Preview
E-FILED
1
EF
McCormick, Barstow, Sheppard,
Wayte & Carruth LLP 11:55:31
7/10/2017 AM
2
Steven
M. McQuillan,
!" # $#107339
% & '
FRESNO *)+(,-SUPERIOR
()COUNTY +.')'COURT *)+',
Steve. 012!" 01130"1
/ mcquillan@mccormickbarstow. / 4 com130 By:
7<Lopez,
:;<S. + ;
)=Deputy
3 Chester 566/$%78
*/ E. Walls, #28639897
*/ walls@mccormickbarstow.
Chester. 466/>01130"1?@/ 34 130
com
4 8A(3
7647 /
North Fresno 3Street
/ 3$*6"B3
Fresno, "9
California
93720
5 ,63
Telephone: C9DA
(559)433-1300
1/"0"6
Facsimile:
I)))IJ)I+AK (
C9DA
(559)
433-2300
6
3
Attomeys;/for B
B3Defendants *G'
/CHRIS '):',
ROBERTS, $H' ( * ,,+==)
JR.,$andAMANDA CATTUZZO
7
SUPERIOR *)+',
+.')'COURT ) ,G , ,)
OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA* )'(
8
*)+(,-)'
COUNTY OF FRESNO ()
9
)
10
E
H G :''$
ELIJAH BREELER, */(3
Case **LA
No.17CECG01740
E
11
E
.6" "BB$
Plaintiff, ( (, (),* ( ),)(
DEFENDANTS' NOTICE AND MOTION
(
12
E
,)QUASH
TO M+ GSERVICE
'N*) + )(
OF SUMMONS
NV.
@D
13
Date: ! !/ 29,
August
9$2017
(
E
*G'
CHRIS '):',
ROBERTS, $JR.,
H' $AMANDA ,"0
Time:
3:30 0
p.m.
14 * ,,+==)$
CATTUZZO, and DOES1 ,)
) TO $
10,
Dept.:
503
.
@O6@F
15 B /
Defendants. 1 "3
Action Filed:
"6 9
5/19/17
16
II
,) *G. ',- (,)*)+( )'*)')' *G. ',-
O O
17 TO EACH PARTY AND TO COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR EACH PARTY:
E
18 -)+
YOU ARE G':-NOTIFIED
'HEREBY (),THAT ,G ,on 3 ! !/ 29,2017,
August 9$$at 0
p.m.
3:30 in
" 0
Department
E
I)
19
503 of
3Bthis *3! $ located
"/ Court, 631 at
1130 PQStreet,
"O" $ / 3$ California,
Fresno, *6"B3 9 B
$ Defendants
"$ 93721, *G'
/ CHRIS
()
20 '):',
ROBERTS, JR.,$and (
$H' * ,,+==)("DEFENDANTS")
AMANDA CATTUZZO CP( (, QDwill
4"66and @; specially
hereby appear /1"66;
(
21E
and03
move the 13! for
court
B3an )Quashing
Order M!/" the 66 service
alleged / "1of !003
3BSummons /"in "/
this action3
1 "3 onthe
((
22 3!
ground of
3Black 3B/3
61?of personal jurisdiction3
6R!"/"1 "3 over ( (,
DEFENDANTS pursuant
!/! to *3of
3Code 3B*" "6
Civil .31!
Procedure
( 4
23 /1 "3 A7
section418.10.
(H&
24 ,Motion
The 3 "3 4"66
will @0on
be made 3 @/"/
the basis
that the !003
Summons /and
*306"
Complaint 4not
were 3 properly
36;
(
25S
served !3
/ ( (,
uponDEFENDANTS in
" 0
the manner2!"
required by@;*3
Code 3B .31!section
*" "6Procedure
of Civil /1 "3 A
415.20.
26
///
(
II
27 (
///
7
28
///
1130!1T
McCormick.: '
,)5
Barstow,
5 -,
G.. ' WAYTE&
Shepparo,
* ''+,G.
CarruthLLP
P&&F 00F<
7M7 NORTH FRESNO STREET
FRESNO. CA 93720
( (,
DEFENDANTS' NOTICE (MOTION
(),*AND ),)(,)TO M+
QUASH GSERVICE
'N*OF + )(
)SUMMONS
1 ,Motion
The 3 "3 will
4"66be
@andis !3
@/upon
"/based this(3 "1$the
"/Notice, 03
1Memorandum
attached !0of3BPoints
.3"
/and
2 Authorities, 16 "3
Declarations
! 3" "/$ the 3BChester
/ of */ E. *G'
566/$ CHRIS
Walls, '):',
ROBERTS, $JR.,
H'
$ and (
AMANDA
3 * ,,+==)$
CATTUZZO, the files
6/and records
13/in
" "/
this 1 "3
$and
action, any
;further "
B! evidence
1and !0
argument that
the
4 Court 0;receive
*3! may 1" at 3before
or @B3the
hearing.
