On October 05, 2018 a
Party Discovery
was filed
involving a dispute between
Hill, Lisa,
and
Quaid Harley-Davidson, Inc. A California Corporation,
for Business Tort/Unfair Business Practice Unlimited
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
DYKEMA (iOSSETT LLP F L
ABIRAMI (iNANAIMiSlUAN. SBN 263375
‘
%F%mum
AI(inumn/m‘igun a (/vrkcnm‘c'om sum 0F 9AM BmNAmNO
l’Al ’I, 1,. NYS'I'ROM (Admitted I’m Huc Vice)
pnyslmm (I drkcmuumz SEP 2 0 2023
JONA I'HAN RAMA
(Admitted Pro Hac Vicc)
jkunnru (/_\'kwnuu)m
444 South Hmwr Slrccl. Suite 2200
'JI
L05 Angclcs. (‘alitbrnia 9007]
’l’clcphonc: (3 3) 457- 800
I l
6 Facsimile: (3 3) 457-]850
l
Attorneys for (‘ross—Dct‘cndanl. HARLEY-
[)AVI[)S()N MOTOR COMPANY. INC.
9
l0 SUPERIOR COURT ()F THE STATE ()F CALIFORNIA
COUNTY ()F SAN BERNARDINO. SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT
l.l.|’
UNION
mmxl
LISA HILL. an individual (‘usc N0. (‘IVDS 826573 I
(QOSSFIT'T IHI-HmIRSIuHI
2200
\I
IH
\.(
Plaintiff. Assigned Io Hon. Wilfred .l. Schneider. .lr.
\ \l I Dcpt. S33
I
\.
kli“
\\¢.I
444M"
|)\
Im
()l b\ll) IlARl.liY-[)AVIDS()N. INC. a (‘ROSS—DEFENDANT HARLEY-
(‘ulil‘ornia (‘orporzuiom and DOES Ihmugh | I)A\'II)S()N MOTOR COMPANY. lN(‘.’S
10. inclusivc. NOTICE ()F MOTION AND MOTION
FOR PR()'l‘l{("l‘l\'lC ORDER RF. CROSS-
Dcfcndant. (‘()MI’LAINANT 013A”) HARLEY-
I)A\’II)S()N. IN('.'S REQUESTS FOR
ADMISSION SET AND REQUEST FOR l
SANCTIONS: .‘lliMORANDlN ()F
()l ?All) ll/\Rl.liY—[)AVIDSON. INC. u POINTS AND ‘»\l"|‘H()Rl’l‘lES
(‘alitbrniu ('urporalion.
HEARING DATE: October l7. 2023
('ross-(‘omplainam. TIME: 8:30 a.m.
I)EP.»\RTMF.N'I‘: $32
\.
ll/\Rl.lfY-[)/\Vl[)$()N MOTOR CROSS (‘()MI’I.AIN'I l‘ll.lil): May 28. 202i
(‘()MI’/\NY. INC. a Wisconsin corporulion. A(‘C Fll‘lil): .lul) 3‘). 2()2|
and RULS through l0. inclusiw.
I
SACC HLIZI): Dcccmbcr (w. 2022
(‘ross-Dct‘cndams. TRIAL: .lanuur} 2‘). 302-1
3v
_(
mm Hmnmxux xmnul tn \Iu|m\ \leIquKMIEHcmw ml rmnlsqm A quxfflRfi-flk 1:1 m \HHImHMIHHva
M1 \NIHI |\|\IHK \()\H\\\U\\) \ \
\\H|\'\l|\ }\\ |l|l\’\\\l H(|\\ \H \Illlx' \\H| \MH |’IH\\\ \\|) \l |HHKH|I\
T0 THIS HONORABLE (‘()l'R'l‘. THE PARTIES AND THEIR COUNSEL ()F
RECORD:
’«J
PLEASE TAKE NOTICE 1|]le on ()ctobcr l7. 2023. at 8:30 u.m.. 0r as soon thereafter us
this matter ma} be heard in Department S32 ot‘Ihc abm c-caplioncd Court. located at 247 West
Third Street. San Bcrnurdino. (‘ulilbrnia 924M. (‘ross-Dcfcndanl ||ar|cy-[)uvidsm1 Motor
Company. Inc. ("HzlrlQ—l)m idson") \\ ill 21nd hcrcb} docs mow Ihc (‘oun for a Protective ()rdcr
pursuant Io California (‘odc 0f(‘i\ il Procedure section 2033.080. to protect Harlcy-Davidson from
responding Io Ihc \\rincn discm cr} pronoundcd b} (‘ross-(‘omplainant Quaid Harley-Ihvidson.
