Preview
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL
FOURTH DISTRICT
WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA
RECORD ON APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT
COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN
AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA
AARON BRUNER
APPELLANT CASE NO.: CACE 21-16576
vs
BONNIE JUDSON
APPELLEE APPEAL NO.: 4D23-1412
RECORDON
APPEAL
CC: VINCENT DUFFY, ESQ.
BRIAN PITA, ESQ.
PAULO R. LIMA, ESQ.
ELIZABETH K. RUSSO, ESQ.
MASTER INDEX ON APPEAL
APPELLATE DIVISION
Case NO: CACE-21-016576
UCN NO: 062021CA016576AXXXCE
Appeal NO: 4D23-1412
DATE: KIND OF PAGES:
INSTRUMENT
07/25/2023 Case Summary 9-14
08/31/2021 Complaint (eFiled) 15-17
08/31/2021 Notice of Filing 18-19
Designation of
Emailing Addresses
08/31/2021 Plaintiff's General 20
- 28
Personal Injury
Negligence
Interrogatories to
Defendant
08/31/2021 Plaintiff's Request for 29
- 33
Production
08/31/2021 Plaintiff's First 34-35
Request for
Admissions
08/31/2021 Notice of Video 36
- 37
Deposition
09/27/2021 Notice of Filing 38
- 39
Designation of
Emailing Addresses
09/27/2021 Defendant's Answer & 40
- 45
Affirmative Defenses
09/27/2021 Defendant's 46
- 49
Response to First
Request for
Admissions
09/28/2021 Notice of 50-51
Unavailability
10/11/2021 Re-Notice of Taking 52
- 53
Deposition
10/12/2021 Defendant's First 54
- 58
Request for
Admissions
10/12/2021 Defendant's First 59
- 64
Request to Produce
10/12/2021 Defendant's 65
- 70
Medicare/C ollateral
Source Requestto
Produce
10/21/2021 Defendant's Motion 71-72
for Extension of Time
to Respond to
Discovery
11/08/2021 Agreed Order on 73
- 74
Defendant's Motion
for Extension of Time
to Respond to
Plaintiff's Discovery
11/12/2021 Plaintiff's Motion for 75
- 76
Enlargement of Time
to Respond to
Defendant's
Discovery
11/22/2021 Notice of Service of 77-78
Answers to
Interrogatories
11/22/2021 Defendant's 79
- 84
Response to First
Request for
Production
11/22/2021 Defendant's Privilege 85
- 87
Log
12/01/2021 Agreed Order on 88
- 89
Plaintiff's Motion for
Enlargement of Time
to Respond to
Defendant's
Discovery
12/06/2021 Second Re-Notice of 90-91
Taking Deposition
01/06/2022 Uniform Case 92-94
Management Order
01/21/2022 Plaintiff's Response 95
- 98
to Defendant's
Request for
Admissions
01/21/2022 Third Re-Notice of 99 - 100
Taking Deposition
01/29/2022 Defendant's Notice of 101 - 103
Taking Deposition
02/03/2022 Defendant's Motion 104 - 112
for Order to Show
Cause, Compel
Compliance With
Court Order and For
Sanctions
02/04/2022 Uniform Order Setting 113 - 119
Pretrial Deadline
02/14/2022 Defendant's Motion to 120 - 120
Compel Discovery
02/14/2022 Order on Plaintiff's 121-121
Motion to Compel
Discovery
03/03/2022 Notice of Service of 122 - 122
Answers to
Interrogatories
03/03/2022 Notice of Service of 123 - 123
Answers to
Interrogatories
03/03/2022 Plaintiff's Response 124 - 130
to Defendant's First
Request for
Production
03/03/2022 Plaintiff's Response 131 - 135
to Defendant's
Medicare/C ollateral
Source Request for
Production
05/13/2022 Fourth Re-Notice of 136 - 137
Taking Deposition
06/03/2022 Plaintiff's Second 138 - 138
Request for
Production of
Documents
07/01/2022 Defendant's 139-141
Response to
Plaintiff's Second
Request for
Production
07/01/2022 Defendant's Privilege 142 - 145
Log
07/18/2022 Defendant's Motion 146 - 263
for Sanctions for
Spoliation of
Evidence
08/08/2022 Notice of 264 - 264
Unavailability
11/30/2022 Defendant's Motion to 265 - 267
Extend Pretrial
Deadlines
12/01/2022 Defendant's Exhibit 268 - 271
List
12/01/2022 Defendant's Witness 272 - 275
List
