Motion to Amend in MARTY MURPHY vs. PAVECON HOLDINGS CO., INC., et al| Trellis.Law

On August 23, 2017 a Trial Materials was filed involving a dispute between Murphy, Marty, and Labcon Inc, Pavecon Holdings Co., Inc., Pavecon Ltd. Co., Pavecon Public Works Gp Llc, Pavecon Public Works Lp, Thompson, Stephanie, Walker, C David, for CNTR CNSMR COM DEBT in the District Court of Dallas County.

Preview
FILED
DALLAS COUNTY
11/21/2019 4:57 PM
FELICIA PITRE
DISTRICT CLERK

NO. DC-l7-10592 Cassandra Walker

MARTY MURPHY, IN THE DISTRICT COURT

Plaintiff and Counterclaim-
Defendant,

PAVECON HOLDING CO., INC.; WWWWWWWWWWWWWW

PAVECON LTD. CO.; PAVECON 192nd DISTRICT COURT
PUBLIC WORKS LP, PAVECON
PUBLIC WORKS GP, LLC,
DAVID WALKER,

Defendants and DALLAS COUNTY, TEXAS
Counterclaim-Plaintiffs,

DEFENDANTS’ AND COUNTERCLAIM-PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED
TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADM/EXC
EX. N0.
L

Deposition of Michael Jeter Exhibit 1 —
Boundary Survey of Murphy’s Property

Deposition of Michael Jeter Exhibit 2 —
Barn/Shop Layout for Murphy’s Property

Deposition of Michael Jeter Exhibit 3 —
3. Daily Log, October 1, 2016
(PAVE000343)

Deposition of Michael Jeter Exhibit 4 —
4. APAC Invoice # 200519642 and Delivery Tickets
(PAVE00096 1 -000962)
Deposition 0f Michael Jeter Exhibit 5 —
5. APAC Invoice # 2005 1 8198 and Delivery Tickets
(PAVE000924-000925)

Deposition of Michael Jeter Exhibit 6 —
6. APAC Invoice # 200518211 and Delivery Tickets
(PAVE000927-000941)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 1
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADM/EXC
EX. NO.
L

Deposition of Michael Jeter Exhibit 7 —
APAC Invoice # 200519604 and Delivery Tickets
(PAVE000942-000956)

Deposition 0f Michael Jeter Exhibit 8 —
APAC Invoice # 200519641 and Delivery Tickets
(PAVE000957-000960)

Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f Michael Jeter Exhibit 10 —
10. Photographs of Murphy’s Property
(PAVE001473-001 571)

Deposition of Ricky Shane Boydston Exhibit 11 —
11. Aerial Map of Murphy’s Property
(PAVE000466)

Deposition of Ricky Shane Boydston Exhibit 12 —
12. Photocopy of Check 2147 dated 2/10/17 with Check
Details (MM000341)
13. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition of Ricky Shane Boydston, Exhibit 14 —
14.
Time Records (PAVE000539-000570)

Deposition of Ricky Shane Boydston,
Exhibit 15 — Production Schedule — Personnel
15. Locations for Dec. 2015, Jan. 2016, Feb. 2016, Sept.
2016, Feb. 2017, and Mar. 2017
(PAVE000874. 1 -000874. 1 8)

16. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f Ismael Ortega Exhibit 17 —
17. Excerpts from Ismael Ortega’s Daily Logs
(PAVE0003 16-000342)
Deposition of Ismael Ortega Exhibit 18 — Feb. 2017
18. Summary Sheets and Time Records for Ismael
Crew (PAVE000539-000542)
Ortega’s

—
Deposition of Ismael Ortega Exhibit 19
—
Production Schedule Personnel Locations for Dec.
19. 2015, Jan. 2016, Feb. 2016, Sept. 2016, Feb. 2017,
and Mar. 20 1 7
(PAVE000874.1-000874. 1 8)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 2
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADMIfEXC
EX. NO. R P

20. Intentionally Left Blank

2 1. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition of Ricardo Gomez Exhibit 22 — 2/1 1/16
22. and 2/12/16 Time Sheets for Ricardo Gomez’s Crew
(PAVEOO 1 O42, PAVEOO 1 046)
Deposition 0f Ricardo Gomez Exhibit 23 —
23. Ricardo Gomez’s Daily Log dated 2/1 1/16
(PAVE000429)

24. Intentionally Left Blank

25. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition of Ricardo Gomez Exhibit 26 —
26. Ricardo Gomez’s Employee Time Sheet for 2/8/16-
2/14/16 (PAVE001048)

