On May 27, 2016 a
Trial Materials
was filed
involving a dispute between
Attorney General Of Texas,
Gupta, Atul Kumar,
Jain, Vibha,
and
Gupta, Atul Kumar,
Jain, Vibha,
for Divorce - With Children
in the District Court of Fort Bend County.
Preview
Filed
7/26/2023 3:03 PM
Beverley McGrew Walker
District Clerk
Fort Bend County, Texas
Kiara Fears
NO. 16-DCV-232,757
IN THE INTEREST OF IN THE DISTRICT COURT
a
A CHILD
328TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
FORT BEND COUNTY, TEXAS
RESPONDENT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
NO. DESCRIPTION Oo A D NOTES
R-1 Respondent’s Proposed Parenting Plan
R-2 Respondent’s Financial Information Statement
R-3 Respondent’s Proposed Child Support Findings
(Mother as obligor)
R-4 Respondent’s Proposed Child Support Findings
(Father as obligor)
R-5 Respondent’s Payroll Statements Pay Date 6/15/23
R-6 Respondent’s 2022 Income Tax Return
R-7 Petitioner’s Payroll Statements Pay Date 5/26/23
R-8 Petitioner’s 2022 Income Tax Return
R-9 Photo — Holiday October 2022 Dated 1.20.23
R-10 Photo — Activity October 2022 RESP 000884
R-1l Photo — Family October 2022 RESP 000885
R-12 Photo — Zoo October 2022 RESP 000886
R-13 Photo — Jones Hall November 2022 RESP 000888
R-14 Photo — Friend November 2022 RESP 000892
R-15 Photo — Christmas December 2022 RESP 000893
R-16 Photo — Hotel December 2022 RESP 000896
R-17 Photo — Jeep December 2022 RESP 000901
NO DESCRIPTION oO A D NOTES
R-18 Photo — Zipline December 2022 RESP 000903
R-19 Photo — Halloween October 2020 RESP 000241
R-20 Photo — London June 2021 RESP 000249
R-21 Photo — Mother and Son June 2021 RESP 000254
R-22 Photo — Blue Lagoon November 2022 RESP 000289
R-23 Photo — Hollywood March 2022 RESP 000293
R-24 Photo — Reading March 2022 RESP 000298
R-25 Photo — Library April 2022 RESP 000301
R-26 Photo — Painting May 2022 RESP 000303
R-27 Photo — Bowling July 2022 RESP 000311
R-28 Photo — School Teacher August 2022 RESP 000314
R-29 Photo — Karate September 2022 RESP 000320
R-30 Photo — Cell Phone RESP 000660
R-31 Screenshot — Hurricane RESP 000663 — 000665
R-32 Screenshot — Switch Times RESP 000666 — 000669
R-33 Screenshot — Brains Class RESP 000670 — 000672
R-34 Screenshot — Late Visit Oct. RESP 000673
R-35 Screenshot — Late Visit Nov. RESP 000674
R-36 Screenshot — Birthday Interruption RESP 000675
R-37 Screenshot — Miss Call May 7" RESP 000678
R-38 Screenshot — Miss Call May 15" RESP 000679
R-39 Screenshot — Miss Call May 234 RESP 000680
R40 Our Family Wizard Calendar (OF W) RESP 000911- 000974
NO DESCRIPTION oO A D NOTES
R-41 OFW Message 10.6.21 RESP 001000
R-42 OFW Message 6.17.21 RESP 001013 - 001014
R-43 OFW Message 6.21.21 RESP 001030
R44 OFW Message 6.22.21 RESP 001032
R-45 OFW Message 7.2.21 RESP 001041
R-46 OFW Message 7.19.21 RESP 001048
R-47 OFW Message 7.31.21 RESP 001053
R-48 OFW Message 8.30.21 RESP 001125 - 001126
R-49 OFW Message 9.6.21 RESP 001134
- 001135
R-50 OFW Message 9.11.21 RESP 0001138
R-S51 OFW Message 9.14.21 RESP 001142
R-52 OFW Message 9.17.21 RESP 001151
R-53 OFW Message 10.25.21 RESP 001166
- 001169
R-54 OFW Message 11.9.21 RESP 001225 - 001227
R-55 OFW Message 11.12.21 RESP 001249
RESP 001252
R-56 OFW Message 11.19.21 RESP 001258 - 001259
