On August 03, 2022 a
Party Notice
was filed
involving a dispute between
Musharbash, Joseph,
and
American Medical Response,
American Medical Response, Inc.,
Cutler, M.D, Aaron,
Does 2-100, Inclusive,
Does 3 -100, Inclusive,
Gibani, M.D, Siraj,
Hide-A-While,
Hide-A-While Lounge,
Musharbash, Susan,
Rancho Cucamonga Fire Protection District,
San Antonio Regional Hospital,
Young, M.D, Richard,
City Of Rancho Cucamonga,
County Of San Bernardino,
for Medical Malpractice Unlimited
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
v ORIGINAL
RA-010
ATTORNEY OR PARTY WITHOUT ATTORNEY: STATE BAR NUMBER: 139034/1 77081
NAME: Michael J. /Jo Lvnn Valoff. Esq.
Trotter. Esq.
FiRM NAME: Carroll. Kellv. Trotter
& Franzen
STREET ADDRESS: P_o, Box 22636
CITY: Lonq Beach STATE: CA ZIP CODE:90801
TELEPHONE No.2 (562) 432-5855 FAX No;
EMAIL ADDRESS: A ,r
r; L r 5:)
oUPERION QOURT OF CALIFORNIA
ATTORNEY FOR (name): Aaron Cutler, M.D. & Richard Young, M.D.
Defs., Siraj Gibani, M.D., COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO
SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT
SUPERIOR COURT 0F CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO
STREET ADDRESS:247 West 3rd Street
MAR 2 3 2023
MAILING ADDRESS: 247 West 3rd Street
CITY AND ZIP CODE: San Bernardino 9241 5
BRANCH NAME: San Bernardino Civil
BY .72:
PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER: Joseph Musharbash Rosmh“ .v m_«ER, DEPUTY
DEFENDANT/RESPONDENTiSirai Gibani. M.D.; Aaron Cutler, M.D.; Richard Young. MD;
OTHER CASE NAME:
CASE NUMBER:
NOTICE OF REMOTE APPEARANCE
C|V3322171 17
You must use this form to tell the court you intend to appear remotely in a civil case, unless the court's website describes an
online process for giving notice. You may also use it to give the required notice to all other parties in the case. (Do not use
this form in a juvenile dependency proceeding.)
Check the court's website for information about how to appear remotely, including the departments and types of cases or
proceedings that allow remote appearances and ways toappear remotely in their departments for such appearances.
See page 3 of this form for more information, including deadlines for giving notice and for opposing a remote appearance if
this notice is for an evidentiary hearing or trial.
A person appearing remotely should conduct themselves as though appearing in court in person.
The person who intends to appear remotely
1.
E
E Plaintiff/Petitioner(name):
Attorney for PIaintiff/Petitioner (name):
is (check and complete a/l that apply):
E
E
Defendant/Respondent (name):
Attorney for Defendant/Respondent (name); Michael J. Trotter. Esq. and Jo Lynn Valoff, Esq. on behalf of Defendants,
GETH
D Other (name and role in case),
Siraj Gibani, M.D., Aaron Cutler, M.D. and Richard Young, MD.
A8
The person or persons
XV:I
intends to appear remotely (check one):
E
2. in 1
a. Throughout the case.
b. At the proceeding described below, including on any later dates ifthe proceeding is continued (describe):
Type of proceedinngrial Setting Conference
Set on (date): 4/5/23 at (time): 8:30 a.m. in (department): S14
Before (name ofjudicia/ officer, if known): Hon. Jeffrey R_ Erickson
3. The person intends to appear by (check court's website for method that may be used):
Videoconference Audio only (including telephone)
4. E For evidentiary hearing or trial only (where testimony may be given): the party requests the following additional aspects ofthe
proceeding be conducted remotely(describe what the party wants to be done remotely and why; attach form MC-25 if more
space is needed):
Page 1 of 3
Form Adopted for Mandatory Use Code of inil Procedure, § 367.75;
Judicial Council of California NOTICE OF REMOTE APPEARANCE Cal. Rules ofCoun, rule 3.672
RA-01O [New January
‘
1, 2022] wwwcounsca gov
& Richard Young, M.D.