Deposition 0f Ricardo Gomez Exhibit 27 —
27. Email dated 2/15/16 from Flor Cantu t0 Ricardo
Gomez re: Summary Sheets (PAVE001047)
Deposition of Darrell Dumke Exhibit 28 —
28 '

Boundary Survey 0f Murphy’s Property

Deposition of Darrell Dumke Exhibit 29 —
29. Job File for Bruce Carter House Pad
(PAVE000294-0003 15)

Deposition 0f Darrell Dumke Exhibit 30 —
30. Job File for Bill Carter House Pad
(PAVE000275-000293)

Deposition of Darrell Dumke Exhibit 31 —
3 1. Mike Jeter’s Daily Log dated 10/1/16
(PAVE000343)

32. Intentionally Left Blank

33. Intentionally Left Blank

34. Intentionally Left Blank

35. Intentionally Left Blank

36. Intentionally Left Blank

37. Intentionally Left Blank

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE3
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADMIfEXC
EX. NO. R P

38. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f Ricky Boydston Exhibit 39 —
39. Ricky Boydston’s Daily Logs
(PAVE000344-000428)

Deposition 0f Ricky Boydston Exhibit 40 —
Daily Logs, Invoices, and Time Sheets regarding
4O '

equipment hauls by Jeff Middleton on 6/29/ 15
(PAVE001297-001307)

Deposition of Ricky Boydston Exhibit 41 —
Daily Records, Invoices, and Time Sheets regarding
41 '

equipment hauls 0n 9/1 7/ 1 5-9/25/ 1 5
(PAVE001318-001327)

Deposition of Ricky Boydston Exhibit 42 —
Daily Records, Invoices, and Time Sheets regarding
42 '

equipment hauls 0n 7/9/15, 7/16/15, and 7/18/15
(PAVE001308-0013 17)

Deposition 0f Ricky Boydston Exhibit 43 —
Daily Records, Invoices, and Time Sheets regarding
43 °

equipment hauls 0n 10/ 1 7/ 1 5 through 10/22/ 1 5
(PAVE001328-001336)

Deposition 0f Ricky Boydston Exhibit 44 —
44 '

HOLT CAT Invoice dated 2/24/17 (MM000269)
Deposition of Ricky Boydston Exhibit 45 —
45 '

HOLT CAT invoice dated 3/13/17 (MM000268)
Deposition 0f Ricky Boydston Exhibit 46 —
46 '

HOLT CAT invoice dated 3/20/17 (MM000267)
Deposition of Ricky Boydston Exhibit 47 —
47 '

RECS invoice dated 3/2/17 (MM000266)
48. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f Ricky Boydston Exhibit 49
49. Ricky Boydston’s Calendar for 4/2/ 17-4/8/17
(PAVE004577)

50. Intentionally Left Blank

5 1. Intentionally Left Blank

52. Intentionally Left Blank

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 4
DATE
DESCRIPTION 011:1: OBJ 8:1
El???) ADMIfEXC

53. Intentionally Left Blank

54. Intentionally Left Blank

55. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f Veronica Moreno Exhibit 56 —
56. Pavecon Dallas Organizational Chart
(PAVE-THOMPSON 000238)
57. Intentionally Left Blank

58. Intentionally Left Blank

59. Intentionally Left Blank

60. Intentionally Left Blank

6 1. Intentionally Left Blank

62. Intentionally Left Blank

63. Intentionally Left Blank

64. Intentionally Left Blank

65. Intentionally Left Blank

66. Intentionally Left Blank

67. Intentionally Left Blank

68. Intentionally Left Blank

69. Intentionally Left Blank

70. Intentionally Left Blank

7 1. Intentionally Left Blank

72. Intentionally Left Blank

73. Intentionally Left Blank

74. Intentionally Left Blank

75. Intentionally Left Blank

76. Intentionally Left Blank

77. Intentionally Left Blank

78. Intentionally Left Blank

79. Intentionally Left Blank

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 5
DATE
DESCRIPTION 011:1: OBJ 8:1
El???) ADMIfEXC

80. Intentionally Left Blank

8 1. Intentionally Left Blank

82. Intentionally Left Blank

83. Intentionally Left Blank

84. Intentionally Left Blank

85. Intentionally Left Blank

86. Intentionally Left Blank

87. Intentionally Left Blank

88. Intentionally Left Blank

89. Intentionally Left Blank

90. Intentionally Left Blank

9 1. Intentionally Left Blank

92. Intentionally Left Blank

93. Intentionally Left Blank

94. Intentionally Left Blank

95. Intentionally Left Blank

96. Intentionally Left Blank

97. Intentionally Left Blank

98. Intentionally Left Blank

99. Intentionally Left Blank

100. Intentionally Left Blank

10 1. Intentionally Left Blank

102. Intentionally Left Blank

103. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f Donald Heierman Exhibit 104 —
Email from Stephanie Thompson to Don Heierman
104. dated 10/ 19/16 re: Mike Jeter’s Crew — Marty
Murphy Residence With attachments
(PAVE000538-000540)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 6
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADMIfEXC
EX. NO. R P