R-57 OFW Message 12.3.21 RESP 001292 - 001293
R-58 OFW Message 12.4.21 RESP 001315 - 001317
R-59 OFW Message 12.5.21 RESP 001338
R-60 OFW Message 12.11.21 RESP 001341 - 001342
R-61 OFW Message 12.20.21 RESP 001352
R-62 OFW Message 12.27.21 RESP 001361 - 001363
R - 63 OFW Message 12.28.21 RESP 001375
NO DESCRIPTION oO A D NOTES
R-64 OFW Message 1.2.22 RESP 001384 - 001385
R-65 OFW Message 1.3.22 RESP 001388 and
001389
R- 66 OFW Message 1.31.22 RESP 001395
R-67 OFW Message 2.16.22 RESP 001406
R-68 OFW Message 2.21.22 RESP 001418 - 001419
R-69 OFW Message 2.26.22 RESP 001431
R-70 OFW Message 3.1.22 RESP 001440 - 001441
R-71 OFW Message 3.5.22 RESP 001484
R-72 OFW Message 3.5.22 RESP 001486 — 001487
And 001491-001492
R-73 OFW Message 3.8.22 RESP 001509 - 001511
R-74 OFW Message 3.8.22 RESP 001508
R-75 OFW Message 3.11.22 RESP 001538
R-76 OFW Message 4.15.22 RESP 001558
R-77 OFW Message 4.19.22 RESP 001574
R-78 OFW Message 4.25.22 RESP 001584
R-79 OFW Message 4.28.22 RESP 001601 - 001602
R-80 OFW Message 4.30.22 RESP 001608
R-81 OFW Message 5.9.22 RESP 001653 - 001654
R-82 OFW Message 5.20.22 (1) RESP 001683 - 001684
R-83 OFW Message 5.20.22 (2) RESP 001694
R-84 OFW Message 6.16.22 RESP 001701
R-85 OFW Message 7.21.22 RESP 001711 - 001712
R-86 OFW Message 8.20.22 RESP 001724
NO DESCRIPTION oO A D NOTES
R-87 OFW Message 8.26.22 RESP 001729
R-88 OFW Message 8.31.22 and 9.6.22 RESP 001730 -001732
and 001751
R-89 OFW Message 9.15.22 RESP 001763 - 001764
R-90 OFW Message 10.29.22 RESP 001796
R-91 OFW Message 12.11.22 RESP 001836 - 001838
R-92 OFW Message 1.8.23 RESP 001895 and
001897 - 001898
R-93 OFW Message 1.26.23 RESP 001910 - 001911
R-94 OFW Message 3.16.23 RESP 001942
R-95 OFW Message 3.20.23 RESP 001947
R-96 OFW Message 4.24.23 RESP 001992 - 001993
R-97 OFW Message 5.9.23 RESP 002001
R-98 OFW Message 5.23.23 RESP 002026
R-99 OFW Message 6.4.23 RESP 002033
R-100 OFW Message 6.5.23 RESP 002036 - 002037
R-101 Marriage Certificate (Petitioner)
R-102 Petitioner’s Answers to Interrogatories Dated 1.20.23
R- 103 Mom - Medical and Dental Cost RESP 000236 — 000240
R-104 Dad — Medical Dental Vision Cost
R-105 Agreed Final Decree of Divorce Signed 5/4/2017
R—- 106 Agreed Child Support Review Order Signed 1/4/2018
R-107 Agreed Final Order in Suit to Modify Parent- Singed 6/4/2021
Child Relationship
R—- 108 Agreed Order for Counseling and Electronic Signed 2/12/2023
Communication
NO. DESCRIPTION Oo A D NOTES
R-109 Attorney Representation Agreement RESP 000682 - 000686
R-110 Attorney Billing Statements RESP 1-6; 687-692;
904-910; and 002090 —
002095.
R-1lll Video RESP 000681
R—112
R-113
R-114
R-115
R-116
R-117
R—-118
R-119
R-120
Respectfully Submitted,
Law Office of Christine R. Thrash, PLLC
440 Louisiana Street, Suite 900
Houston, Texas 77002
Tel: (713) 224-7777
Fax: (877) 308-6443
Email: Christine@ThrashLawTexas.com
By: lel ChristineR. Thrash
Christine R. Thrash
State Bar No. 24033271
Attorney for Respondent
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
1 certify that a true copy of the above was served on each attorney of record or
party in accordance with the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure on July 26, 2023.