Inc. (“Quaid”). consisting ot‘Quuid‘s Requests for Admission SCI ()nc ("Requests"). which
include |04 requests. h) striking all requests hcymd I-35. 0r in Ihc alternative. requiring Quuid Io
rc-scrvc thc chucsls and limit Ihcm Io 35. llzu‘IC) -I)u\ idsun also moves for an order extending
9007i
LLP
thc lime {0r servicc nt‘ its responses Iu 21 dulc [hat is tbunccn I4) days after Ihc Court‘s ruling 0n
(
\
I-HmIRMRHI
H0k\|
this Motion. unless ()uaid’s rcqucsls arc rc-scn ed. qu‘lq-Dzn idson also sccks sanctions
(IOSSETT
IILZZOU
(‘\I
pursuant Io (‘alitbrnia (‘odc ol‘(‘i\ il l’roccdurc sections 3033.080 and 2023.010.
\ III
M I
Ix.
KE‘I
\\(,I
This Motion is madc on Ihc grounds [hut good cause exists for a prolcclixc order because
444M)!
I)\
l.()\
contrar) 10 the rcprcscnlatium mudc in Ihc declaration submitted h) ()uzlid “ilh its Requests. Ihc
numhcr oi‘rcqucals is ummrruntcd, ()uuid has zllsu failcd lu submit a declaration in compliance
with ('ul. (‘odc M(‘iy I’m. § 2033.050. “hich requires a purl) 10 attach a declaration stating that
Ihc number ol‘rcqucsls for udmissivn ix \uu'runlcd undcr (‘zIL (‘odc ot‘(‘i\, Pro. § 2033.040 and
Ihc reasons \\h_\ Ihc complexil) or lhc quunlil} 0f issues in Ihc imlanl la“ suit warrant Ihc number
ot‘rcqucsls. Thc dccluruliun fails Io slulc an} purponcd reasons.
,//
//
//
//
//
w
rmth H wnumv xxuw 1 ml www.wixrfu’n’nduiwziw mum HH numluu ‘ wmxumw \\\\\: m \Hmml H I1\\II)\H\
1V \m‘u |x>xwulc \|1\H\\1n\\\ \
\
wmmln \w ynvq\\\r wmx \I|\lu|\‘\‘m \IHI MW I\ \\1> \I HIHKH1|\
Document Filed Date
September 20, 2023
Case Filing Date
October 05, 2018
Category
Business Tort/Unfair Business Practice Unlimited
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
DYKEMA (iOSSETT LLP F L ABIRAMI (iNANAIMiSlUAN. SBN 263375 ‘ %F%mum AI(inumn/m‘igun a (/vrkcnm‘c'om sum 0F 9AM BmNAmNO l’Al ’I, 1,. NYS'I'ROM (Admitted I’m Huc Vice) pnyslmm (I drkcmuumz SEP 2 0 2023 JONA I'HAN RAMA (Admitted Pro Hac Vicc) jkunnru (/_\'kwnuu)m 444 South Hmwr Slrccl. Suite 2200 'JI L05 Angclcs. (‘alitbrnia 9007] ’l’clcphonc: (3 3) 457- 800 I l 6 Facsimile: (3 3) 457-]850 l Attorneys for (‘ross—Dct‘cndanl. HARLEY- [)AVI[)S()N MOTOR COMPANY. INC. 9 l0 SUPERIOR COURT ()F THE STATE ()F CALIFORNIA COUNTY ()F SAN BERNARDINO. SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT l.l.|’ UNION mmxl LISA HILL. an individual (‘usc N0. (‘IVDS 826573 I (QOSSFIT'T IHI-HmIRSIuHI 2200 \I IH \.( Plaintiff. Assigned Io Hon. Wilfred .l. Schneider. .lr. \ \l I Dcpt. S33 I \. kli“ \\¢.I 444M" |)\ Im ()l b\ll) IlARl.liY-[)AVIDS()N. INC. a (‘ROSS—DEFENDANT HARLEY- (‘ulil‘ornia (‘orporzuiom and DOES Ihmugh | I)A\'II)S()N MOTOR COMPANY. lN(‘.’S 10. inclusivc. NOTICE ()F MOTION AND MOTION FOR PR()'l‘l{("l‘l\'lC ORDER RF. CROSS- Dcfcndant. (‘()MI’LAINANT 013A”) HARLEY- I)A\’II)S()N. IN('.'S REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION SET AND REQUEST FOR l SANCTIONS: .