Deposition 0f Donald Heierman Exhibit 105 —
105. 2015 Shareholder’s Basis Statement for Murphy
(MM000379-000380)

Deposition of Donald Heierman Exhibit 106 —
106. 2015 Pavecon Holding C0., Inc. Stock Ledger
(PAVE002094-002097)

Deposition 0f Donald Heierman Exhibit 107 —
107. Reconciliation of Marty Murphy’s Stock Basis
(MM000423)
108. Intentionally Left Blank

109. Intentionally Left Blank

110. Intentionally Left Blank

111. Intentionally Left Blank

112. Intentionally Left Blank

113. Intentionally Left Blank

114. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f Donald Heierman Exhibit 115 —
Correspondence from Marty Murphy t0 David
11 5 '

Walker following termination with attachments
(PAVE000439-000441)

Deposition 0f Donald Heierman Exhibit 116 —
Email from Stephanie Thompson t0 Don
10/ 18/ 16
116. Heierman regarding Mike Jeter’s Crew — Marty
Murphy Residence with attachments
(PAVE-THOMPSON 000057-000059)
Deposition 0f Donald Heierman Exhibit 117 —
117 Defendants’ First Amended Obj ections and
Responses t0 Plaintiff” s First Set 0f Interrogatories

Deposition of Donald Heierman Exhibit 118 — T-K-
O Monthly invoices for 2/23/17 and 3/13/17 and
11 8 '

Check 2242 dated 3/28/17
(PAVE000443-000445)

Deposition 0f Donald Heierman Exhibit 119 —
119. Holt Cat invoice dated 3/27/17 and Check 2325
dated 5/3/17 (PAVE000463-000464)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE7
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADMIfEXC
EX. NO. R P

Deposition 0f Donald Heierman Exhibit 120 —
Triple JB Transportation, Inc. invoice dated 3/6/17
1 20 '

with tickets and Check 2241 dated 3/28/ 17
(PAVE000445-000448)

Deposition 0f Donald Heierman Exhibit 121 —
121. Bob Ward, Jr. Equipment Company Invoice
Number 34275 dated 8/3 1/16 (PAVE000467)
Deposition of Donald Heierman Exhibit 122 —
1 22 '

Check Deduct Report from 3/9/14 (PAVE000853)

Deposition 0f Donald Heierman Exhibit 123 —
123. Various Pavecon Payments t0 Murphy
(MM00395-000408)

124. Intentionally Left Blank

125. Intentionally Left Blank

126. Intentionally Left Blank

127. Intentionally Left Blank

128. Intentionally Left Blank

129. Intentionally Left Blank

130. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition of Marty Murphy Exhibit 131 —
Warranty Deed With Vendor’s Lien for Murphy’s
13 1. Property between Grantor 1995 Osprey, L.L.C. and
Martin Wade Murphy and Cheryl Carter Murphy
dated 8/ 1 7/ 1 5

Deposition of Marty Murphy Exhibit 132 —
132 '
Unimproved Property Contract between Marty &
Cheryl Murphy and William Carter regarding CR
2400 Terrell, TX 75160 dated 10/2/16

Deposition of Marty Murphy Exhibit 133 —
1 33
Settlement Statement for Bruce & Joy Carter and
'

Marty & Cheryl Murphy regarding CR 2400,
Terrell, TX 75160 dated 11/30/16

Deposition 0f MartyMurphy Exhibit 134 —
1 34 '

Employment Offer for Marty Murphy

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 8
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADM/EXC
EX. NO.
L

Deposition of Marty Murphy Exhibit 135 —
135. 9/24/ 12 Email from David Walker to Jim Thomas
regarding Marty Murphy

Deposition 0f Marty Murphy Exhibit 136 —
136. 2013 Stock Bonus Agreement between Marty
Murphy and Pavecon Holding Co., Inc.
Deposition of Marty Murphy Exhibit 137 —
137. 2014 Stock Bonus Agreement between Marty
Murphy and Pavecon Holding C0., Inc.
Deposition 0f Marty Murphy Exhibit 138 —
138. 2015 Stock Bonus Agreement between Marty
Murphy and Pavecon Holding C0., Inc.
Deposition of MartyMurphy Exhibit 139 —
139. Stock Purchase Agreement between Murphy and
Pavecon Holding C0,, Inc. executed 0n 12/20/16

