On June 15, 2020 a
Motion,Ex Parte
was filed
involving a dispute between
Acosta, Rosa Diaz,
Aviles, Griselda,
Aviles, Guillermo,
and
Fca Us Llc, A Delaware Limited Liability Company,
Jeep Chrysler Of Ontarioinc., A California Corporation,
for Breach of Contract/Warranty Unlimited
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
\y
Barry R Schirm (SBN 94553)
ER :1.“
Yasuzawa (SBN 245322)
Bria’n OUNgROCOUQT C :h'u.
‘ '
Samantha Brignoni (SBN 3 1 1869) SAN 8535' Apggjxgm
BERNAROINO
HAWKINS PARNELL & YOUNG, LLP
DF C
445 South Figueroa Street, Suite 3200 24 2020
Los Angeles, California 90071
BY
Telephone: (213) 486-8000
LEANN' ‘E-«Lw
Facsimile; (213) 486-8080 A
”LAM: Efic‘d . J,
Email: byasuzawa@hpylaw.c0m (3.3!:
J
sbrignonngthlaw.com
Attorneys for Defendants,
FCA US LLC
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO
10 GUILLERMO AVILES, GRISELDA AVILES, )
Case No.1 CIVD82012360
and ROSA DIAZ ACOSTA, )
11 ) DEFENDANT FCA US LLC’S
Plaintiffs, ) MEMORANDUM 0F POINTS AND
12 ) AUTHORITIES IN OPPOSITION TO
V' PLAINTIFF’S MOTION T0 COMPEL
13 g
FURTHER DISCOVERY RESPONSES TO
JEEP CHRYSLER OF ONTARIO INC a )
PLAINTIFFS’ FIRST SET 0F REQUESTS
14 California Corporation dba JEEP CHRYSLER )
DODGE RAM FIAT OF ONTARIO; FCA US )
OF PRODUCTION OF DOCUMETNS
15 LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company, ) FROM DEFENDANT, AND REQUEST
and DOES 1 through 10, inclusive. FOR SANCTIONS
16 g
Defendants'
Hearing Date: Januaxy 8, 2021 (3)3
17 g
Hearing Time: 9:00 am. :31
)
18 Department: S30 Aft}
)
,
:;
)
19 ) Complaint Filed: June 15, 2020
!
3E}
Trial Date: None Eu: ‘1'
20 )
21
Defendant, FCA US LLC (“FCA US”), opposes Plaintiffs” Motion to Compel Further
22
Responses, Set No. One as follows:
23
I. INTRODUCTION
24
This case involves a claim of breach of warranty under the Song—Beverly Consumer
25
Warranty Act, involving one vehicle, Plaintiffs’ 2014 Dodge Ram 1500 (“Subject Vehicle”).
26
Plaintiff counsel’s motion to compel fithher responses is harassing and unwarranted as FCA US has
27
of the responses at issue in this Motion with Irespect to repurchase
already agreed to supplemented all
28
1
DEFENDANT FCA’S MEMORANDUM 0F POINTS AND AUTHORITIES 1N OPPOSITION T0 PLAINTIFFS
MOTION T0
COMPEL
m
>z
mm m: D
fifi
m mn E
fl
z> mm
mD om i
mm
E OO 2
OC 8 <
m
oo E
c
z
j
.
@
Document Filed Date
December 24, 2020
Case Filing Date
June 15, 2020
Category
Breach of Contract/Warranty Unlimited
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
\y Barry R Schirm (SBN 94553) ER :1.“ Yasuzawa (SBN 245322) Bria’n OUNgROCOUQT C :h'u. ‘ ' Samantha Brignoni (SBN 3 1 1869) SAN 8535' Apggjxgm BERNAROINO HAWKINS PARNELL & YOUNG, LLP DF C 445 South Figueroa Street, Suite 3200 24 2020 Los Angeles, California 90071 BY Telephone: (213) 486-8000 LEANN' ‘E-«Lw Facsimile; (213) 486-8080 A ”LAM: Efic‘d . J, Email: byasuzawa@hpylaw.c0m (3.3!: J sbrignonngthlaw.com Attorneys for Defendants, FCA US LLC SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO 10 GUILLERMO AVILES, GRISELDA AVILES, ) Case No.1 CIVD82012360 and ROSA DIAZ ACOSTA, ) 11 ) DEFENDANT FCA US LLC’S Plaintiffs, ) MEMORANDUM 0F POINTS AND 12 ) AUTHORITIES IN OPPOSITION TO V' PLAINTIFF’S MOTION T0 COMPEL 13 g FURTHER DISCOVERY RESPONSES TO JEEP CHRYSLER OF ONTARIO INC a ) PLAINTIFFS’ FIRST SET 0F REQUESTS 14 California Corporation dba JEEP CHRYSLER ) DODGE RAM FIAT OF ONTARIO; FCA US ) OF PRODUCTION OF DOCUMETNS 15 LLC, a Delaware Limited Liability Company, ) FROM DEFENDANT, AND REQUEST and DOES 1 through 10, inclusive. FOR SANCTIONS 16 g Defendants' Hearing Date: Januaxy 8, 2021 (3)3 17 g Hearing Time: 9:00 am. :31 ) 18 Department: S30 Aft} ) , :; ) 19 ) Complaint Filed: June 15, 2020 ! 3E} Trial Date: None Eu: ‘1' 20 ) 21 Defendant, FCA US LLC (“FCA US”), opposes Plaintiffs” Motion to Compel Further 22 Responses, Set No. One as follows: 23 I. INTRODUCTION 24 This case involves a claim of breach of warranty under the Song—Beverly Consumer 25 Warranty Act, involving one vehicle, Plaintiffs’ 2014 Dodge Ram 1500 (“Subject Vehicle”). 26 Plaintiff counsel’s motion to compel fithher responses is harassing and unwarranted as FCA US has 27 of the responses at issue in this Motion with Irespect to repurchase already agreed to supplemented all 28 1 DEFENDANT FCA’S MEMORANDUM 0F POINTS AND AUTHORITIES 1N OPPOSITION T0 PLAINTIFFS MOTION T0 COMPEL m >z mm m: D fifi m mn E fl z> mm mD om i mm E OO 2 OC 8 < m oo E c z j . @