\y \y
RA-010
pLAINTIFF; Joseph Musharbash
CASE NUMBER:
DEFENDANT; Siraj Gibani, M.D.; Aaron Cutler, M.D.; Richard Young, M.D. CIVSBZZ171 17
5. E | agree to keep the proceeding confidential to the same extent as would be required
-1 ‘
ifl were appearing in person.
Date: March 22. 2023
Lyof(th. (¢4fgyj.
,
r
V 3 --
Jo Lynn Valoff, Esq.
(TYPE OR PRINT NAME)
’ ‘1,
H
U
z
(SIGNATURE)
Notice to Other Parties
Anyone intending to appear remotely must provide notice to all other parties by the deadlines stated in Cal. Rules of Court,
rule 3.672, and described on the next page. Notice may be provided orally, electronically, or by giving the other parties this
form in a way to ensure it is received by the applicable deadline. The party must tell the court this was done either by filing a
proof of service (this may be done on forms POS-O4O or POS-050 for electronic service) or by completing and signing the
declaration below.
Declaration of Notice
I gave notice that intend to appear remotely to the other parties or persons entitled to receive notice in this case as stated below.
|
Complete one item below for each person notice was given to, and enter one of the following options for "Method of notice" in c.
- Mail: By mailing them a copy ofthis form (write the mailing address in
d.)
u Overnight delivery: By having a copy of this form delivered overnight
(write the delivery address in d.)
o Electronic notice: By e-mail or text message (write the e-mail or phone
number in d.)
a Phone: By telling them over the telephone or leaving them voice mail (write the phone
number in d.), or
o In person: By giving them a copy ofthis form in person, or
by telling them orally in person (write the address in d.)
1.
E
a.
Plaintiff/Petitioner
Name;
2.
a.
E Attorney
Name: Steven
for:
F.
Joseph Musharbash
Calderwood, Esq.
b. Date of notice: b. Date of notice: March 22, 2023
c. Method of notice: c Method of notice: Electronic
d. Address (mailing, in-person, or email) or phone number: d. Address (mailing, in-person, or email) or phone number:
scaldewvood@calderwoodIawgroup. com
3. EDefendant/Respondent
a. Name:
4
a.
E Attorney for. Rancho Cucamonga Fire Protection District
Name: Joshua Bordin-Wosk, EquBrvan C. Swaim Esq.
b. Date of notice: b. Date ofnotice: March 22, 2023
c. Method ofnotice: c Method ofnotice: Electronic
d. Address (mailing, in-person, or email) or phone number: d. Address (mailing, in-person, or email) phone number:
jbordinwosk@bordinsemmer com/bswaim@bordinsemmer.com
5. E a.
Other
Name: Edward
(specify): Attorney for
F. Morrison, Jr.,
Hide-A-While
Esq./Larry A. Schwartz, Esq.
6
a-
E Attorneyfor
Name JeffrevW Grass Esq/
San Antonio Regional Hospital
Evelin Duenas Esq
b Date ofnotice: March 22 ,2023 b- Date ofnotice- March 22, 2023
c, Method ofnotice; Electronic c Method ofnotice: Electronic
d . Address (mailing, in-person, or email) or phone number: d ~ Address (mailing. in-Person. 0r email) Phone numberi
morrison@morrisonlawgroup.com/schwartz@morrisonlawgroup. com Jeff@daVIS-grass.com/evelln@daVIs-grass.com
7. - gnvsvl
Other
Name. Loren
(specify). Attorney forAmerican Medical Response
S. Leibl, Esq. /Michael Miretsky, Esq.
7. E Name:
Other (specify):
Date of notice: March 22, 2023 9.0.6.1»
Date of notice:
Method of notice: Electronic Method of notice:
Address (mailing. in-person, or email) or phone number: Address (mailing, in-person, or email) or phone number:
Loren.Leib|@jmll.com/Michaelmiretsky@jmll.com
E If more people were given
how and when notice was
notice, check here, attach form MC-025,
given to each person.