12/01/2022 Defendant's Motion 276 - 410
for Final Summary
J udgment and
Memorandum of Law
in Support Thereof
12/01/2022 Notice of 411 - 421
Propounding
Interrogatories
12/01/2022 Defendant's 422 - 427
Supplemental/Update
Request for
Production
12/01/2022 Defendant's Motion in 428 - 437
Limine Regarding
Prejudicial Topics and
Matters for Trial
12/01/2022 Defendant's Motion in 438 - 450
Limine to Prevent
Plaintiff's Treating
Physicians from
Testifying as to
Causation
12/01/2022 Defendant's Motion in 451 - 455
Limine to Preclude
Plaintiff's Experts
From Testifying as to
Matters and/or
Opinions Not
Previously Disclosed
01/05/2023 Notice of Hearing 456 - 457
1/11/22
01/11/2023 Order Resetting Trial 458 - 459
01/18/2023 Notice of Video 460 - 461
Deposition
01/25/2023 Notice of Hearing 462 - 463
3/8/23
01/25/2023 Notice of Amended 464 - 465
Special Set Hearing
3/8/23
02/01/2023 Notice of Mediation 466 - 468
02/02/2023 Defendant's 469 - 472
Statement of Material
Facts in Support of
Defendant's Motion
for Summary
J udgment
02/16/2023 Plaintiff's Notice of 473 - 473
Filing Adverse
Evidence in
Opposition of
Defendant's Motion
for Summary
Judgment
02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 474 - 504
Exhibit 1
02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 505 - 545
Exhibit 2
02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 546 - 557
Exhibit3
02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 558 - 561
Exhibit 4
02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 562 - 566
Exhibit 5
02/16/2023 Plaintiff's Response 567 - 576
in Opposition to
Motion for Final
Summary J udgment
02/24/2023 Order Resetting Trial 577 - 578
03/08/2023 Second Amended 579 - 580
Notice of Special Set
Hearing 3/13/23
03/08/2023 Third Amended 581 - 582
Notice of Special Set
Hearing 3/13/23
03/17/2023 Final Summary 583 - 585
Judgment
03/28/2023 Plaintiff's Motion for 586 - 631
Reconsideration
04/14/2023 Defendant's Motion 632 - 642
for Entitlement to
Attorney Fees and
Costs, Subjectto
Defendant's Rejected
Proposal for
Settlement
04/28/2023 Plaintiff's Notice of 643 - 675
Filing Transcript of
March 13, 2023
Hearing on Motion for
Reconsideration
05/10/2023 Order on Plaintiff's 676 - 677
Motion for
Reconsideration Filed
March 28, 2023
06/08/2023 Notice of Appeal 678 - 680
06/09/2023 Amended Notice of 681 - 686
Appeal
06/21/2023 Directions to the 687 - 688
Clerk
07/12/2023 Notice of Filing 689 - 715
Transcripts for
Inclusion in Record
on Appeal
BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS
PROGRESS DOCKET
CASE NO. CACE-21-016576
Aaron Bruner Location: Civil
Plaintiff Judicial Officer: Olefson, Shari Africk
vs. Filed on: 08/31/2021
4th District Court of 4D23-1412
Bonnie Judson Appeals:
Defendant Divisional Assignment: 25
Uniform Case Number: 062021CA016576AXXXCE
CASE INFORMATION
Statistical Closures
03/17/2023 Disposed by Judge Case Type: Neg - Premises Liability
Residential
Case
04/14/2023 Reopened - CV
Status:
Case Flags: Appeal ‘iled
Jury Trial
DATE CASE ASSIGNMENT
Current Case Assignment
Case Number CACE-21-016576
Court Civil
Date Assigned 08/31/2021
Judicial Officer Olefson, Shari Africk
PARTY INFORMATION
Lead Attorneys
Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron Duffy, Vincent
1630 West Hillsboro Boulevard Retained
Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 954-428-9338(F)
954-428-9333(W)
1630 West Hillsboro Blvd
Deerfield Beach, FL 33442
service.duffy@gdinjurylaw.com
Defendant Judson, Bonnie Pita, Brian Scott
5299 N. Springs "ER Retained
Coral Springs, FL 33076 561-683-8977(F)
561-383-9200(W)
Cole, Scott & Ki sane, P.A.