Ronald Muller
State Bar No. 14649100
6300 West Loop South, Suite 340
Bellaire, Texas 77401
Tel: (713) 271-8282
Fax: (713) 271-2112
Email: muller@rsmlegalteam.com
VIA ELECTRONIC SERVICE
Attorney for Petitioner
Stacy Schnitzer McCarty
State Bar No. 24041881
711 Morton Street
Richmond, Texas 77469
Tel: (281) 633-9919
Fax: (281) 232-9915
Email: stacymecarty@gmail.com
VIA ELECTRONIC SERVICE
Amicus Attorney
Stephanie Truong
State Bar No. 24070451
Office of the Attorney General
Child Support Division
117 Lane Drive, Ste. 7
Rosenberg, Texas 77471
Tel: (800) 252-8014
Fax: (281) 239-4800
Email: CSD-legal-605@texasattorneygeneral.gov
VIA ELECTRONIC SERVICE
Interested Party
lol ChristineR. Thrash
Christine R. Thrash
Attorney for Respondent
Automated Certificate of eService
This automated certificate of service was created by the efiling system.
The filer served this document via email generated by the efiling system
on the date and to the persons listed below. The rules governing
certificates of service have not changed. Filers must still provide a
certificate of service that complies with all applicable rules.
Christine Thrash on behalf of Christine Thrash
Bar No. 24033271
christinethrash@sbcglobal.net
Envelope ID: 77912716
Filing Code Description: No Fee Documents
Filing Description: Respondent's Trial Witness List
Status as of 7/27/2023 8:07 AM CST
Associated Case ro’
Name BarNumber | Email TimestampSubmitted | Status
Stacy SchnitzerMcCarty stacymccarty@ymail.com | 7/26/2023 3:03:47 PM | SENT
Associated Case Party: Attorney General of Texas
Name BarNumber | Email TimestampSubmitted | Status
Stephanie Truong | 24070451 CSD-legal-1003@oag.texas.gov | 7/26/2023 3:03:47 PM | SENT
Case Contacts
Name BarNumber | Email TimestampSubmitted | Status
Ronald C. Muller | 14649100 muller@rsmlegalteam.com | 7/26/2023 3:03:47 PM | SENT
Document Filed Date
July 26, 2023
Case Filing Date
May 27, 2016
Category
Divorce - With Children
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
Filed 7/26/2023 3:03 PM Beverley McGrew Walker District Clerk Fort Bend County, Texas Kiara Fears NO. 16-DCV-232,757 IN THE INTEREST OF IN THE DISTRICT COURT a A CHILD 328TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT FORT BEND COUNTY, TEXAS RESPONDENT’S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST NO. DESCRIPTION Oo A D NOTES R-1 Respondent’s Proposed Parenting Plan R-2 Respondent’s Financial Information Statement R-3 Respondent’s Proposed Child Support Findings (Mother as obligor) R-4 Respondent’s Proposed Child Support Findings (Father as obligor) R-5 Respondent’s Payroll Statements Pay Date 6/15/23 R-6 Respondent’s 2022 Income Tax Return R-7 Petitioner’s Payroll Statements Pay Date 5/26/23 R-8 Petitioner’s 2022 Income Tax Return R-9 Photo — Holiday October 2022 Dated 1.20.23 R-10 Photo — Activity October 2022 RESP 000884 R-1l Photo — Family October 2022 RESP 000885 R-12 Photo — Zoo October 2022 RESP 000886 R-13 Photo — Jones Hall November 2022 RESP 000888 R-14 Photo — Friend November 2022 RESP 000892 R-15 Photo — Christmas December 2022 RESP 000893 R-16 Photo — Hotel December 2022 RESP 000896 R-17 Photo — Jeep December 2022 RESP 000901 NO DESCRIPTION oO A D NOTES R-18 Photo — Zipline December 2022 RESP 000903 R-19 Photo — Halloween October 2020 RESP 000241 R-20 Photo — London June 2021 RESP 000249 