titled as Attachment Notice, and add the information about
| declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct
Date: March 22, 2023
Monica Taormina } '
(TYPE OR PRINT NAME) (SIGNATURE)
RA-010 [New January 1, 2022] NOT|CE OF REMOTE APPEARANCE Page 2 of3
[page 3 need not be filed]
Preview
v ORIGINAL RA-010 ATTORNEY OR PARTY WITHOUT ATTORNEY: STATE BAR NUMBER: 139034/1 77081 NAME: Michael J. /Jo Lvnn Valoff. Esq. Trotter. Esq. FiRM NAME: Carroll. Kellv. Trotter & Franzen STREET ADDRESS: P_o, Box 22636 CITY: Lonq Beach STATE: CA ZIP CODE:90801 TELEPHONE No.2 (562) 432-5855 FAX No; EMAIL ADDRESS: A ,r r; L r 5:) oUPERION QOURT OF CALIFORNIA ATTORNEY FOR (name): Aaron Cutler, M.D. & Richard Young, M.D. Defs., Siraj Gibani, M.D., COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO SAN BERNARDINO DISTRICT SUPERIOR COURT 0F CALIFORNIA, COUNTY OF SAN BERNARDINO STREET ADDRESS:247 West 3rd Street MAR 2 3 2023 MAILING ADDRESS: 247 West 3rd Street CITY AND ZIP CODE: San Bernardino 9241 5 BRANCH NAME: San Bernardino Civil BY .72: PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER: Joseph Musharbash Rosmh“ .v m_«ER, DEPUTY DEFENDANT/RESPONDENTiSirai Gibani. M.D.; Aaron Cutler, M.D.; Richard Young. MD; OTHER CASE NAME: CASE NUMBER: NOTICE OF REMOTE APPEARANCE C|V3322171 17 You must use this form to tell the court you intend to appear remotely in a civil case, unless the court's website describes an online process for giving notice. You may also use it to give the required notice to all other parties in the case. (Do not use this form in a juvenile dependency proceeding.) Check the court's website for information about how to appear remotely, including the departments and types of cases or proceedings that allow remote appearances and ways toappear remotely in their departments for such appearances. See page 3 of this form for more information, including deadlines for giving notice and for opposing a remote appearance if this notice is for an evidentiary hearing or trial. A person appearing remotely should conduct themselves as though appearing in court in person. The person who intends to appear remotely 1. E E Plaintiff/Petitioner(name): Attorney for PIaintiff/Petitioner (name): is (check and complete a/l that apply): E E Defendant/Respondent (name): Attorney for Defendant/Respondent (name); Michael J. Trotter. Esq. and Jo Lynn Valoff, Esq. on behalf of Defendants, GETH D Other (name and role in case), Siraj Gibani, M.D., Aaron Cutler, M.D. and Richard Young, MD. A8 The person or persons XV:I intends to appear remotely (check one): E 2. in 1 a. Throughout the case. b. At the proceeding described below, including on any later dates ifthe proceeding is continued (describe): Type of proceedinngrial Setting Conference Set on (date): 4/5/23 at (time): 8:30 a.m. in (department): S14 Before (name ofjudicia/ officer, if known): Hon. Jeffrey R_ Erickson 3. The person intends to appear by (check court's website for method that may be used): Videoconference Audio only (including telephone) 4. E For evidentiary hearing or trial only (where testimony may be given): the party requests the following additional aspects ofthe proceeding be conducted remotely(describe what the party wants to be done remotely and why; attach form MC-25 if more space is needed): Page 1 of 3 Form Adopted for Mandatory Use Code of inil Procedure, § 367.75; Judicial Council of California NOTICE OF REMOTE APPEARANCE Cal. Rules ofCoun, rule 3.672 RA-01O [New January ‘ 1, 2022] wwwcounsca gov & Richard Young, M.D. \y \y RA-010 pLAINTIFF; Joseph Musharbash CASE NUMBER: DEFENDANT; Siraj Gibani, M.D.; Aaron Cutler, M.D.; Richard Young, M.D. CIVSBZZ171 17 5. E | agree to keep the proceeding confidential to the same extent as would be required -1 ‘ ifl were appearing in person. Date: March 22. 