On November 07, 2017 a
Minute Order - MINUTE ORDER (HEARING ON MOTION FOR ORDER ESTABLISHING A PROTOCOL FOR THE P...)
was filed
involving a dispute between
Pointe Assets Llc,
and
Benson Industries Inc.,
Quanex I.G. Systems Inc,
Quanex I.G. Systems Inc.,
Truseal Technologies Inc.,
Viracon Inc,
Viracon Inc.,
Pointe Assets Llc,
for civil
in the District Court of Los Angeles County.
Preview
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES
Civil Division
North Central District, Glendale Courthouse, Department D
EC067583 July 27, 2020
POINTE ASSESTS, LLC VS. BENSON INDUSTRIES, INC., 11:00 AM
ET AL.
Judge: Honorable Ralph C. Hofer CSR: Not reported
Judicial Assistant: Larry Hironaka ERM: None
Courtroom Assistant: Lillian R. Espejo Deputy Sheriff: None
APPEARANCES:
For Plaintiff(s): POINTE ASSETS, LLC (Telephonic) By: Scott E. Hennigh
For Defendant(s): Bruce L. Cleeland (Telephonic); Eric Seth Fisher (Telephonic); John R. Maley
By: Joseph Wahl (Telephonic)
NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: Hearing on Motion for Order Establishing a Protocol for the
Preservation of Evidence filed on behalf of Defed and Truseal Technologies, Inc.; Hearing -
Other Joinder of Defendant Viracon, Inc. to Ex Parte Application for an Order Establishing a
Protocol for the Preservation of Evidence filed by Defendants Quanez I.G. Systems, Inc. et al.
The above referenced matters now come on calendar before the Court.
Court having read and considered the moving papers and oppositions along with their supporting
declaration and their memorandum of points and authorities now hears from Counsel.
Counsel for Quanez I.G. Systems, Inc. et al. represents to the Court that Issue involve
Designating Storage, Storage Fees and Costs.
Counsel for Plaintiff Point Assets, LLC argues that discovery costs should be paid for by
Defendant and cites his case, San Diego Port Authority v. Barns, 95 Cal App.
4th, 1400 at page 1405.
Counsel for Defendants Quanex I.G. Systems, Inc., argues that the costs are for preservation of
evidence and not discovery costs.
Court trails matter to 7/28/2020, at 11:00 a.m., in this Department.
On the Court's own motion, the Hearing on Motion for Order Establishing a Protocol for the
Preservation of Evidence filed on behalf of Defendants Quanex I.G. Systems, Inc. and Truseal
Minute Order Page 1 of 2
Document Filed Date
July 27, 2020
Case Filing Date
November 07, 2017
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES Civil Division North Central District, Glendale Courthouse, Department D EC067583 July 27, 2020 POINTE ASSESTS, LLC VS. BENSON INDUSTRIES, INC., 11:00 AM ET AL. Judge: Honorable Ralph C. Hofer CSR: Not reported Judicial Assistant: Larry Hironaka ERM: None Courtroom Assistant: Lillian R. Espejo Deputy Sheriff: None APPEARANCES: For Plaintiff(s): POINTE ASSETS, LLC (Telephonic) By: Scott E. Hennigh For Defendant(s): Bruce L. Cleeland (Telephonic); Eric Seth Fisher (Telephonic); John R. Maley By: Joseph Wahl (Telephonic) NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS: Hearing on Motion for Order Establishing a Protocol for the Preservation of Evidence filed on behalf of Defed and Truseal Technologies, Inc.; Hearing - Other Joinder of Defendant Viracon, Inc. to Ex Parte Application for an Order Establishing a Protocol for the Preservation of Evidence filed by Defendants Quanez I.G. Systems, Inc. et al. The above referenced matters now come on calendar before the Court. Court having read and considered the moving papers and oppositions along with their supporting declaration and their memorandum of points and authorities now hears from Counsel. Counsel for Quanez I.G. Systems, Inc. et al. represents to the Court that Issue involve Designating Storage, Storage Fees and Costs. Counsel for Plaintiff Point Assets, LLC argues that discovery costs should be paid for by Defendant and cites his case, San Diego Port Authority v. Barns, 95 Cal App. 4th, 1400 at page 1405. Counsel for Defendants Quanex I.G. Systems, Inc., argues that the costs are for preservation of evidence and not discovery costs. Court trails matter to 7/28/2020, at 11:00 a.m., in this Department. On the Court's own motion, the Hearing on Motion for Order Establishing a Protocol for the Preservation of Evidence filed on behalf of Defendants Quanex I.G. Systems, Inc. and Truseal Minute Order Page 1 of 2