On September 11, 2018 a
Order
was filed
involving a dispute between
Bradbury D.D.S., Michael G,
Bradbury, Rhonda,
Odeh, Ali,
and
Cohan, Kat,
Odeh, Ali,
Fernandez D.D.S, Lyngladen,
Fernandez Dds, Lyngladen,
Kingsley Dentistry,
Kingsly Dentistry,
Lyngadlen Fernandez Dds,
Lyngladen Fernandez D.D.S.,
Ringo Bangalan Dds,
Silagan-Fernandez D.D.S., Lyngadlen,
Suarez-Fernandez Dentistry,
Suarez Fernandez Dentistry And Ringo Bangalan, Dds,
for Medical Malpractice Unlimited
in the District Court of San Bernardino County.
Preview
2020-12-18 04:18:39 GMT 19096148505 From: Ali Odehlara
To: 19097088586 Page: 02 of 50
F I L E
SUPERDR COURT 0F CALIFORNIA
D
COUNTY 0F SAN BERNARDINO
SAN BERNARDINO DuSTRICT
DEC 18 2020
Mi Gdch
f2)
w
31063 Siiver Rim
Moreno Valley,
Plaintifi; In Pm
CA. 92557
Per
BY
NIC LE CAR
/7
%
RI T,
22
DEPUW
SUPERIflR COURT 0F THE STATE 0F (?AUFOHN [A
FOR THE CiHJNTY ()1? SAN BERNARDINO
Casw- N0. CJVD31823772‘
ALI ODEH,
PLAI‘ NTWFS()PPOSI’HUN TU
Naimif'f,
VVVVVVV-vvr
DEFENDANTS MOTION AND MGTI 0N
FOR I‘RD'KECHV E ORDER
REGARBiNG DISCOVHRY AN!) MEET
VS.
AND CONFER WITH EXHI BITS AND
REQUEST FOR SKNCTTH1N5 AGAINST
LYNGADLEN FERNANDEZ; DDS;
BEFENBANT iJYNGAHLEN
KIN C iSL Y DENTISTR Y
Vvvu
FERNANFWZ BBS ANS} COUNSEL
Assignw tn 1hr Hmwrnhic Wilfred J. Scl’mcidw, Jr.
U‘oi'cndmm
v-wawvw DATE; Jainism 33"“, gag]
“fiMEz 09:303431;
lifli’T: 5.32
v
Plaimifi-‘Ali Odeh (“P'la'xmitt‘”) hamby npmscs [bendmn’s mutiou
'E‘br pmwcfiw om;
regarding éiswwry 22nd mfxi and confer wim exhibizs, and hereby requests sanctions againsx
ELLIS and Counsel foxr abuse ofdiscovery and misleading this. wurt
fiei‘endam Lyngadlen Fernandez
for doing go. Rather, Ebcfendm’s
as win be described below Defendant has shu-wn n0 good cause
Dcfcndzmn": unfaundm cameras shat. no pmpcr request far
mqumst appwrie m be motivated by
Plaimififlzas airway provided Dcfm‘xdnm wish
a
inapuctitm has'heen made hy Flainzif‘f. whim in fact
1
_ -
"
PLAINTIFFS OPPOSITION TO DEFEN FJANTS
MOTION ANY) MOTION FOR P-RO'.‘ HVEORDBR ‘
I ‘
WITH LLKHJBHES’ AND REQUtS' "OR DAEV L ION?)
REGARDING DISCOVERY AND ME AND CONFER
I
‘
AGAINST DEFENDAN‘K' LTNCIADLEN FERNANDEL
DDS AND COUNSEL
2020-12-18 04:18:39 GMT 19096148505 From: Ali Odehlara
To: 19097088586 Page: 03 of 50
dawned drscx'iption nfsaiu inspmiem in 2m email 523m on i221 1/2820. Ember, gramiéng D&fwdflnt-‘s
mqucm \muid pmjudzicc Lin: Plaintiff‘in this zwtion.
W
'
z},;
A. DECEMBER 11““, 2020; flEFENDAWI"S COUNSEL’S EMAIL T0 PLMNTIFF
ASKING PLAINTIFF WHEN HE IN’I‘ENDS UN I’ERFQRMMG INSPECTION AN!)