R-21 Photo — Mother and Son June 2021 RESP 000254 R-22 Photo — Blue Lagoon November 2022 RESP 000289 R-23 Photo — Hollywood March 2022 RESP 000293 R-24 Photo — Reading March 2022 RESP 000298 R-25 Photo — Library April 2022 RESP 000301 R-26 Photo — Painting May 2022 RESP 000303 R-27 Photo — Bowling July 2022 RESP 000311 R-28 Photo — School Teacher August 2022 RESP 000314 R-29 Photo — Karate September 2022 RESP 000320 R-30 Photo — Cell Phone RESP 000660 R-31 Screenshot — Hurricane RESP 000663 — 000665 R-32 Screenshot — Switch Times RESP 000666 — 000669 R-33 Screenshot — Brains Class RESP 000670 — 000672 R-34 Screenshot — Late Visit Oct. RESP 000673 R-35 Screenshot — Late Visit Nov. RESP 000674 R-36 Screenshot — Birthday Interruption RESP 000675 R-37 Screenshot — Miss Call May 7" RESP 000678 R-38 Screenshot — Miss Call May 15" RESP 000679 R-39 Screenshot — Miss Call May 234 RESP 000680 R40 Our Family Wizard Calendar (OF W) RESP 000911- 000974 NO DESCRIPTION oO A D NOTES R-41 OFW Message 10.6.21 RESP 001000 R-42 OFW Message 6.17.21 RESP 001013 - 001014 R-43 OFW Message 6.21.21 RESP 001030 R44 OFW Message 6.22.21 RESP 001032 R-45 OFW Message 7.2.21 RESP 001041 R-46 OFW Message 7.19.21 RESP 001048 R-47 OFW Message 7.31.21 RESP 001053 R-48 OFW Message 8.30.21 RESP 001125 - 001126 R-49 OFW Message 9.6.21 RESP 001134 - 001135 R-50 OFW Message 9.11.21 RESP 0001138 R-S51 OFW Message 9.14.21 RESP 001142 R-52 OFW Message 9.17.21 RESP 001151 R-53 OFW Message 10.25.21 RESP 001166 - 001169 R-54 OFW Message 11.9.21 RESP 001225 - 001227 R-55 OFW Message 11.12.21 RESP 001249 RESP 001252 R-56 OFW Message 11.19.21 RESP 001258 - 001259 R-57 OFW Message 12.3.21 RESP 001292 - 001293 R-58 OFW Message 12.4.21 RESP 001315 - 001317 R-59 OFW Message 12.5.21 RESP 001338 R-60 OFW Message 12.11.21 RESP 001341 - 001342 R-61 OFW Message 12.20.21 RESP 001352 R-62 OFW Message 12.27.21 RESP 001361 - 001363 R - 63 OFW Message 12.28.21 RESP 001375 NO DESCRIPTION oO A D NOTES R-64 OFW Message 1.2.22 RESP 001384 - 001385 R-65 OFW Message 1.3.22 RESP 001388 and 001389 R- 66 OFW Message 1.31.22 RESP 001395 R-67 OFW Message 2.16.22 RESP 001406 R-68 OFW Message 2.21.22 RESP 001418 - 001419 R-69 OFW Message 2.26.22 RESP 001431 R-70 OFW Message 3.1.22 RESP 001440 - 001441 R-71 OFW Message 3.5.22 RESP 001484 R-72 OFW Message 3.5.22 RESP 001486 — 001487 And 001491-001492 R-73 OFW Message 3.8.22 RESP 001509 - 001511 R-74 OFW Message 3.8.22 RESP 001508 R-75 OFW Message 3.11.22 RESP 001538 R-76 OFW Message 4.15.22 RESP 001558 R-77 OFW Message 4.19.22 RESP 001574 R-78 OFW Message 4.25.22 RESP 001584 R-79 OFW Message 4.28.22 RESP 001601 - 001602 R-80 OFW Message 4.30.22 RESP 001608 R-81 OFW Message 5.9.22 RESP 001653 - 001654 R-82 OFW Message 5.20.22 (1) RESP 001683 - 001684 R-83 OFW Message 5.20.22 (2) RESP 001694 R-84 OFW Message 6.16.22 RESP 001701 R-85 OFW Message 7.21.22 RESP 001711 - 001712 R-86 OFW Message 8.20.22 RESP 001724 NO DESCRIPTION oO A D NOTES R-87 OFW Message 8.26.22 RESP 001729 R-88 OFW Message 8.31.22 and 9.6.22 RESP 001730 -001732 and 001751 R-89 OFW Message 9.15.22 RESP 001763 - 001764 R-90 OFW Message 10.29.22 RESP 001796 R-91 OFW Message 12.11.22 RESP 001836 - 001838 R-92 OFW Message 1.8.23 RESP 001895 and 001897 - 001898 R-93 OFW Message 1.26.23 RESP 001910 - 001911 R-94 OFW Message 3.16.23 RESP 001942 