Murphy Exhibit 140 —
Deposition of Marty
Executed Second Amended and Restated
140.
Agreement of Limited Partnership of Pavecon
Public Works LP (PAVE002098-002155)

Deposition 0f Marty Murphy Exhibit 141 —
141. Limited Liability Company Agreement 0f Pavecon
Ltd. C0. (PAVE001991-002059)

Deposition of Marty Murphy Exhibit 142 —
Proﬁt/Loss Sharing Agreement for Pavecon Public
142. Works Pavecon Public Works GP LLC,
L.P.,
Pavecon Holding C0., Inc., and Murphy
(MM000244-00249)

Deposition of Marty Murphy Exhibit 143 —
Proﬁt/Loss Sharing Agreement for Pavecon Ltd.
143.
C0. and Marty and Cheryl Murphy
(MM000096-00102)

Deposition of Marty Murphy Exhibit 144 —
First Amended and Restated Proﬁt/Loss Sharing
144.
Agreement forPavecon Ltd. C0. and Marty and
Cheryl Murphy (MMOOO 1 70-000 1 76)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 9
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADMIfEXC
EX. NO. R P

Deposition 0f Marty Murphy Exhibit 145 —
4/ 14/ 17 E-mail from Marty Murphy t0 Mark
145. Murphy and Stephanie Thompson regarding
Pavecon statement and payment status
(PAVEOOI 157-001 159)
Deposition 0f Marty Murphy Exhibit 146 —
3/23/ 1 7 Email from Marty Murphy t0 Shane Korn
146. . . . .

and Stephanle Thompson regardmg 1nV01ce not
approved with attachments (PAVEOOI 145-001 148)

147. Intentionally Left Blank

148. Intentionally Left Blank

149. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition of Charles David Walker Exhibit 150 —
150. Employment Offer for Marty Murphy
(MMOOOOOl-MMOOOOOZ)
Deposition 0f Charles David Walker Exhibit 151 —
15 1. 9/24/ 12 E-mail from David Walker t0 Jim Thomas
regarding Marty Murphy (MMOOOOO3)
Deposition 0f Charles David Walker Exhibit 152 —
152. 2015 Pavecon Holding C0., Inc.’s Schedule K-l for
Murphy (MM0003 8 1 -MM0003 82)
Deposition of Charles David Walker Exhibit 153 —
2015 Business Reorganization Notebook and Stock
1 53 '

Purchase Price Check Details dated 12/20/ 16
(MM000004-000250)

154. Intentionally Left Blank

155. Intentionally Left Blank

156. Intentionally Left Blank

157. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition of Kelsey Greene Exhibit 158 —
Ricochet Fuel Distributors, Inc.’s Invoices and
1 58 '

Murphy Check 2243 dated
Tickets and 3/28/ 17
(PAVE000449-PAVE000464)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 10
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADM/EXC
EX. NO.
L

Deposition 0f Kelsey Greene Exhibit 159 —
2/28/ 17 Email from Stephanie Thompson t0 Marty
159. Murphy and Kelsey Greene regarding Fwd:
INVOICES from Ricochet Fuel Distributors
(PAVEOOI 168)
Deposition 0f Kelsey Greene Exhibit 160 —
Murphy t0 Kelsey
2/27/ 17 E-mail from Marty
160. Greene and Stephanie Thompson regarding
Personal Check for Ricochet Fuel Invoice
(PAVEOOI 135-PAVE001 136)

Deposition 0f Kelsey Greene Exhibit 161 —
between Marty Murphy and Jordy
4/3/ 17 E-mails
161. Richards, PublicWorksAP, and Kelsey Greene
regarding Account Status — Skipped Invoices
(PAVEOOI 153-PAVE001 155)

Deposition 0f Kelsey Greene Exhibit 162 —
Email from Mariana Mendez
11/ 1 1/ 16 t0 Kelsey
162.
Greene re: Check/Release
(PAVEOOO965-PAVE000966)
Deposition of Kelsey Greene Exhibit 163 —
163. APAC Invoice No. 200519642 and Tickets
(PAVE00092 1 -PAVE000922)
Deposition of Kelsey Greene Exhibit 164 —
164. Murphy Check N0. 102 to APAC for $2975.64
dated 10/28/16 (MM000368)

