On June 01, 2022 a
Party Discovery
was filed
involving a dispute between
Parafeinik, Oxana,
and
Does 1-2,
Strong Bridge Management Llc,
Voita, Carol,
for Other PI/PD/WD Unlimited
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
\r V
Fcrouifirfi
'
3 r
£2
I
SUPERIOR {7.15m
COLLEEN A. DEZIEL (Bar No. 164282) COUNH (fur ::;,n,:-ss
8A5”: unHNN'zLu‘NL, :51
cad@amclawlcom g
PETER B. RUSTIN (Bar No. 181734) q .
I
a
pbr@amclaw.com AUU 0 l 201i
ANDERSON, McPHARLIN & CONNERS LLP
707 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 4000 fl
Los Angeles, California 90017-3623 BY WM—EQU p.
Qt? I‘I'm-‘Q
TELEPHONE: (213) 688-0080 o FACSIMILE: (213) 622—7594
(3W7 H'A BEUMY: DEW?!
ND®\I@UI£DJNH
Attorneys for Defendants CAROL VOITA; and STRONG
BRIDGE MANAGEMENT LLC (erroneously sued as Carol
Voita - Sole MemberflVIanager Strong Bridge Management LLC)
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO, SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT
LLP
4000
OXANA PARAFEINIK, Case No. CIVSB2210600
7-3623 r-tr—tr—tr—t
622-7594
WNHC
CONNERS Plaintiff, Assigned to Hon. Gilbert Ochoa, Dept. 824
SUITE
9001
3)
86
(21 vs. Action Filed: June 1, 2022
FAX
LAWYERS
BOULEVARD,
CALIFORNIA
-
p—t
£ CAROL VOITA; CAROL VOITA SOLE - OPPOSITION T0 REQUEST FOR
MCPHARLIN
MEMBER/MANAGER STRONG BRIDGE ENTRY OF DEFAULT OF CAROL
H UI MANAGEMENT LLC; and DOES TO 2, 1 VOITA - SOLE MEMBER/ MANAGER
STRONG BRIDGE MANAGEMENT LLC
688—0080
ANGELES,
WILSHIRE
3)
r—t
a Defendants.
ANDERSON,
(21
Trial Date: None
707
H \l
LOS
TEL
t—t 00 STRONG BRIDGE MANAGEMENT LLC (erroneously sued as Carol Voita - Sole
I— \O Member/Manager Strong Bridge Management LLC) and Carol Voita (“Defendants”) hereby
-
Nc submit their opposition to the Request for Entry of Default against Carol Voita Sole
NH Member/Manager Strong Bridge Management LLC filed by Plaintiff 0n July 29, 2022.
NN As the Court’s records will show, STRONG BRIDGE MANAGEMENT LLC, erroneously
N DJ sued as Carol Voita - Sole Member/Manager Strong Bridge Management LLC filed a motion to
Nh strike and a demurrer on July 25, 2022, accompanied by requests for judicial notice. Copies of the
N U] Motion to Strike; Demurrer and Requests for Judicial Notice are attached as Exhibits A-D.
N a\ It is commonplace and well established that persons 0r entities sued erroneously may
N \l answer by noting that they have been “erroneously sued as.” This has been recognized in
Nw countless cases. See, e.g., Referendum Committee v. City ofHermosa Beach (1986) 184
1
2588185.] 05896-182
OPPOSITION TO REQUEST FOR ENTRY OF DEFAULT
Cal.App.3d 152; Hartline v. Kaiser Foundation Hospitals (2005) 32 Cal.App.4th 458; Cummings
v. Farmers Ins. Exchange (1988) 202 Cal.App.3d 1407.
There is no basis for a default here. Carol Voita - Sole Member/Manager Strong Bridge
Management LLC filed her motion to strike and demurrer as STRONG BRIDGE
WWQ¢UIKDJNH
MANAGEMENT LLC because Plaintiff erroneously sued her both in her personal capacity and as
a “Sole Member/Manager Strong Bridge Management LLC.” There is no basis for this, any more
than there is a legitimate basis for a default to be entered. Defendants request that the request for
entry of default therefore be denied.
DATED: August 1, 2022 ANDERSON, McPHARLIN & CONNERS LLP
LLP
4000
7-3623
622-7594 HHHH WNHG
CONNERS
SUITE
9001
3) By:
8L
(21
Colleen A. De’ziel
FAX
Peter B. Rustin
BOULEVARD.