‘lliMORANDlN ()F ()l ?All) ll/\Rl.liY—[)AVIDSON. INC. u POINTS AND ‘»\l"|‘H()Rl’l‘lES (‘alitbrniu ('urporalion. HEARING DATE: October l7. 2023 ('ross-(‘omplainam. TIME: 8:30 a.m. I)EP.»\RTMF.N'I‘: $32 \. ll/\Rl.lfY-[)/\Vl[)$()N MOTOR CROSS (‘()MI’I.AIN'I l‘ll.lil): May 28. 202i (‘()MI’/\NY. INC. a Wisconsin corporulion. A(‘C Fll‘lil): .lul) 3‘). 2()2| and RULS through l0. inclusiw. I SACC HLIZI): Dcccmbcr (w. 2022 (‘ross-Dct‘cndams. TRIAL: .lanuur} 2‘). 302-1 3v _( mm Hmnmxux xmnul tn \Iu|m\ \leIquKMIEHcmw ml rmnlsqm A quxfflRfi-flk 1:1 m \HHImHMIHHva M1 \NIHI |\|\IHK \()\H\\\U\\) \ \ \\H|\'\l|\ }\\ |l|l\’\\\l H(|\\ \H \Illlx' \\H| \MH |’IH\\\ \\|) \l |HHKH|I\ T0 THIS HONORABLE (‘()l'R'l‘. THE PARTIES AND THEIR COUNSEL ()F RECORD: ’«J PLEASE TAKE NOTICE 1|]le on ()ctobcr l7. 2023. at 8:30 u.m.. 0r as soon thereafter us this matter ma} be heard in Department S32 ot‘Ihc abm c-caplioncd Court. located at 247 West Third Street. San Bcrnurdino. (‘ulilbrnia 924M. (‘ross-Dcfcndanl ||ar|cy-[)uvidsm1 Motor Company. Inc. ("HzlrlQ—l)m idson") \\ ill 21nd hcrcb} docs mow Ihc (‘oun for a Protective ()rdcr pursuant Io California (‘odc 0f(‘i\ il Procedure section 2033.080. to protect Harlcy-Davidson from responding Io Ihc \\rincn discm cr} pronoundcd b} (‘ross-(‘omplainant Quaid Harley-Ihvidson. Inc. (“Quaid”). consisting ot‘Quuid‘s Requests for Admission SCI ()nc ("Requests"). which include |04 requests. h) striking all requests hcymd I-35. 0r in Ihc alternative. requiring Quuid Io rc-scrvc thc chucsls and limit Ihcm Io 35. llzu‘IC) -I)u\ idsun also moves for an order extending 9007i LLP thc lime {0r servicc nt‘ its responses Iu 21 dulc [hat is tbunccn I4) days after Ihc Court‘s ruling 0n ( \ I-HmIRMRHI H0k\| this Motion. unless ()uaid’s rcqucsls arc rc-scn ed. qu‘lq-Dzn idson also sccks sanctions (IOSSETT IILZZOU (‘\I pursuant Io (‘alitbrnia (‘odc ol‘(‘i\ il l’roccdurc sections 3033.080 and 2023.010. \ III M I Ix. KE‘I \\(,I This Motion is madc on Ihc grounds [hut good cause exists for a prolcclixc order because 444M)! I)\ l.()\ contrar) 10 the rcprcscnlatium mudc in Ihc declaration submitted h) ()uzlid “ilh its Requests. Ihc numhcr oi‘rcqucals is ummrruntcd, ()uuid has zllsu failcd lu submit a declaration in compliance with ('ul. (‘odc M(‘iy I’m. § 2033.050. “hich requires a purl) 10 attach a declaration stating that Ihc number ol‘rcqucsls for udmissivn ix \uu'runlcd undcr (‘zIL (‘odc ot‘(‘i\, Pro. § 2033.040 and Ihc reasons \\h_\ Ihc complexil) or lhc quunlil} 0f issues in Ihc imlanl la“ suit warrant Ihc number ot‘rcqucsls. Thc dccluruliun fails Io slulc an} purponcd reasons. ,// // // // // w rmth H wnumv xxuw 1 ml www.wixrfu’n’nduiwziw mum HH numluu ‘ wmxumw \\\\\: m \Hmml H I1\\II)\H\ 1V \m‘u |x>xwulc \|1\H\\1n\\\ \ \ wmmln \w ynvq\\\r wmx \I|\lu|\‘\‘m \IHI MW I\ \\1> \I HIHKH1|\