Deposition 0f Kelsey Greene Exhibit 165 —
2/27/17 E-mail from Stephanie Thompson t0 Marty
165. Murphy, Teresa Belvins, and Kelsey Greene
regarding Personal Check to Ricochet Fuel
(PAVEOOI 166-PAVE001 167)

Deposition 0f Kelsey Greene Exhibit 166 —
Ricochet Fuel Distributors Invoice dated 2/9/ 17 and
166.
Murphy Check 2193 dated 2/14/17
(MM000275-MM000276)
Deposition of Kelsey Greene Exhibit 167 —
T-K-O Equipment Co. Invoices dated 2/23/17 and
167.
3/13/17 and Check N0. 2242 dated 3/28/17
(PAVEOOO442-PAVE000444)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 11
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADM/EXC
EX. NO.
L

Deposition 0f Kelsey Greene Exhibit 168 —
4/ 14/ 17 Emails between Marty Murphy, Mark
168. Murphy, and Stephanie Thompson regarding
Pavecon statement and payment status
(PAVEOOI 157-PAVE001 159)

Deposition 0f Flor Jordan Exhibit 169 —
2/ 15/ 16 Email from Flor Cantu to Ricardo Gomez
169.
Summary Sheets With attachments
regarding
(PAVE001047-PAVE001058)

Deposition 0f Flor Jordan Exhibit 170 —
2/25/ 16 Email from Pavecon Printer t0 Flor Cantu
170. regarding Attached image with Ricardo Gomez’s
2/ 1 1/ 1 6-2/ 1 2/1 6 Time Sheets (PAVEOO 1 06 1 -
PAVEOO 1 063)
171. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f Flor Jordan Exhibit 172 —
172. Murphy
2/23/ 16 Email from Flor Cantu t0 Marty
regarding RATES (PAVEOO 1 024-PAVE00 1 024B)

Deposition of Flor Jordan Exhibit 173 —
2/29/16 Emails between Flor Cantu and Marty
173.
Murphy regarding Marty's place hrs
(PAVEOOlO22-PAVE001023)
Deposition of Flor Jordan Exhibit 174 —
2/9/ 17 Email from Flor Cantu to Marty Murphy
174. regarding Checks and 2017 Charts regarding Crews
for Ismael Ortega, Kenneth Brookshire
(PAVEOO4579-PAVE004585)
Deposition of Flor Jordan Exhibit 175 —
175. Murphy’s Various Check Details
(MM000292-MM0003 63)
Deposition of Cheryl Murphy Exhibit 176 —
176. 10/ 19/ 1 7 Email chain between Cheryl Murphy and
Marty Murphy (PAVEOOI 100-001 101)

Deposition of Cheryl Murphy Exhibit 177 —
2/14/ 17 Email from Marty Murphy to Cheryl
177.
Murphy regarding cost for paving
(PAVEOOI 134)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 12
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADM/EXC
EX. N0.
L

Deposition 0f Cheryl Murphy Exhibit 178 —
3/7/1 7 Email from Marty Murphy to Cheryl Murphy
178.
and Kenneth Brookshire regarding Marty’s Property
PPE (PAVEOOl 140)
Murphy Exhibit 179 —
Deposition 0f Cheryl
179.
Photograph (PAVE000827)

180. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition of Kenneth Brookshire Exhibit 181 —
Production Schedule — Personnel Locations for Dec.
181.
2015, Jan. 2016, Feb. 2016, Sept. 2016, Feb. 2017,
and Mar. 20 1 7 (PAVE000874. 1 -000874. 1 8)

Deposition of Kenneth Brookshire Exhibit 182 —
182.
Notice 0f Subpoena Duces Tecum
183. Intentionally Left Blank

184. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition of Frederick W. Wolfes Exhibit 185 —
Production Schedule — Personnel Locations for Dec.
185. 2015, Jan. 2016, Feb. 2016, Sept. 2016, Feb. 2017,
and Mar. 20 1 7
(PAVE000874. 1 -000874. 1 8)

Deposition 0f Frederick W. Wolfes Exhibit 186 —
186. 02/ 12/16 Time Sheet for Richard Gomez’s Crew
(PAVEOO 1 046)
Deposition 0f Frederick W. Wolfes Exhibit 187 —
187. 02/ 1 1/ 16 Time Sheet for Richard Gomez’s Crew
(PAVEOO 1 042)
Deposition of Frederick W. Wolfes Exhibit 188 —
188. Time Sheet
06/3 0/ 15 for Ricky Boydston’s Crew
(PAVE001300)

Deposition 0f Frederick W. Wolfes Exhibit 189 —
189. Defendant’s Notice 0f Subpoena Duces Tecum t0
Frederick W. Wolfes
Deposition 0f Bryan Piper Exhibit 190 —
190. Defendant’s Subpoena for Oral Deposition to RKM
Utility Services, Inc.

