Preview
LEWIS BRISBOIS BISGAARD & SMITH LLP
JOHN S. LOWENTHAL, SB# 120628
E-Mail: John.Lowenthal@lewisbrisbois.com
TRACI WHALEY PATINO, SB# 2075 12
E—Mail: Traci.Patino@lewisbrisbois.com
UIhDJN
PEYTON M. JONES, SB# 337268
E-Mail: Peyton.Jones@lewisbrisbois.com
650 East Hospitality Lane, Suite 600
San Bemardino, California 92408
COUNTY
2023
Telephone: 909.387.1 130
COURT
ax
Facsimile: 909.387.] 138
8 :3
fiE©EflVE® 2 BERNARDWO
\1
Attorneys for Defendant, FIRST STUDENT, INC. w
SUPERIOR
MAR
oo 03x
SAN
\o SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
Hc COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO
»— H AALIYAH JONES, a minor by and through CASE NO. CIVDS 1935553
her Guardian Ad Litem, ANNETTE (c/w Case No. CIV SB 2027673)
p— N LONDON,
[Assigned for All Purposes t0:
u—n
m Plaintiff, The Hon. Corey G. Lee, Dept. Sl 5]
p— A vs. ORDER RE: DEFENDANT
[-PROPOSEfl]
MOTION FOR
FIRST STUDENT, INC.’S
H u: FIRST STUDENT, INC., a Delaware SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, IN THE
corporation, EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY
y—
ax
OF WARREN EDWARD JACKSON, an ADJUDICATION
individual, and DOES 1-20,
r—n \I
Defendant. Hearing Date: 2/23/23
n— oo Time: 8:30 A.M.
Dept: $15
u—n
\o SKYLIN JACKSON, a minor by and through
her guardian ad litem Carla Randolph,
Nc
Plaintiff,
N ¢—
vs.
NN
FIRST STUDENT, INC., a Delaware
Nw corporation; NINA MACIAS, an individual;
and DOES through 25, Inclusive,
1
NA
Defendants.
N u-
N ax
N \1 ///
N oo ///
LEWIS 913716401
BRISBOIS
BISGAARD
&s~In-I LLP
ATTORNEVS AT LAW
WOMER RE: DEFENDANT FIRST STUDENT,
OR, IN
INC.’S MOTION FOR SUMIVIARY JUDGMENT
THE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION
TO ALL PARTIES HEREIN AND TO THEIR RESPECTIVE ATTORNEYS OF
RECORD:
Oon February 23, 2023, at 8:30 a.m. this matter was called for hearing in Department $15,
of the San Bernardino Superior Court, Judge Corey G. Lee, Presiding.
\DWQQUIfiDJNH
Having considered all of the papers and evidence submitted in support of and in opposition
t0 this Motion, having considered all relevant authorities, and having heard oral argument from
counsel, the Court hereby grants Defendant FIRST STUDENT, INC.’S Motion for Summary
Judgment in its entirety. The Court finds that there is n0 triable issue 0f material fact with regard to
the issue of causation as raised in Defendant FIRST STUDENT, INC.’s Motion for Summary
Judgment, or in the alternative Motion for Summary Adjudication and Defendant FIRST
STUDENT, INC. is entitled to judgment as a matter 0f law, against all Plaintiffs, as set forth in the
Court’s ruling, attached hereto as Exhibit A.
Based on the foregoing, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED that
FIRST STUDENT INC.’S Motion for Summary Judgment is GRANTED.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
NNNNNNNNNHr—tr—I—t—Hr—AHHH
DATED: flédfl! g: 20%;
kéA
Hon. Corey Gfl
Judge of the Superior Court
Corey G. Lee
manI-BDJNt—OVOQOQQUIAMNHG
LEWIS 91371640.]