R-95 OFW Message 3.20.23 RESP 001947 R-96 OFW Message 4.24.23 RESP 001992 - 001993 R-97 OFW Message 5.9.23 RESP 002001 R-98 OFW Message 5.23.23 RESP 002026 R-99 OFW Message 6.4.23 RESP 002033 R-100 OFW Message 6.5.23 RESP 002036 - 002037 R-101 Marriage Certificate (Petitioner) R-102 Petitioner’s Answers to Interrogatories Dated 1.20.23 R- 103 Mom - Medical and Dental Cost RESP 000236 — 000240 R-104 Dad — Medical Dental Vision Cost R-105 Agreed Final Decree of Divorce Signed 5/4/2017 R—- 106 Agreed Child Support Review Order Signed 1/4/2018 R-107 Agreed Final Order in Suit to Modify Parent- Singed 6/4/2021 Child Relationship R—- 108 Agreed Order for Counseling and Electronic Signed 2/12/2023 Communication NO. DESCRIPTION Oo A D NOTES R-109 Attorney Representation Agreement RESP 000682 - 000686 R-110 Attorney Billing Statements RESP 1-6; 687-692; 904-910; and 002090 — 002095. R-1lll Video RESP 000681 R—112 R-113 R-114 R-115 R-116 R-117 R—-118 R-119 R-120 Respectfully Submitted, Law Office of Christine R. Thrash, PLLC 440 Louisiana Street, Suite 900 Houston, Texas 77002 Tel: (713) 224-7777 Fax: (877) 308-6443 Email: Christine@ThrashLawTexas.com By: lel ChristineR. Thrash Christine R. Thrash State Bar No. 24033271 Attorney for Respondent CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 1 certify that a true copy of the above was served on each attorney of record or party in accordance with the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure on July 26, 2023. Ronald Muller State Bar No. 14649100 6300 West Loop South, Suite 340 Bellaire, Texas 77401 Tel: (713) 271-8282 Fax: (713) 271-2112 Email: muller@rsmlegalteam.com VIA ELECTRONIC SERVICE Attorney for Petitioner Stacy Schnitzer McCarty State Bar No. 24041881 711 Morton Street Richmond, Texas 77469 Tel: (281) 633-9919 Fax: (281) 232-9915 Email: stacymecarty@gmail.com VIA ELECTRONIC SERVICE Amicus Attorney Stephanie Truong State Bar No. 24070451 Office of the Attorney General Child Support Division 117 Lane Drive, Ste. 7 Rosenberg, Texas 77471 Tel: (800) 252-8014 Fax: (281) 239-4800 Email: CSD-legal-605@texasattorneygeneral.gov VIA ELECTRONIC SERVICE Interested Party lol ChristineR. Thrash Christine R. Thrash Attorney for Respondent Automated Certificate of eService This automated certificate of service was created by the efiling system. The filer served this document via email generated by the efiling system on the date and to the persons listed below. The rules governing certificates of service have not changed. Filers must still provide a certificate of service that complies with all applicable rules. Christine Thrash on behalf of Christine Thrash Bar No. 24033271 christinethrash@sbcglobal.net Envelope ID: 77912716 Filing Code Description: No Fee Documents Filing Description: Respondent's Trial Witness List Status as of 7/27/2023 8:07 AM CST Associated Case ro’ Name BarNumber | Email TimestampSubmitted | Status Stacy SchnitzerMcCarty stacymccarty@ymail.com | 7/26/2023 3:03:47 PM | SENT Associated Case Party: Attorney General of Texas Name BarNumber | Email TimestampSubmitted | Status Stephanie Truong | 24070451 CSD-legal-1003@oag.texas.gov | 7/26/2023 3:03:47 PM | SENT Case Contacts Name BarNumber | Email TimestampSubmitted | Status Ronald C. Muller | 14649100 muller@rsmlegalteam.com | 7/26/2023 3:03:47 PM | SENT