"
5 H!6;
Dated: $
July 10,2017 **)' *V$BARSTOW,
McCORMICK, : ' ,)5$SHEPPARD,
G.. '$
I33323T0AU4!4
5 -,W* ''+,G
WAYTE & CARRUTH LLP .
6
7
8 :N
By:.
Steven
M. McQuillan
1M!"66
9 */ E.
Chester 566/
Walls
3 ;/for
Attorneys B
B3Defendants *G'
/CHRIS '):',
ROBERTS, $JR.,
H' $
10
and ( * ,,+==)
AMANDA CATTUZZO
11 A794575366.1
52482-C0095A 88 J
12
13
14
15
((((O6"OF)O"O6 FOFOFOFG"O
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
7
28
**)' *V$003Q
MCCORMICK.BARSTOW,
5 N,
G.. '$WAYTE&
Sheppard,
* ''+,G.
CARRUTHLLP
7M7 ' ()STREET
()',GFRESNO
ANORTH /6<'
193720
' ()$CA
FRESNO.
( (,
DEFENDANTS' NOTICE
(),*AND (MOTION
),)(TO ,)QUASH
M+ GSERVICE
'N*OF + )(
)SUMMONS
.'))) 'N*
PROOF OF SERVICE
( , ,OF
STATE )CALIFORNIA,
* )'( $COUNTY *)+(,-OF )FRESNO
' ()
the
At time / "1$ I 4/
3Bservice,
"0of was 3 18
over 7years 3B
;/of
ageandnot
3 aparty
;to 3this 1 "3
"/action. 0
I am
063;in
employed " *3!
County
the 3BFresno,
;of / 3$State 3BCalifornia.
of *6"B3 " ;business
My @!/" ////
address is 8ANorth
"/7647 (3 Fresno
/ 3
/
$Fresno,
Street, * 93720.
3$CA 9
)
On July
H!6; 10, $ I
$ 2017, / true
served 3Bthe
13"/ of
! copies B36634"
following document(s)
31!0 C/D described
/1"@ as/
( (,
DEFENDANTS' (),*AND
NOTICE (MOTION
),)(,) TO M+
QUASH G 'N*
SERVICE )
OF + )(
SUMMONS 3
on the
" / parties
interested
I)))(M.4
"/in
" this 1 "3
"/action as
/B36634/
follows:
:"
Brian L.
/
Larsen
4Offices
Law )B 1/of3BBrian
:" L.
/
Larsen
530Jackson
H1?/3 St., Floor
$2nd 633
San Francisco,
1"/13 * 9A
CA 94133
:-
BY I enclosed
MAIL: 163/the 31!0 C/Din
document(s) " sealed
a 63or
/6envelope 1?
3package addressed
//to
3the
10 /3
persons/at ///
the "
6"/ in
addresses listed the "1List
Service
"/ andplaced
61the 63for
envelope 13661 "3
B3collection mailing,
and 0"6" $
B36634"
following 3!ordinary
our 3" ;@!/" //practices.
business 1 "1/ 0readily
I am 4" this
B0"6"with
"6;familiar @!/" ///practice
"/business's 1 "1for
B3
11 13661 "
collecting
andprocessing
31//" 13/3
correspondence 1for 0"6"
B3mailing. )
On the /0day
same ;that 13/3
correspondence
the 1is
"/
61
placed for 13661 "3
B3collection
andmailing,
0"6" $it
" is3/" in
"/deposited " the 3" ;course
ordinary 3Bbusiness
13!/of @!/" 4" the
//with + "
United
12 .3/ 6Service,
/Postal
States "1$in
" sealed
a 63with
/6envelope 4" postage
3/ fully
B!66;"
prepaid.
13 16!
Ideclare
under 3BR!;under
6 ;ofperjury
penalty ! the
laws 3B State
64/ofthe 3B*6"B3
ofCalifornia "that B3 3"
foregoing
the is
"/
!
true andcorrect.
131
A
14
T1!
Executed on 3 July $$at
H!6;10,2017, / 3$California.
Fresno, *6"B3 "
15
8
16
17 0/ .33
lemse Poor
7
18
9
19
20
21
22
23
A
24
25
8
26
27
7
28
**)' *V: '
McCormick. ,)5$
Barstow,
G.. '$5 N, W
Sheppard,Wayte&
* ''+,GLLP
CaRRUTH.