2
BRISBOIS
BISGAARD
&SMIH Lu=
ATTORNEVS AT LAW
WORDER RE: DEFENDANT FIRST STUDENT, 1NC.’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE SUNIMARY ADJUDICATION
Preview
LEWIS BRISBOIS BISGAARD & SMITH LLP JOHN S. LOWENTHAL, SB# 120628 E-Mail: John.Lowenthal@lewisbrisbois.com TRACI WHALEY PATINO, SB# 2075 12 E—Mail: Traci.Patino@lewisbrisbois.com UIhDJN PEYTON M. JONES, SB# 337268 E-Mail: Peyton.Jones@lewisbrisbois.com 650 East Hospitality Lane, Suite 600 San Bemardino, California 92408 COUNTY 2023 Telephone: 909.387.1 130 COURT ax Facsimile: 909.387.] 138 8 :3 fiE©EflVE® 2 BERNARDWO \1 Attorneys for Defendant, FIRST STUDENT, INC. w SUPERIOR MAR oo 03x SAN \o SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA Hc COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO »— H AALIYAH JONES, a minor by and through CASE NO. CIVDS 1935553 her Guardian Ad Litem, ANNETTE (c/w Case No. CIV SB 2027673) p— N LONDON, [Assigned for All Purposes t0: u—n m Plaintiff, The Hon. Corey G. Lee, Dept. Sl 5] p— A vs. ORDER RE: DEFENDANT [-PROPOSEfl] MOTION FOR FIRST STUDENT, INC.’S H u: FIRST STUDENT, INC., a Delaware SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, IN THE corporation, EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY y— ax OF WARREN EDWARD JACKSON, an ADJUDICATION individual, and DOES 1-20, r—n \I Defendant. Hearing Date: 2/23/23 n— oo Time: 8:30 A.M. Dept: $15 u—n \o SKYLIN JACKSON, a minor by and through her guardian ad litem Carla Randolph, Nc Plaintiff, N ¢— vs. NN FIRST STUDENT, INC., a Delaware Nw corporation; NINA MACIAS, an individual; and DOES through 25, Inclusive, 1 NA Defendants. N u- N ax N \1 /// N oo /// LEWIS 913716401 BRISBOIS BISGAARD &s~In-I LLP ATTORNEVS AT LAW WOMER RE: DEFENDANT FIRST STUDENT, OR, IN INC.’S MOTION FOR SUMIVIARY JUDGMENT THE ALTERNATIVE SUMMARY ADJUDICATION TO ALL PARTIES HEREIN AND TO THEIR RESPECTIVE ATTORNEYS OF RECORD: Oon February 23, 2023, at 8:30 a.m. this matter was called for hearing in Department $15, of the San Bernardino Superior Court, Judge Corey G. Lee, Presiding. \DWQQUIfiDJNH Having considered all of the papers and evidence submitted in support of and in opposition t0 this Motion, having considered all relevant authorities, and having heard oral argument from counsel, the Court hereby grants Defendant FIRST STUDENT, INC.’S Motion for Summary Judgment in its entirety. The Court finds that there is n0 triable issue 0f material fact with regard to the issue of causation as raised in Defendant FIRST STUDENT, INC.’s Motion for Summary Judgment, or in the alternative Motion for Summary Adjudication and Defendant FIRST STUDENT, INC. is entitled to judgment as a matter 0f law, against all Plaintiffs, as set forth in the Court’s ruling, attached hereto as Exhibit A. Based on the foregoing, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED and DECREED that FIRST STUDENT INC.’S Motion for Summary Judgment is GRANTED. IT IS SO ORDERED. NNNNNNNNNHr—tr—I—t—Hr—AHHH DATED: flédfl! g: 20%; kéA Hon. Corey Gfl Judge of the Superior Court Corey G. Lee manI-BDJNt—OVOQOQQUIAMNHG LEWIS 91371640.] 2 BRISBOIS BISGAARD &SMIH Lu= ATTORNEVS AT LAW WORDER RE: DEFENDANT FIRST STUDENT, 1NC.’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR, IN THE ALTERNATIVE SUNIMARY ADJUDICATION