CALIFORNIA
Hfi
LAWYERS
'
CAROL VOITA; and
Attorneys for Defendants
STRONG BRIDGE MANAGEMENT LLC
MCPI'IARLW
UI
H
688-0080
-
(erroneously sued as Carol Voita Sole
Member/Manager Strong Bridge Management LLC)
ANGELES,
WILSHIRE
HQ
(213)
ANDERSON,
707
H \l
LOS
TEL
NNNNNNNNNHH
WQQUIBMNchw
2
2588185.] 05896-182 OPPOSITION TO REQUEST FOR ENTRY OF DEFAULT
Document Filed Date
August 01, 2022
Case Filing Date
June 01, 2022
Category
Other PI/PD/WD Unlimited
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
\r V Fcrouifirfi ' 3 r £2 I SUPERIOR {7.15m COLLEEN A. DEZIEL (Bar No. 164282) COUNH (fur ::;,n,:-ss 8A5”: unHNN'zLu‘NL, :51 cad@amclawlcom g PETER B. RUSTIN (Bar No. 181734) q . I a pbr@amclaw.com AUU 0 l 201i ANDERSON, McPHARLIN & CONNERS LLP 707 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 4000 fl Los Angeles, California 90017-3623 BY WM—EQU p. Qt? I‘I'm-‘Q TELEPHONE: (213) 688-0080 o FACSIMILE: (213) 622—7594 (3W7 H'A BEUMY: DEW?! ND®\I@UI£DJNH Attorneys for Defendants CAROL VOITA; and STRONG BRIDGE MANAGEMENT LLC (erroneously sued as Carol Voita - Sole MemberflVIanager Strong Bridge Management LLC) SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO, SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT LLP 4000 OXANA PARAFEINIK, Case No. CIVSB2210600 7-3623 r-tr—tr—tr—t 622-7594 WNHC CONNERS Plaintiff, Assigned to Hon. Gilbert Ochoa, Dept. 824 SUITE 9001 3) 86 (21 vs. Action Filed: June 1, 2022 FAX LAWYERS BOULEVARD, CALIFORNIA - p—t £ CAROL VOITA; CAROL VOITA SOLE - OPPOSITION T0 REQUEST FOR MCPHARLIN MEMBER/MANAGER STRONG BRIDGE ENTRY OF DEFAULT OF CAROL H UI MANAGEMENT LLC; and DOES TO 2, 1 VOITA - SOLE MEMBER/ MANAGER STRONG BRIDGE MANAGEMENT LLC 688—0080 ANGELES, WILSHIRE 3) r—t a Defendants. ANDERSON, (21 Trial Date: None 707 H \l LOS TEL t—t 00 STRONG BRIDGE MANAGEMENT LLC (erroneously sued as Carol Voita - Sole I— \O Member/Manager Strong Bridge Management LLC) and Carol Voita (“Defendants”) hereby - Nc submit their opposition to the Request for Entry of Default against Carol Voita Sole NH Member/Manager Strong Bridge Management LLC filed by Plaintiff 0n July 29, 2022. NN As the Court’s records will show, STRONG BRIDGE MANAGEMENT LLC, erroneously N DJ sued as Carol Voita - Sole Member/Manager Strong Bridge Management LLC filed a motion to Nh strike and a demurrer on July 25, 2022, accompanied by requests for judicial notice. Copies of the N U] Motion to Strike; Demurrer and Requests for Judicial Notice are attached as Exhibits A-D. N a\ It is commonplace and well established that persons 0r entities sued erroneously may N \l answer by noting that they have been “erroneously sued as.” This has been recognized in Nw countless cases. See, e.g., Referendum Committee v. City ofHermosa Beach (1986) 184 1 2588185.] 05896-182 OPPOSITION TO REQUEST FOR ENTRY OF DEFAULT Cal.App.3d 152; Hartline v. Kaiser Foundation Hospitals (2005) 32 Cal.App.4th 458; Cummings v. Farmers Ins. Exchange (1988) 202 Cal.App.3d 1407. There is no basis for a default here. Carol Voita - Sole Member/Manager Strong Bridge Management LLC filed her motion to strike and demurrer as STRONG BRIDGE WWQ¢UIKDJNH MANAGEMENT LLC because Plaintiff erroneously sued her both in her personal capacity and as a “Sole Member/Manager Strong Bridge Management LLC.” There is no basis for this, any more than there is a legitimate basis for a default to be entered. Defendants request that the request for entry of default therefore be denied. DATED: August 1, 2022 ANDERSON, McPHARLIN & CONNERS LLP LLP 4000 7-3623 622-7594 HHHH WNHG CONNERS SUITE 9001 3) By: 8L (21 Colleen A. De’ziel FAX Peter B. Rustin BOULEVARD. CALIFORNIA Hfi LAWYERS ' CAROL VOITA; and Attorneys for Defendants STRONG BRIDGE MANAGEMENT LLC MCPI'IARLW UI H 688-0080 - (erroneously sued as Carol Voita Sole Member/Manager Strong Bridge Management LLC) ANGELES, WILSHIRE HQ (213) ANDERSON, 707 H \l LOS TEL NNNNNNNNNHH WQQUIBMNchw 2 2588185.] 05896-182 OPPOSITION TO REQUEST FOR ENTRY OF DEFAULT