()'-G
7M7
'
/0
' ()STREET
NORTH FRESNO
* 93720
()$CA
FRESNO.9
( (,
DEFENDANTS' (),*
NOTICE AND (MOTION
),)(TO M+
,)QUASH GSERVICE
'N*OF + )(
)SUMMONS
Preview
E-FILED 1 EF McCormick, Barstow, Sheppard, Wayte & Carruth LLP 11:55:31 7/10/2017 AM 2 Steven M. McQuillan, !" # $#107339 % & ' FRESNO *)+(,-SUPERIOR ()COUNTY +.')'COURT *)+', Steve. 012!" 01130"1 / mcquillan@mccormickbarstow. / 4 com130 By: 7<Lopez, :;<S. + ; )=Deputy 3 Chester 566/$%78 */ E. Walls, #28639897 */ walls@mccormickbarstow. Chester. 466/>01130"1?@/ 34 130 com 4 8A(3 7647 / North Fresno 3Street / 3$*6"B3 Fresno, "9 California 93720 5 ,63 Telephone: C9DA (559)433-1300 1/"0"6 Facsimile: I)))IJ)I+AK ( C9DA (559) 433-2300 6 3 Attomeys;/for B B3Defendants *G' /CHRIS '):', ROBERTS, $H' ( * ,,+==) JR.,$andAMANDA CATTUZZO 7 SUPERIOR *)+', +.')'COURT ) ,G , ,) OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA* )'( 8 *)+(,-)' COUNTY OF FRESNO () 9 ) 10 E H G :''$ ELIJAH BREELER, */(3 Case **LA No.17CECG01740 E 11 E .6" "BB$ Plaintiff, ( (, (),* ( ),)( DEFENDANTS' NOTICE AND MOTION ( 12 E ,)QUASH TO M+ GSERVICE 'N*) + )( OF SUMMONS NV. @D 13 Date: ! !/ 29, August 9$2017 ( E *G' CHRIS '):', ROBERTS, $JR., H' $AMANDA ,"0 Time: 3:30 0 p.m. 14 * ,,+==)$ CATTUZZO, and DOES1 ,) ) TO $ 10, Dept.: 503 . @O6@F 15 B / Defendants. 1 "3 Action Filed: "6 9 5/19/17 16 II ,) *G. ',- (,)*)+( )'*)')' *G. ',- O O 17 TO EACH PARTY AND TO COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR EACH PARTY: E 18 -)+ YOU ARE G':-NOTIFIED 'HEREBY (),THAT ,G ,on 3 ! !/ 29,2017, August 9$$at 0 p.m. 3:30 in " 0 Department E I) 19 503 of 3Bthis *3! $ located "/ Court, 631 at 1130 PQStreet, "O" $ / 3$ California, Fresno, *6"B3 9 B $ Defendants "$ 93721, *G' / CHRIS () 20 '):', ROBERTS, JR.,$and ( $H' * ,,+==)("DEFENDANTS") AMANDA CATTUZZO CP( (, QDwill 4"66and @; specially hereby appear /1"66; ( 21E and03 move the 13! for court B3an )Quashing Order M!/" the 66 service alleged / "1of !003 3BSummons /"in "/ this action3 1 "3 onthe (( 22 3! ground of 3Black 3B/3 61?of personal jurisdiction3 6R!"/"1 "3 over ( (, DEFENDANTS pursuant !/! to *3of 3Code 3B*" "6 Civil .31! Procedure ( 4 23 /1 "3 A7 section418.10. (H& 24 ,Motion The 3 "3 4"66 will @0on be made 3 @/"/ the basis that the !003 Summons /and *306" Complaint 4not were 3 properly 36; ( 25S served !3 / ( (, uponDEFENDANTS in " 0 the manner2!" required by@;*3 Code 3B .31!section *" "6Procedure of Civil /1 "3 A 415.20. 26 /// ( II 27 ( /// 7 28 /// 1130!1T McCormick.: ' ,)5 Barstow, 5 -, G.. ' WAYTE& Shepparo, * ''+,G. CarruthLLP P&&F 00F< 7M7 NORTH FRESNO STREET FRESNO. CA 93720 ( (, DEFENDANTS' NOTICE (MOTION (),*AND ),)(,)TO M+ QUASH GSERVICE 'N*OF + )( )SUMMONS 1 ,Motion The 3 "3 will 4"66be @andis !3 @/upon "/based this(3 "1$the "/Notice, 03 1Memorandum attached !0of3BPoints .3" /and 2 Authorities, 16 "3 Declarations ! 