80W:
11, ()n Dccdmher i
1‘“, 2020 at 20:10 am Plaintiff'mspmadcd m ikfandam‘s counsel 170m
S Akin; with dam 0m}: inspectfion. and gave dsfcmchmt a choice m choose {mm
Ikeem‘ber 26m, 2.020 t0 chemher 30‘“, 2020: M thaw: dates. to chums: 11 dam and firm?
{car mgpwum [Pcfcndam m»; dmggw this rm £1211 mu 12m H mouths and has; ignm‘cfl
i’laintilf“'s mqucst for inspccxion. See a copy 0f mnaiis fmm ?laimifl‘rcqucsfing a {Saw
perform inspection datcd back from Ucanber
7"“. 201 9; and pteviwus
and time to
emaiis requesting inspection dated haek t0 October 2(319 arc: mtmrhcd in Exhibit A..
b. "I'm marl filmuhi dwy defendant Lyagadlm‘s mcrticm for Pmm-ciivc Order, due w {has
plaintiff is unly waking inspection u!" SOLELY l’iaintjff‘s I'Mnml Records; am] m
mnsidcrmimx CQW‘D»
exile: rccord-s win be zwccsmd, l‘kainfifi‘has 213m taken into thx:
19 rcstréctkms amt muck monmmmmm m mm msm'cre with dei-bndwn Ly‘ngad‘fim’s
he
business practicea’pmctices and advised defendants counsef that the inswcticm
<1- n
done MEFCHUE‘, er AFTER dcfeudam‘s busincgs is open,
B. DEFENDAN’I‘S MESLEADING STATEMENFS Ti) T1115; (70121?!“
a. m dcf’cndam’s motion for protective finder memo of points and auéfimriiics, page 1:.
fines 4‘?
I P; 61’. #H 9. dfifimdam slams that *“pkximifi‘ Want; fincnsiu examination w? ALL
V 2 ._
PLAINEWFS 0P?(>$1’110.N 'm [JEFENI‘JAN'I‘S MU‘I‘XON AND MUTION FUR.\PRO'iif(“w'lwa ORDER
?{EGARDING DISCOVERY AND M131?!" AM) CONFI‘IR WITH ISXJNBITS AND ?QUI f FDR
SANCTIUNS
'
AGAENST DEFENHAN'I” [.‘E’NUADLEH FERNANDEZ HUS AN!) L'IOUNFQ‘L
Document Filed Date
December 18, 2020
Case Filing Date
September 11, 2018
Category
Medical Malpractice Unlimited
For full print and download access, please subscribe at https://www.trellis.law/.
Preview
2020-12-18 04:18:39 GMT 19096148505 From: Ali Odehlara To: 19097088586 Page: 02 of 50 F I L E SUPERDR COURT 0F CALIFORNIA D COUNTY 0F SAN BERNARDINO SAN BERNARDINO DuSTRICT DEC 18 2020 Mi Gdch f2) w 31063 Siiver Rim Moreno Valley, Plaintifi; In Pm CA. 92557 Per BY NIC LE CAR /7 % RI T, 22 DEPUW SUPERIflR COURT 0F THE STATE 0F (?AUFOHN [A FOR THE CiHJNTY ()1? SAN BERNARDINO Casw- N0. CJVD31823772‘ ALI ODEH, PLAI‘ NTWFS()PPOSI’HUN TU Naimif'f, VVVVVVV-vvr DEFENDANTS MOTION AND MGTI 0N FOR I‘RD'KECHV E ORDER REGARBiNG DISCOVHRY AN!) MEET VS. AND CONFER WITH EXHI BITS AND REQUEST FOR SKNCTTH1N5 AGAINST LYNGADLEN FERNANDEZ; DDS; BEFENBANT iJYNGAHLEN KIN C iSL Y DENTISTR Y Vvvu FERNANFWZ BBS ANS} COUNSEL Assignw tn 1hr Hmwrnhic Wilfred J. Scl’mcidw, Jr. U‘oi'cndmm v-wawvw DATE; Jainism 33"“, gag] “fiMEz 09:303431; lifli’T: 5.32 v Plaimifi-‘Ali Odeh (“P'la'xmitt‘”) hamby npmscs [bendmn’s mutiou 