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE13
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADM/EXC
EX. N0.
L

191. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 192 —
10/29/1 8 Email t0 Mr. Vernon, from Mr. Heierman
192.
re Before and After
(PAVEO9993-PAVEOO9995)
Deposition 0f Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 193 —
10/29/ 1 8 Email to Mr. Vernon, from Mr. Heierman
193.
re Carter stamps
(PAVEO9996-PAVEO 1 0007)
Deposition 0f Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 194 —
194. 10/29/ 1 8 Email regarding Estimate prepared by
Brian Cottle (PAVEO 1 0008-PAVEO 1 00 1 8)
Deposition of Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 195 —
195. 10/29/1 8 Email with Boundary Survey 0f Murphy’s
Property (PAVEO 1 00 1 9-PAVEO 1 0020)
Deposition 0f Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 196 —
196. 10/29/ 1 8 Email regarding Powell Stamps
(PAVEO 1 002 1 -PAVEO 1 0033)
Deposition 0f Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 197 —
197. 11/13/1 8 Email from D. Heierman t0 R. Vernon
(PAVE010034-010038)

Deposition of Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 198 —
198. 11/13/1 8 Email from D. Heierman t0 R. Vernon
(PAVE010039-010043)

Deposition 0f Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 199 —
199. 11/13/1 8 Email from D. Heierman to R. Vernon
(PAVE010044-010047)

Deposition of Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 200 —
200. 11/13/1 8 Email from D. Heierman t0 R. Vernon
(PAVE010048-010051)

Deposition 0f Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 201 —
201. 11/12/1 8 Email from D. Heierman t0 R. Vernon
(PAVE010052-010054)

Deposition 0f Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 202 —
202. 11/12/1 8 Email from D. Heierman to R. Vernon
(PAVE010055-010060)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE14
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADMIfEXC
EX. NO. R P

Deposition 0f Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 203 —
203. 11/12/1 8 Email from D. Heierman to R. Vernon
(PAVE010061-010062)

Deposition of Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 204 —
204. 11/2/ 1 8 Email from D. Heierman to R. Vernon
(PAVE010063-010064)

Deposition 0f Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 205 —
205. 10/30/1 8 Email from D. Heierman t0 R. Vernon
(PAVE010065)

206. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 207 —
207. ,
.

Ron Vernon s Estlmate

Deposition of Donald R. Vernon, Jr Exhibit 208 —
Summary 0f Limited Liability Company Agreement
208 '

for Pavecon Ltd. C0.
(MM000030-00003 1)

209. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f William Barnard Exhibit 210 —
21 0 '

Resume 0f William Barnard
Deposition of William Barnard Exhibit 211 —
Engagement Letter with William Barnard
7/ 1 0/ 1 8
211 '

and Carter Amett PLLC
(PAVE010302-010308)

2 12. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition 0f William Barnard Exhibit 213 —
21 3 '

William Barnard’s Expert Report

Deposition 0f William Barnard Exhibit 214 —
214 '

Documents relied upon by William Barnard

Deposition 0f William Barnard Exhibit 215 —
2 1 5.
Summary 0f Damages
Deposition of William Barnard Exhibit 216 —
Time Records and Daily Logs regarding Ismael
2 1 6.
Ortega and Crew
(PAVE010325-010348)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 15
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADMIfEXC
EX. NO. R P

Deposition 0f William Barnard Exhibit 217 —
Time Records and Daily Logs regarding Ismael
2 1 7.
Ortega and Crew
(PAVE010309-010324)

2 1 8. Intentionally Left Blank

2 1 9. Intentionally Left Blank

220. Intentionally Left Blank

221. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition of Charles M. Meadows, Jr. Exhibit 222
222 '
— Resume of Charles M. Meadows, Jr.

Deposition of Charles M. Meadows, Jr. Exhibit 223
223. — Engagement M. Meadows, Jr.
Letter for Charles
and Carter Amett PLLC
224. Intentionally Left Blank

225. Intentionally Left Blank

226. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition of Rudy R. Robinson III Exhibit 227 —
227. Resume of Rudy R. Robinson III and Addenda to
Expert Report of Rudy R. Robinson III

Deposition of Rudy R. Robinson III Exhibit 228 —
228 '

R011 Vernon’s Estimate Details

229. Intentionally Left Blank

Deposition of Rudy R. Robinson III Exhibit 230 —
230. Addendum to Expert Report 0f Rudy R. Robinson
III, Estimate Prepared by Brian Cottle