222 Lakeview Av Ste 120
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
brian.pita@ legal.com
DATE EVENTS & ORDERS OF THE COURT
DISPOSITIONS
03/17/2023
Final Summary Judgment
Comment (IN FAVOR OF BONNIE JUDSON)
EVENTS
07/12/2023 Notice of Filing
06/21/2023 Directions to the Clerk
PAGE | OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM
BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS
PROGRESS DOCKET
CASE NO. CACE-21-016576
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
06/09/2023 Amended Notice of Appeal
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
06/09/2023 4th DCA Order
Within ten 10 days
‘from the date of this order, appellant shall submit a conformed copy of the underlying orde
which is the subject of the motion for rehearing for the purpose of determining whether the
06/09/2023 4th DCA Order
ORDERED that appellant shall pay the $300.00 filing fee or file the lower tribunal clerk's
determination of indigent status in this court within ten CIO) days from the date of this ordei
06/09/2023 Acknowledgment
4D23-1412//TD
06/08/2023 Notice of Appeal
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
05/10/2023 Order
ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION. FILED MARCH 28.2023
04/28/2023 Notice of Filing
04/14/2023 Motion
03/28/2023 Motion for Order
FOR RECONSMERATION
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
03/08/2023 Amended Notice of Hearing
03/08/2023 ‘Amended Notice of Hearing
02/24/2023 Order Resetting
trial
02/16/2023 Response to Motion for Judgment
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
02/16/2023 Notice of Filing
02/16/2023 Notice of Filing
02/16/2023 Notice of Filing
02/16/2023 Notice of Filing
02/16/2023 Notice of Filing
02/16/2023 Notice of Filing
02/02/2023 Statement of Facts
02/01/2023 Notice of Mediation
01/25/2023 Notice of Hearing
01/25/2023 Notice of Hearing
01/20/2023 Subpoena Retumed Served
on the 19th day of January, 2023 at 11:48 am-R/C YEHUDA FISHFELD-(JANICE G)- AS
SECRETARY AUTHORIZED TO ACCEPT SERVICE FOR R/C YEHUDA FISHFELD
01/19/2023 Subpoena Returned Served
PAGE 2 OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM
BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS
PROGRESS DOCKET
CASE NO. CACE-21-016576
R/C LAUDERDALE LAKES HEALTH CENTER / 01/18/2023
01/19/2023 Subpoena Returned Served
R/C CORA E. BRAYNON FAMILY HEALTH CENTER / 01/18/2023
01/18/2023 Notice of Video Deposition
01/13/2023 Certificate of No Objection
01/12/2023 Request for Copies (Pursuant to Rule 1.351)
01/12/2023 Notice of Production From Non-Party
01/11/2023 Order Resetting
trial
01/05/2023 Notice of Hearing
12/01/2022 Motion in Limine
TO PRECLUDE PLAINTIFF'S EXPERTS FROM TESTIFYING
AS TO MATTERS AND/OR OPINIONS NOT PREVIOUSLY DISCLOSED
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
12/01/2022 Motion in Limine
TO PREVENT PLAINTIFF'S
REATING PHYSICIANS FROM TESTIFYING AS TO CAUSATION
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
12/01/2022 Motion in Limine
REGARDING PREJUDICIAL TOPICS AND MATTERS FOR TRIAL
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
12/01/2022 Request for Production
TO PLAINTIFF
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
12/01/2022 Notice of Propounding Interrogatories
TO PLAINTIFF
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
12/01/2022 Motion for Summary Judgment
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
12/01/2022 Witness List
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
12/01/2022 UL Exhibit List
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
12/01/2022 Notice of Serving Proposal for Settlement
11/30/2022 Motion for Extension of Time
08/08/2022 Notice of Unavailability
07/20/2022 Appearance As Attomey of Record
INNA KRESLAVSKAYA
FI Bar No.: 1025519
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
07/18/2022 Motion for Sanctions
FOR SPOLIATION OF EVIDENCE
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
07/01/2022 Privilege Log
PAGE 3 OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM
BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS
PROGRESS DOCKET
CASE NO. CACE-21-016576
07/01/2022 Response to Request for Production
06/03/2022 Request for Production of Documents
05/13/2022 Re-Notice of Taking Deposition
05/04/2022 Notice of Cancellation
03/03/2022 Response to Request for Production
03/03/2022 Response to Request for Production
03/03/2022 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories
03/03/2022 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories
02/14/2022 Order
ON PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY
02/14/2022 Order on Motion to Compel
discovery
02/04/2022 Uniform Order Setting Pretrial Deadline
01-12-2023 at 10:00 AM
02/03/2022 Motion for Order to Show Cause
COMPEL COMPLIANCE WITH COURT ORDER AND FOR SANCTIONS.