'E‘br pmwcfiw om; regarding éiswwry 22nd mfxi and confer wim exhibizs, and hereby requests sanctions againsx ELLIS and Counsel foxr abuse ofdiscovery and misleading this. wurt fiei‘endam Lyngadlen Fernandez for doing go. Rather, Ebcfendm’s as win be described below Defendant has shu-wn n0 good cause Dcfcndzmn": unfaundm cameras shat. no pmpcr request far mqumst appwrie m be motivated by Plaimififlzas airway provided Dcfm‘xdnm wish a inapuctitm has'heen made hy Flainzif‘f. whim in fact 1 _ - " PLAINTIFFS OPPOSITION TO DEFEN FJANTS MOTION ANY) MOTION FOR P-RO'.‘ HVEORDBR ‘ I ‘ WITH LLKHJBHES’ AND REQUtS' "OR DAEV L ION?) REGARDING DISCOVERY AND ME AND CONFER I ‘ AGAINST DEFENDAN‘K' LTNCIADLEN FERNANDEL DDS AND COUNSEL 2020-12-18 04:18:39 GMT 19096148505 From: Ali Odehlara To: 19097088586 Page: 03 of 50 dawned drscx'iption nfsaiu inspmiem in 2m email 523m on i221 1/2820. Ember, gramiéng D&fwdflnt-‘s mqucm \muid pmjudzicc Lin: Plaintiff‘in this zwtion. W ' z},; A. DECEMBER 11““, 2020; flEFENDAWI"S COUNSEL’S EMAIL T0 PLMNTIFF ASKING PLAINTIFF WHEN HE IN’I‘ENDS UN I’ERFQRMMG INSPECTION AN!) 80W: 11, ()n Dccdmher i 1‘“, 2020 at 20:10 am Plaintiff'mspmadcd m ikfandam‘s counsel 170m S Akin; with dam 0m}: inspectfion. and gave dsfcmchmt a choice m choose {mm Ikeem‘ber 26m, 2.020 t0 chemher 30‘“, 2020: M thaw: dates. to chums: 11 dam and firm? {car mgpwum [Pcfcndam m»; dmggw this rm £1211 mu 12m H mouths and has; ignm‘cfl i’laintilf“'s mqucst for inspccxion. See a copy 0f mnaiis fmm ?laimifl‘rcqucsfing a {Saw perform inspection datcd back from Ucanber 7"“. 201 9; and pteviwus and time to emaiis requesting inspection dated haek t0 October 2(319 arc: mtmrhcd in Exhibit A.. b. "I'm marl filmuhi dwy defendant Lyagadlm‘s mcrticm for Pmm-ciivc Order, due w {has plaintiff is unly waking inspection u!" SOLELY l’iaintjff‘s I'Mnml Records; am] m mnsidcrmimx CQW‘D» exile: rccord-s win be zwccsmd, l‘kainfifi‘has 213m taken into thx: 19 rcstréctkms amt muck monmmmmm m mm msm'cre with dei-bndwn Ly‘ngad‘fim’s he business practicea’pmctices and advised defendants counsef that the inswcticm <1- n done MEFCHUE‘, er AFTER dcfeudam‘s busincgs is open, B. DEFENDAN’I‘S MESLEADING STATEMENFS Ti) T1115; (70121?!“ a. m dcf’cndam’s motion for protective finder memo of points and auéfimriiics, page 1:. fines 4‘? I P; 61’. #H 9. dfifimdam slams that *“pkximifi‘ Want; fincnsiu examination w? ALL V 2 ._ PLAINEWFS 0P?(>$1’110.N 'm [JEFENI‘JAN'I‘S MU‘I‘XON AND MUTION FUR.\PRO'iif(“w'lwa ORDER ?{EGARDING DISCOVERY AND M131?!" AM) CONFI‘IR WITH ISXJNBITS AND ?QUI f FDR SANCTIUNS ' AGAENST DEFENHAN'I” [.‘E’NUADLEH FERNANDEZ HUS AN!) L'IOUNFQ‘L