3" "/$ the 3BChester / of */ E. *G' 566/$ CHRIS Walls, '):', ROBERTS, $JR., H' $ and ( AMANDA 3 * ,,+==)$ CATTUZZO, the files 6/and records 13/in " "/ this 1 "3 $and action, any ;further " B! evidence 1and !0 argument that the 4 Court 0;receive *3! may 1" at 3before or @B3the hearing. " 5 H!6; Dated: $ July 10,2017 **)' *V$BARSTOW, McCORMICK, : ' ,)5$SHEPPARD, G.. '$ I33323T0AU4!4 5 -,W* ''+,G WAYTE & CARRUTH LLP . 6 7 8 :N By:. Steven M. McQuillan 1M!"66 9 */ E. Chester 566/ Walls 3 ;/for Attorneys B B3Defendants *G' /CHRIS '):', ROBERTS, $JR., H' $ 10 and ( * ,,+==) AMANDA CATTUZZO 11 A794575366.1 52482-C0095A 88 J 12 13 14 15 ((((O6"OF)O"O6 FOFOFOFG"O 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 7 28 **)' *V$003Q MCCORMICK.BARSTOW, 5 N, G.. '$WAYTE& Sheppard, * ''+,G. CARRUTHLLP 7M7 ' ()STREET ()',GFRESNO ANORTH /6<' 193720 ' ()$CA FRESNO. ( (, DEFENDANTS' NOTICE (),*AND (MOTION ),)(TO ,)QUASH M+ GSERVICE 'N*OF + )( )SUMMONS .'))) 'N* PROOF OF SERVICE ( , ,OF STATE )CALIFORNIA, * )'( $COUNTY *)+(,-OF )FRESNO ' () the At time / "1$ I 4/ 3Bservice, "0of was 3 18 over 7years 3B ;/of ageandnot 3 aparty ;to 3this 1 "3 "/action. 0 I am 063;in employed " *3! County the 3BFresno, ;of / 3$State 3BCalifornia. of *6"B3 " ;business My @!/" //// address is 8ANorth "/7647 (3 Fresno / 3 / $Fresno, Street, * 93720. 3$CA 9 ) On July H!6; 10, $ I $ 2017, / true served 3Bthe 13"/ of ! copies B36634" following document(s) 31!0 C/D described /1"@ as/ ( (, DEFENDANTS' (),*AND NOTICE (MOTION ),)(,) TO M+ QUASH G 'N* SERVICE ) OF + )( SUMMONS 3 on the " / parties interested I)))(M.4 "/in " this 1 "3 "/action as /B36634/ follows: :" Brian L. / Larsen 4Offices Law )B 1/of3BBrian :" L. / Larsen 530Jackson H1?/3 St., Floor $2nd 633 San Francisco, 1"/13 * 9A CA 94133 :- BY I enclosed MAIL: 163/the 31!0 C/Din document(s) " sealed a 63or /6envelope 1? 3package addressed //to 3the 10 /3 persons/at /// the " 6"/ in addresses listed the "1List Service "/ andplaced 61the 63for envelope 13661 "3 B3collection mailing, and 0"6" $ B36634" following 3!ordinary our 3" ;@!/" //practices. business 1 "1/ 0readily I am 4" this B0"6"with "6;familiar @!/" ///practice "/business's 1 "1for B3 11 13661 " collecting andprocessing 31//" 13/3 correspondence 1for 0"6" B3mailing. ) On the /0day same ;that 13/3 correspondence the 1is "/ 61 placed for 13661 "3 B3collection andmailing, 0"6" $it " is3/" in "/deposited " the 3" ;course ordinary 3Bbusiness 13!/of @!/" 4" the //with + " United 12 .3/ 6Service, /Postal States "1$in " sealed a 63with /6envelope 4" postage 3/ fully B!66;" prepaid. 13 16! Ideclare under 3BR!;under 6 ;ofperjury penalty ! the laws 3B State 64/ofthe 3B*6"B3 ofCalifornia "that B3 3" foregoing the is "/ ! true andcorrect. 131 A 14 T1! Executed on 3 July $$at H!6;10,2017, / 3$California. Fresno, *6"B3 " 15 8 16 17 0/ .33 lemse Poor 7 18 9 19 20 21 22 23 A 24 25 8 26 27 7 28 **)' *V: ' McCormick. ,)5$ Barstow, G.. '$5 N, W Sheppard,Wayte& * ''+,GLLP CaRRUTH. ()'-G 7M7 ' /0 ' ()STREET NORTH FRESNO * 93720 ()$CA FRESNO.9 ( (, DEFENDANTS' (),* NOTICE AND (MOTION ),)(TO M+ ,)QUASH GSERVICE 'N*OF + )( )SUMMONS