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 5,

23 1. Demographics — Ten Mile Radius 0f Subj ect
Property Illustration

Expert Report of Rudy Robinson III at 9, Site
232 '

Analysis Illustration and Description

Expert Report of Rudy Robinson III at 10,
233 '

Topography and Soil Conditions Illustrations

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 16
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADMIfEXC
EX. NO. R P

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 20, Sale 1
234 '

(Subj ect Property) Illustration

Expert Report of Rudy Robinson III at 22, Sale 2
235. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 24, Sale 3
236. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 26, Sale 4
237. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 28, Sale 5
238. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 30, Sale 6
239. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 32, Sale 7
240. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 34, Sale 8
241. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 36, Sale 9
242. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 38, Sale 10
243. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 40, Sale 11
244. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 42, Sale 12
245. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 44, Sale 13
246. .

Illustratlon

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 46, Before
247. Value (Murphy Property Before Pavecon
Improvements) Chart

Expert Report of Rudy Robinson III at 48, After
248. Value (Murphy Property After Pavecon
Improvements) Chart

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 51,
249 '

Depreciation Chart

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 17
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADMIfEXC
EX. NO. R P

Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at 52, Cost
250
Approach Conclusions (after) Chart

Expert Report of Rudy Robinson III at 53,
251 '

Reconciliation and Summary of Opinions
Expert Report 0f Rudy Robinson III at Addenda,
252 '

Subj ect Photographs 0f Murphy’s Property

Resume 0f Rudy Robinson III and Certiﬁcate from
253. the Texas Appraiser Licensing and Certiﬁcation
Board (PAVEOl 1418-01 1435)

Contract for Appraisal Services of Austin Valuation
254. Consultants, Ltd.
(PAVEOI 1448-01 1452)
Aerial— Close Files reviewed by Expert Rudy
25 5 '

Robinson III (PAVEOOI 1710-001 1753)

Aerial — Farther Files reviewed by Expert Rudy
256 '

Robinson III (PAVEOOI 1754-001 1805)
Aerial Image of Murphy’s Property, Mar. 2014
257. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1807)
Aerial Image of Murphy’s Property, Dec. 2016
258. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEOI 1806)
Aerial Image 0f Murphy’s Property, May 2017
259. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1808)
Aerial Image of Murphy’s Property reviewed by
260. Rudy Robinson III
Expert
(PAVEOI 1809)
AerialImage of Hunt County reviewed by Expert
261. Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEOI 18 10)
Aerial Image 0f Hunt County reviewed by Expert
262. Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 181 1)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 18
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADM/EXC
EX. NO.
L

Warranty Deed with Vendor’s Lien for Murphy’s
263. Property dated 12/5/16 reviewed by Expert Rudy
Robinson III (PAVEOI 18 12-01 18 1 6)

Hunt County CAD Property Search for Property ID:
264. 224797 for year 201 8 reviewed by Expert Rudy
Robinson III (PAVEOI 1824-01 1827)

Hunt County CAD Property Search for Property ID:
265. 224770 for year 201 8 reviewed by Expert Rudy
Robinson III (PAVEOl 1828-01 1832)

AerialImage 0f Murphy’s Property, Dec. 2016
266. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEOI 1817)
Aerial Image of Murphy’s Property, Dec. 2016
267. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 18 1 8)
Hunt County CAD Property Search for Property ID:
268. 34459 for year 201 8 reviewed by Expert Rudy
Robinson III (PAVEOl 18 1 9-01 1823)

Hunt County Topography Image reviewed by
269. Expert Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEOI 1833)
Aerial Image 0f Murphy’s Property, Mar. 2014
270. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1834)
Aerial Image 0f Murphy’s Property, Mar. 2017
271. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1836-01 1837)
Soil Chart reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III
272.
(PAVEOI 1838)
Soil Image reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III
273.
(PAVEOI 1839)
Aerial Data for Windemere reviewed by Expert
274. Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEOI 1840-01 185 1)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 19
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADM/EXC
EX. NO.
L

Agent Full Report for 7623 County Road 2556
275. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1852-01 1857)
Aerial Image for 7623 County Road 2556 reviewed
276. by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1947)
Agent Full Report for 10503 County Road 3605
277. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1858-01 1955)
AerialImage of 10503 County Road reviewed by
278.
Expert Rudy Robinson III (PAVEOl 1956)

