Motion,Ex Parte: JULIO HERNANDEZ VS BMW OF NORTH AMERICA LLC ET AL

• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                e                                                 e                   ORIGINAL
     BOWMAN AND BROOKE LLP
     Brian Takahashi (SBN: 146505
                                                                                              BIL    ED
     Richard L. Stuhlbarg (SBN: 180631                                                                of California
                                                                                    Superior   Court
                                                                                                           les
     Theodore Dorenkamp III (SBN: 277004)                                              Coun fu af Fac Soae
     Jimmy Y. Park (SBN: 228290)
     970     lest 190th Street, Suite 700                                                     JuL 1 3 2018
     Torrance, California 90502
                                                                                                                  Clerk of Court
     Tel No:      310/ 768-3068                                                Sherri R. Ca     executive snicori
                  310/ 719-1019
                                                                                wi
     Fax No:                                                                                                     —      out!
                                                                                              ore

     Attorneys for Defendants
     BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC and
     NICK ALEXANDER IMPORTS d/b/a NICK ALEXANDER BMW

                          SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
10                     FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES - STANLEY MOSK
11

12   JULIO HERNANDEZ,                                     )   CASE NO.:       BC666145
13                              Plaintiff,                    Assigned to: Hon. Michelle Williams Court
                                                          )   Department: 74
14            VS.                                         )
                                                              DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 5
15   BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, a )                           TO EXCLUDE ARGUMENT THAT BMW NA
     Delaware       Limited   Liability      Company,     )   HAD AN AFFIRMATIVE DUTY TO
16   NICK     ALEXANDER     IMPORTS,   a                      REPURCHASE; MEMORANDUM OF
     California Corporation, d/b/a NICK                       POINTS AND AUTHORITIES,
17   ALEXANDER           BMW,      and       DOES 1 )         DECLARATION OF JIMMY Y. PARK;
     through 10, inclusive,                               )   [PROPOSED] ORDER
18
                                Defendants.                   Motion in Limine No. 5
19
20
                                                          )   Action Filed:    June 22, 2017
                                                              Trial:           July 30, 2018
21
22            TO PLAINTIFF AND TO HIS ATTORNEYS OF RECORD:
23             Defendants       BMW          OF     NORTH     AMERICA,        LLC      ("BMW          NA")       and       NICK
24   ALEXANDER          IMPORTS           dba NICK ALEXANDER           BMW          move the court for an Order
25   prohibiting the admission of any argument, testimony, or reference that defendants had

26
my
     an affirmative duty to offer plaintiff a repurchase or replacement vehicle without plaintiff
     first making the request.
od
28            This Motion is based                upon all the files and proceedings herein and upon the
pe   1968481 5v2                                              1
se        DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 5 TO EXCLUDE ARGUMENT THAT BMW NA HAD AN
           AFFIRMATIVE DUTY TO REPURCHASE; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES,
                              DECLARATION OF JIMMY Y. PARK; [PROPOSED] ORDER