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
01/29/2022 Notice of Taking Deposition
01/21/2022 Re-Notice of Taking Deposition
01/21/2022 Notice of Cancellation
01/21/2022 Response to Request for Admissions
01/06/2022 Case Management Order
02-04-2022 10:00 AM
12/06/2021 Re-Notice of Taking Deposition
12/01/2021 Order Extending Time
TO RESPOND TO DISCOVERY
11/22/2021 Privilege Log
11/22/2021 Response to Request for Production
11/22/2021 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories
11/12/2021 Motion for Enlargement of Time
TO RESPOND TO DEFENDANT'S DISCOVERY
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
11/08/2021 Order Extending Time
11/04/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served
11/02/2021 Subpoena Returned Served
WINDSOR IMAGING
11/02/2021 Subpoena Retumed Served
PETER F. MERKLE MD
11/02/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served
PAGE 4 OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM
BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS
PROGRESS DOCKET
CASE NO. CACE-21-016576
11/02/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served
10/28/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served
10/28/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served
10/28/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served
10/25/2021 Certificate of No Objection
10/21/2021 Motion for Extension of Time
TO RESPOND TO DISCOVERY
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
10/13/2021 Request for Copies (Pursuant to Rule 1.351)
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
10/13/2021 Notice of Production From Non-Party
10/12/2021 Request to Produce
10/12/2021 Request to Produce
10/12/2021 Request for Admissions
10/12/2021 Notice of Service of Interrogs
10/12/2021 Notice of Service of Interrogs
10/11/2021 Re-Notice of Taking Deposition
10/06/2021 Notice of Cancellation
09/28/2021 Notice of Unavailability
09/27/2021 Response to Request for Admissions
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
09/27/2021 Answer & Affirmative Defenses
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
09/27/2021 Notice of Filing Designation of Emailing Addresses
DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF DESIGNATION OF E-MAIL ADDRESSES
09/27/2021 Notice of Appearance
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
09/10/2021 Summons Returned Served
09/07/21
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
08/31/2021 Notice of Video Deposition
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
08/31/2021 Request for Admissions
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
08/31/2021 Request for Production
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
08/31/2021 Interrogatories
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
08/31/2021 Notice of Filing Designation of Emailing Addresses
Service. Duff@gdinjurylaw.com
PAGE 5 OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM
BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS
PROGRESS DOCKET
CASE NO. CACE-21-016576
08/31/2021 eSummons Issuance
Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie
08/31/2021 Complaint (eFiled)
FOR DAMAGES
Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
08/31/2021 Civil Cover Sheet
Amount: 00,001.00
08/31/2021 Per AOSC20-23 Amd12, Case is determined General
DATE FINANCIAL INFORMATION
Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron
Total Charges 511.00
Total Payments and Credits 511.00
Balance Due as of 7/25/2023 0.00
PAGE 6 OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM
17™ JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY
CERTIFICATE OF THE CLERK
AARON BRUNER
APPELLANT CASE NO.: CACE 21-16576
vs
BONNIE JUDSON
APPELLEE APPEAL NO.: 4D23-1412
|, Brenda D. Forman, Clerk of the Circuit Court, 17"
Judicial Circuit for the County of Broward, State of Florida, do
hereby certify that the foregoing pages 15 to 715 , contain
a true and correct copy of all such pleadings and proceedings in said
cause as appears from the records and _ files of my office that have
been directed to be included in said record.
Pages to Inclusive embrace the transcribed notes of the
reporter as made at the trial and certified to me by them.
In witness whereof, | have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal
of said court this 25th dayof July , 2023.
