Motion,Ex Parte: JULIO HERNANDEZ VS BMW OF NORTH AMERICA LLC ET AL

• 
• 

						
                                
Preview
                                e
                                  -                                          @               ORIGINAL
        BOWMAN AND BROOKE LLP
        Brian Takahashi (SBN: 146505)
        Richard L. Stuhlbarg (SBN: 180631
        Theodore Dorenkamp III (SBN: 277004)                                                 BELED
        Jimmy Y. Park (SBN: 228290)                                                   Superior Court of California
        970     lest 190th Street, Suite 700                                             Counts: af Une Angeles
        Torrance, California 90502
        Tel No:      310/ 768-3068                                                          JUL 13 2618
        Fax No: 310/719-1019                                                 Sherri R. Lar wes eacctive Ulticer!Clerk of Court
                                                                                 By        XS                     FB Spuly
        Attorneys for Defendants                                                        ~ Raul Sanchez
        BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC and
        NICK ALEXANDER IMPORTS d/b/a NICK ALEXANDER BMW

                           SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
  10                     FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES - STANLEY MOSK
  11
  12    JULIO HERNANDEZ,                                CASE NO.:      BC666145
  13                          Plaintiff,                Assigned to: Hon. Michelle Williams Court
                                                        Department: 74
  14            vs.
                                                        DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 4
  15    BMW OF NORTH AMERICA, LLC, a                    TO EXCLUDE NON-RECOVERABLE
        Delaware Limited Liability Company,             INCIDENTAL AND CONSEQUENTIAL
  16    NICK ALEXANDER IMPORTS, a                       DAMAGES; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS
        California Corporation, d/b/a NICK              AND AUTHORITIES, DECLARATION OF
  17    ALEXANDER BMW, and DOES 1                       JIMMY Y. PARK; EXHIBITS “A” - “C”;
        through 10, inclusive,                          [PROPOSED] ORDER
  18
                              Defendants.               Motion in Limine No. 4
  19
                                                        Action Filed: June 22, 2017
  20                                                      tial:       July 30, 2018
  21
  22            TO PLAINTIFF AND TO HIS ATTORNEYS OF RECORD:
  23             PLEASE    TAKE       NOTICE   that defendants   BMW    OF       NORTH          AMERICA,          LLC
  24    ("BMW        NA") and NICK ALEXANDER        IMPORTS      dba NICK ALEXANDER                  BMW        move
  25    the court for an order preventing plaintiff, his attorneys, and witnesses from introducing

   od
        testimony or evidence of incidental or consequential damages plaintiff is not entitled to
Lt
om td
        recover under the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act. Evidence of non-recoverable
o8      incidental or consequential damages is irrelevant, unfairly prejudicial, will mislead the
62
   mo
fe Ca                                                   4
be      19669409v2
         DEFENDANTS’ MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 4 TO EXCLUDE NON-RECOVERABLE INCIDENTAL AND
        CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES, DECLARATION OF
                                JIMMY Y. PARK; [PROPOSED] ORDER