Aerial Full Report for County Road 2560 reviewed
279. by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1866-01 1873)
AerialImage 0f County Road 2560 reviewed by
280. Expert Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEOI 1945)
Aerial Full Report for 4265 County Road 2509 and
281. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1874-01 1881)
AerialImage of 4625 County Road 2509 reviewed
282. by Expert Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEOI 1946)
Aerial Full Report for 13 1 3 Northshore Rd reviewed
283. by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1893-01 1900)
Aerial Image of 13 13 Northshore Rd reviewed by
284. Rudy Robinson
Expert III

(PAVEOI 1949)
Aerial Full Report for County Road 2332 reviewed
285. by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1901-01 1909)
AerialImage of County Road 2332 reviewed by
286. Expert Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEOI 1950)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 20
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADM/EXC
EX. NO.
L

Aerial Full Report for 6086 Hidden Oaks reviewed
287. by Expert Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEOI 1910-01 1918)
Aerial Image 0f 6086 Hidden Oaks reviewed by
288. Rudy Robinson III
Expert
(PAVEOI 1951)
Aerial Full Report for County Road 2400 reviewed
289. by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1919-01 1924)
AerialImage 0f County Road 2400 reviewed by
290. Expert Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEOI 1952)
Aerial Full Report for 10037 County Road 3605
291. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1925-01 1932)
Aerial Image 0f 10037 County Road 3605 reviewed
292. by Expert Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEOI 1953)
Aerial Full Report for 10327 County Road 2326
293. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1933-01 1936)
Aerial Image of 10327 County Road 2326 reviewed
294. by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1954)
Aerial Full Report for County Road 2452 reviewed
295. by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOI 1937-1 1944)
Aerial Image of County Road 2452 reviewed by
296. Rudy Robinson III
Expert
(PAVEOI 1955)
Hunt CAD Property Search Property ID:224797 for
297. year 201 8 reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III
(PAVE012072-012075)

Hunt CAD Map 0f William Carter’s 2.7 Acres
298. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVE012047)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 21
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI
DESCRIPTION OBJ ADM/EXC
EX. NO.
L

Hunt CAD Property Search Property ID: 224797 for
299. year 201 8 reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVE012076-012079)

Hunt CAD Property Search Property ID: 224770 for
300. year 201 8 reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVE012062-012066)

Hunt CAD Map 0f Bruce & Joy Carter’s 2.5 Acres
301. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III
(PAVEO 12045)
Warranty Deed between Marty and Cheryl Murphy
and Bruce and Joy Carter reviewed by Expert Rudy
302.
Robinson III
(PAVE012155-012159)

Hunt CAD Property Sear Property ID: 224770 for
303. year 2017 reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVEOIZ 160-012164)
Agent Full Report for 10327 County Road 2326
304. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVE012081-012084)

Agent Full Reports reviewed by Expert Rudy
305.
Robinson III (PAVE012085-012154)

Hunt CAD Property Search Property ID: 34450 for
306. year 201 8 reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVE012057-012061)

Hunt CAD Property Search Property ID: 34450 for
307. year 201 8 reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVE012067-01207 1)

Hunt CAD Property Search Property ID: 213 139 for
308. year 201 8 reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVE012048-012056)

Hunt CAD Map of 15. 1 12 Acres in 2 Tracts
309. reviewed by Expert Rudy Robinson III

(PAVE012046)

Hunt CAD Map 0f 15. 1 12 Acres reviewed by
310. ExpertRudy Robinson III
(PAVE012080)

DEFENDANTS AND COUNTERCLAIM PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST PAGE 22
DATE
DEF’S OFF STI

Case Info

Judge

SMITH, CRAIG Track Judge’s New Case

Case No.

(Subscribe to View)

Document Filed Date

November 21, 2019

Case Filing Date

August 23, 2017

County

Parties

ARNETT, JAMES ROBERT, II Attorney for the Defendant
BENNETT, JOSHUA J. Attorney for the Defendant
DAVID, BRYAN Attorney for the Plaintiff
FIELDING, DAVID Attorney for the Defendant
LABCON INC Defendant
MURPHY, MARTY Plaintiff
PAVECON HOLDINGS CO., INC. Defendant
PAVECON LTD. CO. Defendant
PAVECON PUBLIC WORKS GP LLC Defendant
PAVECON PUBLIC WORKS LP Defendant
SMITH, CHARLES H Attorney for the Plaintiff
Thompson, Stephanie Defendant
WALKER, C DAVID Defendant
Stacey Hernandez Attorneys for Defendants
Frank Denny Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Stephanie Merithew Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Bryan Davis Attorneys for Plaintiffs
David Dean Attorney
Bryan Stone Attorneys for Plaintiffs

For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.

Trial Materials: MARTY MURPHY vs. PAVECON HOLDINGS CO., INC., et al

Preview

Case Info

Parties