2023 Lyof(th. (¢4fgyj. , r V 3 -- Jo Lynn Valoff, Esq. (TYPE OR PRINT NAME) ’ ‘1, H U z (SIGNATURE) Notice to Other Parties Anyone intending to appear remotely must provide notice to all other parties by the deadlines stated in Cal. Rules of Court, rule 3.672, and described on the next page. Notice may be provided orally, electronically, or by giving the other parties this form in a way to ensure it is received by the applicable deadline. The party must tell the court this was done either by filing a proof of service (this may be done on forms POS-O4O or POS-050 for electronic service) or by completing and signing the declaration below. Declaration of Notice I gave notice that intend to appear remotely to the other parties or persons entitled to receive notice in this case as stated below. | Complete one item below for each person notice was given to, and enter one of the following options for "Method of notice" in c. - Mail: By mailing them a copy ofthis form (write the mailing address in d.) u Overnight delivery: By having a copy of this form delivered overnight (write the delivery address in d.) o Electronic notice: By e-mail or text message (write the e-mail or phone number in d.) a Phone: By telling them over the telephone or leaving them voice mail (write the phone number in d.), or o In person: By giving them a copy ofthis form in person, or by telling them orally in person (write the address in d.) 1. E a. Plaintiff/Petitioner Name; 2. a. E Attorney Name: Steven for: F. Joseph Musharbash Calderwood, Esq. b. Date of notice: b. Date of notice: March 22, 2023 c. Method of notice: c Method of notice: Electronic d. Address (mailing, in-person, or email) or phone number: d. Address (mailing, in-person, or email) or phone number: scaldewvood@calderwoodIawgroup. com 3. EDefendant/Respondent a. Name: 4 a. E Attorney for. Rancho Cucamonga Fire Protection District Name: Joshua Bordin-Wosk, EquBrvan C. Swaim Esq. b. Date of notice: b. Date ofnotice: March 22, 2023 c. Method ofnotice: c Method ofnotice: Electronic d. Address (mailing, in-person, or email) or phone number: d. Address (mailing, in-person, or email) phone number: jbordinwosk@bordinsemmer com/bswaim@bordinsemmer.com 5. E a. Other Name: Edward (specify): Attorney for F. Morrison, Jr., Hide-A-While Esq./Larry A. Schwartz, Esq. 6 a- E Attorneyfor Name JeffrevW Grass Esq/ San Antonio Regional Hospital Evelin Duenas Esq b Date ofnotice: March 22 ,2023 b- Date ofnotice- March 22, 2023 c, Method ofnotice; Electronic c Method ofnotice: Electronic d . Address (mailing, in-person, or email) or phone number: d ~ Address (mailing. in-Person. 0r email) Phone numberi morrison@morrisonlawgroup.com/schwartz@morrisonlawgroup. com Jeff@daVIS-grass.com/evelln@daVIs-grass.com 7. - gnvsvl Other Name. Loren (specify). Attorney forAmerican Medical Response S. Leibl, Esq. /Michael Miretsky, Esq. 7. E Name: Other (specify): Date of notice: March 22, 2023 9.0.6.1» Date of notice: Method of notice: Electronic Method of notice: Address (mailing. in-person, or email) or phone number: Address (mailing, in-person, or email) or phone number: Loren.Leib|@jmll.com/Michaelmiretsky@jmll.com E If more people were given how and when notice was notice, check here, attach form MC-025, given to each person. titled as Attachment Notice, and add the information about | declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct Date: March 22, 2023 Monica Taormina } ' (TYPE OR PRINT NAME) (SIGNATURE) RA-010 [New January 1, 2022] NOT|CE OF REMOTE APPEARANCE Page 2 of3 [page 3 need not be filed]