Brenda D. Forman, Clerk
Circuit Court Florida
Broward County,
BY: Temarah Daley
Deputy Clerk
954-831-5699
201 SE 6th St., Rm. 4140
Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33301
tdaley@browardclerk.org
Preview
IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL FOURTH DISTRICT WEST PALM BEACH, FLORIDA RECORD ON APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA AARON BRUNER APPELLANT CASE NO.: CACE 21-16576 vs BONNIE JUDSON APPELLEE APPEAL NO.: 4D23-1412 RECORDON APPEAL CC: VINCENT DUFFY, ESQ. BRIAN PITA, ESQ. PAULO R. LIMA, ESQ. ELIZABETH K. RUSSO, ESQ. MASTER INDEX ON APPEAL APPELLATE DIVISION Case NO: CACE-21-016576 UCN NO: 062021CA016576AXXXCE Appeal NO: 4D23-1412 DATE: KIND OF PAGES: INSTRUMENT 07/25/2023 Case Summary 9-14 08/31/2021 Complaint (eFiled) 15-17 08/31/2021 Notice of Filing 18-19 Designation of Emailing Addresses 08/31/2021 Plaintiff's General 20 - 28 Personal Injury Negligence Interrogatories to Defendant 08/31/2021 Plaintiff's Request for 29 - 33 Production 08/31/2021 Plaintiff's First 34-35 Request for Admissions 08/31/2021 Notice of Video 36 - 37 Deposition 09/27/2021 Notice of Filing 38 - 39 Designation of Emailing Addresses 09/27/2021 Defendant's Answer & 40 - 45 Affirmative Defenses 09/27/2021 Defendant's 46 - 49 Response to First Request for Admissions 09/28/2021 Notice of 50-51 Unavailability 10/11/2021 Re-Notice of Taking 52 - 53 Deposition 10/12/2021 Defendant's First 54 - 58 Request for Admissions 10/12/2021 Defendant's First 59 - 64 Request to Produce 10/12/2021 Defendant's 65 - 70 Medicare/C ollateral Source Requestto Produce 10/21/2021 Defendant's Motion 71-72 for Extension of Time to Respond to Discovery 11/08/2021 Agreed Order on 73 - 74 Defendant's Motion for Extension of Time to Respond to Plaintiff's Discovery 11/12/2021 Plaintiff's Motion for 75 - 76 Enlargement of Time to Respond to Defendant's Discovery 11/22/2021 Notice of Service of 77-78 Answers to Interrogatories 11/22/2021 Defendant's 79 - 84 Response to First Request for Production 11/22/2021 Defendant's Privilege 85 - 87 Log 12/01/2021 Agreed Order on 88 - 89 Plaintiff's Motion for Enlargement of Time to Respond to Defendant's Discovery 12/06/2021 Second Re-Notice of 90-91 Taking Deposition 01/06/2022 Uniform Case 92-94 Management Order 01/21/2022 Plaintiff's Response 95 - 98 to Defendant's Request for Admissions 01/21/2022 Third Re-Notice of 99 - 100 Taking Deposition 01/29/2022 Defendant's Notice of 101 - 103 Taking Deposition 02/03/2022 Defendant's Motion 104 - 112 for Order to Show Cause, Compel Compliance With Court Order and For Sanctions 02/04/2022 Uniform Order Setting 113 - 119 Pretrial Deadline 02/14/2022 Defendant's Motion to 120 - 120 Compel Discovery 02/14/2022 Order on Plaintiff's 121-121 Motion to Compel Discovery 03/03/2022 Notice of Service of 122 - 122 Answers to Interrogatories 03/03/2022 Notice of Service of 123 - 123 Answers to Interrogatories 03/03/2022 Plaintiff's Response 124 - 130 to Defendant's First Request for Production 03/03/2022 Plaintiff's Response 131 - 135 to Defendant's Medicare/C ollateral Source Request for Production 05/13/2022 Fourth Re-Notice of 136 - 137 Taking Deposition 06/03/2022 Plaintiff's Second 138 - 138 Request for Production of Documents 07/01/2022 Defendant's 139-141 Response to Plaintiff's Second Request for Production 07/01/2022 Defendant's Privilege 142 - 145 Log 07/18/2022 Defendant's Motion 146 - 263 for Sanctions for Spoliation of Evidence 08/08/2022 Notice of 264 - 264 Unavailability 11/30/2022 Defendant's Motion to 265 - 267 Extend Pretrial Deadlines 12/01/2022 Defendant's Exhibit 268 - 271 List 12/01/2022 Defendant's Witness 272 - 275 List 12/01/2022 Defendant's Motion 276 - 410 for Final Summary J udgment and Memorandum of Law in Support Thereof 12/01/2022 Notice of 411 - 421 Propounding Interrogatories 12/01/2022 Defendant's 422 - 427 Supplemental/Update Request for Production 12/01/2022 Defendant's Motion in 428 - 437 Limine Regarding Prejudicial Topics and Matters for Trial 12/01/2022 Defendant's Motion in 438 - 450 Limine to Prevent Plaintiff's Treating Physicians from Testifying as to Causation 12/01/2022 Defendant's Motion in 451 - 455 Limine to Preclude Plaintiff's Experts From Testifying as to Matters and/or Opinions Not Previously Disclosed 01/05/2023 Notice of Hearing 456 - 457 1/11/22 01/11/2023 Order Resetting Trial 458 - 459 01/18/2023 Notice of Video 460 - 461 Deposition 01/25/2023 Notice of Hearing 462 - 463 3/8/23 01/25/2023 Notice of Amended 464 - 465 Special Set Hearing 3/8/23 02/01/2023 Notice of Mediation 466 - 468 02/02/2023 Defendant's 469 - 472 Statement of Material Facts in Support of Defendant's Motion for Summary J udgment 02/16/2023 Plaintiff's Notice of 473 - 473 Filing Adverse Evidence in Opposition of Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment 02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 474 - 504 Exhibit 1 02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 505 - 545 Exhibit 2 02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 546 - 557 Exhibit3 02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 558 - 561 Exhibit 4 02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 562 - 566 Exhibit 5 02/16/2023 Plaintiff's Response 567 - 576 in Opposition to Motion for Final Summary J udgment 02/24/2023 Order Resetting Trial 577 - 578 03/08/2023 Second Amended 579 - 580 Notice of Special Set Hearing 3/13/23 03/08/2023 Third Amended 581 - 582 Notice of Special Set Hearing 3/13/23 03/17/2023 Final Summary 583 - 585 Judgment 03/28/2023 Plaintiff's Motion for 586 - 631 Reconsideration 04/14/2023 Defendant's Motion 632 - 642 for Entitlement to Attorney Fees and Costs, Subjectto Defendant's Rejected Proposal for Settlement 04/28/2023 Plaintiff's Notice of 643 - 675 Filing Transcript of March 13, 2023 Hearing on Motion for Reconsideration 05/10/2023 Order on Plaintiff's 676 - 677 Motion for Reconsideration Filed March 28, 2023 06/08/2023 Notice of Appeal 678 - 680 06/09/2023 Amended Notice of 681 - 686 Appeal 06/21/2023 Directions to the 687 - 688 Clerk 07/12/2023 Notice of Filing 689 - 715 Transcripts for Inclusion in Record on Appeal BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS PROGRESS DOCKET CASE NO. CACE-21-016576 Aaron Bruner Location: Civil Plaintiff Judicial Officer: Olefson, Shari Africk vs. Filed on: 08/31/2021 4th District Court of 4D23-1412 Bonnie Judson Appeals: Defendant Divisional Assignment: 25 Uniform Case Number: 062021CA016576AXXXCE CASE INFORMATION Statistical Closures 03/17/2023 Disposed by Judge Case Type: Neg - Premises Liability Residential Case 04/14/2023 Reopened - CV Status: Case Flags: Appeal ‘iled Jury Trial DATE CASE ASSIGNMENT Current Case Assignment Case Number CACE-21-016576 Court Civil Date Assigned 08/31/2021 Judicial Officer Olefson, Shari Africk PARTY INFORMATION Lead Attorneys Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron Duffy, Vincent 1630 West Hillsboro Boulevard Retained Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 954-428-9338(F) 954-428-9333(W) 1630 West Hillsboro Blvd Deerfield Beach, FL 33442 service.duffy@gdinjurylaw.com Defendant Judson, Bonnie Pita, Brian Scott 5299 N. Springs "ER Retained Coral Springs, FL 33076 561-683-8977(F) 561-383-9200(W) Cole, Scott & Ki sane, P.A. 222 Lakeview Av Ste 120 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 brian.pita@ legal.com DATE EVENTS & ORDERS OF THE COURT DISPOSITIONS 03/17/2023 Final Summary Judgment Comment (IN FAVOR OF BONNIE JUDSON) EVENTS 07/12/2023 Notice of Filing 06/21/2023 Directions to the Clerk PAGE | OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS PROGRESS DOCKET CASE NO. CACE-21-016576 Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 06/09/2023 Amended Notice of Appeal Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 06/09/2023 4th DCA Order Within ten 10 days ‘from the date of this order, appellant shall submit a conformed copy of the underlying orde which is the subject of the motion for rehearing for the purpose of determining whether the 06/09/2023 4th DCA Order ORDERED that appellant