of Onondaga, New York, at a Maximum Estimated Cost of $500,000,
and Authorizing the Issuance of $500,000 Bonds of Said County to Pay Costs Thereof ($500,000)
(Sponsored by Ms. Cody)

 Annual request for maintaining and improvements to OnCenter complex
 Good portion dedicated to improvements at theaters including seating arrangements, ADA and concessions

A motion was made by Mr. Knapp, seconded by Ms. Abbott, to approve this item.

Comment from Committee:
 In favor of improvements, but do not see a need to bond

A vote was taken on the motion. Ayes: 4 (May, Burtis, Abbott, Knapp) Noes: 3 (Ryan, Kinne, Ervin);
MOTION CARRIED.

a. BOND: A Resolution Authorizing Improvements at Various Facilities in and for the County of
Onondaga, New York, at a Maximum Estimated Cost of $2,115,000, and Authorizing the Issuance
of $2,115,000 Bonds of Said County to Pay Costs Thereof ($2,115,000) (Sponsored by Ms. Cody)

 Civic Center – 8th floor, Children and Family Services and DSS-ES renovations to expand for JobsPlus program
 Army Reserve Center has grant funding and requires capital bonding; project started; bids from prime contractors due
Thursday; begun some demolition, removals and accomplished abatement
 Remainder is going to various projects listed in the CIP

A motion was made by Mrs. Ervin, seconded by Mr. Knapp, to approve this item. Passed unanimously;
MOTION CARRIED.

5. PARKS AND RECREATION: Brian Kelly, Commissioner
a. BOND: A Resolution Authorizing the Oneida Shores Park Shoreline Rehabilitation in and for the
County of Onondaga, New York, at a Maximum Estimated Cost of $240,000, and Authorizing the
Issuance of $240,000 Bonds of Said County to Pay Costs Thereof ($240,000) (Sponsored by Ms. Cody)

 Final phase of project; last year redid boat launch and fixed retaining wall
 This year would like to install pay gate and fish weigh station
 Pay gate
o Allows to catch revenue in offseason
o Only staff booth Memorial Day to 3rd w

Case Info

Judge

Joseph E Lamendola Track Judge’s New Case

Case No.

(Subscribe to View)

Document Filed Date

October 19, 2023

Case Filing Date

June 06, 2023

County

Parties

FELTER, KAREN GUYDER Attorney for the Defendant
KATZ, DAVID M. G. Attorney for the Defendant
LECLAIR, PAUL L. Attorney for the Plaintiff
LEFKOWITZ, RYAN Attorney for the Plaintiff
THE COUNTY OF ONONDAGA Defendant
THE ONONDAGA COUNTY LEGISLATURE Defendant
Tobias Shelley as SHERIFF OF ONONDAGA COUNTY Plaintiff
WILLIAMS, STEVEN WARD Attorney for the Defendant
YAUS, BENJAMIN MICHAEL Attorney for the Defendant

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.

Exhibit,Appendix: Tobias Shelley as SHERIFF OF ONONDAGA COUNTY v. The Onondaga County Legislature, The County Of Onondaga

Preview

Related Topics

Case Info

Parties