shall pay the $300.00 filing fee or file the lower tribunal clerk's determination of indigent status in this court within ten CIO) days from the date of this ordei 06/09/2023 Acknowledgment 4D23-1412//TD 06/08/2023 Notice of Appeal Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 05/10/2023 Order ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION. FILED MARCH 28.2023 04/28/2023 Notice of Filing 04/14/2023 Motion 03/28/2023 Motion for Order FOR RECONSMERATION Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 03/08/2023 Amended Notice of Hearing 03/08/2023 ‘Amended Notice of Hearing 02/24/2023 Order Resetting trial 02/16/2023 Response to Motion for Judgment Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 02/16/2023 Notice of Filing 02/02/2023 Statement of Facts 02/01/2023 Notice of Mediation 01/25/2023 Notice of Hearing 01/25/2023 Notice of Hearing 01/20/2023 Subpoena Retumed Served on the 19th day of January, 2023 at 11:48 am-R/C YEHUDA FISHFELD-(JANICE G)- AS SECRETARY AUTHORIZED TO ACCEPT SERVICE FOR R/C YEHUDA FISHFELD 01/19/2023 Subpoena Returned Served PAGE 2 OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS PROGRESS DOCKET CASE NO. CACE-21-016576 R/C LAUDERDALE LAKES HEALTH CENTER / 01/18/2023 01/19/2023 Subpoena Returned Served R/C CORA E. BRAYNON FAMILY HEALTH CENTER / 01/18/2023 01/18/2023 Notice of Video Deposition 01/13/2023 Certificate of No Objection 01/12/2023 Request for Copies (Pursuant to Rule 1.351) 01/12/2023 Notice of Production From Non-Party 01/11/2023 Order Resetting trial 01/05/2023 Notice of Hearing 12/01/2022 Motion in Limine TO PRECLUDE PLAINTIFF'S EXPERTS FROM TESTIFYING AS TO MATTERS AND/OR OPINIONS NOT PREVIOUSLY DISCLOSED Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 12/01/2022 Motion in Limine TO PREVENT PLAINTIFF'S REATING PHYSICIANS FROM TESTIFYING AS TO CAUSATION Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 12/01/2022 Motion in Limine REGARDING PREJUDICIAL TOPICS AND MATTERS FOR TRIAL Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 12/01/2022 Request for Production TO PLAINTIFF Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 12/01/2022 Notice of Propounding Interrogatories TO PLAINTIFF Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 12/01/2022 Motion for Summary Judgment Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 12/01/2022 Witness List Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 12/01/2022 UL Exhibit List Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 12/01/2022 Notice of Serving Proposal for Settlement 11/30/2022 Motion for Extension of Time 08/08/2022 Notice of Unavailability 07/20/2022 Appearance As Attomey of Record INNA KRESLAVSKAYA FI Bar No.: 1025519 Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 07/18/2022 Motion for Sanctions FOR SPOLIATION OF EVIDENCE Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 07/01/2022 Privilege Log PAGE 3 OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS PROGRESS DOCKET CASE NO. CACE-21-016576 07/01/2022 Response to Request for Production 06/03/2022 Request for Production of Documents 05/13/2022 Re-Notice of Taking Deposition 05/04/2022 Notice of Cancellation 03/03/2022 Response to Request for Production 03/03/2022 Response to Request for Production 03/03/2022 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories 03/03/2022 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories 02/14/2022 Order ON PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY 02/14/2022 Order on Motion to Compel discovery 02/04/2022 Uniform Order Setting Pretrial Deadline 01-12-2023 at 10:00 AM 02/03/2022 Motion for Order to Show Cause COMPEL COMPLIANCE WITH COURT ORDER AND FOR SANCTIONS. Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 01/29/2022 Notice of Taking Deposition 01/21/2022 Re-Notice of Taking Deposition 01/21/2022 Notice of Cancellation 01/21/2022 Response to Request for Admissions 01/06/2022 Case Management Order 02-04-2022 10:00 AM 12/06/2021 Re-Notice of Taking Deposition 12/01/2021 Order Extending Time TO RESPOND TO DISCOVERY 11/22/2021 Privilege Log 11/22/2021 Response to Request for Production 11/22/2021 Notice of Service of Answers to Interrogatories 11/12/2021 Motion for Enlargement of Time TO RESPOND TO DEFENDANT'S DISCOVERY Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 11/08/2021 Order Extending Time 11/04/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served 11/02/2021 Subpoena Returned Served WINDSOR IMAGING 11/02/2021 Subpoena Retumed Served PETER F. MERKLE MD 11/02/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served PAGE 4 OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS PROGRESS DOCKET CASE NO. CACE-21-016576 11/02/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served 10/28/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served 10/28/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served 10/28/2021 Subpoena Duces Tecum W/O Deposition Returned Served 10/25/2021 Certificate of No Objection 10/21/2021 Motion for Extension of Time TO RESPOND TO DISCOVERY Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 10/13/2021 Request for Copies (Pursuant to Rule 1.351) Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 10/13/2021 Notice of Production From Non-Party 10/12/2021 Request to Produce 10/12/2021 Request to Produce 10/12/2021 Request for Admissions 10/12/2021 Notice of Service of Interrogs 10/12/2021 Notice of Service of Interrogs 10/11/2021 Re-Notice of Taking Deposition 10/06/2021 Notice of Cancellation 09/28/2021 Notice of Unavailability 09/27/2021 Response to Request for Admissions Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 09/27/2021 Answer & Affirmative Defenses Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 09/27/2021 Notice of Filing Designation of Emailing Addresses DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF DESIGNATION OF E-MAIL ADDRESSES 09/27/2021 Notice of Appearance Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 09/10/2021 Summons Returned Served 09/07/21 Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 08/31/2021 Notice of Video Deposition Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 08/31/2021 Request for Admissions Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 08/31/2021 Request for Production Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 08/31/2021 Interrogatories Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 08/31/2021 Notice of Filing Designation of Emailing Addresses Service. Duff@gdinjurylaw.com PAGE 5 OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM BRENDA D. FORMAN, BROWARD COUNTY CLERK OF COURTS PROGRESS DOCKET CASE NO. CACE-21-016576 08/31/2021 eSummons Issuance Party: Defendant Judson, Bonnie 08/31/2021 Complaint (eFiled) FOR DAMAGES Party: Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron 08/31/2021 Civil Cover Sheet Amount: 00,001.00 08/31/2021 Per AOSC20-23 Amd12, Case is determined General DATE FINANCIAL INFORMATION Plaintiff Bruner, Aaron Total Charges 511.00 Total Payments and Credits 511.00 Balance Due as of 7/25/2023 0.00 PAGE 6 OF 6 Printed on 07/25/2023 at 10:09 AM 17™ JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY CERTIFICATE OF THE CLERK AARON BRUNER APPELLANT CASE NO.: CACE 21-16576 vs BONNIE JUDSON APPELLEE APPEAL NO.: 4D23-1412 |, Brenda D. Forman, Clerk of the Circuit Court, 17" Judicial Circuit for the County of Broward, State of Florida, do hereby certify that the foregoing pages 15 to 715 , contain a true and correct copy of all such pleadings and proceedings in said cause as appears from the records and _ files of my office that have been directed to be included in said record. Pages to Inclusive embrace the transcribed notes of the reporter as made at the trial and certified to me by them. In witness whereof, | have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of said court this 25th dayof July , 2023. Brenda D. Forman, Clerk Circuit Court Florida Broward County, BY: Temarah Daley Deputy Clerk 954-831-5699 201 SE 6th St., Rm. 4140 Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33301 tdaley@browardclerk.org